Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets:...

56
Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July 13, 2016 Speakers: Paul Emrath, Greg Willett, and Jamie Woodwell

Transcript of Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets:...

Page 1: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily

Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk

July 13, 2016

Speakers: Paul Emrath, Greg Willett, and Jamie Woodwell

Page 2: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Tale of Two Markets A. Single-Family Construction Urban Institute Data Talk Series July 13, 2016

Paul Emrath Vice President of Survey and Housing Policy Research National Association of Home Builders

Page 3: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Outline

• Housing starts / NAHB’s latest forecast

• Supply constraints / costs inhibiting single-family production

• Role of government regulation

• Supply vs. demand for housing in different price ranges

3

Page 4: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Total Housing Starts Since World War II (in thousands)

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,800

2,000

2,200

2,40019

4619

4819

5019

5219

5419

5619

5819

6019

6219

6419

6619

6819

7019

7219

7419

7619

7819

8019

8219

8419

8619

8819

9019

9219

9419

9619

9820

0020

0220

0420

0620

0820

1020

1220

14

Worst Pre-2008 Recession

Annual Starts

4

Page 5: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,800

2,000

00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

Thousands of units, SAAR

80% fall

Single-Family Housing Starts Rising, but still well below normal

Trough to Current: Mar 09 = 353,000

May 16 = 764,000 +116%

2016Q1: 59% of

“Normal”

2018Q4: 81% of

“Normal”

2000-2003 1,343,000 “Normal” 2013 620,000 2014 647,000 4% 2015 713,000 10% 2016 794,000 11% 2017 916,000 15% 2018 1,042,000 14%

5

Page 6: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

550

00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18

Thousands of units, SAAR

76% fall

2018Q4: 110% of “Normal”

Avg=344,000

1995-2003 331,000 “Normal” 2013 308,000 2014 355,000 15% 2015 395,000 12% 2016 376,000 -5% 2017 383,000 2% 2018 368,000 -4%

Multifamily Housing Starts Back to normal

Trough to Current: 4th Q 09 = 82,000 1st Q 16 = 361,000 +340%

2016Q1: 107% of “Normal”

6

Page 7: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Regulation: Difficult to get development approved in some jurisdictions

Fees, restrictions, etc. drive up costs

Why Hasn’t Single-family Production Recovered Further and Faster?

Supply bottlenecks: Availability and price of lots / labor

Especially in key locations / with key skills

7

Page 8: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Share of Builders Reporting Labor Shortages Highest Since 2000 Economy was very strong consistently in the late 1990s Current shortage especially severe relative to housing starts

8

Page 9: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Recent Shortages Worse for Subcontractors than for Labor Directly Employed by Single-family Builders

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Sep.'96

Sep.'97

Dec.'98

Feb.'00

Jul.'00

Nov.'00

Apr.'02

Dec.'03

Jul.'04

Oct.'04

Jul.'05

Oct.'05

Nov.'05

May'06

Jun.'12

Mar. ‘13

Jun. ‘14

Jun. ‘15

Jun. ‘16

Builders Reporting Serious to Some Shortage: Average Percentage for 9 trades

LaborSubcontractors

9

Page 10: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Share of Builders Reporting Lot Shortages: Higher than Ever 10

Page 11: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Lot Prices Also Higher than Ever (even though new-home lots are smaller than ever)

NAHB tabulation of data from the Survey of Construction, U.S. Census Bureau and HUD

11

Page 12: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Labor/Lot Shortages: Sources http://eyeonhousing.org/2016/06/more-builders-report-laborsubcontractor-shortages/

http://eyeonhousing.org/2016/05/shortage-of-lots-now-worse-than-ever/

12

Page 13: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

NAHB Article Published on May 2, 2016: http://www.nahbclassic.org/generic.aspx?sectionID=734&genericContentID=250611&channelID=311

13

Page 14: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Challenges: Have to go to builders; only they have the information

But their accounting systems aren’t designed to capture regulatory costs

Government Regulation in the Price of a New Home

Purpose: Not to argue that all regulation is bad, but to

show how much we already have; question if regulators are adequately considering costs

14

Page 15: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Special Questions on the March 2016 Survey for the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI)

15

Page 16: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

HMI Survey Results Need to Be Combined With Other Data • 1.0 point charged for all land acquisition, development, and construction (AD&C)

loans, based on results from a Quarterly Finance Survey (QFS) that NAHB was conducting in the early 2000s.

• A 7.65 percent interest rate on all AD&C loans. The QFS indicates that rates are e typically set one point above prime, and 6.65 percent is NAHB’s estimate of the prime rate that would prevail in the long run under neutral Federal Reserve policy.

• A 9.6 percent gross profit rate for builders and developers, based on the average rate on NAHB Construction Cost surveys conducted between 2002 and 2015. In the long run, without a competitive return on investment, builders and developers will leave the industry, lots will not be developed, and homes will not be built.

• A broker’s fee of 2.9 percent, based on the “nonconstruction” cost factor the Census Bureau applies to single-family homes built for sale (http://www.census.gov/const/C30/methodology.pdf). In housing markets, broker’s fees are typically set as a fraction of the home’s purchase price.

• Raw land that accounts for 10.6 percent of the price of a home built for sale (Census nonconstruction cost factor).

• A finished lot that accounts for 21.8 percent of the house price (1995-2015 NAHB Construction Cost Survey average).

• Construction costs that account for 56.0 percent of the house price (1995-2015 NAHB Construction Cost Survey average).

etc… (see article for complete details)

16

Page 17: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Government Regulation in the Price of a New Home 17

Page 18: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Government Regulation in the Price of a New Home 18

Page 19: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

7.9%

14.6% 18.8% 4.0%

9.7%

12.7%

Lower Quartile Average Upper Quartile

Regulation as a Share of the Final Price of a Single-family Detached Home Built for Sale

During Construction

During Development

* For quartiles, construction and development costs do not sum to the total.

14.0%*

30.3%*

24.3%

Government Regulation in the Price of a New Home 19

Page 20: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Change in Average Regulatory Costs 25.0% of House Price in 2011; 24.3% in 2016 What if applied to average new home prices?

29.8% increase

20

Page 21: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

How Does the 29.8% Increase in Average Regulatory Cost Compare to Other Changes 2011-2016?

Rising more than twice as fast as

average American’s ability to pay for it

21

Page 22: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Regulation: Imposed by All Levels of Government Federal, State, Local

Can be difficult to tease out which is responsible

Constitution generally leaves land use decision to states

States usually delegate zoning/permitting authority to local jurisdictions

Traditionally, local governments also adopt and enforce building codes

However, there has been a trend toward more codes being adopted and effective statewide

Federal government is becoming more involved

22

Page 23: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Regulation: Examples of Federal Involvement National Permits for Residential Development

Under the 1987 expansion of the Clean Water Act, most construction sites require a permit due to potential for stormwater runoff

Stormwater permits are issued by EPA, or by states under programs authorized and monitored by EPA

Many development projects also require wetlands permits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Building Codes / Resilience April 2016: DOE, FEMA, EPA propose and lobby for changes in the model

International Residential Code (DOE also has a budget to help persuade states to adopt more recent & stringent codes)

May 2016: White House Conference on Resilient Building Codes May 2016: HUD Office of CPD proposed rule to Modernize the

Consolidated Planning Process and Increase Resilience HUD also has an Office of Economic Resilience

23

Page 24: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Consider… Prices of new homes started in 2015

(Survey of Construction, U.S. Census Bureau & HUD)

Effect of Regulatory and Other Cost Increases

Can make it difficult to build homes Americans can afford Especially at the low end of the market

vs. Prices home buyers expect to pay

(NAHB 2015 survey of recent and prospective home buyers)

24

Page 25: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Eye on Housing Blog Post: June 6, 2016 http://eyeonhousing.org/2016/06/new-house-price-data-show-why-costs-are-a-problem/

6%

29%

28%

21%

15%

1%

15%

16%

28%

18%

13%

8%

2%

Less than $100,000

$100,000 - $149,999

$150,000 - $249,999

$250,000 - $349,999

$350,000 - $499,999

$500,000 - $999,999

$1 million and over

Price of Single-family Homes Started in 2015 vs. Price Buyers Expect to Pay

Price of SF Homes StartedWhat Buyers Expect to Pay

Medians Expect to Pay: $219,896 2015 SF Starts: $298,800

Sources: NAHB tabulation of data from the Survey of Construction, U.S. Census Bureau and HUD 2015 Home Buyer Preference Survey, NAHB

25

Page 26: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Contact Paul Emrath

VP-Survey and Housing Policy Research NAHB Economics and Housing Policy Group

1-800-368-5242 x8449 [email protected]

26

Page 27: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Thank You

Page 28: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Urban Institute Data Talk Series July 13, 2016

Greg Willett

Chief Economist RealPage, Inc.

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Multifamily Construction: How Much Is Too Much?

28

Page 29: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Demand for apartments came roaring back in early 2010, with absorption totaling 1.6m units seen since then

262k

-300k

-200k

-100k

k

100k

200k

300k

400k

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

annual demand

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 30: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Tailwinds that support apartment demand are largely solid

The housing demand generated by job additions is disproportionately going to rental units, including apartments, for

both lifestyle and financial reasons.

Demographics say the cycle of strong demand has long legs, assuming

overall economic growth is sustained. Former homeowners “displaced” by the for-sale

bust mainly ended up in single-family rentals, rather

than apartments. But, current apartment renters are proving slow to opt for

purchase.

Page 31: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

More than six years into the cycle, completions are now beginning to catch up with demand

262k

-300k

-200k

-100k

k

100k

200k

300k

400k

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

annual completions

annual demand

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

247k

Page 32: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

U.S. apartment occupancy has been essentially full for quite some time, and is still near record levels

96.2%

85%

90%

95%

100%

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

overall occupancy

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 33: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Rent growth remains robust, especially since we’re deep into this economic/market performance cycle

4.6%

-6%

-4%

-2%

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

12%

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

year-over-year change in same-store effective rents for new leases

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage

19 quarters averaging 2.8% 24 quarters averaging 3.8%

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 34: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Ongoing construction nearly doubles the long-term norm and well exceeds the last cycle’s peak

537k

0k

100k

200k

300k

400k

500k

600k

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage, minus New York

Page 35: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Starts likely have peaked, but the crest in deliveries is continually being pushed out by construction delays

537k

0k

100k

200k

300k

400k

500k

600k

1Q00

3Q00

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

U.S. data is based on the 100 metros that form the core of MPF Research’s coverage, minus New York

Early 2016 did bring the first real signal of a slowdown in starts

Page 36: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Here are some spots where 2016 completions should top the 2015 volume in a big way

Scheduled 2016 Deliveries 2015 Deliveries Difference

San Francisco, CA 7,320 1,598 +358%

Greenville, SC 2,440 578 +322%

Charleston, SC 3,694 958 +286%

Los Angeles, CA 13,237 5,177 +156%

Miami, FL 6,313 2,531 +149%

Nashville, TN 8,121 4,002 +103%

Baltimore, MD 4,014 2,024 +98%

San Jose, CA 6,327 3,261 +94%

Washington, DC 13,735 7,987 +72%

Philadelphia, PA 5,437 3,172 +71%

Tampa, FL 5,455 3,188 +71%

Phoenix, AZ 9,832 6,243 +57%

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 37: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

On the other hand, the surge in completions won’t register in a handful of locales

Scheduled 2016 Deliveries 2015 Deliveries Difference

Jacksonville, FL 1,143 2,147 -47%

Minneapolis-St. Paul, MN 2,517 4,614 -45%

Las Vegas, NV 1,822 2,188 -17%

Boston, MA 5,810 6,677 -13%

Fort Lauderdale, FL 2,651 2,884 -8%

San Diego, CA 2,609 2,810 -7%

Columbus, OH 2,985 2,921 +2%

Atlanta, GA 9,800 9,076 +8%

Fort Worth, TX 3,397 3,066 +11%

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 38: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Most of today’s biggest construction centers still have top-tier markets in strong shape

Will Units on the Way Damage Rent Growth Anywhere?

Units Under Construction

Inventory Growth Rate

3-Year Class A Rent Growth Average

Current Class A Rent Growth

Nashville, TN 12,113 9.4% 4.6% 5.3%

Dallas, TX 43,859 8.3% 4.5% 5.3%

Austin, TX 16,977 7.7% 3.4% 2.8%

Charlotte, NC 11,976 7.6% 4.8% 4.6%

Denver-Boulder, CO 19,001 6.4% 6.3% 3.9%

Houston, TX 38,630 6.1% 3.1% -0.8%

Salt Lake City, UT 6,820 5.7% 4.8% 6.5%

San Jose, CA 8,576 5.3% 9.4% 4.7%

Raleigh-Durham, NC 7,649 5.2% 2.7% 3.4%

West Palm Beach, FL 5,738 5.1% 5.8% 6.9%

Building volumes clearly have played a part in slowed rent growth in Washington, DC. But that metro now is off the list of the most active construction centers.

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Page 39: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

The urban versus suburban story is a significant element in construction’s potential impact on

market fundamentals.

Urban core submarkets are experiencing annual inventory growth near 5%, on average, more than twice inventory growth that’s running around the

2% mark on average in the suburbs.

© 2016 RealPage Inc. 39

Page 40: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

Will affordability constraints dampen the ability to push rents and, thus, rein in construction activity?

© 2016 RealPage Inc. 40

Page 41: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

$40,000

$45,000

$50,000

$55,000

$60,000

21%

22%

23%

24%

25%

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

U.S. Median Rent-to-Income (left)U.S. Median Income (right)

Upgrades in resident quality generally are leaving rent-to-income ratios steady so far in this economic cycle

Figures reflect actual lease transaction information for new residents in properties where RealPage technology solutions are in use

Page 42: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

$20,000

$30,000

$40,000

$50,000

$60,000

$70,000

$80,000

20%

22%

24%

26%

28%

30%

32%

A+ A A- B+ B B- C+ C C- D

Median Rent-to-Income (left)Median Income (right)

Figures reflect actual lease transaction information for new residents in properties where RealPage technology solutions are in use

Rent-to-income ratios look very manageable in top-end and middle-tier market-rate properties

Page 43: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

1Q01

3Q01

1Q02

3Q02

1Q03

3Q03

1Q04

3Q04

1Q05

3Q05

1Q06

3Q06

1Q07

3Q07

1Q08

3Q08

1Q09

3Q09

1Q10

3Q10

1Q11

3Q11

1Q12

3Q12

1Q13

3Q13

1Q14

3Q14

1Q15

3Q15

1Q16

Class A rent premium over Class B

Class B rent premium over Class C

Growing space in pricing power between product niches could have implications for what’s next

Page 44: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

With additional transparency into the market, are we smarter and/or more disciplined than we’ve

been in past cycles?

© 2016 RealPage Inc. 44

Page 45: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

© 2016 RealPage Inc.

Thanks! MPF Research, a division of RealPage, Inc.

www.mpfresearch.com www.realpage.com

[email protected]

45

Page 46: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

46

Housing Development in the Post-crisis World

July 2016

Jamie Woodwell

Vice President, Research & Economics

Mortgage Bankers Association

Page 47: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

47

Multifamily Market Conditions

Source: Census

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

(1,000)

(500)

0

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,50019

70

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

2005

2010

2015

2020

2025

Change in Population Age 16 - 29 (1000s, Left)Units Under Construction (1000s, Right)

Page 48: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

48

Changes in Population Age 25-44 and Single Family Starts

Source: Census

-1000

-500

0

500

1000

1500

2000

70 72 74 76 78 80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 14

Chng in Pop 25-34 Chng in Pop 35-44 Housing Starts: Thous.Units

Page 49: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

49

With lack of overbuilding and shifts in demand, rental/multifamily market has tightened faster than single-family/ownership

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

0 .0

0 .5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

Vacancy rates for sing le-family ow nership ( left ) and mult ifamily rental ( right ) housing

Hom eow ner vacancy rat e -- 1-unit buildings ( lef t)

Renter vacancy rate - - 5+ unit build ings ( right)

Page 50: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

50

Multifamily apartment property prices have risen much more quickly than single-family home prices

Sources: Case Shiller, Moody’s/Real Capital Analytics and REIS

0

50

10 0

150

20 0

250

300

350

1976

- J

an19

77 -

Jan

1978

- J

an19

79 -

Jan

1980

- J

an19

81 -

Jan

1982

- J

an19

83 -

Jan

1984

- J

an19

85 -

Jan

1986

- J

an19

87 -

Jan

1988

- J

an19

89 -

Jan

1990

- J

an19

91 -

Jan

1992

- J

an19

93 -

Jan

1994

- J

an19

95 -

Jan

1996

- J

an19

97 -

Jan

1998

- J

an19

99 -

Jan

200

0 -

Jan

200

1 - J

an20

02

- Ja

n20

03

- Ja

n20

04

- J

an20

05

- Ja

n20

06

- Ja

n20

07

- Ja

n20

08

- Ja

n20

09

- Ja

n20

10 -

Jan

2011

- Ja

n20

12 -

Jan

2013

- J

an20

14 -

Jan

2015

- J

an20

16 -

Jan

Indexed values of U.S. nat ional home prices and rent s (Jan 1998 = 10 0 ) and of apartment build ing prices (Dec

20 0 0 = 115) and rent s

Hom e pr ices A partment Pr ices

Page 51: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

51

Developers have responded to market conditions, with strong multifamily development and slower single-family

Source: Census

0

20 0

400

60 0

800

10 00

1200

1970 -Jan

1975 - Jan 1980 -Jan

1985 -Jan

1990 -Jan

1995 -Jan

20 00 -Jan

20 05 -Jan

20 10 -Jan

20 15 -Jan

Number of units under const ruct ion in 1-unit and 5+-unit build ings

Sing le-family units Mult ifamily units

Page 52: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

52

Some regions are not building new housing to the degree one would expect – 2+unit Construction Starts (1,000s) and Rental Vacancy Rate

Source: Census

West

South

Midwest

Northeast

0

5

10

15

0

20

40

60

80

0

5

10

15

0

20

40

60

80

1985

- Q

119

87 -

Q1

1989

- Q

119

91 -

Q1

1993

- Q

119

95 -

Q1

1997

- Q

119

99 -

Q1

200

1 - Q

120

03

- Q

120

05

- Q

120

07

- Q

120

09

- Q

120

11 -

Q1

2013

- Q

120

15 -

Q1

St art s 2+Unit s (left )

Rental Vacancy Rat e (r ight )

0

5

10

15

0

10

20

30

40

0

5

10

15

0

10

20

30

40

1985

- Q

119

87 -

Q1

1989

- Q

119

91 -

Q1

1993

- Q

119

95 -

Q1

1997

- Q

119

99 -

Q1

200

1 - Q

120

03

- Q

120

05

- Q

120

07

- Q

120

09

- Q

120

11 -

Q1

2013

- Q

120

15 -

Q1

St art s 2+Unit s (left )

Rental Vacancy Rat e (r ight )

Page 53: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

53

Some regions are not building new housing to the degree one would expect -- 1-unit Construction Starts (1,000s) and Homeowner Vacancy Rate

Source: Census

West

South

Midwest

Northeast

0

1

2

3

4

0

50

10 0

150

0

1

2

3

4

0

50

10 0

150

20 0

250

1985

- Q

119

87 -

Q1

1989

- Q

119

91 -

Q1

1993

- Q

119

95 -

Q1

1997

- Q

119

99 -

Q1

200

1 - Q

120

03

- Q

120

05

- Q

120

07

- Q

120

09

- Q

120

11 -

Q1

2013

- Q

120

15 -

Q1

St art s - - 1-unit s (lef t )

Hom eow ner Vacancy Rat e ( right )

0

1

2

3

4

0

20

40

60

80

10 0

0

1

2

3

4

01020304050607080

1985

- Q

119

87 -

Q1

1989

- Q

119

91 -

Q1

1993

- Q

119

95 -

Q1

1997

- Q

119

99 -

Q1

200

1 - Q

120

03

- Q

120

05

- Q

120

07

- Q

120

09

- Q

120

11 -

Q1

2013

- Q

120

15 -

Q1

St art s - - 1-unit s (lef t )

Hom eow ner Vacancy Rat e ( right )

Page 54: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

54

For a variety of reasons, single-family (and multifamily) construction costs more than it otherwise could

• Lots • Locations • Labor • Materials • Regulation

Source: MBA, NAHB and Wall Street Journal

Source: NAHB

Page 55: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

55

Much of the single-family construction infrastructure “blew-up” during the recession and it is unclear how it will be rebuilt

• Land aggregators, permitters, pre-developers • Developers • Labor • ADC lending • Move-up equity • Mortgage availability

Source: MBA, FDIC and Census * Based on 184 repeat MSAs in County Business Patterns

Construction Loans as a Percent of Assets at FDIC Insured Institutions by asset size of institution

2000 Q4 2005 Q4 2016 Q1 2000 Q4 2005 Q4 2016 Q1>$100 billion 0.9% 1.7% 0.9% 31% 44% 65%$10 - $100 billion 2.8% 3.9% 2.0% 36% 30% 17%$1 - $10 billion 3.9% 8.2% 4.5% 16% 13% 11%$100 million - $1 billion 4.4% 9.3% 4.6% 14% 11% 7%<$100 million 3.0% 4.8% 2.3% 4% 2% 1%

Share of Total AssetsConstruction Loans as % of Assets

10

12

14

0

50

10 0

20 06 20 14

General Cont ractors*

Employees (millions, lef t )# Estab lishments (1,00 0s, right )

0

5

10

0

50

10 0

20 06 20 14

Merchant Builders*

Employees (millions, lef t )# Estab lishments (1,00 0s, right )

Page 56: Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily …...2016/07/13  · Tale of Two Markets: Single-Family vs. Multifamily Construction Housing Finance Policy Center Data Talk July

56

Potential for record housing demand over next decade

Source: Census and MBA

+12.9 million

- 2.1 million

+5.1 million

+5.7 million +5.0 million +2.4 million +1.9 million +890k

+15.9 million

-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4

18-24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-70 70-75 75-80 80+

Mill

ions

Projected Changes in Households, by Age 2014-2024

Non-Hisp. White Black Asian Other Hispanic

Using ForecastedHeadship Rates