Tempo Product Launch
Embed Size (px)
description
Transcript of Tempo Product Launch
-
Tempo Product LaunchSabadell 24th July 2008
Johnson Controls
-
Presentation ContentProduct Overview and Product FeaturesSaving Energy with TempoNeighbour Friendly UnitCompact DesignHeat Recovery OptionHydrokitMicrochannel Condenser CoilsDesign Improvement over YLAECompetition ComparisonIntroduction Timeline and Pricing
Johnson Controls
-
Product OverviewTempo
Super Efficient Air-Cooled Liquid ChillerswithMicrochannel TechnologyScroll CompressorsR410A Refrigerant
310 kW to 521 kW
Johnson Controls
-
Product FeaturesTempoA high tech solution providing
Flexible range of 10 modelsHigh full and part load efficienciesLow operating soundSmart controlsCompact designEasy installationBuilding Management System Interface
Johnson Controls
-
Major ComponentsMicrochannel Condenser CoilsScroll CompressorsLiquid ReceiversS&T Evaporator
Johnson Controls
-
Product RangePhase 1 IntroPhase 2 IntroPhase 2 IntroPhase 1 IntroPhase 1 Out (3)Phase 1 Out (4)Phase 2 Out (1)Phase 2 Out (2)Gap is now closed(1): YLAE0190SE to YLAE0330SE(2): YLAE0195HE to YLAE0315HE(3): YLAE0375SE to YLAE0490SE(4): YLAE0355HE to YLAE0510HE
Johnson Controls
Chart1
55595
192118211
176168122
181105179
178126146
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Sheet1
Capacity Start Ph1 [kW]Capacity Finish Ph1 [kW]Capacity Range Ph1 [kW]Capacity Finish ph 2[kW]Capacity Range ph2 [kW]
YCIV-HE55565095
YLAA-HE (ph.1+2)192310118521211
YLAA-SE (ph.1+2)176344168466122
YLAE-HE181286105465179
YLAE-SE178304126450146
-
Save Energy: Low Operating CostsStandard Efficiency Range (SE)Energy Efficiency Ration (EER) up to 2.7Eurovent Class: DEuropean Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ration (ESEER) up to 3.96
High Efficiency Range (HE)Energy Efficiency Ration (EER) up to 3.1Eurovent Class: A & BEuropean Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ration (ESEER) up to 4.35
Johnson Controls
-
Save Energy: Low Operating Costs - EERYLAE-SE to YLAE-HE: +7% EERYLAA-SE to YLAA-HE: +17% EER
Johnson Controls
Chart1
2.653.12.82.93.1
2.543.092.82.93.13
2.73.042.62.7
2.563.042.62.8
3.052.72.8
3.052.52.9
2.72.8
2.62.8
2.62.8
2.52.7
YLAA-SE (ph.1)
YLAA-HE (ph.1)
YLAE-SE
YLAE-HE
YCIV-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
EER
Sheet1
YLAA-SE (ph.1)
Cooling Capacity [kW]344386418466
EER2.652.542.72.56
YLAA-HE (ph.1)
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
EER3.13.093.043.043.053.05
YLAE-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]178201222243277304344361410450
EER2.82.82.62.62.72.52.72.62.62.5
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]181205227244286328349370423465
EER2.92.92.72.82.82.92.82.82.82.7
YCIV-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]555595
EER3.13.13
-
Save Energy: Low Operating Costs ESEEROn Average, 10% better ESEER
Johnson Controls
ESEER
4.3473.88
4.0113.81
4.16853.87
4.16853.76
4.18953.75
4.33
YLAA-HE
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
ESEER
Sheet1
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
ESEER4.3474.0114.16854.16854.18954.33
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
ESEER3.883.813.873.763.75
-
Save Energy: Low Operating Costs Approximate Energy CostAEC = (ACL * OH * Rate) / ESEER
ACL=Average Chiller Load (kW) Use ESEER weighting: 0.03(100%)+0.33(75%)+0.41(50%)+0.23(25%) = 54% Average LoadFor YLAA0515HE Chiller: 521x 0.54 = 281 kW
OH=Operating Hours: Assume 5,000 hours per year
Rate=Utility Energy Charge (/kWh): Assume average 0.10/kWh
ESEER=European Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (kW/kW) For YLAA0515HE: ESEER=4.33
AEC = (281 x 5,000 x 0.1) / 4.33 = 32,500
Johnson Controls
-
Save Energy: Low Operating Costs AEC (continued)Average Savings: 1,300 per yearAverage Savings: 650 per year
Johnson Controls
ESEER
4.3473.88
4.0113.81
4.16853.87
4.16853.76
4.18953.75
4.33
YLAA-HE
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
ESEER
AEC
9627.329192546619254.658385093211412.371134020622824.7422680412
11645.474943904323290.949887808512366.141732283524732.2834645669
12500.899604174225001.799208348312906.97674418625813.9534883721
13893.486865779127786.973731558115151.595744680930303.1914893617
14532.760472610129065.52094522021674033480
16243.64896073932487.2979214781
YLAA-HE (2500 hr)
YLAA-HE (5000 hr)
YLAE-HE (2500 hr)
YLAE-HE (5000 hr)
Cooling Capacity
AEC (Euros)
Sheet1
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
ESEER4.3474.0114.16854.16854.18954.33
YLAA-HE (2500 hr)9,627 11,645 12,501 13,893 14,533 16,244
YLAA-HE (5000 hr)19,255 23,291 25,002 27,787 29,066 32,487
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
ESEER3.883.813.873.763.75
YLAE-HE (2500 hr)11,412 12,366 12,907 15,152 16,740
YLAE-HE (5000 hr)22,825 24,732 25,814 30,303 33,480
-
Save Energy: Evaporator Pressure DropPumping power used to overcome pressure drop through the evaporator has a cost that needs to be taken into accountPumping Power [kW] = P x Q / 103 / PUMP / MOTOR Pumping Cost = Pumping Power x Operating Hours x RateWhere:P = Pressure Drop though Evaporator in kPaQ = Flow Rate in L/s. ( Q = Cooling Capacity [kW] / 4.18 / 5)PUMP = Efficiency of the pump. Considered 90%MOTOR = Efficiency of the motor. Considered 80%Operating Hours and Rate as for AEC model
Johnson Controls
-
Save Energy: Pumping Costs
Johnson Controls
Chart1
190.5568846358381.1137692717201.6214779373403.2429558745
137.9585326954275.9170653908243.5207336523487.0414673046
160.3203083466320.6406166932288.908825093577.8176501861
334.9780701754669.9561403509343.5340244551687.0680489102
292.2149122807584.4298245614370.8133971292741.6267942584
372.192317916744.384635832
YLAA-HE - 2500 hr
YLAA-HE - 5000 hr
YLAE-HE - 2500 hr
YLAE-HE - 5000 hr
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Pumping Cost (Euros)
Sheet1
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
Nominal Evaporator Pressure Drop [kPa]3742474948
Flow Rate [L/s]15.716.717.720.222.2
Pump Ouput Power [kW]0.580.700.830.991.07
Pump Efficiency0.900.900.900.900.90
Motor Efficiency0.800.800.800.800.80
Pump Input Power [kW]0.810.971.161.371.48
YLAE-HE - 2500 hr202244289344371
YLAE-HE - 5000 hr403487578687742
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
Nominal Evaporator Pressure Drop [kPa]372425473943
Flow Rate [L/s]14.816.618.520.521.624.9
Pump Ouput Power [kW]0.550.400.460.960.841.07
Pump Efficiency0.900.900.900.900.900.90
Motor Efficiency0.800.800.800.800.800.80
Pump Input Power [kW]0.760.550.641.341.171.49
YLAA-HE - 2500 hr191138160335292372
YLAA-HE - 5000 hr381276321670584744
-
Save Energy: Total Operating CostsAverage Savings: 1,400 per yearAverage Savings: 700 per year
Johnson Controls
Chart1
9817.886077182419635.772154364811613.992611957923227.9852239158
11783.433476599623566.866953199312609.662465935825219.3249318716
12661.219912520825322.439825041613195.885569279126391.7711385582
14228.464935954528456.92987190915495.129769135930990.2595382719
14824.975384890829649.950769781617110.813397129234221.6267942584
16615.84127865533231.6825573101
YLAA-HE (2500 hr)
YLAA-HE (5000 hr)
YLAE-HE (2500 hr)
YLAE-HE (5000 hr)
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Total Cost (Euros)
Sheet1
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
Nominal Evaporator Pressure Drop [kPa]3742474948
Flow Rate [L/s]15.716.717.720.222.2
Pump Ouput Power [kW]0.580.700.830.991.07
Pump Efficiency0.900.900.900.900.90
Motor Efficiency0.800.800.800.800.80
Pump Input Power [kW]0.810.971.161.371.48
YLAE-HE - 2500 hr202 244 289 344 371
YLAE-HE - 5000 hr403 487 578 687 742
ESEER3.883.813.873.763.75
YLAE-HE (2500 hr)11,412 12,366 12,907 15,152 16,740
YLAE-HE (5000 hr)22,825 24,732 25,814 30,303 33,480
Total Cost
YLAE-HE (2500 hr)11,614 12,610 13,196 15,495 17,111 14,005 683
YLAE-HE (5000 hr)23,228 25,219 26,392 30,990 34,222 28,010 1,366
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
Nominal Evaporator Pressure Drop [kPa]372425473943
Flow Rate [L/s]14.816.618.520.521.624.9
Pump Ouput Power [kW]0.550.400.460.960.841.07
Pump Efficiency0.900.900.900.900.900.90
Motor Efficiency0.800.800.800.800.800.80
Pump Input Power [kW]0.760.550.641.341.171.49
YLAA-HE - 2500 hr191 138 160 335 292 372
YLAA-HE - 5000 hr381 276 321 670 584 744
ESEER4.354.014.174.174.194.33
YLAA-HE (2500 hr)9,627 11,645 12,501 13,893 14,533 16,244
YLAA-HE (5000 hr)19,255 23,291 25,002 27,787 29,066 32,487
Total Cost
YLAA-HE (2500 hr)9,818 11,783 12,661 14,228 14,825 16,616 13,322
YLAA-HE (5000 hr)19,636 23,567 25,322 28,457 29,650 33,232 26,644
-
Save Energy: How do we achieve it? Compressors & Evap.Tandem or Trio Scroll ConfigurationSame compressors as on YCWLProven configuration with High EfficiencyReplace ZP285 as used on YLAE by more efficient ZP295Use of shell and tubes evaporator increases cooling capacity compared to PHE for same compressors configuration
Johnson Controls
-
Save Energy: How do we achieve it? Efficient FansYLAA is using more efficient fans than YLAEMicrochannel air side pressure drop is less than conventional condenser coils allowing higher air flow and lower fan power con-sumption than on YLAEYLAE0510HE8 fans42 m3/s with fans at full speed1.8 kW / fanYLAA0515HE8 fans52 m3/s with fans at full speed (+24 % more air)1.7kW / fan (-6 % fan power)
Johnson Controls
-
Neighbour Friendly: Low Sound
Johnson Controls
Chart1
87868786
87878887
89888988
89888989
898989
8989
YLAA-SE-LS (ph.1)
YLAA-HE-LS (ph.1)
YLAE-SE-LS
YLAE-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Sound Power [dB(A)]
Sheet1
YLAA-SE-LS (ph.1)
Cooling Capacity [kW]336374408452
Sound Power [dB(A)]87878989
YLAA-HE-LS (ph.1)
Cooling Capacity [kW]304340377420443510
Sound Power [dB(A)]868788888989
YLAE-SE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]292331347394432
Sound Power [dB(A)]8788898989
YLAE-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]274315335355406447
Sound Power [dB(A)]868788898989
-
Neighbour Friendly: Low SoundNormal conversation at 1 metre distanceInside car travelling at 50 km/h with windows closedYLAA-HE-LS Sound Pressure at 10m.
Johnson Controls
Chart1
53
54
55
55
56
56
YLAE-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Sound Pressure [dB(A)]
Sheet1
YLAE-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]274315335355406447
Sound Pressure at 10 m [dB(A)]535455555656
-
Neighbour Friendly: LS modelsAs with YLAE, LS models include:Single low speed fansCompressor Acoustic Enclosure
LS model on average 8 dB(A) quieter than standard models
Johnson Controls
-
Compact Design Footprint
Johnson Controls
Chart1
8.278.2710.077.86
8.278.2710.077.86
8.278.2710.0710.07
10.788.2710.0710.07
10.7810.07
10.78
YLAA-HE
YLAA-SE
YLAE-HE
YLAE-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Footprint [m2]
Sheet1
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
Footprint [m2]8.278.278.2710.7810.7810.78
YLAA-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]344386418466
Footprint [m2]8.278.278.278.27
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
Footprint [m2]10.0710.0710.0710.0710.07
YLAE-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]344361410450
Footprint [m2]7.867.8610.0710.07
-
Compact Design - Weight
Johnson Controls
Chart1
2416263024472719
2598270127192835
2859290028352999
3171304229993065
32813065
3488
YLAA-HE
YLAA-SE
YLAE-HE
YLAE-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Shipping Weight [kg]
Sheet1
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
Shipping Weight [kg]241625982859317132813488
YLAA-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]344386418466
Shipping Weight [kg]2630270129003042
YLAE-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]328349370422465
Shipping Weight [kg]24472719283529993065
YLAE-SE
Cooling Capacity [kW]344361410450
Shipping Weight [kg]2719283529993065
-
Heat RecoveryHeat Recovery PHE
Johnson Controls
-
Heat Recovery (Contd)Not only provides free heat but also increases cooling EERHeat Recovery Exchanger converts the YLAA into a water-cooled chiller, therefore increasing efficiency.Standard YLAA0515HE:35C ambient - LCWT 7CEER = 3.05Heat Recovery YLAA0515HE:35C ambient - LCWT 7C LHWT 45CEER = 3.55
Johnson Controls
-
HydrokitSuction Guide with strainerFlow Regulating ValveSingle or Dual Pump(s)Various Available PressureFlow SwitchPipework and components are trace heated and insulatedElectrical Connection boxes for trace heating:
Johnson Controls
-
Microchannel Condenser Coils Elements of designThree basic components are used to construct microchannel coils: Parallel Flow Aluminum TubesEnhanced Aluminum FinsHeader Manifolds
Combined by alternating tube and fin sections (layer of tube, layer of fin, layer of tube, etc). Fins and tubes are captured at both ends by header manifolds. Controlled Atmosphere Brazing (CAB) furnaces are used to manufacture all- aluminum microchannel coils (enriched with Nitrogen to minimize oxidation on the coil surface and promote clean, consistent braze joints).
HeaderParallel Flow TubeEnhanced Aluminum Fins
Johnson Controls
-
Microchannel Condenser Coils Elements of design (Contd)65%35%De-Superheat SectionSub-Cooling SectionVapour InletsLiquid outlet
Johnson Controls
-
Microchannel Condenser Coils Corrosion ResistanceConventional copper tube/aluminum fin coils are predisposed to galvanic corrosion (2 dissimilar materials).Microchannel coils reduce the rate of galvanic corrosion by utilizing tube and fin material with similar properties (aluminum) and provide more than seven times greater corrosion resistanceMicrochannel - 7,000 HrsConventional Coil 1,000 Hrs
Johnson Controls
-
Microchannel Condenser Coils ServiceabilityStructure is more rigid than conventional condenser coil designs since Microchannel Aluminum fins do not protrude past the edge of the tube (as is common in Cu tube / Al fin designs)Microchannel coils can be cleaned with medium-pressure water (10 MPa). It is also safe to use traditional cleaning methods with microchannel coils.Coil repair is accomplished by using a hand-held, light-weight, off the shelf MAPP gas torch as opposed to the typical oxy-acetylene torch.All other interconnecting joints are standard copper to copper connections and current brazing practices apply.
Johnson Controls
-
Microchannel Condenser Coils Additional AdvantagesLeak potential of microchannel condenser coil is far less than tube/fin coil as there are no brazed return bends (only vertical header)Significant Weight reduction on the overall Condenser Section. The coil dimensions are 1200 mm x 2050 mm and weighs approximately 30 kg per coil slab.Air Side pressure is less than for equivalent conventional coil and therefore contributes to quieter sound level.Technology benefits from the automotive industry experience. Car Radiators have endured a severe environment for 15 years or more. They are subjected to: Salt, Oil, Sand, Tar, Gravel, Chemical Road Treatments, Dirt, Insects, Moisture and Full Range of Ambient Temperatures. WHEN DID YOU LAST CHANGE YOUR CAR RADIATOR?
Johnson Controls
-
Bruno HilkensDirect Phone:+49 201 2400.423E-mail:[email protected] or [email protected] One Company One Team One GoalMariano Altamore Direct Phone:+39 02 28042.211 E-mail: [email protected] or [email protected] Germany, Austria, Benelux, Scandinavia, East Europe Countries, Russia and CIS Countries York connectivity all Europe
UK, France, Swiss, South Europe Countries, Adriatic Countries and South Africa Fire and Security all EuropeIntegrated and Special Solutions dedicated to Your BusinessAny Special and Custom Advanced Application/Integration developmentAny 3-party system Integration to Metasys Any 3-party connectivity to JC SystemsAny technology support (LonWorks, BACnet, IT ......)NIE Integrations , MIG applications, N2 and BACnet MS/TP protocol support to 3-party Fire & Security integrationYork devices/systems integration
MissionSystems Integration Services
Johnson Controls
-
JCI Building Efficiency as Solutions Supplier (Internal Leaflet Overview FY08)FIRE CONTROLHVACAPPLICATIONNAEBACnet MS/TPAHUCHILLERVRVFAN COILSMSEA Application Data ServerP2000Server
Johnson Controls
-
York Product Line ConnectivityYork product line connectivity to building automation systems
Johnson Controls
-
Quadro Chiller SequencerSequences from 2 to 4 chillers.
4 line 36 character display.
Option of GB, DE, ES, IT, FR languages.
Bacnet standard.
Auto or Manual lead-lag.
Alarm management.
IP55 hinged and lockable enclosure.
Temperature sensor with 6 metre cable.
Johnson Controls
-
Condenser Fans optionsStandard single speed FansDual Speed FansSingle Low speed FansHigh Static Fans
Johnson Controls
-
Condenser Fans VSD Fan Vs Dual Speed Fan AnalysisYLAA0300HE 5 fans unit VSD Add. Cost = 2,350 ESEER: 4. 35 with Dual Speed Fans< 4.5 with VSD Fans (Prediction subject to testing)Scenario 1:5,000 running hours per yearAEC (2 speed fans) = 19,250 AEC max (VSD fans) = 18,600 Payback (0% interest rate) = 3.7 yearsScenario 2:2,500 running hours per yearAEC (2 speed fans) = 9,600 AEC min (VSD fans) = 9,300 Payback (0% interest rate) = 7.3 years
YLAA0515HE 8 fans unit VSD Add. Cost = 3,760 ESEER: 4.33 with Dual Speed Fans< 4.5 with VSD Fans (Prediction subject to testing)Scenario 1:5,000 running hours per yearAEC (2 speed fans) = 32,500 AEC max (VSD fans) = 31,300 Payback (0% interest rate) = 3.1 yearsScenario 2:2,500 running hours per yearAEC (2 speed fans) = 16,250 AEC min (VSD fans) = 15,650 Payback (0% interest rate) = 6.1 years
Johnson Controls
-
Water Ingress Corrective ActionsYLAE Design 2-door box designTop to Bottom door openingBox fully exposed to elementsPower Harness Entry: Back of panelYLAA Design3-door box designSide door openingBox protected by top louvered panelPower Harness Entry: Bottom of panelImproved wrapper design with sealant on each jointRain gutter at the top of each opening
Johnson Controls
-
Refrigerant Leaks Corrective Actions Reduction of number of joints:Large reduction of return bends on condenser coils, from several hundreds brazed joints to just a few.
Improvement of quality of joints:Six Sigma projects:Loctite joint conversion to brazed joints on angle valvesWhere Loctite joints are necessary, improved manufacturing process for Loctite dosing
Johnson Controls
-
Accessories and OptionsLCD Display and control keypad language: English, French, German, Italian, Spanish.
Heat Recovery
Hydrokit (Single/Dual Pump, Various Available Pressures)
Soft Start
Power Factor Correction
Dual Pressure Relief Valves
Victaulic Flange Kit
2 Speed fans, High Static Fans
Wire Guards / Louvered Panels
Flow Switch.
Spring anti-vibration mountings.
Neoprene Pad Isolators.
Quadro Chiller Sequencer.
Johnson Controls
-
Competition Comparison - EER
Johnson Controls
Chart1
2.482.633.022.682.742.63.1
2.572.82.982.692.762.643.09
2.552.713.012.622.742.683.04
2.522.83.022.782.742.733.04
2.662.662.632.762.693.05
2.772.753.05
2.64
2.63
2.72
Aermec - NRA
Carrier - 30RB
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2
Climaveneta - NECS-ST
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Trane - CGAN
YORK - YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
EER
Sheet1
NRA
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434540
EER2.482.572.552.522.66
30RB
Cooling Capacity [kW]256291325356388415444503593
EER2.632.82.712.82.662.772.642.632.72
AQUACIAT 2
Cooling Capacity [kW]334380438493
EER3.022.983.013.02
NECS-ST
Cooling Capacity [kW]325349369438480
EER2.682.692.622.782.63
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]300323345374425493
EER2.742.762.742.742.762.75
CGAN
Cooling Capacity [kW]316350389428462
EER2.62.642.682.732.69
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
EER3.13.093.043.043.053.05
-
Competition Comparison - ESEER
Johnson Controls
Chart1
3.333.724.184.164.413.644.347
3.673.934.284.054.443.564.011
3.73.924.374.074.493.724.1685
3.644.054.394.024.573.864.1685
3.373.94.064.63.764.1895
3.894.64.33
3.84
3.75
4.07
Aermec - NRA
Carrier - 30RB
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2
Climaveneta - NECS-ST
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Trane - CGAN
YORK - YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
ESEER
Sheet1
NRA
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434540
ESEER3.333.673.73.643.37
30RB
Cooling Capacity [kW]256291325356388415444503593
ESEER3.723.933.924.053.93.893.843.754.07
AQUACIAT 2
Cooling Capacity [kW]334380438493
ESEER4.184.284.374.39
NECS-ST
Cooling Capacity [kW]325349369438480
ESEER4.164.054.074.024.06
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]300323345374425493
ESEER4.414.444.494.574.64.6
CGAN
Cooling Capacity [kW]316350389428462
ESEER3.643.563.723.863.76
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
ESEER4.3474.0114.16854.16854.18954.33
-
Competition Comparison Total Operating Costs
Johnson Controls
Chart1
1427.44083796721036.20929155731234.52153110051315.1540071771054.73098330241304.27467269571099.9338761925
1465.5492614371145.81449285951357.6890399321330.31897926641152.09459459461469.59168861891263.8776379311
1586.25048493471255.32479738311536.46245059291422.58017586961169.36253876241607.12417039671365.520582427
1806.88811188811361.25996810211775.5329097231727.61801042631270.34032016581717.03473237971630.5328971042
2925.40570471231561.21089436881934.81509416171425.21323070521935.09238521841663.6707841031
1663.6165299321718.11576867071892.3433649734
1831.7987440191
2195.8717703349
2229.4054700634
Aermec - NRA
Carrier - 30RB
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2
Climaveneta - NECS-ST
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Trane - CGAN
YORK - YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Total Cost (Euros)
Sheet1
Running Hours2500
NRA
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434540
ESEER3.333.673.73.643.37
AEC - 2500 hrs1297.29729729731335.28610354221422.9729729731609.61538461542163.2047477745
Pressure Drop34303538118
Flow Rate15.311004784717.368421052618.660287081320.765550239225.8373205742
PumpingPower0.52057416270.52105263160.65311004780.78909090913.0488038278
Pumping Cost130.1435406699130.2631578947163.2775119617197.2727272727762.2009569378
Total Cost1427.44083796721465.5492614371586.25048493471806.88811188812925.4057047123
30RB
Cooling Capacity [kW]256291325356388415444503593
ESEER3.723.933.924.053.93.893.843.754.07
AEC - 2500 hrs929.0322580645999.61832061071119.26020408161186.66666666671343.07692307691440.23136246791560.93751810.81966.9533169533
Pressure Drop354235414745516437
Flow Rate12.248803827813.923444976115.550239234417.03349282318.564593301419.856459330121.244019138824.066985645928.3732057416
PumpingPower0.4287081340.5847846890.54425837320.69837320570.87253588520.89354066991.08344497611.54028708131.0498086124
Pumping Cost107.1770334928146.1961722488136.0645933014174.5933014354218.1339712919223.3851674641270.8612440191385.0717703349262.45215311
Total Cost1036.20929155731145.81449285951255.32479738311361.25996810211561.21089436881663.6165299321831.79874401912195.87177033492229.4054700634
AQUACIAT 2
Cooling Capacity [kW]334380438493
ESEER4.184.284.374.39
AEC - 2500 hrs1078.70813397131198.59813084111353.08924485131516.0592255125
Pressure Drop39353544
Flow Rate15.98086124418.181818181820.95693779923.5885167464
PumpingPower0.62325358850.63636363640.7334928231.0378947368
Pumping Cost155.8133971292159.0909090909183.3732057416259.4736842105
Total Cost1234.52153110051357.6890399321536.46245059291775.532909723
NECS-ST
Cooling Capacity [kW]325349369438480
ESEER4.164.054.074.024.06
AEC - 2500 hrs1054.68751163.33333333331223.95577395581470.89552238811596.0591133005
Pressure Drop6740454959
Flow Rate15.550239234416.698564593317.655502392320.95693779922.966507177
PumpingPower1.04186602870.66794258370.79449760771.02688995221.3550239234
Pumping Cost260.466507177166.985645933198.6244019139256.7224880383338.7559808612
Total Cost1315.1540071771330.31897926641422.58017586961727.61801042631934.8150941617
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]300323345374425493
ESEER4.414.444.494.574.64.6
AEC - 2500 hrs918.3673469388982.09459459461037.30512249441104.81400437641247.28260869561446.847826087
Pressure Drop384432373546
Flow Rate14.354066985615.454545454516.507177033517.894736842120.334928229723.5885167464
PumpingPower0.54545454550.680.52822966510.66210526320.7117224881.0850717703
Pumping Cost136.3636363636170132.0574162679165.5263157895177.9306220096271.2679425837
Total Cost1054.73098330241152.09459459461169.36253876241270.34032016581425.21323070521718.1157686707
CGAN
Cooling Capacity [kW]316350389428462
ESEER3.643.563.723.863.76
AEC - 2500 hrs1171.9780219781327.24719101121411.69354838711496.89119170981658.7765957447
Pressure Drop3534424350
Flow Rate15.119617224916.746411483318.612440191420.478468899522.1052631579
PumpingPower0.52918660290.56937799040.7817224880.88057416271.1052631579
Pumping Cost132.2966507177142.3444976077195.4306220096220.1435406699276.3157894737
Total Cost1304.27467269571469.59168861891607.12417039671717.03473237971935.0923852184
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
ESEER4.3474.0114.16854.16854.18954.33
AEC - 2500 hrs962.73291925471164.54749439041250.08996041741389.34868657791453.2760472611624.3648960739
Pressure Drop372425473943
Flow Rate14.832535885216.555023923418.468899521520.526315789521.578947368424.9282296651
PumpingPower0.54880382780.39732057420.4617224880.96473684210.84157894741.0719138756
Pumping Cost137.200956937899.3301435407115.4306220096241.1842105263210.3947368421267.9784688995
Total Cost1099.93387619251263.87763793111365.5205824271630.53289710421663.67078410311892.3433649734
-
Competition Comparison ESEER / EER
Johnson Controls
Chart1
1.34274193551.41444866921.38410596031.5522388061.60948905111.41.4022580645
1.42801556421.40357142861.43624161071.50557620821.60869565221.34848484851.2980582524
1.45098039221.44649446491.45182724251.55343511451.63868613141.38805970151.3712171053
1.44444444441.44642857141.45364238411.44604316551.66788321171.41391941391.3712171053
1.26691729321.46616541351.54372623571.66666666671.39776951671.3736065574
1.404332131.67272727271.4196721311
1.4545454545
1.4258555133
1.4963235294
Aermec - NRA
Carrier - 30RB
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2
Climaveneta - NECS-ST
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Trane - CGAN
YORK - YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
ESEER / EER
Sheet1
NRA
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434540
EER2.482.572.552.522.66
ESEER3.333.673.73.643.37
ESEER Vs EER1.341.431.451.441.27
30RB
Cooling Capacity [kW]256291325356388415444503593
EER2.632.82.712.82.662.772.642.632.72
ESEER3.723.933.924.053.93.893.843.754.07
ESEER Vs EER1.411.401.451.451.471.401.451.431.50
AQUACIAT 2
Cooling Capacity [kW]334380438493
EER3.022.983.013.02
ESEER4.184.284.374.39
ESEER Vs EER1.381.441.451.45
NECS-ST
Cooling Capacity [kW]325349369438480
EER2.682.692.622.782.63
ESEER4.164.054.074.024.06
ESEER Vs EER1.551.511.551.451.54
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]300323345374425493
EER2.742.762.742.742.762.75
ESEER4.414.444.494.574.64.6
ESEER Vs EER1.611.611.641.671.671.67
CGAN
Cooling Capacity [kW]316350389428462
EER2.62.642.682.732.69
ESEER3.643.563.723.863.76
ESEER Vs EER1.401.351.391.411.40
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
EER3.13.093.043.043.053.05
ESEER4.3474.0114.16854.16854.18954.33
ESEER Vs EER1.401.301.371.371.371.42
-
Competition Comparison Sound Power
Johnson Controls
Chart1
858787879386
868787879387
868788889388
878888889488
87899589
879089
8789
88
93
Carrier - 30RB-LS
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2 XLN
Climaveneta - NECS-SL
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-EN-T
Trane - CGAN-SQ
YORK - YLAA-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Sound Power [dB(A)]
Sheet1
NRA320363390434
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434
Sound Power [dB(A)]91919092
Carrier - 30RB-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]244278312347373399427485570
Sound Power [dB(A)]858686878787878893
CIAT - AQUACIAT 2 XLN
Cooling Capacity [kW]327372429481
Sound Power [dB(A)]87878788
Climaveneta - NECS-SL
Cooling Capacity [kW]338356419455
Sound Power [dB(A)]87878888
Clivet - WSAT-XSC-EN-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]288309329357404459493
Sound Power [dB(A)]87878888899089
Trane - CGAN-SQ
Cooling Capacity [kW]316344377413442
Sound Power [dB(A)]9393939495
YORK - YLAA-HE-LS
Cooling Capacity [kW]304340377421443510
Sound Power [dB(A)]868788888989
-
Competition Comparison Footprint
Johnson Controls
Chart1
5.5356219.3728.01426.3640511.451058.27298
8.1198129.3728.01426.3640511.451058.27298
8.11981212.377210.23426.3640511.451058.27298
8.11981212.377210.23426.3640511.4510510.777294
8.1198128.485411.4510510.777294
10.8098948.485410.777294
10.809894
10.809894
13.499976
30RB
AQUACIAT 2
NECS-ST
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
CGAN
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]
Footprint [m2]
Sheet1
NRA
Cooling Capacity [kW]320363390434540
Length [mm]42504250575057505750
Width [mm]N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
Weight [kg]N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
30RB
Cooling Capacity [kW]256291325356388415444503593
Length [mm]245736043604360436044798479847985992
Width [mm]225322532253225322532253225322532253
Weight [kg]218027602956298431103632377239305120
Footprint [m2]5.5356218.1198128.1198128.1198128.11981210.80989410.80989410.80989413.499976
AQUACIAT 2
Cooling Capacity [kW]334380438493
Length [mm]4260426056265626
Width [mm]2200220022002200
Weight [kg]3499395745674621
Footprint [m2]9.3729.37212.377212.3772
NECS-ST
Cooling Capacity [kW]349369438480
Length [mm]3610361046104610
Width [mm]2220222022202220
Weight [kg]2850300034003460
Footprint [m2]8.01428.014210.234210.2342
WSAT-XSC-ST-T
Cooling Capacity [kW]300323345374425493
Length [mm]285028502850285038003800
Width [mm]223322332233223322332233
Weight [kg]195119532417264429302936
Footprint [m2]6.364056.364056.364056.364058.48548.4854
CGAN
Cooling Capacity [kW]316350389428462
Length [mm]51355135513551355135
Width [mm]22302230223022302230
Weight [kg]27103070337034903590
Footprint [m2]11.4510511.4510511.4510511.4510511.45105
YLAA-HE
Cooling Capacity [kW]310346386429451521
Length [mm]369036903690480748074807
Width [mm]224222422242224222422242
Weight [kg]261028053151342134893779
Footprint [m2]8.272988.272988.2729810.77729410.77729410.777294
-
YLAA Phase In / YLAE Phase Out TimelineYLAA Phase In Timeline: (Applies to phase 1 units only)First Order Accepted: July 28thFirst Shipment Ex-Sabadell: November 24th 10 pre-production units manufactured in Sept. and Oct.Pre-production units will be manufactured for stock and advertised on stock list
YLAE Phase Out Timeline: (Overlapping range with phase 1 YLAA)Last order accepted: November 7thMay be limited number of units (specific sizes) available in December depending on residual inventory.
Johnson Controls
-
Pricing SE RangeYLAA-SE FY09:9.6% cheaper than YLAE-SE FY094.3% cheaper than YLAE-SE FY08Comparison made in /kW
Johnson Controls
Chart1
25049.959168525801.004187263327090.9012022067
27459.7848927091.973547019128446.7298763866
29289.74817629983.014802359131481.9085305209
32149.93312832443.007068936534065.4730772488
YLAA SE
YLAE SE - 0907g
YLAE SE - 0808
Cooling Capacity (kW)
Transfer Price (Euros)
Sheet1
YLAA SE
360400435485
344386418466
25,05027,46029,29032,150
YLAA HE
300350390440455515
310346386429451521
23,10925,47728,12630,90032,39736,892
YLAE SE - 0808
375395450490
344361410450
27,09128,44731,48234,065
YLAE HE
355380405465510
328349370422465
26,48928,14829,78732,68234,825
YLAE SE - 0907g
375395450490
344361410450
25,80127,09229,98332,443
-
Pricing HE RangeYLAA-HE FY09:8.0% cheaper than YLAE-HE FY092.9% cheaper than YLAE-HE FY08Comparison made in /kW
Johnson Controls
Chart1
23108.9623323322907.987339598124053.8265680861
25476.9584724925227.970902263326489.2032041029
28125.9908590526808.04797893828148.1437198206
30899.989957528369.000057162829787.4500600209
32396.98947097531125.969340816632681.9018291136
36891.979709433166.003277762834824.5144481612
YLAA HE
YLAE HE - 0907g
YLAE HE - 0808
Cooling Capacity (kW)
Transfer Price (Euros)
Sheet1
YLAA SE
360400435485
344386418466
25,05027,46029,29032,150
YLAA HE
300350390440455515
310346386429451521
23,10925,47728,12630,90032,39736,892
YLAE SE
375395450490
344361410450
27,09128,44731,48234,065
YLAE HE - 0808
315355380405465510
286328349370422465
24,05426,48928,14829,78732,68234,825
YLAE HE - 0907g
315355380405465510
286328349370422465
22,90825,22826,80828,36931,12633,166
-
Global Product Recognition 2008 DEALER DESIGN AWARD from The NEWSThe NEWS is an HVAC contractor magazine
"Product of the Year" finalist nominationThis is a Consulting and Specifying Engineering community Award
Recognition from both side of the industry: Contractors and Consultants
Johnson Controls
-
Questions
Johnson Controls