TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear...

37
TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications “Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013) NanoBio Spectroscopy Group and ETSF Scientific Development Centre Dpto. Física de Materiales, Universidad del País Vasco, Centro Física de Materiales CSIC-UPV/EHU San Sebastián, Spain and FHI Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Berlin, Germany http://nano-bio.ehu.es E-mail: [email protected] Angel Rubio TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications

Transcript of TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear...

Page 1: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

NanoBio Spectroscopy Group and ETSF Scientific Development CentreDpto. Física de Materiales, Universidad del País Vasco,

Centro Física de Materiales CSIC-UPV/EHU San Sebastián, Spainand

FHI Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Berlin, Germany

http://nano-bio.ehu.es E-mail: [email protected]

Angel Rubio

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications

Page 2: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Introduction: TDDFT Four linked concepts:

* Molecular dissociation: bumps in Vxc * Electron many-body tunneling * Rabi Oscillations population analysis * Photochemistry...

Some illustrative applications (recent work)●Monitor excitations: Time and energy resolved spectroscopies●Correlations: H2 and Mott insulators (how do they look in TD-DFT)●Optimal control theory: High-harmonic generation

OUTLINE

Publications:

Quantum coherence controls the charge separation in a prototypical artificial light harvesting system, C. A. Rozzi, S. M. Falke, N. Spallanzani, AR, E. Molinari, D. Brida, M. Maiuri, G. Cerullo, H. Schramm, J. Christoffers, C. Lienau Nature Communications (2013)

Simulating pump-probe photo-electron and absorption spectroscopy on the attosecond time-scale with time-dependent density-functional theory, U. De Giovannini, G. Brunetto, A. Castro, J. Walkenhorst, A.R, Chemphyschem (2013)

Universal Dynamical Steps in the Exact Time-Dependent Exchange-Correlation Potential Peter Elliott, Johanna I. Fuks, Angel Rubio, Neepa T. Maitra, Physical Review Letters 109, 266404 (2012)

Fundamentals of Time-Resolved Charge-Transfer in Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory, Johanna I. Fuks, Peter Elliott, AR, Neepa T. Maitra Journal Of Physical Chemistry Letters (2013)

Page 3: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Beyond linear response: Real-time dynamics

E.g.

High-harmonic generation

Multiple-ionization

Photo-dissociation

Photo-isomerization

Enhanced ionization

Electronic quantum control

But how well do the TDDFT approximations work ?

Light-driven chiral molecular motors, Yamaki, Nakayama, Hoki,

Kono, Fujimura, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 11, 1649 (2009) Dye-Sensitized Solar Cell

Optimizing a single harmonic (in Ar)

Murnane & Kapteyn et al, Nature 2000

Page 4: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Theoretical framework: DFT&TDDFT

DFT (static- ground state)

The ground state energy of a many body system is a unique functional of the density i.e, can be inverted Hohenberg-Kohn (1964)

The functional has a minimum at the 'equilibrium' density

n(r )=n[Ψ]=⟨∑iδ(r−r i)⟩

Ψ(r 1,r 2,.... ,r N)=Ψ[n(r )] → E [Rions]=minn ⟨ΨHeΨ ⟩≡minnE [n]

DFT Success “~chemical accuracy”

Page 5: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Time Dependent Density Functional Theory (Runge and Gross 1984)

All observables are functionals of the TD density

i ℏ ddt=H i ℏ d

dti=H KS [ { j}]i , i=1,⋯N ?

H KS=ℏ2

2mi∇− e

cℏ AAxc

2

V externalV hartreeV exchangeV correlation

One-to-one correspondence between the time-dependent density and the external potential, v(r,t) <------> ρ(r,t)

Linear and non linear phenomena accessible

Octopus Code http://www.tddft.org

Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory, Lecture Notes in Physics, Springer Vols. 837, 706 (2012, 2006)

Page 6: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

…........................... and where we are?

Theoretical framework: DFT&TDDFT and MBPT

● Optical and magnetic responses, Dichroism, EELS, IXS, linear and nonlinear properties, ........

Solids, nanostructures, biomolecules,.......● Correlations ( “Mott insulators”, e.g. H-chain);

Open Question: develop accurate XC functionals

Page 7: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Some illustrative applications (recent work)

●Monitor excitations: Time and energy resolved spectroscopies

●Excite state dynamics for energy store/harvesting applicationsOrganic photovoltaics: triads “carotene-porphyrine-C

60”

●Optimal control theory: High-harmonic generation

Page 8: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Photoelectron spectroscopy: spatial and energy resolved

U. De Giovannini, D. Varsano, H. Appel, M. A. L. Marques,, E.K.U. Gross and and A. Rubio (2012)

Page 9: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Page 10: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Page 11: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Transient Absorption and Photoelectron Spectroscopies

Time resolved pump-probe spectroscopy

Image reconstruction and monitoring electron-ion dynamics in fnite and extended

systems

Page 12: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Ethylene: C2H

4 Transient Absorption Spectroscopy

Simulating pump-probe photo-electron and absorption spectroscopy on the attosecond time-scale with TDDFTU. De Giovannini, G. Brunetto, A. Castro, J. Walkenhorst, A.R, Chemphyschem (2013)

Page 13: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Simulating pump-probe photo-electron and absorption spectroscopy on the attosecond time-scale with TDDFTU. De Giovannini, G. Brunetto, A. Castro, J. Walkenhorst, A.R, Chemphyschem (2013)

Ethylene: C2H

4 Transient Photoelectron Spectroscopy

wpump

=0.291

wprobe

= 1.8

Page 14: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Simulating pump-probe photo-electron and absorption spectroscopy on the attosecond time-scale with TDDFTU. De Giovannini, G. Brunetto, A. Castro, J. Walkenhorst, A.R, Chemphyschem (2013)

Ethylene: C2H

4 Transient Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Page 15: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

TRPES for C2H

4

Simulating pump-probe photo-electron and absorption spectroscopy on the attosecond time-scale with time-dependent density-functional theory, U. De Giovannini, G. Brunetto, A. Castro, J. Walkenhorst, A.R, Chemphyschem (2013)

Page 16: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Problems with extended systems in finite fields?

●Absorption of ligh (matching solar spectra)“Level alignment”

●Exciton dynamics and splitting

●Transport at the interfaceExtracting charges

Efficiency

Page 17: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Macroscopic Polarisation Theory and real-time simulation

E⃗=−1c

d A⃗(t )d t

i ℏ ∂∂ t

ψi=[ 12m

( p⃗+ ec

A⃗)2

+ V ion+ V H+ V xc]ψi

14π

d 2 A⃗

dt2 =−e2 nm

A⃗−c eV ∑i

< ψi∣p⃗m∣ψi > =c2 jmac (t)=−c2 d P⃗ (t)

dt

G.F. Bertsch, J.I. Iwata, AR, K. Yabana, PRB62, 7998 (2000)

A(t) = Aext

(t) + Aind

(t) Emac

= 4 π P(t)

H= H + H

em P=polarisation

What is the link to the “modern theory of polarisation”? (see the recent review by Vanderbilt, Resta)

Page 18: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Macroscopic Polarisation Theory <-->real-time A(t)

Berry Phase

Page 19: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Simple test cases: Li, C, SiC, AlP

Page 20: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Fe-response function spin-polarised (and spinorial calculation, not shown)

Page 21: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Finding the exact time-dependent xc potential for a given known density-evolution

• In general, not easy. • But for 2 electrons, starting in a doubly-occupied orbital, it’s easy

(↑↓ -↓↑)/√2

Insert φ(x,t) into TDKS equation, and solve for :

Must have

Further, we have

so we can extract

Page 22: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Example 1: Field-free evolution of a non-stationary state He-atom

exact vcvc adia-ex

∂u/dt

Page 23: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Example 1: Field-free evolution of a non-stationary state He-atom

exact vcvc adia-ex

∂u/dt

Page 24: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Example 2: Time resolved Charge transfer CT-resonant excitation of two closed shell fragments

(2pi/T

R) = 0.00136 Ha

Page 25: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Example 2: Time resolved Charge transfer CT-resonant excitation of two closed shell fragments

(2pi/T

R) = 0.00136 Ha

Page 26: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Interrogating Molecules?

Science, Nov. 2008

Page 27: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Tailoring HHGHHG consists of the emission of integer multiples of the carrier frequency of a driving laser, due to its highly non-linear interaction with matter. It can be explained with the so-called 3-steps model:

Typically, the HH spectrum (emission intensity vs. photon frequency) consists of a rapid intensity decrease, a plateau, and a cut-off.

Page 28: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Quantum Optimal control theory (QOCT)

Key question: What is the laser pulse that drives the system intoa predefi ned goal?

Procedure: Defi ne a target operator Ô and at the end of thelaser interaction (t = T) maximize the functional

W. Zhu, J. Botina, H. Rabitz, JCP 108, 1953 (1998)

Ô = |Φ > <Φ |F F target state

Page 29: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Tailoring HHG (He atom)

…importance of exactly-solvable models……importance of exactly-solvable models…

Page 30: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Density-functional based-schemes are a powerful tool to “predictively” describe the combined dynamics of electron

and ions in response to external electromagnetic fields of large scale nanostructures, biological molecules and extended

systems spanning very different time scales

“A first principles time-dependent description of non-adiabatic couplings, decoherence and dissipation in many-body quantum

systems (solids, nanostructures, etc..) including quantum control of open quantum-systems is required”

Work to be done: “new spatial and w-dependent functionals”

Conclusions and Perspectives

Page 31: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Acknowledgements U.de Giovannini, A.Larsen, J.Fuks, A.Crawford, J.Walkenhorst, I.Tokatly, S.Kurth

ETSF , Dpto Material Physics, Centro Mixto CSIC-UPV, Donostia, Spain

E.K.U. Gross ; P. Elliot MPI-Halle U. Tampere, Finland

Esa Räsänen N. Maitra Hunter College NY Janne Solanpää

A. Castro BIFI, Zaragoza H. Appel FHI-Berlin

N. Helbig, Julich

Page 32: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

Acknowledgements U.de Giovannini, A.Larsen, J.Fuks, A.Crawford, J.Walkenhorst, I.Tokatly, S.Kurth

ETSF , Dpto Material Physics, Centro Mixto CSIC-UPV, Donostia, Spain

E.K.U. Gross ; P. Elliot MPI-Halle

Esa Räsänen N. Maitra Hunter College NY Janne Solanpää

A. Castro BIFI, Zaragoza H. Appel FHI-Berlin

N. Helbig, Julich

Page 33: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

It is one of the frst duties of a professor, for example, in any

subject, to exaggerate a little both the importance of his subject and

his own importance in it

G. H. Hardy (1940). A Mathematician's Apology.

Thank you!!!!

Page 34: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

H

2 Dimers

Let's increase complexity ??!!!!

Illustrate the problem of SIC and beyond from a different perspective

Page 35: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

The step in KS potential: open shell fragments

Early work of Perdew, Almbladh& von Barth, Gritsenko & Baerends Recent work of Tempel, Martinez, Maitra, JCTC (2009) and N. Helbig, I. Tokatly, A. Rubio, JCP (2009)

●Step aligns the atomic HOMOs ●Kohn-Sham system builds a ”wall“ to mimick the repulsion due to interaction and prevent tunneling

Prevents dissociation to unphysical fractional charges●Step-height = difference between highest eigenvalues of the two wells

Step in exact KS potential that exactly realigns the two atomic HOMOs: Step ∆ = |ID – IA|

Page 36: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

H2

Diference between the KS-efective potential and the external (ionic) one

Page 37: TDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and ... · PDF fileTDDFT€for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications ... solids and nanostructures:

TDDFT for non linear phenomena in solids and nanostructures: fundamentals and applications“Electronic structure calculations with GPAW”, CAMD-DTU, Denmark (22-May 2013)

VK

S- V

ion

ic H-chain Mott insulator : in DFT !!!

Clearly all local functionals and most orbital dependent functionals do not capture the step in the potential

The KS systems is metallic : fxc responsible for the gap