Story Lines and Myths in 20 th Century Immigration Historiography
description
Transcript of Story Lines and Myths in 20 th Century Immigration Historiography
Story Lines and Myths in 20th Century Immigration Historiography
Opening Comments – Where are the immigrants?
• Scholarship and autobiography
• John Higham, STRANGERS IN THE LAND
• Mark I Choate, EMIGRANT NATION; THE MAKING OF ITALY ABROAD
• African Americans
Pre 1790|1790|1820|1880|19
Colonial Period
Early National Period
Middle 19th Century
Immigration High Tide The “New Immigrants”
Mid 20th Century
Late 20th Century
The General Theory – Push/PullPush
Pull
The Mudsill Myth – “La Miseria”
• Difficulties in discerning differences between those who left and those who stayed behind
• Emigration is a positively selective process• Motives for emigrating– Advancing the family economy– Avoiding conscription or jail
• Social strata of repatriates – Benestante, Americani, and new Americani
Social Stratification in Franza – 1900 & 1960
Joseph Lopreato, Peasants No More: Social Class and Social Change in an Underdeveloped Society (1967)
The fallacy of using schooling as a measure of an immigrant’s worth
• Schooling in 19th and early 20th century Italy and America– The significance of this for assessing the character
and resources of emigrants?– In the U.S. the Common School provided 6 to 8
years of instruction to students– In Italy village schools offered 3 years [at best]
American Responses to Immigration
• Open Door– Motivations• Humanitarian• Economic
• Restriction – Motivations• Economic• Nativist
History of Nativism
A Case Study of Pull Immigration The Tirocchi of Providence, RI
A Classic Chain Migration
Origins - Guarcino
Madame Tirocchi{Anna}
Madame Tirocchi her Butler Exchange Shop – “A & L Tirocchi” ca 1911
M. Tirocchi with Shop Girls
The new home of “Tirocchi Gowns”514 Broadway - 1915
Laura Tirocchi-Cella and Dr. Cella
Eugenia Tirocchi – Grocerier and Landlord
The Tirocchi Men
Frank Tirocchi – padrone, pharmacy clerk, trucker
Tirocchi Cousins – sand and gravel merchants, concrete block
manufactures, construction contractors, tire recapping plant, auto service stations, dairy plant
and home delivery service, commercial laundry, etc.
Federico – missionary, parish priest
Ellis Island – The symbol
• 1982 – 1924 – 20+ Million immigrants pass through
Ellis Island– Peak year – 1907 – 1,004,756 pass
through the station– 560, 971 enter in 1921– 1921 Quota Law set nationality limits
for each nationality to 3% of their number in the 1910 U. S. population and total annual limit of 358,000
– 1924 Quota Law moved the “reference date” to 1890 and reduced annual quota to 164,000
The Ellis Island Myth – “our name was changed by officials at Ellis Island”
• Time spent and nature of the processing of immigrants at Ellis Island– Ship
passenger lists– Eligibility
screening– The “six
second physical”
– Utility of the Myth
Americanization/Assimilation - Theories
• Racial implications of the “new immigrant” concept
• Red Scare and the intensity of Americanization efforts
Melting Pot or Salad bowl
The Melting Pot at Ford
Immigrants’ responses to assimilation
• Family economic strategies –Old or new world locus •Schooling for children•Economic choices •Language and citizenship decisions – “language loyalty”
The Myth of the Marginal Man
Americanization – Institutions
• Schools• Settlement Houses• Industry• Public Libraries• Religion• Ethnic Press
George F. Johnson and the Square Deal• New employees at Endicott Johnson
were given a copy of a pamphlet called "An EJ Worker's First Lesson in the Square Deal."
• It read, in part:• "To the new EJ worker: You have
now joined the happy family in the square deal. If you are faithful, loyal, and reliable, you will earn a good living under fair conditions. You are indeed a part of the company. Remember that you are cared for when sick, medical and hospital services are yours, privileges of many kinds are yours. Your friend, George F. Johnson."
Religion
• The American “Irish” Church and Immigrants• “National Parishes”– Protestant evangelicals – Italians– Trusteeism – Other Roman Catholic groups – “The Polish National
Catholic Church -1897”• Ownership of Church property• Parish government in secular matters by parishioners• Parishioner authority in assignment of Priests• Appointment of Polish Bishops in the U.S. – participation of
clergy and Laity
Schools – Public and Parochial
Chazy Central Rural School
Home Economics
Physical Education
Industrial Education
Adult Education