THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on...

29
THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT AS IT IMPACTS ON RHINOCEROUS POACHING IN THE KRUGER NATIONAL PARK SANParks SOLITARY AS IT FACES THE BIGGEST CHALLENGE IN A CENTUARY IN KRUGER NATIONAL PARK Special Projects

Transcript of THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on...

Page 1: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADEIN CONTEXT

AS IT IMPACTS ON RHINOCEROUS POACHING IN THE KRUGER NATIONAL PARK

SANParks SOLITARY AS IT FACES THE BIGGEST CHALLENGE IN A CENTUARY IN KRUGER NATIONAL PARK

Special Projects

Page 2: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

RHINO POACHING IN CONTEXTThe Illicit Wildlife Trade has 4 primary interactive ingredients

ILLICIT WILDLIFE

TRADE DEMAND$GREED

POACHERS POVERTY

SYNDICATED CRIME

ENVIRONMENTAL ASSETS

Page 3: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

3Treat Rhino according to it’s value – higher than gold

ENVIRONMENTAL ASSETS

implied by over R Bn 40 worth of Rhino

ahead of gold, platinum, and diamonds!

Armageddon of the Rhino will or will not be in Kruger…with over 60% of the world rhino population

Cost of Ownership= Resources

Page 4: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

4

…and the geographic surround of Rhino Horn culture

Vietnamese and Chinese end users

Supply meets demand largely

in Kruger

FACING THE FUTUREA Global Challenge

Page 5: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

Protecting assets - key element

Ferreira & Okita-Ouma 2012

Producer Poacher

Local organizer

Poacher

Poacher

PoacherLocal 

organizer

National Buyer

International  distributor

Syndicate Local trader

Within protected areas Beyond protected areas

Consumer

Page 6: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

6

FACING THE FUTUREElements of Successful Environmental Asset Protection

6

Enforce - Law enforcement* integral to Conservation

Page 7: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

7

The KRUGER CHALLENGE

KNP is 2,000,000ha (20,000km²)

380km x 60km

1000 km border line

356km border with Mozambique

The Lebombo mountain range

1,4 Million tourists per annum

Page 8: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

8

THE KRUGER PROBLEM

The role of Mozambicancitizens (and officials) cannot be overstated

…also poaching incursions from South African soil

Page 9: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

9

THE VALUE CONDUIT CHALLENGE AND RISKS

The Ranger Corps can only influence on the ground

• Ranger life and limb

• Wide spread

corruption

• Mass incursion and

poaching

• Tourists and tourism

interference / impact

• Other Parks, other

animals

• Too little to late

Page 10: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

10

CURRENT REALITY IN KRUGER

Poachers are replaced at a faster rate than Rhino

Page 11: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the
Page 12: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

Poachers Neutralised in & around the KNP in 2013

Page 13: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

13

FACING THE FUTUREApproach

Think big• Demand - SEA• Mozambique• Total solution/

capability• Technology

Start small• Pro active• Intelligence• Alliances• Task Force

effect

Act now• Ranger corps• Protect• React

Manage complexity

Page 14: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

14

FACING THE CHALLENGESTRATEGIC FRAMEWORK

Page 15: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

Clear the Park from the outside at a local scale

Page 16: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

16

FACING THE FUTURE

16

• Force – All relevant participants adequately involved

• Enforce – Real legal measures

• Fortify – Intensive Protection Zone

• Out-Class - Technology solutions

• Propagate – Social media

• Mitigate – Rhino options

STRATEGIC OPTIONS

Page 17: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

17

MANAGING THE KRUGER FORCEORGANISATIONAL COMMAND AND CONTROL

Page 18: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

18

Converting rangers to an anti-poaching force

CAPABILITY APPROACH

People Empower Rangers to leaders

Organisation Clear lines of command

Sustainment All facets of support

Training Anti-poaching focussed

Equipment Best, including technology

Doctrine Anti-poaching

Page 19: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

FORCE MULTIPLIERS

• Expand air services• Special rangers

• Night enhancement• Canine capabilities

Persistent and unpredictable

Page 20: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

INTELLIGENCE BASED FORCE MULTIPLIERS

20

STATE A

GEN

CIES

Alli

ance

sPr

ivat

e

Sens

ors

Plat

form

s

TECHNICAL INTELLIGENCE

HUMAN INTELLIGENCE

SHARE

Page 21: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

CONCEPT OF FORCE

OPERATIONSEstablish Actionable Intelligence Systems

Create Buffer Zones

Established detection zones (along strategic entry points/areas and border posts)

Integrated command, communication and early warning technology systems

Sustained specialised intervention unit deployments

Sustainable support infrastructure

Strategically placed Pickets

Mobile Patrols

SI

SI

SI

SISI

SI

SI

SI

Page 22: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

2222

Force National anti-poaching force of 1000 people with specialist support operating from outside the park

START WITH INTELLIGENCE = Focus on syndicates

BEING NOT THE ONLY FORCE

Page 23: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

Enforce in Mozambique

ENFORCING LAWS

Concerted political, diplomatic and economic pressure to the point of

criminal and civil legal actions

Page 24: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

24

Use technology sensibly

OUTCLASS POACHERS

Page 25: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

2525

MILLIONS TO CONDEMN THE SLAUGHTER

Required intellectual support on the drivers of demand and market sentiment of Rhino Horn

YES YES YES !

PROMOTE CULTURAL SENSITIVE PROPAGANDA

Page 26: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

26

MACRO OPTIONS

262626

Remove…Relocate… Trade…Treat…?

MITIGATE THE ASSET

Page 27: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

27

COMPLEX CHALLENGES

Foresight Scenarios and

Risks

Operating Concept

NATIONAL RESPONSIBILITYCOMPOSITE SOLUTIONS

Page 28: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

28

FACING THE FUTURE

28

• SANParks and its partners, have the most highly qualified teams in Africa, although not big enough to cover the expanse of Kruger

• The war will not be won in Kruger. International Boundaries

• This is an international problem requiring International solutions.

• The poaching Rate has not yet exceeded the breeding rate

• Communities play a key role… and so can you.. • There is hope…Passion, Technology, Sanctuaries

etc.

What should we communicate to our Visitors?

Page 29: THE ILLICIT WILDLIFE TRADE IN CONTEXT · the illicit wildlife trade in context as it impacts on rhinocerous poaching in the kruger national park sanparks solitary as it faces the

29