T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to...

27
© NMISA 2013 TRACEABILITY OF SPECTROPHOTOMETRIC MEASUREMENTS TO THE HIGHEST STANDARD OF CALIBRATION Refuoe Pepenene Test and Measurement conference (09 October 2013)

Transcript of T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to...

Page 1: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

TRACEABILITY OF SPECTROPHOTOMETRIC

MEASUREMENTS TO THE HIGHEST STANDARD

OF CALIBRATION

Refuoe PepeneneTest and Measurement conference (09 October 2013)

Page 2: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Layout

• Introduction• Traceability• NMISA Mission• Reference Transmittance Spectrophotometer (RTS)• Measurements technique and the results• Conclusion

Page 3: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Introduction

Regular transmittance - form basis of number of quantities used in spectrophotometer

Such as:Optical density (absorbance)Molar Absorptivity

Industries:PharmaceuticalsAnalytical ChemistrySugar MillingManufactures of: (glass, optical materials and coating)Research Institute

Page 4: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Introduction cont

• Regular Transmittance is measured

• It is customary to express transmittance as a percentage:

• Absorbance can be obtained using Lambert law :

II

T0

=

1000

×=II

T

=

IIA 0log

=

TA1

log

Page 5: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• For analytical purposes, two main propositions define the laws of light absorbance.

• Lambert's law:

• Beer’s law :

• Combination of the two laws - Beer-Lambert Law ,- Which defines the relationship between absorbance (A)and transmittance (T).

=

TA1

log

clA ε=

clTI

IA ε=

=

= 1

loglog 0

Page 6: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• Wavelength accuracy and photometric / absorbanceaccuracy is important for the spectrophotometry.

• Spectrophotometer needs to show compliance with test procedures and, have documented evidence for data integrity.

• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards.

• To ensure equivalent measurements regardless of theinstrument design or region of the world wheremeasurements are made.

Introduction Cont.

Page 7: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Traceability

• NMISA obtain traceability via NPL spectral transmittance scale,

• Participated in the inter-comparison.• For end users to establish traceability, reference

standard filters traceable to National Metrology Institute are use to validate the measurement technique employed.

Page 8: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• Establishes - national scale for regular spectraltransmittance measurements.

• Linked to the primary transmittance scale by means ofoptical filter reference standards,

• Manufactured and calibrated at the National PhysicalLaboratory (NPL) in United Kingdom.

Reference Transmittance Spectrophotometer

(RTS)

Page 9: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Diagram Reference Transmittance

Spectrophotometer

Page 10: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

1) To maintain the national transmittance/absorbancescale and,

2) Disseminate it for the benefit of local laboratories,industries, and others who need the highest accuracymeasurements.

NMISA Mission:

Page 11: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• Sending the spectrophotometer to the calibrationlaboratory - be costly and cumbersome.

• Limitations due to sample compartment size.• Ideal approach – use of reference standards.• Standards need to be certified by either a National

Metrology Institute or an accredited calibrationlaboratory.

• Wavelength accuracy - Holmium oxide solution,Holmium oxide glass filters or Didymium oxide glassfilters.

• Photometric accuracy (absorbance accuracy) - neutraldensity filters / solutions.

Verification of spectrophotometer (Reference Transmittance Spectrophotometer & End user

Spectrophotometer)

Page 12: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Wavelength accuracyMaintenance (RTS)

Photometric scale accuracyMaintenance (RTS)

Linearity of photo-detectorMaintenance (RTS)

End user (Neutral Density & Holmium filter) Dissemination

End User’s Spectrophotometer

Maintenance & Dissemination Transmittance /

Absorbance Scale

Page 13: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Measurement Technique and results

• Operational performance and data quality optimised toinclude wide range of spectral regions.

• For the purpose of this presentation, UV/Vis data isdiscussed.

• Wavelength Accuracy ( Example)- Range (200 nm – 800 nm)- Bandwidth setting: 2 nm- Selected Absorbance peaks measured and compared

with NPL valuesSELECTED ABSORBANCE MAXIMA

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

200 300 400 500 600 700 800

Wavelength (nm)

Abs

orba

nce

(Abs

)

12

3

4

5

67

810

9

Page 14: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

(RTS) Wavelength Accuracy

Page 15: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• Absorbance peak values – are reproducible and withinNPL uncertainties.

• Performance of the moving mechanical components(responsible for positioning the monochromatorcomponents) stable.

(RTS) Wavelength Accuracy Cont.

588

588.2

588.4

588.6

588.8

589

589.2

589.4

2001 2004 2007 2010 2013

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Interval

e) Wavelength of absorption maxima (588,57nm)

NMISA

NPL

Page 16: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Photometric Scale

• Transmittance filters having different nominaltransmittance levels (low, medium and high) selected

• Range (200 nm – 800 nm)• Bandwidth setting: 2nm• Average transmittance values over a period of nine

years presented• NMISA values - compared with NPL valuesLinearity

• Filter set used, Range (200 nm – 800 nm)• NMISA values plotted against NPL values

Page 17: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

RTS Photometric Scale

• Average measurement data reproducible• Stability of photometric scale adequate• Variation that might occur during the calibration will not

limit the precision and accuracy of the measured data

Page 18: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• The photo-detector linearity is appropriate over thetransmittance / absorbance range of calibration.

• Output signal of the photo-detector system is proportional tothe input signal.

• Transmittance values vary from 0,08% to 80%,• This correspond to absorbance values 3 to 0,09.

RTS Linearity check

Page 19: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Calibration of End user’s Reference Standards

Neutral density filter• Absorbance measured at wavelength 420 nm, 480 nm,

546 nm, 600 nm and 700 nm.• Bandwidth setting 2nm,

Page 20: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Calibration of End user’s Reference Standards

Holmium oxide filter• Spectral measurement range (200 nm – 800 nm),

Bandwidth setting 2nm.• Nominal wavelength of selected absorption peaks

measured.• Expanded uncertainty (k=2) of the wavelength values

was ± 0,4 nm .

Page 21: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

End user (Neutral Density Filters)

2.49

2.5

2.51

2.52

2.53

2.54

2.55

2.56

2.57

2.58

Abs

orba

nce(Abs)

Wavelength (420 nm) 2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2012

2.28

2.29

2.3

2.31

2.32

2.33

2.34

2.35

2.36

Abs

orba

nce

(Abs

)

Wavelength (480 nm) 2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2012

2013

2.29

2.3

2.31

2.32

2.33

2.34

2.35

2.36

2.37

2.38

Abs

orba

nce

(Abs

)

Wavelength (546 nm) 2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2012

2.32

2.33

2.34

2.35

2.36

2.37

2.38

2.39

2.4

Abs

orba

nce

(Abs

)

Wavelength (600 nm) 2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2012

Page 22: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

End user (Neutral Density Filters) Cont.

• Measured absorbance within the claimed uncertainty.• Spectrophotometer is capable of reproducing the values

through the years.

1.795

1.8

1.805

1.81

1.815

1.82

1.825

1.83

1.835

1.84

1.845

Abs

orba

nce

(Abs

)

Wavelength (700 nm) 2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2012

Page 23: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

End-user (Holmium oxide filter)

286.5

287

287.5

288

288.5

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (287,5 nm)

360.2360.4360.6360.8

361361.2361.4361.6

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (361,0 nm)

418

418.5

419

419.5

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (419,0 nm)

278

278.5

279

279.5

280

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (278,8 nm)

Page 24: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

End-user (Holmium oxide filter) Cont.

445.6445.8

446446.2446.4446.6446.8

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (446,2 nm)

459

459.5

460

460.5

461

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (460,3 nm)

536536.2536.4536.6536.8

537537.2537.4

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (536,7 nm)

637

637.5

638

638.5

639

2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Wav

elen

gth

(nm

)

Calibration Year

Peak wavelength (637,4 nm)

Page 25: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

• Absorbance peaks within the claimed uncertainty.• Spectrophotometer is capable of reproducing the values

through the years.

End-user (Holmium oxide filter) Cont.

Page 26: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Conclusion

• Verification tests facilitate the acceptance and use ofthe reference transmittance spectrophotometer todisseminate the transmittance/absorbance scale withgreat confidence.

• Calibration of the End user filters - calibration valuesare within NMISA claimed uncertainty and traceable toprimary reference standards.

• Through traceability the laboratory’s qualityconsciousness and reputation will be enhanced, whichwill further support its commitment to analyticalexcellence in the competitive global marketplace.

Page 27: T309 Traceability of spectrophotometric …...• In addition, measurements also required to demonstrate traceability to the national standards. • To ensure equivalent measurements

© NMISA 2013

Acknowledgements:

Dr. Angelique Botha Dr. Clive OliphantElsie Coetzee Margaret BudzinskiMariesa Nel