T5 B59 DOS Docs- NIV 1 of 5 Fdr- man 5 Withdrawal Notices- Immigration Judge Decision

8/14/2019 T5 B59 DOS Docs- NIV 1 of 5 Fdr- man 5 Withdrawal Notices- Immigration Judge Decision

1/31

WITHDRAWAL NOTICERG: 148 Exposition, Anniversary, and Mem orial Comm issionsSERIES: 9/11 Commission, Team 5

N N D PROJECT NUM BER: 51630 FOIA CASE NUM BER: 30768WITHDRAWAL DATE: 09/24/2008

BOX: 00025 FOLDE R: 0003 TAB: 2 DOC ID: 31198430COPIES: 1 PAGES: 15

The item identified below has been withdrawn from this file:FOLDER TITLE: DOS Documents - NIV [1 of 5]DOCUMENT DATE: 12/29/1998 DOCU MEN T TYPE: CableFROM:TO:SUBJECT:

This document has been withdrawn for the following reason(s):9/11 Classif ied Information

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE


2/31

WITHDRAWAL NOTICERG: 148 Exposition, Anniversary, and Mem orial CommissionsSERIES: 9/11 Comm ission, Team 5

NND PROJEC T NUM BER: 51630 FOIA CASE NUM BER: 30768WITHDRAWAL DATE: 09/24/2008

BOX: 00025 FOLDER: 0003 TAB: 3 DOC ID: 31198431COPIES: 1 PAGES: 94

The item iden tified below has been withdrawn from this file:FOLDER TITLE: DOS Documents - NIV [1 of 5]DOCUMENT DATE: DOCU MENT TYPE: FormFROM:TO:SUBJECT: IN S forms re. Omar Abdelrahman

This document has been withdrawn for the following reason(s):9/11 Law Enforcement Privacy

9/11 Law Enforcement Sensitive

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE


3/31

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE

RG: 148 Exposition, Anniversary, and Mem orial Comm issionsSERIES: 9/11 Commission, Team 5

NND PROJECT NUM BER: 51630 FOIA CASE NUM BER: 30768WITHD RAW AL DAT E: 09/24/2008

BOX: 00025 FOLDER: 0003COPIES: 1 PAGES: 26

TAB: 4 DOC ID: 31198598

ACCESS RESTRICTEDThe item identified below has been w ithdrawn from this file:

FOLDER TITLE: DOS Documents - N IV [1 of 5]DOCUMENT DATE: DOC UM ENT TYPE: CableFROM:TO:SUBJECT: Omar A bdelrahman

This document has been withdrawn for the follow ing reason(s):9/11 Classified Information

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE


4/31

OIG002SEGMENT

QUESTION#1B


5/31

WITHDRAWAL NOTICERG: 148 Exposition, Anniversary, and Mem orial Comm issionsSERIES: 9/11 Commission, Team 5

NND PROJECT NUM BER: 51630 FOIA CASE NUM BER: 30768WITHDRAWAL DATE: 09/24/2008


The item identified below has been withdrawn from this file:FOLDER TITLE: DOS Documents - NIV [1 of 5]DOCUMENT DATE: 04/30/1993 DO CUM ENT TYPE: Mem orandumFROM: Inspector GeneralTO: Director of Central IntelligenceSUBJECT: Omar Abdelrahman, Visa

This document has been withdrawn for the following reason(s):9/11 Classified Information

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE


6/31

-MflR-M993 FROM GlCm. CO*SEL EASTEFW - TO GEN.15:20

>VoCD P ,0****, nr JBUXT

73 750

. Jict, cy*t th tlo of application for &xlBloa...vbot not La po**Mian of rmild un*xpird in n I greetrocatry prnit, border crtx&Lag idfltrtic*tionor Otb*r rIid *tttz7 docuMfit rwjulrwd by thisAct, and & vclid fmczjtlrvd passport, or otbor suitabletrtvul docaat, or (Jocwwnt of identity uad11 Ktzeb doacdt ! r0qol*d oodcr tbAttorney Cesoral onder sacU.oa 2U(a)...is

in UM Onit*dSctlea aO of tit*(8 n.(rom I-M7J,jxj HitiotiAiityAct, to

of DpartUon to laypt, ?>Mrunt to Sectionyp, ?>Mrunt2*3(h) of tb Xmi rctioa &od Ntlonlltr Act,(8 U.B.C.tl2S3j.

* IfclvocuC forkhodKMIKU ctxvet, JtoatKflv Tork, T 100M

yrtl or{.!(./ TrlAlMCtor tTMt

K? 07102

On or *boot Aoaact 27, 1992, tb p?llcst flld nppliottioa and accoopanylay docmwtttitloa witfi tM coortrcquerclfiff tint b* b orvnted *yluni L a . the Ooxtd CCAt*aixl' withholding of dport4tJLon to Soypt. Cacala now pending b*for thi*'


7/31

rW-16-199315:20 FRO1

N. COUN HQ P.03RDCOJ P.02

Bfort prtntij>? 4 diouoioa of tb applicant-*li9l2>ilit7 for relief froa ccluion proc*dnge, thlcourt will prat factual Uvek^rauad Inforgxrtloa aadAddreaa preliaioarT1 laruv.Th pplleant 1* fijfty-foar yr old o*tiT xJcitlcn of Xyypt, vho 1 < hiBl/ Of the IlBtc Suuniralicion. Tb ppUent foUowo tM ItlnnJe -SlurU'iA-r^Uytcu* lv, *t forth in > fg?* TJ fpliont tblind -ad b** A


8/31

flCf R-16-1993 16:42 FROM* dEGIONRL COUNSEL EASTERN TOP?-16-19S3 15:20 FRCM INShEUWLLfiS TO

GEN. COUN. HO P.84F3DCDU P.04

O n or lx*it A u v m t 37, 1 9 V 3 , U* applicant riled anApplication with this court resetting thrt ho be grantedtwyitna is tba United states *nd withholding 'of deportationto rgypt.^/ X * rwjuinrd by 8 c.r.JU 236. 3(3) (b}/ uponreceipt of the asylna A nd withholding o f . deportationapplication, this court forwarded * copy of tbe applicationto tbe T 7 5 . Pepareaeat of 8tate, froreau of Buoas Right* sadHuaanXtsrlsn Affairs { - B H K B A " ) for their aoonants puetnontto 8 C.y.R. (208.11. Tb .umSrsl$rri bald IMividn*!Cicndtr b*riagv on October 22,1992 *od Juurr 20, 199Jto pllc*at' pr*atBt rtld*0t ttctvs. At *CalUr Staring h*ld on X*y 14, 1992, tb pplicrtr

COQBJMlr COOCWjfld that h i not eltixaa or r*rraait"t midjnt of tba Onitd Stttmt. ud iproperly in xcltuioa proe Applioot, through hi*footer attorny/ iadtott*d tfact b iru nbjvot to rweiMimproo^tdtagt cad cOfled4 that tba *j>plic*at did aot ti**lyfil* rtqutrot to -r*pi4 to tba notice of zatat toApplicaat, throagda bis fonoar cooaJ(1W2}/ lUtteyPf-Cftardohi. 19 I fi I T Dec. 311, 1 (IA 1585).A29 783 7Z O 3


9/31

r*R-16-1993 16 2 P R O M- =BIONf lL OXNSEL EASTERN TO[-FK-1&-1993 15:23 FROl IN S tUP&< LLPS TO

\.COUN. HQ P.85RQCDU P.05

i.

couol r y u < 3 tft4t t f c f l applicant hd not boon properlyor-red not Leo a required by 8 c.r.R. (34.i ( i2) , * r * &that,- tht ordar of tba Oirtrict Director v iapropar.PurthezTDors, applicant'* coun*l urged tii court to reri*vth re*el**io pro9**oUaf* and the ordr th*t rwoioded hi*permanent rtcidenc* *ttq* dated Xarch 6, 1992. Sinoo tbapplicant did not caqo*t * krijag bfor* n IiBigrtXon

s -,

*t th tine poi>ton procdlogg wrthis court ct3ocladd tA*.t it did not bar* jorlKtletioarericrv U M ordr of th District, Dirctor. fiag 824.J (1992). Coo**i9tt*dto roepRitfT b^* dVociîoa dnylag appULcaat'a c*qaot torrrlow tb* order of t&e Di*trict Director. Applicant

tryaKl t&t tlitv oonrt bai tb aothority to rrlvorder of th* Oivtrlot Cir*ctor IA cxolioa proodia7that tti Cei*ioa by th Board of Imloratioo Appeal(bcriatft*r Board) in thoOtcicieo #30OS (K X 1989}r applied only todoportctififi proctdiS. Coaawtl argo*d that fch plaiaof 8 C.7.1U (3.1(b) aod 2*6.1 ?wraUs ththat th Tuaigrttioo JBdff* ba th* avthorlty torvrlew, rcootwldar ad ervreol* th* District Pirctor*order of r**ai*oo. Bowwrmr, this coart r*4 Katêf oft3EOLr to apply both ia tWportatlon andla flrtter,. of Rcxlrioxie*-grtbfn. gtiprt^ thfosad thct tba rraci*iaa of Uw reapoodeat'

pnrtannt rMidoat rtxtsB wa iznraJLLd bocaaM Uw Serriewbad not 6eBoa*tr*fcd that th repodttt a p*r0oaaliytcrr l with th Rotle* of Intaat to X*elnd. Id at 3.Tb*r*orf tha fimfgrafcino do> taoaiaatad deportirtioQO n appelr tbc 8o*rd ooaolad*d that tb*lck*d rltdictloo la deporttloarto rocoacMcr tb Cictrlct Director ret*jMorder, la It'*doolUoa, tb Board aotMd that 8 C.7.S. $246(1988) did not prorite for tbt rorlev of tb* PUtrietDlrvotor'v deeifioft by *a. Ijai^rvtloo J^do*^ aod that tb*vatrd'i dgr. 0.6 I fi II Dec.32 (BZ 19T7}, to the Xtat thtt it iaplled that theTmnTgratloa ôdge or the. Board h4 jurlv^letloa orr tbeDistrict &ir*ctor'a decision IQ rl**io& attar. Ig. at 4.

applylb? th* eKabfcer p aaalyai* need by th* Board lathis court fiodf that aaA29 753 ?0


10/31

WR-16-1993 16=43 F R O M * nottMrtr*dar*. or if co bwaring i ro^*-tdperiod/ and th* t*t of a p*raat>nt r*idnt w aee>irdthrmgn ad ctiwmt of tttttC voder vectioat 24 $ O C 2 4 9 oftbe Xet, th DUtriat Director t lMU rescind tho pr*rioaalyC/raated t*tBf aad no auoaal Bh al l tie from > i i n dectelon.fifit. * C.7.X. $242.2 (tph4i Added). 73ns, if Urwrpoadtat't taeo fall* vithln UM acop* of 8 c.r.K. S2


11/31

r-W?-16-1993 16:44 PRO-P KEG IONfiL COUNSEL EftSTERN TOm?-l&-1993 15=22 FRCM INS t&ffK U-ftS TO

GEN. COUN. HQ P.07RDCOU P.07

Go TIn c*s t bar, tj applicant ftllftd to fila in anewerto tb Hotlc* of Intnt to JtMeiod vithln th* thirty-4r orto re


12/31

w - Inrnlgratioa Jodys or tb Board hasthat uflif lfffrnrHrlm * jralArasfc totlw Xaai ratioa JlgBctioa, b clwll lafo* th*tbst pro7idu tba eU*cifid Infotwtioa toZoaigrttiOD JMf* ay prorid* aatontxy of tl iaformtttoa for relocaa to tltait dctcraiaM it C C A da *a eoaijtttttly vltkboti tb* elifUd natnr* of tb*iafnation ca d it twirc*. Tb* raastty Blxwld be Mdtaild poiblo, la erdar that th applieaetbairt aa opportunity to o f f r oppociAf a-ridae, Adtoitjcm baMd la wbol* or in part on uea clanlfidinforoctloa hall ctat* tliat ouca infonorcion L mtrial to ta d*cition.

X25 7S3 750


13/31

MRR-16-1993 IB-4S FRO1 * .GIONfiL COUNSEL EASTERN TOM3R-16-1993 15:Z3 FRCM IKE SQPR< LLflS TO

GEN. COJN. HO P.09RDCDU P.09

U. S . Dprtaat of States advitory opiniontf*td Octobc 21, 1992 and urfcod a* exhibit Ho. i, and tWapplicant hu b*n tfLran tha opportunity to offer oppoit>9ridtacv*

lit THR LECM, MTLPX AK POP DgPQRTATTQII

AI*

i .

In liro of txcluioa tad dcportctioo* tho applicanta*yln *a4 wi.tW>oldtv of dwportrtU w, fey^eectiorw 20 8 utd 2 4) ( b > of th A individaiiwh o orrt th dofinition of & "rafugoa, " u provided in101(4) (42) (X ) of th Act. This prtnricioe 9 to rvturn to, vad ! c&tbl* or

to cvxll hlscolf or bertlf of theprotection of that ooontry bcu of parovoatioaor a v*Ll>foa4ed fr of p*r*ccrtion oa account ofr*c, rtll ion, ntiontlity, nabr


14/31

, (WR-16-1993 16:45 FROM * GIONftL COUNSEL EPSTERN TOMPR-16-1993 15:24 FRCM IhS N30PR< LLfiS TO

GEN. COUN. HO P. 10

RCODU P.18

Kff t tg r of Kogharrtbi. 1 Z f Dec. 4S (BJA 1967} that *reasonable person 047 fear porsecotiori even if tJellVallhood that persecution a*y occur 1* Ignificastly !than a clear probability. Ttr* Board of J*ioT*tlon Appeal*delineated tne vell-foanded fear standard thtt tb alienuurt hr of Xoc t: . 19 ZOT D*c. 2Uend nocU_fii. guora. Objectir* faeta tabllxlMd} erdibl aad pervoasir* testinony of tbOov sot saica tbo facta law objvctiTa74) r.2d s (Ttb Cir* ISM);

767 F.2d 1277 . furtlMraara-, agrant of a*ylua ic ovwr naodatory. T he Inntgratica jodgemay daar Mylow ia too xrci* of discretion to aa alienvno ectabliabea etatutory eligiaility for relief. IKS y..s. 421Tb* re


15/31

.f?-16-1993 16:46 FROn \LCOUNSEL EASTERN TOM3R-16-199G 15:24. FRCM 1^6 t&&(. LLPS TO

GEN. COM. HO P.11RDCDU P.11

for withholding of deportation, tho alin othow that MJ "iif or fmdos would to* Uur*tn*


16/31

MPR-16-1993 16:46 FROM ^ .pUeatioarthe applicant usorts tint heopenly criticised tbathy do not ffctnt th Xvloic L.*v (SburUh),though Kgjyt i a Ilal B* dt*ia*d for *tgbtaontkc, vltltovt knovioa tb ca*oji for hi dttfofcioa orrl*aiM. 8 ttd tbat dnriag- Uii dtntioOf IM wasQ^M*Monadt baxton, tortnrd asxl denied food andMdlcins torait hi haalUi -*ita*tioa. B rtitd that b* wac Dote&irg*d with -any crim nd rwt broo^bt b*(onr a tribws*!.Tba court cotas that tb* ajiplicaat. noaiatd t r*ald*at Laatr thi* Incident.Tb applicant testified that h-J- aocood arrest _oecarr*disOctober of If SI, vfaan polio* uvrouadad his hooJM, tookhia awr and ipi?iood nia for thrM r*rf, witboatinitially *t*tiog th r*oa' for bU rr*t. Owriag hisincaxoorxtioa, th tfovatoncut ch*rod tb* pplicaat with twoordering *twabfi/,* or rlloloo opinion, taffoeto&t* th s*stiatloo of PridJt Juarar Ci4t| tadin ormrthrowtng too oiritttng!. Tba

tb* described ab proo*djgmrby t*tio


17/31

MflR-16-1993 16:47 FRO SEGIONPL COUNSEL EASTERN TO

MPR-16-1993 15:25 FRO1 1K B hEL4=R


18/31

MOR-16-1993 16=M oo tb TlM la KovMfMf of 1940rtated Mtt b left the Tto4t4 t*t iA Deoeaber 1590trmreled to Denmark for on* wk, ad appereotlr rwtnrned tothe Oaitdet*ta en t4e Mn* vi*. Zh* Applicant tMtifiwitnatf before fttteaptln? to eater the Dalt*d t*t*s la Julyof 1991r IM iMt Mtcrod tb* United 8tt* on P*eeobtt 16,1990 AS Avisitor foe plAAAttr*. Tb applicant a*ert< thatb ba* not retttraed to 3ypt tic* lAA-rtn la 1990, aadf>r ti*t Lf be rtwrn to Xgypt, 'tbey [tbe ooeraaeat)

will *t op cbry AO lnirt 0e to pot aw In privoa or killno'In Addition to mntirfering the applicant twtinony,tni court Colly cad carefully -conldrd auaaroua plcc oforidoacv pocificAllf cvlctiag ta the Applicant aai tbftott of Airs in Xojptf InclodingZ/i Ikatic* to ..O Q JAOoAiy 20, 1993, tb*

cttoa tad iaclodd la t]ft, V, 0 Wd D, bQVtTttf, tbeparti** that each

wcdotd foeef proctdiag

loch xBlM.te Are tdeatlflad AS followit Ivttorfrom Jans Xlolcfalello, Barrloe TrlAl AtVwmij, dated October27, 1992 nqoecfciag thAt tbe uodflrwlooed Accept AclAAYifiAd report into tbe record, pormAat to 8C.F.B.0.ll A0d 23.3(c)(4) (Xxbiblt A ) j Applicant'*Xotlcm for XntatcroffAtorle* 6 ftvqat for Production ofOocuat (Xxhibit 8)7 fArrlCA xaaorafldnai la C5ppo*ition toApplicant Notion for InterrogatorLM c y*qa*t forA29 753 780


19/31

'MPR-16-1993 16:43 F RO M ( . G I O K W L COUNSEL EflSTHRN TOtTR-16-1993 15:2 F R O M IhS hBJ5R< LLPS TO

JEN. COLN. HQ P. 15ROCDU P.15

I>l

Applicant tor Mai Ion D*tlnd for R*trlns 8foroXjnalgration Jud? (fora 1-122) (Sx&Ibit H o. I) / D . f i .p*prttKJot of Justice, Immigrat ion nd JUturaliMtionTom I-UO (Exhibit *fo. 2 ) f paekaa* of docmxlt,M otion to TmUtt r*clu*ton prod**diatf,counsel's lettar of Joo 9, 1972 Indicating applicant'sdesire to ubtJLtat* .eoan>lf ooun*l'* l*ttur of Jttae 10,1992 ddr*d to applicant'* forvcr C OOAMI, Loacmtorvd by th aodrlgtod on July t> W2 orantiJD7pplicaot'v r*?u**t to obtJ.tut cotml (Exhibit Bo. 3);ajrylca cppllettion [roca I-M9) tiled on Jttn 11, 1932(Exhibit H o. 4); tcylua application [fora I-SM) filed on orA a y u r t 27, 1992, counsel's lettr of A o ^ ut t 25, 1992th*t a Etatfi Department Advjjiory opinion beaad applicant'* affidavit fil*d on Awgrast 13,inin^ It*a /33 o F Q C B * J-B89 (rchibit So. S)|u ac lM lf i < S D.f. Dopcrtaoot of fft*t aflrLtory opinion datedOotob* 23, 1992 (Exhibit Ho. rpvr article* reUtiac to tbe epplicant; (ExhibitK o. t}r C30uasl' letter, dated January IS, 1992, eaolosia?teaoaty mterrntional^Retiert* far 1986, 367, 19W aad 1990(RxfrLbit K o. 10); Application for F*raaaat Kosloence filedoa January 31, 1991 (TrMbit Bo. 11); eooBlttees on PoreigoKlttoos cad roreiott affairs, 102d Coog., 1st S8.r1985.

lf9Q aad 1221 (rtbU.it Bo. 15J; er articles2/ (ooot.) Prod^otioa of Oocoxwnt* (Exhibit C ) jXaooraodua of L*w to Support Zsoigncctioo Jodoe's Aothorityto Vacate District Director's "R*ci*ioa issues* inJUdttsioa Bft4rin7s (Xxhibit D ).

A t en iadlvidaal ocleodar b#riog held on octob** 27,3992, applicant's attorney objected to tlw iaolotio { tb*.caclaaslflad XJ.. pepartatot of 8ttt ~dated October 23, 1993 (exhibit *o. ), into the record ofprooe*4to7 oatil counsel CUrf isterrooxtorie* t beasveged by tba- CT.f. Depai'tiaaut of state, the TOd*r*igodorernle


20/31

fW-16-1993 16 = 43 FROM*


21/31

, r .fiR-16-1993 16:49 FROI1{GI ONflL COUNSEL EfiSTERN TOn=R-l&-1933 15:Z7 FRO1 ihE I-UW< LLfS TO

G E N . COUN. HQ P. 17RXOJ P.17

I \ !

i!

/

th applicant a*y tsar bouo arrest ox mn futurethe Xgyptian yuei:iwieat lor poil_biyJsryptian iw, this court Ooee not belt* thatj*r*ctioa" and procutloa" are on* and tha M**.Prosecution, a* a legitimate exercise o oortkrnitt, Is notpor*etxtlon. fifif Kattgr of A-0-. 15 I t R Dc. 502 (BIA.1787), aff^q rub jjfla^ ?. .X. v. I.H.B., 858 f.3d 210 (4thCir.1 9 9 0 ) (m base). TriWAl* of th Onitod Ctt do act9nnair ralnat thA political juctificctionf Of tbaction* of tcrviga g ranxMist*. Id. at 608, citingKaY*h'BtofaigY T> t.g.s.. 78J F.M 1321 {9th Cir. 1M6J.

rha court. fidi that ti* tpplioaat fallM to *tabllabthat be f f tu r s *pencntlon" dafia*4 by the Act. Theapplicant tuu ail*d to KtablLh a fear of p**t prscutionor tat hi* f*r La vll-fowxJd. Tor xo lc, thac llczct failf to sbov that th OorerttMst has CheincHnrtjea to praiafe bin* Oodar th Ia>j.u


22/31

MflR-16-1993 16=49 FROM ( GIONflL COLKGEL EASTERN TOMPR-16-1993 15:27 FROM ISB hEU*5< LLPS TO

GEN. COUN. HQ P.:RCCOJ P. 18

narrating about 'tiixunv fr*doa i th oait


23/31

MfiR-16-1993 16=58 RROf( REGIONAL COUNSEL EASTERN TOMPR-ier-1993 1529FRCM INS NBJSRK LLPS TO

GEN. COUN. HQ P. 19ROCOU P.19

The applicant ttlfid that h* viit


24/31

".M*-16-l993 1650 FROM f IGIONfiL COUNSEL EASTERN TO \315:29 FRO1 IhG SeLPFfrC LLflSEN. COJN. HQ P.28ROCOJ P.20

vjl>a particular tocial group, or political opinion.4 4 7 , Tb applicant did not a t r t oteou. of

ifl. atthat b < *n*tionalLty, nordoo* th rvi4nc of record land itaalf to such a claix.T b* applicant does not assert or establish that be fearsP*CMtioa on aoctroot o ib*riap l p*rtLclgroup. In fct, tb applicant i^ciiic*llyin *or orgvnlxxtloa, ltho9b tbdri9C7 oplAioo (SxU it R o. t),(XxMl>it K c. 12), and nw*papr urtiolesK O . 11} all*7 ctbrtri*. tt applicant did oot uicrt orth*t h ftara p*reoutioa on ccoont otb* pcUiC*lir tntifibd tbt bo oppow*Ut Rcjjrtian Oov*meot for aot otrictly tpplyiegtb* Il*aio ty,l2/ ttMTtonr tiw only crgr&Mat that tbaAppLictat U*7*, aod O 4A prtvtil on, i* hi* alleyed fewo pz-**euUjan oa account of political opinion.

:JTh court fiM tb*t th ppllc*nt hu net wtahlitdthat b r p*r*Otttioo on .. occmnt ^_of bi* poU-tlcal

opinion. Tb cpplictat tMtifivd tb*t b* twganao an tictant ptatttmor at th ocrrrnnt runTTniwrvity ia 1973. E* m t m t m r n tb*t la 19U, vfaen cl**dfrcm tbr* yaar tar of incatcratioQf be v t t anafmzuUto another job* witbin th oniT rcity, vbr b 'prayftd toOod nod t*ach [*io) at any plaa*.m TtM applicant 6nltt*dth*t tb Zoyptlaa Comment raa AI-JUb*r QnlTcnity tad the1989.

cogaraaoat paid fplicaat a aalazy xtutil th *nd ofZt *MO iaorvdiblft to tba ooort, that to* cgyptianwould prr tb applicant a salary ftoa1973through tha aod of 1988 to har* th cpplloast teteb andporvo* r*Uoioa aotiritii a to* applicant w txr and atetb* Mfi tift*, pariocuto th applleaat for his politicalopinion.Tbo applicant tt_Ula4 rpmitdly that tba XayptJLaacourt* dlsoUffd all ehaxo** r*r %roght aotifitDpita his noaaroov urvttt* tb apnlloaot has aartrceorlotad of ortninal chC7* * With thi* ia miad, itthat tit* tgyptlaa triboaalv. Which arm part of tb Oovmcm*at, ar fair ia th dainlctratioa of juiticv, aw tdo not pr*cata- or dlaoriainat* oo aecoaat of a daadatr*political opinion. Thlc ooort thacvfttr* ral that thOocrts U1 lltely gira the applicant a fair trial/charges b* lodod gaiast hl la Bgypt.hoold

tba applicant assarts that b* s btttan andpbymically aboaad by th* VoyptLaa polio* and Oorvrnaant* tb*applicant mutt show or thta nlstrstast(t to establishparsvcotioa oador tha Act, *(X]n order to prow'on cocunt of' env of tb nvpvrat


25/31

FRQH(flR-16-1993 16:51 FROM! . EGIONPL COUNSEL EASTERN TOMPR-16-1933 15:29 FROM INS KBJPRK LLPS TO

UO\ tdo aor* than ' nov oitrto*nt by th* < fparticvljur v*"P* Hatter .ef r-. Intri D*oi*ton O167,

p.10 (BIX 1)92).Additionally, to th extant that th* applicant fararwtriburtioa orr panoa*! di*4$r**n*at* with th* Xgyptian7r*aidnt, Xin* applicant O)0* a aot ap* ifically *atahliah w h A n ^ why*ho*, or who p*r**cat*d hia in th pat or vill pacooout*him in th* futur*, on accou&t of hia political opinion, U r niaply laborat*d on bit tlx prior arr**tr cn*rtllted of

Oovuxiuuviit &latrv*ts)OQt aad vtat d th* isau*a upon vhion h*criticizes th* OoraranKtb. Mcaut* th* applicant

GEN. COUN. HO P.21ROCOJ P.21

or

f*il* Act.Third, to CM wctcnt that ti* applicant cannotdaoatrat* vt&tctory ali lbllity for aaylna, it follow*ttutt h* oaaoot t*t*Sliso vtctutor? lio^bilitj- Eo rvithbolding of dporttioa nattmr pf T-. pqnr*. citing

848 ?.2d BM, 1007 (9th Cir.Th appliemat sat daoooctrat* tbxt "it i nor* likely thannot* b vould b rabjoct to parBocotioa if rnuic*d tor*tut ft to hi* filtir* la&d, Mhicta ia a J B O T * vtri&gaatthan that rqir*d for legibility of aayliau nffl467 U.S. 407, 429*20 (1984). Xovrrer/ ra iftb applicant cas *tablish that th gtatotary rvqoiraoentefor asylwa bara boon tr tbt ridtwt ia thia oaa do*a notdacoatrt that it ia oat* litaly than oat that; U C thappliowrt; oo imUtoad to tgrpv ta would b*wi-tbin tbt mnslat of th Act. mil* the ayplicw* ayacr%t or vra future iaprisaoAtst by tintbi ooort Oov* not btliar* that itUkly Ua act that th vTrnattt woald pBrvcoot** withintb ftaala? of th Act. th Xgypciaa way proMOttt*" m * aIfrgitiaat* excrciv* of goymrajMmt. H rtqmrt for mehtfflOlof art tborvfor* b dnid. fififl (li)(l) oCtba A c t jTKS v. Ctrric, 467D.S. 407 (194)| t C.IMU $208.16 (1992).

Fourth, Y T O if th Application aatablifhtts that fa* haa w14. fooad6 f*c of p*r*oatloo oa account of hi* raca,religion, n.tioa*lltjrr Diecaberahip ia - a particularor politic*! opiniottf hit asylua application nai:A79 753 7SO


26/31

MPR-16-1993 16=52 FRO GIONOL COUNSEL EASTERN TOMPft-16-1993 15:29 R331 IKS KO*PR< LLflS TO

GEN. COUN. HQ p.22ROCOJ P. 22

because tb* applicant has failed to artablUh tfct beraerite itrylvn relief as a iutter of discretion. Throughoutthe proceeding*, the applicant failed to tnever questionsspecifically and directly, doepite e reral re of th Aot, forml>r*prtftfittioe cf cJttarial ftct, oajnaly, for C&illag tohla yriof *rrl*go oo hif adjoctasnt of it*tuaBwctioo 2I)(it)(Xl> of tb* Act, for FTctioir>gl3( fc)(2)(X) of th Act for * coarlct of a cria* ivrolvin? "Ctrtl tcrpitud*, in tint, Applicant W * f lfOQfid Guilty Of tlur** OOttlTt* OEf*lttflO*tiOfl Of prlTC*not* -cbqa, (or wbitfls It* vti Macaot4 to thrvt natrthii*prl*oranaat for th* coorLctloo*; aa ClaiOly/ pornuit toctloo 213(a)(6){C) of ti Aotr Cor failing to diclooneb rrts aod ooorictlon* ct tit* tifi of &U Leterriowfor

court pzoriod th pplioiat witi> en upportanity tocpliay *ad rbot tb- satcrlal. TlM applirmfc, infaotr xrvr*o: la hit CJcstawnt of rttu Applioctioa.(Xxhlbit Ko. 11} dtS J*imary 30, 1991, that h* btd oarerboon B*rri*d bfor. tfloa ZxbibU 11 p. 1 Q. 20).nirtbux, tb* ppliort tnwr*d in bis to^wtawst of ctctiuiapplication tbct b* i not * polyfoolct and Oooo notadvoott* poLy^ooy. (fitj. bbibit U, p. 2, Q. 26(O)>.cwpit tb*M affirMtioos, turn appli


27/31

MPR-16-199J 16=52 FROM V GIONfiL OXNSEL EASTERN TOMPR-16-1993 15:30 PRCM 1KB KBJ^RK LLPS TO

GEN. COUN. HQ P.23ROCOL) P.23

to not ttnt*ralbd. TT* cowt thcforapplicant' candor in testify!*! daring th procwdiiigB andansv*ring tb* that the applicant ba* a f*w thouaaad followr* w f a o bar*

raopeecihl* for eo&dttccino tpectacolar terrorist(coat.) ia 1751. ttw ajpltotoc admit* that it iriolKtioa of Xgyptica Lt to t placo of noraWp forantl-gotaraaat paobi, aad teita that b* critieixad tteCOTiunat through poh*< in tb*Tinally, th tpplicaat amrarvd ia hi* djoatMt of

tppUwttion (Trtirpit Vd. U) that te bad had notao>eet*d. oe taogbt by pvrtoaal vttaranc*. by vritton orprintsnattr* cr through affillatioa with aa organixatloa,cppotition to orgaitd get+rattenl. tSft ftrttihlt 11 p. 2rQ. 2(D)(1)). Doepit* thi* affixjutioa, tha applicant, iafact, aaMxti ia hi tvrtiaooy aad a*yiua application thatIt* roiood oppoaition to aad oritieiMd Egyptiangovoi-nuMint throogh anirraity aYBpoainate and aava aeditm,aad: throagb ornxm* t a*)U* lao a**). CESS rxTiibit Ko.5, atylun application, at Fart C, p, 2.) . .753"' 75'B-


28/31

FRO!ttR-16-1993 16:53 FROM REGICNQL COUNSEL EASTERN TOMPFM6-1933 15:30 FROM IKS tLPR< LLPS TO

GEN. COUN. HO P. 24RDCDU P.24

including: the assassination of President An*ar(1961); U JMLntioo o the Cpockar of the?opl'a Assembly, Xife't Al-Xahgoob (10| 'icoBpenlaaaj attacks *


29/31


30/31

.- MfiR-16-1993 16:54 FROtlf EGIONRL COUNSEL EASTERN TOMSR-16-1993 15:31 FRCM I K G N3JRR< ILfG TO GEN. COUN. HO P.26ROOXI P.2S._ , will n*ndtorily dsny bio t pllcAtixsa forin tha Onitd 5t*t, purruuxt to th r7vl.&tion.CM Kppllcan't'* withholding of deportation cpplicrtloathtt th tttttory r*


31/31

WITHDRAWAL NOTICERG: 148 Expo sition, Ann iversary, and Memorial Comm issionsSERIES: 9/11 Comm ission, Team 5

NND PROJECT NUMBER: 51630 FOIA CASE NUM BER: 30768WITHDRAWAL DATE: 09/24/2008


^C^ESSRESTOICTEDThe item identified below has been withdrawn from this file:

FOLDER TITLE: DOS Documents - NIV [1 of 5]DOCUMENT DATE: 07/10/1992 DOC UM ENT TYPE: MemorandumFROM: Assistant Director in ChargeTO: Coordinator for CounterterrorismSUBJECT: Omar Abdelrahman

This document has been withdrawn for the following reason(s):9/11 C lassified Information

9/11 Law E nforcement Privacy

WITHDRAWAL NOTICE

T5 B59 DOS Docs- NIV 1 of 5 Fdr- man 5 Withdrawal Notices- Immigration Judge Decision

Documents

Transcript of T5 B59 DOS Docs- NIV 1 of 5 Fdr- man 5 Withdrawal Notices- Immigration Judge Decision