THE MARSI MEWS - Royal College of Psychiatrists ED2015 Sara McCluskey Session.pdf• Exclusion of...
Transcript of THE MARSI MEWS - Royal College of Psychiatrists ED2015 Sara McCluskey Session.pdf• Exclusion of...
THE MARSI MEWS Dr Sara McCluskey and Dr Paul Robinson
• Evolution of the MARSI MEWS
• Results of audit
• Validation
Meet the MARSI MEWS team
Kat Damazer –
Assistant Psychologist
Karishma Talwar-
EDU Healthcare Assistant
Dr Sara McCluskey–
Consultant Psychiatrist
With Special thanks to :
• Dr Paul Robinson – project design
• Jacob Hollis – data analysis
• Dr Francis Connan – data collection
• Dr Sonu Sharma – data collection
• Steven Stokes – Initial audit
• The staff of the EDUs at the Priory Hospital Southampton, Roehampton, Bristol, Cheadle and Hayes Grove
• The staff of the EDU Vincent Square Central and Northwest London NHS Trust
Current Risk Assessment Tools for Community Patients with Anorexia Nervosa
• Mausdley “Rough Guide” – Professor Janet Treasure
• PREDIX John Morgan
SYSTEM TEST* OR INVESTIGATION CONCERN ALERT
Nutrition BMI <14 <12
Weight Loss/Week >0.5 kg >1.0 kg
Skin Breakdown <0.1cm >0.2 cm
Purpuric Rash +
Circulation Systolic BP <90 <80
Diastolic BP <70 <60
Postural Drop (Sit - Stand) >10 >20
Pulse Rate <50 <40
Musculo-skeletal (Squat Test)
Unable to get up without using arms for balance yellow
+
Unable to get up without using arms as leverage (red)
+
Temperature <35 98.0 F
<34.5C <97.0 F
Bone Marrow WCC <4.0 <2.0
Neutrophil Council <1.5 <1.0
Hb <11 <9.0
Acute Hb Drop (MCV and MCH raised - no acute risk)
+
Platelets <130 <110
Salt/Water Balance
K+ <3.5 <3.0
2. Na+ <135 <130
3. Mg++ 0.5-0.7 <0.5
4. PO4-- 0.5-0.8 <0.5
5. Urea >7 >10
Liver Bilirubin >20 >40
Alkpase >110 >200
AsT >40 >80
ALT >45 >90
GGT >45 >90
Nutrition Albumin <35 <32
Creatinine Kinase >170 >250
Glucose <3.5 <2.5
Differential Diagnosis
TFT, ESR
ECG Pulse Rate <50 <40
QTc Interval >500ms
Arrythmias +
* The baselines of these tests vary between labs. Any abnormal result is an indication for
concern and monitoring.
Rough Guide :Janet Treasure
ROUGH GUIDE TO A SUMMARY MEASURE OF RISK
Analogue of Risk Management:
1. No Coloured Scores
Regular review and monitoring of above parameters with routine referral to eating disorders
unit/ secondary services depending on local resources.
2. Score(s) in the Yellow/Concern Area
Regular review of parameters (c. weekly) and assessment of capacity with urgent referral to
eating disorders and appropriate medical intervention if needed.
3. Score(s) in the Red/Alert Area
Immediate contact and referral to eating disorders unit and physicians if outpatient with
assessment of capacity. The patient will need urgent specialist and medical assessment. If
inpatient - immediate contact with on-call physicians.
This table gives values of concern for each part of the assessment and is followed by a
management protocol based on risk.
Please turn over.
John Morgan et al 2013
Why a Modified Early Warning System for EDU’s
• Trusts’ expectation for use of NEWS
• Concerns that this not “fit for purpose” for ED patients
– False positives and false negatives
• Development of adaptations of NEWS for specific clinical groups e.g. PEWS
NEWSRoyal College of Physicians 2013
“MARSI” MEWS using information from physical observations effectively on inpatient EDUs
• MEWS - Modified Early Warning Score
• NEWS - National Early Warning Score
• “MARSI” MEWS – Development of a Meaningful Early Warning Score for Inpatient Eating Disorder Units
MARSI MEWS
Development
• Setting of MARSI MEWS parameters informed by
– Reference to existing community physical risk assessment tools
– Review of patients observation charts at Hayes
– Consultation with MARSIPAN physician
– Consultation via EDSIG list serve
Observation NEWS MARSI MEWS
Systolic BP (mm Hg) 111-219 90-140
Respiratory rate (breaths / min) 12-20 10-20
Postural drop (mm Hg) Not included <10
Pulse rate (BPM) 51-90 51-90
Temperature (°C) 36-38 36-37
O2 saturation >96 No score. < 95% contact RMO
AVPUA
(V P U score 3)
No score.
Other than Alert contact RMO
NEWS and MARSI MEWS parameters
Observation
MARSI MEWS SCORE
1 2 3
Systolic BP (mm Hg) >140 <90, >150 <80, >160
Respiratory rate (breaths / min) >20 <10, >25
Postural drop (mm Hg) >10 >20 >30
Pulse rate (BPM) <50, >90 >100 <40, >110
Temperature (°C) >37 <36, >38 <35, >39
Parameters
Development
• Design of MARSI MEWS Chart
– Piloted at Hayes Grove
• Exclusion of blood sugar from MARSI MEWS score calculation
• BM measurement of less than 5 triggers instructions on reverse of chart
Modification of MARSI MEWS following pilot at Hayes
Development
• Design of MARSI MEWS Chart
– Trialled on 6 Priory and one NHS sight following structured teaching
Development and training issues
• Importance of respiratory rate assessment, recording and scoring to be highlighted to staff
– Respiratory rate is an vital indicator of many bodily functions i.e. respiratory problems, cardiovascular problems, metabolic problems, neurological problems
• Clarification of recording and scoring of BP measurements
– one score for sitting systolic BP
– Second score for difference between sitting and standing BP
Development
– Audit of
• Usability of Chart
• NEWS versus MARSI MEWS scores
Usability of Chart
47%
7%
2%1%
38%
5%
Percentage of Missing Observations from MARSI MEWS chart entries n= 3585
respiratory rate
temperature
pulse
systolic sitting BP
systolic standing BP
O2 sat
Usability – not all observations taken
50%50%
Complete observation sets
Incomplete observation sets
MARSI MEWS scores
60%
40%Unrecorded total MEWS score
Recorded total MEWS score
Recorded MARSI MEWS scores
89%
11%
Correctly recorded total MEWS scores
Incorrectly reported total MEWS scores
MARSI MEWS and NEWS compared
MEWS and NEWS sameMEWS scores higher than
NEWSMEWS scores lower than
NEWS
Series1 458 369 975
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Nu
mb
er
of
MA
RSI
MEW
S ch
arts
Figure 4: A chart to illustrate the difference between NEWS and MARSI MEWS scores obtained from the valid MARSI MEWS CHARTS (n=1802)
MARSI MEWS GROWS UP –do we eat it or play with it ?
The MARSI MEWS Study Phase 2
• Phase 1 has resulted in a large database of physical observations and corresponding MARSI MEWS and NEWS scores.
• The NEWS and the MARSI MEWS are different: NEWS scores tended to be higher than the corresponding MARSI MEWS score- is the NEWS too sensitive?
• Phase 2: To determine if the MARSI MEWS (an adapted version of the NEWS) is a better predictor of physical deterioration in inpatients with anorexia nervosa than the NEWS.
Patient Profiles
• We have compiled information on 60 patients from 2 units to create Patient Profiles.
• Profiles include STATE variables, showing the physical health of a patient on a given day (including the observations on the MARSI MEWS chart)
• And TRAIT variables with information regarding physical and psychiatric medical history.
Patient Profiles State Variables
Patient ID: Date of MARSI MEWS observation:
Respiratory Rate
Temperature
Pulse
Systolic BP Sitting
Postural Drop
O2 Saturation
State of Consciousness (AVPU)
BMI
Most Recent ECG (please include date and
any abnormal findings)
Current Physical Co-Morbidities
Current Psychiatric Co-Morbidities
Days Since Admission
Most Recent Blood Profile (only include
abnormal results. Look just at the following:
Neutrophil, Phosphate, Urea, Creatinine,
Haemoglobin and Potassium)
Current Medications (including dose)
Patient Profiles Trait Variables
Diagnosis (Anorexia Nervosa restrict or
binge/purge)
Years since onset of Anorexia
Current Age
Longstanding Physical Co-Morbidities
Longstanding Psychiatric Co-Morbidities
Diagnosis of Personality Disorder
YOUR MISSION (should you choose to accept it)!
• We would like you to examine the Patient Profiles handed out to you and indicate on the scoring sheet which clinical action you feel is most appropriate if you were confronted with this patient in an inpatient setting.
• There is also a space for any comments at the bottom of each scoring sheet.
• We will then compare this to the MARSI MEWS and NEWS scores that each profile would have scored.
• We will assess which tool (MARSI MEWS or NEWS) produces scores that best match the opinions of the clinicians (you!) as to which of the Patient Profiles are considered to be at risk of physical deterioration.
About You
Workshop 3: Early Intervention for physical decompensation. Questionnaire
ID: Please make up an ID (eg a relative’s first name and birth year) and copy it onto your Response sheet [………………….] Profession (tick): Psychiatry [ ] Other (specify) [ ] Specialty: (tick): General adult [ ] Eating Disorders [ ] Child and Adolescent [ ] Other (specify) ………………………………………. Role: (tick): Consultant [ ] Senior trainee [ ] Junior trainee [ ] Associate specialist [ ] Trust doctor [ ] Other (specify) ………………………………………. Clinical Practice (tick all that apply) NHS [ ] Private [ ] Outpatients [ ] Inpatients [ ] Day-patients [ ] General medical or paediatric ward [ ] Full time [ ] Part time [ ] Number of sessions [ ] Years in Eating Disorders 0-5 [ ] 5-10 [ ] >10 [ ] Do you give us permission to use the data collected anonymously to develop the MARSIMEWS assessment? Yes No (please circle) Thank you Sara McCluskey and Paul Robinson
Your Assessment
Workshop 3: Early Intervention for physical decompensation. Questionnaire
ID: (from questionnaire) […………………………….] Case number (from Patient Profile) Assessment of risk (please tick most appropriate)
Your comments about the most appropriate management of this case ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… Additional comments following discussion with your neighbour ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… ………………………………………………………………………………………… Thank you Sara McCluskey and Paul Robinson
High Consult RMO and Consultant immediately
Medium-High Observations every 30 minutes and RMO to attend immediately
Medium Hourly observations, call RMO to attend within 30 minutes
Low Complete observations every 4 hours
Minimal Continue with Routine monitoring