BIBLIOGRAPHY

TEXT BOOKS

A. Ashworth. The Criminal Process (2M' ed. Oxford: OUP. 1998)

Alan G Atherly, Jack R Glrton 8 h h n F McDonald, The Sclence of Genetics

(Standards College Publ~sh~ng, 1999)

Andrew L C & Ligerrwood Australian Evidence (2"' ed. 1993).

Bentham. Rationale of Ev~dence ( 1 827)

Bernard Devlin 8 Kathryn Roeder, "DNA Profiling: Statistics and Population Genetics", in

David Faigrnan et al. (eds ) Modern Sc,entific Evidence: The Law And Science of Experf

Testimony (1 997).

Bernard Robertson & G.A Vignaux, lnte~reting Evidence- Evaluating Forensic Science in the

Courf Room (John Wiley 8 Sons, Chichester, 1995).

Best, Principles of The Law of Evidence (1849 ed.)

Brian J. Heard. Handbook of Firearms snd Ballistics-Examining and Interpreting Forensic

Evidence (1 997).

Calladine Chris 8 Horace R. Drew. Under::tanding DNA (London: Academic Press 1992).

Carl G. Hernpel. Aspects of Scientific Explanation And Other Essays In The Philosophy

Of Soence (1970).

Carl G. Hempel, The Philosophy of Natbral Science (1966)

Carol A E Jones, Expert Witnesses (Oxford 1994)

Cellmark Diagnostics, Forensic Casewclrk: Collecting and Presefvfng the Best Samples,

Vol.1, No.1, (Germantown, MD: U.S.A.. 1988).

Charles T . McCormick, McCormick On The LawofEvidence (John W . Strong ed. 4m ed. 1992).

Charles T . McCorrnick, McCormickon Evidence (Edward W . Cleary ed. 3'a 1984)

Christopher Oddie, Science And The A~iministration of Justice (1991).

Clive Walker & Keir Starmer, Miscarrjages of Justice - A Review of Justice in Error

(Blackstone Press Ltd. 1999).

Cockle, Cases and Statutes on Evidence (5'"d)

Cross & Tapper. Evidence (8Ih ed Butterworths. London 1995)

D. Peter Snustad & Michael J. Simmcns. Principles of Genetics (John Wiley & Sons.

Inc., 2000).

Edward Philips, Brief Case, Law of Evid?nce (2nd ed. Cavendish Publishing Ltd. 2000)

Edwin Shorts & Claire Than. Civil Liberttes (Sweet & Maxwell. London 1998).

Evidence, Inns of Court School of Law i Blackstone Press Ltd 4'"d 1999)

Farley, MA & Harrington, JJ, Forensic L)NA Technology (Lewis Publishers Inc., Chelsea,

Michigan, 1991).

Febbrajo & 13. Nelken. "The Truth Atlout Laws Truth", in Milan (ed.) The European

Yearbook For Sociology of Law (1993).

Field. Expert Evidence (3'"d R G Sagar for law publishers (India Pvt. Ltd. 1997).

Fong, "Criminalistics And The Prosec:utorn in P. Healy and J. Manak (eds.). The

Prosecutors Desk Book (1 971 ).

Fox et al, "The Criminalistics Mission" in C. Wecht (ed.), Legal Medicine Annual (1972)

Frabkena W.. Ethics (2nd ed., Englewood Cliffs. NJ: Prentice- Hall. Inc., 1973).

Freckelton & H. Selby, Experl Ev~dence ( L o ~ e leafed Law Book Company. Australia, 1993).

H. H. Wilder 8 Wentworth, Personal lde#ltification (R.G. Badger. Boston. 1918)

Helen Reece. Law And Science (Oxford University Press, 1998)

Ian R. Freckelton. The Trial of The Expert (1987).

Ian W. Evett 8 Bruce S Weir, Inter,?reting DNA Evidence: Statistical Genetics for

Forensic Scientists (Sinauer Associates. Inc , Sunderland. Massachusetts. 1998).

J. Thayer. A Prel~minary Treat~se on Ev~dence At Common Law (1989 ed.)

J . Weinstein 8 M. Berger, Weinstein's Evidence (1991)

J Wigmore, Evidence (1943)

Jack Weinstein 8 Margaret Berger Weinstein's Evidence (1995)

James D. Watson. The Double Helics: A Personal Account Of The Discovery Of The

Structure Of DNA (1968).

Jami J . St.Clair, Crime Laboratory Management (Academic Press. Elsevier Science Ltd..

2003).

Jeffrey, AJ, et al, "Principles and Recent Advances in Human DNA Fingerprinting" in

Burke. T , et a1 (ed.) DNA Fingerprintng; Applications and Approaches (Birkhauser

Verlag, Basel. Switzerland, 1991).

Jeremy Narby, The Cosmfc Serpent, DNA and the Origins of Knowledge (Victor

Gollancz. London, 1998).

John F . Kelly & Phillip K. Wearne. Tairrting Evidence: Inside the Scandals at the FBI

Crime Lab (The Free Press, Denver Post Online: Books and Authors).

Juran JM.. Juran's Quality Handbook (5" eJ.. J.M. Juran, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1999)

K. Popper. Conjectures And Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge (5m ed. 1989)

K K Sharma, Psychology and Abnorma' Human Beings (Sublime Publications. Jaipur,

India, 2000).

Karl R. Popper. Science: Conjectures And Refutations (1965)

Karl R. Popper, The erna arc at ion Of .Science And Metaphys~cs in Conjectures And

Refutations (1965).

Karl R . Popper, The Logic of Scfentific Dljcovery (1968)

Karl R. Popper, The Logic Of Scientific Discovery (Science editions. Inc.. New York, 1961)

Leroy Hood & Lee Rowen. Genes. "Genomes, and Soc~ety. Genetic Secrets: Protecting

Privacy and Confidentiality' In Mark A. Rothstein (ed.) Genetic Era (Yale University

Press 1997).

Lorne T . Kirby, DNA Fingerprinting. An Introduction (M. Stocklon press, 1990).

M Krawczak 8 J. Schmidtke, DNA Ffngerpinting (Bios Scientific Publishers, 1998)

Malcolm Brown & Paul Wilson Justice and Nightmares: Success and Failures of

Forensic Science (1 992)

McCorrnick. McCormick on Evidence (J3hn William Strong ed., 4Ih ed., 1992)

McCorrnick, Scientific Evidence (3" ed.:

McCormick, Handbook on The Law of Evidence (2"' ed. 1972).

Michael Freeman 8 Helen Reece. Scieno? in Court (Dartmouth Publishing Co.. Ltd. 1998)

Moenssens, Moses & Inbau, Spectrographic Voice Identification, Scientific Evidence In

Criminal Cases (The Foundation Press, Inc.. 1973).

NLacey, A Readeron Crifn~nal Jtrstice (Oxford: OUP, 1994)

Newton C.R., PCR Essential Data (John Wiley & Sons Ltd.. New York. 1995)

Newton C.R. & A. Graham, PCR- Introduction to Biotechnics Series (New York:

Springer. 1997).

John Woodroffe & Syed Am~r Ali, Law of Evidence (16'~ ed. The Law Book Company

(Pvt) Ltd. 1996)

Patterson, Law in a Scientific Age (196:#)

Paul Berg & Maxine Singer, Dealing with Genes- The Language of Heredity (University

Science Books. Mill Valley. California, Blackwell Scientific Publications. 1992).

Paul C. Giannelli & Edward J. Imwinkelried, Scientific Evidence (2"'ed1993).

Peter Alldridge. Sanneke Berkhout. Vzn Poelgest & Katherine Williams. "DNA Profiling

and the Use of Expert Scientific Witriesses in Criminal Proceedings", in Christopher

Harding, Phil Fennel, Nico Jorg & Bert Swart (eds.) Criminal Justice in Europe (Oxford:

Clarendon Press, 1995).

Peter Murphy, Evidence (5m ed. 1995).

Peter W. Huber. Galileo's Revenge: Junk Science In The Court Room (New York, 1991).

Phipson. Evidence ( loth ed. 1983)

Phipson. Evidence (1999 ed.).

Phipson. Evidence 556 (1 3Ih ed. 1982)

Phipson, Law of Evidence (9Ih ed)

Pollack 8 Robert, Signs of Life: The Language and Meanings of DNA (New York:

Viking, 1994).

Powell, Law of Evidence (3" ed).

R Old & S. Primrose, Principles of Gene Manipulation, An Introduction to Genetic

Engineering (1 985).

R.L.Gupta, Law Relating to ldent~ficatio.~ and Expert Opinion (Eastern Book Company

1990)

Rachels J The Elements of Moral Philosophy (2"ded. McGraw-Hill I nc , New York 1993).

Richard Leofric Jackson. Crfminal In~~estigation (5Ih ed. Universal Law Publishing

Company, 2000).

Robert G Weyant, "Protoscience, Pseucloscience, Metaphors and Animal Magnetism" in

Osier and Wean, (eds.) Hamden.

Robert H. Tamarin. Principles of Genetic.; ( 5 I h ed Wm.C. Brown Publishers, 1996)

Roger, Expert Testimony (zrn ed.)

Ronald Dworkin, Laws Empfre (London 1386)

Simon A. Cole. Suspect Identifies- A History of Fingerprinting and CrIrninal Identification

(Haward University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2001).

Starrs, "Mountebanks Among Forensic: Scientists" in R. Saferstein (ed.) Forensic

Science Handbook (1988).

Stephen Seabrooke 8 John Sprack. Ciirninal Evidence and Procedure-The Essential

Frame Work (zna ed. Black Stone Press Ltd. 1999).

Stephen. Digest of the Law of Evidence (.l2Ih ed.)

Steve Jones, The Language of the Gene:: (London, 1993)

T Hodgk~nson, Expert Ev~dence Law An,l Practtce (London, 1990)

T . Maniatts. E . Fritsch 8 J . Sambrook, Mc~lecular Cloning- A Laboratory Manual (1982)

Thayer. Preliminary Treatise on Evidence

Thayer, Prelimina~y Treat~se on The Lam of Evidence.

Thomas M. Cooley. The General Princi~~les of Constitutional Law In the United States of

America (41h ed.. Hindustan Law Book Company, Calcutta, 1994 reprint).

Thomas R. Mertens & Robert L. Hammersmith, Genetics -Laboratory Investigations ( 1 2 ~

ed, Prentice Hall. Upper Saddle River. New Jersey 2001).

Tom Strachan & Andrew P. Reed, Human Molecular Genetics (2nd ed. John Wiley &

Sons (Asia) 1999).

U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, and Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Forensic DNA Analysis: Issues (Governnient Printing Office. Washington D.C, 1990).

Wigmore J.H.. Wigmore On Evidence (Little Brown & Co. Boston, 1983).

Wigmore, A Treatise on the Anglo- Amer'can System of Evidence (3rd ed. 1940).

Wigrnore, Evidence (3'd ed. 1940).

Wigmore, Evidence (Chadbourn rev. 1978)

William Thompson & Simon Ford, "The Meaning of a Match: Sources of Ambiguity in the

Interpretation of DNA Prints", in Farley & Harrington (eds.) Forensic DNA Technology

(1990).

ARTICLES

A. Carracedo and Others, ''DNA Commission of The International Society for Forensic

Genetics: Guidelines for Mitochondrial CINA Typing" 110 Forensic Sci. int. 79 (2000).

A. Hutchison, J.E. Newbold. S.S. Fotter & M.H. Edgell. "Maternal Inheritance of

Mammalian Mitochondrial D N A 51 Nature 536 (1974).

A. Michelle Willis, "Nonpsychiatric Expert Assistance and the Requisite Showing of

Need: A Catch-22 in the Post-Ake Criminal Justice System", 37 Emory L.J. 995 (1988).

A.J. Jeffereys, Wilson & S.L. Thein, "Individual Fingerprints of Human D N A 316 Nature

76 (1985)

A.M. Colman & R.D. Mackay, "Legal Issues Surrounding the Admissibility of Expert

Psychological and Psychiatric Testimony" 20 Issues in Criminological and Legal

Psychology 46 (1993).

Adina Schwartz, "A Dogma of Errpiricism Revisited: Daubert v. Merrell Dow

Pharmaceuticals. Inc., And the Need to Resurrect the Philosophical Insight of Frye v.

United States" 10 Haw J 1.. 8 Tech. 149 (1997).

Adrian Linacre, "The UK National DNA Catabase" 361 The Lancet 1841(2003)

Alec J. Jeffrey's. F.Y Brookfield & Robert Serneonoff, "Positive Identification of an

Immigration Test Case Using Human DhlA Fingerprints" 317 Nature 818 (1985).

Alec J. Jeffreys. "Hype~ariable:Minisatellitt?' Regions in Human DNA 314 Nature 67 (1985).

Alec J. Jeffreys, Annette Mac Leod, Keii Tamaki; David L Neil & Darren G. Monckton,

"Minisatellite Repeat Coding as a Digital Approach to DNA Typing" 354 Nature 204 (1991).

Allan. T R S., "Legal Privilege and the Frinciple of Fairness in the Criminal Trial" [1987]

C r i m L R 449.

Allan W. Tamarelli, "Daubert v Merrel Dow Pharmaceuticals: Pushing the Limits of

Scientific Reliability-The Questionable Wlsdorn of Abandoning the Peer Review Standard

for Adm~tting Expert Testimony" Vand. L. Rev. 11 75 (1 994)

Alma Kelley McLeod, "Is Frye Dying or is Daubert Doomed? Determining the Standard

of Adm~ssibility of Scientific Evidence in Plabama Courts" Ala. L. Rev. 883 (2000).

"AMPFISTR SGM PlusE System for Use in Forensic DNA Technology" 112 Forensic Sci.

lnt. 151(2000).

Anderson S. Bankier AT, Barrell BG, de Bruijin MHL R Coulson AR, et al. "Sequence and

Organization of the Human Mitochondria1 Genome" 290 Nature 457 (1981).

Andre A Moenssens, "DNA Evldence and its Crltlcs - How Valld are the Challenges" 31

Jurfrnet J 87 (1990)

Andre A. Moenssens. "Novel Scientilic Evidence In Criminal Cases: Some Words of

Caution" 84 J. Crim. L. & Criminol. 1 (1993).

Andrew Lawler, "Massive DNA Identification Effort Gets Under Way" 294 Science278 (2001)

B. Quintans, V. A. Lvarez-Lglesias, 1,. Salas. C. Phillips, M.V.Lareu, & A. Carracedo,

"Typing of Mitochondria1 DNA Coding Region SNPs of Forensic and Anthropological

Interest Using SNaPshot Minisequenc~iig~ 140 Forensic SCI. lnt. 251 (2004).

Balding & Donnelly, "The Prosecutors F;3llacy And DNA Evidence" [1994] Crim. L. R. 71 1

Barbara Ann Hocking. Hamish McCallum. Alison Smith, R Chris Butler, "DNA, Human

Rights and The Criminal Justice Systern" Australian Journal of Human Rights 9 (1997).

Barbara E. Dodd. "DNA Flngerpnnting in Matters of Family and Crime" 318 Nature 506 (1985)

Barry C. Scheck. "DNA And Daubert", '5 Cardozo L. Rev. 1959 (1 994)

Bert Black, "A Unified Theory of Scientific Evidence" 56 Fordham L. Rev. 595 (1988)

Bob Woffinden, "Ear print Landed Innocent Man in Jail for Murder: 'Grotesque

Miscarriage of Justice' Resolved after Seven Years" Guardian Unlimited (2004) at

http://w.guardian.co.uk/

Bob Woffinden, "Justice isn't working" /Jew Statesman, December 2000 at,

w.newstatesman.co.~k.i

Borders, Jr , "Fit to be Fried: Frye v. United States and the Admissibility of Novel

Scientific Evidence", Ky. L J . 849 (1988.1989).

Bruce Budowle. John Waye et a\.. "Fixed Bin Analysis for Statistical Evaluation on

Continuous Distribution of Allele Data from VNTR Loci for use in Forensics" 48 Am. J.

Hum. Genet.841(1991)

Bruce Budowle, Marc W. Allard. 8 Mark R. Wilson, "Critique on Interpretation of High

Levels of Heteroplasmy in the Human tvlitochondrial DNA Hypervariable Region 1 from

Hair" 126 Forensic Sci. lnt.30 (2002).

Bruce Budowle, Marc W. Allard. Marc R. Wilson, 8 Ranajit Chakraborty. " Forensics and

Mitochondrial DNA: Applicatlons, De3ates. and Foundations'' in Annual Review.

Genomics Human Genetic:; (2003), p . 1 9

C.A. Hutchison, J.E. Newbold, S.S. Potter, M.H. Edgell, "Maternal Inheritance of

Mammalian Mitochondrial D N A 251 Nature 536 (1974).

Can0 R. J., HNPoinar, N.J.Pieniazek, A. Acra 8 G.O.Poinar, "Amplification and

Sequencing of DNA from a 120-135 million- Year Old Weevil" 363 Nature 536 (1993).

Carlna Dennis. "Error Reports Threaten to Unravel Databases of Mitochondial D N A 421

Nature 773 (2003).

Carol Midgely. "Injustice Casts a Lifelong Shadow" The Times. 7Ih ~ u n e 2001

Cavers, "Introduction, Science and the Law Symposium" 63 Mich. L. Rev1325 (1965).

Christopher Anderson. "DNA Flngerprintlng on Trlal" 342 Nature 844 (1989)

Christopher Anderson. News. "FBI Giver; in on Genetics" 355 Nature 663 (1992)

'Confronting the New Challenges of Scientific Evidence" 108 H a m L. Rev. 1481 (1995)

Peter Alldrldge "Recognizing Novel Sclsntlflc Techn~ques DNA as a Test Case" [I9921

Cr~m L R 687

Clare M. Tande. "DNA typing: .A New Inbestigator Tool" Duke L. J. 474 (1989)

Clifton T. Hutchinson & Danny S. Ashby, "Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc..:

Redefining the Bases for the Admissibility of Expert Scientific Testimony" 15 Cardozo L.

Rev. 1875 (1 994).

Code of Ethics for the American Academy of Forensic Science 31 (3) J. Forensic Sci.

798 (1986).

Comment, "The Evidentiary uses of Neutron Activation Analysis" 59 Cal. L. Rev. 997 (1971)

Craig Bowman, Note, "The Indlgent':; Right to an Adequate Defense: Expert and

lnvest~gat~onal Assistance in Criminal P~oceedings", 55 Cornell L. Rev 632 (1970).

Dennis W. Alexander, Comment. "Assistance in Addition to Counsel for lndigent

Defendants: The Need for, The Lack of; The Right To", 16 Vill L. Rev. 323 (1970).

Deryck Beyleveld. "Ethical Issues in the? Applications of DNA Analysis" 88 Forensic Sci.

Int.3 (1 997)

Devlin Risch & Roeder Statistical Ev;aluat~on of DNA Fingerprinting A Critique of The

NRC's Report" 259 Sc~ence 748 (1 993)

Don Harper Mills. "Comments from the Perspective of the AAFS Ethics Committee

Chairman", A Special Communication 4:!(6) J. Forensic Sc;. 1207 (1997).

Donna H. Lee, "In the Wake of Ake v. Clklahoma: An lndigent Criminal Defendant's Lack

of Ex Parte Access to Expert Services", 57 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 154 (1992).

E.A. Cotton, R.F. Allsop. J L. Guest. R.3.E. Frazier, P. Koumi, I.P. Callow, A. Seager &

RLParkes. "Validation of the AMPFISTR SGM Plus E system For use in Forensic

Casework" 112 Forens~c S8~i . lnt 151 (2000).

Edward j. lmwinkelried, "The Next Step After Daubert: Developing a Similarly

Epistemological Approach to Ensuring the Relfiability of Nonscientific Expert Testimony"

15 Cardozo L. Rev. 2271 ('1994).

Edward J. Imwinkelried, "Ray Rushton Ilistinguished Lecturer Series: The Taxonomy of

Testimony Post-Kumho: Refocusing on The Bottomlines of Reliability and Necessity" 30

Cumb. L. Rev. 185 (2000)

Eilis S. Magner, "Exclusior~ of Polygraph Evidence: Can it be Justified?" 30 Crim. L. Q.

412 (1988).

Ephraim Margolin & Allen Wagner. "?-he lndigent Criminal Defendant and Defense

Services: A Search for Constitutional Standards". 24 Hastfngs L.J. 647 (1973).

Eric S Lander. "DNA Fingerprinting on Trial" 339 Nature 501 (1989).

E.S. Gardner. "Need for New Concepts in the Administration of Criminal Justice' 50 J.

Cr~m. L. Cr~rninol & Pol. S o 25

Faigman, Porter & Saks 'Check your Crystal Ball at the Court House Door Please

Exploring the Past, Understand~ng the Present and Worry~ng About the Future of

Scient~fic Evidence" 15 Cardozo L Rev 1799 (1994)

Flndlay. A Taylor, P Qu~rke, R Frazlc5r, A Urquhart, "DNA Flngerpr~ntlng from Slngle

Cells" 389 Nature 555 (1907)

Freckelton. "Expert Ev~dencs and the Role of the Jury" 12 Austl. B. Rev73 (1994)

G. Passarino. G.L. Cavalleri, A.A. Lin, L.L. Cavalli-Sforza. A.L. Borresen-Dale & P.A.

Underhill, "Different Genetic Componelltsin the Norwegian Population Revealed by the

Analysis of mtDNA and Y Cnromosome Polymorphisms" 10 European Journal of Human

Genetics 52 1 (2002).

G. Penacook. A. Sala & D. Corach "Are DNA Tests Infallible" 1239 International

Congress Series 873 (2003).

G. Tully 8 M. Lareu, "Controversies over Heteroplasmy" (Letter to the Editor) 22

Electrophoresis 180 (2001 ).

G. Tully. W. Bar. B. Brinkmann, A Carracedo. P. Gill, N. Morling. W. Parson & P.

Schneider. "Consideration by the European DNA Profiling (EDNAP) Group on the

working Practices, Nomenclature and Interpretation of Mitochondrial DNA Profiles" 124

Forensic Sci. lnt. 83 (2001 )

Gary Edmond & David Mercer. "Keeping 'Junk' History, Philosophy and Sociology of

Science Out of the Courtroom: Probleris with the Reception of Daubert v. Merrell Dow

Pharmaceuticals Inc" 20 11. N S. W L. J. 83 (1997).

Gary Edmond, "Deflating Daubert: Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael and the Inevitability of

General Acceptance (Frye)" 23 U. N. S. W L. J.38 (2000).

Gill. Jeffreys 8 Werrett. "Forensic Applicaton of DNA Fingerprints" 318 Nature 577 (1985).

Gordon B. Burns, "The Right to the Eflective Assistance of a Psychiatrist Under Ake v.

Oklahoma", 30 Crim. L. Bull. 429 (1994).

Grzybowski T, "Extremely High Levels of Human Mitochondrial DNA Heteroplasmy in

Single Hair roots" 21 Electrophoresis 548 (2000)

H.A. Hammelmann. "Expert - Evidence? 10 Mod. L. Rev. 32

Harold L. Korn, "Law Fact and Sc~ence n the Courts" 66 Colum. L. Rev. 1080 (1966).

Harry Edmond 8 David Mercer. "Trashing "Junk Science" Stanford Tech. L. Rev3 (1998)

Helen Pearson, ''Beyond the Double Helix'' 421 Nature 310 (2003),

Henry A. Erlich, David Gelfand & Joh i J. Sninsky. "Recent Advances in the Polymerase

Chain Reaction" 252 Science 1643 (1091 j.

Higuchi. Von Beroldingen, Sensabaugh & Erlich, "DNA typing from Single Hairs" 332

Nature 543 (1988).

Hodge E., "Guarding against Error" 20 A.F.T.E. J. 290 (1988)

Holmes, "The Path of the law" 10 Han: L. Rev. 465.

I. Findlay & et al., "DNA Fingerprinting from Single Cells" 389 Nature 555 (1997)

Ian W. Evett, Lindsey A. Foreman. Graham Jackson & James A. Lambert, "DNA

profiling: A Discussion of Issues F:elating to the Reporting of Very Small Match

Probabil~ties" [2000] Criml. L.R. 341

Imw~nkelried. "The Constitutionality of Introducing Evaluat~ve Laboratory Reports Against

Criminal Defendants" 30 Hast~ngs L J. 621 (1979).

J. Hollis. "Hearsay as the Bas~s of Op~nion Evidence" Crim. L. Q. 288 (1967-68).

J Thayer, "Law and Logic" 14 Haw. L. Rev. 139 (1900)

J.D.Watson & F.H.C. Crick. "Genetical Implications of the Structure of Deoxyribonucleic

Acid" 171 Nature 964 (1953).

J.L. Montrose. "Basic Concepts of the _aw of Evidence" 70 L. Q. R. 540 (Oct. 1954)

J.P. Henderson, 'The Use of DNA Statistics In Crimtnal Trial". 128 Forensic Sci. lnt 183 (2002)

James A Martin, "The proposed Scienc:e Court" 73 Mich. L. Rev. 1058 (April-May 1977).

James E. Starrs. "The Forensic Scientist and the open mind" 31(2) Journal of Forens~c

Sc~ence Society 11 1 (1991 j.

James Morton, "Opinion", J. Crf L. 68 (2004) (Online Publication of Lexis. Vathek

Publishing, 2004).

Jay A. Zollinger. "Defence Access to ijtate-funded DNA Experts: Considerations of Due

Process" 85 Cal L. Rev 1803 (1997).

Jean L. Marx. "Multiplying Genes by Leaps and Bounds" 240 Science 1408 (1988)

Jennifer L. Mnookin. Fingerprint Evid~?nce in an Age of DNA Profiling, 67 Brooklyn L.

Rev. 13 (2001).

Jeremy Cherfas, "Genes Unlimited" N?w Scientist 29 (1990)

Jim Wasserman, Experts Defend Peterson Case DNA Test, p. 3,

~http://www.fresnobee.comllocal/crime/story/768544Op-858948lchtml (last

updated Sep. 28, 2004).

John D. Borders, "Fit to be Fryed: Frye v. United States and the Admissibility of Novel

Scientific Evidence" 77 Ky. L. J. 849 (1 989).

John F. Decker. "Expert Services in the Defense of Criminal Cases: The Constitutional

and Statutory Rights of Indigent?.". 51 11. Cin. L. Rev. 574 (1982).

John F Y Brookfield, "Gene Justice" 3133 Nature 122 (1993).

John J. Wash, "The Population Genetics of Forensic DNA Typing: Could it Have been

Someone Else?" 34 Crim L. 0. 469 (1 392).

John M. West, "Expert Services and tlie Indigent Criminal Defendant: The Constitutional

Mandate of Ake v. Oklahoma", 84 Mict. L. Rev. 1326 (1986).

Jonakait. "WIII Blood Tell? Genetic Markers in Criminal Cases" 31 Emory L J. 833 (1982)

Jonathan J. Koehler. "DNA Matches and Statistics: Important Questions. Surprising

Answers" Judicature 222 (1 993).

Jonathan J. Koehler. "Error and Exaggeration in the Presentation of DNA Evidence at

Trial" Jurfmet. J. 21 (2003).

Joseph L. Peterson, "Ethical Issues in the Collection. Examination, and the Use of

Physical Evidence" Journal of Forensic Science Society 35 (1986).

Joseph L. Peterson, Penelope N. Narkham, "Crime Laboratory Proficiency Testing

Results, 1978-1991. 1: dentification and Classification of Physical Evidence" 40 J.

Forensic Sci. 994 (1995)

Juan J. Sanchez, Claus B~irsting. Charlotte Hallenberg, Anders Buchard. Alexis

Hernandez 8 Niels Morling, "Multiplex PCR and Minisequencing of SNPs -A Model with

35 Y Chromosome SNPs" 137 Forensic: Sci. lnt 74 (2003).

KC. Sunny. "Amendments Suggested By The Indian Constitution Review Commission:

A Critical Appra~sal" 26 Ac. L. R. 61 (2032)

Kary B. Mullis, "The Unusual Origin of the Polymerase Chain Reaction" Scientific

Amerrcan 36 (1990).

Kaushal 6. Majrnudar. "Daubert v. Mf?rrell Dow: A Flexible Approach to the Admissibility

of Novel Scientific Evidence" 7 Haw. ,'. L. & Tech. 187 (1993).

Keith A. Findley, "New Laws Reflect The Power and Potential of DNA Wisconsin Lawyer

20 (2002)

Kelly. Rankin 8 Wink, "Method and Application of DNA Fingerprintlng: A Guide for the

Non-scientist (1987) Cfirn. L. R.105.

Kenneth J Chesebro, ""Jalileo's Report: Peter Hubers Junk Scholarship" Am. U. L.

Rev1637 (1993).

Kenneth S. Roberts. "Curing the Ake of an Incompetent Expert: A Separate Reviewable

Issue?", 29 San Dlego L. Rev 799 (19!32).

L. Hamlard 8 A. Ashworth, "Some Prc~blems of Evidence Obtained by Hypnosis" [1980]

Grim L. R. 469.

L a j Singh, "DNA Profiling and its Applii:atlonsn 60 Current Science 580 (1991)

Lee Novinger, "Science and Legal Rules of Evidence: A Review of Galileo's Revenge:

Junk Science in Coult Room" 32 Jurimt?t. J. 487 (1992).

Lloyd L. Rosenthal. "The Development of the use of Expert Testimony" (1935) 2 L. &

Contemp. Probs. 401 (1 935)

Lucas, Leete 8 Field, "An American Proficiency Testing Program" 27 Forensic Sci.

lnt.71 (1985).

M Jobl~ng A Pandya, C Tyler, The L chromosome in Forenslc Analys~s and Paternity'

testlng" 110 International Journal of Legal Med~ccne 118 (1997)

M. Kinga Balogh, Joachirn Burger. Klaus Bender, Peter M. Schneider, Kurt W. Alt, "STR

Genotyping and MtDNA Sequencing oi Latent Fingerprint on Paper" 137 Forensic Sci.

lnt. 185 (2003).

M. Seielstad, "A Symmetries in the Mat~?rnal and Paternalgenetic Histories of Colombian

Populations" 67 Am. J. Hum. Genet. 10Ei2 (2000).

M. Stone. "Instant Lie Derection? Demeanour and Credibility in Criminal Trials" 119911

Crlm. L. R. 821

M A Jobling. "Y-Chromosomal SNP iaplotype Dlvers~ty In Forenslc Analysis" 118

Forens~c S o fnt 158 (200 I )

Mason Ladd, "ExpertTestimony", Van11 L. R. 414 (1952)

M.J. Fereday & I Koop, "European Nc!twork of Forensic Science Institutes (ENFSI) and

its Quality and Competence Assurance Efforts" 43 Science and Justice 99 (2003).

M.J. Sacks. D.M. Risinger, R. Rosenthal 8 W.C. Thompson. "Context Effects in Forensic

Science: A Review and Application of the Science of Science to Crime Laboratory

Practice in the United States" 43 Science & Just~ce 77 (20031.

M.K. Balogh, J. Burger. P M. Schneidel- & K.W. Alt, "Fingerprints from Fingerprints" 1239

International Congress Series 953 (2003).

Major Russell L. Miller, "Wrestling with Mre 304(g): The Struggle to Apply the

Corroboration Rule" 178 Mil. L. Rev. 1 (:!003),

Marcello Mega 8 Rajeev Syal. Errors 3ut wrong men in jail, says fingerprint specialist

(2001) Electronic Telegraph, 26 August, at http://w.telegraph.co.uk/

Marie Lussier, "Tailoring the Rules of Admissibility: Genes and Canadian Criminal Law"

71 Can. B. Rev. 319 (19921.

Mason Ladd, "Expert Testirnony", Vand. L. Rev. 414 (1952)

Matthews, "Improving The Odds on Justi,:ep New Scientist 12 (1994)

Mc L Emmerson, "The Understanding of Technical Evidence" 68 Austl. L. J. 875

Melissa J. Moore, "When the Junk isn't junk" 379 Nature 402 (1996).

Merilee M. Kapsa & Carl 3. Meyer, "S-ientific Experts Making their Testimony More

Reliable" Cal W. L. Rev. 313 (1999).

Michael C. Mason, "The Scientific Ev~dence Problem: A Philosophical Approach". 33

Ariz. St. L. J. 857 (2001).

Michael H. Graham, "Lay W~tness Opinion Testimony; Opinion on Ultimate Issues by Lay

or Expert Witness", 22 Cr~m. L. Bull. 144 (1986).

Michael J. Saks. "Banishing lpse Dixii: The Impact of Kumho Tyre on Forensic

ldentification Science" Wash &Lee L. Rev 879 (2000)

Michael 0. Finkelstein & William B. Fa :ley, "A Bayesian Approach To Identification

Evidence" 3 Harv. L. Rev. 489 (1970).

Mlke Redmayne, "Doubts and Burcen DNA Ev~dence, Probab~llty and the Courts",

[I9951 Crtm L R 464

Mike Redmayne, "Science, Ev~dence and Logic" 59 Mod. L. Rev. 747 (1996).

Mike Redmayne, "The DNA Database: Civil Liberty and Evidentiary Issues" [I9981 Crim.

L. R. 437

Morgan. "Judicial Notice" 57 Haw. L. F:ev. 269 (1944).

Murder Conviction IS Quashed (2002) ~36C News, 15Ih ~ u ~ u s t

N.J. Vidrnar & R.A. Schuller, "Juries and Expert Evidence: Social Frame Work

Testimony" 52 L. &Contemp. frobs. 133 (1989).

Neil J. Rlsch & B. Delvin, "On the Protability of Matching DNA Fingerprints" 255 Science

717 (1992).

News and Comment, "Forensic DNA Gm!s To Court With O.J." 265 Science 1362 (1994).

Note. "Construed in Proof of the Corpu; Delecti Aliunde the Defendant's Confession'' 103

U. Pa. L. Rev. 638 (1955)

Note. "Expert Legal Testimony" 97 Han,. L. Rev. 797 (1984).

Note, "Improving Judicial Gate keeping Technical Advisors and Scientific Evidence" 110

Haw. L. Rev. 941 (1997).

Oliver C. Schroeder, JR, 'Ethical and Moral Dimensions in Forensic Science" Journal of

Forensrc Science Society 27 (1986).

"Opinion on Ultimate Issues byLay or Expert Witness" 22 Criminal Law Bulletin 144 (1986).

Orgel, Leslie E. & Francis H C Crick. "Selfish DNA: The Ultimate Parasite" 284 Nature

604 (1980).

P. Awadalla, A Eyre- Walker 8. J. Maynard Smith, "Linkage Disequilibrium and

Recombination in Hominid Mitochondria DNA" 286 Science 2524 (1999).

P. Alldridge. "Recognising Novel Scientfic Techniques" 119921 Crim. L. R. 687.

P, Gill. "An Assessment of the Utility of Single Nucleotide Polyrnorphisrns (SNPs) for

Forensic Purposes" 114 lnlernational Jo~rnal of Legal Medicine 204 (2001).

Paabo S. "Anc~ent DNA 269 Soenttfic 4merlcan 87 (1 993)

Paul C. Giannelli, "Ake v Oklahoma: The Right to Expert Assistance in a Post-Daubert.

Post-DNA World" 89 Come11 L Rev. 305 (2004).

Paul C. Giannelli, "Junk Science: The Oriminal Cases" J. Crim. L. & Criminol. 105 (1993).

Paul C. Giannelli. "The Twenty-First Annual Kenneth J. Hodson Lecture-Scientific

Evidence in Criminal Prosecutions" Mj'it. L. Rev.167 (1992).

Paul E. Tracy & Vincent Morgan, "Big Brother and his Science Kit: DNA Databases For

21'' Century Crime Control" 90 J. Crin'. L. & Criminol. 635 (2000).

Paul S Milich, "Controversial Science in the Court Room: Daubert and the Laws Hubris"

Emory L. J. 91 3 (1 994).

Paul. C Giannelli, "The Admissibility 3f Novel Scientific Evidence: Frye v. United States.

a Half-Century Later" 80 Colum. L. REV. 11 97 (1980).

Peter Alldridge. "Recognizing Novel Scientific Techniques: DNA as a Test Case" [I9921

Crim L. R. 687.

Peter D Martin. Hermann Schmitt'?r, Peter M. Schneider, "A Brief History of the

Formation of DNA Databases in Fontnsic Science within Europe" 119 Forensic Sci. lnt.

225 (2001).

Peter Gill, Alec J. Jeffreys & David J. Werrett, "Forensic Application of DNA Fingerprints"

318 Nature 577 (1985).

Peter Gillies. "Opinion Evidence" 60 jiustl. L. J.597 (1986).

Peter Huber, "Medical Experts and the C~host of Galileo" 54 L. & Contemp. Probs. 121 (1991).

Peter J. Neufeld 8 Neville Collman. "When Science Takes The Witness Stand 262

Scientific American18 (1 990).

Peter McGuffin. Brier1 Riley, Robert Plomin. "Genomics and Behavior: Toward

Behavioral Genomics" 291 Science 1232.

Peterson & Murdock. "Forensic Sciences Ethics Developing an Integrated System of

Support and Enforcement 34 J. Fort?nsic Sci. 749 (1989).

Peterson, Ryan. Houlden & Mahajlo\'ic. "The Uses and Effects of Forensic Science in the

Adjudication of Felony Cases" 32 J. r'orensic Sc;. 1730 (1987).

Quirin Schiermeier & Munlch, "Y Chromosome Analysis Urged for Sex Crimes" 413

Nature 6 (2001)

R. Bramley, "Quality in the Laboratory" 43 Science and Justrce 104 (2003)

R. Sachidanandam, et al. "A Map of Human Genome Sequence Variation Containing

1.42 million Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms" 409 Nature 928 (2001).

R. Sparkes, C. Kimpton, S. Gilbard, F'. Carne. J. Andersen, N. Oldroyd, D. Thomas. A.

Urquhart, P. Gill. "The Validation of , 3 7 locus Multiplex STR test for use in Forensic

Casework. II. Artefacts, Casework Studies and Success Rates" 109 inf J. Legal Med.

195 (1996).

R C Lewontin 8 Daniel L. Hartl. "Pc~pulation Genetics in Forensic DNA Typing" 254

Science1745 (1991).

R.D. Mackay & A D . Colman, "Ecuivocal Rulings on Expert Psychological and

Psychiatric Evidence: Turning a muddlt? in to nonsense" [I9961 Crim. L. R. 88.

R.D. Mackay 8 Andrew M. Colman. "Excluding Expert Evidence: A Tale or Ordinary Folk

and Common Experience' (19911 Crim L. R. 800.

R.J. Allen & J.S. Miller, "The Common -aw Theory of Experts. Deference or Education? "

87 N w U. L. Rev. 1131 (1993).

R KRaghavan. "Ev~dence in The Genes The Problems and Prospects of DNA

Fingerpr~nt~ng", Fronti~ne Vol 20 No 26. December 20 (2003) -January 2 (2004)

Ralph K~rby, Correspondence "The Many Dangers of Rely~ng on a DNA Database" 419

Nature 247 (2002)

Ranajit Chakraborty & Kenneth K. Kid.i. "The Utility of DNA Typing in Forensic Work.

254 Science 1735 (1991)

Randolph N. Jonakait, "Forensic Science; The Need for Regulation" 4 Harv J. L. &

Tech.109 (1991).

Recent Case. "Evidence-Admissibility of Scientific Evidence- Fifth Circuit Limits

Permissible Scientific Evicence to Gent!rally Accepted Theories (Christophersen v. Allied

Slgnal Corp . 5Ih Cir. 1991:'" 105 Harv. L Rev. 791.

Reid Hastie 8 Nancy Pennington, "The O.J. Simpson Stories: Behavioral Scientists

Reflections on the People of the Stats of California v. Orenthal James Simpson" U. of

Colo L. Rev. 957 (1996).

Reinhard Szibor, Matthis Michael, lnes Plate, Dieter Krause. "Efficiency of Forensic

Mitochondria1 DNA Analysis Case Examples Demonstrating the Identification of Traces"

1 13 Forensic Sci In:. 71 (2000).

Ricardo G Federico, "The Genetic Wilness: DNA Evidence and Canadas Criminal Law"

(1990) Crim. L. Q.

Rlchard A. Nakashima. "DNA Evidence in Crimlnal Trials: A Defence Attorney Primer"

Neb. L. Rev. 444 (1995).

Richard C. Lewontin & Daniel L. Hart, "Population Genetics in Forensic DNA Typing"

254 Science 1745 (1991).

Richard Lempert. "DNA, Science And 1-he Law: Two Cheers for the Ceiling Principle" 34

Jurimet. J. 41 (1993).

Richard Lempert. "Some Caveats Concerning DNA as Criminal ldentification Evidence:

With Thanks to the Reverend Bayes" 1: Cardozo L. Rev. 303 (1991).

Ristina L. Needham, "Questioning Thc? Admissibility of Non-scientific Testimony After

Daubert: The Need for Increased Judicial Gatekeeping to Ensure the Reliability of all

Expert Testimony" Fordham Urban L. J. 541 (1998).

Robert J. Brown, Diane Rowold. Mohammed Tahir, Charles Barna, George Duncan.

Rene JHerrera, "Distribution of the HLA-DQAI and Polymarker Alleles in the Basque

Population of Spain" 108 Forensic Sci. Int. 145 (2000).

Roberta Rosenthal K. Wall, "The Use cf Expert Services by Privately Retained Criminal

Defense Attorneys", 13 Loyola. U. Chi. L.J. 1 (1981)

Robert Weinstock, "Ethical Practice in the Farensic Sciences" 42 J. Forensic Sci. 1189 (1997)

Robert Williamson & Rony Duncan. Commentary, "DNA Testing for All" 418 Nature 585 (2002).

Roderick Munday. "Expert Evidence. Law and Practice" 51 Cam. L. J. 180 (1992).

Roeder K "DNA fingerpnntinq: A Review of the Controversy" 9 Statistical Science 222 (1994).

Roger Lewtn, "DNA Typlng on the Witness Stand" 244 Sclence 1033 (1989)

Roland A H Van Oorschot 8 Maxwell K. Jones, "DNA Finger Prints From Fingerprints"

387 Nature 767 (1997)

Rosemary Pattenden, "Expert Opinion E~idence Based on Hearsay" 119821 Cnm. L. R. 85,

S. J. Young, "DNA Evidence" [1991] C,-im. L. R. 264.

S. Odgers 8 J. Richardson. "Keeping Bad Science out of the Court Room: Changes in

American and Australian Expert Evidence Law" 18 U. N. S. W.L. J. 117 (1995).

Samuel C. Seiden 8 Karine Morin. ''Th,? Physician as a Gatekeeper to the use of Genetic

Information in the Criminal Justice System" Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 88 (2002).

Scott Brewer, "Scientific Expert Testimon:~ and Intellectual Due Process" 107 Yale L. J. 1596.

Sophla I. Gatowski et al, ''The Diffusior of Scientific Evidence: A comparative analysis of

Admissibility Standards in Australia, Canada and England and the United States and

Their impact on Social and Behavioural Sciences" 4 Exp. Evi. 86 (1996).

Stephen J. Odgers 8 James T. Richal'dson. "Keeping Bad science out of court Rwm-

Changes in American and Australian Expert Evidence Law" 18 U. N. S. W L. J. 108 (1995).

Sullivan KM. Hopgood R. Gill P, "Identification of Human Remains by Amplification and

Automated Sequencing of Mitochondria1 D N A 105 int. J. Legal Med. 83 (1992).

Technical Comments, "Forensic DNA Tests and Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium" 252

Science, 1038 (1991).

Teresa Herdman, "Criminal Law: Mi~rshaling the Defense - Indigent defendants

Guaranteed Psychiatric Assistance at Trial to Explain Battered Woman Syndrome", 32

Washburn L.J. 249 (1993).

Thompson 8 Ford, "DNA Typing: A,:ceptance and We~ght of the New Genetic

Identification Tests" 75 Va L. Rev. 45 (1089).

Thompson WC 8 Schumann EL, 'In erpretatlon of Statlst~cal Evldence cn Crlm~nal

Tr~als Prosecutors Fallacy and Defeiise Attorneys Fallacy" 11 Law and Human

Behavfour 167 (1987)

Walls. "Ten Years of Forensic Science 11164-73" 11 9741 Crfm L. R. 505

William Brown, "DNA Fingerprinting Back in The Dock" New Scientist 14 (1993)

William C. Thompson, "Are Juries Competent to Evaluate Statistical Evidence" 52 L. &

Confemp. Probs. 9 (1989)

William C. Thompson, "A Sociological Perspective on the Science of Forensic DNA

Testing" 30 (4) U. C. Davis L. Rev. 11 121 (1997).

William C. Thompson. "Evaluating the Admissibility of New Genetic Identification Tests:

Lessons from the DNA War" 84 J. Crim. L. 8 Criminal. 22 (1993).

Willlam Thompson & Simon Ford, "Is 3NA F~ngerpr~nting Ready for the Courts?" New

Scientist 38 (1990).

William C. Thompson & Michele Netnercott, "Feature: Forensics: The Challenge of

Forensic Evidence" 28 Champion 50 (21104).

William E. O'Brian, "Court Scrutiny of E:xpert Evidence: Recent Decisions Highlight The

Tensions" International Journal of Evideiice and Proof. 7(172) (2003), www.lexis.com

Wilson MR, DiZinno JA, Polanskey D, Replogle J & Budowle B, "Validation of

Mitochondria1 DNA Sequerlcing for Forensic Case work Analysis" 108 int. J. Legal Med.

68 (1995).

Yoshihisa Watanabe, et at. "DNA Typing f r m Cigarette Butts" 5 Legal Medicine 177 (2003)

ACTS, REPORTS AND MISCELLANEOUS

Acts

Criminal Justice Act. 1988 (England).

Civil Evidence Act. 1972 (England).

Civil Evidence Act, 1995. (England).

Criminal Evidence, Act, 1598 (England I.

Criminal Procedure, Act, 1965 (Englan(i).

Evidence Act, 1995. (Australia).

Federal Rules of Evidence ( U S )

Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

Mental Health Act. 1959 (England).

Obscene Publications Act, 1959. (England).

Post Office Act. 1953. (Elgland).

Road Traffic Regulations Act 1984 (England).

Road Traffic Regulations Act, 1984 (England).

DICTIONARIES, ENCYCLOPEDIAS AND REPORTS

Merriam-Webster, Websters Ninth A'ew Collegiate Dictionary (Merriam-Webster lnc..

Publishers, 1988).

Glenn D. Considine, Van Nostrands, Scientific Encyclopedia (9'"d. Wiley- Inter-science.

A John Willey 8 Sons. Inc., 2002), vol- I

The New Encyclopedia Britannica (Encyclopedia Britannica Inc., 1997). Vol-19

Sagan 8 Carl, Encyclopedia Britannica (15'"d. 1993), vol-22

McGraw- Hill. Encyclopeaia of Science and Technology (8'"d.).

The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice, The Role of Forensic Science in Criminal

Proceedings (1 993)

Royal Commission of Inquiry on Char~berline Convictions. Commonwealth Parliament

Paper No. 192 (1987).

Australian Law Reform Commission, Interim Report No.26 (1985)

US. Department of Justice. Office of Jistice Programs, and Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Forensic DNA Analysis: Issues (Governnent Printing Office, Washington D.C., 1990).

Cellmark Diagnostics, Forensic Casework: Collecting and Preserving the Best Samples,

(Germantown. MD; U. S. A.. 1988), vol-1.

T. Maniatis. E. Fritsch 8 J. Sambrook, Molecular Cloning, A Laboratory Manual(1982)

Sullivan, K.M, et al. "The Use of Flucrescence Labeling Technology in the Forensic

Analysis of PCR products" 18 Criminal L3b Digest 164 (1991)

Wilson, et al. "Guidelines For the Use of Mitochondria1 DNA Sequencing in Forensic" 20

(4) Crime Laboratory Digest (1993).

R. Thomson, J.K. Pritchard, P. Shen, P.J. Oefner, M.W.Feldman. "Recent Common

Ancestry of Human Y Chromosome:;: Evidence From DNA Sequence Data" 97

Proceedings of the National Academy of Science U.S.A. 7360 (2000).

Perkin-Elmer Corporation. Users Manual for the AmpFl STR SGM Plus PCR

Amplification Kit (Applied B~osystems. U.S.A.. 1999).

California Association of Crime Laboratov Directors, DNA Committee Report No.6 (Oct. 1, 1988).

National Research Council Committee:, DNA technology In Forensic Science (National

Academy Press. Washington DC. 1992).

The Committee of The National Ressarch Counc~l, The Evaluation of Forensic DNA

Evidence (National Academy Press, Washington DC 1996).

P.M. Schncider, "DNA Databases for Offender Identification in Europe - the need for

Technical, Legal and Political Harmonization", in Proceedings of the rd European

Symposium on Human Identification (P.omega Corporation, Madison. WI. USA, 1998).

Legal Information Access Centre ILIAC) - Hot Topics, http://www.austlii.edu.au

Idatabaseshtml

Report of National Comrniss~on to Review the Working of the Constitution (New Delhi,

Government of lndia, 2002).

"From Maps to Medicine: About the Huinan Genome Research Project." National Human

Genome Research Institute, Australia at http://www.nhgri.nih.gov: 801Policy-and-

public~affairslCommunications/Publications/Maps~to~medicine/about.htmI

"IXth All lndia Forensic Science Confetence", Shimla (1995) Bureau of Police Research

and Development, Mfnfstry of Home Afhrs, Government of India, New Delhi.

Law Commission of lndia, One Hundred and Eighty-fifth Report on Review of the Indian

Evidence Act, 1872 (Government of lndia. 2003).

John F. Kelly & Phillip K Wearne, Tiinting Evfdence: Inside the Scandals at the FBI

Crfme Lab (The Free Press, Denve!r Post Online: Books & Authors). 7/25/2003

http://63.147.65.175/books/chapl73.htni

www theiai.org and www criminalistics.comlABC/

TABLEOFCASES

A.R. Antulay v. R. S. Nayak, AIR 1988 S.C. 1531. 351

Ake v. Oklahoma, 105 S.Ct. 108 352

Allied-Signal Corporations case, 939 F.2d 1106 (C.A.5 (Tex.) 1991) ......................... 140

.......................... Aloe Coal Co. v. Clark Equipment Co., 816 F.2d 110 (3rd Cir. 1987). 35

Alvarado v. Stander, 2004 Wash. App. LEXlS 2651 73

Anderson v. Boeing Co., 222 F.R.D. !521 (loth cir. 2004) 163

Andrews v. State, 533 So.2d 841(FlaDist.Ct. App. 1988) ............................ 289,302,303

Attorney General's Reference (No 3 of 1999), [2001] 1 All ER 577 ........................... 396

Azizbano v. Mohammad lbrahim Husain, AIR 1925 All. 720. ...................................... 70

B.R.B. v. J.B., [I9681 2 All ER 1023 (OA) .................................................................... 387

Bal Krishna Das v. Radha Devi, AIR 'I989 All. 133 0.180

....................................................................... Barefoot v. Estelle, 463 U.S. 880 (1983) 97

Barindranath Kumar v. Emperor, 1.L.F:. (1 910) 37 Cai. 467. ....................................... 396

...................................................................... Basudeo Gir v. State, AIR 1959 Pat. !j34 37

Breithaupt v. Abram. 352 U.S. 432 (1 357)

Briginshaw v. Briginshaw. (1938) 60 C.L.R. 33

Bugg v. Day, (1949) 79 C.L.R. 44

Caldwell v. Mississippi, 472 U.S. 320 (1985

Caldwell v. State, 260 Ga. 278 (199

California v. Greenwood, 486 U.S. 35 (1988)

Chamberlain v. R., (1984) 153 C.L.R. 521

Clark v. Ryan, (1960) 103 C.L.R. 486

Cobey v. State, 559 A.2d 391 (Md. App., 1989

Commonwealth v. Blasioli, 552 Pa.149 (1998

Conn. v. Porter, 698 A.2d 739, 757 (C:onn. 1997). 313

Connecticut v. Pappas, 776 A.2d 1031 (Conn. 2001) 312

Coppolino v. State, 223 So.2d 68 (Fla. App. 1968) .............................................. 132,286

Coral lndira Gounsalves v. Joseph Frabhakar Iswaraiah, AIR 1953 Mad. 858 .......... 182

D.P.P. v. A and B.C. Chewing gum, 1-td, [1967] 2 All ER 504. ................................ 66,75

Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceutisals Inc.. (1993) 125 L.Ed. 2d 469. ........................

89,143161,195,286,287,306,310,314,419

Davis v. Mississippi, 394 U.S. 721 (1 969 367

Dean-Willcocks and Another v. Comnon Wealth Bank of Australia,

[ZOO31 N.S.W.S.C. 466

Diwan Chand v. Tirath Ram, AIR 1972 Del. 41

................................. Dowthitt v. Johnson. US Court of Appeals (fifth Circuit) (2000). 329

Emperor v. Kauro Mizari, AIR 1938 Sind 22 39

........... English Exporters (London) Ltd. v. Elilonwall Ltd., [I9731 1 All ER 726 52, 53, 63

Ex parte Grayson, 479 So.2d 76 (Ala

Exparte Perry. 586 So. 2d 242 (Ala., 1991

Fakhuruddin v. State of M.P., AIR 1987 S.C. 132

Folkes v. Chadd, (1782) 3 Doug K.B. 15 2

Fryev. Unitedstates, 293F.1013 (D.C. Cir. 1923) ....... 101,118,121,130,155,286,290,310

General Electric Co. v. Joiner, 118 S.Ot. 512 (1 997). .......................................... 154,159

Glover v. State, 787 S.W.2d 544 (Tex. Ct. App. 1990) 295

S. Gopal Reddy v. State of A.P., AIR 1996 S.C. 2148 ................................................ 184

................................. Gotham Construction Co. v. Amulya Krishna, AIR 1968 Cal. 91. 46

Goutam Kundu v. West Bengal, AIR 1993 S.C. 2295 ................................................. 385

....................... Government of Virgin Islands v. Knight, 989 F.2d 619 (3rd Cir. 1993). 8, 9

..................... Grismore v. Consolidated products Go., 5.N.W.2d 646 (Iowa 1942). 20, 72

Guerre-Chaley v. State, 88 P.3d 539 (9Ih cir. 2004) 129,163

.......... 'H' and Another v. Schering Chemical:; Ltd. and Another. [I9831 lA l l ER 849. 57

Hanumant v. State of M.P, AIR 1952 S.C. 34 38

Harvey v. State, 2004 Alas. App. LEXIS 4. ................................................................ 330

Harising v. Lachmi Devi,(l921) Indian Cases, Vol. LIX, 220 ...................................... 409

Henry v. United States, 361 U.S. 98. .......................................................................... 365

HG v. R, (1999) 197 C.L.R. 414 32,177,178

Hodo v. Superior Court, 30 Cal. Appl 3d 790. ............................................................ 107

Hollington v. Hewthorn and Co. Ltd., [I9431 2 All E R 35. 3

Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar, AIR 1979 S.C. 1369. ............................. 358,360

lshwari Prasad Misra v. Mohammad Isa. (1963) 3 S.C.R. 722. ........................... 184,189

James Victor Salem v. United States Lines Company, (1962) L.Ed 2d 313. .............. 44

Jones v. U.S, 548 A.2d 35 (D.C. App. 1988

Jurek v. Texas, 428 U.S. 262 (1976)

Kamti Devi v. Poshi Ram, 2001 (5) S.C.C. 31 1

Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967)

Kelly v. Richardson, 37 N.W. 514 Mic:h. (1888) 26

Kumho Tyre Company, Ltd. v. Carmicliael, 143 L. Ed. 2d 238. . . . 152,155,158,162,164,197

Kunhiraman v. Manoj, 1991 (2) K.L.7. 190. 331,334

Lahey v. Kelly, 71 N.Y. 2d. 135. 103

Lam Chi-Ming v. The Queen, [I9911 2 A.C. 212 374

Lance et al v. Luzerne County Manul'acturers Association, 77 A.2d 386 (Pa. 1951). 34

Little v. Armontrout, 835 F.2d 1240 (8Ih Cir. 1987). ..................................................... 356

Little v. Streater, 452 U. S. 1 354

Logerquist v. McVey, 1 P.3d 113 (Ariz. 2000). ........................................................... 287

M.H. Hoscot v. State of Maharastra, AIR 1978 S.C. 1548. .................................. 358,359

Magan Biharilal v. State of Punjab, AIR 1977 S.C. 1091. ............................. 184,185,189

Magnuson v. State, 203 N.W. 749 (Vdis. 1925 119

Makita (Australia) Pvt. Ltd v. Sprowles, (2001) 52 N.S.W.L.R. 705 ......................... 178

Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, AIR 1978 S.C. 597 ........................... 350,358,391,393

............................................... Manohar Lal v. Seith Hiralal, AIR 1962 S.C. 527, 537. 384

Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U. S. 319 354

McCord v. State, 507 So. 2d 1030 (Ala. Crim. App. 1987) ......................................... 356

Mc Quaker v. Goddard, [I9401 1 K.B.68 58

Minor v. State. 2004 Ala. Crim. App. LEXIS 156 ....................................................................... 130

Moultrie v. Martin, 690 F.2d 1078 at 1082 (4'h Cir. 1982) 275

Murarilal v. State of M.P., AIR 1980 S.C. 531 .............................................. 186,187,188

Murphy v R, (1989) 167 C.L.R. 9 32. 44,174

National Justice Compania Naviera v Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd,

[1993] 2 Lloyd's Rep. 68 .......................................................................................... 24

New York v. Klingert, 713 N.Y.S. 2d 823 (N.Y. 2000 31 2

Norfolk S. Corp. v. Chevron U.S.A., Inc., 279 F. Supp. 2d 1250 ( l l t h cir. 2003) ....... 106

Old Chief v. United States, (1 I ) , 519 1J.S. 172 (1997 88

Opper v. United States, 348 U.S. 84, 86 (1 954). ........................................................ 185

Osburn v. Anchor Laboratories Inc., 8:!5 F.2d 908 (5Ih cir. 1987). ............................ 142

Osland v. R, (1998) 197 C.L.R. 316 174

Parwat v. Sukdev, AIR 1956 Bom. 617. 182

Patodia v. R.K. Birla, AIR 1971 S.C. 129 397

People v. Collins, 405 N.Y.S. 2d 365, (Sup. Ct. 1978) 119

People v. Collins, 68 Cal. 2d 319 (1968 274

People v. Kelly, 549 P.2d 1240 (Cal. 1376). 104,106,109,135

People v. King, 266 Cal. App. 2d 437 (1968

People v. Leahy, 882 P.2d 321 (Cal. 11394). 105,109,125,135

People v. Miller, 670 N.E.2d 721 (111. 1096

People v. Mohit, 579 N.Y.S.2d 990 (N.'f.Co.Ct. 1992)

People v. Palmer, 80 Cal. App. 3d 239

People v. Rogers, 385 N.Y. S. 2d 22'3 (Sup. Ct. 1976) ............................................... 107

People v. Soto. 981 P.2d 958 (Cal. 1999) 318

People v. Wesley, 533 N.Y.S. 2d 643 (Co. Ct. 1988). ......................................... 283,288

People v. Wesley. 633 N.E.2d 451 (P.I.Y. 1994) 105

People v. Wesley, 589 N.Y.S. 2d 197 (N.Y.A.D. 3Dept. 1992) ................................... 295

People v. Young, 391 N.W.2d. 270 (Ivlich. 1986 102

Perry v. The Queen, (1 982) 150 C.L.R. 580. .............................................................. 31 9

Polavarapu Venkateswaralu v. Polavarapu Subbayya, AIR 1951 Mad. 910. ............. 385

Prater v. State. 820 S. W. 2d 429 (Arc. 1991 290,302,305

Preece v. H.M. Advocate, [I9811 Crirn.L.R. 783.

Pushpadevi v. M.L. Wadhavan, AIR 1987 S.C. 1748

Queen v. Silverlock, 118941 2 Q.B. 766

R v Lewis, (1987) 88 F.L.R. 104

R v Maguire, [I9921 2 All ER 433.

R v Tran, (1990) 50 A Crim. R. 233.

R v. Adams, (1996) 2 Cr. App. R. 46

R v. Abadom, [I9831 1 All ER 36

R v. Adams, [I9961 Crim.L.R. 898

R v. Ahluvalia, [I9931 Crim. L.R. 728.

R v. Anderson and Others, [I9711 3,411 ER 115

R v. Baptiste, (1991) http:l/www.canlii.orglbclcaslbcscll99111991 bcscl0898 . . . 306

R v. Beland and Phillips, [I9871 2 S.C.R. 398

R v. Bonython, (1984) 38 S.A.S.R. 4

R v. Calder and Boyars Ltd., [I9631 :I All ER 644

R v. Clark, [ZOO31 E.W.C.A. Crim. 1020

R v. Constable of South Yorkshire, [:!003] 1 All ER 148 (CA). ......................... ...... 374

R v. David John Mclntyre, [2001] N..S.W.S.C. 31 1 31 0

R, v, Doe, (1986) 31 C.C.C. (3d) 353 at 362 (Ont. Dist. Ct.). .............................. 164.165

R v. Doheny and R v. Adarns, (19971 Crirn. L R.669 75,272,321

R v. Edwards. [I9961 1 S.C.R. 12

R v. Gilfoyle, (20011 2 Cr. App. R. 57

R v. Gilmore, [1977] 2 N.S.W.L.R. 925

R v. Hodges and another, (20031 Criln. L. R. 472

R v. Huckerby and another, (20041 All ER (D

R.v. J. (L.J.), [2000]2S.C.R.6

R v. Johnston. (1992) 69 CCC (3D) :39

R v. Karger, 120011 S.A.S.C.

R v. Karger, (20021 S.A.S.C. 294

R v. Lavallee, (19901 1 S.C.R. 852

R v. Loughran, [1999] Crirn. L.R. 405

R v. Luttrell and others, (20041 All ER (D) 454

R v. Mcllkenny, (19921 2 All ER 41

R v. Mohan, (19941 2 S.C.R.

R v. O'Sullivan, (19693 2 All ER 231'

R v. Pantoja, (1996) 88 A Crirn. R. !554

R v. Robb, [1991] Crirn. L.R. 539.

.................................................................................... R v. Sang, [ l 9791 All ER 1222. 395

R v. Shephard, [I9931 1 All ER 22:. 30

R v. Sims. (1946) K.B 539. ........................................................................ 83

R v. Stamford. (19721 2 Q.B. 39 2

R v. Stillman, [I9971 1 S.C.R. 607 ............................................................................... 382

......................................... R v. Turner, (19751 1 Q.B. 834. 23, 29, 42, 48, 63,165,169,286

R v. Ward, (19931 2 All ER 577 ...................................................................................... 50

R v. Weightman, (19911 Cfim. L R. i 43

R. v. Harris. (19521 1 All ER 104

R. v. Blastland, (1986) A.C. 41

R. v. Chamberline, (1984) 153 C.L.R. 521

R v. Dallagher. [2003] 1 Cr. App. R.195

................................................................................. R. v. Davies, [I9621 3 All ER. 97. 11

................................ R. v. Melaragni, (1992) 73 C.C.C. (31'1) 348 (0nt.Ct. (Gen.Div.). 315

........................................ R v. Pinfold and Mac Kenney, [2003] E.W.C.A. Crim. 3643. 50

R. v. Robinson. [I9941 3 All ER 346

R v. Toohey, [I9651 1 All ER 506 at 51

Rajagopal v. Tamil Nadu, AIR 1995 SC 26

Ram Chand v. Kanhayalal, AIR 1966 S.C. 1899

Ram Chandra v. State of U.P., AIR -957 S.C. 38

Ram Das v. Secretary of State, AIR 1930 All. 58

Ramsay v. Watson, (1961) 108 C.L.?. 64

Ratliff v. Schiber Truck Co., 150 F.31'1 949 (8th cir. 1998)

Rawlings v. Kentucky. 448 U.S. 98 (1980) 381

re Paoli R.R. and PCB Litig.. 916 F.2d 829 (3d Cir. 1990). ............................. ......... 309

Reilly v. Berry, 166 N.E. 165. 167 (h1.Y. 1929)

Rupert v. People. 429 P.2d 276 (Colo.1967).

S.V.S., W. v. Official Solicitor, [1970] 3 All ER 107.

Sajitha v. State of Kerala, 2002 (3) K.L.T. 762

Sashi Kumar v. Subodh Kumar, AIR 1964 S.C. 529 .......................................... 184.189

Schmerber v. California, 384 U.S. 757 (1966). 365

Seyfang v. G.D. Searle and Co., [ I $1731 1 Q.B. 148 ....................................................... 54

Shahid Ganj v. S.G.P. Committee, AIR 1940 P.C. 11 70

Sharda v. Dharrnapal, (2003) 4 S.C:.C. 493. .................................................. 386,390

Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives Association, 489 U.S. 602 (1989) .................... 368

Smith v. Baldi, 344 U.S. 561, 568 (1053 353

Smith v. Hobart Mfg. Co., 185 F.Supu. 751 (D.C. Pennsylvania 1960) ....................... 34

Specht v. Jensen, 853 F.2d. 805 ( lofh Cir. 1988). 68

Standard Oil Co. of California v. Moore, 251 F.2d 188 (gth cir. 1983) .......................... 61

State of H.P. v. Jailal, 1999 S.C. 331;3 40,180,183,184

State of Tennessee v. Paul Ware; (1996). ............................................................... 310

State v. Barnett, 909 S.W.2d 423. 42'7-28 (Tenn. 1995

State v. Brown, 470 N.W.2d 30 (Iowa 1991)

State V. Carter, 524 N.W.2d 763 (Net)., 1994)

State v. Castro, 545 N.Y. S.2d 985 (h.Y. 1989

State v. Chapple, 660 P.2d 1208 (Arii:. 1983

State v. Faught, 908 P.2d 566 (Oho, '1995)

State v. Freeman, 253 Neb. 385 (1997

State v. Lucero, 85 P.3d 1059 (gth cir. 2004)

State v. Pali Ram, AIR 1979 S.C.l

State v. Pennington. 393 S.E.2d 847 (N.C.1990

State v. S.J. Choudhary, AIR 1996 S.C. 149

State of Gujarat v. Abdul Rahim Abdullabhai Ranginwala,

1983 Cr. L. J. (NOC) H.P. .................................................................................... 186

State of Maharastra v. Sukhdeo Singh, AIR 1992 S.C. 2100. .................................... 189

State v. Williams, 599 A.2d 960 (N.J. Super.L., 1991) ............................................. 298

State v. Woodall, 385 S.E.2d 253 (W.\'a., 1989). .................................................. 290

Strickland Transportation Co. v. Ingrani. 403 S.W. 2d 192 ........................................ 17

Sunil Batra v. Delhi Admn., AIR 1978 S.C. 1675. .................................................. 350

Tech. Licensing Corp. v. Gennum Corl~.,

2004 U.S. Dist. LEXlS 10604 (9Ih Cir. 2004) ................................................... 163

Thurman v. State, 861 S.W.2d 96 (Tex. Ct. App. 1993). ................................ .. ..... 371

Tracy Peerage Case, 10 CI 8 F 154 :I843 192

Transport Publishing Co. v. Literature! Board of Review, (1956) 99 C.L.R. 11 1. ........ I 74

Tropel v. Roadway Express Inc., 194 F.3d 708 (6" Cir. 1999) ..................................... 59

Turley v. People, 216 P 536 (Colo. 1923

U.S v. Baller, 519 F.2d 463 (C.A.W. \/a. 1975

U.S v. Yee. 134 F.R.D. 161 (N.D. Oh o 1991). .............................. 102,105,263,291,297

U.S. V. Bonds, 12 F.3d 540 (6'h cir. 1393

United States v. Brown. 557 F.2d 541 (6" Cir. 1977

U.S. v. Jakobetz, 747 F. Supp.250 (D. Vt., 1990)

United States v. Cox, 696 F.2d 1294 (1 1" Cir. 1983

United States v. Crawford, 239 F.3d 1086 (91h cir. 2001)

............................ United States v. Downing, 753 F.2d 1 224 (3'd Cir. 1985). 137,148,302

United States v. Edwards, 819 F.2d 2162 (11" Cir. 1987 74

.................................. United States v. Figueroa-Lopez, 125 F.3d 1241 (91h cir. 1 997) 19

United States v. Garber, 607 F.2d 92 (51h cir. 1979) 69

.............................................. United States v. Hall, 165 F.3d 1095 (71h cir. 1999). 45. 47

United States v. Hickey, 917 F.2d 901 (6Ih cir. 1990) 18

United States v. Jackson, 688 F.2d 1121 (71h cir. 1982) 20

United States v. Kozminski. 821 F.2d 1186 (6" Cir.1987 297

United States v. Martinez. 3 F.3d 119'1 (1993). 307

United States v. Miller. 425 U.S. 435 (1976

United States v. Milton, 555 F.2d 119tl (51h cir.1977)

United States v. Peoples, 250 F.3d 630 (8th Cir. 2001)

..................... United States v. Plaza, 179 F. Supp. i d 492 (E.D.Pa.7 January 2002) 195

United States v. Seschillie. 310 F.3d 1208 (91h cir. 2002)

United States v. Skeet, 665 F.2d 983 19" Cir. 1982).

................................... United States v. Two Bulls, 918 F.2d 56 (C.A. 8 (S.D.) 1990). 296

United States v. White, 401 U.S. 745 :1971). 371

............................ United States v. Williams, 583 F.2d 1 .I 94 (2nd Cir. 1978). 135,136,165

United States v. Williams. 343 F.3d 423 (!jth cir. 2003

United States v. Wood, 207 F.3d 1222 (loth cir. 2000

United States v. Zeiger, 350 F. Supp. 685 (D.D.C.).

Woolmington v. DPP, [I9351 A.C. 46: