Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles

11
Law Institute page 1 Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber Berkeley, March 19, 2012

description

Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber. Berkeley, March 19, 2012. “Control” of a large machine. Secure communications interception standards. Constitutional principles. Democracy. Human rights. Public interest in general. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles

Page 1: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 1

Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles

Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Berkeley, March 19, 2012

Page 2: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 2Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Secure communications interception standards

“Control” of a large machine“Control” of a large machine

Human rights

Constitutional principles

Democracy

Page 3: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 3Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Page 4: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 4Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

No rules in Internet world?

Public interest in general Public interest in general

Public order

Public morals

Page 5: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 5Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

ICCPR, ECHR

Human rights Human rights

Freedom of expression v. privacy

Collection/storage of data v. right to be forgotten

Page 6: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 6Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Page 7: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 7Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Computer confidentiality and integrity right

Right of having identification avoided

Newly developed specific fundamental rights Newly developed specific fundamental rights

Right to limit data storage

Page 8: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 8Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

General conditions for State interventions

Scope of State interventions

Positive obligations of States?

Page 9: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 9Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Technical environment

Use of Trojan Horse softwareUse of Trojan Horse software

Legal assessment

Page 10: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 10Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Page 11: Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine  and Constitutional Principles

Law Institute

page 11Tensions between the Large Immortal Machine and Constitutional Principles. Prof. Dr. Rolf H. Weber

Council of Europe’s Convention on Cybercrime

International (Internet-ional) Customary

Legal Principles

New horizons?