7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 1/13

By Tyler Figenbaum

 The Emancipation Proclamation

Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 2/13

Peter the Great

Peter the great abolished slavery in Russia in1!" and believed that abolishing slavery#ould help$ but Russia returned the act of

serfdom #hich is very closely related toslavery$ and basically the same thing butRussia #ent for nearly 1%% years believingthat they did not have slavery #ithin theircountry$ #hile this #as the &nited 'tates( )rsttime abolishing slavery*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 3/13

Buying of 'laves   The Emancipation

Proclamation #hen

stated #as referringto slaves in #hichthe &nited 'tatespurchased from

+frica and otherindigenous lands$so they #ere notconsidered &nited'tates citi,ens$

#hile on the otherhand in Russia the'erfs #ere born inRussia*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 4/13

 Treatment of 'laves

'laveholders punished slaves through

#hipping$ shac-ling$ hanging$ beating$burning$ mutilation$ branding$ andimprisonment*

Punishment #as most often meted in responseto disobedience or perceived infractions$ butsometimes abuse #as carried out simply toreassert the dominance of the master oroverseer*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 5/13

 Treatment of 'erfs

 +t the time +le/ander 00 obtained the position

of Tsar$ during the rimean #ar con2ict in1344$ )fty million of the si/ty million legaloccupants of Russia #ere serfs* Gruesometreatment$ rape and torture topped the longlist of ho# serfs #ere treated daily* 0f theprevious list did not cure the serf of hisrebellion$ he #as to be enlisted into themilitary$ #here far #orse treatment #asreceived*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 6/13

'lave and 'erf Rebellions

0n both the &nited 'tates and in Russia there#ere 'lave and 'erf Rebellions* Rebellion hasal#ays been a common act #hen being held inbondage$ so the 'laves and 'erfs both felt as ifthey deserved their freedom and they #eretreated very harshly because of theserebellions*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 7/13

ause of EmancipationManifesto

 This is a painting of the rimean 5ar$ #hich#as a con2ict bet#een the Russian Empire andan +lliance of the French Empire$ the BritishEmpire$ the 6ttoman Empire$ and the 7ingdom

of 'ardinia* +fter the #ar had been concluded$and the death of +le/ander 0 had ta-en place$#hile +le/ander 00 #as in charge he reali,edthat he could no longer rely on the labor of the'urfs$ and that Russia must embrace ne#technologies* The loss of this #ar caused theEmancipation Manifesto to be issued$ #hile inthe &nited 'tates the EmancipationProclamation #as issued in the middle of theivil 5ar to change the motivation of the 5ar*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 8/13

ause of EmancipationProclamation

 This picture is a snapshot from the Battle of+ntietam$ #hich is also -no#n as the Battle of'harpsburg* This battle #as fought on

5ednesday 'eptember 1$ 138!* 0t #as the)rst ma9or battle of the ivil 5ar to ta-e placeon &nion soil* This battle #as signi)cant in thee:ort of +braham ;incoln issuing theEmancipation Proclamation because heneeded con)dence before posting such adeclaratory bill$ and a &nion victory in theBattle of +ntietam #ould give him thecon)dence of a #in*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 9/13

5hat 'erfs Receive #hen Free

0n Russia the freedom of the 'erfs allo#ed the'erfs to be able to purchase the land that they hadpreviously #or-ed on$ many thought that this #asvery good for the serfs* <o#ever$ the 'erfsreceived the #orst land possible and it #as not fairat all to the 'erfs #ho have been #or-ing hardtheir #hole lives*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 10/13

Face of EmancipationManifesto

0n the Emancipation Manifesto of 1381+le/ander had a di:erent position on the#hole abolishing serfdom in Russia* 0n contrastto +braham ;incoln(s statements that this #ashis decision +le/ander 00 #as straying a#ayfrom that approach by using pronouns such as=5e$ 6ur$ &s>$ +le/ander 00 believed that is#as going to be a #idely communal e:ort bythe entire country of Russia rather than himdoing this on his o#n* +le/ander 00 ma-esattempts at not #anting to be the face of theManifesto? he #ants the country of Russia to

be the face of the abolishment of 'erfdom*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 11/13

Face of EmancipationProclamation

 This picture is sho#ing that +braham #antedto be the face of the EmancipationProclamation? he #anted to be the maneveryone thought of #hen they thought of the&nited 'tates abolishing slavery* 0n theEmancipation Proclamation it states$ =@o#$therefore 0$ +braham ;incoln$ President of the&nited 'tates$ by virtue of the po#er in mevested as ommanderAinAhief$ of the +rmyand @avy of the &nited 'tates>$ and this issho#ing that +braham ;incoln is ma-ing thisdecision on his o#n$ and that he truly believes

in ma-ing this decision*

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 12/13

;incoln$ +braham* The Emancipation Proclamation* hampaign$ 0ll* Pro9ectGutenberg$ 1C8"* Print*

00$ +le/ander* D+le/ander 00$ Emancipation Manifesto$ 1381 A ocuments inRussian <istory*D Seton Hall University Academic Server * @*p*$ 1C Feb* 1381*5eb* 1 une !%1"* httpHHacademic*shu*eduHrussianhistoryHin

D'lave Rebellions I <istory*com +rticles$ Video$ Pictures andFacts*D History.com — History Made Every Day — American & World History *@*p*$ n*d* 5eb* 1 une !%1"* httpHH###*history*comHtopicsHslaveryAivAslaveArebellionsJ*

Eichler$ <onna Michelle * D'erfs Emancipated 1381*D Then Again. . .* @*p*$1! 'ept* !%%"* 5eb* 1 une !%1"*httpHH###*thenagain*infoH#ebchronHeaste

lair*7ellerD'T6R +n Error 6ccurred 'etting Kour &ser oo-ie*D ST!"#*@*p*$ n*d* 5eb* 1 une !%1"*httpHH###*9stor*orgHdiscoverH1%*!"%H!418!8"CLuid""C8C8Nuid!NuidONuid""C!48Nsid

Bibliography

7/28/2019 The Emancipation Proclamation Versus The Emancipation Manifesto

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-emancipation-proclamation-versus-the-emancipation-manifesto 13/13

Emancipation Proclamation* 13C8* +be ;incoln$ 5ashington *** loc.gov * 5eb* 1" une!%18* httpHH###*loc*govHpicturesHitemH!%%"8883C%H

 $attle o% Antietam* 133* +ntietam$ &nited 'tates* loc.gov * 5eb* 1" une !%18*httpHH###*loc*govHpicturesHitemH!%%"88"3!H

The Siege o% Sevastopol* 1C%O* Russia$ Russia* i'imedia.org* 5eb* 1" une !%18*httpHHcommons*#i-imedia*orgH#i-iHFileMala-hov!*9pg

(egroes driven so)th *y the "e*el o+cers* 138!* 'laves$ &nited 'tates*loc.gov * 5eb* 1"

 une !%18* httpHH###*loc*govHpicturesHitemHC!414%1OH ,ing -ottons ong Shado* @*d* 'laves$ &nited 'tates*neyo)r'times.com* 5eb* 1" une

!%18* httpHHopinionator*blogs*nytimes*comH!%1"H%"H"%H-ingAcottonsAlongAshado#H

Peter /0 the 1reat0 Emperor o% ")ssia0 hal%2length portrait0 %acing right0 in armor * 13!*Russia$ Russia* loc.gov * 5eb* 1" une !%18* httpHH###*loc*govHpicturesHitemHC84%3O!8H

he 34ort5 Monroe Doctrine* @*d* 'laves$ &nited 'tates* loc.gov * 5eb* 1" une !%18*httpHH###*loc*govHpicturesHitemH!%%38818"OH

Galt$ 7eoni* D!1st entury 'erfdom*D the2spearhead.com * @*p*$ !O uly !%1%* 5eb* 1" une!%18* ###*theAspearhead*comH!%1%H%H!OHtheAamericanAdreamA!1stAcenturyAserfdomHJ*

mid$ the* D'erfs Russiapedia 6f Russian origin*D 1et ")ssianali6ed 7 ")ssiapedia* @*p*$ n*d*5eb* 18 une !%1"* httpHHrussiapedia*rt*comHofArussianAoriginHserfsHJ*

DEmancipation reform of 1381 A 5i-ipedia$ the free encyclopedia*DWi'ipedia0 the %ree

encyclopedia* @*p*$ n*d* 5eb* 18 une !%1"* httpHHen*#i-ipedia*orgH#i-iHEmancipationQref 

Pictography