The Ceremony of Tasua and Ashura as a Tourism Attractions ... › cgi ›...
Transcript of The Ceremony of Tasua and Ashura as a Tourism Attractions ... › cgi ›...
The Ceremony of Tasua and Ashura as a Tourism Attractions in
Iran (Case Study: Taft City)
Abstract:
Today, tourism as a global and social phenomenon has special implication of its own. The
mechanism behind the phenomenon intertwines and takes different forms in different times
and places and completely different effects on the human beings (de freitas, 2003:47). There
are many types of tourism. One of the most important tourism forms is religious tourism.
Religious tourism is a combination of travel and religion. Most writers are taking into account
religious tourism as a part of cultural tourism. Of course, both are quite different, but these
two are tied together, and religion is a part of culture. Religious Cultural Festival is an event
that causes tourism to travel to a foreign country for looking for religion and heritage
experience. Hence the Muharram ceremonies (Ashura and Tasua) as a religious event can be
raised as an event that can familiarize domestic and foreign tourists with part of Iranian
religious and culture society. Iran is an old and historical country and its present religious is
Islam, most of the people are Shia? The ceremonies of Tasua and Ashura in most part of this
country with different showings are done. One of those is in Taft city located in Yazd
province. This research is with aims to optimize utilization of the Ashura and Tasua religious
festival in order to develop Taft city and to remove barriers on the way of Taft religious
tourism using the SWOT model. This evaluation model (that evaluated strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities and threats) is considered one of the best strategies for tourism planning.
Methods of data collection and analysis of required data is more documentaries, analytical
and Survey research. The results indicate that proximity to population centers and urban
centers, such as the city of Yazd and distinctive funeral's style from other parts of Province,
are the best strengths for this city's religious tourism. Short duration of tourists stay in the
cities and Lack of tourists' economic outputs in the city are the weaknesses. Finally,
considering to strengths, weaknesses, threats and opportunities were presented competitive -
aggressive, variation, revision and defensive strategies.
Keywords: Religious tourism, religious carnivals, Moharram, Taft, SWOT model
1. Introduction
Tourism is traditionally closely linked to religion which has acted as powerful motive for
travel from the time of early pilgrimages to contemporary journeys to sacred
places(Jackowski & Smith, 1992
events are important tourism attractions for those with a casual interest as well as mor
followers of the particular systems of belief
In urban tourism different factors can be lead to attract tourism, that existe
be one of these factors(Papoli
being Muslim is among countries that can be
number of eager tourist(Mousavi & Baghery, 2013
example of Shia-Muslim cultural
and movement folk (Ghaderi, Ezati
as a ceremony that reflects culture and religious of Shia Muslims can be
form of the events as tourism attraction. The most important aim of this research is
discrimination of positive points in Tas
strengths and on the other hand
tourism industries in Tasua and Ashura in Taft city
research is that what are the potential
development of tourism industries in Taft city
Pic 1: Two scenes of Tasua and A
So far, In addition, little attention has been paid to religious events and festivals and most
studies in this mater have only been carried out in a small number of areas. Hence, General
texts about events and religious tourism include those by Getz (2008);
(2013); Lamont, Kennelly, and Wilson (2012
and Wong (2010); Collins-Kreiner (2010b
and Lee (2012); Henderson (2003
2. Theoretical Basis
Jackowski & Smith, 1992). Religious buildings, rituals, festivals and ceremonial
events are important tourism attractions for those with a casual interest as well as mor
followers of the particular systems of belief represented(Henderson, 2003;
In urban tourism different factors can be lead to attract tourism, that existe
Papoli yazdy & Saqaei, 2006). Iran due to its specific situation and
is among countries that can be very active in religious tourism and attract large
Mousavi & Baghery, 2013). Tasua and Ashura ceremonies are one
Muslim cultural-religious ceremonies that every year held in form of
Ezati, & Hafezi zade, 2009) (Pic. 1). Tasua and Ash
as a ceremony that reflects culture and religious of Shia Muslims can be
form of the events as tourism attraction. The most important aim of this research is
discrimination of positive points in Tasua and Ashura ceremonies in Taft city and
on the other hand surveys the factors that are as an obstacle in the wa
tourism industries in Tasua and Ashura in Taft city and resolve them. Basic question in this
the potentials Tasua and Ashura ceremony and what role
ourism industries in Taft city?
Ashura ceremony in Taft City.
So far, In addition, little attention has been paid to religious events and festivals and most
s in this mater have only been carried out in a small number of areas. Hence, General
texts about events and religious tourism include those by Getz (2008); Mills and Rosentraub
Lamont, Kennelly, and Wilson (2012); del Barrio, Devesa, and Herrero (2012
Kreiner (2010b), Felsenstein and Fleischer (2003);
Henderson (2003); Anwar and Sohail (2004).
buildings, rituals, festivals and ceremonial
events are important tourism attractions for those with a casual interest as well as more devout
; Montazeri, 2011).
In urban tourism different factors can be lead to attract tourism, that existence of custom can
. Iran due to its specific situation and
very active in religious tourism and attract large
ra ceremonies are one
held in form of flow
a and Ashura ceremonies
as a ceremony that reflects culture and religious of Shia Muslims can be introduced in the
form of the events as tourism attraction. The most important aim of this research is
Taft city and their
the factors that are as an obstacle in the way of
and resolve them. Basic question in this
ra ceremony and what role it has in
So far, In addition, little attention has been paid to religious events and festivals and most
s in this mater have only been carried out in a small number of areas. Hence, General
Mills and Rosentraub
del Barrio, Devesa, and Herrero (2012); Haq
, Felsenstein and Fleischer (2003); Lee, Arcodia,
Lefebvre, in Vukonic (1996), Vukonic and Matesic (1996)defines religious tourism as
consisting of a range of spiritual sites and associated services, which are visited for both
secular and religious reasons. Within this definition two different kinds of sites can be
identified: shrines and pilgrimage sites. Shrines encompass sites where a relic or image is
‘venerated’, whereas pilgrimage sites are places where it is recognized that a miracle has
occurred, still occurs and may do so again: an example of the latter is Lourdes in France(Raj
& Morpeth, 2007). Pilgrimage is one of the oldest forms of tourism and is an integral
component of the tourist industry; the three terms, above, can be defined in different ways and
from differing viewpoints. Pilgrimage is a journey made by a pilgrim, who travels from place
to place, usually journeying a long distance and to a sacred place as an act of
devotion(Onions, 1983). Harvey (2000) describes religion as structured, orderly, socially,
sanctioned ways of reaching out for what people want most(Rotherham, 2007). Cohen
(1992)raises important ideas, in particular noting relationships between pilgrim and tourist as
travelers(Rotherham, 2007) . Religious journeys are not new phenomena. Traditionally
religion has been an impartible motive for journeys that it considered as the earliest form of
non-economical and non-financial journeys. Jackowski (2000) estimates that approximately
240 million people travel every year because of the religion, including Christians, Muslims
and Hindus(Rojo, 2007). Lately the number of worldwide pilgrims and religious tourists has
increased significantly ((Blackwell, 2007; Collins-Kreiner, 2010a) The United Nations’
World Tourism Organization(UNWTO, 2011) has estimated the number of religious tourists
in the world to 600 million of which 50% in Asia and the Pacific and 40% in Europe(Egresi,
Kara, & Bayram, 2012)
Shackley (2003) has classified set of attraction based on religion as follows:
- Natural phenomenon (lakes, mountains, islands and gardens and Etc.).
- Buildings and places that originally are made for religious purposes.
- Buildings with religious content.-
- Special events with religious importance that held on non-religious places.
- Places with secular thought that are relevant with tragic stories or those events are
particular politically. For example: Nelson Mandela prison on Robin island.
Generally religious tourist is one who has five characteristics: first, volunteer, and temporary
and without any wages. Second, has religious motive. Third, be imposed by other motive.
Fourth, destination was a religious place and finally travel to destination was a religious
obligation(Santos, 2003).
Visitors of holy places can be classified in these groups:
• Pilgrims visiting sacred sites that have meaning for them.
• Religious tourists.
• Secular tourists.
• Pilgrims visiting sacred sites that have no religious meaning for them (tacked on to the
end of pilgrimage).
• Religious festival and religious event participants(Raj & Morpeth, 2007)
Maybe some of religious tourists are more pilgrims than tourists and on other hand maybe
they are tourists than pilgrims(Sharpley & Sundaram, 2005)
Cultural – religious festivals as an event cause a tourist to travel from a country for gain
experience from religion and heritage of other countries. Hence, Muharram ceremony
(tasooa and ashura) in Iran can be introduce as event that cause to inner and outer tourists.
Accustom with part of religious and spiritual heritage of Iranian culture. Do not perform
Muharram mourning ceremonies in Iran only, in many religious of the world
(Afghanistan, Germany, Sweden, Finland, Istanbul and Los Angeles) followers of Imam
Hussein with magnificent ceremony, exhibit their beliefs.
3. Research Area
Territory of this research is Taft city in Yazd province. Yazd province with area about
131,551 square kilometers located in center of Iran, among provinces such as Kerman,
Esfahan, Fars, Khorasn. The mean of Yazd is pure and holy. This province located
between 131 north degrees latitude and 54 east degrees longitude. The counties of this
province are including Yazd, Meybod, Mehriz, Tabas, Sadogh, Khatam, Ardakan,
Abarkouh and Taft. Taft city located from 11 and 18 until 11,2 and 87 northern latitude
and 11,7 until 11,72 eastern longitude. This city is in southwest of Yazd province and a
distance about 20 kilometer to Yazd city (provincial capital). The area that Taft located is
a valley that limited by mountain from three sides.
Map1: spatial location of
The area of this city is about 15 square kilometers and most of spaces of this city formed
by old neighborhoods and garden. Generally this city formed by two section, northern part
and southern part that respectively named garmsir and sardsir. The current city has 24
small and large neighborhoods. (http://yazdchto.ir). The people of this city before arrival
of Islam to Iran tend to Zoroastrian
included Muslims. Nevertheless we see Zoroastrians in some parts
prominent religious ceremony of this city is Nakhlbardari ceremony that this ceremony
done in Ashura day. In slang term, the means of Nakhl is palm tree but in mourning
ceremony Nakhl term is something that is like a big coffin and people turn around
(www.rasekhoon.net). Of course tasu
ceremony and people holding
Picture 2: Aerial Photos of Taft city
Map1: spatial location of Taft Township in province and country, source authors
The area of this city is about 15 square kilometers and most of spaces of this city formed
by old neighborhoods and garden. Generally this city formed by two section, northern part
at respectively named garmsir and sardsir. The current city has 24
small and large neighborhoods. (http://yazdchto.ir). The people of this city before arrival
nd to Zoroastrian religion, but today the most of population of Taft city
ms. Nevertheless we see Zoroastrians in some parts
prominent religious ceremony of this city is Nakhlbardari ceremony that this ceremony
done in Ashura day. In slang term, the means of Nakhl is palm tree but in mourning
hl term is something that is like a big coffin and people turn around
Of course tasua and shura ceremony is not unique to n
holding mourning ceremony in tasua night and ashura morning.
of Taft city and location of mourning ceremonies places
Taft Township in province and country, source authors
The area of this city is about 15 square kilometers and most of spaces of this city formed
by old neighborhoods and garden. Generally this city formed by two section, northern part
at respectively named garmsir and sardsir. The current city has 24
small and large neighborhoods. (http://yazdchto.ir). The people of this city before arrival
religion, but today the most of population of Taft city
ms. Nevertheless we see Zoroastrians in some parts of city. Most
prominent religious ceremony of this city is Nakhlbardari ceremony that this ceremony
done in Ashura day. In slang term, the means of Nakhl is palm tree but in mourning
hl term is something that is like a big coffin and people turn around
a and shura ceremony is not unique to nakhlbardari
a night and ashura morning.
of mourning ceremonies places.
4. Methodology
This research from the point of view of purpose is applied and developmental and
research method is descriptive and analytical. Techniques of data collection were
documentary and field studies like interview, then due to obtained data was survived to
attractions, facilities, services and general religious tourism policies in Taft city,
recognition quad factors of SWOT model as a inevitable in order to weaknesses and
threats removal, strengths and opportunity improvement that has been stated below:
1.1.Effective external factors of Taft city religious tourism and method of valuation
The purpose of this step is survey external circumference effects in study area for
recognize opportunities and threats that this city is faced in relation with tourism
development. Base on done studies and survey peripheral area situation, studied collection
of opportunities and threats that are effective in this city in view of tourism that they are
stated in table 1 and 2:
Table 1: analysis external factors of opportunities and threats
Weighted
Score
Score Weight Opportunities(O)
1/2 4 0/3 Employment and income generation
0/8 4 0/2 Contribute to the city economic dynamism
0/3 3 0/1 Growth tourism industries in Taft city, Taft township and Yazd
province
0/15 2 0/075 Increase rate of absorbed provincial funding in Taft township
0/225 3 0/075 Improvement of Infrastructures city facilities
0/1 2 0/05 Introduction of Taft as sample of tourism city and enhance the city
prestige
0/025 1 0/025 Enhance sense of belonging and citizen participation in city affairs
0/025 1 0/025 Appropriate opportunity for introducing other productions of Taft
0/3 3 0/1 Absorption of native and non-native investors
0/5 1 0/5 A reduction in migration indigenous people to provincial capital
0/2 2 0/1 Proper geographical location of Yazd province
3.375 1 Sum
Weighted
Score
Score Weight Threats(T)
0/1 1 0/1 Environmental pollution
0/2 2 0/1 Destruction of gardens and city green spaces.
0/1 4 0/25 Changing nature of ceremony from a spiritual ceremony to a folk
show
0/4 2 0/2 Influx off population and disrupting in perform ceremony
0/3 3 0/1 Creating conflict with indigenous people due to entering tourism
with different cultures
0/1 2 0/05 A general increase in prices particularly in land prices
0/15 3 0/05 Reduction in presence of indigenous people in this ceremony
0/1 1 0/1 Destruction infrastructures and city facilities
0/05 1 0/05 Destruction and exhaustion of mosques and religious sites
1/5 1 Sum
According to table 1, the most important opportunities that Taft city in religious tourism is
faced with them: Employment and income generation with weighted score 1/2 as first
opportunity, Contribute to the city economic dynamism with weighted score 0/8 as second
opportunity, Absorption of native and non-native investors and Growth tourism industries in
Taft city, Taft township and Yazd province with weighted score 0/3 as third opportunity,
Improvement of Infrastructures city facilities with weighted score 0/225 as fourth opportunity,
Proper geographical location of Yazd province with weighted score 0/2 as fifth opportunity,
Increase rate of absorbed provincial funding in Taft township with weighted score 0/15 as
sixth opportunity, A reduction in migration indigenous people to provincial capital with
weighted score 0/05 as seventh opportunity and town opportunities of Enhance sense of
belonging and citizen participation in city affairs and Appropriate opportunity for introducing
other productions of Taft are known as eight opportunity. On the other hand, according to
table 2, components such as influx of population and disturbing in perform ceremony with
weighted score 0/4 as first threat, creating conflict with indigenous people due to entering
tourisms with different culture with weighted score0/3 as second threat, destruction of
gardens and city green space with weighted score 0/2 as third threat. Reduction in presence
of indigenous people in this ceremony with weighted score 0/15 as fourth threat,
environmental pollution, changing nature of the ceremony from a spiritual ceremony to a
folkloric show, a general increases in prices particularly in land prices and destruction
infrastructures and city facilities with weighted score 0/1 are as fifth threat, destruction and
exhausting of mosques and religious sites with weighted score 0/05 as sixth threat, are known
as threats that Taft religious tourism in tasooa and ashura ceremony is faced with them.
1.2.Effective eternal factors on religious tourism and method of valuation
The purpose of this step is survey of the internal circumference study area for recognizing
strength and weakness. Aspects are considered that have conductive or obstructive content in
achieving to plan goals. Hence, in this part, were investigated three existing strategic
categories, functions, resources and was divided in framework of Taft religious tourism
dimensions in table 3 and 2.
Table 2: analysis internal factors of Strengths and Weakness
Weighte
d Score Score Weight Strengths(S)
0/1 2 0/05 Attention of authorities to this ceremony and being this ceremony in national
heritage list of Iran.
0/8 4 0/2 Proximity of Taft city to urban centers such as Yazd city.
0/14 2 0/07 Taft city is being able to invest on tourism planning.
0/3 3 0/1 Existence of beautiful and unique view with green space and gardens in the city.
0/8 4 0/2 Performing this ceremony with different style forms in other cities in Yazd
province.
0/15 3 0/05 Existence of proper space for car park.
0/14 2 0/07 High capacity of Taft city for attraction of tourists.
0/3 3 0/1 Existence of many vows and devotes for serving.
0/12 2 0/06 Performing this ceremony in different hours in other surrounding cities.
3.05 1 Sum
Weighte
d Score Score Weight Weakness(W)
0/3 2 0/15 Existence of heavy traffic at early and late hours of ceremony.
0/45 3 0/15 Weakness of related infrastructures to tourism in the city.
0/6 4 0/15 Short staying time of tourists in the city.
0/6 4 0/15 Lack of tourists economic returns.
0/15 2 0/75 Pollution and making garbage.
0/1 2 0/05 Disorder in performing ceremony by tourists.
0/15 1 0/15 Wake of full informing this ceremony in country.
0/25 2 0/125 Impose a financial burden to city organizations like municipality.
2/6 1 Sum
According to table 2, most important strength is proximity to urban centers like Yazd city and
performing this ceremony in different style from other cities with weighted score0/8 as first
strength, existence of beautiful scene with green spaces and gardens in the city and existence
of many vows and devotes for serving to tourists with weighted score 0/3 as second strength,
existence of proper space for car park with weighted score 0/15 as third strength. Proper space
and capacity in the city for attraction tourists and make able Taft to invest on tourism
planning and introduce Taft as an important pole for tourism with weighted score 0/14 as
fourth strength and finally performing this ceremony in different hours from other
surrounding cities.
According to table 2, section weakness the first weakness that gain highest weighted score is
short staying of tourists in the city and on the other hand lack of tourists economic returns for
city weighted score 0/6, weakness of infrastructure related to tourism with weighted score
0/45,existence heavy traffic at early and late hours of ceremony with weighted score 0/3,
impose a financial burden to city organizations like municipality with weighted score
0/25,pollution and making garbage and wake of full informing this ceremony in country with
weighted score 0/15, disorder in performing this ceremony by tourists with weighted score
0/1, are respectively most important weakness in Taft religious tourism.
Figure 1: Internal and external matrix (IE) Taft city religious tourism.
Table 3: the matrix of SWOT model for Taft city religious development
2. Conclusion
eakness Strengths
� Existence heavy traffic at early
and late hours of ceremony.
� Weakness of related
infrastructures to tourism in the
city .
� Short staying time of tourists in
the city.
� Lack of tourists economic
returns.
� Pollution and making garbage.
� Disorder in perform ceremony by
tourists.
� Wake of full informing this
ceremony in country.
� Attention of authorities to this ceremony
and being this ceremony in national
heritage list of Iran.
� Proximity of Taft city to urban centers
such as Yazd city.
� Taft city is being able to investment and
tourism planning.
� Existence beautiful and unique view with
green space and gardens in the city.
WO Strategy SO Strategy
• Development and
improvement of
Communication ways.
• Consultation and interact
among city authorities and
organizations related to
tourism in development of
tourism plans.
• Using from people
participation in all level of
tourism planning
• Attraction native and non-
native investigators to exit
from Lack of economic
returns conditions.
• Recognition and utilization from
other tourism attraction of this
city with use this ceremony.
• Draw attention of Authorities to
increase investigation and
employment in the city.
• Draw attention of investigators to
investigation in Taft tourism
sector.
• Attraction native and non-native
experts from other parts of
province and country.
• Attraction tourism in other
seasons of the year.
• Using from people donations to
improvement infrastructures and
Municipal utilities.
• Development Tourism
infrastructures like build hotel
and restaurant and using from
Beautiful and pristine Taft nature
to attract tourists and create new
jobs.
� Employment and income
generation
� Contribute to the city economic
dynamism
� Growth tourism industries in Taft
city, Taft township and Yazd
province
� Increase rate of absorbed
provincial funding in Taft
township
� Improvement of Infrastructures
city facility
� Introduction of Taft as sample
city tourism and enhance the city
prestige
� Enhance sense of belonging and
citizen participation in city affairs
� Appropriate opportunity for
introducing other production of
Taft
Op
po
rtu
nit
ies
WT Strategy STStrategy � Environmental pollution
� Destruction of gardens and city
green space .
� Changing nature of ceremony
from a spiritual ceremony to a
folk show
� Influx off population and
disrupting in perform ceremony
� Creating conflict with indigenous
people due to entering tourism
with different cultures
� A general increase in prices
particularly in land prices
� Reduction in presence of
indigenous people in this
ceremony
� Destruction infrastructures and
city facilities
� Destruction and exhaustion of
mosques and religious sites
Th
rea
ts
• Attraction public
participation in
conservation of Natural
and human resources.
• Holding mitting with the
presence of community
elders and adoption
measures about
performing ceremony
regularity.
• Consultations of city
authorities with
government officials about
receive a budget for those
expenses that tourist
imposed.
• Coordination among
organizations to decrease
environmental pollutions.
• Attract Public investment to
reconstruction of mosques and
religious site.
• Increase of indigenous people in
performing this ceremony.
• Using from Yazd city as nearest
and biggest city to Taft for
attract excess entered
population.
• Strengthening advertising In the
Media about Taft tourism
capabilities.
Taft city Religious Tourism
Development
According to theoretical basis and preformed field studies, in order to offer strategies and
guidelines for development of tourism capacity, specified tourism limitation in the city and
presented practical response for city tourism development. With this description can present
obtained results in both qualitative and quantitative aspects. The results of identified
qualitative aspects reflect these subjects that, first: level of vulnerability is in high level in
view of tourism development in the city. Second, this city has needs in tourism that they are
necessary for tourism development. quantities aspects review show that, among strong points
proximity to population and city centers like Yazd and perform this mourning ceremony in
different style in other cities of Yazd province, existence of beautiful and unique scene with
green spaces and gardens in the city and existence of many vows and devotes for serving
passengers are most important strength for development of Taft city religious tourism.
with respect to obtain results among weak points, short staying of tourists in the city and lack
of tourism economic returns for city, weakness of infrastructures related to tourism in the city,
heavy traffic at early and late hours of ceremony are as barriers for development of tourism
and must remove and improve these barriers. Moreover, among external opportunities,
employment and income generation contribute to city economic dynamism and absorption of
native and non-native investors are most important opportunities that Taft city faces with
them among external threats factors like influx of population and disputing in performing
ceremony. Creating conflict with indigenous people due to entering tourisms with different
culture and disruption of gardens and city green space are most important external threats.
In total it can be said if Taft city wants to develop and has a role in tourism attraction should
at first identify potentials and capacities in the city and develop tourism with codified
planning. This city has high potential and this invisible export (tourism) can do considerable
help with development and growth of the city. Tasua and ashura ceremony is one of this
tourism potential. Props to prepare comprehensive and detailed tourism plan and it is
necessary to provide enough money for create tourism data bank and research marketing for
tourism attraction. It is necessary to maintain and restore mosques and husaniyes and develop
and improve facilities and city infrastructures in standard level. It is necessary to coordinate
among responsible organizations through create an integrated management and doing
extensive advertisement in the country and neighbor countries for acquainting more tourists,
particularly shies for this ceremony. On the other hand, should revive traditional jobs like
handicrafts and create marketplaces for sale handicrafts, livestock products, agricultural
products for job creating and earning in the city. Active participation in external and internal
tourism exhibition and establishment of different exhibitions in the city will cause to
introduce this city and gain useful experience.
Refrences
Anwar, Syed Aziz, & Sohail, M. Sadiq. (2004). Festival tourism in the United Arab Emirates: First-
time versus repeat visitor perceptions. Journal of Vacation Marketing, 10(2), 161-170. doi:
10.1177/135676670401000206
Blackwell, Ruth. (2007). Motivations for religious tourism, pilgrimage, festivals and events. Religious
tourism and pilgrimage festivals management: an international perspective, 35-47.
Cohen, Erik. (1992). Pilgrimage centers: Concentric and excentric. Annals of tourism research, 19(1),
33-50.
Collins-Kreiner, Noga. (2010a). Current Jewish pilgrimage tourism: Modes and models of
development. Turizam: znanstveno-stručni časopis, 58(3), 259-270.
Collins-Kreiner, Noga. (2010b). The geography of pilgrimage and tourism: Transformations and
implications for applied geography. Applied Geography, 30(1), 153-164.
del Barrio, María José, Devesa, María, & Herrero, Luis César. (2012). Evaluating intangible cultural
heritage: The case of cultural festivals. City, Culture and Society, 3(4), 235-244. doi:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ccs.2012.09.002
Egresi, Istvan, Kara, Fatih, & Bayram, Büşra. (2012). Economic Impact of Religious Tourism in
Mardin, Turkey. Journal of Economics and Business Research, 7.
Ghaderi, asmael, Ezati, ezatola, & Hafezi zade, shaghayegh. (2009). the ways of using from tasooa and ashura
ceremony as religious cultural tourism potential in central bazaar area of Tehran. geographic space,
9(28), 75-101.
Haq, Farooq, & Wong, Ho Yin. (2010). Is spiritual tourism a new strategy for marketing Islam?
Journal of Islamic Marketing, 1(2), 136-148.
Harvey, Graham. (2000). Indigenous religions: a companion (Vol. 3): Cassell.
Henderson, Joan C. (2003). Managing tourism and Islam in peninsular Malaysia. Tourism
Management, 24(4), 447-456.
Jackowski, Antoni. (2000). Religious Tourism-Problems with Terminology: Instytut Geografii
Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.
Jackowski, Antoni, & Smith, Valene L. (1992). Polish pilgrim-tourists. Annals of tourism research,
19(1), 92-106.
Lamont, Matthew, Kennelly, Millicent, & Wilson, Erica. (2012). Competing priorities as constraints in
event travel careers. Tourism Management, 33(5), 1068-1079. doi:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2011.12.005
Lee, Insun, Arcodia, Charles, & Lee, Timothy Jeonglyeol. (2012). Benefits of visiting a multicultural
festival: The case of South Korea. Tourism Management, 33(2), 334-340.
Mills, Brian M., & Rosentraub, Mark S. (2013). Hosting mega-events: A guide to the evaluation of
development effects in integrated metropolitan regions. Tourism Management, 34(0), 238-
246. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2012.03.011
Montazeri, Hamid. (2011). Experimental and numerical study on natural ventilation performance of
various multi-opening wind catchers. Building and Environment, 46(2), 370-378.
Mousavi, M , & Baghery, A (2013). Cultural tourism( nature & concepts). Tehran: Arad book
publisher
Onions, CT. (1983). The Shorter Oxford Dictionary on Historical Principles. 3rd edn., Book Club
Associates with Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK.
Papoli yazdy, Mohammad hossein, & Saqaei, Mahdi (2006). Tourism(nature & concepts). Tehran:
Samt Publisher
Raj, Razaq, & Morpeth, Nigel D. (2007). Religious tourism and pilgrimage festivals management: An
international perspective: CABI.
Rojo, David Mashhadigholam. (2007). Religious tourism: The way to Santiago. MA European
Tourism Management, Bournemouth University.
Rotherham, Ian D. (2007). Sustaining tourism infrastructures for religious tourists and pilgrims within
the UK. Religious tourism and pilgrimage festivals management, 64-77.
Santos, MGMP. (2003). Religious tourism: Contributions towards a clarification of concepts.
Religious tourism and pilgrimage. Fatima, Portugal: Tourism Board of Leiria.
Shackley, Myra. (2003). Management challenges for religion-based attractions. Managing Visitor
Attractions, 4.
Sharpley, Richard, & Sundaram, Priya. (2005). Tourism: A sacred journey? The case of ashram
tourism, India. International Journal of Tourism Research, 7(3), 161-171.
UNWTO. (2011). Religious Tourism in Asia and the Pacific, Madrid. Madrid, Spain: World Tourism
Organization (UNWTO)
Vukonic, Boris, & Matesic, Sanja. (1996). Tourism and religion: Pergamon Oxford.