SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA PETITIONS · 2019-08-16 · Page 2 of 41 041P19-2 Jonathan Brunson...

of 41

SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA

PETITIONS

14 August 2019

010P19 State v. Brodie Lee

Hamilton

1. Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-1365)

2. State’s

Conditional PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Denied

2. Dismissed as

moot

017P13-3 State v. Ca’Sey R. Tyler Def’s Pro Se Motion

for PDR

(COAP19-105)

Denied

06/13/2019

Ervin, J. recused

022P19-3 State v. Jennifer

Jimenez/April Myers

1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Recall

Order for Arrest;

Failure to Appear;

Strike Called and

Failed; and to Set

Aside Bond

Forfeiture

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Recall

Order for Arrest;

Failure to Appear;

Strike Called and

Failed; and to Set

Aside Bond

Forfeiture

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

036P19 State v. Timothy John

Clark

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-1356)

Denied

Ervin, J., recused

of 41

041P19-2 Jonathan Brunson v.

North Carolina

Innocence Inquiry

Commission and the

State of North Carolina

Plt’s Pro Se Motion

for Petition for

Rehearing of PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31 (COA18-

659)

Dismissed

044P19-2 Jonathan E. Brunson v.

North Carolina

Department of Public

Safety, North Carolina

Prisoner Legal Services,

Inc., and the State of

North Carolina


for Petition for

Rehearing of PDR

Dismissed

055P19 Ashley D. Carney v.

Wake County Sheriff’s

Office

1. Plt’s Pro Se PDR

Prior to a Decision

of the COA

2. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for Timely

Filing of PDR

1. Dismissed

2. Denied

063P19 State v. Michael

Christopher Weaver

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-740)

Denied

065A19 In the Matter of:

A.R.A., P.Z.A., Z.K.A.

Respondent-

Father’s Motion to

Withdraw Appeal

Allowed

07/01/2019

068P19-2 State v. Eric

Christopher Orr

Def’s Pro Se Petition

for Writ of

Certiorari to Review

Decision of the COA

(COA18-424)

Denied

of 41

074P98-6 State v. William T.

Barnes

1. Def’s Pro Se

Petition for Writ of

Mandamus

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion in the

Alternative to

Appoint Counsel

1. Denied

07/01/2019

2. Dismissed as

moot

07/01/2019

075P19 State v. Adam Warren

Conley

1. State’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-305)

2. State’s Petition

for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S

§ 7A-31

1. Allowed

03/06/2019

2. Allowed

3. Allowed

080P19 State v. Jerry Lee

Adams, Jr.

Def’s Pro Se Motion

for PDR Under

N.C.G.S § 7A-31

(COA17-601)

Denied

082A14-2 State v. Sethy Tony

Seam


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-202)

2. Def’s Motion to

Amend PDR

1. Allowed

2. Allowed

Ervin, J., recused

Davis, J., recused

of 41

085P19 State v. Adam Joshua

Sanders


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-476)

2. Def’s Petition in

the Alternative for

Writ of Certiorari to

Review Decision of

the COA

3. Def’s Motion in

the Alternative to

Remand Case for

Evidentiary

Hearing

4. State’s Motion to

Dismiss Petitions

1. Denied

2. Denied

3. Denied

4. Dismissed as

moot

086P19 State v. Travis

Kingsberry

1. Def’s Notice of

Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question

(COA18-226)


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Def’s Petition for


Review Decision of

the COA


Dismiss PDR


Dismiss Appeal

1. ---

2. ---

3. Denied

4. Allowed

5. Allowed

091P14-6 State v. Salim Abdu

Gould


for Habeas Corpus

Arbitration-

Mediation

Denied

07/24/2019

Davis, J. recused

of 41

094P19 State v. James A. Cox 1. State’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-692)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s PDR

4. Def’s Conditional

PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

03/22/2019

2. Allowed

3. Allowed

4. Denied

098P19 State v. Curtis O’Neil

Logan

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-723)

Denied

101P19 Rene Robinson,

Individually, and as

Administratrix of the

Estate of Velvet Foote v.

GGNSC Holdings, LLC

d/b/a Golden Living

Center, a/k/a Sava

Senior Center, LLC

d/b/a McGregor Downs

Health and

Rehabilitation Center,

and Neil Kurtz

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-706)

Denied

106P19 In the Matter of:

P.R.T.

Petitioner’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-730)

Denied

of 41

107P16-2 State v. Soyer Lewis

Moll

1. Def’s Pro Se



Order of Superior

Court, Onslow

County

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Appoint

Counsel

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed as

moot

Ervin, J. recused

107P19 In the Matter of the

Appeal of:

Aaron’s, Inc.

From the decision of the

Sampson County Board

of Equalization and

Review concerning the

valuation of certain

personal property for

tax year 2016

Taxpayer’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S

§ 7A-31

(COA18-607)

Denied

108P19 Nanny’s Korner Day

Care Center, Inc. v.

North Carolina

Department of Health

and Human Services,

Division of Child

Development and Early

Education

1. Plt’s Notice of

Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question

(COA18-679)

2. Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Dismissed ex

mero motu

2. Denied

Ervin, J., recused

Davis, J., recused

122PA18 Zloop, Inc. v. Parker Poe

Adams & Bernstein

LLP, et al.

Plt’s Motion to Stay

All Proceedings in

the Present Matter

Allowed

07/05/2019

122PA18 Zloop, Inc. v. Parker Poe

Adams & Bernstein

LLP, et al.

Plt’s Motion to

Dismiss Appeal

with Prejudice

Allowed

07/25/2019

of 41

124P19 Donna J. Preston,

Administrator of the

Estate of William M.

Preston v. Assadollah

Movahead, M.D.,

Deepak Joshi, M.D., and

Pitt County Memorial

Hospital, Incorporated,

d/b/a Vidant Medical

Center

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-674)

Allowed

125PA18 In the Matter of:

E.D.

Def’s Petition for

Writ of Mandamus

Denied

06/24/2019

Davis, J. recused

131P01-17 State v. Anthony Dove Def’s Pro Se Motion

for Evidentiary

Hearing

Dismissed

Ervin, J. recused

Davis, J. recused

131P16-12 Somchai Noonsab v.

State

1. Petitioner’s Pro

Se Motion for

Verified Complaint


Se Motion for Arrest

of Judgment


Se Motion to

Dismiss


Se Motion for Order

for Release

1. Dismissed

07/11/2019

2. Dismissed

07/11/2019

3. Dismissed

07/11/2019

4. Denied

07/11/2019

of 41

132PA18-2 Beth Desmond v. The

News and Observer

Publishing Company,

McClatchy Newspapers,

Inc., and Mandy Locke

1. Defs’ (The News

and Observer

Publishing

Company, and

Mandy Locke)

Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a

Constitutional

Question

(COA18-411)

2. Defs’ (The News

and Observer

Publishing

Company, and

Mandy Locke) PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

3. Plt’s Motion to

Dismiss Appeal

4. Professor William

Van Alystyne’s

Motion for Leave to

File Amicus Brief

5. The Reporter

Committee for

Freedom of Press, et

al.’s Motion for

Leave to File

Amicus Brief

6. Def’s (Mandy

Locke) Motion for

Additional Time for

Oral Argument

1. Dismissed

03/27/2019

2. Allowed

03/27/2019

3. Allowed

03/27/2019

4. Allowed

03/27/2019

5. Allowed

03/27/2019

6. Denied

of 41

132P19 Eric Denney, and wife

Christine Denney v.

Wardson Construction,

Inc., and Healthy Home

Insulation, LLC

Def’s (Wardson

Construction, Inc.)

PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-667)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

134A18 Regency Centers

Acquisition, LLC v.

Crescent Acquisitions,

LLC


Hold Case in

Advance of

Settlement


Dismiss Appeal

with Prejudice

1. Allowed

08/10/2019

2. Allowed

08/02/2019

134PA19 State v. John Christian

Duff

1. Def’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-874)


Writ of Supersedeas


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

04/15/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Special Order

136P16-2 State v. Maurice Parker 1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for Notice of

Appeal

(COAP19-81)

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for PDR

3. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for PDR

4. Def’s Pro Se



Order of Superior

Court, Cumberland

County

1. Dismissed ex

mero motu

2. Dismissed

3. Dismissed

4. Dismissed

of 41

142PA17-2 State v. Terance

Germaine Malachi


Temporary Stay

(COA16-752-2)


Writ of Supersedeas


Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31


Dismiss Appeal

1. Denied

03/26/2019

2. Denied

3. ---

4. Denied

5. Allowed

142PA18 DTH Media

Corporation, Capital

Broadcasting Company,

Inc., the Charlotte

Observer Publishing

Company and the

Durham Herald

Company v. Carol L.

Folt, in her official

capacity as Chancellor

of the University of

North Carolina at

Chapel Hill, and Gavin

Young, in his official

capacity as Senior

Director of Public

Records for the

University of North

Carolina at Chapel Hill

Motion of Amici

Curiae Victim

Rights

Organizations for

Leave to Participate

in Oral Argument

Denied

142P19 State v. Radhwan Al-

Hamood

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-682)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

of 41

144P19 The Estate of Robert

Eugene Tipton, Jr., by

and through his

Ancillary Administrator,

Deborah Dunklin Tipton

and Deborah Dunklin

Tipton, Individually v.

Delta Sigma Phi

Fraternity, Inc., Michael

Qubein, Individually

and as an Agent for

Delta Sigma Phi

Fraternity, Marshall

Jefferson, Individually

and as an Agent for

Delta Sigma Phi

Fraternity, High Point

University, Nido

Qubein, Individually

and as President of

High Point University

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-581)

Denied

Davis, J. recused


M.F.B., L.B., III,

M.W.E.B.

Respondent-

Mother’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-848)

Denied

Davis, J., recused

146P19 Trisha Wright,

Administratrix of the

Estate of Christopher

Wright, Deceased

Employee v. Alltech

Wiring & Controls,

Employer, Builders

Mutual Insurance

Company, Carrier

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-833)

Denied

of 41

147PA18 Chambers v. Moses H.

Cone Memorial

Hospital, et al.

Def’s Motion to File

Amended Brief

Allowed

07/12/2019

147P19 State v. Malon Kysheef

Griffin


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-681)


Deem Response to

PDR Timely Filed

1. Denied

2. Denied

154P19 Jonathan E. Brunson v.

The Office of the

Governor of North

Carolina, et al.

Plt’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-836)

Denied

155P17-4 State v. Joe Robert

Reynolds

1. Def’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-445)

2. Def’s Pro Se



Order of the COA

3. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to

Supplement

Petition with

Affidavit of Facts

4. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Withdraw

1. Denied

2. ---

3. Dismissed as

moot

4. Allowed

155P19 Jonathan Brunson v.

Office of the Twelfth

Judiciary

Plt’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-838)

Denied

of 41

161P19 Elizabeth Ball,

Employee v. Bayada

Home Health Care,

Employer, Arch

Insurance Group, Inc.,

Carrier (Gallagher

Bassett Services, Inc.,

Third-Party

Administrator)

1. Defs’ Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-918)

2. Defs’ Petition for

Writ of Supersedeas

3. Defs’ PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

05/01/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Denied

Davis, J., recused

164P15-2 State v. Charles Gilbert

Gillespie

1. Def’s Pro Se



Order of the COA

2. Def’s Pro Se



Order of Superior

Court, Rowan

County

3. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Appoint

Counsel

1. Denied

06/26/2019

2. Denied

06/26/2019

3. Dismissed as

moot

06/26/2019

Davis, J. recused

of 41

168A19 Cardiorentis AG v. Iqvia

Ltd. and Iqvia RDS, Inc.

1. Plt’s Petition in

the Alternative for


Review Order of

Business Court


Admit Catherine E.

Stetson Pro Hac

Vice


Admit Kyle Druding

Pro Hac Vice

4. Defs’ Motion to

Supplement Record

on Appeal

1. Go with case

2. Allowed

06/25/2019

3. Allowed

06/25/2019

4. Allowed

169P19 State v. Brian Keith

Hughes


Temporary Stay

(COA18-967)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Allowed

05/03/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Denied

of 41

170A19 State v. Melvin Lamar

Fields


Temporary Stay

(COA18-673)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s Notice of

Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

4. State’s PDR as to

Additional Issues

1. Allowed

05/06/2019

2. Allowed

3. ---

4. Allowed

171P19 State v. Lamarquis

Letron Smallwood

Def’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-578)

Denied


J.H., Z.R., A.R., and

D.R.

Respondent-

Mother’s Motion to

Amend Record on

Appeal

Allowed

07/08/2019

183P19-2 State v. Coriante Pierce Def’s Pro Se Petition

for Writ of


Order of the COA

(COAP19-265)

Dismissed

184P18 N.C. Department of

Environmental Quality,

Division of Waste

Management v. TRK

Development, LLC

Respondent’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA17-882)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

185P19 James Bryan Sluder v.

Marilyn W. Sluder

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-920)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

of 41

186P19 State v. Michael

Caldwell Angram


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-993)



Review Decision of

the COA

1. Denied

2. Denied

190P19 Flor Johnson v. Capree

Ricketts

1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for PDR

(COA19-239)

2. Def’s Pro Se



Order of the COA

1. Denied

2. Dismissed

of 41

192P19 Betty Burden Jackson,

Nancy Burden Elliott,

James Burden, Rebecca

Burton Bell, Darren

Burton, Clarence

Burton, Jr.,

and John Burden,

Plaintiffs v. Don

Johnson Forestry, Inc.

and East Carolina

Timber, LLC,

Defendants

and

Nellie Burden Ward,

Albert R. Burden, Levy

Burden, Clarence L.

Burden, and Brenda B.

Miller, Other

Grandchildren

Defendants

and

East Carolina Timber,

LLC, Third Party/

Counterclaim Plaintiff

v. Estate of William F.

Bazemore by and

through its Executors,

Nellie Ward and Tarsha

Dudley, and Estate of

Florida Bazemore by

and through its

Administrator, Maria

Jones, Third-Party/

Counterclaim

Defendants

Plts’ PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-354-2)

Denied

of 41

193P19 Slok, LLC v. Courtside

Condominium Owners

Association, Inc.


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-736)


Dismiss PDR


PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Denied

2. Dismissed as

moot

3. Dismissed as

moot

194P19-3 State v. David Ezell

Simpson

1. Def’s Pro Se


Mandamus

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Amend


Mandamus

1. Dismissed

without prejudice

2. Allowed

195A19 State v. Chad Cameron

Copley

1. State’s

Application for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-895)


for Writ of

Supersedeas


Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

1. Allowed

05/23/2019

2. Allowed

06/13/2019

3. ---

196A19 State v. David Leroy

Carver


Temporary Stay

(COA18-935)


for Writ of

Supersedeas


Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

1. Allowed

05/28/2019

2. Allowed

06/17/2019

3. ---

of 41

198PA19 Askalemariam Yigzaw

v. Alehegn Asres

Plt’s Petition for


Review Order of the

COA (COA19-12)

Special Order

199P19 State v. Bennie Lee

Graham

1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for En Banc

Review (COA18-1)


Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Dismissed

2. Denied

201A19 State v. David Alan

Keller


Temporary Stay

(COA17-1318)


Writ of Supersedeas


Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

1. Allowed

06/04/2019

2. Allowed

3. ---

202P19 State v. Dwayne

Rayshon Degraffenried


for PDR

(COAP19-256)

Dismissed

204P19 State v. Alexander

DeJesus aka Alexander

Sigaru-Argueta

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-750)

Denied


W.A.B., B.F.B., A.G.B.,

E.H.B., R.A.B., M.A.B.

Respondent-

Father’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-953)

Denied

of 41

206A19 State v. Ben Lee Capps 1. State’s Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-386)


for Writ of

Supersedeas


Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

1. Allowed

06/05/2019

2. Allowed

06/26/2019

3. ---

207P19 State v. Mark Edwin

Jones

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-508)

Denied

210P19 Diondra N. Pittman v.

James E. Pittman, Jr.

and Adrian N. Flemings

Def’s (James E.

Pittman, Jr.) Pro Se


Appeal

Dismissed

213P19 Cumberland County ex

rel.: State of Alabama

O.B.O.: Alisha Lee v.

Clifford Lee

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-754)

Denied

217P18-2 State v. Edwin

Christopher Lawing


for Writ of


Order of Superior

Court, Wake County

Dismissed

223P19 State v. James E. White 1. Def’s Pro Se



Order of the COA

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Proceed

In Forma Pauperis

3. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Appoint

Counsel

1. Dismissed

2. Allowed

3. Dismissed as

moot

of 41

224P19 In re:

James Allen Hill

Petitioner’s Pro Se


Mandamus

Denied

06/27/2019

225P10-2 State v. Jesus Espinoza-

Valenzuela

1. Def’s Pro Se



Order of Superior

Court, Wake County

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Proceed

In Forma Pauperis

1. Dismissed

2. Allowed

225P19 State v. Dale Erwin

Foat


for Relief Upon

Appeal

(COAP19-294)

Dismissed

226P19 Timothy Morris McCoy

v. North Carolina

Department of Revenue


Motion for Appeal

Against Final

Decision

Dismissed

227P18 State v. Carl Ray Poore,

Jr.


Temporary Stay

(COA17-1387)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Allowed

07/23/2018

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Denied

228P19 State v. Timothy Calvin

Denton


Temporary Stay

(COA18-742)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

1. Allowed

06/14/2019

2.

of 41


K.K.

A minor child

Appellant-Father’s

Motion to Extend

the time to File the

Record on Appeal

Allow extension of

time up to &

including 17 June

2019

06/18/2019

233PA12-2 State v. Montrez

Benjamin Williams


Appropriate Relief


Hold Resentencing

Appeal in Abeyance

1. Special Order

2. Special Order

234P19 Corey France v. North

Carolina Department of

Public Safety

1. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for Leave for

Joinder of Appeals

(COA19-294, 295)

2. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for PDR

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

Davis, J. recused

235P19 State v. Hector Trevino,

III

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-741)

Denied

238P19 State v. Matthew Garret

McMahan


Temporary Stay

(COA18-672)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

1. Allowed

06/24/2019

2.

239P19 State v. Tyrone Churell

Davis

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-1017)

Denied

of 41

240P19 State v. Daniel Yair

Marino


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-1135)




Decision of the COA

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed


M.T.-L.Y.

1. Petitioner’s

Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-826)

2. Petitioner’s


Supersedeas

3. Petitioner’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

4. Guardian Ad

Litem’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

06/25/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Denied

4. Denied

246P19 Walston v. Duke

University

Defendant Attorney

Carl Newman’s

Motion to Withdraw

as Counsel of

Record

Allowed

07/17/2019

247P16-7 State v. Jonathan

Eugene Brunson


for Petition for

Rehearing of PDR

Dismissed

247P19 State v. Dante Lorenzo

Ross

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-652)

Denied

248A18 Sykes v. Blue Cross &

Blue Shield of North

Carolina (Sykes II)

Plt’s Petition for

Rehearing

Denied

of 41

248P19 State v. Tamora C.

Williams


Temporary Stay

(COA18-994)


Writ of Supersedeas

1. Allowed

06/25/2019

2.

250P17-2 State v. Justin Lee

Perry


for Writ of


Order of the COA

(COAP19-355)

Denied

07/24/2019

Davis, J., recused

251PA18 Sykes, et al. v. Health

Network Solutions, Inc.,

et al.

Plts’ Petition for

Rehearing

Denied

251P19 D. Cameron Murchison,

Jr. and Joan H.

Murchison, his wife v.

Regional Surgical

Specialists and

Christopher Edwards,

M.D.

Plt’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-297)

Denied

Ervin, J. recused

252P19 State v. Frank Thomas

Bennett


for Arrest of

Judgment

Denied

07/02/2019

253P19 State v. Justin Michael

Tyson


for Writ of Habeas

Corpus

Denied

06/27/2019

253P19-2 State v. Justin Michael

Tyson


for Court to

Overturn its Denial

of Petition for Writ

of Habeas Corpus

Denied

07/12/2019

of 41

255P18 State v. Edward Earl

Jones


Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question

(COA17-114)


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31



Review Order of the

COA


Dismiss Appeal

1. ---

2. Denied

3. Dismissed

4. Allowed

256P19 In the Matter of the

Estate of Thalia Dukes,

by her son, Tony C.

Thomas v. Lawrence S.

Craige


for North Carolina

Supreme Court to

Assume Jurisdiction

Dismissed

257P16-3 Federal National

Mortgage Association

a/k/a Fannie Mae v.

William Gerald Price


to Appeal

(COA18-775)

Dismissed

Davis, J. recused

260P19 State v. Brandon Leon

Wilson


for Judicial Review

Denied

07/17/2019

262P19 State v. Dora Parker

Bullock

1. Def’s Pro Se


Appeal (COA19-503)


Dismiss Appeal

1. ---

2. Allowed

of 41

263PA18 State v. Cedric Theodis

Hobbs, Jr.

1. Amicus Curiae’s

Motion to Admit

Robert S. Chang Pro

Hac Vice


Motion to Admit

Taki V. Flevaris Pro

Hac Vice


Amended Motion to

Admit Robert S.

Chang Pro Hac Vice


Amended Motion to

Admit Taki V.

Flevaris Pro Hac

Vice

1. Dismissed as

moot

07/10/2019

2. Dismissed as

moot

07/10/2019

3. Allowed

07/10/2019

4. Allowed

07/10/2019


Hobbs, Jr.


(Coalition of State

and National

Criminal Justice

and Civil Rights

Advocates) Motion

for Leave to

Participate in Oral

Argument


(Fred T. Korematsu

Center for Law and

Equality) Motion for

Leave to Participate

in Oral Argument

1. Denied

2. Denied


Hobbs, Jr.

Def’s Motion to

Supplement Record

on Appeal

Allowed

of 41

264P19 State v. Matthew

Joseph Schmieder


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-1027)


Deem PDR Timely

Filed

3. Def’s Motion in

the Alternative to

Treat the PDR as a


Certiorari

1. Dismissed

2. Denied

3. Denied

265P19 State v. Darrin M.

Sanders


for PDR

(COAP19-357)

Denied

266P19 State v. Ontrel Latre

Gilchrist

Def’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-479)

Denied

267P19 Winston Affordable

Housing, L.L.C. d/b/a

Winston Summit

Apartments v. Deborah

Roberts


Temporary Stay

(COA18-553)


Writ of Supersedeas

3. Plt’s Motion for

Clarification as to

Effect of 9 July 2019

Order Allowing the

Motion for

Temporary Stay

4. Plt’s Motion for

Reconsideration,

Vacation, or

Modification of

Order

1. Allowed

07/08/2019

2.

3. Special Order

07/10/2019

4. Special Order

07/10/2019

Davis, J. recused

of 41

271P19 State v. Robert B.

Williams


for Notice of Appeal

of a Writ of Habeas

Corpus in State

Court

Denied

07/10/2019

275P19 Elizabeth M.T. O’Nan,

and Individual v.

Nationwide Insurance

Company, a

Corporation; Servpro

Industries, Inc., a

Corporation; Servpro of

Marion, a Corporation,

aka Servpro of Asheville

East, aka Servpro of

Asheville West, aka

Servpro of McDowell

and Rutherford

Counties, aka J.L.

Kuder Enterprises, a

Corporation; John

Kuder, an Individual;

Linda Kuder, an

Individual; Spencer

Gates, an Individual;

Debra Whittemore, and

Individual; Jennifer

Robinson, an Individual;

and Lisa Tilley, an

Individual

1. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA18-990)

2. Plt’s Pro Se


Supersedeas

3. Plt’s Pro Se

Notice of Appeal

Based Upon a

Constitutional

Question

4. Plt’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

5. Defs’ (Servpro of

Marion, et al.)

Motion to Dismiss

Appeal

1. Allowed

07/18/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Dismissed ex

mero motu

4. Denied

5. Dismissed as

moot

of 41

277P18-4 State v. Gabriel Adrian

Ferrari


to Strike the Court

Order to Dismiss as

Illegal and Non-

Constitutional in

Violation of

Defendant’s

Constitutional

Rights, TN. Law

and U.S. Federal

Rules, by Court in

Conference March

27, 2019

Dismissed

279A19 Global Textile Alliance,

Inc. v. TDI Worldwide,

LLC, et al.

Plt’s Motion to

Admit Stanley E.

Woodward, Jr. Pro

Hac Vice

Allowed

08/07/2019

291P19 State v. Harvey Lee

Stevens, Jr.


Temporary Stay

(COA17-584)


Writ of Supersedeas

1. Allowed

08/01/2019

2.

293A19 State v. Adam Richard

Carey


Temporary Stay


for Writ of

Supersedeas

1. Allowed

08/05/2019

2.

294P19 State v. Leo Kearney Def’s Pro Se Motion

for Extension of

Time to File Federal

Habeas Corpus

Petition

Dismissed

08/02/2019

of 41

309P15-7 State v. Reginald

Underwood Fullard


for Objection Entry

to Motion to

Dismissed by Order

of Court Conference

of 9 May 2019

Dismissed

310P19 State v. Luis Guillermo

Neira


Temporary Stay

(COA19-653;

COAP19-380)


Writ of Supersedeas



Review Order of the

COA


Adjudicate Petitions

and Motions

Without Undue

Delay


Issue a Brief

Precedential

Published Order but

Not a Full Opinion

on the Issues


Seal All Motions

and Petitions Filed

Before this Court


Seal All Motions

and Petitions Filed

Before the COA

1. Denied

08/12/2019

2. Denied

08/12/2019

3. Denied

08/12/2019

4. Dismissed as

moot

08/12/2019

5. Dismissed

08/12/2019

6. Denied

08/12/2019

7. Denied

08/12/2019

of 41


Allow Defendant to

Proceed Using the

Pseudonym “John

Doe” or “L.G.N.” at

this Court


Allow Defendant to

Proceed Using the

Pseudonym “John

Doe” or “L.G.N.” at

the COA


Re-caption the

Above-Titled Action

to “State of North

Carolina v John

Doe” or “State of

North Carolina v.

L.G.N.”


Re-caption the

Titled of the COA

Action to “State of

North Carolina v

John Doe” or “State

of North Carolina v.

L.G.N.”


Bar the COA from

Publishing any

Documents,

Particularly

Opinions,

Containing the Def’s

Real Name During

the Pendency of His

Action Before this

Court

8. Denied

08/12/2019

9. Denied

08/12/2019

10. Denied

08/12/2019

11. Denied

08/12/2019

12. Denied

08/12/2019

of 41

316P18-2 Johnny Jermaine

McMillan v. Harvey

Clay, Superintendent

(Now referred to as

Warden) of Lumberton

Correctional Institution,

State of N.C.



Habeas Corpus

Denied

07/11/2019

317P16-3 State v. Ronald

Thompson Corbett

1. Def’s Pro Se


Petition to Appeal

(COA18-327)

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion to Make

Appeal Private and

Sealed

1. Dismissed ex

mero motu

2. Dismissed as

moot

Davis, J. recused

319P18 Dale Thomas Winkler;

and DJ’s Heating

Service v. North

Carolina State Board of

Plumbing, Heating &

Fire Sprinkler

Contractors


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-873)


PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

2. Allowed

324A16 State v. Antwan

Anthony

(DEATH)

Def’s Motion to

Provide Full

Transcript to

Defendant

Special Order

327P18 DavFam, LLC v. Arthur

E. Davis, III

Def’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31 (COA18-43)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

of 41

332P18 State v. Michael Stanley

Mazur and Anne-Marie

Mazur

1. Def’s (Anne-Marie

Mazur) Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA17-736)


Mazur) Petition for

Writ of Supersedeas


Mazur) Notice of

Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question


Mazur) PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31


Dismiss Appeal

6. Def’s (Michael

Stanley Mazur)

Motion for

Temporary Stay

(COA17-736)

7. Def’s (Michael

Stanley Mazur)


Supersedeas

8. Def’s (Michael

Stanley Mazur)

PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Allowed

10/05/2018

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. ---

4. Denied

5. Allowed

6. Allowed

10/08/2018

Dissolved

08/14/2019

7. Denied

8. Denied

341P18 State v. Olivia Chisholm Def’s Pro Se PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA18-23)

Denied

of 41

343P18 Mario Seguro-Suarez,

by and through his

Guardian Ad Litem,

Edward G. Connette v.

Key Risk Insurance

Company, Joseph J.

Abriola, Sharon

Sosebee, Suzanne

McAuliffe, Cheryl Gless,

Robert E. Hill, and

Carolina Investigative

Services, Inc.

1. Defs’ (Key Risk

Insurance

Company, Joseph J.

Abriola, Sharon

Sosebee, Suzanne

McAuliffe, and

Cheryl Gless) PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COA17-697)

2. Defs’ (Key Risk

Insurance

Company, Joseph J.

Abriola, Sharon

Sosebee, Suzanne

McAuliffe, and

Cheryl Gless)

Motion to Withdraw

PDR

1. ---

2. Allowed

07/12/2019

Davis, J. recused

349P09-3 State v. Jeffrey

Robinson


for Writ of


Order of the COA

(COAP19-222)

Denied

06/25/2019

362P17-3 James Cornell Howard

v. Wayne County Clerk

of Court


for Writ of

Mandamus

Denied

Davis, J. recused

378P18-4 State v. Napier

Sandford Fuller


Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

(COAP18-623)

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for

Emergency Stay

1. Denied

06/21/2019

2. Denied

06/21/2019

379P18 State v. Van Buren

Killette, Sr.

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-26)

Special Order

of 41

392P18 State v. Kevin Deshaun

Dixon

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-1333)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

398P18 Town of Pinebluff v.

Moore County,

Catherine Graham in

her capacity as a

County Commissioner,

Nick Picerno in his

capacity as a County

Commissioner, Otis

Ritter in his capacity as

a County Commissioner,

Randy Saunders in his


Commissioner, and

Jerry Daeke in his


Commissioner

Defs’ PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-286)

Allowed

399P18 State v. Joshua A. Bice Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-1188)

Denied

402PA15-3 State v. Donna Helms

Ledbetter


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA15-414-3)


Temporary Stay


Writ of Supersedeas


Dismiss PDR

1. Special Order

2. Allowed

10/15/2018

Dissolved

08/14/2019

3. Denied

4. Dismissed as

moot

of 41

406PA18 State v. Cory Dion

Bennett


(Coalition of State

and National

Criminal Justice

and Civil Rights

Advocates) Motion

for Leave to

Participate in Oral

Argument


(Korematsu Center)

Motion for Leave to

Participate in Oral

Argument

1. Denied

2. Denied

414P18 State v. Owen P.

Williams


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-620)

2. State’s

Conditional PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Denied

2. Dismissed as

moot

420P18 State v. Temon Tavoi

McNeil


Temporary Stay

(COA18-175)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

3. State’s PDR

Under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

1. Allowed

11/28/2018

Dissolved

08/14/2019

2. Denied

3. Denied

of 41

449P11-22 Charles Everette

Hinton v. State of North

Carolina, et al.

1. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for En Banc

Judicial Writ of

Sequestration

2. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for En Banc

Ex Parte Replevin

at Common-Law

Action

3. Plt’s Pro Se

Motion for

Independent

Judicial Writ for

Certiorari

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

3. Dismissed

Ervin, J. recused

432P18 Jian Shen v. Charles

Hugh McGowan, III

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-263)

Denied

433P18 Rebecca B. Everett and

Simon J. Everett, Co-

Administrators of the

Estate of Simon T.

Everett v. Duke Energy

Carolinas, LLC; and

FDB, LLC

1. Def’s (Duke

Energy Carolinas,

LLC) PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA18-159)

2. Def’s (FDB, LLC)

PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

3. Plts’ Conditional

PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

1. Denied

2. Denied

3. Dismissed as

moot

434PA18 PHG Asheville, LLC v.

City of Asheville

Respondent’s

Motion to

Supplement the

Record on Appeal

Allowed

of 41

437PA18 Chavez et al. v.

Carmichael

1. United States of

America’s Motion

for Leave to File

Amicus Brief

2. United States of

America’s Motion to

Amend Certificate of

Service


Motion to Admit

Joshua S. Press Pro

Hac Vice


(United States of

America) Motion to

Participate at Oral

Argument

1. Allowed

07/31/2019

2. Allowed

08/02/2019

3. Allowed

08/02/2019

4. Denied

451P18 State v. Kendrick Louis

Robinson

Def’s PDR Under

N.C.G.S. § 7A-31

(COA17-1262)

Denied

Davis, J. recused

of 41

453P18 State v. Barbara Jean

Myers-McNeil


Appeal Based Upon

a Constitutional

Question

(COA17-1404)


N.C.G.S. § 7A-31


Deem Response

Timely Filed


Temporary Stay


Writ of Supersedeas


File an Amended

PDR

7. Def’s Amended

PDR under N.C.G.S.

§ 7A-31

8. Def’s Petition in

the Alternative for


Review Decision of

the COA

1. Dismissed ex

mero motu

2. Dismissed as

moot

3. Allowed

4. Allowed

04/17/2019

Dissolved

08/14/2019

5. Denied

6. Allowed

7. Denied

8. Dismissed as

moot

of 41

455A18 John Tyler Routten v.

Kelly Georgene Routten

1. Def’s Pro Se

Notice of Appeal

Based Upon A

Constitutional

Question

(COA17-1360)


Under N.C.G.S

§ 7A-31

3. Plt’s Notice of

Appeal Based Upon

a Dissent

1. Dismissed ex

mero motu

2. Denied

3. ---

499P04-3 Andre M. Spates v.

State of North Carolina,

et al.



Mandamus

Denied

504P04-3 State v. Marion Beasley,

Sr.

1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for Appeal

(COAP19-167)

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for

Declaratory

Judgment

1. Dismissed

2. Dismissed

548A04-2 State v. Vincent Lamont

Harris


Temporary Stay

(COA18-952)


for Writ of

Supersedeas

1. Allowed

07/17/2019

2.

580P05-16 State v. David Lee

Smith


for PDR

Dismissed

Ervin, J., recused

of 41

597P01-6 State v. Maechel Shawn

Patterson

1. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for Amended

Notice of Appeal

(COAP17-245)

2. Def’s Pro Se

Motion for PDR

3. Def’s Pro Se



Order of the COA

1. Dismissed

2. Denied

3. Dismissed

Ervin, J. recused

SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA PETITIONS · 2019-08-16 · Page 2 of 41 041P19-2 Jonathan Brunson...

Documents

Transcript of SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA PETITIONS · 2019-08-16 · Page 2 of 41 041P19-2 Jonathan Brunson...