Supported by - Humanitarian Library€¦ · 2008 2009 2010 2011-2012 2013-2014 2015-2016 140 Case...

Shelter Projects - Shelter Meeting 18b, Geneva, 5 October 2018 ShelterCluster.orgCoordinating Humanitarian Shelter

Global Shelter Cluster

Shelter ProjectsCase studies of humanitarian shelter and settlement responses

Shelter Meeting 18b, Geneva, 5 October 2018

Supported by:

European UnionCivil Protec�on andHumanitarian Aid

ShelterCluster.orgCoordinating Humanitarian Shelter




Shelter Projects - some key questions

How do we learn as a sector?

What worked and what didn’t?

What is the story that a project can tell?

Shelter Projects - some key questions



What is Shelter Projects?

• Compilation of case studies, 6 past editions

• Over 200 case studies and overviews, 70 countries

• Truly collaborative effort: over 300 contributors

• Overall objective: learning from past experiences

• Building a body of evidence for the sector

• Multiple audiences and uses

• Projects are presented anonymously

• Selection criteria: completed, scale, timeframe, data

• Peer review process

• Projects are context driven



Shelter Projects past editions

Contents from past editions

2008 2009 2010 2011-2012 2013-2014 2015-2016

140Case studies

post 2005

13Opinionpieces

51Case studies

pre 2005

9Updates

28Overviews



193SHELTER PROJECTS 2015 - 2016

ANNEXES C.1 / index of Case studies by Country

all the case studies, overviews and updates in this book and the past editions of Shelter Projects are available online, and they can be searched by country, year, article type, emergen-cy type and publication, or through a free text search.

C.1 / index of Case studies by Country

1

Case studies/overviews

2

3-4

5-9

10-16

Afghanistan, 2012, Conflict SP 2011-2012Afghanistan, 2009, Conflict SP 2010Afghanistan, 2009, Conflict SP 2009Afghanistan, 2002, Conflict SP 2008Afghanistan, 2002, Conflict SP 2009Algeria, 1980, Earthquake SP 2009Azerbaijan, 1992, Conflict SP 2008Bangladesh, 2009, Cyclone SP 2009Bangladesh, 2007, Cyclone SP 2009Bangladesh, 2007, Cyclone SP 2009Bangladesh, 1975, Conflict SP 2008Benin, 2010-11, Floods SP 2015-2016Burkina Faso, 2012, Conflict SP 2011-2012CAR, 2013, Conflict SP 2013-2014Chile, 2014-16, Fire SP 2015-2016Chile, 2010, Earthquake SP 2010China, Sichuan, 2008, Earthquake SP 2009Colombia, 2011, Floods SP 2013-2014Colombia, 2010, Floods SP 2011-2012Côte d’Ivoire, 2010-11, Conflict SP 2011-2012Côte d’Ivoire, 2010-11, Conflict (2) SP 2011-2012Cuba, 2012, Hurricane SP 2013-2014Dominican Rep., 2012, Hurricane SP 2013-2014DR Congo, 2008-16, Conflict SP 2015-2016DR Congo, 2009, Conflict SP 2009DR Congo, 2002, Volcano SP 2011-2012DR Congo, 2002, Volcano SP 2008Ecuador, 2016, Earthquake SP 2015-2016Ecuador, 2016, Earthquake SP 2015-2016Eritrea, 2004, Conflict SP 2009Eritrea, 1998, Conflict SP 2008Ethiopia, 2014-2016, Conflict SP 2015-2016Ethiopia, 2011, Conflict SP 2011-2012

CSUPCSCSUPCSCSOVOVCSCS

CSCS

CSCSCSCSOVCS

Ethiopia, 2012, Conflict SP 2011-2012Europe Refugee Crisis, 2015-16 SP 2015-2016Fiji, 2016, Tropical Cyclone SP 2015-2016Fiji, 2012, Tropical Cyclone SP 2013-2014Gaza (Palestine), 2014-16, Conflict SP 2015-2016Gaza (Palestine), 2009, Conflict SP 2009Georgia, 2008, Conflict SP 2009Germany, 2015-16, Refugees SP 2015-2016Grenada, 2004, Hurricanes SP 2010Guatemala, 1976, Earthquake SP 2008Haiti, 2012, Hurricane SP 2013-2014Haiti, 2010, Earthquake SP 2011-2012Haiti, 2010, Earthquake (3) SP 2011-2012Haiti, 2010, Earthquake SP 2010Haiti, 2010, Earthquake (7) SP 2010Haiti, 2008, Floods SP 2009Haiti, 1982, Hurricane SP 2009Honduras, 1998, Hurricane SP 2008Honduras, 1974, Hurricane SP 2009Hurricane Sandy, 2012, SP 2013-2014India, 2001, Earthquake SP 2008India, 1977, Cyclone (2) SP 2009India, 1977, Cyclone SP 2008India, 1971, Conflict SP 2008Indonesia, 2009, Earthquake SP 2010Indonesia, 2009, Earthquake (3) SP 2010Indonesia, 2006, Earthquake SP 2008Indonesia, 2006, Earthquake (2) SP 2008Indonesia, 2004, Eq./Tsunami SP 2008Ingushetia, 1999, Conflict SP 2008Iraq, 2014-16, Conflict SP 2015-2016Iraq, 2014-16, Conflict (3) SP 2015-2016Iraq (KR-I), 2013, Conflict SP 2013-2014

CSOV

CSUPCS

UPCS

CS

CS

CS

CSCS

CSCSCSOVCSOVCSCSCSCSCSOVCSCSCS

OV

CS

CS

CS

CS

CS

CSOV

OV

CS

natural disasterConflictComplex/multiple

1 23 - 45 - 910 - 16

Number of Case studies/Overviews

INDEX OF CASE STUDIES BY COUNTRY

OV overviewCase studyupdate

CSUP

CS

CS

CS

OVCS

OVCSOVCSCS

www.shelterprojects.orgThis map is for illustrative purposes only and

should not be considered authoritative.

Number of case studies by country



Shelter Projects contributors

50+ 300+



The Websitewww.shelterprojects.org

http://www.sheltercasestudies.org



The Website - search function



Thematic BookletsCash, Urban, East Africa and more editions

http://shelterprojects.org/shelterprojects-compilations.html

LAUNCH EVENTS

SESSIONS AT WORLD URBAN

FORUM 9

and more...

SHELTER PROJ-ECTS WORKSHOP BANGKOK + ASIA SHELTER FORUM

SHELTER PROJECTS WORKSHOP NAIROBI + EAST AFRICA SHELTER

FORUM

UKSF

GSC 2017



Dissemination



Audience and uses

Reference / example to inform programming

Advocacy

Lessons learned to inform strategy development

Research / Academia

Training / Capacity building



Project timeline: Shelter Projects 2017-2018

AprilMay June July August September October November December January February March

Inception Workshop

Call for abstracts!Session at the Global Shelter Cluster Meeting

Print-ready PDF copy

Case studies submissions

Editing (Word) Final editing (Indesign)+ Proofreading (PDF)

Peer review (1st Round)

Peer review (2nd Round)

Layout (Indesign)



Categorizing projects...



Categorizing projects...Shelter Projects 2008 Shelter Projects 2009



Categorizing projects...Shelter Projects 2011-2012Shelter Projects 2010



Categorizing projects...Shelter Projects 2013-2014




2010 2009 2008

TYPE OF RESPONSE SETTLEMENT OPTIONS SETTLEMENT OPTIONS TYPE OF RESPONSE TYPE OF RESPONSE TYPE OF RESPONSE TYPE OF RESPONSE

Household items Non-displaced / returns Non-displaced / returns Household items General items Urban X

Construction materials Dispersed self-settlement Dispersed self-settlement Construction materials Construction materials Household items Household

ToolsShort-term land, house or apartment tenant

Short-term land, house or apartment tenant Tools Shelter materials Shelter

Emergency shelter Unplanned camps Unplanned camps Emergency shelter Emergency shelter X X

Transitional shelter Collective centres Collective centres Transitional shelter Transitional shelter Transitional Transitional

Support for host families Hosting Hosting Support for host families Host families / rental Permanent/housing Permanent

Rental supportPlanned and managed camps / relocation sites

Planned and managed camps / relocation sites Rental support X X X

Core housing / progressive shelter Resettlements Resettlements

Core housing / progressive shelter Core housing Cash or voucher Cash

Housing repair and retrofitting Urban neighbourhoods Urban neighbourhoods Housing repair and retrofitting Permanent housing / repair X XCash / vouchers Cash / vouchers Cash / vouchers Community CommunityLoans Loans Loans Contracted ContractedAdvocacy / Legal Advocacy / Legal Advocacy / Legal Direct DirectSite planning Site planning Site planning X XInfrastructure Infrastructure X Technical expertise Technical expertiseTraining Training Training X XStructural assessment Structural assessment Structural assessment X XGuidelines/materials/mass communications

Guidelines/materials/mass communications

Guidelines and training materials X X

Previous editions of Shelter Projects - Categories of case studies

Labo

urSh

elte

r co

nstr

uctio

NFI

dist

ribut

io

2013-2014 2011-2012

dist

ribut

ion

Shel

ter t

ype

Supp

ort m

etho

ds

Comparing across editions




xii SHELTER PROJECTS 2015 - 2016

INTRODUCTION

CASE STUDY

SUPPORT METHODSDistribution

Hou

seho

ld it

ems

Con

stru

ctio

n m

ater

ials

Tool

s/Fi

xing

s

Oth

er D

istri

butio

n

Cas

h / V

ouch

ers

Loan

s

Adv

ocac

y / L

egal

Site

Pla

nnin

g

Infra

stru

ctur

e

Trai

ning

Stru

ctur

al a

sses

smen

t

Gui

delin

es /

mas

s co

mm

unic

atio

ns

A.2 / Myanmar / 2014-2016 / Conflict X X X X X X X

A.5 / Nepal / 2015 / Earthquake X X X X

A.6 / Nepal / 2015 / Earthquake X X

A.7 / Nepal / 2015-2016 / Earthquake X X X

A.9 / Philippines / 2013-2017 / Typhoon Haiyan X X X X X X X X

A.10 / Philippines / 2014-2015 / Typhoon Haiyan X X

A.11 / Philippines / 2013-2015 / Typhoon Haiyan X X X X X X

A.12 / Philippines / 2013-2015 / Typhoon Haiyan X X X X X

A.13 / Philippines / 2013-2015 / Typhoon Haiyan X X X X X X X X X

A.16 / Benin / 2010-2011 / Floods X X X

A.17 / DR Congo / 2008-2016 / NFI voucher fairs X X

A.18 / Nigeria / 2015-2016 / Conflict X X X

A.20 / Malawi / 2015 / Floods X X

A.21 / Malawi / 2015-2016 / Floods X X X X X

A.22 / Somalia / 2011-2013 / Drought and Conflict X X X X X

A.24 / South Sudan / 2014-2016 / Conflict/Complex X X X X

A.25 / South Sudan / 2014-2016 / Conflict/Complex X

A.26 / Ethiopia / 2014-2016 / South Sudan crisis X X X X X

A.27 / Un. Rep. of Tanzania / 2016-2017 / Burundi crisis X X X X

A.28 / Gaza / 2014-2016 / Conflict X X X X X X X

A.30 / Syrian Arab Republic / 2015-2016 / Conflict X X X X

A.31 / Lebanon / 2015-2016 / Syrian crisis X X X X X X

A.32 / Lebanon / 2015-2016 / Syrian crisis X

A.34 / Iraq / 2015-2016 / Conflict X X X X

A.35 / Iraq / 2014-2015 / Syrian crisis X

A.36 / Iraq / 2015-2016 / Conflict X X X X

A.38 / Chile / 2014-2016 / Fire X X

A.40 / Ecuador / 2016 / Earthquake X X X X

A.42 / Germany / 2015-2016 / Refugee crisis X X X X

xiiiSHELTER PROJECTS 2015 - 2016

INTRODUCTION

CASE STUDY

SHELTER TYPE SETTLEMENT OPTION

Em

erge

ncy

shel

ter

Tran

sitio

nal s

helte

r

Hos

t fam

ily s

uppo

rt

Ren

tal s

uppo

rt

Cor

e ho

usin

g

Hou

sing

repa

ir / r

etro

-fit

ting

Oth

er -

indi

vidu

al h

ousi

ng

Oth

er -

pref

ab u

nit

Non

dis

plac

ed /

retu

rns

Dis

pers

ed s

elf-s

ettle

d

Sho

rt te

rm la

nd /

hous

e / fl

at

Unp

lann

ed c

amps

Col

lect

ive

cent

res

Hos

ting

Pla

nned

and

man

aged

ca

mps

Pla

nned

relo

catio

n si

tes

Res

ettle

men

ts

Urb

an n

eigh

bour

hood

s

A.2 X X X X X X X X X X

A.5 X X X X

A.6 X X

A.7 X X

A.9 X X X X

A.10 X X

A.11 X X X

A.12 X X X X

A.13 X X X X X X

A.16 X X X X X

A.17

A.18 X X

A.20 X X X

A.21 X X X X

A.22 X X X X

A.24 X X X X X X

A.25 X X

A.26 X X

A.27 X X

A.28 X X

A.30 X X X

A.31 X X X

A.32 X X X

A.34 X X X X X X

A.35 X X X

A.36 X X

A.38 X X X X X

A.40 X X

A.42 X X X X

www.shelterprojects.org

Shelter Projects 2015-2016



Categorizing projects...Spreadsheet Database 2008 to 2016



Categorizing projects...Interactive

Dashboard ?trial version




Shelter Projects 2017-2018 - new template

SPREADSHEET DATABASE OF ALL

CASE STUDIES

SPHERE HANDBOOK REVISED

TERMINOLOGY

SETTLEMENT SCENARIOS

SETTLEMENT OPTIONS

SHELTER ASSISTANCE

TYPES

SUPPORT METHODS

ASSIS-TANCE OP-

TIONS

REVISED CATEGORISATION&

ENHANCED SEARCH FUNCTION

+ =




There has been a lot of academic and practical debate surrounding terminology used in the shelter sector. Additional confusions have been added by language translation. In particular, issues have been significant in the different definitions used for different phases of assistance. For ex-ample, the terms “emergency shelter”, “transitional shelter”, “T-shelter”, “temporary shelter”, “semi-permanent shelter”, and “incremental shelter” have all been used in responses to define both the types of shelters and the processes used.

In Shelter Projects, we use the terms used in-country for each response, and these may vary from country to country. In some cases, flexibility in terminology has helped projects to take place sooner.

“

”Shelter Projects - Shelter Meeting 18b, Geneva, 5 October 2018 ShelterCluster.orgCoordinating Humanitarian Shelter


Note on terminology used in Shelter Projects

Thank you

Visit: www.shelterprojects.org

Contact: [email protected]

European UnionCivil Protec�on andHumanitarian Aid

ShelterCluster.orgCoordinating Humanitarian Shelter


Supported by - Humanitarian Library€¦ · 2008 2009 2010 2011-2012 2013-2014 2015-2016 140 Case...

Documents

Transcript of Supported by - Humanitarian Library€¦ · 2008 2009 2010 2011-2012 2013-2014 2015-2016 140 Case...