TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement...

32
TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 e Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution 2. The Progressives: Their Methods, Goals, and Limitations Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line 3. Progressives in State and Local Politics Redesigning the City Reform Mayors, City Services, and the States 4. The President Becomes “The Administration” The Executive Branch Against the Trusts Conserving Water, Land, and Forests Big Stick Diplomacy and Dollar Diplomacy 5. Rival Visions of the Industrial Future The New Nationalism The 1912 Election and New Freedom

Transcript of TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement...

Page 1: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The Progressive Movement

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

2. The Progressives: Their Methods, Goals, and Limitations Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics Redesigning the City Reform Mayors, City Services, and the States

4. The President Becomes “The Administration” The Executive Branch Against the Trusts Conserving Water, Land, and Forests Big Stick Diplomacy and Dollar Diplomacy

5. Rival Visions of the Industrial Future The New Nationalism The 1912 Election and New Freedom

Page 2: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The Railroad: The Mother of the Corporation - and

of Modern Live

Page 3: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The Power of Corporate Trusts – J.P. Morgan:

(1837-1913), began as an accountant for banking firms until he became a partner in a company in 1871, which was reorganized as

J.P. Morgan and Company in 1895. A coldly rational man, Morgan reorganized railroads

after 1885, by gaining control of large amounts of stock. In 1896, Morgan embarked on consolidations in the electric and steel

industries, creating the world's first billion-dollar corporation: U.S. Steel. By the early

1900s, Morgan was the main force behind the “Money Trusts”, controlling virtually all the

basic American industries.

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

Page 4: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

Page 5: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

Children sleeping in Mulberry Street, Jacob Riis, 1890

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Jacob Riis, Five Cents Lodging, Bayard Street, c. 1889

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism 

The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

Living and Working Conditions of the Working Class

Page 6: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

Luna Park at Coney IslandConey Island became a pleasure resort

in the 1870s, but not until the turn of the century, with the development of elaborate amusement parks like Luna

Park -- pictured here with its elaborate tower, electric lights, flags, and "Helter Skelter" chute--did Coney Island come

into its own as the capital of commercialized leisure. Highlights for

Coney Island visitors included the beach, the vaudeville hall, and the

midway with its rides and its risqué harem dancers. It was the largest

amusement area in the United States through World War II.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California’s Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism 

The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

Sins and Pleasures of Working Class Immigrants

Page 7: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

The Radical Labor Movement and Socialism

Page 8: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

Populism - The Wonderful Wizard of Oz?This beloved children's classic was published in

1900 in the wake of the collapse of western Populism, and many have read it as a metaphor

of the movement. The author, L. Frank Baum, was an advocate of Populism. He was married to Maud Gage, daughter of suffrage leader Matilda

Joslyn Gage. The book centers around an adventuresome young girl from the Populist

farm state of Kansas, named Dorothy after the Baums' recently deceased daughter. In the

book, Dorothy is saved through magical shoes made of silver, echoing the Populist demand for

a silver-based currency.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism  The Insecurity of Modern Life Social Housekeeping Evolution or Revolution

Page 9: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

muckraker: term coined by Theodore Roosevelt that referred to a group of investigative

journalists who published stories exposing shady practices and corruption in business and

politics.

2. The Progressives: Their Methods, Goals, and Limitations Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line

Page 10: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The Progressive Movement

Ida TarbellIda M. Tarbell served as managing editor of McClure's

Magazine, where her "History of the Standard Oil Company" ran in serial form for three years. Her

revelations of the ruthless practices John D. Rockefeller used to seize control of the oil-refining industry

convinced readers that it was time for economic and political reforms to curb the power of big business.

Tarbell grew up in the Pennsylvania oil region and knew firsthand how Standard Oil crushed competitors--her

father was forced out of business by Rockefeller's South Improvement Company.

2. The Progressives Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line

Page 11: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.
Page 12: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The Progressive Movement

Triangle Shirtwaist Factory FireThe doors were the problem. Most were locked (to keep the working girls from leaving early); the few that were open became jammed by bodies as the flames spread. When the fire trucks finally came, the ladders were too short. Compared with those caught inside, the girls who leapt to their deaths were the lucky ones. "As I looked up I saw a love affair in the midst of all the horror," a reporter wrote. A young man was helping girls leap from a window. The fourth "put her arms about him and kiss[ed] him. Then he held her out into space and dropped her." He immediately followed. "Thud--dead, Thud--dead...I saw his face before they covered it...He was a real man. He had done his best." -New York Tribune, March 26, 1911.

2. The Progressives Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line

Page 13: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Hull House: the first settlement house in the United States. Opened in Chicago by Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr in 1889. Set up a nursery for the children of working

mothers, a penny savings bank, an employment bureau, a baby clinic, a playground, and a social club. Also promoted the arts by sponsoring an orchestra, reading groups,

and a lecture series.

2. The Progressives Social workers and

Muckrakers Dictatorship of the

Experts Progressives on the

Color Line

Page 14: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

Frederick Winslow Taylor and Scientific Management

2. The Progressives Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Page 15: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

2. The Progressives The Nation and the Body

Page 16: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

2. The Progressives The Nation and the Body

Page 17: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

2. The Progressives Progressives on the Color Line

Ida B. Wells – muckraking on Lynching

Page 18: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Booker T. Washington:Born into slavery in Virginia in 1856,

struggled to obtain an education, founded the Tuskegee Institute in 1881. Known as an “accommodator” he called

on southern blacks to “cast down your bucket where you are,” and focus on self-improvement rather than equal

rights of citizenship. Praised by whites for his “Atlanta Compromise” (1895),

he gained access to the most powerful men in the country.

2. The Progressives Progressives on the Color Line

Page 19: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

2. The Progressives Social workers and Muckrakers Dictatorship of the Experts Progressives on the Color Line

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Page 20: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

FaucetIn response to Chicago's typhoid fever outbreak in 1882 (which was caused by polluted water), enlightened city engineers created and expanded municipal sewage systems and devised ingenious ways to bring clean water to the urban population. By the 1890s, the residents of American cities demanded and received, at the twist of a faucet, water for their bathtubs, toilets, and even their lawn sprinklers. Those who could afford it enjoyed a standard of living that was the envy of civilization.

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics

Redesigning the City Reform Mayors, City Services,

and the States

Page 21: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

The City:Zoning Laws

Housing CodesSettlement Houses

Americanization:Women’s Christian Temperance Union

National Urban League

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics

Redesigning the City Reform Mayors, City Services, and the

States

Galveston after its Hurricane 1900

Mulberry Street, New York, 1898

Page 22: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.
Page 23: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Australian ballot: secret ballot printed by the government, introduced in virtually every state by the 1890s. Enabled voters to cast their votes privately. Signified the

government’s commitment to election reform.

Reforming Democracy:17th Amendment (Senators)

19th Amendment (Vote for Women)

Reforming City Government:Citywide Elections

City Commission PlanCity Manager Plan

Reforming State Government:Initiative

ReferendumRecall

Creating the Virtuous Electorate:Secret Voting

RegistrationPoll Tax

Creation of the INS (1906)Disfranchisement

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics Redesigning the City Reform Mayors, City Services, and the States

Page 24: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Campaigning for Woman's Suffrage (Woman's Suffrage Flag)In 1896 women voted in only four states--Wyoming, Colorado, Idaho, and Utah. The West led the way in the campaign for womn suffrage, partially because of demographics, as in the case of Wyoming, where only 16 votes were needed in the state's tiny legislature to obtain passage of the vote for women. This flag illustrates the number of states where women voted.

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics

Redesigning the City

Reform Mayors, City Services, and the States

Page 25: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

3. Progressives in State and Local Politics

Redesigning the City

Reform Mayors, City Services, and the States

Page 26: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

Campaigning for the Square DealWhen William McKinley ran for president in 1896, he sat on his front porch in Canton, Ohio, and received delegations of voters. That was not Theodore Roosevelt's way. He

considered the presidency a "bully pulpit," and he used the office brilliantly to mobilize public opinion and to assert his leadership. The preeminence of the presidence in

American public life begins with Roosevelt's administration. Here, Roosevelt stumps for the Square Deal in the 1904 election.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

4. The President Becomes “The Administration”

The Executive Branch Against the Trusts

Conserving Water, Land, and Forests

Big Stick Diplomacy and Dollar Diplomacy

Page 27: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

4. The President Becomes “The Administration”

The Executive Branch Against the Trusts Conserving Water, Land, and Forests

Big Stick Diplomacy and Dollar Diplomacy

Busting the Trusts: Regulating Businesses:Theodore Roosevelt: Public Pressure and Trust-BusterHoward Taft: Hostile LitigatorWoodrow Wilson: Regulation and Government Oversight

Page 28: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Teddy Roosevelt once declared himself to be "as strong as a bull moose." The

appellation stuck and the moose became the popular symbol for the Progressive

Party. This cartoon depicting the mascots of the major parties appeared in Harper's

Weekly, July 20, 1912, just before the "Bull Moose" convention opened in Chicago.e "as

strong as a bull moose." The appellation stuck and the moose became the popular

symbol for the Progressive Party under Roosevelt. This cartoon depicting the

mascots of the major parties appeared in Harper's Weekly, July 20, 1912, just before

the "Bull Moose" convention opened in Chicago.

4. The President Becomes “The Administration”

The Executive Branch Against the Trusts Conserving Water, Land, and Forests

Page 29: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

4. The President Becomes “The Administration”

The Executive Branch Against the Trusts Conserving Water, Land, and Forests

Page 30: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

5. Rival Visions of the Industrial Future

The New Nationalism The 1912 Election and

New Freedom

Page 31: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Important Regulatory Initiatives of the Progressive Era:

Sherman Anti-Trust ActPure Food and Drug Act

Meat Inspection ActFederal Trade Commission

Federal Reserve ActFederal Income Tax Amendment

(16th)

5. Rival Visions of the Industrial Future The New Nationalism The 1912 Election and New Freedom

Regulating Capital-Labor Relations:Kern McGillicuddy Act (Federal

Workers’ Comp)Factory Inspection Laws (NY)

Keating Owen Act (Child Labor Prohibition)

Clayton Anti-Trust Act (businesses vs. unions)

Federal Industries Relations Commission

Page 32: TAH Pasadena Progressivism and California's Era of Reform November 5, 2011 The Progressive Movement 1. Toward a New Politics: The Context of Progressivism.

TAH PasadenaProgressivism and California's Era of Reform

November 5, 2011

Discussion:

1. How have you taught Progressivism in the past?

2. What has worked? What hasn’t?

3. What are the challenges of teaching this topic?

4. New Approaches to Teaching Progressivism: