String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New...

154
String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles in 6D Ori Ganor Berkeley Center for Theoretical Physics, UC Berkeley December 14, 2018 arXiv:1710.06880, and thanks to Kevin Schaeffer for a discussion in 2012 that provided motivation for this project. 1 41

Transcript of String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New...

Page 1: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

String and M-Theory:

The New Geometry of the 21st Century

National Univ. of Singapore, 2018

Supersymmetric Curvepoles in 6D

Ori Ganor

Berkeley Center for Theoretical Physics, UC Berkeley

December 14, 2018

arXiv:1710.06880, and thanks to Kevin Schaeffer for adiscussion in 2012 that provided motivation for this project.

1 41

Page 2: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

String and M-Theory:

The New Geometry of the 21st Century

National Univ. of Singapore, 2018

Supersymmetric Curvepoles in 6D

(New effects on M5-branes in strong flux?)

Ori Ganor

Berkeley Center for Theoretical Physics, UC Berkeley

December 14, 2018

arXiv:1710.06880, and thanks to Kevin Schaeffer for adiscussion in 2012 that provided motivation for this project.

2 41

Page 3: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

3 41

Page 4: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

3 41

Page 5: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

− +

Dipole:

Two endpoints interacting

with a 1-form gauge field A

with opposite charges.

3 41

Page 6: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

− +

Dipole:

Two endpoints interacting

with a 1-form gauge field A

with opposite charges.

C

Σ

Curvepole:

3 41

Page 7: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

− +

Dipole:

Two endpoints interacting

with a 1-form gauge field A

with opposite charges.

C

Σ

Curvepole:

Has closed curve boundary C = ∂Σ

charged under 2-form gauge field B.

3 41

Page 8: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

− +

Dipole:

Two endpoints interacting

with a 1-form gauge field A

with opposite charges.

C

Σ

Curvepole:

Has closed curve boundary C = ∂Σ

charged under 2-form gauge field B.

Bulk of Σ is inert.

3 41

Page 9: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Dipoles and Curvepoles

Curvepole – counterpart of E&M dipole, interacting with a 2-form.

E&M Tensor field

− +

Dipole:

Two endpoints interacting

with a 1-form gauge field A

with opposite charges.

C

Σ

Curvepole:

Has closed curve boundary C = ∂Σ

charged under 2-form gauge field B.

Bulk of Σ is inert.

Focus on 6D where (anti-)selfduality can impose restrictions.

3 41

Page 10: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

4 41

Page 11: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

4 41

Page 12: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

4 41

Page 13: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

4 41

Page 14: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

4 41

Page 15: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

NOTE: The shape C of these curvepoles is fixed!

C is an external parameter of the theory.

4 41

Page 16: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The Goal

Construct a supersymmetric second quantized theory of curvepolesinteracting with a 6D tensor multiplet of (1, 0) SUSY.

dB = H = −?H interacts with a field Φ whose quanta are:

NOTE: The shape C of these curvepoles is fixed!

C is an external parameter of the theory.

Does SUSY impose any restrictions on C?

4 41

Page 17: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

5 41

Page 18: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

5 41

Page 19: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

5 41

Page 20: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

− There is a restriction on C , imposed by SUSY.

5 41

Page 21: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

− There is a restriction on C , imposed by SUSY. (sufficient condition)

5 41

Page 22: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

− There is a restriction on C , imposed by SUSY. (sufficient condition)

− There is another restriction on C , imposed by Hollowness.

5 41

Page 23: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

− There is a restriction on C , imposed by SUSY. (sufficient condition)

− There is another restriction on C , imposed by Hollowness.

♦ If C is planar, both SUSY and Hollowness hold? (up to 4th order).

5 41

Page 24: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Preview of resultsConstruct action order by order:

L = L2 + L3 + L4 + · · ·δSUSY = δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · ·

Require SUSY and Hollowness.

Hollowness – theory depends only on C = ∂Σ, but not on Σ.

− I’ll present explicit formulas for up to quartic interactions.

− There is a restriction on C , imposed by SUSY. (sufficient condition)

− There is another restriction on C , imposed by Hollowness.

♦ If C is planar, both SUSY and Hollowness hold? (up to 4th order).

All of this is at the “classical” level.I’ll briefly mention issues regarding anomalies at the end.

5 41

Page 25: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

6 41

Page 26: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

U-duality

6 41

Page 27: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

U-duality

U-dual T 3

Vol(U-dual T 3)→∞

Wrapped M5:

freehyper ’plet

& tensor ’plet

(1,0) multiplets

6 41

Page 28: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

U-duality

U-dual T 3

Vol(U-dual T 3)→∞

Wrapped M5:

freehyper ’plet

& tensor ’plet

(1,0) multipletsΩ

Insert Ω ∈ Spin(5) twist

Scaling limit: Ω→ I with (Ω− I )/M4pVol2/3 → finite

6 41

Page 29: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

U-duality

U-dual T 3

Vol(U-dual T 3)→∞

Wrapped M5:

freehyper ’plet

& tensor ’plet

(1,0) multipletsΩ

Insert Ω ∈ Spin(5) twist

Scaling limit: Ω→ I with (Ω− I )/M4pVol2/3 → finite

curvepole

6 41

Page 30: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

A digression: Connection to M-theory

T 3

Vol(T 3)→ 0

M2

U-duality

U-dual T 3

Vol(U-dual T 3)→∞

Wrapped M5:

freehyper ’plet

& tensor ’plet

(1,0) multipletsΩ

Insert Ω ∈ Spin(5) twist

Scaling limit: Ω→ I with (Ω− I )/M4pVol2/3 → finite

curvepole

[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001; Alishahiha & OG 2003]c.f. [Douglas & Hull, 1997; Connes & Douglas & Schwarz, 1997]

6 41

Page 31: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5

7 41

Page 32: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5x5

x3

x4x5

x3

x4

0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi 0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi

V = (2π)3R3R4R5U

V = (2π)3R3R4R5 = (2π)6

M6pV

7 41

Page 33: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5x5

x3

x4x5

x3

x4

0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi 0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi

V = (2π)3R3R4R5U

V = (2π)3R3R4R5 = (2π)6

M6pV

Twist: x5 → x5 + 2πR5

accompanied by e iθ ∈ U(1)︸︷︷︸J

⊂ SO(5)6,...,10

7 41

Page 34: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5x5

x3

x4x5

x3

x4

0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi 0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi

V = (2π)3R3R4R5U

V = (2π)3R3R4R5 = (2π)6

M6pV

Twist: x5 → x5 + 2πR5

accompanied by e iθ ∈ U(1)︸︷︷︸J

⊂ SO(5)6,...,10

Momentum quantization: P5R5 ∈ Z + θJ2π

7 41

Page 35: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5x5

x3

x4x5

x3

x4

0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi 0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi

V = (2π)3R3R4R5U

V = (2π)3R3R4R5 = (2π)6

M6pV

Twist: x5 → x5 + 2πR5

accompanied by e iθ ∈ U(1)︸︷︷︸J

⊂ SO(5)6,...,10

Momentum quantization: P5R5 ∈ Z + θJ2π

Dual to : M2-area ∈ Z(2π)2R3R4 + (2πθR3R4)︸ ︷︷ ︸keep finite

J

7 41

Page 36: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction (more details)

T 3 T 3

M2

U

M5x5

x3

x4x5

x3

x4

0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi 0 ≤ xi ≤ 2πRi

V = (2π)3R3R4R5U

V = (2π)3R3R4R5 = (2π)6

M6pV

Twist: x5 → x5 + 2πR5

accompanied by e iθ ∈ U(1)︸︷︷︸J

⊂ SO(5)6,...,10

Momentum quantization: P5R5 ∈ Z + θJ2π

Dual to : M2-area ∈ Z(2π)2R3R4 + (2πθR3R4)︸ ︷︷ ︸keep finite

J

Area(Σ)7 41

Page 37: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

M5

8 41

Page 38: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

M5x7 x6

0, . . . , 5

8 41

Page 39: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

Strong G1267 flux

M5x7 x6

0, . . . , 5

8 41

Page 40: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

Strong G1267 flux

M5x7 x6

0, . . . , 5

M2

8 41

Page 41: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

Strong G1267 flux

M5x7 x6

0, . . . , 5

M2

Σ

8 41

Page 42: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

M-theory construction - what are the curvepoles?

Curvepoles can also be explained (heuristically) by a Myers effect

(dielectric open M2’s)[Bergman & OG, 2000; Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG, 2001]

Strong G1267 flux

M5x7 x6

0, . . . , 5

M2

Σ

See also [Witten, 1997; Aganagic & Park & Popscu & Schwarz, 1997;

Bergshoeff & Berman, & van der Schaar & Sundell, 2000;

Berman & Tadrowski, 2007; Lambert & Orlando & Reffert, 2014; Lambert & Orlando & Reffert & Sekiguchi, 2018]

8 41

Page 43: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

9 41

Page 44: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

Free 6D (2, 0) tensor ’plet

9 41

Page 45: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

Free 6D (2, 0) tensor ’plet

(1, 0) tensor(B, χi, ϕ) i = 1, 2

SU(2)R index: (1, 0) hyper(φi, ψ)

9 41

Page 46: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

Free 6D (2, 0) tensor ’plet

(1, 0) tensor(B, χi, ϕ)

H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0

i = 1, 2SU(2)R index: (1, 0) hyper

(φi, ψ)

9 41

Page 47: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

Free 6D (2, 0) tensor ’plet

(1, 0) tensor(B, χi, ϕ)

H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0

i = 1, 2SU(2)R index: (1, 0) hyper

(φi, ψ)

want their quanta

to become curvepoles:

9 41

Page 48: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Deforming the free theory to Curvepole Theory

Free 6D (2, 0) tensor ’plet

(1, 0) tensor(B, χi, ϕ)

H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0

i = 1, 2SU(2)R index: (1, 0) hyper

(φi, ψ)

want their quanta

to become curvepoles:

want their quanta

to stay pointlike.

9 41

Page 49: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +

10 41

Page 50: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

10 41

Page 51: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

10 41

Page 52: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

Φ is 2nd quantized field of dipole.

10 41

Page 53: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

Φ is 2nd quantized field of dipole.

Modified covariant derivative:

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iAµ(x + L2 )Φ(x)− iAµ(x − L

2 )Φ(x)

10 41

Page 54: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

Φ is 2nd quantized field of dipole.

Modified covariant derivative:

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iAµ(x + L2 )Φ(x)− iAµ(x − L

2 )Φ(x)

[Bergman & OG, Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG]

10 41

Page 55: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

Φ is 2nd quantized field of dipole.

Modified covariant derivative:

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iAµ(x + L2 )Φ(x)− iAµ(x − L

2 )Φ(x)

[Bergman & OG, Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG]

Attach Wilson line:

− +

Px

P is a fixed path from −L2 to L

2 .

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

Px := x + P is “P translated by x .”

10 41

Page 56: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Recall: 2nd quantized dipolesDipole:

− +x

L

L is a fixed vector.(Counterpart of Σ)

Φ is 2nd quantized field of dipole.

Modified covariant derivative:

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iAµ(x + L2 )Φ(x)− iAµ(x − L

2 )Φ(x)

[Bergman & OG, Bergman & Dasgupta & Karczmarek & Rajesh & OG]

Attach Wilson line:

− +

Px

P is a fixed path from −L2 to L

2 .

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

Px := x + P is “P translated by x .”

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iΦ(x)

∫Px

Fνµdxν

10 41

Page 57: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

11 41

Page 58: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

11 41

Page 59: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1: “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iφ(x)∫∂Σ Bµν(x + y)dyν

[Schaeffer, 2012 (unpublished)], (Implicit in [Alishahiha & OG, 2003])

11 41

Page 60: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1: “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iφ(x)∫∂Σ Bµν(x + y)dyν

[Schaeffer, 2012 (unpublished)], (Implicit in [Alishahiha & OG, 2003])

But action should depend only on H(−) := 12 (dB − ∗dB).

11 41

Page 61: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1: “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iφ(x)∫∂Σ Bµν(x + y)dyν

[Schaeffer, 2012 (unpublished)], (Implicit in [Alishahiha & OG, 2003])

But action should depend only on H(−) := 12 (dB − ∗dB).

For free tensor: H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0⇒ H(−) = dB,

a field redefinition φ(x) := e i∫

Σ Bµν(x+y)dyµ∧dyνφ(x) does it:

11 41

Page 62: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1: “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iφ(x)∫∂Σ Bµν(x + y)dyν

[Schaeffer, 2012 (unpublished)], (Implicit in [Alishahiha & OG, 2003])

But action should depend only on H(−) := 12 (dB − ∗dB).

For free tensor: H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0⇒ H(−) = dB,

a field redefinition φ(x) := e i∫

Σ Bµν(x+y)dyµ∧dyνφ(x) does it:

⇒ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + i φ(x)∫

Σ(dB)µνσ(x + y)dyν ∧ dyσ

11 41

Page 63: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory (first try)

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1: “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iφ(x)∫∂Σ Bµν(x + y)dyν

[Schaeffer, 2012 (unpublished)], (Implicit in [Alishahiha & OG, 2003])

But action should depend only on H(−) := 12 (dB − ∗dB).

For free tensor: H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = 0⇒ H(−) = dB,

a field redefinition φ(x) := e i∫

Σ Bµν(x+y)dyµ∧dyνφ(x) does it:

⇒ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + i φ(x)∫

Σ(dB)µνσ(x + y)dyν ∧ dyσ

But interactions ⇒ H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) = K (+) = (φ-contributions)

11 41

Page 64: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

12 41

Page 65: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

12 41

Page 66: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1’: Modified “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iVµ(x)φ(x)

Vµ(x) := 12

∫Σ dyν ∧ dyσH

(−)µνσ(x + y)

12 41

Page 67: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1’: Modified “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iVµ(x)φ(x)

Vµ(x) := 12

∫Σ dyν ∧ dyσH

(−)µνσ(x + y) −1

2

∫∂Σ dyµϕ(x + y)

required for SUSY

12 41

Page 68: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1’: Modified “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iVµ(x)φ(x)

Vµ(x) := 12

∫Σ dyν ∧ dyσH

(−)µνσ(x + y) −1

2

∫∂Σ dyµϕ(x + y)

required for SUSYAdditional terms in L

12 41

Page 69: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Curvepole Theory

We want quanta of φ to be curvepoles:

[interacting with (H(−), χi, ϕ)]

Σ – fixed shape (open surface) around origin.

Σ

Step 1’: Modified “covariant” curvepole derivative

∂µφ→ Dµφ(x) := ∂µφ(x) + iVµ(x)φ(x)

Vµ(x) := 12

∫Σ dyν ∧ dyσH

(−)µνσ(x + y) −1

2

∫∂Σ dyµϕ(x + y)

required for SUSYAdditional terms in L

A condition on Σ

12 41

Page 70: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

13 41

Page 71: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

13 41

Page 72: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

A condition on Σ appears by requiring SUSY at quartic order.

13 41

Page 73: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

A condition on Σ appears by requiring SUSY at quartic order.

SUSY preserved if:

(up to quartic order)

13 41

Page 74: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

A condition on Σ appears by requiring SUSY at quartic order.

SUSY preserved if:

(up to quartic order)

Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

13 41

Page 75: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

What is the condition on Σ?

Define the curvepole integrals: Σ

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

A condition on Σ appears by requiring SUSY at quartic order.

SUSY preserved if:

(up to quartic order)

Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

This is a geometric condition on Σ.

Let’s call such Σ’s balanced curvepoles.

13 41

Page 76: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced Curvepoles

ΣΨ

µν:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

14 41

Page 77: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced Curvepoles

ΣΨ

µν:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Equivalent to:∫d6x Ψ αβ Φ γδ =

∫d6x Ψ γδ Φ αβ

for arbitrary Ψ,Φ

14 41

Page 78: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced Curvepoles

ΣΨ

µν:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Equivalent to:∫d6x Ψ αβ Φ γδ =

∫d6x Ψ γδ Φ αβ

for arbitrary Ψ,Φ

(This is a stronger condition)

Ψ αβ Φ γδ = Ψ γδ Φ αβ

14 41

Page 79: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced Curvepoles

ΣΨ

µν:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Equivalent to:∫d6x Ψ αβ Φ γδ =

∫d6x Ψ γδ Φ αβ

for arbitrary Ψ,Φ

(This is a stronger condition)

Ψ αβ Φ γδ = Ψ γδ Φ αβPlanar curvepole

(Σ ⊂ R2 ⊂ R6)

14 41

Page 80: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced and Unbalanced Curvepoles

ΣΨµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

15 41

Page 81: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced and Unbalanced Curvepoles

ΣΨµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Parity invariant (Σ = −Σ) (balanced)

15 41

Page 82: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced and Unbalanced Curvepoles

ΣΨµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Parity invariant (Σ = −Σ) (balanced)

Planar (Σ ⊂ R2 ⊂ R6) (balanced)

15 41

Page 83: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Balanced and Unbalanced Curvepoles

ΣΨµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Ψµν

:=∫

Σ Ψ(x − y)dyµ ∧ dyν

Balanced curvepole: Ψ αβγδ

= Ψ γδαβ

for arbitrary Ψ

Parity invariant (Σ = −Σ) (balanced)

Planar (Σ ⊂ R2 ⊂ R6) (balanced)

(a chair) (not balanced)

15 41

Page 84: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The action - quadratic termsThe bosonic quadratic terms are:

L(bosonic)2 = 1

12πHµνσHµνσ + 1

4π∂µϕ∂µϕ+ ∂µφi∂

µφi

whereHµνσ := 3∂[µBνσ] 3-form field strength

H(±)µνσ := 1

2 (Hµνσ ± i6εµνσαβγH

αβγ)selfdual and anti-selfdual components

16 41

Page 85: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The action - cubic termsThe bosonic cubic terms are:

L(bosonic)3 = −JµVµ

whereJµ := i(φi∂µφ

i − ∂µφiφi) U(1) current

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

effective gauge field defined above

17 41

Page 86: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The action - quartic termsThe additional bosonic quartic terms are:

L(bosonic)4 = VµVµφiφ

i − 3π16 J [µ

σν]

J[µσν]

+ π2 ∂

µM ji µσ

∂νMij

νσ

whereJµ := i(φi∂µφ

i − ∂µφiφi) U(1) current

M ji := φiφ

j − 12δ

jiφkφ

k SU(2)R triplet

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

effective gauge field defined above

18 41

Page 87: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness

C = ∂Σ

Σ

19 41

Page 88: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness

C = ∂Σ

Σ

It would be nice if the theory depended only on C ; not on Σ.

19 41

Page 89: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness

C = ∂Σ

Σ

It would be nice if the theory depended only on C ; not on Σ.

If ∂Σ = ∂Σ′, we’d like theory (Σ) ' theory(Σ′)

up to a field redefinition.

19 41

Page 90: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness

C = ∂Σ

Σ

It would be nice if the theory depended only on C ; not on Σ.

If ∂Σ = ∂Σ′, we’d like theory (Σ) ' theory(Σ′)

up to a field redefinition.

That turns out to be true . . . well . . . sort of.

19 41

Page 91: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +

20 41

Page 92: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

20 41

Page 93: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

20 41

Page 94: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

DµΦ(x) =

∂µΦ(x) + i [Aµ(x + L2 )− Aµ(x − L

2 )]Φ(x)

20 41

Page 95: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

DµΦ(x) =

∂µΦ(x) + i [Aµ(x + L2 )− Aµ(x − L

2 )]Φ(x)

− +

Px

Field redefinition (attach Wilson line):

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

20 41

Page 96: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

DµΦ(x) =

∂µΦ(x) + i [Aµ(x + L2 )− Aµ(x − L

2 )]Φ(x)

− +

Px

Field redefinition (attach Wilson line):

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iΦ(x)

∫Px

Fνµdxν

20 41

Page 97: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

DµΦ(x) =

∂µΦ(x) + i [Aµ(x + L2 )− Aµ(x − L

2 )]Φ(x)

− +

Px

Field redefinition (attach Wilson line):

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iΦ(x)

∫Px

Fνµdxν

P ′x

20 41

Page 98: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

HollownessRecall dipole case:

− +x

L

DµΦ(x) =

∂µΦ(x) + i [Aµ(x + L2 )− Aµ(x − L

2 )]Φ(x)

− +

Px

Field redefinition (attach Wilson line):

Φ(x) := e−i∫Px

AΦ(x) is gauge invariant.

DµΦ(x) = ∂µΦ(x) + iΦ(x)

∫Px

Fνµdxν

P ′x

Px → P ′x can be compensated by a field redefinition.

20 41

Page 99: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

21 41

Page 100: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

21 41

Page 101: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

21 41

Page 102: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

21 41

Page 103: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

21 41

Page 104: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

∂νϕµν

=∫

Σ ∂νϕ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν =

∫∂Σ ϕ(x + y)dyµ is hollow.

21 41

Page 105: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

∂νϕµν

=∫

Σ ∂νϕ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν =

∫∂Σ ϕ(x + y)dyµ is hollow.

H(−)µνσ

νσ

would have been hollow if dH(−) = 0 but

21 41

Page 106: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

∂νϕµν

=∫

Σ ∂νϕ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν =

∫∂Σ ϕ(x + y)dyµ is hollow.

H(−)µνσ

νσ

would have been hollow if dH(−) = 0 but

∂[αH(−)µνσ] = −3πi

32 εαµνσγδ ∂τJ[γ

δτ ]

+ 3π4 ∂[αJµ

νσ].

21 41

Page 107: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness for cuvepoles

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

∂νϕµν

=∫

Σ ∂νϕ(x + y)dyµ ∧ dyν =

∫∂Σ ϕ(x + y)dyµ is hollow.

H(−)µνσ

νσ

would have been hollow if dH(−) = 0 but

∂[αH(−)µνσ] = −3πi

32 εαµνσγδ ∂τJ[γ

δτ ]

+ 3π4 ∂[αJµ

νσ]. Nevertheless . . .

21 41

Page 108: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The action (again)

L(bosonic) =

112πHµνσH

µνσ + 14π∂µϕ∂

µϕ+ ∂µφi∂µφi + π

2 ∂µM j

i µσ∂νM

ij

νσ

︸ ︷︷ ︸hollow

−JµVµ + VµVµφiφ

i − 3π16 J [µ

σν]

J[µσν]︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

Jµ := i(φi∂µφi − ∂µφiφi) U(1) current

M ji := φiφ

j − 12δ

jiφkφ

k SU(2)R triplet

Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

−12 ∂

νϕµν︸ ︷︷ ︸

hollow

effective gauge field defined above

22 41

Page 109: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued)

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

23 41

Page 110: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued)

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

But with a suitable field redefinition ( δξBµν = · · · , δξφi = · · · , etc.),

23 41

Page 111: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued)

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

But with a suitable field redefinition ( δξBµν = · · · , δξφi = · · · , etc.),

δξ∫d6x

(· · · −JµVµ + VµV

µφiφi − 3π

16 J [µσν]

J[µσν]︸ ︷︷ ︸

non-hollow terms

)=

23 41

Page 112: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued)

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ Φµν

= ξσ∂σΦµν

+ ξµ∂σΦνσ− ξν∂σΦ

µσ

But with a suitable field redefinition ( δξBµν = · · · , δξφi = · · · , etc.),

δξ∫d6x

(· · · −JµVµ + VµV

µφiφi − 3π

16 J [µσν]

J[µσν]︸ ︷︷ ︸

non-hollow terms

)=

πi32

∫εαβγµνσ Jα

βγξτ∂τJ

µ νσd6x .

23 41

Page 113: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued . . . )

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

24 41

Page 114: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued . . . )

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ∫ (· · · · · · · · ·

)d6x = πi

32

∫εαβγµνσ Jα

βγξτ∂τJ

µ νσd6x .

24 41

Page 115: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued . . . )

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ∫ (· · · · · · · · ·

)d6x = πi

32

∫εαβγµνσ Jα

βγξτ∂τJ

µ νσd6x .

εαβγµνσ · · · βγ · · · νσ = 0 for 3-planar Σ (i.e., Σ ⊂ R3 ⊂ R6)

24 41

Page 116: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Hollowness (continued . . . )

Σ

Σ′

ξ ξ : Σ→ R6

is the deformation vector

δξ∫ (· · · · · · · · ·

)d6x = πi

32

∫εαβγµνσ Jα

βγξτ∂τJ

µ νσd6x .

εαβγµνσ · · · βγ · · · νσ = 0 for 3-planar Σ (i.e., Σ ⊂ R3 ⊂ R6)

=⇒ δξ∫Ld6x = 0 for 3-planar Σ. (up to quartic terms)

24 41

Page 117: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

25 41

Page 118: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

1. SUSY alone doesn’t rule out adding a quartic term

∆L = (#)

(12 Jσ µν

Jσµν− ∂σM

ijµν∂σM j

i

µν

+ fermions

)︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

25 41

Page 119: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

1. SUSY alone doesn’t rule out adding a quartic term

∆L = (#)

(12 Jσ µν

Jσµν− ∂σM

ijµν∂σM j

i

µν

+ fermions

)︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

2. Ruling out higher order terms:

25 41

Page 120: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

1. SUSY alone doesn’t rule out adding a quartic term

∆L = (#)

(12 Jσ µν

Jσµν− ∂σM

ijµν∂σM j

i

µν

+ fermions

)︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

2. Ruling out higher order terms:

hollowness requires a ∂ for every · · · .

Terms of the form ∂n−2 · · · n−2φn have dimension (n + 2);

25 41

Page 121: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

1. SUSY alone doesn’t rule out adding a quartic term

∆L = (#)

(12 Jσ µν

Jσµν− ∂σM

ijµν∂σM j

i

µν

+ fermions

)︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

2. Ruling out higher order terms:

hollowness requires a ∂ for every · · · .

Terms of the form ∂n−2 · · · n−2φn have dimension (n + 2);

n + 2 > 6 for n > 4.

25 41

Page 122: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Applications of hollowness

Insisting on Hollowness is useful:

1. SUSY alone doesn’t rule out adding a quartic term

∆L = (#)

(12 Jσ µν

Jσµν− ∂σM

ijµν∂σM j

i

µν

+ fermions

)︸ ︷︷ ︸

not hollow

2. Ruling out higher order terms:

hollowness requires a ∂ for every · · · .

Terms of the form ∂n−2 · · · n−2φn have dimension (n + 2);

n + 2 > 6 for n > 4. But . . .

25 41

Page 123: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Is hollowness anomalous?

The field redefinition is

δBγδ = πi4 εαµνσγδ ξ

αJµνσ

δφi = iεφi,

δφi

= −iεφi,

δψi = iεψi,

δψi

= −iεψi,

ε := 12 ξ

αH(−)αµν

µν

.

26 41

Page 124: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Is hollowness anomalous?

The field redefinition is

δBγδ = πi4 εαµνσγδ ξ

αJµνσ

δφi = iεφi,

δφi

= −iεφi,

δψi = iεψi,

δψi

= −iεψi,

ε := 12 ξ

αH(−)αµν

µν

.

Anomaly ∼∫εdV ∧ dV ∧ dV at order · · · 4

26 41

Page 125: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Is hollowness anomalous?

The field redefinition is

δBγδ = πi4 εαµνσγδ ξ

αJµνσ

δφi = iεφi,

δφi

= −iεφi,

δψi = iεψi,

δψi

= −iεψi,

ε := 12 ξ

αH(−)αµν

µν

.

Anomaly ∼∫εdV ∧ dV ∧ dV at order · · · 4

Reminder: Vµ := 12 H(−)

µνσ

νσ

− 12 ∂

νϕµν

26 41

Page 126: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

27 41

Page 127: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

Higher than quartic orders? Additional restrictions on Σ?

27 41

Page 128: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

Higher than quartic orders? Additional restrictions on Σ?

Hollowness anomaly cancellation? (Green-Schwarz-like?)

Quantum corrections? (protected by anti-selfduality?)

27 41

Page 129: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

Higher than quartic orders? Additional restrictions on Σ?

Hollowness anomaly cancellation? (Green-Schwarz-like?)

Quantum corrections? (protected by anti-selfduality?)

How are these theories related to the M-theory construction?

Which Σ are realized? (Probably disks.)

27 41

Page 130: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

Higher than quartic orders? Additional restrictions on Σ?

Hollowness anomaly cancellation? (Green-Schwarz-like?)

Quantum corrections? (protected by anti-selfduality?)

How are these theories related to the M-theory construction?

Which Σ are realized? (Probably disks.)

Perhaps technique of [Ho & Matsuo, 2008, and Ho & Huang & Matsuo, 2011],

applying Bagger-Lambert-Gustavsson theory to

Poisson triple-product, can help here.

27 41

Page 131: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Open Questions

Higher than quartic orders? Additional restrictions on Σ?

Hollowness anomaly cancellation? (Green-Schwarz-like?)

Quantum corrections? (protected by anti-selfduality?)

How are these theories related to the M-theory construction?

Which Σ are realized? (Probably disks.)

Perhaps technique of [Ho & Matsuo, 2008, and Ho & Huang & Matsuo, 2011],

applying Bagger-Lambert-Gustavsson theory to

Poisson triple-product, can help here.

Applications to interactions induced on M5-brane by G -flux?

cf. [Perry & Schwarz, Aganagic & Park & Popescu & Schwarz, Bergshoeff & Berman & van der Schaar

& Sundell, Gopakumar & Minwalla & Seiberg & Strominger, Lambert & Orlando & Reffert & Sekiguchi]

27 41

Page 132: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

More Questions

28 41

Page 133: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

More Questions

Can pure-spinor techniques simplify the equations?

cf. [Cederwall & Karlsson, 2011] for BI.

28 41

Page 134: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

More Questions

Can pure-spinor techniques simplify the equations?

cf. [Cederwall & Karlsson, 2011] for BI.

Recast in projective superspace?[Galperin & Ivanov & Ogievetsky & Sokatchev; Karlhede & Lindstrom & Rocek]

28 41

Page 135: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

29 41

Page 136: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

There is a geometric constraint on curvepole shape

29 41

Page 137: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

There is a geometric constraint on curvepole shape

Explicit formulas for the quartic interactions

29 41

Page 138: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Thanks!

30 41

Page 139: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

MORE DETAILS

31 41

Page 140: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Antiselfduality with interactions

Action: S = 14π

∫dB ∧ ∗dB +

∫(dB − ∗dB) ∧ K

Field strength: H(±) := 12 (dB ± ∗dB)

EOMs: 0 = d[

12π∗dB + (K + ∗K )

]= d

[1πH

(+) + (K + ∗K )]

Corrections to free anti-selfduality condition:

H(+) = −π(K + ∗K )

Can define: H(+) := 12 (dB + ∗dB) + π(K + ∗K ) = 0

32 41

Page 141: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Spinor notation in 6Da,b, c,d, . . . = 1, . . . 4 spinor indices

∂ab = 12εabcd∂

cd derivative

Bab 2-form (Ba

a = 0)

H(−)ab = H

(−)ba antiselfdual 3-form

H(+)ab = H(+)ba selfdual 3-form

H(−)ab = 2∂c(aBb)

c ⇐⇒H

(−)µνσ = 1

2 (Hµνσ − i3!εµνσαβγH

αβγ)

for Hµνσ = 3∂[σBµν]

33 41

Page 142: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

SUSY transformations at 0th order

δ0φi = ηaiψa

δ0φi = ηai ψa

δ0ψa = −2iηbi ∂abφi

δ0ψa = −2iηbi ∂abφi

δ0ϕ = ηai χia

δ0χia = iηbi∂abϕ+ iηbiHab

δ0Hab = ηci ∂caχib + ηci ∂cbχ

ia

34 41

Page 143: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Effective vector multipletOut of H and χ we construct a vector multiplet:

Vab := Hc[ac

b]+ ∂c[a ϕ

c

b] Vector field

ρia := ∂ab χic

c

bGaugino field

Fba = ∂bcVac − 1

4δba∂

dcVdc Associated field strength

Their 0th order SUSY transformations:

δ0Vab = −ηai ρib + ηbi ρia − ∂abλ

δ0ρia = 2iηbiFa

b

λ := ηai χib

b

aField-dependent gauge parameter

35 41

Page 144: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

SUSY transformations at 1st order

δ1φi = −iηaj φi χ

jb

b

a

δ1φi

= iηaj φiχjb

b

a

δ1ψa = 2ηbi Hc[bc

a]φi + 2ηbi φ

i∂c[b ϕc

a]+ iηbi ψa χ

ic

c

b

δ1ψa = 2ηbi Hc[ac

b]φi+ 2ηbi φ

i∂c[a ϕ

c

b]− iηbi ψa χ

ic

c

b

δ1ϕ = 0

36 41

Page 145: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

SUSY transformations at 1st order (Continued)

δ1χia = πiηci ψbψ(a

b

c)+ πiηci ψbψ(a

b

c)

−πηcj12φ

j∂bcφ

i + 12φ

j∂bcφi+ 3

2φi∂bcφ

j + 32φ

i∂bcφj

b

a

−πηcj14φ

i∂abφj+ 1

4φi∂abφ

j + 34φ

j∂abφi+ 3

4φj∂abφ

ib

c

δ1Bab = − iπ

2 ηci ψcφ

i+ ψcφ

ia

b+ iπηci ψbφ

i+ ψbφ

ia

c

+iπηai ψcφi+ ψcφ

ic

b− iπ

2 δabη

ci ψdφ

i+ ψdφ

id

c

37 41

Page 146: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Origin of Balanced Curvepole condition

We want (δ0 + δ1 + δ2 + · · · )∫

(L2 + L3 + L4 + · · · ) = 0.

Look at the φψψψ terms in δ1L3

+ηei ∂ab φiψa

c

bψcψd

d

e− ηei ∂ab φ

iψa

d

eψcψd

c

b

+ηei ∂ab φiψa

c

eψcψd

d

b− ηei ∂ab φ

iψa

d

bψcψd

c

e

+ 12η

ei ∂

ab φiψa

c

dψbψc

d

e− 1

2ηei ∂

ab φiψa

d

eψbψc

c

d

+ 12η

ei ∂

ab φiψa

c

eψdψb

d

c− 1

2ηei ∂

ab φiψa

d

cψdψb

c

e

Doesn’t seem to be possible to cancel with δ0L4 + δ2L2 unless

∫X

c

b Yd

e =∫

Xd

e Yc

b

38 41

Page 147: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary (repeat)

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

39 41

Page 148: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary (repeat)

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

There is a geometric constraint on curvepole shape

39 41

Page 149: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary (repeat)

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

There is a geometric constraint on curvepole shape

Explicit formulas for the quartic interactions

39 41

Page 150: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Summary (repeat)

Constructed a SUSY action of interacting curvepoles

(up to quartic terms)

There is a geometric constraint on curvepole shape

Explicit formulas for the quartic interactions

39 41

Page 151: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The bigger picture?

This is another example of new nonlocal theories that appear

when probing regions of strong flux with branes.

Other examples include:

40 41

Page 152: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The bigger picture?

This is another example of new nonlocal theories that appear

when probing regions of strong flux with branes.

Other examples include:

Noncommutative spacetime[Connes & Douglas & Schwarz, Douglas & Hull, Seiberg & Witten, 1998]

40 41

Page 153: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

The bigger picture?

This is another example of new nonlocal theories that appear

when probing regions of strong flux with branes.

Other examples include:

Noncommutative spacetime[Connes & Douglas & Schwarz, Douglas & Hull, Seiberg & Witten, 1998]

Dipole theories

Puff Field Theory [Hashimoto & Jue & Kim & Ndirango & OG, 2007]

40 41

Page 154: String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century ... · String and M-Theory: The New Geometry of the 21st Century National Univ. of Singapore, 2018 Supersymmetric Curvepoles

Thanks!

41 41