TCCC MeetingTCCC Meeting@GC 2005@GC 2005

St. Louis, USANov 30, 2005

AgendaAgenda

• Welcome• Conferences: Announcements, Reports, Co-

sponsorship

• Report from Technical Activities Council meeting

• Change in ICC/Globecom• Elections

• Nomination Process• Motion on Elimination of Conference Coordinator

Joe Evans, NSF: Update on NeTS/FIND program

TCCC distinguished service awardTCCC distinguished service award

• Goal: Recognize individuals with outstanding service contributions to the TCCC community

• Mark Karol has chaired awards committee:– Committee made awards for 2004 and 2005:

• 2004: John Daigle, John Silvester• 2005: Henning Schulzrinne, Jim Kurose

• Proposed procedure:– TCCC chair appoints chair of awards committee– Awards committee makes open call for

nominations and makes selection– Award is announced at Infocom opening

session

Recent endorsement of ComSoc co-Recent endorsement of ComSoc co-sponsorshipsponsorship

• Qshine 2006• ICCCN 2006• WINET• IWCMC2006• WiOpt (not granted)• IWQOS 2006.

Co-sponsorship of ICC/Globecom Co-sponsorship of ICC/Globecom symposiasymposia

• ICC 2006: "Network Security and Information AssuranChair: Bulent Yener (RPI)Co-Chair: Refik Molva (EUROCOM)

• Globecom 2006: "Control and Management of High Performance Networks"Chair: Ibrahim Habib (CUNY)Vice-Chairs: TBD

• ICC 2007: “Network Services and Operation Symposium”Co-Chairs: Burkhard Stiller, ETH Zurich, Switzerland Marcus Brunner, NEC Europe Ltdjointly with: Communications Switching & Routing TC, TCCC, Internet TC.

Update on Main ComSoc ConferencesUpdate on Main ComSoc Conferences

Infocom(March/April)

ICC (May/June)

Globecom(Nov./Dec.)

2005 Miami Seoul St. Louis

2006 Barcelona Istanbul San Francisco

2007 Anchorage Glasgow Washington, DC

2008 Phoenix Beijing New Orleans

2009 TBD Dresden Hawaii

Reports from conferencesReports from conferences

• CCW 2005, Chair: Magda El Zarki– October 23-26, 2004 at the Hilton Hotel,

Huntington Beach, CA. – Workshop chair was Prof. Magda El Zarki

(University of California, Irvine).

• Feedback received from workshop: – CCW is not fully recovered from the

interruption in CCW 2003– Extra effort is needed to re-create an informal

forum of discussion for broad range of topics

CCW 2006 Proposal by Ty Znati CCW 2006 Proposal by Ty Znati (UPitt)(UPitt)

• Formation of an advisory board to help with CCW logistics

• Articulate well-defined themes with potentially well-focused sub-themes within each theme

• Selected key note presentations about the selected themes (as opposed to sessions with "very narrowly focused" presentations of research results.)

• Moderated round table discussion, as opposed to classical panels

• CD of presentations will be distributed to the attendees.

Motion: Task Ty Znati with organization of CCW 2006.

Update from today’s TAC meeting Update from today’s TAC meeting (TAC = Technical Activities Council)(TAC = Technical Activities Council)

• IEEE Fellow Program in 2005: – 75 nominations in ComSoc 20 elevated to

• Recertification process of TCs in 2006– Reorganization of Technical committees

• Incoming Vice-President for Technical Activities: Sergio Benedetto (Politecnico di Torino)

Technical Activities CouncilTechnical Activities Council

• Fellow nominations from TCs needed each year: – Now is the time– Process starts February and March– ComSoc committee ranks them

• Awards Nominations are solicited: – Many awards on ComSoC websites– Nomination forms available from web

Reorganization of TCsReorganization of TCs

• Reorganization discussed by a committee Vice-President for technical activities. – Organize technical committees (TCs) into

groups/sectors– Better coordination of ICC/Globecom

Symposia– Better coordination with M&C board about

co-sponosrship

Issues with ICC and GlobecomIssues with ICC and Globecom

• From the perspective of the TCCC, the organization of symposia at ICC and Globecom is less than satisfactory:– Procedures change from year to year

• GC 2006: only one symposium can be proposed by one TC• GC 2005: Program co-chairs are added without

consultation of people proposing the workshops

• Current status of ICC and Globecom: – Quality of symposia is highly variable– Many technical sessions of symposia are poorly

attended – Many TCCC members no longer attend ICC/Globecom

(This is bad since almost all ComSoc business meetings are at ICC and Globecom)

From TCCC Infocom 05 meeting

Change of Organization of Globecom and Change of Organization of Globecom and ICCICC

• In May 2005, ComSoc President (Curtis Siller) tasked an ad-hoc committee to make recommendations on re-organizing ICC and Globecom– Committee chaired by R. de Marca– TCCC chair served on the committee

• Recommendations:– Separate technical and organizational

planning of these conferences– Replace the steering committee of ICC and

Globecom (GICC) by two committees: GIMS and GITC

Change of Organization of Globecom and Change of Organization of Globecom and ICCICC

1. GIMS: – Committee responsible for strategy and

organization – Appoints / approves General Chair

2. GITC:– Oversee and provide guidance to the

conference Technical Program Committees – Appoints / approves Technical Program

Chair

• Committees active since Fall 2005:– GITC Chair: Heiner Stuttgen– GIMS Chair: Mike Kincaid

TCCC Elections for 2006/7TCCC Elections for 2006/7

• Nominations Committee:Dinesh Verma (IBM) Chuck Kalmanek (AT&T Research)

• Call for nominations have been posted on Nov. 4• Nominations can made by email to:

tccc.election@ gmail.com• Nominations until Dec. 2, 5pm.

Conference CoordinatorConference Coordinator

• In the past the conference coordinator was responsible for organizing the review process for TCCC assigned sessions at Globecom and ICC.

• Since several years, ICC/Globecom no longer assign sessions to the TCs. Instead, the conferences are organized as symposia, with separate review committees.

• Other TCs who had a conference coordinator (e.g., Internet TC) have eliminated this office. Currently, TCCC is the only technical committee (of about 30) that still has this office.

• Motion: Let the office of the Conference Coordinator expire as an elected office.

Other businessOther business

• Comments, questions, suggestions ….

• Next TCCC meeting at Infocom 2006 in Barcelona.

Other businessOther business

• Comments, questions, suggestions ….

• Next TCCC meeting at Infocom 2006 in Barcelona.

OfficesOffices

(1) Chair The Chair sets overall direction and policy, in consultation with other officers and the TCCC membership, coordinates the activities of other TCCC Officers, chairs the TCCC meetings, represents the committee in the ComSoc Technical Advisory Committee (TAC), and initiates elections for vacant officer positions. The chair, in consultation with the other officers, also approves or denies requests for TCCC to technically co-sponsor conferences and workshops.

(2) Vice Chair The Vice Chair fulfills the duties of the Chair in his or her absence.

(3) Secretary The Secretary maintains the TCCC web page and mailing list(s), deals with questions regarding mailing list postings and web page, arranges for meeting facilities for TCCC meetings, announces these meetings to the TCCC membership, compiles minutes of the meetings, and participates in the discussions of the TCCC Officers.

(4) Conference Coordinator The Conference Coordinator solicits reviewers and participation for suitable IEEE Communications Society events. NOTE: There will be a motion held at the TCCC meeting at Globecom 2005 to eliminate the conference coordinator as an elected office (please see related emails for the rationale). Depending on the outcome of the vote, the ballot may or may not include the conference coordinator.

Eligibility RequirementsEligibility Requirements

• Any member of the TCCC can nominate candidates, including himself or herself. At the time of election, candidates must be members of the IEEE Communications Society, IEEE Communications Society Affiliate or IEEE Communications Society Sister Society. Candidates nominated must agree to serve before being put on a ballot. A candidate may run for more than one office. If a candidate is elected for Chair, he or she is removed from consideration for all other offices. Similarly, if a candidate is elected for Vice Chair, he or she is removed from consideration for Secretary or Conference Coordinator. If a candidate is elected for Secretary, he or she is removed from consideration for Conference Coordinator. Votes for candidates removed from consideration for a particular position are discarded.

ProcedureProcedure

• All nominations must be made via email to the address of tccc.election at gmail.com. The nomination must include – (a) the name of the candidate – (b) the email of the candidate and – (c) the position that the nomination is for.

• All nominations must be received at the above address at or before 5:00 PM Eastern Time on Friday, December 2, 2005.

Elections ProcedureElections Procedure

Runoff voting (http://www.fairvote.org/irv/faq.htm.)– For each position, all TCCC members will rank candidates

in their order of preference, 1, 2, 3, etc. It takes a majority to win.

– If anyone receives a majority of the first choice votes, that candidate is elected.

– If not, the last place candidate is defeated, just as in a runoff election, and all ballots are counted again, but this time each ballot cast for the defeated candidate counts for the next choice candidate listed on the ballot.

– The process of eliminating the last place candidate and recounting the ballots continues until one candidate receives a majority of the vote.

– If the above procedure results in a tie, ties will be resolved by having each tieing candidate be assigned a number between 0 and the number of ties minus one. The candidate number that matches the appropriate module of the Dow Jones Industrial Average for a future date wins.