T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the...

44
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS CUSTOM HOUSE, IS/I, STRAND ROAD, KOLKATA - 700 001 F.No.S.51(Misc)-12/2018 Estt. Dated: 04.09.2018 ESTABLISHMENT CIRCULAR NO. 90/2018 As decided in the meeting held on 26.06.18 regarding revision of seniority lists of Direct Recruits and Promotees in the cadre of LDCs on the basis of the outcome of Judgement in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated for wide publicity among employees of the Custom House. Representation/ clarification if any against the above report may be submitted to the undersigned along with valid documentary evidence within ten (10) days of publication of the report. The report can be accessed in the officialwebsite of Kolkata Customs. . (M~~\""\T Additional Commissioner of Customs (CCO) Custom House, Kolkata Copy to:- 1. PAto Commissioner (A&A) 2. Chairman of Review Committee and ADC, CCO 3. The Hony. Secretary, Calcutta Customs Employees Association. 4. The Hony. Secretary, Kolkata Customs Ministerial Officers' Association. S. Notice Board 6. Kolkata Customs Website

Transcript of T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the...

Page 1: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

GOVERNMENT OF INDIAOFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS

CUSTOM HOUSE, IS/I, STRAND ROAD, KOLKATA - 700 001

F.No.S.51(Misc)-12/2018 Estt. Dated: 04.09.2018

ESTABLISHMENT CIRCULAR NO. 90/2018

As decided in the meeting held on 26.06.18 regarding revision of seniority lists of

Direct Recruits and Promotees in the cadre of LDCs on the basis of the outcome of Judgement

in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the

Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018.

The report is hereby circulated for wide publicity among employees of the Custom

House.

Representation/ clarification if any against the above report may be submitted to the

undersigned along with valid documentary evidence within ten (10) days of publication of the

report.

The report can be accessed in the officialwebsite of Kolkata Customs.

. (M~~\""\TAdditional Commissioner of Customs (CCO)

Custom House, Kolkata

Copy to:-

1. PA to Commissioner (A&A)2. Chairman of ReviewCommittee and ADC,CCO3. The Hony. Secretary, Calcutta Customs Employees Association.4. The Hony. Secretary, Kolkata Customs Ministerial Officers' Association.S. Notice Board6. Kolkata Customs Website

Page 2: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

m®~@uu[?@u

m®oVOM([lUO@lli) @V~®lli)D@uDUW [SD~u

@[?

[S@w®u [])owo~O@lli) ©D®u~

Page 3: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

1. Introduction:-

A Committee consisting of the following ministerial Officers/staff constituted with the approval

of the competent authority for preparing the seniority list of the ministerial staff in terms of order of the

Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal NO.7514-7515 of 2005 in the case of N.R. Parmar & Ors. Vs. Union

of India & Ors.

SI. No.1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.ll.12.13.14.15.

Name (Shri/Smt./Km.)Barun RoySoumitra ChakrabortyNaba Kumar DasSanjib GhoshBimalendu SenPrasanta Kumar BasuUday Sankar BhattacharyaArun Kr. MeheraShankha ChakrabortyKhamchin HauSanjib PaulAbhijit BandyopadhyayManoj BiswasOebi Prasad SardarSanjit Kumar Bose

DesignationE.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.A.O.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.A.O.E.A.E.A.

DepartmentVigilanceSTRC(Port)EstablishmentAccountsAccountsM.e.O.EstablishmentAccountsEstablishmentEstablishmentCBSectionCB SectionC.C.O.Sevottam (Port)M.e.O.

One more staff Sri Ahmed Ameer Khushroo, Tax Assistant, intended to work as a member of this

committee and represented for the same. A.e. (P & E) has directed to incorporate his submission in the

report of the above mentioned committee.

The committee was provided with the CBEC order No.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated

08/09/2014 containing instructions for fixing inter-se seniority of Direct recruits and promotees.

The CBECorder No.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated 08/09/2014 issued in pursuance of DOP&T's

O.M. No.20011/1/2012-Estt.{O) dated 04/03/2014 and containing DOP&T's clarification to CBECthereof.

However, it is also clarified that the seniority fixed under the provisions of OM dated 3.3.2008 is liable to

be re-visited. Further, this advice/clarification and clause 5{h) of the OM dated 4/3/2014 complement

each other and are not contradictory in that the provisions of OM dated 7.2.1986/3.7.1986 will apply till

27/11/2012, after which the circular dated 4/3/2014 will apply. And it is also clarified in para 5{i) of O.M.

dated 04.03.2014 of DOP&T that the cases of seniority already settled with reference to the applicable

interpretation of the term availability, as contained in DOP&T OM dated 07.02.1986/3.7.1986 may not

be re-opened.

On verification of the earlier seniority list published vide following Estt. Order it is observed that

the LDCsnominated by the SSCwere not placed in the seniority list as per the date of requisition sent to

SSe. The sequence of Direct Recruit candidates i.e., Direct recruit through SSCgiven priority followed by

the Direct recruit meritorious sports person and then the Direct recruit through Surplus Cell followed by

the Direct recruit on Compassionate ground has been followed as per the extant Rules and Guidelines.

1. Estt. Circular No.146/86 dated 04/06/1986 vide F.No.S.51-79/86 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;

2. Estt. Circular No.45/88 dated 09/03/1988 vide F.No.S.51-44/88 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;

Page 4: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

3. Estt. Circular No.173/89 dated 06/12/1989 vide F.No.S.51-116/89 EsU.-Seniority List of LDCs;

~4. EsU. Circular No.140/91 dated 04/12/1991 vide F.No.S.51-149/91 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;

5. EsU. Circular No.49/94 dated 05/3/1994 vide F.No.S.51-27/94 EsU.-Seniority List of LDCs;

6. Estt. Circular No.52/99 dated 15/6/1999 vide F.No.S.51-159/98 EsU(Pt.}.-Seniority List of LDCs;

7. EsU. Circular No.74/2007 dated 1/6/2007 vide F.No.S.51-48/2002 EsU.-Seniority List of LDCs;

In view of the same it is proposed to revise the seniority list and placed the Direct recruit LDCs in

the draft seniority list as per the date of requisition. Accordingly the amended seniority list of LDC has

been prepared subject to approval by the competent authority.

2. Inter Commissionerate transfer:

In respect of re-fixation of seniority of the Direct recruit LDCs who have joined in this CCA on

Inter Commissionerate transfer basis it may be mentioned here that as per tetter issued vide no.C-

18012/9/2012-Ad.IIB of CBECdated 03/08/2017 issued in terms of the judgement dated 03/08/2012 of

Hon'ble CAT, Chandigarh Bench in O.A. No.338/PB/2012 in the case of Balwinder Singh Matharoo & Ors.

vs. Union of India the seniority may be fixed as per joining in the feeder cadre in the parent

Commissionerate. It is not clear from the available documents which date will be considered for

determining seniority whether his date of joining in the parent Commissionerate/directorates or from

the date of requisition sent to SSCas per the judgement delivered in N.R.Parmar case. The re-fixation of

seniority of the candidates joined on ICT may be determined considering the clarification from the CBEC

or from any other competent authority empowered to do so. Moreover, this committee has not been

entrusted with the task of such re-fixation of seniority. In this respect representations of the stake

holders may be taken into consideration. A letter dated 10.07.2018 vide F.No.S32-04/2017 Estt. has

been issued to Joint Secretary (Admn.), CBIC, by Chief Commissioner of Customs, Kolkata Zone seeking

clarification in this matter.

3. Regular promotion on 05.05.2003:-

It is also for information that a doubt has also been arisen regarding seniority of the last 11

(Eleven) LDCs (placed at SL.No.743 to 753 on page nO.27 of the enclosed list) promoted on regular basis

w.eJ. 05.05.2003 i.e., on the date of publication of Tax Assistant Recruit Rules, 2003. In this context it is

to be clearly stated that this committee has not been assigned with the task of review of any promotion

order issued earlier but only have task to place the officers working on regular basis, irrespective of

Direct Recruit or Promotee, in the revised seniority list in terms of extant guidelines of DOP&T. It is

obvious to review the case by the competent authority, if inevitable and if the all relevant documents

and orders related to the case mentioned about demands to do so, and the same may be done

separately as per the extant rules or guidelines in force.

It is also to be mentioned here that after finalization of the LDC seniority list review DPC should

be conducted by the competent authority in terms of relevant Recruitment Rules of UDC and thereafter

the seniority list of Tax Assistant may be finalized in terms of Recruitment Rules of Tax Assistant, 2003

published vide GSR No.381(E} dated 05.05.2003. In this respect submission of Sri Shankha Chakraborty,

member, dated 11.05.2018 and representations of the stake holders may be taken into consideration.

Page 5: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

1. Introduction:-

A Committee consisting of the following ministerial Officers/staff constituted with the approval

of the competent authority for preparing the seniority list of the ministerial staff in terms of order of the

Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.7514-7515 of 2005 in the case of N.R. Parmar & Ors. Vs. Union

of India & Ors.

SI. No.1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.15.

Name (Shri/Smt./Km.lBarun RoySoumitra ChakrabortyNaba Kumar DasSanjib GhoshBimalendu SenPrasanta Kumar BasuUday Sankar BhattacharyaArun Kr. MeheraShankha ChakrabortyKhamchin HauSanjib PaulAbhijit BandyopadhyayManoj BiswasDebi Prasad SardarSanjit Kumar Bose

DesignationE.A.

E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.E.A.A.a.E.A.E.A.E.A.

E.A.A.a.E.A.

E.A.

DepartmentVigilanceSTRC(Port)EstablishmentAccountsAccountsM.e.D.EstablishmentAccountsEstablishmentEstablishmentCB SectionCB Sectione.C.O.Sevottam (Port)M.e.D.

One more staff Sri Ahmed Ameer Khushroo, Tax Assistant, intended to work as a member of this

committee and represented for the same. A.e. (P & E) has directed to incorporate his submission in the

report of the above mentioned committee.

The committee was provided with the CBEC order No.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated

08/09/2014 containing instructions for fixing inter-se seniority of Direct recruits and promotees.

The CBECorder No.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated 08/09/2014 issued in pursuance of DOP&T's

a.M. No.20011/1/2012-Estt.(D) dated 04/03/2014 and containing DOP&1's clarification to CBECthereof.

However, it is also clarified that the seniority fixed under the provisions of OM dated 3.3.2008 is liable to

be re-visited. Further, this advice/clarification and clause 5{h) of the OM dated 4/3/2014 complement

each other and are not contradictory in that the provisions of OM dated 7.2.1986/3.7.1986 will apply till

27/11/2012, after which the circular dated 4/3/2014 will apply. And it is also clarified in para 5{i) of a.M.

dated 04.03.2014 of DOP&T that the cases of seniority already settled with reference to the applicable

interpretation of the term availability, as contained in DOP&T OM dated 07.02.1986/3.7.1986 may not

be re-opened.

On verification of the earlier seniority list published vide following Estt. Order it is observed that

the LDCsnominated by the SSCwere not placed in the seniority list as per the date of requisition sent to

Sse. The sequence of Direct Recruit candidates i.e., Direct recruit through SSCgiven priority followed by

the Direct recruit meritorious sports person and then the Direct recruit through Surplus Cell followed by

the Direct recruit on Compassionate ground has been followed as per the extant Rules and Guidelines.

1. Estt. Circular No.146/86 dated 04/06/1986 vide F.No.s.51-79/86 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;

2. Estt. Circular No.45/88 dated 09/03/1988 vide F.No.S.51-44/88 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;

Page 6: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

4. THE COURSE OF ACTION INITIATED DURING THE RE-FIXATION OF SENIORITY OF LOWERDIVISION CLERK:-"i. Seniority of i.o.c.s appointed prior to issuance of DOP&T's O.M. dated 07.02.1986/03.07.1986remained unchanged.2. LDCs appointed in Cash Department have been placed in terms of Estt. Circular No.74/2007dated 01/05/2007 vide F.No.S51-48/2002 Estt.3. Since 07.02.1986 seniority maintained keeping in mind the date of confirmation in the presentgrade read with date of requisition sent for direct recruitment to SSe. Sequence of seniority maintainedas follows:-Year: 1987-88(i) Surplus staff appointed as L.D.e. vide letter no.4(146)/87-CS-11I dated 28/10/1987 of D.O.P & Tagainst this office requisition dated 15/07/1987 vide File No. 551-145/86 - Estt.(ii) Appointment made through SSC Clerks Grade Exam, 1987 vide this office requisition dated02/08/1988 vide File No. 531-15/87 - Estt.(iii) Surplus staff appointed as L.D.e. vide letter no.4(190)/88-CS-1I1 dated 03/11/1988 of D.O.P & Tagainst this office requlsition dated 25/05/1988 vide File No. 531-15/87 - Estt.(iv) As per date of appointment Sports quota.(v) As per date of appointment Compassionate ground.(vi) DOP&T O.M. dated 04/11/1992 regarding delinking seniority from confirmation has been kept inview. Confirmation order issued till 19/04/1991 have been placed in seniority list keeping in mind thetune of DOP&T's O.M. dated 07.02.1986 read with DOP&T O.M. dated 04/11/1992.(vii) Letter 5/1/89-Nom. Dated 3/7/1989 of Regional Director (ER) for determination of inter-se-seniority among the DR LDC recruited through Clerks Grade Exam.-1988 and Clerks Grade Spl. Exam.(forSTonly) -1988.Till 19.04.1991, seniority has been kept intact due to extant rule linking seniority with confirmation.After 19.04.1991, seniority has been delinked from confirmation vide Dopt Order and accordingly, DR and PR were placed as perrotational quota mentioned in R.R.Year 1993(i) PR quota placed with DR SSC- 1993 in rotational quota basis based on ratio mentioned in RR.Compassionate appointee and ICT (DR quota), placed after DR SSC - 1993 candidates following rotaquota with PRs.Year: 1994(i) PR quota placed with DR SSC- 1994 in rotational quota basis based on ratio mentioned in' RR.Compassionate appointee and ICT (DR quota), placed after DR SSC - 1994 candidates following rotaquota with PRs.Year: 1995(i) PR quota placed with DR SSC- 1995 in rotational quota basis based on ratio mentioned in RR.Compassionate appointee and ICT (DR quota), placed after DR SSC- 1995 candidates following rotaquota with PRs. t

Year: 1996(i) PR quota placed with DR SSC- 1996 in rotational quota basis based on ratio mentioned in RR.Compassionate appointee and ICT (DR quota), placed after DR SSC - 1996 candidates following rotaquota with PRs.Year: 1997(i) PR quota placed with DR SSC- 1997 in rotational quota basis based on ratio mentioned in RR.Compassionate appointee and ICT (DR quota), placed after DR SSC- 1997 candidates following rotaquota with PRs.Year: 1998 to 2003There is no nomination from Sse.

Page 7: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

Year: 1998 to 2003There is no nomination from sse.

s. Documents kept in view while preparing the seniority list of Lower Division Clerk for the periodupto 2003 in terms of CBECletter no.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated 8/9/2014 read with DOP&T's O.M.No.20011/1/2012-Estt.{D) dated 4/3/2014 :-1. CBECletter no.A-32022/06/2014-Ad.IIIA dated 8/9/2014;2. DOP&T's O.M. No.20011/1/2012-Estt.{D) dated 4/3/2014;3. DOP&T's O.M. dated 07.02.1986/03.07.1986;4. Estt. Circular No.74/2007 dated 01/05/2007 vide F.No.S51-48/2002 Estt;5. Letter nO.4(146)/87-CS-11Idated 28/10/1987 of D.O.P &T;6. DOP&TO.M. dated 04/11/1992;7. Letter 5/1/89-Nom. Dated 3/7/1989;8. Letter No.5/1/89-Nom dated 03/07/1990;9. Estt. Order No.426/88 dated 11/08/1988;10. DOP&T's O.M. Nq.20011/1/2008-Estt.{D) dated 11.11.2010;11. DOP&T's O.M. No.20019/2/83-Estt.{D) dated 10.9.1985;12. DOP&T's O.M. No.20011/1/2008-Estt.{D) dated 12.12.1988;13. DOP&T's O.M. No.20020/4/89-Estt.{D) dated 7.2.1990;14. DOP&T's O.M. No.20011/1/2006-Estt.{D) dated 3.3.2008;15. DOP&T's O.M. No.9/11/55-RPS dated 22.12.1959;16. DOP&T's O.M. No.14015/1/76-Estt.{D) dated 4.8.1980;17. DOP&T's O.M. No.35014/2/80-Estt.{D) dated 7.2.1986;18. DOP&T's O.M. No.9/22/68-Estt.{D) dated 6.2.1969;19. DOP&T's O.M. No.20011/5/90-Estt.{D) dated 04.11.1992;20. DOP&T's O.M. No.20011/1/2008-Estt.{D) dated 11.11.2010;21. Estt. Circular No.146/86 dated 04/06/1986 vide F.No.S.51-79/86 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;22. Estt. Circular No.45/88 dated 09/03/1988 vide F.No.S.51-44/88 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;23. Estt. Circular No.173/89 dated 06/12/1989 vide F.No.S.51-116/89 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;24. Estt. Circular No.140/91 dated 04/12/1991 vide F.No.S.51-149/91 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;25. Estt. Circular No.49/94 dated 05/3/1994 vide F.No.S.51-27/94 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;26. Estt. Circular No.52/99 dated 15/6/1999 vide F.No.S.51-159/98 Estt{Pt.).-Seniority List of LDCs;27. Estt. Circular No.74/2007 dated 1/6/2007 vide F.No.5.51-48/2002 Estt.-Seniority List of LDCs;28. Estt. Order No. 16/93 dated 08/01/1993 vide F.No.S.51-112/1992 Estt.29. Ministry of Supply & Rehabilitation's Office Order No.87/76 dated 23/04/1976 (No.2/25/76-

Admn.-7847-64).30. Estt. Order No.315/95 dated 14/9/1995 vide F.No.S13-6/87 Estt.31. Office Order No.33/48/MZ/Estt/GE/NP/VoI.XIV/32308-85 dated 30/11/87 of Dandakaranya

Development Authority;32. Office Order No.33/48/MZ/Estt/GE/N&P/86/27681-730 dated 18/9/86 of Dandakaranya

Development Authority;33. Estt. Order No.353/93 dated 18/10/1993 vide F.No.513-6/87 Estt.34. Nomination by SSC:-

(i) Clerks Grade Examination, 1987:- SSC Letter No.3/2/88-Nom. dated 31/10/1988 &29/11/1988;

(ii) Clerks Grade Examination, 1988:- SSC Letter No.3/3/89-Nom. dated 16/8/1989, 28/8/1989,7/9/1989 & 21/9/1989;

(iii) Clerks Grade Examination, 1989:- SSC Letter No.3/2/90-Nom./WB dated 22/11/1990,13/5/1991, 7/6/1991 & 8/12/1993;

(iv) Clerks Grade Examination, 1990:- SSC Letter No.3/2/92-Nom./WB dated 20/3/1992,20/4/1992, 3/6/1992{02 letters);

Page 8: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

)I' Recruited through

SSC/Compassionat

> e Ground/Surplus/Date of Joining in Date of Joining in Date of Joining Date of"- Sports Quota/0 Educational Date of BirthSL.No. Name (Sri/Smt./Km.) b.O Govt. Service Custom House as LDC ConfirmationClI Qualification (DD/MM/YYYV) Promotee/•..

ra (DD/MM/YVYY) (DD/MM/YYYY) (DD/MM/YYYY) (DD/MM/YVYY)u ICT/MutualTransfer/Emp.

EXCH.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101 Gopal Ch. Mandi ST P.U. 24/07/1943 DR 13/04/1965 i3/04/1965 13/04/1965 03/03/19702 Pratip Kumar

UR S.F. 17/02/1937 DR 26/03/1966 26/03/1966 26/03/1966 30/12/1971 -Sengupta

3 Santi Kundu UR P.U. 04/01/1944 DR 04/08/1967 04/08/1967 04/08/1967 22/12/19724 Sudhir Kumar Biswas SC S.F. 31/03/1933 PR 02/04/1956 02/04/1956 26/04/1971 18/01/1978

5 Kala Kant Jha UR S.s.Exam. 03/01/1944 DR 25/10/1965 25/10/1965 25/10/1965 18/01/19786 Hriday Ranjan Roy UR Matric 08/01/1935 PR 18/06/1957 18/06/1957 06/04/1971 18/01/1978

Subal ChandraMatric 02/01/1937 30/10/1971 30/10/1971 30/10/1971 18/01/19787 UR DR

Chakraborty8 Anil Kumar Saha SC Class X 17/01/1945 DR 27/06/1974 27/06/1974 27/06/1974 18/01/19789 Sisir Kumar Saha UR S.F. 15/08/1944 DR 04/12/1973 04/12/1973 04/12/1973 18/01/1978

10 Birendra Nath Das UR S.F. 19/06/1938 DR 01/12/1973 01/12/1973 01/12/1973 18/01/197811 Amulya Chandra

SC S.F. 15/12/1946 PR 10/06/1965 10/06/1965 07/07/1973 04/11/1978Mandai

12 Anjan Kundu UR P.U. 23/03/1957 Compassionate 30/01/1975 30/01/1975 30/01/1975 17/07/1979

13 Kanu Lal Guha UR P.U. 04/10/1950 DR 15/03/1976 15/03/1976 15/03/1976 03/09/197914 Akhil Kumar Das SC B.COM 10/06/1949 DR 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 03/09/197915 Behula Topno ST P.U. 29/01/1955 DR 27/02/1978 27/02/1978 27/02/1978 27/02/198016 Rakhal Ranjan Mitra UR P.U. 01/03/1933 DR 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 15/06/1980

17 Ashok Kr. Khan SC B.COM, LLB 02/01/1951 DR 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 18/09/1975 15/06/1980

~~¥'f;~~~~Qj~~

Page 9: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

{v} Clerks Grade Examination, 1991:- SSC Letter No.3/6/92-Nom./WB dated 1/3/1993,20/7/1993;- {vi} Clerks Grade Examination, 1992:- SSCLetter No.3/2/93-Nom. dated 11/3/1994, 25/4/1994;

{vii} Clerks Grade Examination, 1993:- SSC Letter No.3/1/94-Nom.{Vol.l}WB dated 18/4/1995,3/5/1995;

{viii} Clerks Grade Examination, 1994:- SSC Letter NO.3/1/95-Nom.{Vol.l}WB dated 29/2/1996,20/3/1996;

{ix} Clerks Grade Examination, 1995:- SSC Letter No.3/1/96-Nom.{WB} dated 27/9/1996,23/10/1996, 16/12/1996;

(x) Clerks Grade Examination, 1996:- SSC Letter No.3/3/98-Nom.(WB} dated 2/4/1998,12/5/1998,18/5/1998,26/8/1998;

(xi) Clerks Grade Examination, 1997:- SSC Letter No.3/4/99-Nom.(WB} dated 27/1/2000,3/3/2000, 31/3/2000, 24/5/2000, 22/6/2000 { letters}, 28/7/2000.The above report approved and signed by the following nominated members:

SI. No. Name (Shri/Smt./Km.) Designation Signature

l. Arun Kr. Mehera A.D. ~ ft:rc \uL4A-= rt:t\ ~(

2. Manoj Kumar Biswas A.D. ,/th!9" M/ ~ £'(Id/l~

3. Barun Roy E.A.r-

4. Soumitra Chakraborty E.A.~:-C~~J"J '

5. Naba Kumar Das E.A. N~ ~ ~ '":tl,/!f>!l~

6. Sanjib Ghosh E.A. ~~~ ~~. ~\~\q

7. Bimalendu Sen E.A. J1d~~~8. Prasanta Kumar Basu E.A. kA ~~. t9~~~l,t9. Uday Sankar Bhattacharya E.A. {)::J7 l'/aw{~ ~c4. ~Ue e

10. Shankha Chakraborty E.A.~~..J(1..... e.t..oJ.<,.,..J."" fy '}.,.,~ r 2

1l. Sanjib Paul E.A. ~{t12. Abhijit Bandyopadhyay E.A. J!,b·~1-~9d!;/u/f~

13. Khamchin Hau E.A. tJJd ~l@j./tt!.

14. Debi Prasad Sardar E.A.~f~~\tl\,~

15. Sanjit Kumar Bose E.A.~

Page 10: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

\ Sumanta Kumar38 UR B.5c. 19/05/1954 DR 05/06/1978 05/06/1978 05/06/1978 01/01/1983Mitra

39 Premananda Saha SC S.F. 01/02/1934 PR .1957 .1957 08/08/1974 01/01/198340 Amartya Kumar UR H.S. 26/01/1956 Sports Quota 05/02/1975 05/02/1975 05/02/1975 01/01/1983

Ghosh41 Rentamoni Tudu ST H.5. 31/12/1949 DR 25/10/1975 25/10/1975 25/10/1975 01/01/1983

42 Samir Kumar Ghosh-II UR B.Sc.{Pt-l) 03/03/1952 DR 16/08/1976 16/08/1976 16/08/1976 01/01/1983

43 Shyamal Kanti UR S.F. 01/02/1941 PR 12/01/1965 12/01/1965 31/05/1977 01/01/1983Ganguly .

44 Nripendra Nath UR P.U. 15/07/1953 DR 10/08/1978 10/08/1978 10/08/1978 01/01/1983Chakraborty

45 Ranjit Kumar Biswas - SC H.S. 01/01/1951 Surplus 12/07/1976 08/05/1978 01/01/1983III

46 Puranjay Sarkar UR S.F. 13/07/1940 Surplus 15/05/1978 15/05/1978 01/01/1983Jiban Krishna

04/09/1950 24/08/1973 24/08/1973 10/08/1978 01/01/198347 UR S.F. PRBanerjee

48 Gopal Chandra Oas UR P.U. 28/11/1946 PR 01/09/1975 01/09/1975 08/05/1978 01/01/1983

49 Subhas Narayan Roy UR H.S. 01/09/1958 DR 01/11/1978 01/11/1978 01/11/1978 01/01/1983

50 Amal Krishna Biswas SC H.S. 24/12/1954 DR 14/08/1978 14/08/1978 14/08/1978 02/01/1983

51 Nibir Chakraborty UR H.S. 14/11/1956 DR 02/03/1978 02/03/1978 02/03/1978 02/02/1983

52 Pradip Kumar Sarkar SC B.COM 16/10/1956 DR 24/08/1978 24/08/1978 24/08/1978 02/02/1983

53 Subhas Chandra Nath UR S.F. 06/08/1956 DR 24/08/1978 24/08/1978 24/08/1978 02/03/1983

54 Xavier Tigga ST S.5.E 18/05/1959 KPO/KVO 02/12/1980 02/12/1980 02/12/1980 02/03/1983

55 Tapan Kumar UR H.5 28/07/1953 DR 03/08/1979 03/08/1979 03/08/1979 01/06/1983Bhattacharjee

56 Sunil Kumar Mallick UR H.S. 30/11/1947 PR 16/08/1973 16/08/1973 21/12/1979 02/06/1983

57 Arup Kumar UR U.E 14/01/1947 PR 19/08/1980 19/08/1980 19/8/1980 01/07/1983Chakraborty

58 Kalipada Mandai SC S.F. 07/05/1936 PR 07/01/1956 07/01/1956 11/12/1979 28/08/1983

Page 3 of 36

Page 11: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

" MAOHYAMI 05/02/1952 22/09/1975 22/09/1975 22/09/1975 25/08/198218 Jagnandan Prasad UR DRK PARIKSHA

19 Chiranjib UR P.U. 03/04/1951 DR 02/08/1976 02/08/1976 02/08/1976 25/08/1982Guhathakurta

20 Haripada Dhali SC S.F. 04/11/1949 Surplus 28/10/1976 28/10/1976 25/08/198221 Giribala Biswas SC H.S. 27/03/1948 Surplus 30/10/1976 30/10/1976 . 25/08/198222 Satya Rn. Sen UR S.F. 10/03/1936 PR 06/02/1956 06/02/1956 31/05/1977 25/08/1982

23 Md. Sukkur UR S.F. 17/01/1953 Compassionate 03/10/1977 03/10/1977 03/10/1977 25/08/1982.24 Bhaskar Sengupta UR S.F. 22/02/1958 DR 20/02/1978 20/02/1978 20/02/1978 25/08/1982

25 Pranab Kumar Sarkar UR B.Se. 02/02/1954 DR 23/02/1978 23/02/1978 23/02/1978 25/08/1982

Subrata 05/04/1953 07/08/1978 07/08/1978 07/08/1978 01/01/198326 UR B.Com. DRBandyopadhyay

27 Dilip Bandyopadhyay UR H.S. 05/05/1950 DR 07/09/1978 07/09/1978 09/07/1978 01/01/1983

28 Rathin Kumar Pal UR B.Com. 13/06/1951 Surplus 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 01/01/1983Samir Kumar Ghosh- 27/08/1952 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 01/01/198329 UR B.Com. DRIII

30 Satya Ranjan Moitra SC S.F. 12/10/1952 Surplus 10/05/1978 10/05/1978 01/01/1983

31 Haripada Das SC H.S. 25/11/1953 DR 04/11/1978 04/11/1978 04/11/1978 01/01/1983Tarun Kumar H.S. 12/11/1947 O·R 11/09/1978 11/09/1978 11/09/1978 01/01/198332 URMukherjee

33 Manik Lal Majumder UR S.F. 23/06/1942 Surplus 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 01/01/1983

34 Samir Ranjan UR B.Com. 17/03/1951 DR 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 11/08/1978 01/01/1983Bhattacharjee

35 Chandra Nath Sardar SC B.A. 09/02/1950 Surplus 08/09/1978 08/09/1978 01/01/1983

36 Madan Mohan Paul UR H.S. 16/01/1949 Surplus 17/08/1978 17/08/1978 01/01/1983

37 Kalyan Kumar SC B.Com 03/01/1950 Surplus 01/03/1978 01/03/1978 01/01/1983Samaddar

Page 2 of 36

Page 12: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

I 59 Kripal Kanti Biswas 5C S.F. 01/11/1954 PR 19/02/1973 19/02/1973 11/12/1979 02/11/198360 Dipak Dey UR B.SC 08/09/1956 SSC-1978 24/03/1980 24/03/1980 24/03/1980 23/12/1983

61 Ramchandra Murmu ST H.S. 09/11/1955 5SC-1978 06/03/1981 06/03/1981 06/03/1981 23/12/1983

62 Sumanta Kumar Pal UR B.A. 01/02/1957 S5C-1978 11/04/1980 11/04/1980 11/04/1980 23/12/198363 Satyajit Dey UR H.5. 15/01/1958 55C-1978 26/03/1980 26/03/1980 26/03/1980 23/12/198364 Ashish Ch. Dutta UR B.A. 07/07/1953 SSC-1978 22/03/1980 22/03/1980 22/03/1980 23/12/1983

Asit Kumar 18/03/1954 29/07/1980 29/07/1980 29/07/1980 23/12/198365Chakraborty

UR B.COM Sports Quota

MADHYAMI .66 Rina Mukherjee UR 25/05/1960 Sports Quota 01/08/1980 01/08/1980 01/08/1980 23/12/1983

K67 Usha Rani Biswas UR MATRIC 25/09/1945 Surplus 23/06/1980 23/06/1980 23/12/1983

68 Monotosh Kr. Sardar ST H.5 10/09/1955 Surplus 17/01/1981 17/01/1981 23/12/1983

69 Manju Rani Biswas SC H.S 24/09/1948 Surplus 23/06/1980 23/06/1980 23/12/1983Kana Rani 10/01/1956 Surplus 23/06/1980 23/06/1980 23/12/198370Roychowdhury

UR H.S.

71 Arati Kar UR B.A. 03/10/1953 Surplus 23/06/1980 23/06/1980 23/12/1983

72 Subhas Chandra Roy 5C B.COM 18/01/1950 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 23/12/1983

Krishna Kanta H.S.(East 04/07/1949 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 23/12/198373Mondal

SC Pakistan)74 Dasarath Halder SC H.S. 07/02/1949 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 23/12/198375 Tripti Mondal 5C S.F. 12/01/1948 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/1983

Debendra Chandra 15/11/1943 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/198376 5C P.U.Das

77 Sudam Ch. Gope UR Matric 19/09/1942 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/198378 Anil Krishna Roy SC H.S. 10/02/1940 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/198379 Basanti Chowdhury UR S.F. 12/07/1951 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/198380 Akhil Chandra Bala SC s.s.c. 30/04/1950 Surplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 24/12/198381 Manju Shome UR H.S.5.e. 15/03/1941 Surplus 26/06/1980 26/06/1980 24/12/198382 Sefali Goswami UR H.S 11/01/1942 Surplus 26/06/1980 26/06/1980 24/12/198383 Maya Dhar UR H.S 22/10/1950 Surplus 26/06/1980 26/06/1980 24/12/1983

84 Kazi Hafiz Zamal UR B.COM 10/01/1960 Compassionate 08/08/1980 08/08/1980 08/08/1980 24/12/1983

Page 4 of 36

Page 13: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

)26/12/1937 30/0)/198085 Sabita Biswas SC P.U. Compassionate 30/07/1980 30/07/1980 24/12/1983

86 Pritha Ghosh UR S.F. 01/04/1945 Compassionate 31/10/1980 31/10/1980 31/10/1980 24/12/198387 Pratima Raha UR B.A. 21/10/1955 55C-1979 24/11/1980 24/11/1980 24/11/1980 24/12/198388 Binoy Sarkar UR H.5. 05/01/1958 55C-1979 25/11/1980 25/11/1980 25/11/1980 24/12/198389 Kushal Kr. Mondal 5C B.Com. 15/12/1956 55C-1979 20/11/1980 20/11/1980 20/11/1980 .24/12/1983

Haradhan 20/05/1944 27/11/1974 27/11/1974 25/08/1980 24/12/198390Gangopadhyay

UR P.U. PR

Biraj Kr. EkkaMADHYAMI 13/01/1960 14/04/1982 14/04/1982 14/04/1982 24/12/198391 5T 5SC-1980K

92 Makhanlal Basu UR 5.F. 25/05/1945 PR 30/11/1974 30/11/1974 22/08/1980 24/12/198393 Kabita Dhar UR B.A. 10/02/1938 Compassionate 22/08/1980 22/08/1980 22/08/1980 24/12/1983

94 Pulin Behari Seal 5C Matric 10/07/1944 5urplus 30/09/1980 30/09/1980 24/12/1983

95 Rabindra Nath Moitra UR P.U. 01/03/1934 Emp. Exchange 05/01/1981 05/01/1981 05/01/1981 24/12/1983

96 Makhan Lal Ghosh UR 5.F. 15/10/1938 Emp. Exchange 01/04/1981 01/04/1981 01/04/1981 24/12/1983

97 Pankaj Kumar 5C s.s.c. 14/03/1951 5urplus 24/06/1980 24/06/1980 01/03/1985Mondal

98 Biplabananda Poddar 5C H.5. 01/05/1953 Compassionate 06/08/1980 06/08/1980 06/08/1980 01/03/1985

99 Chittaranjan Mitra UR 5.F. 25/04/1938 Emp. Exchange 05/01/1981 05/01/1981 05/01/1981 01/03/1985

100 Vokil Prasad Singh UR B.A. 04/02/1957 Hindi Typist(LOC} 26/05/1981 26/05/1981 26/05/1981 01/03/1985

101 Arati Roy UR H.5 15/07/1957 KPO/KVO 26/10/1981 26/10/1981 26/10/1981 01/03/1985Chandana 14/05/1958 KPO/KVO 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 01/03/1985102Bhattacharjee

UR H.5.

103 Dipankar Bose UR P.U. 12/01/1958 KPO/KVO 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 01/03/1985104 Manidipa Halder UR H.5 01/10/1961 KPO/KVO 23/10/1981 23/10/1981 23/10/1981 01/03/1985105 Sukla Sen UR B.A. 07/01/1961 KPO/KVO 22/02/1982 22/02/1982 22/2/1982 01/03/1985106 Prabir Bal UR S.F. 03/03/1957 KPO/KVO 10/09/1982 10/09/1982 09/10/1982 01/03/1985107 Chewang Lama 5T 5.E. 15/06/1962 55C-1980 03/04/1982 03/04/1982 03/04/1982 01/03/1985

Page 5 of 36

Page 14: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

l 128 Sarbani Dey UR S.F. 08/10/1958 SSC-1981 20/09/1982 20/09/1982 20/09/1982 02/03/1985

129 Ranjan Chatterjee UR Madhyamik 04/01/1966 Cash 14/12/1983 14/12/1983 14/12/1983 09/03/1986

130 Aditya Das UR B.SC 15/01/1960 SSC-1981 10/03/1983 10/03/1983 10/03/1983 10/03/1985Uttam Kumar B.COM 25/09/1959 SSC-1981 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 02/06/1985131 Chattopadhyay UR

132 Gautam Chatterjee UR H.5 02/08/1957 SSC-1981 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 . 01/07/1985133 Swapan Sarkar UR H.S 01/01/1960 SSC-1981 22/09/1982 22/09/1982 22/09/1982 28/08/1986134 SushilChakraborty UR X pass 09/06/1957 Sports Quota 13/07/1976 13/07/1976 22/05/1980 30/04/1987135 Indu Bhusan Biswas SC B.A. 23/02/1946 Surplus 23/06/1980 23/06/1980 30/04/1987136 Dipak Kr. Das UR B.COM 08/01/1959 SSC-1981 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 30/04/1987137 Sankar Das UR B.SC 01/12/1957 SSC-1981 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 30/04/1987138 RanjitGhosh UR H.S 21/01/1957 SSC-1981 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 24/09/1982 30/04/1987139 Tapan Ranjan Dey UR S.F. 04/08/1959 SSC-1981 22/09/1982 22/09/1982 24/09/1982 30/04/1987140 Sandhya Sen UR B.A. 05/03/1959 SSC-1981 26/11/1982 26/11/1982 26/11/1982 30/04/1987141 DilipKumar Chanda UR X pass 07/11/1958 SSC-1981 01/10/1982 01/10/1982 10/01/1982 30/04/1987142 Monoranjan Sen UR B.SC(PT-1) 02/12/1958 SSC-1981 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 30/04/1987143 Moloy Sengupta UR H.5 09/01/1959 SSC-1981 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 30/04/1987144 Arup Kumar Dey UR B.A. 06/01/1958 SSC-1981 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 30/04/1987

145 Sikha Ghosh Dastidar UR H.S 03/04/1962 SSC-1981 07/10/1982 07/10/1982 07/10/1982 30/04/1987

146 Ajoy Kundu UR B.SC 18/01/1959 SSC-1981 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 30/04/1987147 Amitava Som UR B.Com 22/10/1961 SSC-1981 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 30/04/1987

Chandan Kumar H.5 15/11/1959 SSC-1981 11/10/1982 11/10/1982 11/10/1982 30/04/1987148 Chattopad hyay UR

149 Biswajit UR H.5 02/09/1959 SSC-1981 08/10/1982 08/10/1982 08/10/1982 26/09/1987Bandyopadhyay150 Binoy Kumar Dubey UR B.A. 08/03/1957 SSC-1981 15/12/1982 15/12/1982 15/12/1982 11/08/1988

151 Shyamal Kumar SC H.S 18/01/1954 SSC-1981 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 11/08/1988Biswas

152 Badal Chandra Midya SC SEC EXAM 01/05/1959 SSC-1981 11/10/1982 11/10/1982 10/11/1982 11/08/1988

153 AbhijitMondal SC H.S. 07/09/1960 SSC-1981 01/10/1982 01/10/1982 01/10/1982154 Asta Kumar Adak SC H.S 13/07/1957 SSC-1981 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 30/09/1982 11/08/1988155 Sibapada Das SC B.Sc.(Pt.l) 10/07/1954 SSC-1981 06/11/1982 06/11/1982 06/11/1982 11/08/1988

Page 7 of 36

Page 15: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

)108 Pravati Dey UR P.U. 19/03/1946 Compassionate 20/08/1976 20/08/1976 20/8/1976 02/03/1985

109 Anjan Chankraborty UR B.COM 09/06/1956 Compassionate 25/11/1980 25/11/1980 25/11/1980 02/03/1985

110 Achinta Kumar Gupta UR B.A. 17/01/1959 55C-1980 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 02/03/1985Sankar 03/01/1956 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 02/03/1985111Mukhopadhyay

UR B.5C 55C-1980

112 Dipak Chandra Sarkar 5C X pass 01/03/1958 55C-1980 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 24/10/1981 02/03/1985.113 Subhas Chandra Mal 5C B.A. 25/12/1956 55C-1980 28/10/1981 28/10/1981 28/10/1981 02/03/1985

Narendra Nath B.COM(Pt-l} 08/06/1952 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 21/10/1981 02/03/1985114Mondal-II

5C 55C-1980

115 Tarun Kanti Das UR B.5e. 16/10/1955 55C-1980 07/04/1982 07/04/1982 04/07/1982 02/03/1985Krishna Pada 5.F.(Equiv.) 15/08/1956 25/02/1982 25/02/1982 25/2/1982 02/03/1985116Bhattacha rjee

UR 55C-1980

117 Kali Kinkar Paul UR B.COM(Pt-l} 18/12/1958 Compassionate 23/10/1981 23/10/1981 23/10/1981 02/03/1985

Madan Mohan 04/01/1956 02/12/1974 02/12/1974 09/12/1981 02/03/1985118Bhumij

5T 5.F. PR

119 Tarapada Kumar UR 5.F.(Equiv.) 14/01/1951 PR 06/12/1974 06/12/1974 14/12/1981 02/03/1985

120 Chhanda Banerjee UR 5.F. 21/10/1944 Compassionate 22/02/1982 22/02/1982 22/02/1982 02/03/1985

121 Subrata Bhowmick UR H.5. 03/06/1960 Sports Quota 01/05/1982 01/05/1982 01/05/1982 02/03/1985

122 Tapan Kumar Bhakta 5C H.5. 01/02/1960 Sports Quota 01/05/1982 01/05/1982 01/05/1982 02/03/1985

Ashim Kr. 22/12/1958 20/03/1982 20/03/1982 20/03/1982 02/03/1985123Chattopadhyay

UR B.COM Compassionate

124 Hridesh Kumar UR 5.F. 06/01/1963 Compassionate 26/03/1982 26/03/1982 26/03/1982 02/03/1985

125 Shukla Banerjee UR 5.F. 16/04/1952 Surplus 13/08/1982 13/08/1982 02/03/1985126 Jayanta Deb UR H.5 28/01/1960 55C-1981 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 04/10/1982 02/03/1985127 Gopal Chandra Dey UR B.Com(H} 01/05/1961 55C-1981 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 21/09/1982 02/03/1985

Page 6 of 36

Page 16: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

156 Ashis Kumar Roy SC B.Com 16/04/1958 SSC-1981 05/11/1982 05/11/1982 05/11/1982Ananta Kumar 01/06/1958 03/12/1982 03/12/1982 03/12/1982 11/08/1988157 SC SEC EXAM SSC-1981Mondal

158 Ashit Kumar Roy SC B.Se. 07/10/1958 SSC-1981 16/12/1982 16/12/1982 16/12/1982 11/08/1988159 Ranendra lalSaha UR Matric 02/03/1929 PR 22/07/1982 22/07/1982 22/07/1982160 Ratanlal Bose UR Matric 01/09/1932 Surplus 08/09/1982 09/08/1982 11/08/1988161 Sankar Kr. Das UR H.5 02/02/1958 PR 15/07/1976 15/07/1976 22/06/1982 . 11/08/1988162 Khokan Sarkar UR H.S 07/01/1957 PR 13/07/1976 13/07/1976 14/12/1982 11/08/1988163 Narendra Nath Saha SC S.F. 11/05/1949 PR 03/12/1974 03/12/1974 22/06/1982 11/08/1988-164 Sadananda Baidya UR S.F. 18/08/1945 Surplus 14/10/1982 14/10/1982 11/08/1988165 Manisha Roy SC B.A. 17/03/1959 ICT 15/04/1980 23/08/1982 23/08/1982 11/08/1988166 Biswajit Das UR H.S 31/01/1961 Sports Quota 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 11/08/1988

Ashish 28/01/1959 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 05/10/1982 11/08/1988167 Mukhopadhayay UR H.S Sports Quota

168 Sudeb Kumar Roy SC B.Com. 02/02/1955 SSC-1981 24/12/1982 24/12/1982 24/12/1982

169 Bishnupada Adhikari SC S.F. 29/07/1959 SSC-1981 24/12/1982 24/12/1982 24/12/1982 11/08/1988170 Swapan Kumar Pal UR B.COM. 01/01/1957 SSC-1981 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 11/08/1988171 Aftabuddin Sarkar UR B.COM. 31/08/1958 SSC-1981 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 11/08/1988172 Monoj Kumar Ghosh UR B.COM 23/12/1953 SSC-1981 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 27/12/1982 11/08/1988

173 Sadhan Kr. Biswas UR B.5C 26/09/1953 SSC-1981 30/12/1982 30/12/1982 30/12/1982 11/08/1988174 Kartick Ch. Mistry SC B.A 04/11/1956 ICT 25/02/1981 30/08/1983 30/08/1983 11/08/1988175 RatriDas UR B.Se. 27/12/1956 SSC-1982 17/08/1984 17/08/1984 17/08/1984 11/08/1988

176 Bhupendra Nath Pal UR B.COM 02/01/1958 SSC-1982 15/06/1984 15/06/1984 15/06/1984

177 Vijay Chenapadi UR H.5. 16/10/1958 SSC-1982 31/03/1984 31/03/1984 31/03/1984Ramaswamy178 Prabir Kumar Basu UR B.COM 01/01/1959 SSC-1982 07/06/1984 07/06/1984 07/06/1984 11/08/1988179 Alok Kumar Roy SC H.S 08/07/1960 SSC-1982 01/06/1984 01/06/1984 01/06/1984 11/08/1988180 Shyamal Kumar UR H.S 12/02/1954 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 24/12/1983 11/08/1988Ghosh-II181 Sanjay Kr. Roy SC S.F 10/09/1955 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 02/01/1984

Page 8 of 36

Page 17: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

I Rabindra Kumar182 SC S.F 01/03/1952 PR 04/12/1970 04/12/1970 30/12/1983 11/08/1988Biswas

183 Sishu Rani Mazumder SC B.A 04/07/1939 Compassionate 27/02/1984 27/02/1984 27/02/1984 11/08/1988

184 Bijoy Kr. Pandey UR I.A 31/12/1960 Com passionate 01/03/1984 01/03/1984 01/03/1984 11/08/1988

185 Prasanta Kr. Tikadar SC P.U 21/02/1955 Compassionate 31/03/1984 31/03/1984 31/03/1984 11/08/1988

186 Soma Oas UR H.S 18/09/1962 Compassionate 02/04/1984 02/.04/1984 02/04/1984 11/08/1988

187 Tarun Kumar Oey UR H.S 06/08/1960 Compassionate 06/04/1984 06/04/1984 06/04/1984 11/08/1988

188 Balai Chand Outta UR B.se. 11/02/1960 SSC-1982 11/04/1984 11/04/1984 11/04/1984 11/08/1988189 Shyam Sundar Saha UR B.Se. 13/06/1962 SSC-1982 23/05/1984 23/05/1984 23/05/1984190 Prabir Kumar Oas UR M.A. 31/07/1959 SSC-1982 11/06/1984 11/06/1984 11/06/1984 11/08/1988

191 Ranjana Nandy Gupta UR B.A(HONS) 04/09/1958 SSC-1982 16/08/1984 16/08/1984 16/08/1984 11/08/1988

Pulak BoseB.COM. 05/02/1961 02/06/1984 02/06/1984 02/06/1984 11/08/1988192 UR (HONS) SSC-1982

193 Gadadhar Hazra UR B.Se. 05/01/1958 SSC-1982 03/05/1984 03/05/1984 03/05/1984194 Geetashree Sarkar UR B.Se. 21/09/1960 SSC-1982 22/06/1984 22/06/1984 22/06/1984195 Ranjan Kr. Saha SC B.COM 01/08/1959 SSC-1982 06/11/1986 06/11/1986 06/11/1986 11/08/1988196 Ashish Biswas SC B.A. 06/08/1960 SSC-1982 15/02/1985 15/02/1985 15/02/1985197 Samir Kr. Naskar SC B.COM 30/03/1956 SSC-1982 10/08/1984 10/08/1984 10/08/1984 11/08/1988

Birendra Kumar 02/02/1959 KPO/KVO 03/07/1984 03/07/1984 03/07/1984 11/08/1988198Pandey

UR H.S

199 Krishna Pad a Sen UR B.COM 05/08/1958 KPO/KVO 17/07/1984 17/07/1984 17/07/1984 11/08/1988

200 Sikha Ghosh (Biswas) UR B.A 20/11/1959 Emp. Exchange 04/09/1984 04/09/1984 04/09/1984 11/08/1988

201 Biswajit Chakraborty UR H.s 09/01/1964 SSC-1983 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 11/08/1988

202 Biswadeb Chatterjee UR B.COM 06/09/1958 SSC-1983 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 11/08/1988

203 Shyama Prasad UR B.COM 12/08/1963 SSC-1983 20/04/1985 20/04/1985 20/04/1985 11/08/1988Chakraborty

Page 9 of 36

Page 18: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 231 Subol Chandra Das UR MATRIC 06/04/1952 PR 25/01/1974 25/01/1974 20/11/1984 11/08/1988232 Nirmal Ch. Moitra SC H.S 19/06/1955 PR 18/09/1978 18/09/1978 12/11/1984 11/08/1988233 Sanatan Mondal SC Matric 22/09/1952 ICT 19/11/1984 19/11/1984 11/08/1988234 Hem Chandra Bagchi SC H.S 10/09/1949 Surplus 19/12/1984 19/12/1984 11/08/1988235 Narayan Ch. Barai UR MATRIC 31/10/1936 surplus 28/12/1984 28/12/1984 11/08/1988

Joy Mukherjee MADHYAMI 15/08/1963 25/02/1985 25/02/1985 25/02/1985 11/08/1988236 UR CompassionateK

237 Debi Prasad Adak UR B.A 02/10/1957 SSC-1983 05/11/1985 05/11/1985 05/11/1985 11/08/1988238 Km. Rajarshi UR H.S. 06/12/1964 sportquota 06/04/1985 06/64/1985 06/04/1985Dasgupta239 Sibnath Chakraborty UR B.COM 06/01/1960 sportquota 08/04/1985 08/04/1985 08/04/1985 11/08/1988

Kushal Banerjee MADHYAMI 12/01/1961 08/04/1985 08/04/1985 08/04/1985 11/08/1988240 UR sportquotaK

241 Sambhu Prasad Das UR H.S 01/01/1962 sportquota 10/04/1985 10/04/1985 10/04/1985 11/08/1988242 Arup Kr.Roy UR H.S 01/01/1958 Compassionate 06/05/1985 06/05/1985 06/05/1985 11/08/1988

Amalendu 12/01/1960 23/08/1985 23/08/1985 23/08/1985 11/08/1988243 Bhattacharjee UR B.COM ICT

244 Ranju Ghosh UR B.A 10/01/1944 Compassionate 09/01/1984 09/01/1984 09/01/1984 09/11/1989

245 Parimalendu Haldar UR MATRIC 28/12/1944 surplus 20/12/1984 20/12/1984 09/11/1989

246 Tushar KantiRoy SC S.F 08/07/1957 Com passionate 22/01/1985{AN) 22/01/1985{AN) 22/01/1985{AN 09/11/1989)

247 Nirmal Kr.Dey UR Madhyamik 16/01/1967 Cash 02/07/1986 02/07/1986 02/07/1986 09/11/1989

248 PallabRoychowdhury UR H.S 01/02/1962 Com passionate 16/12/1985 16/12/1985 16/12/1985 09/11/1989

249 Animesh Chandra Roy UR H.5 18.01.1956 ICT 03/02/1986 03/02/1986 09/11/1989250 MotilalNandy UR S.F 14.05.1948 PR 03/05/1971 03/05/1971 10/03/1986 09/11/1989251 Arup Kumar Sinha UR B.COM{H), 01.11.1958 Mutual transfer 1982 04/04/1986 04/04/1986 09/11/1989LLB

Page 11 of 36

Page 19: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

204 Sumanta Chatterjee UR B.COM 05/01/1959 55C-1983 24/05/1985 24/05/1985 24/05/1985 11/08/1988

205 S.Sobhana UR B.Com 15/10/1964 55C-1983 15/04/1985 15/04/1985 15/04/1985 11/08/1988206 Ashit Kumar Ghosh UR H.5 07/01/1961 55C-1983 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 11/08/1988207 Tapas Kumar Bagchi UR H.5 07/01/1959 55C-1983 27/05/1985 27/05/1985 27/05/1985 11/08/1988

208 Nagbhushan Rao UR B.COM 01.07.1960 5SC-1983 10/09/1986 10/09/1986 10/09/1986Balla209 Alok Kumar Sen UR B.A. 13/08/1960 SSC-1983 12/04/1985 12/04/1985 12/04/1985210 Amitava Ghosh - II UR H.S 06/11/1958 5SC-1983 03/04/1985 03/04/1985 03/04/1985 11/08/1988211 Naba Kr. Bera UR H.5 21/01/1960 5SC-1983 18/09/1986 18/09/1986 18/09/1986 11/08/1988

212 Sanjoy Bhatacharjee UR H.5 21/04/1960 SSC-1983 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 04/04/1985 11/08/1988

213 Moloy Das - II UR B.SC 15/01/1960 SSC-1983 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 11/08/1988214 Rafic Mollah UR B.COM 15/07/1961 SSC-1983 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 11/08/1988215 Rup Chand Sarkar SC B.SC 15/01/1961 SSC-1983 19/04/1985 19/04/1985 19/04/1985 11/08/1988216 Rathin Roy - II SC B.A 01/09/1956 5SC-1983 03/04/85(AN} 03/04/85(AN} 03/04/85(AN} 11/08/1988217 Ashok Kr.Saha - III SC B.COM 21/03/1955 SSC-1983 15/04/1985 15/04/1985 15/04/1985 11/08/1988

Hem Chandra Naskar MADHYAMI 01/11/1959 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 11/08/1988218 5C S5C-1983K

219 Sribash Ch. Saha SC B.COM 19/02/1960 SSC-1983 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 06/04/1985 11/08/1988220 Anil Kumar Sarkar SC B.A 30/11/1961 SSC-1983 17/04/1985 17/04/1985 17/04/1985 11/08/1988221 Swarnendu Roy UR B.COM 12/08/1958 SSC-1983 11/11/1985 11/11/1985 11/11/1985 11/08/1988222 Sunil Kumar Sinha UR P.U 11/12/1935 PR 02/07/1966 02/07/1966 16/08/1984 11/08/1988223 Nani Gopal Biswas UR 5.F 12/02/1941 PR 21/12/1959 21/12/1959 29/08/1984 11/08/1988224 Sankar Mohan Dey UR S.F 23/03/1946 PR 05/06/1965 05/06/1965 16/08/1984 11/08/1988225 Ranjit Dutta UR P.U 07/02/1943 PR 08/09/1966 08/09/1966 22/08/1984 11/08/1988

226 Samar Kumar Roy SC B.COM 09/12/1956 Mutual Transfer 24/09/1984 24/09/1984 11/08/1988

227 Tridip Kumar Mullick SC SSC 10/10/1958 ICT 15/11/1984 15/11/1984 11/08/1988

228 SurajitKr. Roy UR 5.F 02/04/1954 PR 19/08/1978 19/08/1978 12/11/1984 11/08/1988

229 Rabindranath Brahma UR 5.F 27/05/1956 PR 19/08/1978 19/08/1978 12/11/1984 11/08/1988

230 Sushobhan Kr. Deb UR B.COM(P-I} 15/06/1952 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 20/11/1984 11/08/1988

Page 10 of 36

Page 20: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 252 Basudev Karmakar UR H.5 02.10.1956 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 21/05/1986 09/11/1989253 Arup Kumar Das UR H.S 31.01.1953 PR 24/06/1971 24/06/1971 24/12/1986 09/11/1989254 Pasang Sherpa ST H.S 09.06.1955 PR 12/11/1979 12/11/1979 26/05/1986 09/11/1989255 Sukumar Chakraborty UR H.S 03.10.1958 Surplus 19/09/1986 19/09/1986 09/11/1989256 Bimal Kumar Sinha UR H.S. 08.09.1955 Surplus 23/09/1986 23/09/1986 09/11/1989257 Pradip Kumar Guha UR H.S. 03.03.1951 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989

Roy

258 Ananga Bhushan UR B.A{h) 02.03.1947 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989Mukherjee .

259 Gouranga Chandra UR P.U 09/03/1938 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989Biswas

260 Nishakar Pradhan UR P.U 07.12.1943 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989261 Sajal Chandra Sarkar SC S.s.C 30.12.1955 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989262 Saibal Chakraborty UR H.S. 03.04.1954 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989263 Bimal Kanti lodh UR H.5. 01.02.1954 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989264 Rabindra Nath Roy UR S.F 03.11.1951 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989265 Saibalini Dhali UR S.F. 02.10.1952 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 09/11/1989266 Anil Krishna Mondal SC I.A. 18.03.1956 Surplus 30/09/1986 30/09/1986 09/11/1989

267 Ashok Kumar Ganguly UR H.S.C 03.01.1956 Surplus 30/09/1986 30/09/1986 09/11/1989268 Mrinal Kanti Roy UR S.S.C 15.03.1952 Surplus 30/09/1986 30/09/1986 09/11/1989

Sisir Kumar 06/10/1986 06/10/1986269Chatterjee

UR H.S. 16.10.1953 Surplus 09/11/1989

270 Supta Bhattacharjee UR I.A 14.10.1961 Surplus 06/10/1986 06/10/1986 09/11/1989

271 Jayanta Kumar UR H.S. 27.03.1965 Sports quota 26/12/86{AN) 26/12/86{AN)Chatterjee

272 Ganapati Das SC B.A.,B.Ed 13.02.1958 DR (ICT) 19/03/1987 09/11/1989273 Nita Draon ST S.F. 02.10.1959 Compassionate 08/05/1987 08/05/1987 08/05/1987 09/11/1989

274 Biswajit Dasgupta UR H.S. 04.11.1965 Compassionate 28/05/1987 28/05/1987 28/05/1987 09/11/1989

Page 12 of 36

Page 21: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

I 275 Jitendra Nath Das UR B.Com 01/02/1963 Cash 18/02/1987 18/02/1987 18/02/1987 09/11/1989276 Sukhlal Singh ST H.S 06/03/1952 PR 17/07/1976 17/07/1976 02/12/1977 19/04/1991277 Debashis Das SC H.S 11/03/1959 Compassionate 18/08/1978 18/08/1978 18/08/1978 19/04/1991

Dhirendra Nath 01/08/1947 surplus 28/01/1985 28/01/1985 19/04/1991278Bepari

SC H.S.

Ganesh Chandra 01/01/1958 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986 19/04/1991279Adhikary

SC H.S

280 Bharati Debnath UR S.F 02/03/1950 Surplus 06/10/1986 06/10/1986 19/04/1991

281 Swapan Kumar Ghosh UR H.S. 05/08/1958 Cash{PR) 12/01/1982 12/01/1982 30/10/1987 19/04/1991

282 Bimal Kumar Sapui UR S.F 21/09/1940 Surplus 01/12/1987 01/12/1987 19/04/1991283 Mrinal Kanti Ghosh UR S.F 12/01/1942 Surplus 01/12/1987 01/12/1987 19/04/1991284 Prabir Kanti Naha UR B.A.B.Ed 02/04/1949 Surplus 07/12/1987 07/12/1987 19/04/1991285 Putul Biswas UR S.F 10/02/1950 Surplus 07/12/1987 07/12/1987 19/04/1991286 Shefali Mandai UR VIIIPassed 10/03/1944 Surplus 07/12/1987 07/12/1987 19/04/1991287 Kalipada Sarkar SC MATRIC 18/02/1938 Surplus 08/12/1987 08/12/1987 19/04/1991288 Nilratan Roy SC MATRIC 02/01/1945 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991289 Surendranath Boral SC MATRIC 02/11/1941 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991

290 Amiya Kumar Mandai UR H.S 04/03/1957 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991

291 Anil Chandra Sikder SC H.S 12/10/1951 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991292 Sakti Pada Pal UR H.5 28/01/1951 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991

Amrita Chandra 10/06/1957 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991293Mandai

SC H.S

294 Sanjib Kumar UR H.S 08/10/1949 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987 19/04/1991Majumder

295 Bina Pani Pal SC S.F 12/08/1952 Surplus 10/12/1987 10/12/1987 19/04/1991Rakhal Chandra 09/01/1930 Surplus 12/10/1987 12/10/1987296Nandi

UR MATRIC

297 Haralal Gayan SC MATRIC 28/01/1944 Surplus 10/12/1987 10/12/1987 19/04/1991

298 Santi Ranjan Debnath UR H.S 01/07/1948 Surplus 10/12/1987 10/12/1987 19/04/19911Purna Chandra 29/09/1938 Surplus 11/12/1987 11/12/1987 19/04/1991299Bhuiyan

UR P.B.C.

Page 13 of 36

Page 22: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

325 Kanapala SC B.COM 14/03/1961 SSC-1987 09/12/1988 09/12/1988 09/12/1988 19/04/1991Namassivaya

326 Samar Purkait SC B.COM 05/05/1962 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991327 Nil Ratan Sarkar SC B.Com 06/11/1963 SSC-1987 29/11/1988{AN) 29/11/1988{AN) 29/11/1988{AN

)

328 Dilip Kumar Mondal SC B.A 12/06/1964 SSC-1987 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 . 19/04/1991

329 Rabindra Nath Biswas SC B.COM 29/11/1964 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988

330 Kashi Nath Pramanick SC B.SC 27/12/1965 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991

331 Nirmal Sardar SC B.COM 10/12/1965 SSC-1987 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 19/04/1991332 Saroj Kumar Gayen SC B.A 03/01/1964 SSC-1987 17/11/1988{AN) 17/11/88{AN) 17/11/88{AN) 19/04/1991

Sentu MajhiMADHYAMI 04/04/1960 29/11/1988 29/11/1988 29/11/1988 19/04/1991333 SC SSC-1987

K334 Bablu Kumar Sardar SC B.COM 01/03/1962 SSC-1987 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 19/04/1991

335 Dilip Daniel Singh Nag ST I.A 13/12/1966 SSC-1987 20/12/1988 20/12/1988 20/12/1988 19/04/1991

336 Shyamal Kumar Das UR (ESM) B.SC 10/04/1952 SSC-1987 18/11/1988 18/11/1988 18/11/1988 19/04/1991337 Mira Chakraborty UR (PH) B.A. 28/12/1964 SSC-1987 25/01/1989 25/01/1989 25/01/1989 19/04/1991338 Rakhendu Bikash Roy SC (PH) H.S. 14/10/1957 SSC-1987 06/01/1989 (AN) 06/01/1989 (AN) 06/01/1989 19/04/1991(AN)339 Prabir Samanta UR (PH) H.5. 07/01/1966 SSC-1987 06/02/1989 06/02/1989 06/02/1989 19/04/1991340 Dhiman Das UR (PH) B.Se. 22/10/1965 SSC-1987 09/01/1989 09/01/1989 09/01/1989 19/04/1991341 Indranil Das UR H.S. 08/02/1969 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 19/04/1991342 Sahadeb Talukdar UR B.SC 26/07/1966 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 19/04/1991

343 Tapas Kumar Dutta UR H.S. 14/02/1964 Sports Quota 28/10/1988{AN) 28/10/1988{AN) 28/10/1988{AN 19/04/1991)

344 Sovaram Bala SC P.U 11/07/1949 Surplus 02/01/1989 02/01/1989 19/04/1991345 Pulak Kanti Roy UR H.5. 13/09/1953 Surplus 02/01/1989 02/01/1989 19/04/1991346 Putul Dewanji UR B.A. 07/04/1956 Surplus 02/01/1989 02/01/1989 19/04/1991347 Haripada Biswas SC s.s.c. 25/11/1948 Surplus 02/01/1989 02/01/1989 19/04/1991348 Bimal Kumar Maity UR H.5. 03/11/1964 Compassionate 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 19/04/1991

Page 15 of 36

Page 23: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 300 Surendra Nath Giri SC P.B.C 31/12/1942 Surplus 11/12/1987 11/12/1987 19/04/1991301 Panchanan Roy SC MATRIC 31/03/1941 Surplus 11/12/1987 11/12/1987 19/04/1991302 Gopal Chandra UR P.B.C 28/02/1941 Surplus 11/12/1987 11/12/1987 19/04/1991Pradhan303 Banbihari Sarkar UR S.F. 19/11/1943 Surplus 28/3/1988 28/3/1988304 Krishnendu Banerjee UR B.A I B.SC 15/04/1964 SSC-1987 24/11/1988 24/11/1988 24/11/1988

305 Sarbani Das UR B.SC 01/06/1965 SSC-1987 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 19/04/1991306 Nilanjan Ganguly UR B.SC 01/10/1965 SSC-1987 29/11/1988 29/11/1988 29/11/1988 19/04/1991307 Amitava Goswami UR B.SC 28/12/1965 SSC-1987 12/02/1988 12/02/1988 12/02/1988308 Alok Kumar Chanda UR B.SC 14/09/1966 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988

309 Rabindra Narayan UR B.SC 02/01/1967 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991Mishra

310 Amitava lahiri UR B.SC 26/08/1967 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991Surya Padmavathi

311 (Vallabhajasyula) UR B.SC 30/06/1968 SSC-1987 24/11/1988 24/11/1988 24/11/1988Nishtala

312 Gautam Sil UR B.SC 07/01/1963 SSC-1987 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 19/04/1991313 Utpal Dutta UR B.COM 01/12/1963 SSC-1987 01/08/1989 01/08/1989 01/08/1989 19/04/1991314 Shyamal Chakraborty UR B.SC 06/01/1964 SSC-1987 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 28/11/1988 19/04/1991315 Subrata Sadhukhan UR B.Com 07/03/1964 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988316 Gouranga UR B.COM 06/04/1964 SSC-1987 24/11/1988 24/11/1988 24/11/1988 19/04/1991

Bhatacharjee317 Sudip Dutta UR I.S.CE 27/08/1965 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991318 Kaushik Sen UR B.SC 07/10/1965 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991319 Debabrata Mallick UR B.COM 06/12/1965 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988

Mousumi 16/01/1966 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991320Bhattacharyya

UR B.SC SSC-1987

321 Jayanta Khan UR B.Com 12/02/1963 SSC-1987 09/12/1988 09/12/1988 09/12/1988322 Utpal Majumder SC H.S. 10/09/1966 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991323 Bade Hemanth Kumar SC H.S. 04/10/1967 SSC-1987 28/12/1988 28/12/1988 28/12/1988

324 Debprosad Biswas SC H.S. 02/10/1960 SSC-1987 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 25/11/1988 19/04/1991

Page 14 of 36

Page 24: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

)648 Chittaranjan Biswas SC P.U. 13/08/1957 PR 28/09/1987 28/09/1987 16/10/1996

649 P. Satya Murali UR B.SC 21/10/1973 SSC-1996 28/09/1998 28/09/1998 28/09/1998Krishna

650 Vijay Kumar Arya OBC B.A. 04/10/1972 SSC-1996 07/10/1998 07/10/1998 07/10/1998

651 Mihir Kumar Biswas SC B.SC 15/02/1968 SSC-1996 15/09/1998 15/09/1998 15/09/1998

Siddhartha Shankar B.COM(H) 10/08/1973 18/09/1998 18/09/1998 18/09/1998652Naskar

SC SSC-1996

653 Ashis Kr. Roy OBC B.COM 13/10/1968 SSC-1996 18/09/1998 18/09/1998 18/09/1998

654 Manoj KumarINTERMIDIA 01/03/1978 24/12/1998 24/12/1998 24/12/1998OBC SSC-1996TE

655 Shrabani Pramanik OBC B.SC 20/12/1972 SSC-1996 15/09/1998 15/09/1998 15/09/1998656 Sanjib Paul OBC H.s. 03/07/1974 SSC-1996 17/09/1998 17/09/1998 17/09/1998

657 Km. Sindhu M OBC VHSE (Eqv. 05/05/1974 SSC-1996 28/09/1998 28/09/1998 28/09/1998H.S.)

658 Krishna BoseMADHYAMI 18/10/1962 26/07/1984 26/07/1984 16/10/1996UR PR

K

659 Mrinmoy Majumdar UR S.S.C 01/07/1948 PR 20/12/1983 20/12/1983 14/02/1997

660 Krishna Kanta Roy UR H.S 10/01/1960 PR 17/08/1984 17/08/1984 14/02/1997661 Partha Chowdhury UR B.A 27/08/1961 PR 21/09/1987 21/09/1987 14/02/1997

662 Subrata Giri SC H.s. 20/03/1978 Compassionate . 31/05/1996 (AN) 31/05/1996 (AN) 31/05/1996(AN)

663 Rekha Sen UR S.F. 25/12/1954 Compassionate 15/11/1996 15/11/1996 15/11/1996

664 Subal Ch. Roy - II SC S.F. 01/06/1958 PR 14/03/1980 14/03/1980 14/05/1997

665 Dhaneshree Bishayi UR B.COM(H) 25/08/1973 SSC-1997 28/03/2000 28/03/2000 28/03/2000

666 Abhijit Dutta uR"" B.A(H) 01/02/1975 SSC-1997 29/03/2000 29/03/2000 29/03/2000667 Biswajit Sen UR B.SC(H) 08/03/1973 SSC-1997 10/03/2000 10/03/2000 10/03/2000668 Baidyanath Bhar OBC B.A 06/04/1973 SSC-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000669 Ashok Neogi UR B.COM(H) 30/06/1973 SSC-1997 29/03/2000 29/03/2000 29/03/2000670 Partha Chatterjee UR B.SC(H) 14/01/1973 SSC-1997 21/03/2000 21/03/2000 21/03/2000671 Amit Banerjee UR B.SC 31/10/1974 SSC-1997 12/04/2000 12/04/2000 12/04/2000672 Nasim Akhtar UR B.SC(H) 07/11/1972 SSC-1997 20/06/2000 20/06/2000 20/06/2000

Page 29 of 36

Page 25: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 349 Smt. Suparna Biswas UR H.5. 24/01/1966 Compassionate 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 19/04/1991

350 Merry Kayal UR H.S. 25/01/1966 Compassionate 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 20/06/1988 19/04/1991

MADHYAMI 10/03/1964 Compassionate 21/06/88 (AN) 21/06/88(AN) 21/06/88 (AN) 19/04/1991351 Tapas Dey URK

Srikanta 09/05/1968 Compassionate 24/06/1988 24/06/1988 24/06/1988 19/04/1991352 UR H.S.Bandyopadhyay

353 Tapan Kumar Sen UR B.COM. 01/01/1957 Compassionate 09/02/1989 09/02/1989 09/02/1989 19/04/1991

354 Dilip Pain UR B.Com 29/9/1964 Cash 28/06/1988 28/06/1988 28/06/1988 19/04/1991355 Deb Dulal Dhar UR B.Com 06/08/1969 Cash 17/5/1988 17/5/1988 17/5/1988 19/04/1991356 Arun kr. Saha SC H.S 18/08/1945 PR 02/12/1974 02/12/1974 11/08/1978

357 Moloy Bose UR H.S 21/09/1960 Compassionate 29/07/1980 29/07/1980 29/07/1980

358 Amal Chowdhury UR H.S. 25/10/1954 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 02/01/1984

359 Swapan Kumar Das - I SC P.U 16/05/1954 Compassionate 11/04/1984 11/04/1984 11/04/1984

360 Shyamal Kanti Biswas UR S.F 02/09/1949 Surplus 29/09/1986 29/09/1986

361 Jyoti Mohan Karati SC H.SC 05/08/1958 Surplus 30/09/1986 30/09/1986362 Sulata Roy Biswas SC S.F 15/08/1952 Surplus 24/11/1986 24/11/1986

Kalyan BhaumickMADHYAMI 02/05/1961 Compassionate 21/04/1986 21/04/1986 21/04/1986363 UR

K

364 Kamaruzzaman UR U.B 28/10/1954 Compassionate 25/06/1986 25/06/1986 25/06/1986

Bhabasindhu SC H.S 02/11/1953 Surplus 24/11/1987 24/11/1987365Talukder

366 Abhinoy Chandra UR MATRIC 19/04/1952 Surplus 09/12/1987 09/12/1987Majumder

367 Tapas Aditya UR H.5 02/12/1957 Compassionate 28/05/1987 28/05/1987 28/05/1987

MADHYAMI 22/05/1950 01/08/1970 01/08/1970 02/06/1988368 Nagina Singh UR PRK

369 Baljeet Singh UR H.5. 12/08/1969 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988

Page 16 of 36

Page 26: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) Sujoy Kumar390Mukhopadhyay

UR B.COM. 30/11/1967 SSC-1988 19/12/1989 19/12/1989 19/12/1989

391 Biswajit Ghosh UR B.COM. 01/01/1968 SSC-1988 20/12/1989 20/12/1989 20/12/1989392 Pradip Kumar Khan UR B.Se.(H) 03/04/1968 SSC-1988 07/12/1989 07/12/1989 07/12/1989393 Abhijit Sengupta UR H.5. 28/05/1968 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989394 Tapas laha UR B.COM. 03/06/1969 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989

395 Ashish Kumar Sarkar UR B.COM. 04/08/1963 SSC-1988 15/12/1989 15/12/1989 15/12/1989

396 Apurba Kumar UR B.Se. 26/09/1963 SSC-1988 04/01/1990 04/01/1990 04/01/1990BhawalSumanta 01/01/1964 11/12/1989 11/12/1989 11/12/1989397Gangopadhyay

UR B.COM. SSC-1988

398 Swapna Oas UR B.Se. 01/06/1964 SSC-1988 07/12/1989 07/12/1989 07/12/1989399 Asis Majumder UR B.Se. 06/12/1964 SSC-1988 15/12/1989 15/12/1989 15/12/1989400 Soumitra Banerjee UR B.COM. 01/01/1965 SSC-1988 05/12/1989 05/12/1989 05/12/1989

401 Uday Shankar UR B.COM. 07/01/1965 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989Bhattacharyya

402 Samir Kumar Haldar UR B.COM. 28/02/1965 SSC-1988 13/12/1989 13/12/1989 13/12/1989403 Tapan Oas UR B.COM. 05/11/1965 SSC-1988 07/12/1989 07/12/1989 07/12/1989404 Moloy Goswami UR B.5e. 11/11/1965 SSC-1988 07/12/1989 07/12/1989 07/12/1989405 Partha Ghosh UR B.COM. 02/01/1966 SSC-1988 11/12/1989 11/12/1989 11/12/1989406 Amalesh Oasgupta UR B.Se. 22/01/1966 SSC-1988 15/12/1989 15/12/1989 15/12/1989

Samiran 07/05/1966 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989407Bhattacharyya

UR B.A. SSC-1988

Sumit Kumar 21/08/1966 08/12/1989 08/12/1989 08/12/1989408Chakraborty

UR B.COM. SSC-1988

409 Santi Kumar Mal UR B.5e. 03/12/1966 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989410 Srikanta Oas SC B.Se. 25/01/1965 SSC-1988 05/09/1989 05/09/1989 05/09/1989

411 Tarun Kumar Mondal SC B.A. 01/01/1963 SSC-1988 05/09/1989 05/09/1989 05/09/1989

412 Sunanda Sen SC H.S. 10/12/1964 SSC-1988 11/09/1989 11/09/1989 11/09/1989413 Kamala Oasgupta SC B.Se. 01/12/1967 SSC-1988 05/09/1989 05/09/1989 05/09/1989

414 Manoj Kumar Biswas SC H.S. 06/11/1968 SSC-1988 12/09/1989 12/09/1989 12/09/1989

Page 18 of 36

Page 27: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 370 Jasbir Singh Khaira UR H.S. 19/10/1969 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988371 Pinaki Sengupta UR B.COM 20/09/1961 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988372 Basab Lal Basu UR H.S. 31/12/1963 Sports Quota 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988(AN

}

373 Chanchal Chakraborty UR B.COM 24/09/1964 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988

374 Sabyasachi Majumder UR H.S. 29/08/1963 Sports Quota 04/11/88(FN} 04/11/88(FN} 04/11/88(FN}

Partha GhoshMADHYAMI 25/02/1969 28/10/88(AN} 28/10/88(AN} 28/10/88(AN}375 UR Sports Quota

KPrasantha 03/08/1965 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988376Bhattacharjee

UR H.S. Sports Quota

Paritosh ChakrabortyMADHYAMI 01/01/1967 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 02/12/1988377 UR Sports Quota

KMADHYAMI 10/10/1966 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988378 Soumen Banerjee UR Sports Quota

K (AN)

379 Uday Sankar Ganguly UR B.COM 22/12/1963 Sports Quota 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988

380 Narayan Chandra Das UR H.S. 06/09/1966 Sports Quota 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988 (AN) 28/10/1988(AN)

Indrani BagMADHYAMI 12/06/1970 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 31/10/1988381 UR Sports Quota

K

382 Biswanath Sil UR B.A 02/01/1963 Sports Quota 07/11/1988 (FN) 07/11/1988 (FN) 07/11/1988(FN)

383 Rathin Oas UR B.Se. 10/01/1966 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989384 Abhijit Ghosh UR B.COM. 05/07/1966 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989385 Bijon Kanti Raha UR H.S. 23/08/1966 SSC-1988 07/12/1989 07/12/1989 07/12/1989

386 Saugata Chakraborty UR B.COM. 13/11/1966 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989

387 Asis Saha UR B.COM. 04/12/1966 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989

388 Tultul Kumar Ghosh UR H.5. 30/12/1965 SSC-1988 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989

Partha Pratim 10/07/1967 06/12/1989 06/12/1989 06/12/1989389Banerjee

UR B.Se. SSC-1988

Page 17 of 36

Page 28: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

)415 Tapas Kumar Biswas SC B.A. 09/12/1959 SSC-1988 11/09/1989 11/09/1989 11/09/1989

416 Aparna Naskar SC B.Se. 26/12/1966 SSC-1988 18/09/1989 18/09/1989 18/09/1989417 Oebasish Saha SC B.COM. 22/12/1964 SSC-1988 29/09/1989 29/09/1989 29/09/1989418 Ranjan Kumar Saha SC B.Se. 04/01/1967 SSC-1988 15/09/1989 15/09/1989 15/09/1989419 Uttam Saha SC H.S. 22/11/1967 SSC-1988 15/09/1989 15/09/1989 15/09/1989420 Oipanjan Oas SC H.S. 21/01/1969 SSC-1988 19/09/1989 19/09/1989 19/09/1989421 Sishuram Murmu ST H.S. 24/01/1966 SSC-1988 05/09/1989 05/09/1989 05/09/1989

MADHYAMI 07/01/1963 06/09/1989 06/09/1989 06/09/1989422 Laxmiram Murmu ST SSC-1988K

423 Lakhu Mardi ST H.S. 24/01/1963 SSC-1988 06/09/1989 06/09/1989 06/09/1989

Gunduwa Tirkey 06/01/1962 SSC-1988 12/09/1989 12/09/1989 12/09/1989424 ST B.COM. (Specialdrive)

425 Sisir Kumar Bakhla ST IA 23/10/1963 SSC-1988 (Special 31/08/1989 31/08/1989 31/08/1989drive)

426 Basant Kumar Routh ST H.S. 08/05/1961 SSC-1988 (Special 01/09/1989 01/09/1989 01/09/1989drive)MADHYAMI 22/11/1961 SSC-1988 (Special 11/09/1989 11/09/1989 11/09/1989427 Lucian Minz ST

K drive)

428 Tarun Khalkho ST B.COM. 13/06/1960 SSC-1988 (Special 08/09/1989 08/09/1989 08/09/1989drive)

429 Binod Hansda ST B.A. 12/03/1962 SSC-1988 (Special 11/09/1989 11/09/1989 11/09/1989drive)

430 Saroj Kumar Prasad ST B.COM. 04/03/1967 SSC-1988 (Special 31/08/1989 31/08/1989 31/08/1989drive)

431 Nilima Pal UR H.S. 13/05/1952 Compassionate 17/06/1988 17/06/1988 17/06/1988

Ashok Kr. SinghMADHYAMI 01/07/1953 Compassionate 17/06/1988 17/06/1988 17/06/1988432 UR

K

Supriti BhattacharyyaMADHYAMI 06/02/1948 21/06/1988 21/06/1988 21/06/1988433 UR Compassionate

K434 Panchu Gopal Roy UR H.S. 02/09/1950 PR 21/06/1971 21/06/1971 01/06/1989435 Benudhar Giri UR B.A. 25/05/1965 SSC-1989 23/02/1994 23/02/1994 23/02/1994

436 Oebasish Chatterjee UR B.A. 23/05/1969 SSC-1989 14/03/1991 14/03/1991 14/03/1991

Page 19 of 36

Page 29: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

r

J 437 Bhabani Sankar 10/10/1966 13/05/1991 13/05/1991 13/05/1991Nayek

UR B.A. 55C-1989

438 Ashok Karmakar UR B.5e. 15/01/1967 55C-1989 04/03/1991 04/03/1991 04/03/1991439 Debdas Banerjee UR B.5c.(H) 02/01/1968 55C-1989 01/04/1991 01/04/1991 01/04/1991

Partha Kumar 31/12/1969 18/02/1991 18/02/1991 18/02/1991440Bhattacharya

UR B.A. 55C-1989

441 Nirmalendu Sarkar UR B.5e. 08/08/1964 55C-1989 08/05/1991 08/05/1991 08/05/1991442 Kalyan Kumar Ghosh UR B.COM.(P) 17/09/1964 55C-1989 29/04/1991 29/04/1991 29/04/1991

443 Sohini Chowdhury UR B.5c(H) 17/04/1966 55C-1989 09/05/1991 09/05/1991 09/05/1991Sadhan Chandra 29/03/1952 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 05/06/1989444Haldar

UR B.5e. PR

445 Jayanta Kumar UR B.Com(H) 19/06/1968 55C-1989 14/02/1991 14/02/1991 14/02/1991Bhowmik

446 Gautam Banerjee - II UR B.5e. 23/11/1964 55C-1989 18/03/1991 18/03/1991 18/03/1991

447 Sampa Singha Basu UR B.A.(H) 30/11/1964 55C-1989 26/04/1991 26/04/1991 26/04/1991

448 Sanjoy Mukherjee UR B.5e.(H) 07/06/1965 SSC-1989 29/04/1991 (AN) 29/04/1991 (AN) 29/04/1991(AN)

449 Sekhar Dutta UR B.5e. 01/08/1966 SSC-1989 26/04/1991 (AN) 26/04/1991 (AN) 26/04/1991(AN)

450 Shyamal Kumar Pal UR B.Com 05/09/1966 SSC-1989 01/04/1991 01/04/1991 01/04/1991

451 Ranjan Bhattacharya UR B.Se.(H) 18/10/1966 SSC-1989 13/02/1991 13/02/1991 13/02/1991

452 Subhasish Dey UR B.COM.(H) 07/01/1967 S5C-1989 19/04/1991 19/04/1991 19/04/1991

453 Abhijit UR B.5e. 17/01/1967 SSC-1989 25/02/1991 25/02/1991 25/02/1991Bandyopadhyay

454 Jayanta Singha UR s.sc. 01/02/1967 SSC-1989 27/03/1991 27/03/1991 27/03/1991455 Santi Ram Ghosh UR B.A.(H) 26/02/1967 SSC-1989 18/04/1991 18/04/1991 18/04/1991456 Mala Bose UR B.Se. 17/12/1967 5SC-1989 25/04/1991 25/04/1991 25/04/1991457 Nemai Prasad Ram UR B.Se.(H) 06/01/1968 SSC-1989 22/02/1991 22/02/1991 22/02/1991458 Pradip Majumder UR B.COM. 08/01/1969 SSC-1989 21/03/1991 21/03/1991 21/03/1991459 Sukanta Ash UR H.5. 11/01/1969 SSC-1989 06/08/1991 06/08/1991 06/08/1991460 Kumar Chowdhury UR B.COM. 11/02/1969 SSC-1989 06/03/1991 06/03/1991 06/03/1991

Page 20 of 36

Page 30: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 1.5.e.(XII461 Partha Das URClass)

17/10/1970 55C-1989 18/03/1991 18/03/1991 18/03/1991

462 Ramapada Hazra UR B.5e. 22/10/1964 55C-1989 06/05/1991 06/05/1991 06/05/1991

463 Subrata Chakraborty UR B.COM. 18/01/1965 55C-1989 22/07/1991 22/07/1991 22/07/1991

464 Dibyendu Pal UR B.5e. 01/05/1965 55C-1989 22/04/1991 22/04/1991 22/04/1991465 Pradipta Roy UR B.COM. 02/05/1965 55C-1989 14/06/1991 14/06/1991 14/06/1991

466 Guruprasad UR B.COM{H) 16/05/1966 55C-1989 22/03/1991 22/03/1991 22/03/1991Mukhopadhyay

467 Debasish maity UR B.5e.,B.ED. 05/07/1966 55C-1989 25/03/1991 25/3/1991 25/3/1991468 Rammoy Kar UR B.5e. 28/12/1966 55C-1989 29/04/1991 29/04/1991 29/04/1991

Maloy SarkarMADHYAMI 05/01/1967 06/06/1991 06/06/1991 06/06/1991469 UR 55C-1989

K470 Subir Kumar Ghosh UR H.5. 24/12/1965 55C-1989 22/03/1991 22/03/1991 22/03/1991471 Alok Poddar UR{PH) B.A. 12/01/1961 55C-1989 26/06/1991 26/06/1991 26/06/1991472 Maniklal Purkait 5C H.5. 17/3/1968 55C-1989 13/03/1991 13/03/1991 13/03/1991473 Sumit Biswas 5C H.5. 12/02/1969 55C-1989 26/08/1991 26/08/1991 26/08/1991

474 Nirbedananda Midya UR (PH) H.5. 07/10/1960 55C-1989 21/10/1991 21/10/1991 21/10/1991

475 Narayan Chandra 5C B.COM 08/05/1962 55C-1989 18/02/1991 18/02/1991 18/02/1991Sardar

476 Subrata Sarkar 5C B.5C 07/10/1967 55C-1989 26/07/1991 26/07/1991 26/07/1991477 Sufal Chandra Das 5C B.COM 11/03/1963 55C-1989 16/04/1991 16/04/1991 16/04/1991478 Rampada Mandai 5C B.COM 05/12/1963 55C-1989 13/09/1991 13/09/1991 13/09/1991

479 Ashok Kumar Mandai 5C B.COM 08/02/1965 55C-1989 12/04/1991 12/04/1991 12/04/1991

480 Pranabananda Bala 5C B.5C 04/04/1965 55C-1989 26/03/1991 26/03/1991 26/03/1991

481 Swapan Kumar Das - 5C B.COM 20/08/1967 55C-1989 19/04/1991 19/04/1991 19/04/1991II

482 Arun Kumar Bagani 5C B.COM 20/09/1963 55C-1989 11/02/91{AN) 11/02/91{AN) 11/02/91{AN)483 Jagannath Saha 5C B.5C 15/11/1967 55C-1989 26/02/1991 26/02/1991 26/02/1991484 Srikanta Mani 5C B.5C 09/02/1961 55C-1989 29/10/1991 29/10/1991 29/10/1991485 Gopa Roy 5C B.A. 10/07/1961 55C-1989 25/02/1992 25/02/1992 25/02/1992

486 Anup Kumar Mandai 5C B.COM 01/04/1962 55C-1989 04/12/1991 04/12/1991 04/12/1991

Page 21 of 36

Page 31: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

I 487 Samir Kanti Das SC B.COM 03/01/1963 SSC-1989 09/09/1991 09/09/1991 09/09/1991488 P. T.Sherpa ST H.S. 18/02/1967 SSC-1989 27/05/1991 27/05/1991 27/05/1991489 Shyamal Chakraborty UR B.Com 30/11/1967 Cash 09/11/1989 09/11/1989 09/11/1989

490 Abhijit UR B.Com 03/01/1968 Cash 17/11/1989 17/11/1989 17/11/1989Bandyopadhyay

491 Bina Sen UR B.Se. 27/09/1963 Compassionate 26/06/1989 26/06/1989 26/06/1989

492 Uttam Kumar Singha UR B.A. 02/01/1964 Compassionate 29/06/1989 29/06/1989 29/06/1989

493 Arundhuti Sengupta UR B.A. 10/01/1964 Compassionate 25/09/1989 25/09/1989 25/09/1989

494 MADHYAMI 12/10/1966 06/11/1989 06/11/1989 06/11/1989Tapan Barua UR CompassionateK

495 Malati Mitra UR MATRIC 25/12/1951 PR 27/11/1974 27/11/1974 12/04/1990496 Indu Rani UR B.5C(H} 02/09/1969 SSC-1990 28/09/1992 28/09/1992 28/09/1992497 Joydeep Banerjee UR B.Com{H} 30/08/1966 SSC-1990 22/05/1992 22/05/1992 22/05/1992

Prema 14/07/1971 09/07/1992 09/07/1992 09/07/1992498Venkatachalam

UR B.Cm SSC-1990

499 Tapas Kanti Mandai SC B.A 15/05/1967 SSC-1990 03/07/1992 03/07/1992 03/07/1992Prasanta Kumar 04/11/1965 10/09/1992 10/09/1992 10/09/1992500Mandai

UR B.SC SSC-1990

501 Suvendu Dutta UR B.SC 02/01/1967 SSC-1990 24/07/1992 24/07/1992 24/07/1992502 Oipankar Marik UR B.Se 03/09/1968 SSC-1990 03/08/1992 03/08/1992 03/08/1992503 Bijoy Kumar Basak UR H.5 29/01/1971 SSC-1990 03/07/1992 03/07/1992 03/07/1992504 Arun Kumar Mehera UR B.SC 03/02/1966 SSC-1990 28/07/1992 28/07/1992 28/07/1992

505 Lal Mohan Haldar SC P.U. 31/05/1946 PR 13/07/1976 13/07/1976 09/03/1990506 Sandip Pal UR B.5C 17/07/1966 SSC-1990 13/08/1992 13/08/1992 13/08/1992507 Suvra Deb UR B.SC 09/02/1967 SSC-1990 09/07/1992 09/07/1992 09/07/1992508 Sujit kumar Pal UR B.SC 10/04/1967 SSC-1990 04/08/1992 04/08/1992 04/08/1992509 Siddhartha Oas UR B.SC 05/05/1967 SSC-1990 18/06/1992 18/06/1992 18/06/1992510 Dwarikanath Roy UR SSCE {Equv 08/09/1967 5SC-1990 20/08/1992 20/08/1992 20/08/1992to H.S.}

Page 22 of 36

Page 32: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

511 Puranjan Roy UR B.Se 24/04/1968 SSC-1990 13/07/1992 13/07/1992 13/07/1992Chowdhuri

512 Arup Kumar Roy UR B.SC 18/12/1965 SSC-1990 25/06/1992 25/06/1992 25/06/1992513 Manas Ranjan UR B.5C(H) 22/06/1966 SSC-1990 28/10/1992 28/10/1992 28/10/1992

Rakshit514 Gautam Bhar UR B.SC 04/01/1966 SSC-1990 15/09/1992 15/09/1992 15/09/1992515 Chinmoy Sardar SC S.F. 20/10/1956 PR 08/07/1977 08/07/1977 07/03/1990516 Naba Kumar Das UR B.COM(H) 01/01/1967 SSC-1990 02/07/1992 02/07/1992 02/07/1992517 Jayanta Kumar Roy UR H.S 01/12/1965 SSC-1990 29/09/1992 29/09/1992 29/09/1992518 Pradip Sen UR B.SC 23/09/1966 SSC-1990 30/07/1992 30/07/1992 30/07/1992

Susanta Kumar 04/08/1967 19/08/1992 19/08/1992 19/08/1992519Chowdhury

UR H.S SSC-1990

520 Amit Kumar Pal UR B.COM 26/08/1965 SSC-1990 22/10/1992 22/10/1992 22/10/1992521 Tarak nath Saha UR B.COM 08/09/1965 SSC-1990 19/11/1992 19/11/1992 19/11/1992522 Ratan Dey UR B.COM(H) 07/09/1965 SSC-1990 02/07/1992 02/07/1992 02/07/1992523 Goutam Brahmachary UR H.5 01/01/1967 SSC-1990 04/08/1992 04/08/1992 04/08/1992

524 Shyamal Kumar Dutta SC B.COM 01/02/1966 SSC-1990 14/09/1992 14/09/1992 14/09/1992

Krishna Gobinda 19/01/1956 05/05/1981 05/05/1981 09/03/1990525Sarkar

SC H.5. PR

526 Pradyut Haldar SC B.COM 15/02/1969 SSC-1990 27/11/1992 27/11/1992 27/11/1992527 Avijit Burman SC B.COM 14/10/1970 SSC-1990 08/09/1992 08/09/1992 08/09/1992528 Anima Mondal SC B.A 09/03/1962 SSC-1990 14/08/1992 14/08/1992 14/08/1992

529 Tapan Kumar Biswas SC B.SC 01/12/1962 SSC-1990 14/09/1992 14/09/1992 14/09/1992

530 Aloke Kumar Naskar SC B.COM 03/10/1963 SSC-1990 28/10/1992 28/10/1992 28/10/1992

531 Asit Kumar Sen UR(PH) B.SC 14/02/1965 SSC-1990 18/09/1992 18/09/1992 18/09/1992532 Sukhendu Gupta UR(PH) B.COM 20/10/1968 SSC-1990 23/07/1992 23/07/1992 23/07/1992533 Ashok Pal UR (ESM) H.S 03/06/1955 SSC-1990 19/10/1992 19/10/1992 19/10/1992534 Pradip Kumar UR (ESM) H.S 19/01/1952 SSC-1990 21/09/1992 21/09/1992 21/09/1992

Mahanta

535 Shanti Ranjan UR H.S. 23/02/1957 PR 16/02/1981 16/02/1981 09/03/1990Debnath-II

Page 23 of 36

Page 33: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

· 560 Sanajit Naskar 5C B.A 04/09/1968 55C-1991 11/06/1993 11/06/1993 11/06/1993561 Sunil Saha UR B.COM 18/10/1968 55C-1991 24/06/1993 . 24/06/1993 24/06/1993562 Shilabrata Nandy UR B.5C 16/05/1969 55C-1991 29/07/1993 29/07/1993 29/07/1993563 Jayanta Kumar Ghosh UR B.5C 18/01/1969 55C-1991 28/05/1993 28/05/1993 28/05/1993- II

564 Rabindra Nath Sardar 5C B.COM 02/03/1968 55C-1991 26/07/1993 26/07/1993 26/07/1993

565 Jayanta Kumar 5C B.COM 02/01/1970 55C-1991 19/07/1993 19/07/1993 19/07/1993Mondal566 Malati Haldar 5C B.A 30/06/1968 55C-1991 24/09/1993 24/09/1993 24/09/1993567 Asit Biswas 5C H.5 04/07/1966 55C-1991 28/06/1993 - 28/06/1993 28/06/1993568 Anup Kumar Mitra 5C H.5 11/02/1970 55C-1991 25/11/1993 25/11/1993 25/11/1993569 Sunil Kumar Sarkar 5C H.5. 14/02/1966 55C-1991 27/08/1993 27/08/1993 27/08/1993570 Debasish Oey UR(E5M) P.U 26/02/1958 55C-1991 16/07/1993 16/07/1993 16/07/1993571 Salhay Tudu 5T B.A 22/07/1968 55C-1991 01/10/1993 01/10/1993 01/10/1993572 Tulika Chaudhuri UR B.A. 14/05/1970 Compassionate 08/11/1991 08/11/1991 08/11/1991

Sanjoy Kumar MitraMADHYAMI 29/09/1965 16/01/1992 16/01/1992 16/01/1992573 UR Compassionate

K

574 Minakshi Adhikary 5C B.A 14/12/1964 Compassionate 02/04/1992 (AN) 02/04/1992 (AN) 02/04/1992(AN)

575 Mrinal Kanti Sarkar 5C H.5.5.C 10/05/1973 Compassionate 02/04/1992 (AN) 02/04/1992 (AN) 02/04/1992(AN)

Ashok Kumar 05/01/1953 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 12/07/1976576Chatterjee

UR B.COM PR

577 Jayanta Kumar Haldar 5C B.COM 20/12/1968 55C-1992 29/06/1994 29/06/1994 29/06/1994

578 Oebiprasad Sardar 5C H.5 30/12/1968 55C-1992 26/08/1994 26/08/1994 26/08/1994579 Ashish Kumar Haldar 5C B.A 03/02/1969 55C-1992 22/09/1994 22/09/1994 22/09/1994

580 Priyabrata Banik UR B.COM(H) 05/09/1969 55C-1992 04/07/1994 04/07/1994 04/07/1994581 Sourav Ghosh UR B.COM(H) 13/06/1972 55C-1992 10/08/1994 10/08/1994 10/08/1994582 Chittaranjan Roy 5C H.5 26/11/1964 55C-1992 19/09/1994 19/09/1994 19/09/1994583 Ashok Sardar 5C B.COM 18/02/1968 55C-1992 24/06/1994 24/06/1994 24/06/1994

Page 25 of 36

Page 34: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 536 Arun Walter Beck ST H.S 25/05/1966 SSC-1990 01/03/1992 01/03/1992 01/03/1992537 Krishna Chandra Tudu ST B.A 28/10/1965 SSC-1990 21/01/1993 21/01/1993 21/01/1993

538 Daso Soren ST B.A{H) 22/02/1964 SSC-1990 18/12/1992 18/12/1992 18/12/1992Christopher Kerketta

MADHYAMI 28/01/1965 20/08/1992 20/08/1992 20/08/1992539 ST SSC-1990K

540 Kamal Ranjan Sarkhel UR B.Se. 15/04/1950 Surplus 09/03/1990 09/03/1990

Ajoy Kumar SantraCLASS X 15/01/1952 28/05/1990 28/05/1990541 UR ICTPass

542 Avijit Dey Roy UR H.S. 31/10/1966 ICT 02/07/1990 02/07/1990543 Debasish Banerjee UR H.S. 08/12/1958 PR 17/03/1981 17/03/1981 13/03/1990

544 Nagendra Kumar UR H.5. 07/07/1956 PR 09/03/1981 09/03/1981 07/03/1990Singh

545 Tapan Kumar Das UR H.S. 03/01/1960 PR 17/03/1981 17/03/1981 09/03/1990546 Subhasish Sanyal UR H.S. 22/10/1958 PR 30/10/1981 30/10/1981 09/03/1990

Samir Kumar 17/02/1954 03/10/1982 03/10/1982 19/06/1990547Hembram

ST H.5. PR

548 Jiban Kanai Poddar UR H.S. 28/03/1956 Compassionate 01/11/90{AN) 01/11/90{AN) 01/11/90{AN)549 Ajoy Kumar Das UR P.U. 01/06/1958 PR 21/11/1983 21/11/1983 11/02/1992

550 Gopal Krishna SC H.5 08/07/1963 SSC-1991 09/07/1993 09/07/1993 09/07/1993Mondal

551 Subir Hazra UR H.S 10/06/1971 SSC-1991 25/06/1993 25/06/1993 25/06/1993

552 Manindra Nath 16/12/1965 24/09/1993 24/09/1993 24/09/1993Mondal

SC B.COM SSC-1991

553 Sanjit Kumar Bose UR B.COM 29/11/1966 SSC-1991 07/07/1993 07/07/1993 07/07/1993

554 Sushanta Kumar Barai SC B.SC 13/02/1967 SSC-1991 11/10/1993 11/10/1993 11/10/1993

555 Dulal Debnath UR B.COM{H) 01/06/1967 SSC-1991 16/07/1993 16/07/1993 16/07/1993556 Tapan Das SC B.Com 31/12/1968 SSC-1991 16/07/1993 16/07/1993 16/07/1993557 Tarak Dutta UR B.COM 28/02/1968 SSC-1991 16/07/1993 16/07/1993 16/07/1993558 Barun Kumar Roy UR B.SC 01/01/1967 SSC-1991 16/07/1993 16/07/1993 16/07/1993559 Dinesh Chandra Das UR B.COM 02/01/1967 SSC-1991 20/07/1993 20/07/1993 20/07/1993

Page 24 of 36

Page 35: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

r

Kali Charan TuduMADHYAMI 21/04/1974 23/08/1994 23/08/1994 23/08/1994584 ST SSC-1992

K585 Smt. Deepa Ghosh ST M.A 06/12/1970 SSC-1992 06/03/1995 06/03/1995 06/03/1995586 Haradhan Saha UR H.S. 07/01/1955 PR 12/07/1976 12/07/1976 30/06/1993587 Gauranga Das UR S.F 15/01/1952 PR 30/11/1974 30/11/1974 02/07/1993

588 Pradyut Ghosh UR H.S 06/05/1972 Compassionate 14/08/1992 14/08/1992 14/08/1992

589 Jayanta Ghosh UR H.5 02/12/1967 Compassionate 21/08/1992 21/08/1992 21/08/1992

590 Suvrangshu Biswas UR B.A 06/06/1967 Compassionate 02/04/1993 02/04/1993 02/04/1993

MADHYAMI 01/01/1958 06/04/1993 06/04/1993 06/04/1993591 Niva Rani Roy 5C CompassionateK

592 Samir Sarkar 5C H.S 09/12/1972 Compassionate 06/04/1993 06/04/1993 06/04/1993

593 Sasanka Biswas SC B.SC 23/08/1967 Compassionate 08/04/1993 08/04/1993 08/04/1993

594 leena Biswas UR H.S 21/06/1974 Compassionate 13/04/1993 13/04/1993 13/04/1993

595 Raj Kumar Tudu ST I.SC 07/03/1974 Com passionate 28/04/1993 28/04/1993 28/04/1993

596 Sumana Chakraborty UR B.SC(H) 01/02/1970 SSC-1993 18/09/1995 18/9/1995 18/9/1995

597 Satindra Saha 5C B.A 08/02/1970 SSC-1993 06/09/1995 09/06/1995 09/06/1995598 Subrata Dutta UR B.5C 13/03/1970 5SC-1993 07/08/1995 08/07/1995 08/07/1995599 Baby De UR B.A 04/04/1970 SSC-1993 14/09/1995 14/9/1995 14/9/1995600 Prabir Kr. Saha 5C B.COM 26/12/1971 S5C-1993 31/07/1995 31/7/1995 31/7/1995601 Raja Pramanik SC B.5C 17/01/1972 55C-1993 26/07/1995 26/7/1995 26/7/1995

602 Sisir Kr. Chakraborty UR H.5. 08/08/1959 SSC-1993 15/04/1996 15/4/1996 15/4/1996

603 Sudip Kar UR H.5 08/01/1969 Compassionate 16/03/1994 16/03/1994 16/03/1994

Sujoy Kumar SarkarMADHYAMI 23/04/1956 13/07/1976 13/07/1976 28/06/1994604 UR PR

K

Page 26 of 36

Page 36: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

r, Hemendra Kumar605Ambastha

UR B.SC(H) 11/11/1972 SSC-1994 09/07/1996 09/07/1996 09/07/1996

606 Sudip UR B.COM 12/12/1971 SSC-1994 16/10/1996 16/10/1996 16/10/1996Bandyopadhyay

607 Soumitra Chakraborty UR B.COM 07/01/1973 SSC-1994 22/05/1996 22/05/1996 22/05/1996

608 Subrata Basu UR B.COM{H) 05/01/1970 SSC-1994 30/10/1996 30/10/1996 30/10/1996609 Rajendra Bishwas OBC B.A{H) 01/12/1970 SSC-1994 22/07/1996 22/07/1996 22/07/1996

610 Sudhangshu Shekhar SC B.SC 01/05/1971 SSC-1994 03/10/1996 03/10/1996 03/10/1996Biswas

611 Santanu Chatterjee UR B.SC 30/11/1970 SSC-1994 04/10/1996 04/10/1996 04/10/1996

612 Prasanta Kumar Basu UR B.COM{H) 10/02/1971 SSC-1994 24/09/1996 24/09/1996 24/09/1996

613 Anil Kumar OBC B.SC(H) 01/02/1971 SSC-1994 18/09/1996 18/09/1996 18/09/1996614 Swapan Dey UR H.S 07/02/1956 PR 18/12/1979 18/12/1979 28/06/1994615 Bimal Kumar Biswas SC B.COM 08/03/1965 SSC-1994 11/07/1996 11/07/1996 11/07/1996

616 Akhil Kumar Sardar SC H.S 02/08/1965 SSC-1994 10/07/1997 10/07/1997 10/07/1997617 Sudip Kumar Biswas SC H.S. 01/01/1969 SSC-1994 24/07/1996 24/07/1996 24/07/1996

618 Ranjit Kumar SC s.sc., B.A. 11/06/1969 SSC-1994 25/09/1996 25/09/1996 25/09/1996Majumdar

619 Raj kumar Roy SC B.COM 12/06/1969 SSC-1994 04/07/1996 04/07/1996 04/07/1996Durga Prasad Gupta

MADHYAMI 10/05/1975 28/08/1996 28/08/1996 28/08/1996620 OBC SSC-1994K

621 Dhriti Roy SC M.A 05/11/1966 SSC-1994 29/08/1996 29/08/1996 29/08/1996622 . Kaushal Kumar Arya OBC B.A{H) 05/07/1970 SSC-1994 30/07/1996 30/07/1996 30/07/1996

623 Bijoy Kumar Shaw ST B.COM 13/07/1970 SSC-1994 04/10/1996 04/10/1996 04/10/1996624 Kamal Mondal SC H.S 13/11/1965 ICT 18/04/1994 18/04/1994625 Susanta Saha SC B.COM 14/10/1968 ICT 01/06/1994 01/06/1994 01/06/1994626 Asit Dasgupta UR B.COM 24/11/1967 Compassionate 01/06/1994 01/06/1994 01/06/1994

627 Subrata Adhikary SC B.SC 01/09/1970 Compassionate 14/07/1994 14/07/1994 14/07/1994

Page 27 of 36

Page 37: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

r:I

673 Surajit Adhya UR B.SC(H} 24/12/1972 SSC-1997 21/03/2000 (A/N)21/03/2000 21/03/2000

(A/N) (A/N)

674 Mahadev Naskar SCB.COM,

20/02/1962 PR 23/09/1987 23/09/1987 14/05/1997B.A.(Eeon.}

675 Prajesh Kumar UR B.A(H} 22/12/1973 SSC-1997 21/03/2000 21/03/2000 21/03/2000676 Santanu Das-I UR B.SC 14/11/1973 5SC-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000

Gaur Shankar MandaiMADHYAMI

30/10/1974 17/07/2000 17/07/2000 17/07/2000677 SC S5C-1997K

678 Shardul Amit Singh UR B.Com(H} 18/01/1977 55C-1997 13/03/2000 13/03/2000 13/03/2000679 Tanweer Alam OBC B.A 20/12/1969 SSC-1997 12/07/2000 12/07/2000 12/07/2000

SomenathB.COM(H} 10/11/1975 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000680

ChowdhuryOBC 5SC-1997

681 Sanjib Kumar De OBC B.COM 15/05/1973 SSC-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000682 Amar Kumar Pyara OBC B.SC(H} 02/12/1975 S5C-1997 26/04/2000 26/04/2000 26/04/2000683 Sanjib Ghosh OBC B.COM 04/02/1972 5SC-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000684 Anima Bose UR H.S 14/07/1964 PR 18/01/1988 18/01/1988 05/12/1997685 Snehasish Chanda OBC M.COM 09/01/1971 SSC-1997 05/04/2000 05/04/2000 05/04/2000686 Bhaskar Sen OBC H.S. 01/10/1971 SSC-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000687 Soumitra Dey OBC B.SC 01/12/1975 S5C-1997 13/03/2000 13/03/2000 13/03/2000688 Sima Sarkar (Das) OBC B.SC 12/10/1971 SSC-1997 14/03/2000 14/03/2000 14/03/2000689 Bimalendu Sen OBC B.A 31/12/1969 55C-1997 16/03/2000 16/03/2000 16/03/2000690 Debabrata Ghosh OBC B.COM 04/02/1972 SSC-1997 03/04/2000 03/04/2000 03/04/2000691 Samaresh Pramanik OBC B.COM(H} 29/08/1974 S5C-1997 21/03/2000 21/03/2000 21/03/2000692 Francisca Ekka ST M.A. 30/11/1969 SSC-1997 24/07/2000 24/07/2000 24/07/2000

693Rajendra Kumar

ST M.A. 20/10/1975 SSC-1997 20/08/2000 20/08/2000 20/08/2000Meena

694MADHYAMI

06/03/1961 02/03/1988 02/03/1988 05/12/1997Hemanta Das SC PRK

695 Debasish Sengupta UR B.SC 12/02/1973 Compassionate 08/09/1997 08/09/1997 08/09/1997

696 Sikha Majumder SC B.A. 02/08/1959 Compassionate 17/11/1997 17/11/1997 17/11/1997

697 Chandan Dey UR S.F. 16/04/1974 Sports Quota 28/12/1998 28/12/1998 28/12/1998

Page 30 of 36

Page 38: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

· )628 Debasish Dey -II UR H.S 16/02/1975 Compassionate 25/07/1994 25/07/1994 25/07/1994

Gopal Chandra MADHYAMI 06/03/1968 26/07/1994 26/07/1994 26/07/1994629 SC CompassionateGochhayat K

630 Kamal Bandhu Saha SC H.S 06/06/1965 Compassionate 09/09/1994 09/09/1994 09/09/1994

631 Tapash Biswas UR H.5 22/05/1970 Compassionate 06/10/1994 06/10/1994 06/10/1994

632 Mithu Saha SC H.S 20/11/1975 Compassionate 06/10/1994 06/10/1994 06/10/1994

633 Bivash Chandra Kayet UR B.COM(H) 09/01/1964 Compassionate 30/11/94(AN) 30/11/94(AN) 30/11/94(AN)634 Asim Saha SC H.5. 10/01/1967 ICT 02/01/1995 02/01/1995

635 Sankar Nath Sarkar UR H.S. 13/06/1956 PR 30/11/1974 30/11/1974 17/10/199614/08/95 (~O)

636 Tapas Roy UR B.COM. 19/03/1971 SSC-1995 02/04/1997 02/04/1997 02/04/1997637 SanjibSarkar UR B.SC 29/09/1970 SSC-1995 03/04/1997 03/04/1997 03/04/1997638 Goutam Kr.Chanda UR B.5C 10/10/1972 SSC-1995 03/04/1997 03/04/1997 03/04/1997639 Swarup Kumar Shee OBC H.S 21/11/1972 SSC-1995 12/03/1997 12/03/1997 12/03/1997

640 BiplabKumar Biswas SC B.A. 14/01/1970 SSC-1995 02/05/1997 02/05/1997 02/05/1997

641 Swapan Kumar SC B.A. 28/04/1976 SSC-1995 30/04/1997 30/04/1997 30/04/1997Biswas642 Ashish Kumar Biswas SC B.A. 25/12/1972 SSC-1995 11/07/1997 11/07/1997 11/07/1997643 RanjitKr.Chandra UR (ESM) S.F. 31/12/1946 SSC-1995 26/06/1997 26/06/1997 26/06/1997644 Bidyut Kumar Sarkar UR (ESM) B.A.,Spl. 02/01/1961 SSC-1995 14/03/1997 14/03/1997 14/03/1997B.A.645 Sikha Kundu UR B.SC 22/07/1958 PR 24/03/1984 24/03/1984 17/08/1995

MAOHYAMI 26/11/1962 02/07/1984 02/07/1984 17/08/1995646 KantiLalDebnath UR PRK

Tanmoy Chakraborty MAOHYAMI 01/03/1970 01/12/1995 01/12/1995 01/12/1995647 UR CompassionateK

Page 28 of 36

Page 39: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

'\698 Kaushik Bhattacharya UR H.S. 31/03/1974 Sports Quota 28/12/1998 28/12/1998 28/12/1998

699 Ayaz Ahmed UR B.A. 20/06/1976 Sports Quota 28/12/1998 28/12/1998 28/12/1998700 Rudra Mukherjee UR B.COM{H} 31/08/1978 Sports Quota 31/12/1998 31/1;2/1998 31/12/1998701 Tapash Kr. Biswas UR S.F. 28/02/1959 PR 14/03/1980 14/03/1980 23/11/1998702 Gautam Guha UR S.F. 06/09/1963 PR 30/07/1984 30/07/1984 23/11/1998

Sudipta ChakrabortyMADHYAMI 07/01/1965 21/09/1987 21/09/1987 23/11/1998703 UR PR

K704 Javed Mansoor UR B.A 23/03/1978 Sports Quota 15/01/1999 15/01/1999 15/01/1999

Dipankar AdhikaryMADHYAMI 28/09/1978 18/01/1999 18/01/1999 18/01/1999705 UR Sports Quota

K

706 Avik Basu UR B.COM{Pt-l} 22/09/1975 Sports Quota 15/01/1999 15/01/1999 15/01/1999

707 Somenath Chatterjee UR H.S. 08/01/1971 Compassionate 13/04/1998 13/04/1998 13/04/1998

Sanjib BhumijMADHYAMI 27/01/1980 21/04/1998 21/04/1998 21/04/1998708 ST Compassionate

K

709 Pinaki Dutta UR B.SC 17/10/1975 Compassionate 14/10/1998 14/10/1998 14/10/1998

710 Ravinder Kaur SC H.S. 10/01/1951 Compassionate 01/12/1998 01/12/1998 01/12/1998

711 Kanchan Sil UR B.A. 15/12/1970 DR-ICT 02/02/1999 02/02/1999MADHYAMI 01/06/1970 31/10/1988 31/10/1988 25/02/1999712 Chandana Bose SC PR

K

Sukla DuttaMADHYAMI 25/02/1964 08/11/1988 08/11/1988 25/02/1999713 UR PR

K714 Purna Chandra Pani UR B.A. 26/03/1963 PR 03/03/1989 03/03/1989 25/02/1999715 Bipranshu Sanyal UR H.S. 15/08/1961 PR 24/05/1989 24/05/1989 25/02/1999716 G. Kaviyarasan UR S.F. 29/04/1967 PR 16/10/1989 16/10/1989 15/04/1999717 Sujit Kumar Garai UR H.S. 20/08/1962 PR 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 25/02/1999

Joyjit AdhikaryMADHYAMI 21/03/1972 14/05/1990 14/05/1990 25/02/1999718 UR PR

K

Angshu Kumar GhoshMADHYAMI 02/10/1964 12/07/1990 12/07/1990 25/02/1999719 UR PR

K

Page 31 of 36

Page 40: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

~ Smt. Mithu (Sen) MADHYAMI720 UR 14/10/1964 PR 25/07/1990 25/07/1990 12/03/99{AN)Mitra K

721 Ashis Chakraborty-II UR B.COM 20/11/1966 PR 17/07/1990 17/07/1990 25/02/1999Sarbari Biswas 30/06/1966 01/12/1992 01/12/1992 25/02/1999722(Soren)

ST H.5. PRX Passed

723 Sudhir Kr. Shaw UR equv.To 18/10/1979 SportsQuota 20/12/1999 20/12/1999 20/12/1999MADHYAMIK

724 Shyamal Konra ST S.F. 15/11/1974 Compassionate 15/11/1999 15/11/1999 15/11/1999MADHYAMI 28/03/1963 09/12/1991 09/12/1991 23/12/1999725 Tapas Kr. Saha UR PR

K

726 Alpana KayalMADHYAMI 02/04/1969 26/09/1988 26/09/1988 23/12/1999SC PR

K

727 Shyamali Dhar UR H.S. 17/02/1960 Compassionate 31/03/2000 31/03/2000 31/03/2000

728 Arindam Dutta UR H.S. 17/02/1980 Compassionate 20/04/2000 20/04/2000 20/04/2000

Shila GhoshMADHYAMI 04/03/1954 24/04/2000 24/04/2000 24/04/2000729 UR Compassionate

K

730 Deepa Sarkar UR H.S. 07/04/1960 Compassionate 05/05/2000 05/05/2000 05/05/2000

731 Kaushik Kr. Mondal SC B.A.{H} 07/11/1974 Compassionate 17/05/2000 17/05/2000 17/05/2000Sandeep Kr. INTERMIDIA 01/07/1975 16/06/2000 16/06/2000 16/06/2000732 UR SportsQuotaSrivastava TE

733 Tarun Kr. Dey UR H.S. 15/08/1957 PR 19/07/1976 19/07/1976 01/07/2000734 Goutam Biswas UR P.U. 23/01/1956 PR 18/09/1981 18/09/1981 01/08/2000

Abani Bhusan BiswasMADHYAMI 01/01/1954 22/05/1982 22/05/1982 01/08/2000735 SC PR

KMADHYAMI 17/11/1968 02/12/1992 02/12/1992 29/08/2000736 Sumanta Roy UR PR

K737 Swapan Sinhababu UR B.A 20/10/1968 PR 04/12/1992 04/12/1992 01/09/2000

Page 32 of36

Page 41: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

) 738 Tapash Dutta UR H.S. 05/02/1967 PR 01/12/1992 01/12/1992 01/10/2000739 Kabi Kumar Sarkar UR H.S. 09/05/1967 PR 03/12/1992 03/12/1992 01/10/2000740 Saugata Das UR B.A. 07/02/1971 PR 01/12/1992 01/12/1992 01/10/2000

MADHYAMI 07/04/1968 01/12/1992 01/12/1992 08/03/2001741 Dasudev Bachhar SC PRK

MADHYAMI 02/03/1962 30/11/1992 30/11/1992 08/03/2001742 Prosanta Sarkar SC PRK

Anita SarkarMADHYAMI 09/06/1963 17/04/1985 17/04/1985 05/05/2003743 UR PR

K744 Archana Saha - II UR H.S. 24/11/1964 PR 08/03/1988 08/03/1988 05/05/2003745 Nitya Ranjan Saha UR B.COM 01/02/1964 PR 25/03/1988 25/03/1988 05/05/2003746 Sukla Roy UR S.F. 13/05/1963 PR 02/12/1988 02/12/1988 05/05/2003747 lIa Banerjee UR H.S. 03/04/1965 PR 19/07/1990 19/07/1990 05/05/2003748 Sudipa Chatterjee UR B.A. 01/11/1967 PR 14/09/1994 14/09/1994 05/05/2003

MADHYAMI 15/06/1970 12/09/1994 12/09/1994 05/05/2003749 Prasenjit Das UR PRK

750 Swapan Kumar Sarkar UR B.SC(H) 14/01/1968 PR 12/09/1994 12/09/1994 05/05/2003

751 Krishna Dhan Baidya SC B.COM 03/01/1966 PR 13/09/1994 13/09/1994 05/05/2003

752 Kanai Chandra Paul UR B.A. 24/11/1959 PR 19/09/1994 (AN) 19/09/1994 (AN) 05/05/2003

MADHYAMI 10/01/1968 21/09/1992 21/09/1992 05/05/2003753 Santanu Das - II UR PRK

754 Smt Swapna Ghosh UR Madhyamik 02/01/1963 PR 08/03/1988 08/03/1988 30/10/2003

755 Uttam Kr. Haldar SC B.A. 02/09/1962 PR 04/04/1988 04/04/1988 30/10/2003756 Partha Basak UR H.S. 04/01/1966 PR 08/06/1992 08/06/1992 30/10/2003757 Subhajit Nath UR H.S. 20/02/1977 PR 02/11/1998 02/11/1998 28/03/2005758 Pulak Sarkar OBC B.Com. 02/02/1970 PR 20/11/1998 20/11/1998 28/03/2005759 Abu Sarif Akunji OBC H.S. 05/01/1974 PR 19/11/1998 19/11/1998 28/03/2005760 Sanjoy Kumar Pal OBC B.Com. 04/12/1974 PR 23/11/1998 23/11/1998 28/03/2005

761 Sanjoy Kumar OBC Madhyamik 04/01/1974 PR 23/11/1998 23/11/1998 28/03/2005Malakar

Page 33 of 36

Page 42: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

~ 762 Pinaki Mazumdar OBCMadyamik 16/10/1969 PR 23/11/1998 23/11/1998 28/03/2005(H.S.)

763 Pradip Oas OBC B.A. 04/07/1969 PR 23/11/1998 23/11/1998 30/03/2005764 Arup Kumar UR H.S. 21/09/1955 PR 07/08/1985 07/08/1985 07/10/2005

MukhopadhyayManik Kumar 07/02/1958 07/08/1985 07/08/1985 07/10/2005765Chandra

UR H.S. PR

766 Sajal Kumar Oas OBC H.S. 15/03/1954 PR 15/09/1978 15/09/1978 07/10/2005(D.O.)

767 Jahalal Kar UR Madhyamik 01/09/1962 PR 02/03/1988 02/03/1988 19/10/2008

768 Sankari Nath OBC Madhyamik 25/01/1971 PR 24/11/1998 24/11/1998 03/08/2006

769 Sudip Nandi UR Madhyamik 08/08/1975 PR 16/03/1999 16/03/1999 04/08/2006

770 Ratan Kumar Oas SC B.Com. 02/08/1972 PR 25/11/1999 25/11/1999 03/08/2006771 Pritam Samanta UR B.Com. 06/11/1974 PR 26.11.1999 26.11.1999 03/08/2006772 Amal Kumar Oas OBC B.Com. 28/12/1972 PR 30/11/1999 30/11/1999 03/08/2006773 Atanu Sengupta UR B.Com. 02/01/1976 PR 15/12/1999 15/12/1999 03/08/2006774 Sabmit Pramanick SC H.S. 24/12/1972 PR 20/12/1999 20/12/1999 03/08/2006775 Smt. Sibani Sarkar OBC Madhyamik 10/12/1974 PR 20/12/1999 20/12/1999 03/08/2006776 Binod Thakur OBC B.Com. 2512/1974 PR 15/12/1999 15/12/1999 03/08/2006777 Sujoy Oey UR H.S. 08/05/1980 PR 15/12/1999 15/12/1999 13/09/2007778 Sadananda Chatterjee UR Madhyamik 31/12/1963 PR 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 13/09/2007

779 Shibu Banerjee UR Madhyamik 02/01/1964 PR 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 13/09/2007

780 Amal Biswas SC H.S. 13/11/1974 PR 10/09/2009 10/09/2009 13/09/2007781 Mrinmoy Outta UR Madhyamik 15/09/1972 PR 10/09/2009 10/09/2009 13/09/2007782 Sudiman Guha UR H.S. 02/03/1971 PR 10/09/2009 10/09/2009 13/09/2007783 Mridul Kr. Mukherjee UR B.Com. 02/01/1969 PR 10/09/2009 10/09/2009 13/09/2007784 Pradip Raha UR H.S. 11/03/1980 PR 15/12/1999 15/12/1999 13/09/2007

Page 34 of 36

Page 43: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

· ») 785 Parthe Das SC H.5. 07/06/1977 PR 16/12/1999 16/12/1999 13/09/2007e-786 SABYASACHI DAS UR S.5.E. 27/08/1978 PR 28/12/1998 28/12/1998 23/12/2009

AJAY PRAKASH 13/04/1979 05/06/2000 05/06/2000 23/12/2009787 UR H.S. PRTHAPA

SOMENATH Madhyamik 25/10/1963 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 23/12/2009788 UR PRBANERJEE

789 SUSANTA GHOSH UR Madhyamik 18/09/1962 PR 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 23/12/2009790 MD. SHAMIM UR S.F. 20/02/1960 PR 01/04/1982 01/04/1982 24/12/2009

SUBIR KUMAR Madhyamik 06/10/1962 29/12/1986 29/12/1986 30/12/2009791 UR PRCHANDA

792 RAJ KUMAR SINGH SC Secondary 01/02/1965 PR 07/09/1988 07/09/1988 23/12/2009MD. EKRAM High 29/12/1967 05/01/1988 05/01/1988 23/12/2009793 UR PRHOSSAIN MadrasaSATYEN KU MAR 01/11/1964 17/07/1990 17/07/1990 23/12/2009794 UR H.S. PRBERA

795 GOUTAM RAHA OBC H.S. 01/12/1973 PR 09/08/1999 09/08/1999 23/12/2009796 PRADIP KR. SAHA - II SC Madhyamik 10/01/1963 PR 02/11/1988 02/11/1988 31/12/2009

797 DUlAl CH. DAS UR Madhyamik 05/01/1963 PR 12/04/1990 12/04/1990 24/03/2011SUBHAS CH. Madhyamik 19/10/1960 16/07/1990 16/07/1990 06/04/2011798 SC PRMAHANTA

799 PURNIMA DEWAN OBC B.A. 15/10/1974 PR 22/12/1999 22/12/1999 24/03/2011800 Subhadip Sarkar UR H.S. 15/14/1981 PR 31/01/2003 31/01/2003 24.03.2011

801 ANJU CHAKRABORTY UR IX Pass 21/12/1958 PR 20/01/1982 (A/N) 20/01/1982 18/12/2013(A/N) (O.O)

802 PARTHO ROY UR IX Pass 24/12/1967 PR 31/10/1988 (F/N) 31/10/1988 (F/N) 18/12/2013(O.O)

803 SMT. RUBY GHOSH PR 18/12/2013(O.O)

804 SMT. TUKAI DAS SC X Pass 04/03/1969 PR 09/04/1990 (F/N) 09/04/1990 (F/N) 18/12/2013(0.0)

Page 35 of 36

Page 44: T · in the case of N.R. Parmar Vs UOI, the Ministerial Subcommittee nominated to review the Seniority Lists has submitted its report on 24.08.2018. The report is hereby circulated

~ 18/12/2013'805 MD. MANSOOR All UR VIIIPass 10/01/1963 PR 12/04/1990 (F/N) 12/04/1990 (F/N) (O.O)806 BIJAY KUMAR DAS UR IXPass 01/01/1966 PR 17/06/1988 (F/N) 17/06/1988 (F/N)

18/12/2013(O.O)

807 DEBASHIS DUTIA UR IXPass 11/01/1968 PR 09/04/1990 (F/N) 09/04/1990 (F/N)18/12/2013

(O.O) J

808 SANKARLAL MONDAL UR VIIIPass 14/01/1964 PR 12/04/1990 (F/N) 12/04/1990 (F/N)18/12/2013

(O.O)15/01/1965 16/04/1990 (F/N) 16/04/1990 (F/N)

18/12/2013 I809 ALOKE CHANDRA DAS UR VIIIPass PR (O.O) I

..PROBHUDAYAL

13/09/1962 12/04/1990 (F/N) 12/04/1990 (F/N)18/12/2013 I

810 SC VIIIPass PRSONAR (0.0)

811 SUBHASHIS SINGHA UR VIIPass 21/02/1971 PR 26/06/1990 26/06/199018/12/2013

(O.O)812 RANJIT BACHAR OBC Madhyamik 06/03/1972 PR 30/11/1998 30/11/1998 01/04/2015

813 PROTUL SARDAR SC B.A. 17/05/1978 PR 27/06/2008 27/06/200824/03/2015

(A/N)MANAS KUMAR

05/01/1977 19/06/2008 19/06/200824/03/2015

814 SC B.A. PRSARDAR (A/N)

815 RAJIB BAG SC I.S.c. 18/03/1985 PR 26/06/2008 26/06/2008 01/04/2015

816 PRASENJIT DAS SC B.Com. 15/01/1977 PR 19/06/2008 19/06/200824/03/2015

(A/N)

817 MAHUA BISWAS SC B.A. 22/01/1985 PR 27/06/2008 27/06/200824/03/2015

(A/N)

818 JOY BANDHU SAHA SC B.Com. 11/02/1983 PR 24/06/2008 24/06/200824/03/2015

(A/N)

819 RANAJIT SARDAR ST B.A. 23/03/1981 PR 25/06/2008 25/06/200824/03/2015

(A/N)820 RITAN DAS SC H.S. 07/03/1979 PR 19/06/2008 19/06/2008 18/07/2016

821 RATAN KUMAR DAS SC B.Com 02/08/1972 PR 25/11/1999 25/11/1999 18/07/2016

822 HARI SHANKAR DAS SCSENIOR

05/03/1978 PR 01/07/2008 01/07/200806/07/2018

SECONDARY (A/N)

A Cl,y~!3 j ~ ~ ~~~ P~360f36