The controversy around apartheid

10
THE CONTROVERSY AROUND APARTHEID – CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE HISTORY TEACHER

description

Paper presented at the South African Society for History Teachers, 4 October 2012.

Transcript of The controversy around apartheid

Page 1: The controversy around apartheid

THE CONTROVERSY AROUND APARTHEID – CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE

HISTORY TEACHER

Page 2: The controversy around apartheid

THINKING ALOUD

The British had SlaveryThe Germans had NazismThe Americans had Segregation

South Africa had Apartheid

Page 3: The controversy around apartheid

F.W DE KLERK AND PROF GILIOMEE

In his column, Jan-Jan Joubert, political journalist of Rapport accused Prof Giliomee of “glorifying” of Apartheid.

Page 4: The controversy around apartheid

Nocheap

emotionalism!

"History has demonstrated that the most notable winners usually encounteredheart-breaking obstacles before they triumphed. They won because they refused to become discouraged by their defeats." B.C. Forbes

Page 5: The controversy around apartheid

APARTHEID’S MUSEUM…

To what extent should a society (SA) remember or forget its past? Does History education have a role to play in peace and reconciliation? Can it become a vehicle for teaching the values and skills of democracy?

Page 6: The controversy around apartheid

CHANGE AGENTS?

Teachers in post-conflict societies are expected to teach new attitudes and values. However, our identities have been shaped by our particular experiences under Apartheid and without …..???, we will struggle to be the transformative agents that the new (SA) society demands we become.

Page 7: The controversy around apartheid

APARTHEID

1. Engage History teachers with personal legacies of apartheid2. Challenge History teachers to teach a difficult past through understanding their own apartheid experience,3. Encourage students to become caring and committed citizens of the new South African democracy.

Page 8: The controversy around apartheid

ELASTOPLAST?

…we still struggle to find closure on many issues related to the past. This is in part because the wounds are still raw. It is also because we have difficulty acknowledging the depths of our trauma. (Mamphele Ramphele, 2008)

Page 9: The controversy around apartheid

APPEAL FOR A VERDICT

Failure to achieve consensus on the hurt of Apartheid spells defeat for our country and our beloved subject”

Page 10: The controversy around apartheid

DANKIETHANK YOU

ENKOSI