Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date...

21
Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations Date: October 18, 2012 To: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations From: Derek Duval, Staff Liaison/Fire Protection Engineer Re: Agenda Package – NFPA 51B ROC Meeting – October 2012 Enclosed is the agenda package for the October 18 th meeting for the NFPA 51B ROC Meeting. Please ensure that you have reviewed the public input and the other agenda items in advance to prepare for discussion. The agenda and public comment will be posted on the document information page (www.nfpa.org/51b ). Some items to have available during the meeting include: Agenda package with comments A copy of NFPA 51B (visit the NFPA 51B Document information page for your free committee copy) Any previous copies of 51B Optional items that are sometimes useful include: Previous ROP/ROCs if handy If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to reach me at (617) 984-7434 or by e- mail at [email protected] . I look forward to our meeting to finish up the revision cycle! 1

Transcript of Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date...

Page 1: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations

Date: October 18, 2012 To: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations From: Derek Duval, Staff Liaison/Fire Protection Engineer Re: Agenda Package – NFPA 51B ROC Meeting – October 2012 Enclosed is the agenda package for the October 18th meeting for the NFPA 51B ROC Meeting. Please ensure that you have reviewed the public input and the other agenda items in advance to prepare for discussion. The agenda and public comment will be posted on the document information page (www.nfpa.org/51b). Some items to have available during the meeting include:

• Agenda package with comments • A copy of NFPA 51B (visit the NFPA 51B Document information page for your

free committee copy) • Any previous copies of 51B

Optional items that are sometimes useful include: • Previous ROP/ROCs if handy

If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to reach me at (617) 984-7434 or by e-mail at [email protected]. I look forward to our meeting to finish up the revision cycle!

1

Page 2: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations AGENDA

October 18, 2012 Adobe Connect – Web Conference:

http://nfpa.adobeconnect.com/nfpa51b 1:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. (EDT)

1. Meeting opening, introduction and attendance

2. Chair's remarks, Mark Blank

3. Staff Liaison update:

a. A2013 Schedule (Attachment A, A2013 Revision Cycle)

b. Committee Membership Update (Attachment B, HWO-AAA Membership)

4. Approval of Minutes from February 2012 ROP Meeting (Attachment C, HWO-

AAA Minutes ROP Feb 2012 )

5. NFPA 51B Report on Comments (ROC) (Attachment D, NFPA 51B Public

Comment)

a. Review and act on public comments

b. Develop Committee Comments

i. Task Group Work: Designated Area (Attachment E, Designated Area)

ii. Task Group Work: Smoldering (Attachment F, Smoldering)

6. Other business

a. CSB

7. Next meeting – To be scheduled as needed.

8. Adjournment

Attachments:

A. A2013 – Revision Cycle

B. HWO-AAA Committee Membership

C. HWO-AAA_NFPA 51B Minutes ROP_Feb 2012

D. NFPA 51B Public Comment

E. Designated Area Task Group Work

F. Smoldering Task Group Work

2

Page 3: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment A: A2013 Revision Cycle

3

Page 4: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

ANNUAL 2013 REVISION CYCLE PROCESS STAGE PROCESS STEP

DATES FOR TC

DATES FOR TCC

1 PRELIMINARY 1.0 Notification of intent to enter cycle 7/8/11 7/8/11

2 REPORT ON

PROPOSALS (ROP)

2.1 Proposal closing date *11/25/11 *11/25/11 2.2 Final date for ROP meeting 2/24/12 2/3/12 2.3 Final date for mailing TC ballots 3/16/12 2/17/12 2.4 Receipt of (TC) ballots by staff liaison 4/20/12 3/9/12 2.5 Receipt of TC recirculation ballots 5/4/12 3/16/12 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt of TCC recirculation ballots 5/18/12 2.10 Final copy (w/ ballot statements) to Secretary, Standards Council

5/11/12 5/25/12

2.11 Completion of Reports 5/18/12 6/1/12 2.12 ROP Published and Posted 6/22/12 6/22/12

3 REPORT ON

COMMENTS

(ROC)

3.1 Comment closing date 8/31/12 8/31/12 3.2 Final date for ROC meeting 11/2/12 10/5/12 3.3 Final date for mailing TC ballots 11/16/12 10/19/12 3.4 Receipt of (TC) ballots by staff liaison 11/30/12 11/9/12 3.5 Receipt of TC recirculation ballots 12/7/12 11/16/12 3.6 Final date for TCC meeting 12/14/12 3.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 12/21/12 3.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 1/11/13 3.9 Receipt of TCC recirculation ballots 1/18/13 3.10 Final copy (w/ ballot statements) to Secretary, Standards Council

12/21/12 1/25/13

3.11 Completion of Reports 1/11/13 2/1/13 3.12 ROC Published and Posted 2/22/13 2/22/13

TECH SESSION

PREPARATION &

ISSUANCE

4.1 Notice of Intent to Make a Motion (NITMAM) Closing Date 4/5/13 4/5/13 4.2 Posting of Filed NITMAM (Motions Committee Report) 5/3/13 5/3/13

4.3 Appeal Closing Date for Consent Documents or without NITMAM

5/18/13 5/18/13

4.4 Council Issuance for Consent Documents or without NITMAM

5/28/13 5/28/13

TECHNICAL

SESSION 5.0 Association Meeting for Documents with Certified Amending Motions

6/9-13/13 6/9-13/13

APPEALS & 6.1 Appeal closing date for Association Meeting Documents 7/3/13 7/3/13

6.2 Council issuance for Association Meeting Documents 8/1/13 8/1/13

* Proposal Closing Dates may vary according to documents and schedules for Revision Cycles may change. Please check the NFPA website (www.nfpa.org) for the most up-to-date information on proposal closing dates and schedules.

4

Page 5: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment B: HWO-AAA Committee Membership

5

Page 6: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Address List No PhoneHot Work Operations HWO-AAA

Derek Duval10/19/2012

HWO-AAA

Mark E. Blank

ChairFM Global300 South Northwest Highway, Suite 100Park Ridge, IL 60068-5872Alternate: Sergio Prete

I 10/1/1995HWO-AAA

Scott R. Altemose

PrincipalTrefoil Training & Technical Assistance1420 Andrew DriveWhitehall, PA 18052

SE 8/5/2009

HWO-AAA

Richard S. Anderson

PrincipalXL Global Asset Protection Services2420 Sand Creek Road C-1, #142Brentwood, CA 94513Alternate: Daniel M. Fritz

I 1/1/1991HWO-AAA

Richard M. Arvin

PrincipalNational Institutes of HealthFire Marshal’s Office508 Kansala DriveAnnapolis, MD 21401

E 8/9/2011

HWO-AAA

Christopher J. Bloom

PrincipalCJB Fire ConsultantsPO Box 2611White City, OR 97503Alternate: Joseph M. Bloom

SE 10/1/1995HWO-AAA

Gregory R. Cameron

PrincipalArizona Public Service CompanyPalo Verde Nuclear Generating StationPO Box 52034, MS 7098Phoenix, AZ 85072

U 7/23/2008

HWO-AAA

Daniel Driebel

PrincipalRoad Sprinkler Fitters UA Local Union 669PO Box 211New London, WI 54961United Assn. of Journeymen & Apprentices of thePlumbing & Pipe Fitting Industry

L 8/5/2009HWO-AAA

Christopher Drobny

PrincipalChubb Group of Insurance Companies777 South Flower Street, 3rd FloorLos Angeles, CA 90071Alternate: Christopher S. O'Shell

I 10/28/2008

HWO-AAA

Aaron D. Duff

PrincipalBristol-Myers Squibb Company1 Squibb Drive, Bldg. 102, Office 133New Brunswick, NJ 08903NFPA Industrial Fire Protection Section

U 8/2/2010HWO-AAA

Tolga Durak

PrincipalRadford UniversityEnvironmental Health & Safety501 Stockton StreetRadford, VA 24142

SE 1/10/2008

HWO-AAA

Thomas K. Furlong

PrincipalNuclear Service Organization1201 North Market Street, Suite 1100Wilmington, DE 19801Alternate: Andrew J. Brady

I 7/23/2008HWO-AAA

Satya Prakash Garg

PrincipalGAIL (India) LimitedCorporate HSE DepartmentCabin- 1830, 3rd Floor, PARC BuildingGTI, Sector- 16ANoida, 201301 India

E 10/10/1998

HWO-AAA

James R. Haiser, Jr.

PrincipalDow Corning Corporation225 West Wackerly RoadSanford, MI 48657

U 1/10/2008HWO-AAA

David W. Hollinger

PrincipalCity of Reading Department of Fire & Rescue Services815 Washington StreetReading, PA 19601

E 8/5/2009

1

Page 7: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Address List No PhoneHot Work Operations HWO-AAA

Derek Duval10/19/2012

HWO-AAA

Dennis R. Howard

PrincipalSafety Management, Inc.PO Box 2937St. Francisville, LA 70775

SE 7/12/2001HWO-AAA

Traci D. Huffman

PrincipalAllianz Risk Consulting, LLCPO Box 3331Iowa City, IA 52244-3331Alternate: DeAndrea D. Cooley

I 10/28/2008

HWO-AAA

Sergio Linan

PrincipalZurich Insurance CompanyViddrio Plano 908 OteMonterrey, NL 64520 MexicoAlternate: Robert D. Ziebarth

I 3/4/2009HWO-AAA

Richard T. Long, Jr.

PrincipalExponent, Inc.17000 Science Drive, Suite 200Bowie, MD 20715Alternate: Andrew Blum

SE 10/28/2008

HWO-AAA

August F. Manz

PrincipalA. F. Manz Associates470 Whitewood RoadUnion, NJ 07083American Welding SocietyAlternate: Stephen P. Hedrick

M 1/1/1981HWO-AAA

Robert B. Nicholson, III

PrincipalEastern Propane Corporation255 Oak Ridge RoadPO Box 285Oak Ridge, NJ 07438National Propane Gas Association

IM 7/24/1997

HWO-AAA

Michael F. O'Brien

PrincipalAuburn Manufacturing, Inc.PO Box 220Mechanic Falls, ME 04256

M 4/17/2002HWO-AAA

Lester W. Swanson

PrincipalArcelorMittal250 West US Highway 12Burns Harbor, IN 46304

U 8/9/2011

HWO-AAA

Alain Theriault

PrincipalPyrotech BEI Inc.1455 MichelinLaval, QC H7L 4S2 Canada

SE 10/20/2010HWO-AAA

Antony D. Tijerina

PrincipalTijerina Investigations, Inc.1541 Laurel River TrailLawrenceville, GA 30043

SE 7/24/1997

HWO-AAA

David A. Werba

PrincipalMiller Electric Manufacturing Company1635 West Spencer StreetAppleton, WI 54914National Electrical Manufacturers Association

M 7/29/2005HWO-AAA

Edward J. Willwerth

PrincipalMarine Chemist Association, Inc.41 George Hill RoadGrafton, MA 01519-1417

SE 1/16/2003

HWO-AAA

John Zimlich, Jr.

PrincipalBAE Systems163 Rochester DriveLouisville, KY 40214

U 03/05/2012HWO-AAA

Joseph M. Bloom

AlternateBloom Fire InvestigationPO Box 207Grants Pass, OR 97528Principal: Christopher J. Bloom

SE 4/1/1996

2

Page 8: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Address List No PhoneHot Work Operations HWO-AAA

Derek Duval10/19/2012

HWO-AAA

Andrew Blum

AlternateExponent, Inc.17000 Science Drive, Suite 200Bowie, MD 20715Principal: Richard T. Long, Jr.

SE 3/1/2011HWO-AAA

Andrew J. Brady

AlternateNuclear Service Organization1201 North Market Street, Suite 1100Wilmington, DE 19801Principal: Thomas K. Furlong

I 8/9/2011

HWO-AAA

DeAndrea D. Cooley

AlternateAllianz Risk Consulting, LLC21347 Kildare AvenueMatteson, IL 60443-2351Principal: Traci D. Huffman

I 10/27/2009HWO-AAA

Daniel M. Fritz

AlternateXL Insurance America, Inc.190 South LaSalle Street, Suite 950Chicago, IL 60603XL Global Asset Protection ServicesPrincipal: Richard S. Anderson

I 3/4/2008

HWO-AAA

Stephen P. Hedrick

AlternateAmerican Welding Society550 NW LeJeune RoadMiami, FL 33126American Welding SocietyPrincipal: August F. Manz

M 7/24/1997HWO-AAA

Christopher S. O'Shell

AlternateChubb Group of Insurance Companies2155 W. Pinnacle Peak Road, Suite 100Phoenix, AZ 85027Principal: Christopher Drobny

I 3/2/2010

HWO-AAA

Sergio Prete

AlternateFM Global270 Central AvenueJohnston, RI 02915Principal: Mark E. Blank

I 10/18/2011HWO-AAA

Robert D. Ziebarth

AlternateZurich Services Corporation5005 Rockside Road, Suite 200Independence, OH 44131Principal: Sergio Linan

I 10/27/2009

HWO-AAA

Derek Duval

Staff LiaisonNational Fire Protection Association1 Batterymarch ParkQuincy, MA 02169-7471

4/29/2011

3

Page 9: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

10/09/2012

Hot Work OperationsHWO-AAAName Representation Class Office

Distribution by %

Company

Richard M. Arvin National Institutes of Health E Principal

Satya Prakash Garg GAIL (India) Limited E Principal

David W. Hollinger City of Reading Department of Fire &Rescue Services

E Principal

3Voting Number Percent 11%

Mark E. Blank FM Global FM I Chair

Richard S. Anderson XL Global Asset Protection Services XLGAPS I Principal

Christopher Drobny Chubb Group of InsuranceCompanies

I Principal

Thomas K. Furlong Nuclear Service Organization I Principal

Traci D. Huffman Allianz Risk Consulting, LLC I Principal

Sergio Linan Zurich Insurance Company I Principal

6Voting Number Percent 22%

Robert B. Nicholson, III Eastern Propane Corporation NPGA IM Principal

1Voting Number Percent 4%

Daniel Driebel Road Sprinkler Fitters UA Local Union669

UA L Principal

1Voting Number Percent 4%

August F. Manz A. F. Manz Associates AWS M Principal

Michael F. O'Brien Auburn Manufacturing, Inc. M Principal

David A. Werba Miller Electric ManufacturingCompany

NEMA M Principal

3Voting Number Percent 11%

Scott R. Altemose Trefoil Training & TechnicalAssistance

SE Principal

Christopher J. Bloom CJB Fire Consultants SE Principal

Tolga Durak Radford University SE Principal

Dennis R. Howard Safety Management, Inc. SE Principal

Richard T. Long, Jr. Exponent, Inc. SE Principal

6

Page 10: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Tuesday 10 9, Tuesday

Hot Work OperationsHWO-AAAName Representation Class Office

Distribution by %

Company

Alain Theriault Pyrotech BEI Inc. SE Principal

Antony D. Tijerina Tijerina Investigations, Inc. SE Principal

Edward J. Willwerth Marine Chemist Association, Inc. MCA SE Principal

8Voting Number Percent 30%

Gregory R. Cameron Arizona Public Service Company U Principal

Aaron D. Duff Bristol-Myers Squibb Company NFPA/IFPS U Principal

James R. Haiser, Jr. Dow Corning Corporation U Principal

Lester W. Swanson ArcelorMittal U Principal

John Zimlich, Jr. BAE Systems U Principal

5Voting Number Percent 19%

27Total Voting Number

7

Page 11: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment C: HWO-AAA NFPA 51B ROP Minutes

Feb 2012

8

Page 12: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

 

TECHINICAL COMMITTEE ON HOT WORK OPERATIONS 

TO:   TECHNICAL COMMITTEE ON HOT WORK OPERATIONS 

FROM:  Derek Duval, Staff Liaison 

DATE:   February 16, 2012 

SUBJ: HWO‐AAA, NFPA 51B ROP Meeting Minutes (St. Louis, MO) 

 _________________________________________________________________________________ 

I. Attendance: 

 

Members and Alternates: 

Mark Blank, Committee Chair, FM Global, IL 

Richard Anderson, XL Global Asset Protective Services, CA 

Christopher Bloom, CJB Fire Consultants, OR (telephone) 

Christopher Drobny, Chubb Group of Insurance Companies, CA 

Aaron Duff, Bristol‐Myers Squibb Company, representing NFPA Industrial Fire Protection Section, NJ 

Thomas Furlong, Nuclear Service Organization, DE 

James Haiser, Dow Corning Corporation, MI (telephone) 

Traci Huffman, Allianz Risk Consulting, LLC, IA 

Richard Long, Exponent, MD (telephone) 

Michael O’Brien, Auburn Manufacturing, Inc., ME 

Lester Swanson, ArcelorMittal, IN 

Alain Theriault, Pyrotech BEI Inc., QC 

Antony Tijerina, Tijerina Investigations, Inc., GA 

David Werba, National Electrical Manufacturers, WI (telephone) 

Joseph Bloom, Bloom Fire Investigation, OR (telephone) Alternate to Christopher Bloom 

Andrew Brady, Nuclear Service Organization, DE Alternate to Thomas Furlong 

DeAndrea Cooley, Allianz Risk Consulting, LLC, IA Alternate to Traci Huffman 

Robert Ziebarth, Zurich Services Corporation, OH Alternate to Sergio Linan 

Derek Duval, NFPA, Staff Liaison 

 

Guests: 

Guy Colonna, NFPA, MA (telephone) 

 

 

II. Minutes of Meeting: 

 

1. The Chair opened the meeting at 8:00 a.m., February 16, 2012. 

9

Page 13: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO‐AAA, NFPA 51B ROP Meeting Minutes February 16, 2012 – page 2     

 

2. The Staff introduced the new Chair to the committee, Mark Blank. During the Chair’s opening remarks, the Chair asked the committee to consider “How can we, as in the committee, influence the awareness of the hot work hazards?”

3. Attendees introduced themselves and necessary corrections were made to the

Technical Committee roster.

4. The Staff reported on the current committee roster and member status, reviewed the general procedures, available resources from the Fire Research Foundation, and reviewed the milestones for the revision cycle for Annual 2013. Additionally, the Staff introduced the new standards development process that will be in effect for the next revision cycle. The Staff also informed the Committee of the forum that will be available at the NFPA Conference and Expo on June 12, 2012 in Las Vegas, NV.

5. The Committee reviewed and took actions on all Public Proposals (20) to NFPA

51B and developed three (3) committee proposal. The actions included addressing the proposal that was held from the last cycle (Annual 2008 ROC). Anthony Tijerina assumed Chair when the held proposal (Log#1a) was reviewed and acted on.

6. The Committee approved a motion directing the Staff to prepare and

distribute the NFPA 51B ROP letter ballot.

7. The Chair recognized Christopher Bloom to report on the Smoldering Task group. After discussion, the Committee agreed that there is still work to be done by the task group. The task group was reestablished and the new task group members include August Manz, Anthony Tijerina, Alain Theriault, Lester Swanson, and Chris Drobny.

8. The Committee discussed ways that the Committee could increase the

awareness about hot work safety:

i. Holding a Hot Work Symposium ii. Bring NFPA 51B into technical schools where hot work is taught iii. Working with the CSB to develop strategies on educating the users

about hot work safety iv. Requesting to change the document number of NFPA 51B

9. The Committee discussed the idea of reassigning the document number for

NFPA 51B. The Committee discussed that the hot work safety standard needs to separate itself from the other 51 numbered documents (NFPA 51 and 51A, both of which are the responsibility of another committee, IMG-AAA) and be its own independent document. The committee discussed that the “B” on the current numbering may cause users confusion that the document supports or is a part of the NFPA 51 document. The Staff will investigate further and report to the Committee.

10. The Committee discussed ways to increase the support and input from

enforcers. The committee currently only has two (2) Enforcers as members.

10

Page 14: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO‐AAA, NFPA 51B ROP Meeting Minutes February 16, 2012 – page 3     

i. The Staff asked the committee members to seek potential enforcers

that they work with that could be beneficial to the committee. ii. The Committee presented the idea of inviting the local fire services

(fire marshal, fire chief, code inspector, etc) to attend the next revision meetings as guests to encourage the involvement of enforcers in both the awareness of hot work safety and the NFPA process.

11. Next Meeting. The Committee’s next meeting will be the NFPA 51B ROC

meeting. The Committee proposed the next meeting to be on October 18 to 19, 2012 (subject to change) with the recommendations of the following locations; Las Vegas, Orlando, Quincy, or Los Angeles.

12. The Chair thanked everyone for their input. The Committee Meeting was

adjourned at 3:42 p.m., on Date February 16, 2012.

Respectfully submitted, Derek Duval, NFPA, Staff Liaison

11

Page 15: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment D: NFPA 51B Public Comment

12

Page 16: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

Report on Comments – June 2013 NFPA 51B_______________________________________________________________________________________________51B- Log #1 Final Action:(4.1.7)_______________________________________________________________________________________________Submitter: Kelly Nicolello, Western Regional Fire Code Development CommitteeComment on Proposal No: 51B-17Recommendation: Add the following to the annex.Elevated Locations where wind can carry hot embers beyond the view of the fire watch unless measures are taken.Substantiation: They stated it was addressed in 4.1.7 so we wish to add the text to the annex to make sure thiscondition is covered.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________51B- Log #2 Final Action:(7.4.3.1)_______________________________________________________________________________________________Submitter: Kelly Nicolello, Western Regional Fire Code Development CommitteeComment on Proposal No: 51B-21Recommendation: Add new text to read as follows:7.4.3.1 Permits. When required by the AHJ, permits shall be obtained from the local AHJ.Substantiation: In many jurisdictions local fire codes require the AHJ to issue permits for these types of operations. Byadding this reference, it makes the user find out if a permit is required by the local ahj preventing issues if work is donewithout the appropriate permit. Due to the hazards associated with this work and the potential of the jurisdiction torequire a permit, the mention of this necessary and prudent. The wording stated “when required by the AHJ” you needto get a permit. This should be known by the person performing hot work before starting work.

1Printed on 10/9/201213

Page 17: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment E: Designated Area Task Group Work

14

Page 18: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

August 30, 2012 Designated Area Task Group

Designated Area Task Group Recommendation: Proposed Requirements for Designated Area: 5.2.2.1 Designated Areas. 5.2.2.1.1 In order for a location to be a designated area, a risk assessment shall be performed. 5.2.2.1.2 The designated area shall meet the requirements in section 5.4.2. 5.2.2.1.3 The risk assessment for a designated area shall be reviewed at least annually. 5.2.2.1.4 Prior to the start of any hot work in a designated area, the hot work operator shall perform the following:

(a) The location is verified as fire safe. (b) Combustible materials are at least 35 ft from where hot work is being performed (c) Fire extinguishers are in working condition readily available (d) Ventilation is working properly (e) Equipment is in working order

Substantiation: There are limited requirements on designated areas in NFPA 51B. The industry identified the need for some general requirements regarding designated areas. The task group developed requirements for users and AHJs to better understand the use of designated areas for hot work and emphasize that these areas need to be fire safe just as permitted areas.

15

Page 19: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

HWO-AAA ROC Meeting Oct. 18 2012

Attachment F: Smoldering Task Group Work

16

Page 20: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

September 11, 2012

Derek;

The following note is in regard to the smoldering subgroup conference call on 8-23-2012.

Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that the smoldering subgroup was formed to explore the

logic behind the post hotwork monitoring period. The NFPA document (NFPA 51B, 5.5.2)

indicates that a ½ hour period is sufficient unless specified otherwise by the PAI.

Factory Mutual, in their Property Loss Prevention Data Sheet on Hot Work says that a one

hour period is sufficient but it is to be followed by an additional three hour period monitoring

period. The Factory Mutual rule seems to likely have some loss history to support it. But, as a

committee, it might be difficult to withstand challenges if we require this.

My thoughts:

It is difficult to come up with a hard and fast duration for a post hot work monitoring period. As

noted in the Factory Mutual data sheet 10-3, (section 3.2.3) there are examples of fires breaking

out long after hot work has ceased. The NFPA Fire Protection Handbook (20th

ed., section 9,

page 9-5) discusses how piles of wood particulate matter can smolder for extended periods of

time, and under the correct conditions can evolve into a fire.

It is my opinion that a 60 minute period is appropriate unless the PAI can justify a shorter period.

Also, an additional monitoring period is appropriate. This additional monitoring period would

not require the fire watcher to remain dedicated solely to the hot work site, it could take the form

of periodic visits (15 minute intervals to start with) to the hot work site. But, as a committee,

placing the additional burden on the PAI would likely prove to be unpopular, and would likely

be challenged.

For discussion purposes, I would like to submit the following:

Add section A5.2.2 to annex “A” explaining that the prescribed time period is a minimum

monitoring period, and should be extended if necessary.

The following was transcribed from the 51B document. The item labeled A5.5.2 is proposed.

4.2.7* Where a fire watch is not required, (see section 5.5) the PAI shall make a final check ½

hour after the completion of hot work operations to detect and extinguish smoldering fires.

A 4.2.7 The inspection is usually made ½ hour after the completion of hot work to detect and

extinguish possible smoldering fires. The inspector should be alert for circumstances that can

require an extension of the final inspection interval.

17

Page 21: Technical Committee on Hot Work Operations · 2.6 Final date for TCC meeting 4/13/12 2.7 Final date for mailing TCC ballots 4/20/12 2.8 Receipt of TCC ballots 5/11/12 2.9 Receipt

5.5.2* A fire watch shall be maintained for at least 1/2 1 hour after completion of hot work

operations in order to detect and extinguish smoldering fires. The duration of the fire watch shall

be extended if the PAI determines the fire hazards warrant the extension.

A 5.5.2 (Draft Item) It should be understood that the 1 hour time period is considered to be the

absolute minimum amount of observation time after the hot work is concluded. At the conclusion

of the 1 hour monitoring period, the affected area(s) should be inspected by the PAI (or their

designate) to assure that no smoldering fires exist. If deemed necessary by the PAI, (or their

designate) the observation time should be extended long enough to assure that there are no

smoldering fires related to the hot work procedure. The area should be inspected by the PAI (or

their designate) before the area is deemed safe to leave unmonitored. Les Swanson CFPS

18