The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe...
Transcript of The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe...
![Page 1: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
The astronomical system of Ptolemy ofAlexandria (ca. 150 AD)
Jan P. Hogendijk
Dept of Mathematics, Utrecht
May 12, 2011
![Page 2: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
The Almagest of Ptolemy (ca. A.D. 150)
Basic work of Greek astronomy; much wiped out most of the olderastronomical literature. Title: megale syntaxis = greatcomposition. Hence: al+megiste = the greatest.
13 “books” (big chapters): 1. Introduction and math; 2. Math ofthe sphere (earth and celestial sphere); 3. Solar theory, 4. Lunartheory of conjunctions and oppositions; 5. General lunar theory; 6.Parallax and eclipses; 7 and 8. The fixed stars; precession; starcatalogue; 9. Planets in general, Mercury 10. Venus and Mars, 11.Jupiter and Saturn; 12. Stationary points and retrograde motion;13. Latitude of planets.
![Page 3: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Structure of the Almagest
The book is structured as a mathematical work.The theoretical structure is: sun → moon → fixed stars → planets.The basic reference circle is the ecliptic (path of the sun) with thevernal point as basic point of reference.
![Page 4: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Theory of the sun
Philosophical Assumption: sun moves in a circle around the earthwith uniform velocity around center E .
Α
ΒGsolstice
summer
spring
equinox
equinox
equatorwinter
fall
BT perpendicular to ATG
Τ E
Input: Observations of the solar noon altitude; hence: lengths ofthe three seasons. Output: a theory of the solar motion.
![Page 5: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
The lunar theory (simple case: for conjunction andopposition with the sun)
.Philosophical Assumption: the moon moves uniformly on anepicycle around a point, which moves uniformly in a circle aroundthe center of the earth. (The lunar daily motion varies.)
Earth
Moon
C
![Page 6: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
The lunar theory (simple case: for conjunction andopposition with the sun)
Problem: The moon is so close that we cannot ignore its parallax:the difference between the position as seen from the center of theearth, and the position seen by the observer. So we almost neverknow where the moon is with respect to the center of the earth(except when it is right above our head).
theoryobserved
Moon
Earth
Solution: look at lunar eclipses (close in time). Observe themidpoint carefully. In the middle of a lunar eclipse, the positioncan be computed as sun + 180o .
![Page 7: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Three lunar eclipses
Input: the period of the velocity of the moon (varies between 11and 15 degrees per day); the moments and positions of three lunareclipses
X Y
Z
E
C
C is the center of the epicycle, X the positionof the first eclipse. For the second and thirdeclipse, turn the epicycle back around E so itscenter coincides with C , and let Y and Z bethe positions of the eclipses. The time intervalsgive ∠XCY ,YCZ . The position differences (ofthe sun at mid-eclipse) give ∠XEY ,YEZ .Hard mathematics then produces|EC | : |CX |,∠CEX .
![Page 8: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
More general lunar Theory
This theory works well for conjunction and opposition, but Ptolemyfinds discrepancies with observed values of the moon atquadrature. Then the epicycle should be bigger.Solution: a crank mechanism which draws the moon closer atquadratures.
The resulting theory works well at quadratures, but not at theoctants.Solution: compute the angles from a different (prosneusis) point.The resulting (difficult) theory works well at opposition andconjunction, quadratures and octants - for lunar positions. Not fordistances to the earth. At first and last quadrature, the distance isonly half of the distance at opposition.
![Page 9: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
Parallax
One can again compare the theoretical position of the moon withthe actual observed position.The difference is the lunar parallax q.
theoryobserved
Moon
Earth
(sin q = r/d · cos a, a the altitude above the horizon, r the earthradius, d the lunar distance).Hence d ≈ 60r (mean distance).Lunar radius ≈ 0.27 earth radius.N.B. Ptolemy uses one false parallax observation and his falsemodel (for the quadratures) to arrive at true lunar distance atconjunctions and oppositions.
![Page 10: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Solar Distance
Input: radius of shadow cone of the Earth is 13/5 times the moonradius.Apparent radius of sun and moon is 1
4
o.
moon Earth moonR
sunx
d60R 60R
0.27R0.27R
Output: solar distance is ≈ 1200 times earth radius (≈ 7.5 millionkm).
![Page 11: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
The universe of Ptolemy
Sat
V
Mars
Jup
Sphere of Mars
Sphere of Jupiter
Sphere of Saturn
Sphere of the fixed starsOutermost sphere (signs of zodiac)
Sun
Mo
Me
E
![Page 12: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
“Proof” of the Ptolemaic System: Part 1
Basic idea: ratio between maximum and minimum distance ofplanet can be deduced from observations.
α α
r
R
C
P
E
r = R sin α
max/min = (R + r)/(R − r) = (1 + sinα)/(1− sin α).
![Page 13: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
“Proof” of the Ptolemaic System: Part 2
Maximum distance of the moon us 64 earth radii (R).
Philosophical assumption: this is minimum distance of the ‘next’planet (Mercury), because there is no useless space. For Mercury,min:max = 34:88. So max. Mercury is 166R.
Assumption: this is minimum distance of Venus. For Venus,min:max = 16:104. So max. distance Venus is 1079R.
But: the solar distance is approximately 1200 R; minimum 1160R.So everything fits nicely together!
![Page 14: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Ptolemy’s equant model for a superior planet
M EqE
sun
Mars, Jupiter, Saturn acc. to Ptolemy
E=earth; center C of epicycle moveson circle with center M, motion is
Line C−P (Planet) is parallel to lineEarth − mean sun.
uniform with respect to Eq.
C
P
![Page 15: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
The value of Ptolemaic astronomy
Ptolemaic astronomy is physically wrong!
BUT:
it is not inconsistent with (naked eye) observations
(except extremely accurate observations by Tycho Brahe).
![Page 16: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
The value of Ptolemaic astronomy
For the mathematical prediction of the positions of sun andplanets, there is no real difference between:
1. The Ptolemaic model of the universe, as updated andmodified by some Islamic astronomers.
2. The heliocentric model of Copernicus (1543).
![Page 17: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
The value of Ptolemaic astronomy: the sun
E
S
Heliocentric
Geocentric
E
S
Geocentric motion of the sun is mathematically equivalent toheliocentric motion of the earth
![Page 18: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
The value of Ptolemaic astronomy: inferior planets
P P
P
Mercury, Venus
S S S
E E E
HeliocentricGeocentric
(epicycle with centeron line ES)
Ptolemy and medieval
The Ptolemaic model of Mercury and Venus is (more or less)mathematically equivalent to a heliocentric model
![Page 19: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
The value of Ptolemaic astronomy: superior planets
PC C
P
Mars, Jupiter, Saturnus
Modern
E E
S=Sun, P=Planet, E=Earth,
S
C=Center epicycle
Ptolemy, medieval
The Ptolemaic model of Mars, Jupiter and Saturn is (more or less)mathematically equivalent to a heliocentric model
![Page 20: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Conclusion
Thus one can understand why the Almagest of Ptolemy becamethe basic work of astronomy for almost 1400 years (ca. 150 AD -1543)
![Page 21: The astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD)fverbunt/iac2011/greek2.pdfThe astronomical system of Ptolemy of Alexandria (ca. 150 AD) Jan P. Hogendijk Dept of Mathematics,](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041720/5e4e02a947a2bf68e513b6d1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Exam question
Explain the universe of Ptolemy in a drawing, and explain thereasons why the Ptolemaic models are consistent with naked-eyeobservations of the sun and the inferior and superior planets.
Literature: Pannekoek, chapter on Greek astronomy, sections onHipparchus and Ptolemy, Sections 13, 14 (ligthly).Pannekoek English version: p. 133-144; 145-162 (lightly)Nederlands: p. 110-118; 118-132 (globaal)
Further reading (not necessary for the exam):G.J. Toomer, The Almagest, London: Duckworth, 1984 (Englishtranslation)O. Pedersen, A Survey of the Almagest, Odense 1974 (goodintroduction)