Susan B. Anthony: How the author used scrapbooks to track ... · NEWS & POLITICS TECH BUSINESS ARTS...
6
By Ellen Gruber Garvey | Posted Monday, Aug. 26, 2013, at 1:00 PM 33 How Susan B. Anthony Used Scrapbooks to Talk Back to the Media The Vault is Slate's history blog. Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter @slatevault, and find us on Tumblr. Find out more about what this space is all about here. The activists who struggled for seven decades to get women the right to vote followed the press closely. Scrapbooks were one of their tools. Nineteenth-century scrapbooks were more like today's digital bookmarks and favorites lists than simple memorabilia collections—nearly everyone used them to save articles, stories, and poems that they might not see again if they left them buried in piles of unindexed newspapers. Abraham Lincoln's scrapbooks tracked his debates with Stephen Douglas, Mark Twain's gathered trial records for possible stories, and women's rights activists collected news items on attacks on women as fuel for speeches. Susan B. Anthony's 33-volume scrapbook, now at the Library of Congress, begins with a refutation of masculine objections to women speaking in public. She opens the first volume with an article transcribed from an 1837 issue of the abolitionist paper The Liberator. The anonymous author, speaking for a Protestant church organization, proclaimed that public speaking would make a woman's character "unnatural.” Anthony's riposte was her teaching license, pasted in below: Wasn't teaching another form of public speaking? Anthony outlived her comrade Elizabeth Cady Stanton (another scrapbook maker) by four years. Anthony collected obituaries and articles about Stanton after her 1902 death. Stanton's death had prompted the popular magazine Collier's Weekly to ask Anthony for two articles summing up their work. Perhaps it was because Collier's attention to women's rights issues had previously been slight that Anthony noted next to the pasted-in clipping that the article was "called out by Mrs. Stanton's death!!" Like many scrapbookers, Anthony didn't buy expensive blank books, but reused old ones—in this case an old ledger. The lines from it peep out at the bottom of the page. Ellen Gruber Garvey is the author of Writing with Scissors: American Scrapbooks From the Civil War to the Harlem Renaissance. Follow Follow @slate @slate 650K followers LOG IN/REGISTER OLDER The Saucy Juvenile Ballads Yankees Used to Taunt Jefferson Davis NEWER How to Host a Protest: Pages from the Organizers' Handbook for the March on Washington « » Like 126 Tweet Tweet 49 1 NEWS & POLITICS TECH BUSINESS ARTS LIFE HEALTH & SCIENCE SPORTS DOUBLE X PODCASTS PHOTOS VIDEO SLATEST BLOGS MYSLATE
Transcript of Susan B. Anthony: How the author used scrapbooks to track ... · NEWS & POLITICS TECH BUSINESS ARTS...
By Ellen Gruber Garvey | Posted Monday, Aug. 26, 2013, at 1:00 PM
33
How Susan B. Anthony Used Scrapbooks to Talk Back to the Media
The Vault is Slate's history blog. Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter @slatevault, and find us on Tumblr. Find out more about what this space isall about here.
The activists who struggled for seven decades to get women the right to vote followed the press closely. Scrapbooks were one of their tools.
Nineteenth-century scrapbooks were more like today's digital bookmarks and favorites lists than simple memorabilia collections—nearly everyone usedthem to save articles, stories, and poems that they might not see again if they left them buried in piles of unindexed newspapers. Abraham Lincoln'sscrapbooks tracked his debates with Stephen Douglas, Mark Twain's gathered trial records for possible stories, and women's rights activists collectednews items on attacks on women as fuel for speeches.
Susan B. Anthony's 33-volume scrapbook, now at the Library of Congress, begins with a refutation of masculine objections to women speaking inpublic. She opens the first volume with an article transcribed from an 1837 issue of the abolitionist paper The Liberator. The anonymous author,speaking for a Protestant church organization, proclaimed that public speaking would make a woman's character "unnatural.” Anthony's riposte washer teaching license, pasted in below: Wasn't teaching another form of public speaking?
Anthony outlived her comrade Elizabeth Cady Stanton (another scrapbook maker) by four years. Anthony collected obituaries and articles aboutStanton after her 1902 death. Stanton's death had prompted the popular magazine Collier's Weekly to ask Anthony for two articles summing up theirwork. Perhaps it was because Collier's attention to women's rights issues had previously been slight that Anthony noted next to the pasted-in clippingthat the article was "called out by Mrs. Stanton's death!!"
Like many scrapbookers, Anthony didn't buy expensive blank books, but reused old ones—in this case an old ledger. The lines from it peep out at thebottom of the page.
Ellen Gruber Garvey is the author of Writing with Scissors: American Scrapbooks From the Civil War to the Harlem Renaissance.
Follow Follow @slate@slate 650K followers LOG IN/REGISTER
OLDERThe Saucy Juvenile Ballads Yankees Used to Taunt Jefferson Davis
NEWER How to Host a Protest: Pages from the Organizers' Handbook
for the March on Washington
« »
Like 126 TweetTweet 49 1
NEWS & POLITICS TECH BUSINESS ARTS LIFE HEALTH & SCIENCE SPORTS DOUBLE X PODCASTS PHOTOS VIDEO SLATEST BLOGS MYSLATE
Library of Congress. Image courtesy Ellen Gruber Garvey.
Library of Congress. Image courtesy Ellen Gruber Garvey.
1 49
MORE FROM SLATEAn Overworked Chemist Is AllegedlyResponsible for One of the BiggestScandals in Massachusetts HistoryPolice Are Always “Asking for the Public’sHelp.” Here’s a Handy Guide on Whether toCooperate.When Did Indians Start DividingThemselves Into Castes?Why Did Almost All Societies Believe thatWomen Were Inferior to Men?A Boy Shot His Grandmother after PlayingGrand Theft Auto IV. Here’s Why ThisShouldn’t Be a Story about Violent VideoGames.
FROM AROUND THE WEB'No Muslim parking' signs in Texasshopping center shame us all (Opinion)allvoicesClip: A Jaw-Dropping Investigation of theChurch of Scientology FandorAverage Salary of a Catholic Priest eHowSaved By The Blood! Born-Again CelebrityChristians MadameNoireTen Things Every Dad Should Tell His SonBeliefnet.com
Guest
What are these links?
LOG IN/REGISTER
Please log in to comment.
Length: 0 characters (Max: 5000)
Click here to load comments.
Rebecca Onion is a writer living inPhiladelphia.
Buy a link here
1. Very Good Advice from Calvinand Hobbes Creator BillWatterson, BeautifullyIllustratedBy Gavin Aung Than | August 27,2013
Sponsored Links
VA Loan Refinance 2.50%2013 VA Loan Guidelines As Seen On MilitaryChannel ! All Loan AmountsVeteransAdministration.com
Stock Pick WinOpportunities Abound with This Company--Invest Today,Free Info!OTCStockPick.com
Odd Food Kills Joint PainWeird Food from the Himalayas fights offpainful joint pain for good.omegaflexformula.com
FROM AROUND THE WEBSaudi Arabian Women Unveiled (VICE)The Most Embarrassing Interview Fox News HasEver Done (Mevio)Did Nostradamus and St. Malachy Foresee thePope’s Resignation ! and the End of the World?(Beliefnet.com)20 Stars Who Left Scientology (Hollyscoop)No Pearly Gates For Them! Celebrities Who AreAtheists (MadameNoire)
What are these links?
OLDERThe Saucy Juvenile Ballads Yankees Used to Taunt Jefferson Davis
NEWER How to Host a Protest: Pages from the Organizers' Handbook
for the March on Washington
« »
SPONSORED FROM AROUND THE WEB
How New iPadsare Selling forUnder $40
How to FrenchKiss
Get On The Floor -5 Floor ExercisesThat Melt Fat
A New SolutionThat StopsSnoring and LetsYou Sleep
What's Your ShoePersonality?
See Anyone'sArrest RecordOnline!
How to track yourbudget and goalsaccurately
How to Add$1,000 to YourSocial SecurityChecks
5 Dumb MistakesThat Will DestroyYour Retirement
Pastor Mocked for'Biblical MoneyCode' (SeeShocking Video)
?
Post
PREV NEXT « »
Follow RSS
2. Why the Gin and Tonic Wasthe British Empire’s SecretWeaponBy Kal Raustiala | August 28, 2013
3. Marissa Mayer’s Haters GonnaHateBy David Auerbach | August 27, 2013
4. Love Canal Was Supposed toCause Cancer. How ManyPeople Died?By George Johnson | August 28,2013
5. What Does “Natural MaleEnhancement” Have to DoWith Email Privacy? A Lot.By Nate Anderson | August 28, 2013
Obama, Clinton, Carter to Speak onAnniversary of MLK Speech (Time)
Lady Gaga's Ex-DJ Recalls TheirDowntown Days (Rolling Stone)
Book Claims Secret Deformity MadeSalinger a Recluse (Newser)
Kate Middleton’s Post-Baby Body —Slim & Lovely Just 1 Month AfterBirth (Social Reader)
Poniewozik: The Making of ChelseaManning (Time)
Super-Heavy New Element Set toJoin Table (Newser)
7 tips for keeping your man (fromthe 1950s) (The Week)
Interracial Couple Attacked in NYC(The Root)
The Air Force's $40 Billion SpacePush (Foreign Policy)
WATCH: Miley Cyrus' bizarretwerking and 4 other VMA highlights(The Week)
U.N. Urges Peace as Attack AgainstSyria Looms (Time)
When Both Sides Of The MarijuanaDebate Use Actual Facts, ThingsGet Very Interesting (Upworthy)
How Turkey Went From 'ZeroProblems' to Zero Friends (ForeignPolicy)
Love Canal Was Supposedto Cause Cancer. ButActually No One Died.
Why Bloggers Fell for aFake TechCrunch StoryAbout Self-Driving Cars
Microsoft Invested Billionsin Bing—and Made GoogleBetter
Hushpuppies Are the BestFried Food. Sorry, Chicken,Potatoes, and Dough.
Should You Go See YourFavorite Band’s ReunionTour? Yes.
The Bottle Deposit ShouldBe 30 Cents. It’d Be Goodfor the Planet, the Poor, and
the Portly.
about us | contact us | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Discussion and Submission Guidelines | Slate on Facebook | ad choicesfeedback | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage
Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Division of the Washington Post Company
All contents © 2013 The Slate Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
