THE FUNDAMENTALS OF ROUTE DEVELOPMENT · Advantages Disadvantages • Can raise large sums of money...
Transcript of THE FUNDAMENTALS OF ROUTE DEVELOPMENT · Advantages Disadvantages • Can raise large sums of money...
THE FUNDAMENTALS OF ROUTE
DEVELOPMENT
AIRLINE DEALSMODULE 8
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 AIRLINE DEALS
Experiences?
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 WHY?
1. Your airport operates in a competitive
environment
2. To reward existing customers for traffic growth
3. To encourage new customers to use the
facilities and services
AIRPORT / DESTINATION PERSPECTIVE
• Airports around you
• Airports with deeper pockets
• Airports that provide something
you may or may not
• Additional frequencies
• Year round operations
• Larger aircraft
• New routes
• Network development
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 WHAT IS THE AIRLINE TRYING TO ACHIEVE ?
AIRLINE PERSPECTIVE
1. Mitigate costs / share commercial
revenue generated by passenger
(their customer)
2. Competitive advantage
3. Non binding support
• Minimise/eliminate the cost levied by airports.
• Realise a share of the incremental passenger
revenues at the airport and destination.
• Improve overall margin
• Gain a cost differential to enable a competitive
advantage.
• To not be restricted if and when the market changes.
• Be able to walk away if it’s not working.
• Move capacity if a better deal emerges.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8
There are broadly three types of support
A. Support to boost a carriers revenue through promoting passenger demand
B. Support designed to induce carriers to supply air service by reducing costs
C. Support designed to mitigate risk
ROUTE SUPPORT
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 VARIANTS OF ROUTE SUPPORT
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 AERONAUTICAL INCENTIVES
Typically airport aeronautical charges are levied on some or all of the following:
Schedule
• Aircraft type/weight
• Time of day
• Season
• Destination (domestic/international)
Facilities
• Air bridges
• Parking
Ancillary items
• De-icing, aircraft washing facilities
• Navigational charges
• Security
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 THE CONVENTIONAL AIRPORT AGREEMENT
• Discounts over a 3-5 year period,
reducing over time
• Discounts are normally on
aeronautical charges, sometimes
on handling charges
• Simple, easy to understand
Beware though:
1. airline new-route business cases are unlikely to go beyond 2-3 years (at least for short
haul)
2. Landing fees account for perhaps 20% of a short-haul carrier’s total operating costs,
10% or less for a long-haul carrier. A modest discount has only a small effect on the
route economics
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 MARKETING SUPPORT/DIRECT FUNDING
Types of Support
• Direct marketing funds
• Non-financial marketing information (data,
corporate database)
• Access to marketing (web links, consumer
magazines)
Apply Conditions
• Matching funds
• Minimum frequency/season/aircraft size
• New destination only
• Receipts of spend
• Recourse if route is cancelled
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 SUBSIDIES & JOINT VENTURES
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
Airport &
StakeholdersRisk Sharing
Airport &
Stakeholders
Joint
Ventures
e.g. revenue guarantees
i.e. share risk
& profits
asm-global.com
MODULE 8
Revenue related:
Minimum Revenue Guarantees (MRG)
Agreements that establish a target amount of revenue that a carrier will receive for operating a particular service to a particular destination over a
given length of time. Only paid out if passenger demand and target revenues do not materialise. The amount paid is equal to the shortfall. If
target met no funds are drawn down (All subject to certain criteria being achieved)
Advantages
- Carriers like them
- Potentially low cost if route works
- Cash flow – paid at end or at intervals
- Easy to admin and track
Risks
- No guarantees, may lose entire amount
- Doesn’t motivate demand
- Carriers can be wary – if it doesn’t work reputations are damaged
- Changing economics
- Difficult to raise the money
ROUTE SUPPORT - REVENUE RELATED
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 MISCELLANEOUS SUPPORT
• Maintenance support
• Handling
• Fuel
• Facilities
• Office Space
• Airport advertising
• Crew base costs
• GSA availability and costs
• PR support
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
Aeronautical Incentives
Miscellaneous Support
Subsidies & Joint
Ventures
Marketing Support/
Direct Funding
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 ROUTE DEVELOPMENT FUNDS
A route development fund (RDF) is a fund set up by private and / or public sectors stakeholders
offered to airlines to help establish new strategically important routes or additional capacity.
Examples ?
• UK Regional Air connectivity fund - £56m over 3 years to encourage more flights from airports of less than 5mppa
• Lithuania – Over 1 million Euro’s funded under the Route Development Fund and earmarked for 8 airline companies
to support regular flights.
• Northern Ireland – State Route Development Fund for Long Haul Flights
• Canary Island fund for specific target route development
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 DIRECT PASSENGER CHARGES
A number of airports have opted to charge the passengers directly and position the tax as a ‘Development Fee’
Lima Buenos Aires New Delhi, India
Knock, Ireland Norwich, UK Most Canadian airports
Advantages Disadvantages
• Can raise large sums of money for specific
development projects
• Adverse passenger perceptions among local
community and inbound visitors
• Takes the airport cost out of the airline negotiation
(hence offer kick backs)• Cost of collection (at point of sale / at airport)
• Allows airport product to be differentiated and the
airport may appear less expensive
• Passengers will still account for the cost in the
choice of airport
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 TENDERS – RFP’S
Airports and Airlines both issue tenders as buyers and sellers
Recent examples:
- Canary Island route development tender – specific routes
- Scoot / Norwegian / Thomas Cook / Condor/Air Asia X / Saudi Airlines
- Dublin Airport – specific routes
- Stockholm Skavsta
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING
LCCs
Characteristics of LCC negotiations
• Will not pay full aeronautical charges
• Per passenger basis
• Seek stakeholder support
• Demand marketing assistance
• Assistance with hotel accommodation
• Subsidised ground transport to City centres
• Long term deals (5 years +)
• Country/route specific
• Require contracts
• Creative Support, for example website advertising
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING
LCCs
Negatives
• Financially driven – rarely strategic
• You must agree now or the opportunity
will disappear – “Deadline Driven”
• “All your competitors want our business”
• Most aggressive sector particularly ultra
LCC’s
Positives
• Passenger volume, non-aero income
• Carrier is tied to growth, which enables
clear airport planning
• Builds your network rapidly
• Generates year round business
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING
FSCs
Characteristics of scheduled carrier negotiations
• More facility and product focussed
• Seek short term agreements
• Less flexibility to switch capacity to competitors (i.e. secondary airports)
• Negotiations usually less aggressive than low cost, however, watch out for...
Negatives
• Market support not allocated to specific route – lost to a central budget
• Financials under increasing pressure, becoming more dependent of agreements
• Generally don’t generate large numbers
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING
TOUR OPERATORS
Characteristics of Tour Operator negotiations
• Seek per pax incentive
• Landing fee discounts (for integrated charter airline): Based aircraft support/positioning support/parking assistance/shoulder season support (tour operator)
• Tourism authority support/marketing tools and or fund
• 50/50 advertising/airport sites/branding opportunities
Pitfalls
• In a vertically integrated organisation, always look to provide financial benefit to the decision maker (tour op) rather than the transport provider (charter airline). Be careful not to double discount
• Agree in advance of negotiations who is the right “group” contact – who can make top level decisions and maintain visibility of agreed terms/conditions (documented)
• Ensure regular feedback on progress/sales/new opportunities
• Substitution of traffic; one operator’s growth is generally another’s decline
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING
CARGO AIRLINES
Seeking cost reduction wherever possible:
• Handling charges (may be support from handling agent)
• Landing fees
• 24 hour access
• Crew layover assistance (may be support from handling agent)
• Self handling permission e.g. express operators (DHL, Fedex)
• Special procedures/facilities e.g. cold storage
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 NEGOTIATING GUIDELINES
• Watch for the shopping list approach – hear it all first
• Never commit beyond your business case
• Never let yourself become time pressured
• Always be prepared to walk away
Remember - Negotiating is a positive sign. It signals an intention to buy.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Passenger Related
Bonus scheme for passenger growth
The aim of the bonus scheme is to reward airlines who are contributing to passenger growth for the Avinor group. The scheme is valid from January 1st 2013, and until further notice.
Calculation
A bonus is awarded for each additional departing passenger from one calendar year to the next, based on the number of passengers for which passenger charge is payable. The bonus is 25 Norwegian kroner per departing international passenger and 12.50 Norwegian kroner per departing domestic passenger. The scheme encompasses all of Avinor’s airports, and the calculation of bonus is made on company level, in effect adding up the total amount of passengers for each airliner for all of Avinor’s airports. For calculation of bonus payments, Avinor will use reported data as of the end of the year. Avinor reserves the right to make changes in bonus payments if considerable changes to reported data on passengers occur.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Charter Flights Related
The Charter Fund Northern Norway is a newly launched incentive scheme, managed by the Northern Norway Tourist Board, designed to help tour operators and their charter airline partners establish new tourism products to northern Norway and the Norwegian Arctic Lapland region, by bringing in tourists directly by air transport.
Financed by the counties of Nordland, Troms and Finnmark, the goal of the fund is to encourage tour operators to partner with our tourism stakeholders in northern Norway to build new tourism markets.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Volume Related
In accordance with the Katowice Airport list of tariffs, aircraft landing fees and departing passenger charges are calculated in increasing increments throughout the annual settlement period. Upon exceeding a given bracket with regards to the number of landings or departing passengers, fees are reduced.
The more operations airlines perform in a given year and the more passengers they transport, the less they pay. Landing fees for aircraft with a MTOW greater than 2 tons, as well as departing passenger charges are provided in the tables below.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Time of Day Related
Off-Peak Period Rates
In order to qualify for the PFC Off-Peak Rate an Airline must:-
a) operate a minimum of one Service each Week for 52 weeks of a Year, and
b) ensure that the departure of the Aircraft in the Off-Peak Periods 05:30 to
05:59, 06:30 to 06:59, 13:00 to 13:29, 19:00 to 19:59 and 22:00 to 22:59
achieves the applicable QC Ratings shown in the table at Section 1.7
For the avoidance of doubt:-
a) if an Aircraft does not achieve the applicable QC Ratings that flight will not be an eligible flight for the Off-Peak PFC Charge Rate and the relevant Standard Rate PFC will apply.
b) Code F Aircraft are not eligible for PFC Off-Peak Rates.
1.7 PFC
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Seasonality Related
The Three-Year Program of Incentives regards the 5 following categories of flights, to be activated by the end of the IATA Winter season 2015-2016:
Category 1. New intercontinental routes;
Category 2. New flights to hubs (by carriers that have a hub at the airport of destination or business agreements that allow passengers to utilise connecting flights);
Category 3. New “strategic” point-to-point European/Mediterranean routes, meaning those of greatest interest to Naples Airport, based on its evaluations of potential traffic demand;
Category 4. New point-to-point European/Mediterranean routes “of interest” to Naples Airport;
Category 5. De-seasonalisation – increase in the number of seats offered during the period October-May on existing routes by carriers that already operate flights on those routes.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Marketing Support
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Volume Related
This incentive is provided to all air carriers with more than 50,000 transported passengers paying full passenger service charge (i.e. the sum total of passengers after transfer, transit and exempt passengers have been deducted) upon departure from Prague/Ruzyně airport via regular scheduled connections during a calendar year. The individual rates per one departing passenger paying in full are defined as follows:
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 EXAMPLES OF PUBLISHED INCENTIVES
Tender/RFP
Flight Development Fund against target new routes for Canary Islands. Lead by PromoTur, collaboratively Islands Tourism Authority.
Fund can pay up to 50% of airport charges for up to three years.
Airline bids include the specific of the route business plan, operating plan, showing assessment of sustainability and marketing plan.
asm-global.com
MODULE 8 ROUTE SUPPORT CHECKLIST
Negotiating checklist:
• Establish maximum position
• Let them ask first – don’t offer
• Budget
• Check what is permitted under regulatory jurisdiction, keep up to date with changes
• Assess impact on existing customers – attrition
• Do your homework - research and prepare
• Assess competition
• Seek third party support
• Assign a negotiator with authority
• Make sure you are dealing with the decision maker
• Conclude with a contract (conditions, control)
• Add in a review period
• Always keep control of any marketing spend