Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 1

Zelgai Saleh, Nathan Zelalem, Amanda Hendrix

Mrs. Partlow

English 11 AP

March 10, 2014

Pushing Up Daisies

A large Victorian house in the suburbs, an apple pie on the windowsill cooling just as dad

gets home from work to greet his family by their white picket fence. This is the image that comes

mind when people picture the American dream. The American dream can mainly be reached in

two ways. Through money and materialistic means, or through idealistic personal achievement.

Sometimes money is enough to make someone happy. Money provides comfort, and in Gatsby’s

case, company. On the other hand, the idea of the American Dream can also be interpreted as

personal achievement, rugged individualism and unadulterated expressions of spontaneous free

will. While neither Gatsby nor McCandless really achieved the American Dream, Chris

McCandless came the closest because he was content throughout his journey, he embodies

rugged individualism and freedom and Jay Gatsby never came close to achieving his dream, or

the American Dream.

Before we can get into the specifics of each man’s achievements and goals and who came

the closest to achieving the “American Dream”, we need to have a clear definition of what The

Dream is. As stated above, people’s perception of the American Dream can vary and does so

wildly. Yet, when evaluating and closely examining each variation of the American Dream

common themes prevail. One of the most common themes is individualism. This is seen in

Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 2

stories of the “self-made man”, in America’s apparent capacity for great social mobility and even

in our picture of the American family. Another common theme is freedom, this, in some senses,

can be regarded as the original American Dream. Freedom is the reason why America was

founded and the reason why we prosper. The ability of people to be free not only from the

government but also from society has been our constant idea of Freedom. The noble families of

England don’t exist here and each man is his own man, made and judged by his own volition and

effort, not by his family. The last common theme is personal achievement and happiness. This, in

some ways, is linked to individualism; you can achieve what you want when you want as you

strive to fulfill yourself. This prevails throughout American history, going as far back as the

Declaration of Independence and man’s inalienable right to the “Pursuit of Happiness”.  

“It is the experiences, the memories, the great triumph of joy of living to the fullest

extent, in which real meaning is found. God it’s great to be alive! Thank you. Thank you.”

(Krakauer 37). Throughout the book we see McCandless consistently declare himself overjoyed

or satisfied with something he has pursued. McCandless’ journey therefore provided him with

more happiness than Gatsby’s did. Along his journey, McCandless was able to find meaning, and

in his own measure success. We see that not only did he love the life he chose to lead but he had

no regrets and was content with it: “As for me, I’ve decided I’m going to live this life for some

time to come. The freedom and simple beauty of it is just too good to pass up.” (Krakauer 33).

On the other hand Gatsby reaps the exact opposite. He has found no meaning and has not

succeed primary goal of getting Daisy. “You loved me too? He repeated. … The words seemed

to bite physically into Gatsby.” (Fitzgerald 132). Here Gatsby’s dreams of Daisy and his

conception of their relationship is shattered as she tells him that she loved him and Tom too

Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 3

essentially crushing his fantasy of Daisy. McCandless’ journey had its shortcomings too, while

he was happy throughout his journey he did not intend to die in Alaska: “It may be a very long

time before we see each other again. But providing that I get through this Alaskan Deal in one

piece you will be hearing from me again in the future.” (Krakauer 56) So while McCandless

came close his unpreparedness still killed him and he never truly achieve the American Dream.

While Gatsby’s version of the American Dream was riches and parties and getting the

girl, McCandless’ dream differed greatly but better embodied the American Dream. The original,

rugged and true American Dream. The one seen in the frontiersmen of the historic American

west and the original American patriots that freed the US from British control. We see this

continuing idea of freedom from social bonds and using that freedom with the individualism bred

by American culture to explore and do amazing things and fulfill ourselves with our own two

hands. McCandless exemplifies all these true American ideals:

… Chris was gone. Five week earlier he’d loaded all his belongings into his little car and

headed west without an itinerary. The trip was to be an odyssey in the fullest sense of the

world, an epic journey that would change everything. … At long last he was

unencumbered, emancipated from the stifling world of his parents and peers, a world of

abstraction and security and material excess, … . (Krakauer 22)

Yet, while McCandless exemplified all these great American ideals and the true American

Dream Gatsby did exactly the opposite. The story of Jay Gatsby is a story of what the American

Dream hopes to escape. Clearly Scott Fitzgerald has written the “Great Gatsby” not to show that

Gatsby lived the American Dream or that even he came close but rather as a satire of wealth and

material excess, to show us what we need to escape to truly be happy and to truly live the

Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 4

American Dream. Throughout the story Gatsby, while he may seem free is constantly bound by

the chains of social order and by his wealth, the very things meant to free him only bind him

closer into a society that stifles and distorts the American Dream.

Jay Gatsby was a man who went from rags to riches, but at a great cost. His primary goal

was to marry and run away with the girl that he met 5 years earlier, but he attempted to achieve

this goal through dishonest means. Like Chris McCandless, Gatsby had a dream, but his dream

became corrupted by the idea that money could buy his happiness. Amassing his wealth to

impress Daisy through illegal techniques ultimately led to his demise. Gatsby died knowing that

Daisy would never truly love him as he had always intended. “He had come a long way to this

blue lawn, and his dream must have seemed so close that he could hardly fail to grasp it. He did

not know that it was already behind him.” (Fitzgerald 180) His entire life revolved around the

past, and the fact that he believed he could change it. “Can’t repeat the past?” He cried

incredulously. “Why of course you can!” (Fitzgerald 110) However, this could never happen

because Daisy and Gatsby lived in different social positions. Daisy was not going to give up on

Tom to be with Gatsby and face the social consequences. Tom would also never be completely

out of their lives because he and Daisy had a child together. Jay Gatsby lost sight of happiness,

his dream and the American Dream because he was strove to achieve an impossible thing and

ultimately was in love with a past time and a past life.

Neither Gatsby nor McCandless truly achieved the American Dream. For one thing, the

American Dream involves living. Neither of them made it to the end of their race, and were cut short.

However if each were to continue their story and live on, we would see that Gatsby would first need

to completely come to terms with the end of his dream, and begin anew to free himself of the chains

Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 5

that bind him into a distorted version of the American Dream. McCandless would remain proud of

himself for accomplishing such a feat, and would most likely find peace after living his dream.

McCandless would have reason to be content because he was unhappy and took it upon himself to go

out and fulfill his idea of freedom. By escaping his parents and peers to find his own way. He pushed

for independence and needed no other comforts to satisfy himself. His lack of excess materialistic

needs freed him, while Gatsby’s obsession with materials did the opposite. “So many people live in

unhappy circumstances and yet ... they are conditioned to a life of security , conformity, and

conservatism.” (Krakauer 57) McCandless freed himself and Gatsby stayed chained in the social

order of West Egg and East Egg trying to achieve a goal which was already lost and was already just

a memory. McCandless embodied all that the American Dream was, is and stands for and Gatsby

embodied all the American Dream hopes to escape. Although in the end they were both just, pushing

up daisies.

Saleh, Zelalem, Hendrix 6

Works Cited

Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. New York: Scribner, 2004. Print.

Krakauer, Jon. Into The Wild. New York: Anchor, 2007. Print.