The Disturbing True Story of the Pied Piper of Hamelin _ Ancient Origins

16
General History & Archaeology Science & Space Evolution & Human Origins Mysterious Phenomena Home / Myths & Legends / The Disturbing True Story of the Pied Piper of Hamelin More ACTIVE FORUM TOPICS REAL STORY OF THE NATIVE EUROPEANS The World body speaks Please introduce yourself Supporting AO The stories of the first faith:Zoroastrianism Seven Accused African Witches Burned to Death Zoroaster Created Judeo Christian Religions Ancient Mystery Solved? SUGGESTED BOOKS 14 AUGUST, 2014 - 01:09 DHWTY The Disturbing True Story of the Pied Piper of Hamelin When, lo! as they reached the mountainside, A wondrous portal opened wide, As if a cavern was suddenly hollowed; And the Piper advanced and the children followed, And when all were in to the very last, The door in the mountainside shut fast. Robert Browning, The Pied Piper of Hamelin: A Child’s Story Many are familiar with the story of the Pied Piper of Hamelin. Few realise however, that the story is based on real events, which evolved over the years into a fairy tale made to scare children. For those unfamiliar with the tale, it is set in 1284 in the town of Hamelin, Lower Saxony, Germany. This town was facing a rat infestation, and a piper, dressed in a coat of many coloured, bright cloth, appeared. This piper promised to get rid of the rats in return for a payment, to which the townspeople agreed too. Although the piper got rid of the rats by leading them away with his music, the people of Hamelin reneged on their promise. The furious piper left, vowing revenge. On the 26th of July of that same year, the piper returned and led the children away, never to be seen again, just as he did the rats. Nevertheless, one or three children were left behind, depending on which version is being told. One of these children was lame, and could not keep up, another was deaf and could not hear the music, while the third one was blind and could not see where he was going. NEWS HUMAN ORIGINS MYTHS ANCIENT PLACES ARTIFACTS HISTORY UNEXPLAINED OPINION Enter your keywords ABOUT REGISTER LOGIN LINKS BOOKS EVENTS GALLERY VIDEO FORUMS CONTACT NEXT ARTICLE

description

Historia

Transcript of The Disturbing True Story of the Pied Piper of Hamelin _ Ancient Origins

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 1/16

    General History&Archaeology Science&Space Evolution&HumanOrigins MysteriousPhenomena

    Home/Myths&Legends/TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin

    More

    ACTIVE FORUM TOPICSREALSTORYOFTHENATIVE

    EUROPEANSTheWorldbodyspeaksPleaseintroduceyourselfSupportingAOThestoriesofthefirst

    faith:ZoroastrianismSevenAccusedAfrican

    WitchesBurnedtoDeathZoroasterCreatedJudeo

    ChristianReligionsAncientMysterySolved?

    SUGGESTED BOOKS

    14 AUGUST, 2014 - 01:09 DHWTY

    The Disturbing True Storyof the Pied Piper of Hamelin

    When,lo!astheyreachedthemountainside,Awondrousportalopenedwide,

    AsifacavernwassuddenlyhollowedAndthePiperadvancedandthechildren

    followed,Andwhenallwereintotheverylast,

    Thedoorinthemountainsideshutfast.RobertBrowning,ThePiedPiperofHamelin:A

    ChildsStory

    ManyarefamiliarwiththestoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin.Fewrealisehowever,thatthestoryisbasedonrealevents,whichevolvedovertheyearsintoafairytalemadetoscarechildren.

    Forthoseunfamiliarwiththetale,itissetin1284inthetownofHamelin,LowerSaxony,Germany.Thistownwasfacingaratinfestation,andapiper,dressedinacoatofmanycoloured,brightcloth,appeared.Thispiperpromisedtogetridoftheratsinreturnforapayment,towhichthetownspeopleagreedtoo.Althoughthepipergotridoftheratsbyleadingthemawaywithhismusic,thepeopleofHamelinrenegedontheirpromise.Thefuriouspiperleft,vowingrevenge.Onthe26thofJulyofthatsameyear,thepiperreturnedandledthechildrenaway,nevertobeseenagain,justashedidtherats.Nevertheless,oneorthreechildrenwereleftbehind,dependingonwhichversionisbeingtold.Oneofthesechildrenwaslame,andcouldnotkeepup,anotherwasdeafandcouldnothearthemusic,whilethethirdonewasblindandcouldnotseewherehewasgoing.

    NEWS HUMAN ORIGINS MYTHS ANCIENT PLACES ARTIFACTS HISTORY UNEXPLAINED OPINION

    Enteryourkeywords ABOUT REGISTER LOGIN LINKS BOOKS EVENTS GALLERY VIDEO FORUMS CONTACT

    NEXTARTICLE

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 2/16

    BryanHilliard

    SteveAndrews

    dhwty

    RyanStone

    LATEST CONTENTFoundationRitualsofAncientEgypt:ElaborateRitesConductedtoProtectGreatMonuments

    TheMysteryoftheGuanchesandthePyramidsofTenerife

    NecropolisofWarriorsandGods:TheAncientStatuesofSanAgustn,Colombia

    HolyConversations:TheImpactoftheMysteriousBookofSoyga

    SUGGESTED BOOKS

    TheearliestknownrecordofthisstoryisfromthetownofHamelinitselfdepictedinastainedglasswindowcreatedforthechurchofHamelin,whichdatestoaround1300AD.Althoughitwasdestroyedin1660,severalwrittenaccountshavesurvived.TheoldestcomesfromtheLueneburgmanuscript(c144050),whichstated:Intheyearof1284,onthedayofSaintsJohnandPaulonJune26,byapiper,clothedinmanykindsofcolours,130childrenborninHamelinwereseduced,andlostattheplaceofexecutionnearthekoppen.

    TheoldestknownpictureofthePiedPipercopiedfromtheglasswindowoftheMarketChurchinHameln/HamelinGermany

    (c.13001633).Imagesource:Wikimedia.

    ThesupposedstreetwherethechildrenwerelastseenistodaycalledBungelosenstrasse(streetwithoutdrums),asnooneisallowedtoplaymusicordancethere.Incidentally,itissaidthattheratswereabsentfromearlieraccounts,andonlyaddedtothestoryaroundthemiddleofthe16thcentury.Moreover,thestainedglasswindowandotherprimarywrittensourcesdonotspeakoftheplagueofrats.

    Ifthechildrensdisappearancewasnotanactofrevenge,thenwhatwasitscause?TherehavebeennumeroustheoriestryingtoexplainwhathappenedtothechildrenofHamelin.Forinstance,onetheorysuggeststhatthechildrendiedofsomenaturalcauses,andthatthePiedPiperwasthepersonificationofDeath.ByassociatingtheratswiththeBlackDeath,ithasbeensuggestedthatthechildrenwerevictimsofthisplague.Yet,theBlackDeathwasmostsevereinEuropebetween1348and1350,morethanhalfacenturyaftertheeventinHamelin.Anothertheorysuggeststhatthechildrenwereactuallysentawaybytheirparents,duetotheextremepovertythattheywerelivingin.YetanothertheoryspeculatesthatthechildrenwereparticipantsofadoomedChildrensCrusade,andmighthaveendedupinmoderndayRomania,orthatthedepartureofHamelin'schildrenistiedtotheOstsiedlung,inwhichanumberofGermanslefttheirhomestocolonizeEasternEurope.OneofthedarkertheoriesevenproposesthatthePiedPiperwasactuallyapaedophilewhocreptintothetownofHamelintoabductchildrenduringtheirsleep.

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 3/16

    POPULAR CONTENTInitialDNAanalysisof

    ParacaselongatedskullreleasedwithincredibleresultsThestoryofRagnarokand

    theApocalypseExtensiveAncient

    UndergroundNetworksDiscoveredThroughoutEuropeThehumanskullthat

    challengestheOutofAfricatheoryAncientHumansBredwith

    CompletelyUnknownSpeciesEntireNeanderthalgenome

    finallymappedwithamazingresultsCodexGigas(theDevils

    Bible)thelargestmanuscriptintheworldTheSumerianKingListstill

    OneofthedarkerthemedrepresentationsofthePiedPiperofHamelin.Credit:LuiGonJinn

    HistoricalrecordssuggestthatthestoryofthePiedPiperofHamelinwasarealeventthattookplace.Nevertheless,thetransmissionofthisstoryundoubtedlyevolvedandchangedoverthecenturies,althoughtowhatextentisunknown,andthemysteryofwhatreallyhappenedtothosechildrenhasneverbeensolved.Thestoryalsoraisesthequestion,ifthePiedPiperofHamelinwasbasedonreality,howmuchtruthisthereinotherfairytalesthatweweretoldaschildren?

    Featuredimage:AnillustrationofthePiedPiperofHamelin.Credit:Monlster

    Bywty

    References

    Anderson,D.,2012.ThePiedPiperofHamelin:Thefactsbehindthefairytale.[Online]Availableat:http://www.examiner.com/article/thepiedpiperofhamelinthefactsbehindthefairytale

    Ashliman,D.L.,2013.ThePiedPiperofHamelnandrelatedlegendsfromothertowns.[Online]Availableat:http://www.pitt.edu/~dash/hameln.html

    Cuervo,M.J.P.,2010.TheLostChildrenofHamelin.[Online]Availableat:http://www.forteantimes.com/features/articles/3805/the_lost_children_of_hamelin.html

    Dennis,2011.TheTruthBehindtheLegendofthePiedPiper.[Online]Availableat:http://www.topsecretwriters.com/2011/01/thetruthbehindthelegendofthepiedpiper/

    Foster,N.,2014.IsthePiedPiperofHamelinBasedonanActualEvent?.[Online]Availableat:http://www.wisegeek.com/isthepiedpiperofhamelinbasedonanactualevent.htm

    McGarth,J.,2014.WastherereallyapiedpiperofHamelin?.[Online]Availableat:http://history.howstuffworks.com/historyvsmyth/piedpiper.htm

    Pearson,L.,2005.OnthetrailoftherealPiedPiper.[Online]

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 4/16

    puzzleshistoriansaftermorethanacenturyofresearch

    SUGGESTED BOOKS

    Myths&Legends

    piedpiper Hamelin Germany children rats village

    fairytale story Music pipe

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    Availableat:http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/4277707.stm

    Wikipedia,2014.PiedPiperofHamelin.[Online]Availableat:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pied_Piper_of_Hamelin

    Section:

    Tags:

    Comments

    TSURUGI WROTE ON 14 AUGUST, 2014 - 14:40

    ThetricksterelementsinthePiedPiperstoryhavealwaysseemeddarkandeerietome.Hadnoideaitwasarealevent.Soundsalmostlikeacloseencountertome...?

    KISSES4KATIE WROTE ON 3 SEPTEMBER, 2014 - 01:20

    I'vebeenfascinatedwiththePiedPiperforawhile(andallparanormalentities)andIwasneverawareofthePiperbeingclothedinmanycolors.ThisbringstomindachapterinJohnKeel'sbook,TheCompleteGuidetoMysteriousBeings.Inchaptersreferringtobedroominvadersandghosts,hemakesmentionof'checkeredshirts'orplaidshirts.Also,onceyouareawareofthisfact,mentionofhowanentitywasdressedincolorsorplaidspopsupinmanyparanormalstories.Justsomethingtobewaryof....Wonderingifithastodowiththegreatermysterythatallofthisholds.

    ROWAN HAWTHORN WROTE ON 3 SEPTEMBER, 2014 -

    15:33

    ...isthemeaningoftheword"pied".

    CHUCK K WROTE ON 22 SEPTEMBER, 2014 - 20:46

    meansmorethanonecolorormanycolored.

    These StockImages WillLeave youSpeechless!

    SurprisingFacts AboutFast FoodBurgers. DidYou Know?

    These tipswill keep youmotivatedand help youachieve yourweight loss

    8 Must SeeVacationSpots ThatNeed To BeOn Your List...

    Amazingfacts youprobably don'twant to knowabout!

    10 ideas for agreat firstdate

    These tipswill makesure that anemployer willpick yourresume first!

    Do You Havethe Traits toBe a GoodLeader? FindOut Now!

    OffersandArticlesYouMayLike

    AdsbyAdblade

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 5/16

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    RBFLOORINGINSTALL WROTE ON 15 SEPTEMBER, 2014 - 14:27

    Makesyouwonderaboutsomeofthoseothercreepyfairytalesyouhearwhenyou'reakid.

    PeaceandLove,

    Ricky.

    JANE RASSMANN WROTE ON 15 SEPTEMBER, 2014 - 16:21

    Ihadnoideathatthisstoryhadfactualbasis.Creepy!

    ANTIENTARCANA WROTE ON 27 OCTOBER, 2014 - 03:12

    Ihaveneverheardthisstory,butIknewtheexpressionpayingthepiedpiper....

    SUSAN WROTE ON 28 DECEMBER, 2014 - 19:58

    Theactualphraseis,"paythepiper,"andisnotrelatedtothePiedPiperstory.

    MALISA WRIGHT WROTE ON 15 DECEMBER, 2014 - 02:33

    Creepy,forsure.IwouldliketoexplorethetheoryofaChildren'sCrusademore,asIfinditplausible.Leadingthechildrenoffwithaflute,soastodistractthemfromthefactthattheywereleavingtheirfamilies.Seemspossible.

    malisawright

    SUSAN WROTE ON 28 DECEMBER, 2014 - 19:59

    Theactualsayingis,"paythepiper,"andisunrelatedtothisstory.

    HENRY HALTINER WROTE ON 28 DECEMBER, 2014 - 20:40

    germanshavemanywordswhichhavemorethanonemeaningthewordseducedshouldbemorecloselyexaminedwiththisinmindandsecondifitwasmusicthatledthechildrenawaywhyweretheadultsnotaffectedmusicismusicandtheyonlyhadwhatwecallclassicalthensoiwouldhavetosaythatalotmorewasgoingonherethenweareinformedof

    TSURUGI WROTE ON 19 JANUARY, 2015 - 05:37

    Musicismusic,butkidsarevastlydifferentthanadults.

    JOHN DALE WROTE ON 29 DECEMBER, 2014 - 14:51

    InGermanyitself,theycallthestory"DerRattenfaengervonHamelin"whichdirectlytranslates

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 6/16

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    to"TheRatcatcherofHamelin".Alsothereareaccountsthatthepiperwasnotaflutist,butplayedbagpipes.ThefactthattheGermantitlementionsratssuggeststhatratswereinvolvedintheoriginalstory.

    Thisfairytaleisoddtome.Suchstorieswereoriginallytoldtochildrentoscarethemawayfromunwantedbehaviourorasamorallesson.TheGermanshadbrutalstoriesfortheiryoungones.Therewasayoungchildwhowasahabitualthumbsucker.ThemotherwarnedherofacreepyTaylorwithlageclothshearswholurksintheshadows,waitingtopounceuponunsuspectingthumbsuckersandswiftlydeprivingthemoftheirmoistlittleappendages.Themothergoesoutshoppingand,thechild,nowunsupervised,promptlysticksherthumbintohermouth.Suddenly,thelongcoatedcreephopsoutfrombehindthecurtainsandwithsissorsthesizeofhedgecutterstakesoffbothofthechild'sthumbs.

    However,thepiedpipertaleisuniquebecausethechildrensufferduetothefaultoftheparentsratherthantheirownmisbehaviour.Perhapsthisstorywasmeantforthegrownups.

    VLAD_BASARD WROTE ON 9 JANUARY, 2015 - 04:46

    Itis,it'salessontoadultstopayyourduesaspromisedandnotconpeoplebecausethepricemaybehigherthanpayingtheagreeduponprice.Mythoughtisitwasachildkiller.

    PETER HARRAP WROTE ON 15 JANUARY, 2015 - 20:05

    Itisnottrue.Why?Becausethereisnoaftermathindocumentedhistory.Aretherediaryandotherwrittenaccountsbydistraught,grievingparents?NONE.

    SameastheLegendofSt.Ursulaandthe11,000virgins,whom"History"records,wellsheisinWikipaedia:itisasimilarlyoutlandishstory.

    Lookitup!

    TSURUGI WROTE ON 19 JANUARY, 2015 - 05:47

    It'snottruebecausetherearenodiaryaccounts??Readingandwritingwasmagictomostpeoplein13thcenturyEurope,andyouwantdiaryaccounts,lol.

    Itisrecorded,inthetown's"diary."Asforhistoricalaftermath,itisstillforbiddentoplaymusiconthatstreet.Whetherthetalehasitsrootsinrealeventsornot,Idon'tknow,butitcertainlystandsuptoscrutinybetterthanyourattempttodebunkit.

    Whateverhelpsyousleepatnight,Isuppose.

    FERD WROTE ON 14 MARCH, 2015 - 01:23

    iguesssheexpectedsomeonetohaverecordeditontheiriPhone.....

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 7/16

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    TOMASINA SERVEAUX WROTE ON 8 FEBRUARY, 2015 - 06:49

    Ifinditinterestingthattheywereledintoacave.Cavesfeaturefrequentlyinmythsaroundtheworld,andoftenhaveaplaceinstoriesaboutfairyabductions.Inthesestories,thevictimencountersagroupoffairies,alldancinginacircleandplayingmusic.Heisentrancedbythesight,andsuddenlylosesallwilltoresist,andsoisdrawninexorablyintothecircleoffairiesanddisappears,nevertobeseenagain.Therearemanycavesaroundtheworldthataresaidtobesacredtothefairyfolkandtravelersarewarnedthattheyenterattheirownrisk.Likethecircularfairydance,thecavesareportalstoanotherworld,andtheunwaryexplorermightnevercomeoutagain.

    InthePiedPiperstory,thechildrenfollowastrange,colorfulentityplayingmusicthatentrancesthem,whereuponheleadsthemtoacaveandtheyareneverseenagain.Maybethesimilaritiesarecoincidental,buttheycertainlyareinteresting.

    SUNNIVA1947 WROTE ON 22 MARCH, 2015 - 22:03

    I'vebeenawareformanyyearsnowofthefactthatthishorriblestorythatgavemenightmaresasachild,isbasedonrealfacts.ThatiswhyIneverreadallthoscreepyfairytalestomygrandchildren.Ialwayswonderwhichpartistrue.HanselandGretchnforinstance...brrr.LetthmwatchtheDisneystories,muchlesscreepy

    SunnyYoung

    KARIN WROTE ON 1 APRIL, 2015 - 05:29

    WasdisappointedasIthought,judgingbythetitleofthearticle,thatweweregoingtogetthetruestorybehindthefairytale,insteadstilljustalotofspeculation.

    MICHAEL S WROTE ON 1 APRIL, 2015 - 06:52

    Whatdoyoumean??

    BWH WROTE ON 15 JUNE, 2015 - 08:16

    It'sobviouswhatshemeans.Thetitleis,"TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin."Butinthelastparagraph,theauthorwrites,"...themysteryofwhatreallyhappenedtothosechildrenhasneverbeensolved."

    Asshesaid,justanarticlefilledwithspeculationaboutwhatMIGHThavehappened,notthe"TrueStory"!Iwasequallydisappointedbecauseofthemisleadingtitle.

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 8/16

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    YORDANKA KRALIK WROTE ON 1 APRIL, 2015 - 14:51

    Newsletter&ResearchPapers

    SILVER RABBIT WROTE ON 1 APRIL, 2015 - 22:37

    IwonderifyoucouldfindoriginalfamiliesandgettheirDNAandmaybeseewhereanotherbunchwas,withsimilarDNAandtracethelineagebackward,maybegetcluesthatway?Andbeforeanyonesmarterthanmestartsinonwhythiswon'tworkI'mjusttryingtocomeupwithideas.

    NIETONO NO SHANA WROTE ON 9 APRIL, 2015 - 02:09

    With700yearsofdisplacement,thereis,sadly,notachancewhatsoeverofthat.Notonlywoulditbedifficulttofindaresidentofthetownwhoseancestorshavelivedthereforseveralhundredyears,butalsoDNAtestinginitselfisexpensive,sotestingmany,manypeoplethroughouttheworldissimplynotplausible.Itwasagoodthought,however.

    NIETONO NO SHANA WROTE ON 9 APRIL, 2015 - 02:09

    With700yearsofdisplacement,thereis,sadly,notachancewhatsoeverofthat.Notonlywoulditbedifficulttofindaresidentofthetownwhoseancestorshavelivedthereforseveralhundredyears,butalsoDNAtestinginitselfisexpensive,sotestingmany,manypeoplethroughouttheworldissimplynotplausible.Itwasagoodthought,however.

    SHANI WROTE ON 15 JUNE, 2015 - 15:42

    IlookedupwhatWikipediahastosayandwhilethereisnodefinitiveconclusiontowhathappeneditdoesseemtotrendtowardyoungpeoplebeingrelocatedtoremoteterritoriesforthepurposeofcolonization.TransylvaniaandPolandaresomepossibilities.Oneresearcherwasmentionedbecausehethinksalinkcanbemadethroughplaceandfamilynames.Sowe'reDNAmightfail,surnamescouldprevail.:)

    PSEUDO-NEMO WROTE ON 22 APRIL, 2015 - 09:30

    Alsohistoricallycavesareassociatedwiththeunderworld,alsocarryingasymbolismofdeath.Similarlyofnotehere"placeofexecutionnearthekoppen"Thiscouldeasilybearecordofachildsacrifice,oramasschildsacrifice,althoughhowsuchwouldbeaccomplishedbyoneperson,assumingthepiperwasaperson,isanyone'sguess.Itcertainlycouldbeaplagueofsomemanner,notnecessarilyThePlagueitself,asweknowfromhistory,childrenandtheelderlyarebothabitmoresusceptibletobiologicalagents,butifitwereabiologicalagentitseemsitwouldbeprevalentinchildren,andwedon'thearanythingoftheelderlyvanishingaswell,given

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 9/16

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    thatgermsdon'thave"preferences"persay,thelackofperishingoftheelderlymightbeanindicatoragainstitbeingaplague,orifitwasitwasaveryparticularone,whichmightonlyaffectchildren.

    Certainlytheimplicationofa"manycolorwearing"personcouldbeaclue,butwhatitpointsat,Idon'tknow.Hasanyonecheckedaroundthetownorinanynearbycavesforremainsand/orartifacts?Forthosepeoplesupposingasupernaturalorigin,Ihavehearditsaidbeforethatthepiperwasodin(orwotaningermany'scase)althoughtheactseemsabitmalevolentforsuchadeity(morelikesomethinglokiwouldpull.)andofcourse,thedevilfromChristianitywouldimmediatelybesuspect.

    Lastly,itcouldalsobethattheleadingawayofthechildrenwasindicativeofaconversionfromonereligiontoanotherandthusbesimilarinimplicationtodeath.Atthatpointintimethevillagewasprobablyromancatholic,soonecouldreasonablysuspectthatitcouldhavebeenapaganrevival.

    Thenthereistheideathechildrenwerestolenoutright,perhapsaveryearlyexpeditionof"gypsies"orsomesimilarsortofforeigngroupwasinvolved?

    SHANI WROTE ON 22 APRIL, 2015 - 13:16

    Ihavetwothoughts...

    1.ThemanycoloredclothingalongwiththeaccompanyingpicturebringstomindtheguardsoftheVatican.Perhapsarecruitment?Trainthemwhileyoung,perhapsthechildrenweresomesortoftributetothePope,orGod?

    2.Beingtakentoacaveapossibleminingoperationthatwouldrequirepeopleofsmallstature?

    Theeventwasimportantenoughtomakearecordof,butnoexplanation.Weird.

    KERGHAN WROTE ON 22 APRIL, 2015 - 16:05

    IreallylikeyourideaabouttheguardsoftheVatican,nowthatyoumentionit,thedescriptionofthePiedPiper(andmorespecifically,hisclothes)couldleadsomeonetomakeacorrelationwiththeseguards..butifitwastrulyguardsoftheVaticanwhohavetookawaythechildren..why?AndthetownpeopleshouldhaveknownthattheywerefromtheVatican,don'tyouthink?

    SHANI WROTE ON 22 APRIL, 2015 - 19:22

    Thanks!Youknow,Ithinkpeopleofthattimewouldn'thavequestionedanythingtheChurchdid.Perhapssomeshadyagreementwasmadeinexchangeforareligiousrelic,protectionofsomekind,orpaymentforsomething.TheVaticanisnotoriousfortheirsecrecy,maybetheyknowsomethingaboutthis.But,thisarticlealsomademerecallthemovieChittyChitty

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 10/16

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    PERMALINK

    REPLY

    BangBang,andtheEmperorwhohadallthechildrenroundedupandlockedup,andtheuseofbrightcolorsandcandytolurethechildrenaway.MaybethePiedPiperwascarryingoutsomeabsurdorderalongthoselines.

    JANEC WROTE ON 29 APRIL, 2015 - 05:26

    TheSwissGuardsoftheVaticandidn'texistuntil200yearsafterthePiedPiperstoryoriginated.Nicetheory,butno.

    PATRICIA GOODWIN WROTE ON 22 APRIL, 2015 - 17:05

    Fascinatingarticleandcomments!Irealized,too,thattheremaynothavebeenasmanychildrenastheillustrationsshow.Inasmallvillage,maybeadozen.Yes,peoplehadalotmorechildreninthosedays,butnotmanysurvived.Fewerchildrenwouldmakethestorymoreplausible,thoughnotanylesshorrifying.Iwasalsofrightenedbythistale,wayoverintheU.S.,soIcanonlyimaginehowscaryitwasforchildrenlivingintheareanow!ThemanycoloredclothingalsoremindsmeofthevillainclownofStephenKingsItandItsprecurser,thederelictclowninWillaCathersTheSongoftheLarkbothofwhomkilledchildreninthetown.Atimelessterror!

    PatriciaGoodwin

    MOONSONG WROTE ON 24 APRIL, 2015 - 06:44

    Ihavealwaysbeenfascinatedbytheoriginsoffairytales.Manywritersandpsychologistsclaimthatthebasisforeveryfairytalearepopularpsychologicalfearsandarchetypes.HeretherearedefinitelyechoesofJungstheories.HoweverIpersonallybelievethatthereisatleastakerneloftruthineachstory.Atthetime,thenormalpeoplehardlyknewhowtoreadandwrite,andstoriesweretheonlywaytheyhadofrelatingeventsandpassingthemontofuturegenerations.Storieswherethewaytheytoldtheirhistorytotheirchildren,thewaytheytaughtthemtobecautiousandaboutthefactsoflife.Inthiscase,theyevenhadacommemoratingwindowabouttheevent,whichisjustproofthatitactuallyhappened.

    MoonsongAdreamerisonewhocanonlyfindhiswaybymoonlight,andhispunishmentisthatheseesthedawnbeforetherestoftheworld~OscarWilde

    Registertobecomepartofouractivecommunity,getupdates,receiveamonthlynewsletter,andenjoythebenefitsandrewardsofourmemberpointsystemORjustpostyourcommentbelowasaGuest.

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 11/16

    Moreinformationabouttextformats

    Yourname*

    Email*

    Thecontentofthisfieldiskeptprivateandwillnotbeshownpublicly.

    Homepage

    Notifymewhennewcommentsareposted

    Subject

    Comment*

    NoHTMLtagsallowed.Webpageaddressesandemailaddressesturnintolinksautomatically.Linesandparagraphsbreakautomatically.

    Bysubmittingthisform,youaccepttheMollomprivacypolicy.

    Save

    MOST READ TODAYTheSumerianKingListstillpuzzles

    historiansaftermorethanacenturyofresearch

    TheWhiteSlavesofBarbary

    ThehumanskullthatchallengestheOutofAfricatheory

    TheoriginsofhumanbeingsaccordingtoancientSumeriantexts

    AncientHumansBredwithCompletely

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 12/16

    UnknownSpecies

    UnravellingtheMysteriesofAncientArtifactsEbook

    InitialDNAanalysisofParacaselongatedskullreleasedwithincredibleresults

    MOST POPULAR

    TheSumerianKingListstillpuzzleshistoriansaftermorethanacenturyofresearchOutofthemanyincredibleartefactsthathavebeenrecoveredfromsitesinIraqwhereflourishingSumeriancitiesoncestood,fewhavebeenmoreintriguingthattheSumerianKingList,anancient...

    ThesymboloftheSwastikaandits12,000yearoldhistory

    TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin

    PaganGodsandthenamingofthedays

    Bethefirstofyourfriendstolikethis.

    AncientOrigins328,134likes

    LikePage ShareSignUp

    Legends Technology AncientPlaces

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 13/16

    more

    ThelegendaryTowerofBabel

    TheSecretLivesofElvesandFaeries:TheTruthbehindtheStoryofRevRobertKirk

    RECENT COMMENTSIlookedupwhatWikipedia1minagoEMthanksforreadingmy1hour26minagoGuanchees4hours18minagoAsfamilyofavictimIhada6hours5minagoIt'sobviouswhatshemeans.7hours27minago"Voynich"isthebookyou're9hours3minagoThePaganOriginsoftheGreenMan9hours14minagohi10hours58minago

    SUGGESTED BOOKS

    NaturaldeodorantMadeusingancientformulaWearedirectimportersfrom

    Egypt

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 14/16

    EVENTS

    M T W T F S S1 2 3 4 5 6 78 9 10 11 12 13 14

    15 16 17 18 19 20 2122 23 24 25 26 27 2829 30

    TOP NEW STORIES

    FoundationRitualsofAncientEgypt:ElaborateRitesConductedtoProtectGreatMonuments

    Inmoderntimes,itiscommontoinitiateanewbuildingwithwhatisknownasa"groundbreaking"ceremony.Thistraditionsymbolicallymarksthebeginningofanewprojectinmanyculturesandis...

    NecropolisofWarriorsandGods:TheAncientStatuesofSanAgustn,Colombia

    HolyConversations:TheImpactoftheMysteriousBookofSoyga

    DietofhumanbrainshelpedPapuaNewGuineatribetoresistdisease

    TheMysteryoftheGuanchesandthePyramidsofTenerife

    HUMAN ORIGINS

    ThehumanskullthatchallengestheOutofAfricatheory

    Thisistheaccountofthediscoveryofaskullthathasthepotentialtochangewhatweknowabouthumanevolution,andasuppressionandcoverupwhichfollowed.In1959,inanareacalled...

    TheoriginsofhumanbeingsaccordingtoancientSumeriantexts

    HollywoodresurrectsNoah'sArk,butdidtheygetitright?

    AreTheNephilimReallyTheOffspringOfSonsofGodAndTheDaughtersOfMan?

    RadicalnewdocumentaryclaimsCopernicusandfourcenturiesofscienceiswrong

    ANCIENT PLACES

    TheWhiteSlavesofBarbary

    MuchattentionandcondemnationhasbeendirectedtowardsthetragedyoftheAfricanslavetrade,whichtookplacebetweenthe16thandthe19thcenturies.However,anotherequallydespicabletrade...

    NecropolisofWarriorsandGods:TheAncientStatuesofSanAgustn,Colombia

    TheMysteryoftheGuanchesandthePyramidsofTenerife

    UnravellingthemysterybehindthemegalithicstonewallsofSaksaywaman

    ThemysteriouscivilizationoftheOlmecs

    MONDAY, JUNE 1

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 15/16

    NaqsheRustam:AncientTombsofPowerfulPersianKings

    MYTHS & LEGENDS

    TheSumerianKingListstillpuzzleshistoriansaftermorethanacenturyofresearch

    OutofthemanyincredibleartefactsthathavebeenrecoveredfromsitesinIraqwhereflourishingSumeriancitiesoncestood,fewhavebeenmoreintriguingthattheSumerianKingList,anancient...

    ThesymboloftheSwastikaandits12,000yearoldhistory

    TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin

    PaganGodsandthenamingofthedays

    ThelegendaryTowerofBabel

    TheSecretLivesofElvesandFaeries:TheTruthbehindtheStoryofRevRobertKirk

    TheIncrediblePowersoftheAncientSiddhars

    ANCIENT TECHNOLOGY

    NewanalysisofAntikytheraMechanismrevealscluestooneofhistorysgreatestpuzzles

    AnewstudyoftheworldfamousAntikytheramechanismhasrevealedfascinatingnewinformationaboutthepuzzlingartifact,includingthatthemathsusedforitseclipsepredictionappearstobe...

    TheIndianSagewhodevelopedAtomicTheory2,600yearsago

    150,000YearOldPipesBaffleScientistsinChina:OutofPlaceinTime?

    Therevolutionaryinventionofthewheel

    ThehydraulictelegraphofAeneaslongdistancecommunicationofantiquity

    Tenamazinginventionsfromancienttimes

    AdamsCalendar:OldestMegalithicSiteintheWorld?

    OPINION

    AtlantisRevealed:Plato'sCautionaryTaleWasBasedOnARealSetting

    Thetimeis360BC,thedawnofWesterncivilization.Athens,thecradleofdemocracy,istheepicenteroftheancientworld.InhisdialoguesofTimaeusandCritias,Platointroducesataleofan...

    Visoko:AnAstronomicalMapofMorethan100,000Years

    TheStatuesandSymbolicGesturesthatLinkAncientGbekliTepe,EasterIsland,andOtherSitesAroundtheWorld

    TheAnuandAncientSeersintheRigVeda

    AncientPersianInscriptionsLinkaBabylonianKingtotheManWhoBecameBuddha

    TheSecretofGobekliTepe:CosmicEquinoxandSacredMarriagePartII

    OUR MISSION

    AncientOriginsseekstouncover,whatwebelieve,isoneofthemostimportantpiecesofknowledgewecanacquireashumanbeingsourbeginnings.

    Whilemanybelievethatwealreadyholdsuchknowledge,ourviewisthattherestillexistsamultitudeofanomaliesandmysteriesinhumanity'spastthatdeservefurtherexamination.

    Wethereforewishtofosteranopencommunitythatisdedicatedtoinvestigating,understandingandexplainingtheoriginsofourspeciesonplanetearth.Tothisend,weaimtoorganize,supportandevenfinanceeffortsinthisdirection.

    Ouraimistomovebeyondtheoriesandtopresentathoroughexaminationofcurrentresearchandevidenceandtoofferalternativeviewpointsandexplanationstothosecurrentlyheldbymainstreamscienceandarchaeology.

    Comewithusonajourneytoexplorelostcivilisations,sacredwritings,ancientplaces,unexplainedartefactsandscientificmysterieswhileweseektoreconstructandretellthestoryofourbeginnings.

    ANCIENT IMAGE GALLERIES

    AncientOrigins20132015DisclaimerTermsofPublicationPrivacyPolicyAdvertisingPolicyWeGiveBackContactus

    AprojectofStellaNovusDevelopmentandCustomizationbyNovusWebSolutions

  • 15/6/2015 TheDisturbingTrueStoryofthePiedPiperofHamelin|AncientOrigins

    http://www.ancientorigins.net/mythslegends/disturbingtruestorypiedpiperhamelin001969 16/16