Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of...
Transcript of Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of...
![Page 1: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
StudyofVermontStateFundingforSpecialEducation
LegislativeTestimony
January9,2017TammyKolbe,UniversityofVermont
![Page 2: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
KeyObjectivesForReport
• Developacomprehensiveprofileofspecialeducationcosts&describethefactorsinfluencingcosts
• Evaluatecurrentfundingformula&establishparametersforredesign
• Describeacensus-basedfundingmechanism&simulatehowitcouldbeimplementedinVermont
![Page 3: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
DataConsidered• Independentanalysisofspecialeducationandfinancialdata
– StatedataprovidedbyVermontAgencyofEducation– NationaldatafromU.S.DepartmentofEducation’sdatarepositories
• Policyanalysisofotherstatestudiesofspecialeducationfunding– Fundingadequacystudies– Fundingformulasummariesandevaluations
• Stakeholderinput,including:
– InterviewswithstateofficialsresponsibleforoverseeingandimplementingVermont’sspecialeducationfundingformula.
– Interviewswithsupervisoryunion,district,andschoolleadersabouttheirexperiencesimplementingtheState’sspecialeducationfundingformula.
– Interviewswithparentsofstudentswithdisabilitieswhocurrentlyreceivespecialeducationandrelatedservices.– Focusgroupswithrepresentativesfromorganizationsthatrepresenttheinterestsofeducationandsocialservice
professionals– bothgenerallyandspecifictostudentswithdisabilities– aswellasothercitizengroups(e.g.,parentandfamily-basedorganizations).
– Astatewidesurveywithspecialeducationadministrators(co-sponsoredwiththeVermontCounselofSpecialEducationAdministrators).
– Focusgroupswithteachers onwhether,andinwhatways,thefundingformulainfluencestheirprocessesforidentifying,classifying,andservingstudentswithandwithoutdisabilities.
![Page 4: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
SpecialEducationCostsinVermont
![Page 5: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
UnderstandingSpecialEducationCosts
• Thenumberofstudentswhoareidentifiedforspecialeducation&relatedservices
Identification
•Studentswithdisabilitiesareclassifiedaccordingto13federally-defineddisabilitycategories
Classification•IndividualizedEducationProgramincludesaplanforsupportsandservicesastudentmightreceive
Placement&Services
• FundsexpendedforFAPEforstudentswithdisabilitiesintheleastrestrictiveenvironment.
Costs
![Page 6: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
SpecialEducationChildCount(SY2015)
• ThepercentageofstudentswithdisabilitiesinVermontissomewhathigherthannationalaverage,butonparwithneighboringandpeergroupstates (ReportTable1,p.18)
Autism Spectrum Disorder
(ASD) Deaf-blindEmotional
Disturbance
Hearing Impairment (Including Deafness)
Intellectual Disability
Multiple Disabilities
Orthopedic Impairment
Other Health
Impairment (OHI)
Specific Learning Disability
(SLD)
Speech or Language
Impairment
Traumatic Brain Injury
Visual Impairment (Including Blindness)
(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
Vermont 16.1 8.9 0.0 17.6 0.6 6.0 2.0 0.3 19.8 34.5 9.6 0.3 0.2
National Average 13.3 9.3 0.0 5.9 1.1 7.1 2.1 0.7 15.4 39.8 17.7 0.4 0.4
Selected Comparison StatesNew Hampshire 15.0 10.1 0.0 8.9 0.8 3.3 1.5 0.2 21.7 40.0 12.8 0.3 0.5
Maine 17.7 9.4 0.0 7.7 0.4 2.6 10.3 0.1 21.6 32.5 15.0 0.1 0.1Massachusetts 17.6 11.0 0.1 10.8 0.7 6.2 2.6 0.7 14.7 29.9 16.4 6.5 0.4Rhode Island 15.8 11.1 0.0 8.5 0.7 4.0 1.9 0.3 18.4 39.8 14.7 0.3 0.3
Delaware 15.3 8.1 0.2 4.7 1.1 8.4 0.0 1.2 14.1 51.8 9.7 0.4 0.4Kentucky 13.5 7.4 0.0 5.9 0.8 17.5 2.6 0.5 18.3 20.8 25.4 0.3 0.6
South Dakota 14.3 6.1 0.0 6.5 0.8 9.9 2.9 0.3 14.9 39.7 18.1 0.3 0.3
Percent of All
Students
Percentage of All Students With Disabilities
![Page 7: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
NumberofIEPsQualifyingforExtraordinaryCostReimbursement(FY2009-2017)
227 220 233 224 287
386 417 446
564
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
• Since2014,therehasbeena75%increase(since2013)inthenumberofIEPsqualifyingfortheState’sextraordinarycostreimbursement(ReportFigure3;p.20)
![Page 8: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
StateSpendingonSpecialEducation
2013 2014 2015 2016StateSpending
ReimbursementFormula $138,178,560 $144,741,288 $149,478,388 $157,891,972%Year-to-yearChange 5% 3% 6%
Extraordinarycostreimbursement $10,992,045 $11,542,990 $12,299,063 $14,282,780%Year-to-yearChange 5% 7% 16%
TotalStateSpending(ReimbursementFormula&ExtraordinaryCosts) $149,170,605 $156,284,278 $161,777,451 $172,174,752%Year-to-yearChange 4.8% 3.5% 6.4%
LocalSpending $103,863,779 $109,167,010 $112,780,331 $116,074,894%Year-to-yearChange 5.1% 3.3% 2.9%
TotalState&LocalSpending $253,034,384 $265,451,288 $274,557,782 $288,249,646%Year-to-yearChange 4.9% 3.4% 5.0%
See:ReportTable5,p.25
• Statespendingforitsreimbursementformulaincreased14%sinceFY2013,and6%forFY2016
• Stateforitsextraordinarycostreimbursementformulaincreased29%sinceFY2013and16%forFY2016
![Page 9: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
State&LocalExpendituresPerIEP
• Onaverage,forFY16,supervisoryunionsandschooldistricts,spentanadditional$21,840perstudentwithanIEP (ReportTable7,p.27)
• SinceFY2014,averagespendingperIEPhasincreased8%
![Page 10: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
SpendingComparison
• ForFY2016,Vermont’sactualaveragespendingperIEPwasabouttwotimegreaterthanwhatispredictedusingnationalestimatesforspecialeducationcosts(Table13,p.53)
• Vermont’saveragespendingperIEPexceeded thenationalaverageandotherpeerstates
![Page 11: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
CostDrivers1. AdministrativerequirementsandrulesdefiningallowablecostsundertheState’s
existingspecialeducationfundingformula createinefficienciesinservicedeliverythatcontributetohigheroverallspending
2. Thenatureandextentofstudentneedhasgrownmoremorecomplex
3. Weakfundingforcomprehensiveandearlysupportsystemscreatesincentivestoidentifymorestudentsforspecialeducationto accessadditionalfundingfromState
![Page 12: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Vermont’sExistingSpecialEducationFundingFormula
![Page 13: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
FundingSpecialEducationinVermont
• State– Reimbursementmodel
• Onaverage,thestatereimburseslocalitiesforabout60%ofqualifyingexpendituresforstudentsidentifiedforspecialeducation
– Extraordinarycostprovision• Statereimburseslocalitiesfor90%ofqualifyingexpendituresforanindividual
student,inexcessof$50k
• Federal– IDEAPartB(School-agedchildren)
• Local– Remainder(afterstateandfederalcontributions)
![Page 14: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
CritiquesofExistingSystem
• Voicesfromthefield:– Administrativelycostly(forStateandlocalities)– Fundingismisalignedwithpolicypriorities,particularlyMTSSandPBIS
–Misplacedincentivesforstudentidentification,categorizationandplacement
– Discouragescostcontainment– Unpredictableandlackstransparency
![Page 15: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
ImplementingaCensus-basedFundingMechanism
inVermont
![Page 16: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Census-basedFundingMechanism• Amountofspecialeducationfundingadistrictreceivesis
basedonnumberofnon-disabledstudentswithinaschooldistrict(e.g.,ADM/ADA)– Lumpsumisnotbasedonvariationbetweenindividualschooldistricts
• Pros:– Simple/transparent– Flexibilityinhowfundingcanbeused– Alignedwithpolicypriorities(servingstrugglingstudentsacrossthe
general/specialeducationservicedeliverysystems)– Predictable
• Cons:– Possibleincentivesfordistrictstolimitservices– Potentialcostliabilityfordistrictsifcensusgrantamountissettoolow
![Page 17: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
CalculatingaCensusGrant
• Censusgrantamountiscalculatedas:
• Percapitagrantamount=(NumberK12studentswithIEPs*ExcesscostperIEP) *StateshareofspendingK12ADM
• Keyassumptions:– Thenumberofstudents(statewide)withIEPs– Theexcess(ormarginal)costperIEP– Thenumberofstudents(statewide)enrolledinK-12education(i.e.,K12ADM)– Thestate’sshare/responsibilityforspending(e.g.,60%)
![Page 18: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
PerStudentSpendingAmountEstimates
• Perstudentspendingamountsfallbetweenabout$1,467and$3,062• Spendingamountsreflect100%oftheanticipatedspendingforspecialeducation
onapercapitabasis(currently,theStateshareofspecialeducationspendingis60%)
Spending Based on Actual Number of IEPs in Vermont
Spending Based on Reducing Number of
IEPs to National Average
(Col 1) (Col 2)
Actual ExpendituresAverage Supervisory Union/District Expenditures (FY2016) $3,062 $2,905
SEEP Adjusted Per IEP Costs
VermontDisability-specific Weights $1,547 $1,467
Maryland Adequacy Study
All Disability GroupingsResource Costs* $1,641 $1,557
Disability Grouping Weights $1,970 $1,869
Mild/Moderate Disabilities OnlyResource Costs* $1,209 $1,161
Disability Grouping Weights $1,457 $1,400
Per Capita Spending Equivalent (K12 ADM)
Inourreport,wecalculatedpossiblegrantamountsbasedondifferentassumptionsfor:
1) Thenumberofstudents(statewide)withanIEP
2) TheaverageamountspentperIEP
See:ReportTable16,p.58
![Page 19: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Census-basedFormulaSimulations
Example1 Example2 Example3
ModifiedStatusQuo(FY16AverageSpending)
PredictionsforWhat“Should”Be SpentperStudentwithIEPinVermont
StudentswithDisabilitiesAssumption(VT2016) 11,218 11,218 11,218CostperIEPAssumption
Actual SpendingVermontDisability-
specificWeights(SEEP)ResourceCosts(MD
Adequacy)CensusGrantAmount(K-12ADM)
PerStudent $1,837 $928 $985
PerStudent,withPovertyAdjustment $1,881 $958 $1,008
AssumesStateShareofCosts 60% 60% 60%
EstimatedStateAppropriation(perFY)
BasedonK-12ADM $147,633,732 $74,684,055 $79,134,027
Differencefrom2016StateFormula(Reimbursement&BlockGrantOnly) ($10,258,236) ($83,207,913) ($78,757,942)
See:Report,Table18,p.62
![Page 20: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
ExtraordinaryCostReimbursementModelsModel1
FixedThreshold(StatusQuo)
Model3Two-stepThresholdModel
Description
StatereimbursessupervisoryunionsforIEPcostsinexcessof$50,000.
Thresholdamountsforreimbursementaretiedtowhetherastudentisplacedwithin- orout-of-supervisoryunion (e.g.,separateschoolresidentialplacement).
CostAssumpions
ThresholdAmount $50,000WithinSU:4.62xStatewideAverageRegular
EducationPerPupilSpending($51,051for2016)
OutsideofSU:5.9xStatewideAverageRegularEducationPerPupilSpending$65,195for2016)
StateReimbursementParameters 60%ofcosts<ThresholdAmount 60%ofcosts<ThresholdAmount
90%ofcosts>ThresholdAmount 90%ofcosts>ThresholdAmount
EstimatedCosttoState(perFY) $31,981,016 $36,191,554
![Page 21: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
ImplementationConsiderations• Afive-yearphase-inperiodfortransitioningtoacensus-basedmodel.
– Currentcostsreflectcurrentpractice– Simplyreducingspendingwouldlikelyresultinchildrengoingunservedandlocalities
notmeetingtheirobligationsunderfederalandstatelaw.– Supervisoryunionsandschooldistrictsneedtimetoadapttonewflexibilityinfunding
approachandtoresettheirservicedeliverysystems
• Additionaltechnicalsupportforlocaleducators.– Localitieswillrequiretechnicalassistancewithmakingappropriatechanges
thatresultincostsavings
![Page 22: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
OtherDesignConsiderations• Studentscountedforaidallocation
– K12vs.PK12ADM
• Categoricalvs.blockgrantfunding– Example:30%categorical&70%blockgrant
• Accountability– Performancemetricstoensurethattheneedsforstudentswithdisabilitiescontinueto
bemetandoutcomesimprove
• Maintenanceofeffortforfederalfunding– ReductionsinstateappropriationmaytriggerreductionstofederalIDEAPartBgrant
![Page 23: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Summary• State&localspendingforspecialeducationhasincreasedinrecentyears.
However,thepercentageofstudentswithdisabilitieshasbeenrelativelystable,andonparwithotherNortheasternstates.
• Onaverage,VermontspendsconsiderablymoreperIEPthanrelevantcomparisonstatesorthenationalaverage.
• Existingstatefundingapproachmayincentivizelocalitiestoidentifystudentsforspecialeducation&discouragescostcontrol.
• Existingstatefundingapproachlackstheflexibilityneededtoimplementbestpracticesforaneffectiveandefficientservicedeliverysystemforstrugglinganddisabledstudents.
![Page 24: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Summary• Acensus-basedfundingformulamaybeanappropriatefundingmechanismfor
Vermont.
• AssumingtheState’sexistingshareofspending(60%),acensusgrantamountof$930-985perstudentwouldbeanappropriatecensusgrantamount.
– ThisrepresentsapotentialannualFYsavingsof$79-83million,overFY2016Stateappropriationsfortheexistingreimbursementformula(excludingextraordinarycostreimbursement).
• Acensus-basedmodelshouldbepairedwithanextraordinarycostreimbursementmechanism.– Werecommendatwo-steppedthresholdmodelforreimbursinglocalities,withthresholdamounts
forwithinandout-of-districtplacements.
![Page 25: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Summary
• Afive-yeartimelineforimplementingthenewfundingmodeltocoincidewithsimultaneouschangesinservicedeliverymodelsonthepartofsupervisoryunionsandschooldistricts.
• AdditionaltechnicalsupportandcapacitybuildingbyAOEtohelplocalitiesadjustservicedeliverymodelstorepresentnewfoundflexibilityandthepotentialforinnovationinhowstudentsareserved.
![Page 26: Study of Vermont State Funding for Special Education … · 2018-01-10 · 1) The number of students (statewide) with an IEP 2) The average amount spent per IEP See: Report Table](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022051511/6017e56f2e479d095c63de2b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
ContactInformation
• TammyKolbe,CollegeofEducation&SocialServices,UniversityofVermont– Email:[email protected]
• KieranKilleen,CollegeofEducation&SocialServices,UniversityofVermont– Email:[email protected]