TAITZ v FUDDY (HI Cir. Ct.) - Certified Transcript - Hearing Held Nov. 30 2011 - tfb

8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY (HI Cir. Ct.) - Certified Transcript - Hearing Held Nov. 30 2011 - tfb

1/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g ,

8 DL [AN GD_G^D[ G@^_[ @B [AN BD_W[ GD_G^D[? W[H[N @B AHUHDD7; K_, @_IT [HD[Z) NWX,) GDRDI L`, 88#8#8578> ] i h d l { d b b )2 w ,5 I@_N[[H B^KKT) n { h i )1 Knbnlkhl { w ,48=88 [_HLWG_D][ @B ]_@GNNKDLEW8? ahk onb`rn {an A@L@_HOIN _A@LKH LDWADC^_H) J~ken87 } rnw d k d l e ) `l Unklnwkht ) L`nconr 7=) ?=88) dl {a n8; ho ` n #nl { d { i nk ch{ { n r , Ncnrenlgt c`{d`l b` r r n an h r d le8> c`{d`l {` w { ht b d l h i `r kn r }nlkdle r na nh r dl e ,8285 H]]NH_HLGNW:8184?=?8???7?;?>

K_, @_IT [HD[Z)JDII LHEHCDLN_NONGGH X^DLL

NWX, ]r` WnB`r {a n Kn}hr {cnl{` b Anhi {a

Kn}~{ dnw H{ {`rlnt Enlnrhi

_N]@_[NK OT:Ganrti H, Kdq`l) _]_) G__) GW_ ';78@ bb d g d h iW{ h { n ` b

G`~r {Ahuhdd

_n}`r {n r

@ bb d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n rB d r w { G d rg ~ d { G`~r {

W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd

8


2/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g ,

8 Unklnwkht) L`nconr 7=) ?=88? = = =7 !Ghwn g h i i n k , $; [AN OHDIDBB: H}}nhrhlgnw ) } i nhwn ,> CW, [HD[Z: @rit [ hd { z , H{ {`rlnt @rit [ hd { z )2 } i h d l { d b b ) }r` wn ,5 CW, LHEHCDLN: E``k c`rldle) T`~r A`l`r, Jdii1 Lhehcdln) Kn}~{t H{ {`rlnt Enlnrh i , ]rnwnl { ud {a cn) _nonggh4 X~dll) Kn}~{t H{ {`rlnt Enlnrh i ) rn}rnwnl { dle {a n Kn}hr{cnl{ ` b8= Anhi {a ,88 Onb`rn un onedl ) T`~r A`l`r) D k` ahn8? ` o jng { d` l w {` {an cnkdh g`nrhen hlk D u`~ik hwf d{ on { ~ rlnk87 ` b b uad in D chfn { a`wn ` o jng { d` l w { ` { a n G`~r { ,8; [AN G@^_[: H ii r d e a { , [~rlnk ` b b uad in t`~8> chfn {a n ` o jng { d` l w hlk {anl un ghl hkkrnww { a h { ,82 CW, LHEHCDLN: [ahlf t`~) T`~r A`l`r, [u`85 ` o j ng { d ` l w ) b d r w { h en ln r h i ` o j ng { d ` l , Dl e nl nrh i ) { a nwn81 }r`gnnk dlew hlk ` {a n r w i d f n {anc j ~ w { edn c`rn h { { nl { d ` l hlk84 krhu c`rn h { { nl { d ` l {` { a d w c n r d { i n w w d w w~n , Un { a dl f d{%w?= { dcn {` w {`} nlg`~rhedle {a n w` #gh i i nk o d r { a n r g`lw} d rhgt?8 { a n ` r d w { w ot l`{ ed dle {anc {a n h { { nl { d ` l { a h { {ant wnnf dl?? {a n cnkdh,?7 Wng`lkit ) ct w } ng d b d g `ojng { d`l {` { a d w?; } h r { d g ~ i h r r n } ` r { n r d w { a h { hgg`rk dle {` Cr, Ih Brhlgn % w?> r nx ~ nw { ) D k` l`{ oni dnn { a h { a n % w h i ne d { d ch { n cnkdh

@ bb d g d h i G`~r{ _n}`r {n rB d r w { G d rg ~ d { G`~r{W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd

?


3/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2 ,87 ) n { g , 7

8 r n } r n w n l { h { d n , An ahw h i r nhk t knc`lw { rh {nk { a h { an d w o d hwnk? hlk) dl b h g { ) g ~ { br`c {a n whcn g i ` { a hw Cw, [h d { z hlk ` { a n r7 o d r { a n r w ongh~wn an ahw w~ocd { { nk h in{{nr {` {a n @bb d gn ` b; Ning { d ` l w dl w ~ } } ` r { ` b hl` {anr } n { d { d ` l ` b Cw, [ h d { z % w { n i i d l e> {anc { a h { h l` rn w}`lwn {` Cw, [ h d { z %w } n { d { d ` l g`~ ik w ~ r n i t on2 wnnl hw hl h g { ` b g` c} i d g d { t , [a`wn h rn ct ` o j n g { d ` l w ) T`~r5 A`l`r, D a`}n {a n G` ~ r { b dlkw e``k gh~wn ) uadga d w {a n1 w { hl k h r k ~ l k n r _~in > ,8 ,4 CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) db D cdea{ rnw}`lk0

8= [adw d w hl d w w ~ n ` b l h { d ` l h i dc}`r {hlgn , [adw d w l `{ h } r d h { n88 c h{ { n r , [a dw d w l`{ h k d ` r gn ` r h g~w {`kt anhr dle uanrn8? { t } d g h i i t cnkdh d w l`{ h i i ` unk ` r w~ga ` o jng { d ` l w h rn e r hl { nk ,87 Un % r n { h i f d l e ho`~{ } r nw d k nl gt ` b { a n ^ld { nk W { h { n w , D ahn8; anrn g d { d z n l w ` b { a n W { h { n ` b Ahuh d d ) ` {n r w dl {a n W { h { n ` b8> Ahuh d d ) ua` t nw { n rk ht { ` e n { a n r ud{a cn b d i n k h r nx ~ nw { b ` r hl82 ncnrenlgt anhr dle ud { a {a n g a d n b ud { a Cr, Wg` { { Lhe`) Gadn b85 Ning { d ` l w @ b b d gn ` b { a n W{h {n ` b Ahuhd d , Un ahn w n r d` ~ w d w w ~ n81 ` b b rh~k g`ccd{{nk dl r n i h { d ` l { ` l h { d ` l h i } r n w d k n l { d h i84 n i n g { d ` l , D b { a d w d w l` { h } i hgn uanrn cnkdh d w h i i`unk ) uanrn?= d w 0 [adw d w {a n c`w{ d c} ` r { h l { d w w ~ n uanl # # ` b g ` l w { d { ~ { d ` l h i?8 r d e a { w ` b 788 c d i i d ` l Hcnrdghl g d { d z n l w , Dl { a d w fdlk ` b ghwn?? cnkdh wa`~ ik on h i i ` unk ,?7 Hk k d { d ` l h i i t ) D u`~ik hwf {` w { r d f n br`c {a n?; r ng`rk d l h } } r ` } r d h { n g a h r h g { n r d z h { d ` l w ot {a n Kn}~{t H{ {` rlnt?> Enlnrh i uanrn wan d w w { h { d l e { a d w d w h o d r { a n r g`lw} d rhgt ) a n % w

@ b b d g d h i G` ~ r { _ n } ` r { n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G` ~ r {

W{h {n ` b Ahuhd d


4/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , ;

8 chkn br`c {a n whcn g i` {a , [ah{ `lit waùw {a n i n n i ` b chidgn? hlk g` c} i d g d { t ` b Kn}~{t H{ {`rlnt Enlnrhi dl { a h { i ne d { d ch { n7 d w w~ nw ` b g ` l w { d { ~ { d ` l h i n i d e d o d i d { t `b {an } rnw d k nl { ) d l i d e a {; `b {an b h g { { a h { uah{ an gih dcw {` on h g`}t ` b a dw ` r d e d l h i> o d r { a g n r { d b d g h { n uhw b`~lk {` on h b` ren rt ) dl i d e a { `b {an2 b h g { { a h { an n r d b d n w # # w { h { n w { a h { {a n w ` g d h i w n g ~ r d { t l~conr5 { a h { an d w ~wdle uhw lnnr hww delnk {` adc, [adw d w {a n c`w{1 dc}`r {hl { d w w~n , Hlk d{ `lit waùw { a h { { a d w Kn}~{t H{ {`rlnt4 Enlnrhi d w l`{ wnnfdle {` en { {` {an { r ~ { a ) edn { r ~ { a b ~ i

8= d l b`rch{ d`l {` {an } ~ o i d g ) o~{ wan d w on dle g` c} i d g d { dl { rt dle88 {` g`nr ~} {a n d w w~ nw ` b b rh~k hlk b` ren rt , [an } ~ o i d g d w8? n l { d { i n k {` flù hlk e n { w~ga { r ~ { a b ~ i d l b ` r c h { d `l ,87 T`~r A`l`r) D ghcn br`c h g`cc~ldw{ g`~l{ rt , D8; uhw o`rl hlk r h d wnk d l {a n W`dn { ^ld`l uanrn } ~ o i d g k dk l` {8> ahn h r d e a { {` flù, Hlk D %c hre~ dle { a`wn ghwnw }r` o`l`,82 Cw, Lhehcdln d w on dle } h dk , D %c k`dle d{ }r` o`l` ongh~wn D %c85 { rt dle {` ~}aìk {a n g ` l w { d { ~ { d ` l h i r d e a { w `b {an ^,W,81 g d { d z n l w ,84 [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ hd { z ) o`{a w dknw ) in{%w w n {?= hw dkn hlt {t}n ` b g a h rh g { n r d z h { d ` l w , In { % w anhr {a n cnr d { w ` b?8 {a n c`{d`l , In { % w }r`gnnk , T`~ ghl {~ rl `l, In { % w }r`gnnk `l?? {an cnr d { w ` b {an c`{d`l,?7 Un%rn anrn `l {a n ncnrenlgt c`{d`l b` r rnanhr dle?; c`{d`l {` w { h t b d l h i ` rk n r }nlkdle r na nh r dl e , Lù) d{ ahw onnl?> or`~ea{ {` ct h { { n l { d ` l ) Cw, [ hd { z ) { a h { t`~ unrn { rt dle {`



5/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2 ,87 ) n { g , >

8 b d i n hl hcnlknk c`{ d`l ,? CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,7 [AN G@^_[: ^lknr uah{ r ~ i n 0; CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) D h g { ~ h i i t ahn h> w { h { ncnl{ dl r n eh r kw {` # #2 [AN G@^_[: L`, L`, L`, Uah{ r~ i n k` t`~ wnnf5 {` b d i n hl hcnlknk c`{d`l0 Ongh~wn t`~ ~lkn r w { h lk ) c `{ d`lw h rn1 e`nrlnk ot A_G] _~in 5 hw un i i hw {a n G d r g ~ d { G`~r { _~in4 rneh rk dle w n { { d l e ` b c `{ d`lw ~lkn r _~in 1) w` D k ` l % { wnn

8= hlt{a dle { a h { } n r { h d l w {` hcnlknk c `{ d`lw ongh~wn db t`~ udwa88 {a n G`~r { {` g ` l w d k n r t`~r hcnlknk c`{ d`lw ) un lnnk {` w n { h8? lnu an h r dle k h { n ~lknr _~in 1,87 CW, [HD[Z: Ct g`lgnrl ) T`~r A`l`r) { a h { D ahn8; w~ocd { {nk hl hcnlknk c`{d`l # #8> [AN G@^_[: L`, L`, Ct x ~ n w { d ` l # # Cw, [ h d { z )82 hlwunr ct x ~ n w { d ` l , K` t`~ udwa {a n G`~r { { ` g ` l w d k n r hl85 hcnlknk c`{d`l ongh~wn d{ d w h lnu c`{d`l w d l g n t ` ~ % r n81 d l w n r { d l e lnu hre~cnl{w ) lnu b h g { w ) lnu d w w ~ n w ) hlk ~lknr _~in84 1 un lnnk {` r n w n { {a n c`{d`l0?= CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) w d l g n D b inu h i i {a n uht?8 br`c G h i d b ` r l d h D u d i i hre~n {`kht `l {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,?? [AN G@^_[: [ahlf t`~, E` hanhk , Hlk hw { ` { a n?7 ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ) t`~r c`{ d`l b` r r n a n h r d l e ) h rn t`~ g`cdle?; ~lknr _~in >4 ` r _~in 2=0?> CW, [HD[Z: ^c # #

@ bb d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G`~r {

W { h { n ` b Ahuhd d


6/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , 2

8 [AN G@^_[: C`{d`l b` r r ng`lw dkn rh { d`lw h r n n r t? i dc d {nk dl {nrcw `b {an G`~r { % w rndnu,7 CW, [HD[Z: D on i d nn ~lknr _~in 2= t`~ # # D %c; w` r rt , D %c w` r rt ) ~lknr _~in > 4 !n $ ) t`~ h rn hi i`unk {` o r dl e> c`{d`l b` r r ng`lw dkn rh { d`l uanrn { an r n uhw hl n r r ` r ` b ihu hlk2 b h g { hlk chl d b n w { d l j ~ w { d g n ) w` D u`~ik i d f n {` g i h r d b t { a h {5 { a d w d w e`dle {` on ~lknr > 4 !n $ ,1 [AN G@^_[: L`u) ahw {a n j~kecnl{ onnl b d i nk04 CW, [HD[Z: L`{ t n { ,

8= [AN G@^_[: ^lknr > 4 !n $ ) h c`{d`l {` h i { n r ` r88 hcnlk j~kecnl{ , L~conr `ln ) ahw h j~kecnl{ onnl b d i n k ongh~wn8? { a n r n % w l` _~in >4!n$ dl {nrcw `b {an o h w d w ` b t`~r c`{d`l db87 l` j~kecnl{ ahw onnl b d i nk08; CW, [HD[Z: D b8> [AN G@^_[: W` { a h { % w uat D lnnknk82 g i h r d b d g h { d ` l85 CW, [HD[Z: W~rn ,81 [AN G@^_[: # # ongh~wn {a n G`~r { % w rndnu d w84 ohwnk ~}`l uah{ t`~ hrn wnnf dle hlk {a n i n e h i h ~ { a ` r d { d n w ,?= CW, [HD[Z: D ahn {` wht { a h { g`cdle br`c?8 hl ` { a n r w { h { n D o n i d n nk { a h { w dl gn {an ` rknr uhw w delnk {a n?? j~kecnl{ uhw h~ {`ch{ d g ,?7 [AN G@^_[: L`) d{%w l`{ , [anrn d w h } h r { d g ~ i h r?; r~ in e`nrldle j^kecnl{w,?> CW, [HD[Z: @fht, Ghl # #

@ b b d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r { n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G`~r {W{h {n ` b Ahuhdd


7/23


8 [AN G@^_[: D k`l % { wnn hlt j~kecnl{ ahdle onnl? b d i nk hlk D %k i d f n {` wnnf g i h r d b d g h { d ` l br`c {a n HE,7 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, [anl D u`~ik i d f n # # T`~r; A`l`r) {anl D u`~ik # #> [AN G@^_[: L` j~kecnl{ ahw onnl b d i nk tn{02 CW, LHEHCDLN: L`) d{ ahw l` { ) T`~r A`l`r, D5 {a`~ea{ d{ u`~ik on on w { {` uhd { b` r { `kht % w anh r d le ,1 CW, [HD[Z: [anl D u`~ik i d f n {` g i h r d b t { a h {4 D %c wnnf dle {` w n { h w d kn hlk r nn r wn hl `rkn r hlk `l {a n

8= j~kecnl{ ,88 [AN G@^_[: ^lknr uah{ r~ i n08? CW, [HD[Z: D on i d nn ~lknr _~in 2= D ghl # #87 [AN G@^_[: [anrn % w }h r { d g ~ i h r w~owng { d `lw ~lkn r8; _~in 2=6 dl }h r { d g ~ i h r 08> CW, [HD[Z: Ghl D }r`dkn h w~}}incnl{h i o r d n b82 hlk hre~n # # t`~ fl`u) T`~r A`l`r) { a d w d w hl dc}`r { hl { d w w~ n ,85 [AN G@^_[: Cw, [hd { z ) d{%w hl dc}`r { hl { d w w~n81 w` {a n G`~r { % w kng d w d`l d w dc}`r {hl { , [an G`~r { % w kng d w d`l ahw84 {` on kn}nlknl{ ~}`l uah{ t`~ % r n hwf dle {a n G`~r { {` k` hlk?= ~lknr uah{ h~ { a` r d { t ,?8 CW, [HD[Z: D %c hwf dle {a n G`~r { {` rng`lw dkn r?? hl nq d w { dle `rkn r { a h { uhw d w w~nk h b { n r {a n anh r dle `l @g{`onr?7 {a n 8?{a k~n {` {a n b h g { { a h { lnu n dknlgn uhw # # lnu n dknlgn?; ghcn b`ruhrk hlk # #?> [AN G@^_[: @fht, W`) {` g i h r d b t ) t`~ % r n e`dle

@bb d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n rB d r w { Gd rg~ d { G`~r {

W{h { n ` b Ahuhdd


8/23


8 ~lknr # # }r`gnnkdle ~lknr _~in 2=!o$? ) uadga d w lnuit? k dwg`nrnk ndknlgn uadga ot k~n k d i d e n l g n g`~ik l `{ ahn onnl7 k dwg`nrnk dl { dcn {` w` c`n ~lknr _~in >4!o$ ,; CW, [HD[Z: L`{ `l it hkk d { d `lh i ndknlgn o ~ {> h i w` hkk d { d `lh i n r r ` r ` b ihu hlk chl d b n w { d l j ~ w { d g n ,2 [AN G@^_[: ^lknr uah{ } h r { d g ~ i h r wng { d`l0 Hrn5 t`~ i``fdle ~lknr _~in 2=!o$2 ) Cw, [hd {z01 CW, [HD[Z: D k` l `{ ahn d{ dl b r`l { ` b cn {a n4 A_W,

8= [AN G@^_[: Ongh~wn { an r n hrn g n r { h d l w {hlkhrkw88 `b rn dnu b` r {an k d b b n r n l { w~owng { d`lw hlk {a n G`~r { % w8? hlh itw d w d w e`nrlnk ot uah { t`~ hrn r n it dle ~}`l, D lnnk {`87 bì iù t`~ dl {nrcw ` b b` r cn {` hlhitzn ,8; CW, [HD[Z: D ~lknrw { hlk , Dl ct } inhk dlew D8> ahn D ahn x~`{nk _~in 2= hlk }r`dknk ndknlgn { a h { ~lknr82 _~in 2=) {a n j~kecnl{ # # {a n j~kecnl{ ` r ` rk n r ghl on w n { hw dkn85 ua nl { an r n d w h cdw {hfn ` b h ihu,81 [AN G@^_[: @fht, Cw, [h d {z ) D %c i``fdle h { {a n84 } h r { d g ~ i h r c`{d`l { a h { t`~ b d i n k , [adw d w kh{nk @g{ònr ?8)?= ?=88, D k ` l % { wnn hlt r n bn rnl gn {` _~in 2=, Lù) D %c e d dle?8 t`~ {a n o n l n b d { `b {an k`~o{ hlk i n { cn { hfn h i``f h { t`~r?? r n} it cnc` {` wnn ,?7 CW, [HD[Z: Dl r n} it # #?; CW, LHEHCDLN: Nqg~wn cn) T`~r A`l`r ) un k dk l` {?> r ngn d n h r n} it ,

@ b b d g d h i G`~r{ _n}`r { n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G`~r{W{h {n ` b Ahuhdd


9/23


8 CW, [HD[Z: D{ uhw w n l { ,? [AN G@^_[: @fht, [ a h { % w g ` r r n g { , [an r n } i t7 t`~ ahn b d i nk d{ whtw r n} it { ` ` } } ` w d { d ` l {` hcnlknk ncnrenlgt; c`{d`l b` r r n a n h r d l e , Lù) hw D dl b`rcnk t`~) Cw, [ h d { z ) db> t ` ~ % r n wnnf dle {a n G`~r { {` g ` l w d k n r hl hcnlknk ncnrenlgt2 c`{d`l {anl }~ r w ~h l { {` o` {a {a n G d r g ~ d { G`~r { _~in hlk {a n5 Ahuhd d _~inw ` b ]r`gnk~ rn ) un lnnk {` w n { h lnu an h r dle k h { n ,1 O~{ db t`~ udwa {a n G`~r { {` j ~ w { hkkrnww t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l4 { a n r n uhw r n h i i t l` r n } i t {` {a n W { h { n % w cnc` dl ` } } ` w d { d ` l

8= r n bn rnl g dl e t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,88 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, [anl D u d i i }r` dkn {a n r n} it8? dl ct ` r h i hre~cnl{ , D u d i i }r` dkn r n } i t {` {a n ` } } ` w d { d ` l ,87 [ant ahn b d i nk # # { ant ahn b d i nk hl ` } } ` w d { d` l { ` { a n8; ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l , Aùnnr) D k` ahn }r `` b ` b w n r d g n waùdle8> { a h { {a n hcnlknk c`{d`l uhw rngn dnk ot {a n G`~r { hlk {a n82 @bb dgn ` b {an H{ {` r ln t Enlnr h i85 [AN G@^_[: L`) o ~ { {a n hcnlknk c`{ d`l ) hw D81 cnl{ d`lnk {` t`~) ~lknr _~in 5 ) hw un i i hw ~lkn r _~in 2 hlk 584 `b {an G d r g ~ d { G`~r { _~inw ) db d{%w hl hcnlknk c`{d`l hlk t`~?= ud w a {a n G`~r { {` ahn {a n hcnlknk c`{d`l w~ } } i h l { t`~r?8 ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l {anl h lnu an h r dle k h { n lnnkw {` on wgank~ink ,?? Ongh~wn hl hcnlknk c`{ d`l ) db t ` ~ % r n wnnf dle {a n G`~r { l` { {`?7 g ` l w d k n r h { h i i t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l o ~ { {` w ~ o w { d { ~ { n ud{a?; t`~r hcnlknk c`{ d`l ) {anl un lnnk {` w n { h lnu an h r dle k h { n ,?> CW, [HD[Z: Unii ) D %c j ~ w { { r t d l e {` w { h { n { a h {

@ b b d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G`~r {



10/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2 ,87 ) n { g , 8=

8 D %c e rn h { i t g`lgnrlnk { a h { nnl {a`~ea {a n c`{d`l uhw rngn dnk? ot {a n G`~r { d{ uhw lnnr k`gfn {nk hlk d{ uhw lnnr e dnl {`7 t`~) hlk D %c g`lgnrlnk db D %c w~ocd { { dle h l` {an r hcnlknk c`{d`l; {a n whcn { a dl e cdea{ ah}}nl,> [AN G@^_[: Unii ) t`~r hcnlknk c`{d`l lnnkw {`2 } ~ { dl h lnu an h r dle k h { n ,5 CW, [HD[Z: O~{ d{ uhw rngn dnk ot {a n G`~r {1 [AN G@^_[: L`, L`, O ~{ ) Cw, [ h d { z ) t`~r4 hcnlknk c`{d`l lnnkw {` }~ { dl h lnu an h r dle k h { n ongh~wn d{%w

8= h g { ~ h i i t h lnu c`{ d`l ,88 CW, [HD[Z: [ a h { % w { r ~ n o ~ { { a n x ~ n w { d ` l d w uah{8? d w e` dle `l anrn0 Uat {a n c`{d`l87 [AN G@^_[: D rngn dnk h r n} it { ` ` } } ` w d { d ` l {`8; hcnlknk ncnrenlgt c`{d`l b` r r n a n h r d l e { a h { uhw b d i nk `l8> L`nconr ?4) ?=88 h { ?:>5 },c, O~{ d{ r n b n r n l g n w {a n hcnlknk82 ncnrenlgt c`{d`l b` r r n a n h r d l e ) uadga l` an h r dle k h { n ahw onnl85 wgank~ink ,81 CW, [HD[Z: D ~lknr w {hlk ) T`~r A`l`r, Uah{ D %c84 wht dle d w { a h {?= [AN G@^_[: Dl ` { a n r u`rkw # #?8 CW, [HD[Z: {a n k`g~cnl{w {anl k d wh } } n h r ,?? [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ h d { z ) {a n k`g~cnl{w ahn l` {?7 k d wh } } n h r n k , Ct x ~ n w { d ` l d w { a h { k` t`~ udwa {a n G`~r { {`?; hkkrnww t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l ` r k` t`~ udwa h lnu an h r dle k h { n?> w~ga { a h { {a n G`~r { u d i i w ~ o w { d { ~ { n t`~r hcnlknk c`{d`l0




11/23


8 CW, [HD[Z: D u d i i # # D u`~ik i d f n {a n G`~r { {`? hkkrnww ct ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l k~n {` {a n b h g { { a h { D b inu h i i {a n7 uht br`c G h i d b ` r l d h ,; [AN G@^_[: W` {a n G`~r { d w hkkrnww dle t`~r> ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ) hlk { a d w uhw b d i nk `l L`nconr 8 ) w` un ahn h2 g`}t ` b { a h { ,5 Lù) i``f dle h { t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ) t`~1 cnl{d`lnk { a h { d{%w or`~ea{ ~}`l h r d `~w o h w d w , @l }hen ? ` b4 t`~r c`{d`l t`~ ahn b dn wn} h rh { n hre~cnl{w , Lù) h i {a`~ea

8= t`~ k ` l % { g d { n {` _~in 2=) D%ii edn t`~ {a n o n l n b d { `b {an88 k`~o{ hlk hi iù t`~ {` hre~n _~in 2=) `fht08? CW, [HD[Z: @fht, W` D u`~ik i d f n {` }r`gnnk ,87 B d r w { ) {a n lnu d l b`rch{ d`l { a h {8; [AN G@^_[: Lù) {a n lnuit kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn )8> `l uah{ }hen d w d{ w n { b` r { a ongh~wn { a n r n % w l` }hen l~conrw082 CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) { a d w n dknlgn uhw85 kd wg`nrnk t nw { n rk ht , D ahk h k ng d w d` l ot h j~ken dl # #81 [AN G@^_[: W` d{%w l`{ dl t`~r c`{d`l084 CW, [HD[Z: D{%w l`{ dl {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l w` D?= u d i i }r ` dkn t`~ ud{a {a n k`g~cnl{w , J ~ w { t nw { n rk ht h?8 k n } ~ { t # #?? CW, LHEHCDLN: @ojng { d`l ) T`~r A`l`r,?7 [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ hd { z ) hw {a n c`hl{ t`~ ahn {`?; }~ { dl nnrt {a dle dl t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,?> CW, [HD[Z: O~{ db d{ uhw rngn dnk t nw { n rk ht # #


W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd


12/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , 8?

8 [AN G@^_[: L`, L`, O~{ {a n o h w d w ) db {a n? o hw d w ` b t`~r c`{ d`l d w `l lnuit kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn ) d{ ahw {`7 on w n { b` r { a d l t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l,; CW, [HD[Z: D ~lknrw { hlk ) T`~r A`l`r, D> h }` iè d zn , D {a`~ea{ { a h { un # # { a h { {a n hcnlknk c`{d`l u d i i2 on an r n , Aùnnr) {a n c`{d`l { a h { uhw rngn dnk ot {a n G`~r{5 { a h { uhw rngn dnk uhw g n r { d b d n k chdi k d wh }}n h r n k ) uhw lnnr1 k`gfn {nk ,4 [AN G@^_[: D flù o ~ { ) Cw, [ hd { z ) t ` ~ % r n

8= cnl{ d`l dle lnuit kd wg`nrnk ndknlgn dl g`llng { d`l ud{a t`~r88 hcnlknk c`{d`l uadga d w l` { onb`rn {a n G`~r { ,8? CW, [HD[Z: @fht, W` D %c }r` dk dle lnuit87 kd wg`nrnk ndknlgn dl g`llng { d`l ud{a {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l,8; [AN G@^_[: L` ) t`~ ghll` { h b { n r {an b h g { , Uanl8> t`~ } rnwnl { t`~r c`{d`l) t`~ ahn {` }~ { dl t`~r c`{d`l h i i {a n82 i n e h i hre~cnl{w) h i i {a n b h g { w ) uan{anr d{%w n q a d o d { w )85 h b b d k h d { w ,81 CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) {anl D %c or dle dle hl84 ` rh i c`{d`l r d e a { lù { a h { lnuit kd wg`nrnk ndknlgn knni`}nk?= h b { n r {a n c`{d`l uhw b d i nk hlk # #?8 [AN G@^_[: W` {a n o hw d w ` b t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l?? uhw l` { ohwnk ~}`l _~in 2=!o$?7?; n dknlgn ,?>

CW, [HD[Z: D{%w 2=!o$ o~ { h iw` { a n rn d w lnu

[AN G@^_[: L` , L`, O~{ {a n o hw d w `b t`~r



13/23


8 ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l uhw l` { ohwnk ~}`l lnuit kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn )? 2=!o$? ,7 CW, [HD[Z: D{%w ohwnk `l n r r` r ` b ihu) ohwnk `l; chld bnw { d l j ~ w { d g n ,> [AN G@^_[: Ongh~wn ) Cw, [ h d { z ) db t`~ uhl{ {a n2 G`~r{ {` g`lw dknr lnuit kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn ) d{ u`~ik on {a n5 w ~ o j n g { ` b hl hcnlknk c`{d`l ud{a h lnu anhr dle kh { n ,1 CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r # #4 [AN G@^_[: W` D %c e d dle t`~ h ga` dgn )

8= Cw, [ h d { z ,88 CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r # #8? [AN G@^_[: D k ` l % { flù uah { n i wn c`rn ongh~wn87 D %c anh r dle { a h { t`~ ahn lnuit kd wg`nrnk ndknlgn `lit br`c8; t nw { n rk ht o ~{ t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l chkn l` cnl{ d`l `b d{,8> CW, [HD[Z: T`~r A`l`r) D %c an rn ) Kn}~{t82 H{ {`rlnt Enlnrhi d w anrn hlk D %c # # dl g`lw dknr dle {an b h g {85 { a h { D hc g`cdle br`c hl` {an r w { h { n ) D %c hwf dle T`~r A`l`r {`81 hi iù cn {` w~ocd{ { a d w ` rh i c`{d`l hlk edn {a n Kn}~{t84 H{ {`rlnt Enlnrhi hl ` } } ` r {~ l d {t { ` b d i n hl `}}`w d { d`l h { h?= i h { n r kh { n , O~{ g`lw dknr dle {a n b h g { { a h { o`{a } h r { d n w h rn?8 anrn hlk i ` e d w { d g h i k d b b d g ~ i { t ` b or dle dle { a d w {` g`~r { ) D %c?? hwf dle T`~r A`l`r {` hi iù {` }r` dkn {a n G`~r{ ud {a h k k d { d ` l h i?7 ndknlgn ud{a Kn}~{t H{ {`rlnt Enlnrhi r n wn r dl e a nr r d e a { {`?; rnw}`lk,?> [AN G@^_[: W`) dl ` { an r u` r k w ) k` t`~ udwa {a n



14/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , 8;

8 G`~r { {` g `lw d kn r t`~r hcnlknk c`{d`l hw h w~}}incnl{ {` t`~r? ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l07 CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,; [AN G@^_[: H ii r d e a { , Chkhc H{ {`rlnt Enlnrh i )> l`u { a h { un%n e ` { { nl { a h { g i h r d b d n k ) Cw, [ hd { z wnnfw i nhn ` b2 {a n G`~r { {` g `lw d kn r an r hcnlknk c`{d`l ud{a h lnuit5 kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn g`l{h dlnk { an rn dl hw h w~}}incnl{ {` an r1 ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l ed dle t`~ i nhn {` h i w` w~}}incnl{ hlt4 ` } } ` w d { d ` l ) { a n rn b` rn {a n G`~r { u`~ik {anl on { hf dle { an c h { { n r

8= ~lknr hkdwncnl{ hlk d w w~ d l e h cdl~{n `r kn r {` { a h { n b b n g { ,88 CW, LHEHCDLN: D u`~ik ` o j ng { {` { a h { ) T`~r8? A`l`r) ongh~wn D ahn l` { ahk hl ` } } ` r {~ l d {t { ` }rn}hrn87 hre~cnl{ b` r a nr hcnlknk c`{d`l hlk k d wg` nr dl e { a h { { a h { uhw8; l`{ `l {a n G` ~ r { % w gh i nl k h r ,8> [AN G@^_[: Hlk {` { a h { n q { n l { {anl {a n G`~r {82 ghll` { an h r hlt b ~ r { a n r hre~cnl{ ) Cw, [ h d { z ) ongh~wn {anl { ant85 ahn l` { ahk {a n ` } } ` r {~ l d {t { ` i``f h { t`~r hcnlknk c`{ d`l )81 i``f h { t`~r lnuit kd wg`nrnk n dknlgn , W` { a nt % r n h { h84 kd whkhl {hen dl { a h { t`~ udwa {a n G`~r { {` hi i`u t`~ i nhn {`?= hre~n br`c t`~r hcnlknk c`{d`l uadga d w l` { `l {a n G` ~ r { % w?8 k`gfn { ,?? CW, [HD[Z: @fht, Ghl D # # dl { a h { d l w { hl gn # #?7 [AN G@^_[: D%ii {nii t`~ uah{ ) o`{a w d k nw ) l`?; b ~ r { a n r hre~cnl{ o~ { t`~ ghl w~ocd { w~}}incnl{h i ,?> CW, [HD[Z: Tnw) { a h { % w uah{ D hwfnk ,


W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd


15/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , 8>

8 [AN G@^_[: H ii r d e a { ) o`{a w d k n w , [anrn b`rn )? t`~ ghl }r n wn r n t`~r hre~cnl{w `l }h}nr `l {a n rng`rk hlk {a n7 G`~r { ghl d w w~ n h k ng d w d` l { a n r n h b { n r ahdle onnl b ~ i i t o r d n b n k; `l }h}nr , D { a dl f { a h { % w b h d r {` o`{a w d k n w ,> CW, LHEHCDLN: W` un u d i i # #2 [AN G@^_[: W` dl {nrcw ` b t`~ fl`u) k` t`~5 udwa {` j ~ w { r n w { `l t`~r hcnlknk # # t`~r r n} it {` `}}`w d { d`l1 {` hcnlknk wnn ) D %c l` { nq hg { i t w~rn uah{ h i i t`~ b d i n k )4 Cw, [ hd { z , D wnn {a n r n } i t {` `}}` w d { d`l {` hcnlknk ncnrenlgt

8= c`{d`l b` r rna nh r dl e , K` t`~ udwa {a n G`~r { {` g `lw d kn r { a h {88 hw h w~}}incnl{ {` t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l08? CW, [HD[Z: Tnw, O~{ D u d i i # # D k` ahn87 hk k d { d ` l h i n dknlgn { a h { D u d i i w~ocd { dl h w~}}incnl{h i8; ordnb##8> [AN G@^_[: O~{ {an n dknlgn ghll` { on hlt{a dle82 { a h { } ` w {k h { n w {`kht ,85 CW, [HD[Z: [anl D u d i i j ~ w { w~ocd { h81 w~}}incnl{h i o r d n b ud{a h i i {a n k`g~cnl{w , D u d i i hre~n {`kht84 `l {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l hlk D u d i i w~ocd { h w~}}incnl{h i o r d n b ,?= [AN G@^_[: @fht, W` j ~ w { hre~n `l {a n ` r d e d l h i?8 c`{ d`l ,?? CW, [HD[Z: @fht, Tnw) T`~r A`l`r,?7 [AN G@^_[: [ a h { % w b h d r , T`~ ghl h iw` rnw}`lk?; ` r h i hre~cnl{ `l {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l hlk D%ii edn {a n b ~ r { a n r?> o r d n b d l e wgank~in {` o`{a w dk nw b` r hlt w~}}incnl{ , W`)


W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd


16/23


8 { a n r n b ` r n ) {a n G`~r { lnnk l` { r n w g an k~ in h l` {an r an h r dle `l hlt? hcnlknk c`{d`l {` on b d i nk ` r g `lw dkn r n k ,7 H ii r d e a { ) e` hanhk `l {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,; CW, [HD[Z: Tnw, Tnw) T`~r A`l`r, Dl {a n> ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l }r `oh o it {a n c`w{ dc }`r { h l { d w w~ n d w {a n d w w~ n2 `b {an { n g al dx~n { a h { d w ~wnk {` h~ { anl { d gh { n k`g~cnl{w )5 h~ { anl { d gh { n hlk n r d bt k`g~cnl{ ,1 [AN G@^_[: Hl k { a h { % w g `l {h dln k dl hre~cnl{4 l~conr {u`0

8= CW, [HD[Z: Tnw) D o n i d n n d{%w l~conr {u`,88 [an chdl d w w~ n d w { a h { {a n knbnlwn ahw w { h { n k8? hlk d{ d w `l r ng`rk { a h { dl {a n W { h { n ` b Ahuhd d {a n k`g~cnl{87 h rn on dle n r d b d n k hlk h ~ { a n l { d g h { n k ud{a `ln u`rk) tnw ) l`,8; H b { n r {a n an h r dle D ahn k`ln n q { n l w d n r n wn h r g a hlk { a n r n d w8> l` w~ga r~ i n ` b h~ { anl { d gh { d `l ud{a `ln u`rk tnw ` r l`, @l {a n82 g` l { rh rt ) uah{ D kdk b dlk { a h { dl n i n g { d ` l w ihu ` b { a n W { h { n ` b85 Ahuhd d k`nw w { h { n { a h { `ln h g { ~ h i i t { a h { d w w~ nw ` b n i n g { d ` l w81 b rh~k hw un i i hw } n { d { d ` l w dl r n eh r kw {` gahlen ` b r ~ i n w ghl on84 or`~ea { ~lkn r 7#858 #7 , Hl k d{ w } n g d b d g h i i t w { h { n w { a h { d{ d w?= k`ln dl hgg`rk dle {` }r`gnk~rnw w n { b` r {a d l Gah} {n r 48,?8 Gah} {n r 48) dl } n r { d l n l { h rnhw ) w { h { n w?? k`g~c nl{h rt n dknlgn cht on rngn dnk dl {a n b`rc ` b g`}dnw ` r?7 n q g n r } { w dl # # db {a n ` r d e d l h i d w l` { r n h k d i t hh d i ho i n?; }r` dknk { a h { ~}`l r n x ~ n w { } h r { d n w w a h i i on e dnl hl?> ` } } ` r { ~ l d { t { ` g`c}hrn {a n g`}t ud{a {a n ` r d e d l h i ,

@ b b d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n rB d r w { G d r g ~ d { G`~r {


W` d{%w


17/23


8 h g { ~ h i i t { a n ` } } ` w d { n ` b ua h { % w w { h { n k ot Cw, Lhehcdln,? Hk k d { d` l h i it ) Ahuhddhl N i n g { d ` l w Ihu Wng { d`l7 7#85?#87= ) hggnww {` n i n g { d ` l k`g~cnl{w ) w { h { n w { a h {; CW, LHEHCDLN: @ojn g { d `l ) T`~r A`l`r, L`ln ` b> { a d w d w dl Cw, [ h d { z % w ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,2 [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ h d { z ) d w { a d w dl t`~r ` r d e d l h i5 c`{d`l01 CW, [HD[Z: Dl r n eh r kw {` {a n n i n g { d ` l w ihu D4 k dk l` { w { h { n n i n g { d ` l w ihu o ~ { D k dk }r ` dkn 48#8=#? hw {a n

8= e`nrl dle ihu dl {a n W { h { n ` b Ahuhd d , Hlk) hw h c h { { n r ` b88 b h g { ) h { {a n } r d ` r an h r dle Cw, Lhehcdln ahw w { h { n k anrn dl {a n8? W { h { n ` b Ahuhd d db `ln unrn {` hwf uhw { a d w }nr w`l o`rl a n r n )87 {a n uht d{ d w k`ln ) d{ d w k`ln ot hl ` b b d g d h i wht dle tnw ` r l`,8; Tnw) un ahn h r n g ` r k , L`) un k`l % { ahn h r n g ` r k ,8> Cw, Lhehcdln k d k l % { nnl edn cn h g ` ~ r { n wt ` b g d { h { d ` l ` b82 uanrn wan e` { d{) uadga w n g { d ` l ) uadga ihu, Uanrn k dk wan e n {85 d{ br`c0 Wan j ~ w { chkn ~} w`cn{adle `l {a n w }h r n `b {an c`cnl{81 @g{`on r 8 ? { a , W` D %c w { h { d l e { a h { { a n r n d w l` w~ga ihu, D{84 j ~ w { k ` n w l % { n q d w { ,?= C`rn`nr ) w } n g d b d g h i i t dl r nehrkw {`?8 n i n g { d ` l w # #?? CW, LHEHCDLN: @ojn g { d `l ) T`~r A`l`r, [anrn d w?7 l` cnl{ d`l ` b n i n g { d ` l w { a h { D ghl b dlk dl {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,?; [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ h d { z ) t`~ lnnk g `l b dln t`~r?> hre~cnl{ { ` { a n ` r d e d l h i c`{ d`l ,




18/23


8 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, D h}ìè dzn , D j ~ w { D k dk? l`{ flù { a h { {an hcnlknk c`{d`l u`~ik l` { on k`gfn{nk w` d{%w7 h id{{in ahrk {` { hfn `~ { dc}`r {hl { } h r { w ,; Hkkd { d ` l h i i t ) {`kht ) r d e a { lù hw d{%w> uni i #flùl) { a n rn h rn gah i i nlenw uanrnot g d { d z nl w br`c h i i ` n r2 g`~l{ rt hlk w { h r { d l e br`c {a n b d r w { }r dchrt w { h { n w `b Lnu5 A h c } w a d r n # #1 [AN G@^_[: L` ) D { a dl f { a h { { a nt % r n hcnlknk)4 l`{ dl t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l ,

8= CW, [HD[Z: @fht, [adw d w h b h g { { a h { d w88 unii#flùl # #8? [AN G@^_[: L`) Cw, [ hd { z ) heh dl ) {a n G`~r{ d w87 gh~ { d`l dle t`~ ongh~wn {a n G`~r{ d w ed dle t`~ x ~ d { n h o d { ` b8; i h { d { ~ k n dl {nrcw ` b h i iùdle t`~ {` w~}}incnl{ , O~{ dl {nrcw8> `b ` rh i hre~cnl{ ) g`lb dln t ` ~ r wn i b {` t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l82 w dl gn t`~ k` l`{ udwa {` r n { ~ rl {` ahn hl`{an r anh r dle k h {n `l85 h i i { a d w ` { a n r hre~cnl{ ,81 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, Unii ) hw Cw, Lhehcdln ahw84 w {h {nk { a h { {a n hlwunr d w h tnw ` r l`) tnw ) un ahn d{ dl {a n?= h~ i { ) l`) un k ` l % { ) {a n x~nw { d`l d w aù k` Hcnrdghl g d { d z nl w?8 flù { a h { { a n rn d w hlt{a dle dl {an h~ i {0 D b un ahn h?? w d { ~ h { d ` l ua n rn hl ` b b d g d h i ) h w { h { n ` b b d g d h i ) d w r n i nh w d l e h?7 k`g~cnl{ uadga d w hgg`rk dle {` nq } nr { h b { n r nq } nr { waùw {` on?; h b` renrt hlk {an whcn ` b b d g d h i d w {a n `ln ua` d w k`dle?> h~ { a nl { d gh { d ` l ) a` u k` un r n it `l w~ga h~ { a nl { d gh { d ` l 0 Aù k`



19/23


8 un fl`u { a h { { a n rn d w hlt{a dle dl { a`wn h~ i { w0 Uat {a n W{ h { n? `b Ahuhdd nnl ahw { a`wn h~ i { w07 C`rn`nr ) hw D w { h { nk } rn d` ~ w it ) Cr, @ohch ahw; w delnk h r n i nh wn w { h { d l e { a h { a dw ` r d e d l h i o d r { a g n r { d b d g h { n> ghl on }r` dknk ) ghl on rn inhwnk {` {an } ~ o i d g , An ahw # # an2 ahw uhdnk hlt r d e a { w {` } r d hgt , Hlk dl rnw}`lwn {`5 Cw, Lhehcdln) _~in >88 `b {an Ahuhdd _~inw ` b Ndknlgn e`nrlw1 d{ hlk { a n rn h rn l` b~ r { a n r r d e a { w {a n c`cnl{ an ahw ednl w~ga4 rn i nh wn ,

8= C`rn`nr) Ahuhddhl _~inw ` b Ndknlgn >=? w { h { n88 { a h { db b rh~k d w g`ccd{{nk # #8? CW, LHEHCDLN: @ojng { d`l ) T`~r A`l`r,87 [AN G@^_[: D{%w l`{ g`l{h dlnk dl t`~r ` r d e d l h i8; c`{d`l,8> CW, LHEHCDLN: D{%w l`{ dl {a n ` r d e d l h i ,82 CW, [HD[Z: D{%w ahrk b` r cn {` {nii uah {%w dl85 {a n ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l ongh~wn D ahn h i rnhk t b d i nk hw D wh d k81 hcnlknk c`{d`l hlk r n} it ,84 [AN G@^_[: Hlk { a h { % w uat ) Cw, [ hd { z ) D % n?= ednl t`~ {a n ` } } ` r {~ l d {t hlk {a n ga`dgn ` b rn {~ rl dle hlk b ~ i i t?8 hre~ dle hl hcnlknk c`{d`l ud {a h lnu anhr dle k h { n , O~{ db t`~?? h rn ~lhoin {` ` r l`{ ud i i dle {` on o`~lk ot t`~r ` r d e d l h i?7 c`{d`l {anl un lnnk {` w n { h lnu anhr dle k h {n w` { a h { t`~ ghl?; b ~ i i t hre~n nnrt {a dle dl t`~r ` r d e d l h i c`{d`l hw uni i hw hlt?> w~}}incnl{h i hre~cnl{ hlk hlt lnu n dknlgn ,



20/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , ?=

8 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, Unii ) uah{ D u`~ik i d f n {` k`? {a`~ea # # D ~lknrw { hlk , Un ahn anrn hw D wh d k {u` d l k d d k ~ h i w7 ud{a cn ua` b d i nk hl ncnrenlgt r nx ~ nw { b` r h anhr dle ud {a {a n; g a d n b n ing { d`lw ` b b d g n r , Hlk {a n anhr dle u d i i # # un h rn { rt dle> {` h w g n r { h d l uanl {a n anhr dle u d i i on ud{a Cr, Wg` { { Lhe`) t`~r2 g a d n b n ing { d`lw ` b b d g n r ) hlk D uhw u`lknrdle db { a n rn d w # # hlk5 D ~lknr w {hlk { a h { t`~ ahn h o~wt wgank~in ) db { a n rn d w hl1 ` } } ` r {~ l d {t { ` g` ` rk dl h {n { a`wn {u` anhr dlew w` { a h { D u`~ik4 l`{ ahn {` b it br`c Ghi d b` rl d h {udgn b` r {an anhr dle on b`rn

8= {a n g a d n b n ing { d`lw ` b b d g d h i hlk h iw` anhr dle anrn0 [ a h { % w `ln88 x ~ nw { d` l ,8? Hl`{anr x~nw { d`l { a h { D ahn) j ~ w { t nw { n rk ht D87 uhw erhl {nk }r` ahg dgn {` r n} rn wnl { g i d n l { w dl {a n w { h { n ` b8; En`redh ua` h rn or dle dle w d c d i h r r nx ~ nw { w b` r k d wg i ` w~ rn hlk8> dlw}ng { d`l ` b rng` rk w , D w { a n rn # # hlk h iw` D ahn ldln82 w { h { n % w r n } r n w n l { h { d n w br`c {a n w { h { n ` b Lnu Ahc}wadrn ua`85 w delnk h g`lwnl { hlk uhl{ cn {` r n} rn wnl { {anc, Wdcd i h r81 c`{ d`lw h rn on dle b d i nk h i i ` n r {a n lh{ d`l ongh~wn {a n lh{ d`l84 ahw h r d e a { {` fl`u hlk?= [AN G@^_[: Uah{ d w t`~r r nx ~ nw { ) Cw, [hd {z0?8 CW, [HD[Z: D w { a n rn hlt uht {` chton b` r cn {`?? u`rf ud{a t`~r h w w d w { h l { hlk g``rk dlh {n {an D %c i``f dle b` r )?7 hw D wh d k ) ` r d e d l h i k`g~cnl{ hlk {a n ghwn d w e`dle {` {rdhi dl?; En`redh {` g``rk dlh {n { a`wn chton g` ~ r { anhr dlew0?> [AN G@^_[: L`) nhga g` ~ r { d w wn} h rh { n hlk h} h r {



21/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2 ,87 ) n { g , ?8

8 br`c nhga ` { a n r ud{a r n w } n g { {` a` u { ant chlhen { a n d r k`g fn { ,? Hlk dl { n r cw ` b hlt } h r { d g ~ i h r an h r dle k h { n w ) `lgn t`~ ahn h7 } h r { d g ~ i h r an h r dle k h { n br`c h } h r { d g ~ i h r b`r~c ` r nl~n ) {anl; db t`~ wnnf h w d c d i h r an h r dle k h { n ) {anl w~ocd { h c`{d`l ` r hwf> g ` ~ l w n i ` r r n x ~ n w { h an h r dle k h { n , O~{ ~ l { d i w~ga { dcn { a h {2 { a h { } h r { d g ~ i h r r n x ~ n w { d w onb`rn {a n G`~r { ) {a n G`~r { ghll`{5 dl h hg~~c rnw}`lk h g g ` r k d l e i t ,1 CW, [HD[Z: @fht, @fht, [anl D u d i i w~ocd {4 h l` {an r hcnlknk c`{d`l h } } h r n l { i t

8= [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ h d { z ,88 CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,8? [AN G@^_[: Uanl t`~ wht t`~ uhl{ {` w~ocd {87 h l` {an r hcnlknk c`{ d`l ) w` h rn t`~ ud{akrhudle { a d w c`{d`l hlk8; {anl t`~ }ihl {` b d i n h l` {an r c`{d`l8> CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,82 [AN G@^_[: ## b ` r r n a n h r d l e ##85 CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,81 [AN G@^_[: ## w~ga { a h { t`~ ghl b ~ i i t o r d n b84 CW, [HD[Z: Tnw,?= [AN G@^_[: ## {a n d w w ~ n w ud{a uah{nnr?8 k`g~cnl{w ) n q a d o d { w ) n { g , 0?? CW, [HD[Z: Tnw) T`~r A`l`r, D u d i i k` { a h { ,?7 h i w ` ) hw D w { h { n k ) D ahn h erhn g`lgnrl dl { a h { {udgn {a n?; k`g~cnl{w { a h { D w~ocd { {nk # # u n i i ) { a n r n h rn r n g n d } { w )?> g n r { d b d n k chd i r n g n d } { w ) { a h { ct hcnlknk c`{d`l uhw rngn dnk



##

D


22/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , ??

8 anrn hlk d{ uhw lnnr k`gfn{nk ot {a n g i n rf `b {an g` ~ r { hlk? uhw l` { rn {~ rlnk {` cn hlk uhw l`{ ednl {` t`~, J ~ w {7 t nw { n rk ht D b`~lk `~ { {a n r n} it { a h { D w~ocd { {nk ot Bnk Nq uhw; r n j n g { n k ot {a n G`~r { , W` D ahn h c`{d`l db D g`~ik # # D> }rn}hrnk d{ hw hl ncnrenlgt c`{d`l k nh i dl e `lit ud{a {a n d w w~ n2 `b # #5 [AN G@^_[: Cw, [ hd { z ) t`~ ghll` { # # t`~ ahn {`1 bì iù {a n }r`}nr } r` {` g` i dl {nrcw ` b b d i d l e , D b t`~ wnnf {`4 b d i n h lnu c`{d`l dl {nrcw ` b e n { { d l e h lnu anhr dle k h { n ) {anl

8= bì iù { a h { } r ` { ` g ` i , W` un ghl edn t`~ h lnu anhr dle k h { n ,88 W` { an x~n w { d `l { a h { % w on b ` r n {a n G`~r { d w { a h {8? k` t`~ wnnf {` ud{akrhu t`~r } r n w n l { c`{d`l w` { a h { t`~ ghl87 b d i n h lnu c`{d`l { ` e n { h lnu anhr dle kh {n08; CW, [HD[Z: Tnw) D%ii k` { a h { ,8> [AN G@^_[: H ii r d e a { , L`{adle b~ r { a n r ) g` ~ r {82 w { hlkw dl r ngnww , C`{d`l ahw onnl ud {akrhul,858184?=?8???7?;?>

![an }r`gnnk dlew g`lg i~knk , $### = = = ###


W{ h { n ` b Ahuhdd


23/23

]N_CDWWD@L [@ G@]T KNLDNK) A_W 2=2,87 ) n { g , ?7

8 W[H[N @B AHUHDD? GD[T HLK G@^L[T @B A@L@I^I^7;>2 D ) GAN_TI H, KDQ@L) _]_) G__) GW_ ';78) hl @ bb d g d h i5 G`~r { _n}`r {n r b` r {a n B d r w { G d rg ~ d { G`~r { ) W{ h { n `b Ahuhdd ) k`1 anrnot g n r { d b t { a h { {a n b` rne`dle }henw g`c}r d wn h b ~ i i ) { r ~ n4 hlk g ` r r n g { { r hl w g r d} { d ` l ` b ct w { n l`e r h }a d g l`{nw { hfnl dl {a n

8= ho ` n #nl { d { i nk gh~wn ) {` {a n o n w { `b ct h o d i d { t ,888?878;8>82858184?=?8???7?;?>

Kh{nk { a d w ?={a kht ` b Kngnconr) ?=88,

/ w / Ganrti H, Kdq`lGAN_TI H, KDQ@L) _]_) G__) GW_ ';78@ bb d g d h i G`~r { _n}`r {n r

TAITZ v FUDDY (HI Cir. Ct.) - Certified Transcript - Hearing Held Nov. 30 2011 - tfb

Documents

Transcript of TAITZ v FUDDY (HI Cir. Ct.) - Certified Transcript - Hearing Held Nov. 30 2011 - tfb