Stretching to Find the Negative: Gary Bergera’s Review of Joseph Smith’s Polygamy: History and...

7/29/2019 Stretching to Find the Negative: Gary Bergera’s Review of Joseph Smith’s Polygamy: History and Theology

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/stretching-to-find-the-negative-gary-bergeras-review-of-joseph-smiths 1/32

Offprint Series

Stretching to Find the Negative:Gary Bergera’s Review of Joseph Smith’s Polygamy:

History and Teology

B C. H

Volume 6 · 2013 · Pages 165-190



© T I Fu. A z.

T k u C C Abu-NC-ND . U L. , ://-.//b--/./ C C, 444 CS, Su 9, Mu V, C, 944, USA.

T T I Fu u uu u b , u u, , , u,uu, , , , , , , . I ub u LDS u R, LDS . W -u, b u , u u— Ju C.

Au B u u Cu, IFu , b T Cu Ju C L- S, B Yu U-. A b u, u b B, LDS , b .

T ju k ub. V u MI.



Ab: A h-- S Sy

Ag 2, 2013, Gy Bg dvd v 90% h -

vw z y 1500+ g, h-v, J

S’ P: H T. T d

v h dg d by Bg h

w . A ddd h

d g byd by y d d

h dvd g h (1) Jh C. B d

ygy Jh Sh, (2) h Fy Ag-Jh Sh

h w dy, d (3) h Ph d x

ydy. T vd g b by

dg w vd bhd h h h

v b gd by Bg. T w d d bv w d xd h ddg

byd h w d Bg’

vw.

Du x u-- -

u Su Su, G B u, Jh

Sh’ Pygy: Hy d Tgy . H

k , bu

. I

Ax ( 48) .7%

.

Stretching to Find the Negative:

Gary Bergera’s Review o JosephSmith’s Polygamy: History and

heology

B C. H



• Interpreter: A Journal o Mormon Scripture 6 (2013)

u-- J

W H A I,Mu, 9. T I qu Nv Pygy: “…b

w d g” u b G D. S

S-P Fu (G B’ ). W

I b I b , I

Nv Pygy b ,

u u J S’ . S

, I G’ u

k G D. S bk—

b uu. I

, ub x

b b.

T u u B’

, bu k u

b . A k k

b , B’ qu uu

u.

Use of Late RecollectionsI u Su , G B

z u

u . T u b

Nu bu

b u. G qu

u k u b qu b . I , G I

b

, u u,

x u u b

. T b

u.



Hales, Stretching to Find the Negative • 7Hales, Stretching to Find the Negative • 7

I I B

ub . I J S u , u “I

E M P, 84-44,” ub Dg:

A J M Tgh 5. T qu

uu , u

u . I b u

bu u b. D u u b

u J

S’ u ( )

k u k C

L F, G B’ uu .

G uub ku u J

S u , R C

Pu M ( LDS D&C )

ju W C. J

u ju x ,

bu u . T J N R 84

ub b J C. B Auu 9, 84,

J S b N K.

W Ju 7, 84. H, b u,

S x, G J B, “I E M

P, 84-44,” Dg: A J M Tgh 8/ (F 5):4 .7, 5 .8, ., ., 7 .4, 8 .5-, 9 .8, 9 ., ., .4, .

J C. B, “Sx J C. B,” Sg J

(S, I), Auu 9, 84; ., J C. B, T Hy h

S: O Exé J Sh d M (B: L & W,

84), 4-44. T N K. W, Ju 7, 84,

LDS Cu H Lb. qu H. M Mqu, ., T Jh

Sh Rv: x d Cy (S Lk C: Su Bk,

999), 5-.



8 • Interpreter: A Journal o Mormon Scripture 6 (2013)

u J S b.4 I

u, z u u z u ( ) u u

.

What Was the Purpose of Plural Marriage?

A G B’

J S u u

. T P ju,

u . R,

Su , B u

z x xu u:

“u .”5

4 Fu u. O O

W L ju Nu . O b

b u f Cu 84. (S O O P,

Bk Lb, Y U; LDS Cu H Lb,MS

889, 8.) H ub T Abd M Pyd:

A B Skh (Hk, I., 9). I 84. W L

u F P Ju 9, 84, (D&C 4:)

( D&C ).

H, b ju u Ju , 844, ju k b

xu. (S L W. Ck, W Lw: Bgh Ey – Nv Dy – Cd - Ivw [O, U: G

Bk, 994], 7.) Au u ,

Nv Ex Ju 7, 844, . J

C. B ub Hy h S Nb 84,

b x ub S Ju. L,

J H. Jk : A Nv h Adv d Ex

Jh H. Jk Nv, Exg h Dh M Vy (.

M, I., 9) ju k . Mu

Jk Nw Yk Hd , Sb 5 7, 844, Wky Hd (N Yk C), Sb 7, 844. O u u,

L u u b J S. T uu

u b -M b, k

, , bu uu.

5 S, x, G J B, “Vx Jh Vx D: R

S M E A J S’ P Pu

M,” T Jh Wh H A J / (S/

Su ): 4.




T b P

O “u ” A :. T

ju

K, O, -8 J

F A. Bj F. J 9: “I 85

K I S Hub, L R.

S, P, R

. T u b

b Cu.”7 A 84, J

S b ub. H M

Kb b: “H [J] b

,

Ab, I Jb, u b

, .”8 T : “I L G…. I u u

k , I ”

(. 4; 45).

I b u J

S . H , “O

I’ .” T

S u J S. H

bu b . S L W.

Ck, “L S—M G, Wu-B A,” BYU Sd 9/

(F 978): -4.

7 D R. Z, I Kw h Ph: A Ay h L

Bj F. Jh Gg F. Gbb (MA T, B Yu U,

97), 7-8; J H. Jk Nu

“M I.” J H. Jk, A Nv h Adv d Ex Jh H. Jk, .

8 H M W, P Mg gh by h Ph Jh:

A Ry Jh Sh [III], Ed h L Iw “Hd,” (S Lk

C: Ju Iu, 88), ; J Bb Hz R

Nz Hz, ., A W’ Vw: H M Why’ R

Ey Chh Hy (P, U: Ru Su C, BYU, 997), 4-4.

S J A. K, “A,” M , 894, -;

K, “S,” Jv I 9 (M , 894): 89-9.




. Au k F B u u J’

u .9

T b J S u

u u u b

b - u b b .

Nu L- S C Lb qu P

u “u b

. T

u , b .” H

M Kb J u “u ,

ub, xu

k b .” T

88 u b u b .

H, x

: “ [u ] u

[ ub] u ” (D&C

:).

I u “u ”

. T xu u qu u u u.

S z

ju. O

u : “C bu

x .” B u Su

9 S F M. B, N M Kw My Hy: T L Jh Sh,h M Ph , . . (N Yk: V, 97), 97.

C Lb, “Aub,” 88, qu D W. B,

“T Au Mu D C S ,” 4

. 44.

H M Kb W, Why W P P Mg (S

Lk C: Ju Iu, 884), 7.

G D. S, “Pu M W J C

M,” T Jh Wh H A J (): .




: “T S’ : u

b .” T qu x J S’ u uju

b b u

. I u

u xu, u J S’ Ru V

S, “ ” ( b), u

u u . T u.

J S b Ju

u ( D&C ):

T, ,

b b ,

,

, u

; , bu b

u .

T, u ; bu

, ,

,

x, .

F b ; , b , bu ,

u x, ,

; , bu

G (D&C :5-7).

S u Su B, “T E M C

B,” Dg 44/ (S ), 8.




V - u ub

u u b u “ [ u ’] x .” T

P x: “T k L

k &

” ( D&C :-4).4

W , “u

” “ u ,”

, bu

y . A b, u

ub u “ , u

x, , ” (D&C

:), x D&C ( .

4 ). T u

b b ub ju.

A, I u G b

u J S’ xu bu

u

. x,

b .

Contradictions?

B u “”

bk. I x,

H,

S’ b Nu. I Vu , I

“ b b.”5

4 A F. E, L W. Ck, . T Wd Jh Sh:

T Cy A h Nv D h Ph Jh

Sh (P, U: B Yu U Ru Su C, 98);

Fk D. R . Ju 84, . S Lz S,

“Du,” M S / 5 (M 8, 899): 547-48.

5 B C. H Jh Sh’ Pygy: Hy d Tgy , .

(S Lk C: G Kf Bk), :55 7.




L, B b I

“u b .”

T kb . F,

bu I Cu

C L Mk u

H b

u J S’ . M

b k

ubu, , u

u J S’ . Wu x,

b u b . E

, u b . T

b B’ “”

uz x ,

x u, x u.

A “” b B

“ k J S

u ,

x, u u b

x.”7 B qu u

I k b 84 89,

u L-

S, .8 T “”

b b u u. N

x I G’

H b

. N u b b Cu . T qu

b u qu

b u L- S b 84

H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , :9.

7 H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , :9.

8 H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , :7, :8.




89. H, Cu u u

G’ Bk

M N b

k u u.

John C. Bennett: A Polygamy Insider?

B b 4% u

- , J C. B, F A,

. H

J C. B ,

F A u J S,

P xu . Su

x, B qu . H,

u u b u u u I bk

u .

F x, J C. B, B b

Cu Wk bu u

J S 84. R Wk, B :

“H B, b

S Wk, u.” I

, Wk , bu

J B.

T, , B

“ u.” T u u

u b.

F, u u JS bu u u

B Nu. B , W L,

u F P, u

-84. S R,

u F P, bu u

P. Hu S, J’ b,




A Cu P, Cu P, ’

bu u M 84.9

S, ES u 84. T b

u J S u k W L,

S R, Hu S, E S k

u 84, u k B u

u Ju 84.

S, B Ob 84

bu

Nu. I , b B k

bu u S P N

R J

S . H, b

. W

J u x x u b . I ,

u b u u .

T, x u T Hy

h S b B ub Ob 84

u

b J S Ju 84

u ( D&C ). I

9 G D. S, ., A I Ch: T J W

Cy (S Lk C: Su Bk, 995), ; A F. E,

“J S’ Iu O M Su

Qu.” (M.A. , B Yu U, 98), 5-.

J C. B, “L G B,” Ob 8, 84,

Hwk Ey (Bu, I, Db 7, 84), .

B N b “ b Cy S… k b S Chy … [

] C h C …” (B,

T Hy h S, 4.) B’ Nu

uu b u b b

, u z .

P P. P, J., ., Abghy Py Pk P, O h

wv A h Chh J Ch L-dy S (S Lk C:

D Bk C., 97), 97-98 (985 , 59-).




B J S,

x , b b u

, k u

C S, Cb S, C

C.

I u, B’ bu Cu Wk

84, B u b f

“ u” k u, u

b u u. I ,

b B

k u b .

Fanny Alger and Joseph Smith: Plural Marriage or Adultery?

I JS u F A 85, G

B : “T u

S A, S’

x f. H, H

, u (:5),

, ub,

u u

S.”

T b . I u

k u .

N .4 Fu, I

B, T Hy h S, 220-25. L F u

b b B’ Nu J S’ u : “Tu, ‘ ub’ u

B’ u u .” (L F,

Rg d Sxy: T Shk, h M, d h Od Cy

[N Yk: Ox U P, 98], 7.) T

b ub ub b Nu. N

ub Cu b

J S’ .

4 S H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , :9-78.




u u u bu u

k ju.5

T k u J-

F 88,

. T

84 u

“ u.” T b

u u u u .

O u, buu

. T u 88

O C, b “, ,

” J C. B’ Hy

h S qu F B, 87

u K, O, xu

b P .7 I b

u b

5 S H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , :5, b 5..

O C, L J S, Ju , 88;

O C W A. C , O

C Lbk, 8, Hu Lb. I “L OC,” 8–8. I Nw M Sd: A Chv R Lby ;

. I k J .

7 F B, qu B, T Hy h S, 85–8;

. I ubu B k ,

F A bu u S . I

889, Bj W bu “P

M” ub S Lk b: “[I 85]

ub S

J’ u u, . J’ u .”

W, “P M—P N I,” . W

K u 85–7 , bu b Auu ,

87; u u u k b

J S u . Fu, W’

“ ” uub b

. I W u

.




u . T u b u .

F, C / B k u , bu k

. S, k

. T, u. B

C’ B’ u u, bu

u u u

bu C B u

k . R, b

( :, 77, 48, 44; :).

I, u

u. M Hk ,

L Hk, u F A J S u

.8 R , C : “I

b, u bu , ’ , M K,

Nu S Lk C.”9 Su, B

u b D B

A J P Cu H Lb. J

Ez R. S 88

“ qu” F A k bu . T Ez

F u J S, F’

.

8 L W Hk Aub 89 b M

Hk, , CHL; b M (M 57, ). S

C, I Sd L: T P Wv Jh Sh (S Lk

C: Su Bk, 997), . W b C b ub ju (T Mh Hk J , S

Lk C: P P, .., 74 T Lv Hk J , .., ..

58 ) F A

. S C, “F A S Cu M’

F Pu W?” J M Hy , / (S 99) :75 .

9 C, I Sd L, 9.

A J P [. 87-94], MS 795; CHL, Bx 49, F

, u .




I u, b u

, B bJ S F A “x f.”

H, “ u” u b

B qu

u . R

u ub J S’ Pygy: Hy

d Tgy

F A u J

S.

Sexual Polyandry: Was it Part of Joseph Smith’s Plural

Marriages?

I , B u

J S xu : “[H] u

k u xu

S u k xu

( . -). H

u S

- b

u

uu xu .

T, , , qu ub x.”

O u B , bu

xu u ’ (u

u) kb

b x u b k Nu 84.

F G J

S xu , qu

b

u J S’

. I




, xu b

J u b? O J S u b u b

?

I xu u, x

k

b ? I b b

J u ub

b ? (A .) A, ’ J C.

B W L z u ?

T xu I u b

ub 85.

I J S u xu

, u

u ?

W b

b k u

u u?

W x LDS

k O P J F. S? W xu -u uu u? (A

u u

xu ’ x.)

Polyandry was Universally Condemned

A qu xu (. 4-4, -) b

“u,”

“u b ” (4, ). A, Cu

b u ?

W k 85, “W u k

ub ?” B Yu , “T




k .” F Hb C. Kb

u, “T b u Px b— b

k—& b.” T O P

u: “G b, Bb, u

ub, .” P

u x:

“C ub ? N: Su

b u. T bj u

, G. A

ub u ,

, u; ,

u, bb, u

, u

. A u ub, u

, u

u.”4

B M P 854: “‘W u

ub5 u ?’ I :

G u

ub….” O Ob 8, 89, A G A. S

u “ u hbd .” H ,

Bb S, k 89 u “b

u ub

B Yu, J D, :, Auu , 85.

M h A T Chh J Ch L-dy S,1835-1893 (S Lk C: P Pub [S-P Fu], ),

; 57.

O P, J D, 8:55-5, Ju , 875.

4 O P, “C M,” T S , /4 (A 85): .

5 B M P, “D P: B L U,

L H S N H,” M S , (Ju 9, 854): 47.

G Ab S, J D, :4, Ob 8, 89,

.




….” S : “I k u.”7

A u Nu , uub J S’

. F P Cu J

F. S 889: “P , ,

, u . I

Bb, b G u

‘M’ u .”8 EJ F S 95: “P,

u ub

Cu Ju C L- S U

.”9

Te New and Everlasting Covenant of Marriage Supersedes

All Other Marriage Covenants

A u

J S xu k

D&C : u

b “ .” H u

, “ ”

( D&C :4). S u

ub u x xu ,

J S’ . G bk

ub u b u bu

Cu, .

7 Bb S, , L , ’

( ), 47, qu 4.

8 J F. S Z H. Gu, Ju 9, 889, CHL. R E.

u, J. Sd C h Ahv T Chh J Ch

L-dy S, (P, U: BYU P), . , DVD #9.

9 J F S, Bd A d h Og P

Mg (S Lk C: D N, 95), 48.




“Eternity Only” Sealings Did Occur

J 4 ub.

Su bu 4

u. C

u, “ ”

Nu. T , k Ru V S, ub

-b, b

, . S J S “ ” u A

J’ u Cu H

Lb.

O 4 , I b

u : “ ” . T “ ,”

bb u xu J. (S

A W S S)

ub,

b ub qu.

I J’




, M H,

u.

Why Were Women Eternally Sealed to Joseph Instead of the

Legal Husbands?

T qu u b

J S u? I ,

ub b bu

M. H, u L- S. E ,

. Lu Wk b

P’ u: “A u ,

u b .”4 T k

u u

. H, u b u J b .

N , k

bu J

S .

No Evidence that Joseph Smith Forced Any Woman to

Marry HimS J S

u, bu

u b b . O u -

M u J S

4 u u b u f .4

4 Lu Wk Kb, “A B B Sk L Lb Lu Wk Kb S,” CHL; qu L O L,

R L-dy S: Gvg A Mh Idvd

Sfg Edd Rg C (L, U: U Ju C,

888), 4.

4 S x G D. S, ”T F S Nu

C M,” J M Hy , /4 (F ):57. B

qu Lu Wk’ u, G D. S k

J u u -u




T k, bu b u u

u u Lu Wk u .J u Lu 84. S

, bu z

. S : “I u b

u u b. O u

k , I …. O, b

u . A u I u. T

P . H u I ….”4

F, A , 84, J u k

, u u: “I

f. I G u. I u u

. I u j

b u.” H Lu

? N Nu , ub u k

u j J. I,

k u :

T u S . F

I b , k

…. I b , bu

u u : “Au u

G u u u k

, u I k G

u. I u . I bu

, ,” b

k ubj. E u .4

u uu , b

.

4 L, R L-dy S, 4;

A J, ”Pu M,” H R (Ju 887):9-.

4 L, R L-dy S, 4-48; ;

J, “Pu M”:9-.




Lu buf. S qu

b . T u J

u :

S I, “T G

B I

H u H .” H k

, u b buu x u, : “G

A b u. Yu

G u; u

. I u b. I b

j u k.”44

S J’ u :

O u I u

I k G .

A I k u

k u .

F I , L

G .45

A b bu J S,

bu ub, J C. B’

J u u

u .4 W k u

44 L, R L-dy S, 4-48;

J, “Pu M”: 9-.

45 U “T b Ju D. H. M

S. G, U…” V P. C C, M Lb,

U U, MS 5, bx , 5.

4 S x B, T Hy h S, (S P)

5 (W Fu).




P’ u .47 A x

. T k bu ( ) .

S Kb – ub b

b. S :

I k . H k

, “W u

? G qu u, u b b b.”

H , “I u, u

k u G , u b

.”48

I u S P N R u

J S ,

. H,

P R

, u qu “

b b b.”

I u, J

xu ux u b

(-) Vu . Fu, u

b u u

u u b b u b

P. Pu J

47 B S G Kb, u E J (BjF. J, My L’ Rvw, M: Cu P, .,. 85.), L M

(S, . A I Ch, .), C C. M (Aub,

, HBLL, BYU, 4.) R R. I G (qu R W

Wk, “R R. G: T Cu L F I,”

Sg S: L S Nh-Cy M, D Q.

C, D J. Wk, . [P, U: B Yu U

Ru Su C, 985], .)

48 A J, “Pu M,” H Rd , .




ub u, bu b

u .

Conclusion

G B Jh Sh’

Pygy: Hy d Tgy . W qu

Su, k .

H, k b b

k qu x. I

G bu

u . S :

. C u A J

ub , u

u (bk

). R

A J ,

u J S’ .

. C k u

u u J S 5 ,u C’ “b ”

b G D. S (Ax

B).

. C k u

J S

(Vu , C 8).4. C k u xu

u buu

(Ax E).

5. C 9 u

F A— b u

(Ax D).




. C u b

k J S, k (Vu , C ).

7. C x

89 L ub .

8. C - u J S

b u , u

b , u -M

u. I ub

u (Vu ).

9. Iu uu bb. T

bb Vu ,

u ub

b.

. Iu x ub- u .

O

u. C Bu bk “

u b u

J S’ Nu”49 L F

u “-bk b…u [] u

b x .”

C u “k

M .”5

Ob b G B’

J S z, x f

F A xu ,

b u u

49 C L. Bu, ”F Tu J S’ P b B

H,” Wd Wh Ed: A M Sd Rdb, M 4, ,

://.u./u-j---b-/

( Auu , ).

5 H, Jh Sh’ Pygy , u jk.




k b . N,

u b b u u . I

, ,

k u

uzz u u u u

.

B C. H, h h x bk dg wh ygy,

y h h-v, J S’ P:

H T (Gg Kfd Bk, 2013). H M

P M Fu: T G

M vd h “B Bk 2007 Awd”

h Jh Wh H A. H h d

g d y d bhd TJu M H, M H Su , d

Du w bg h T P

P . B wk hg h Dv

H d Md C Ly, Uh, d h vd

h Pd h Uh Md A.

Stretching to Find the Negative: Gary Bergera’s Review of Joseph Smith’s Polygamy: History and...

Documents

Transcript of Stretching to Find the Negative: Gary Bergera’s Review of Joseph Smith’s Polygamy: History and...