Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple...

14
Štefan Olejník Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave- Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave- functional functional in 2+1 dimensions from gauge invariance in 2+1 dimensions from gauge invariance J. Greensite, ŠO: Confinement from gauge invariance in 2+1 dimensions, archive/0609nnn (to appear probably this week). [Topic announced in the program can be found in: J. Greensite, ŠO: PR D74 (2006) 014502, hep-lat/0603024.]

Transcript of Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple...

Page 1: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

Štefan OlejníkŠtefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional functional

in 2+1 dimensions from gauge invariancein 2+1 dimensions from gauge invariance

• J. Greensite, ŠO: Confinement from gauge invariance in 2+1 dimensions, archive/0609nnn (to appear probably this week).

[Topic announced in the program can be found in: J. Greensite, ŠO: PR D74 (2006) 014502, hep-lat/0603024.]

Page 2: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

2QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

IntroductionIntroduction

Confinement is the property of the vacuum of quantized non-abelian gauge theories. In the hamiltonian formulation in D=d+1 dimensions and temporal gauge:

Strong-coupling lattice-gauge theory – systematic expansion:

Greensite (1980)

Page 3: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

3QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

At large distance scales one expects:

Greensite (1979)Greensite, Iwasaki (1989)Karabali, Kim, Nair (1998)

Property of dimensional reduction: Computation of a spacelike loop in d+1 dimensions reduces to the calculation of a Wilson loop in Yang-Mills theory in d Euclidean dimensions.

Page 4: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

4QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

At weak couplings, one would like to similarly expand:

For g!0 one has simply:

Wheeler (1962)

Page 5: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

5QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

A possibility to enforce gauge invariance:

No handle on how to choose f’s.

Page 6: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

6QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

SuggestionSuggestion

Building blocks of a systematic expansion: covariant derivatives and covariant Green’s functions of local operators. Then the choice of Q0 is essentially unique:

If the kernel is of finite range, one would have far enough:

Page 7: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

7QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Self-consistency check in 2+1 dimensionsSelf-consistency check in 2+1 dimensions

In 2 dimensions there is no Bianchi identity; the field-strength correlation length can only arise from a non-zero range of the vacuum kernel. The range of the vacuum kernel determines the correlation length of vacuum fluctuations, but vacuum fluctuations determine the range of the kernel.Take a vacuum fluctuation typical for massless free field theory:

Page 8: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

8QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Compute:

Page 9: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

9QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Result:

The kernel is finite range, in any stochastic background. The vacuum functional has the dimensional-reduction form, therefore it is confining!

Page 10: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

10QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Possible explanationPossible explanation

The result – at first sight rather surprising – may have a natural explanation.Weak (Anderson) localization: Consider a non-relativistic particle moving in a stochastic potential in one and two dimensions. Eigenstates of the corresponding hamiltonian are all localized, no matter how the weak the stochastic potential may be. Then the inverse operator to the hamiltonian has a finite range.Our covariant laplacian is fully analogous to the Anderson hamiltonian.

Page 11: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

11QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

How far is the simple vacuum from the true How far is the simple vacuum from the true one?one?

Estimate of the glueball mass: compute the range of the kernel in true vacuum configurations from MC simulations of lattice YM theory in D=3 – estimate glueball mass as inverse of the kernel range.

Meyer, Teper (2003)

Page 12: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

12QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Consistent with

Page 13: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

13QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

Conclusions and open questionsConclusions and open questions

We have proposed a simple approximate form of the confining YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions. Essential ingredients:

known g=0 limit, gauge invariance, and(probably) the phenomenon of weak localization.

This cannot be the whole story – with the simple wave-functional one would expect Casimir scaling of higher-representation asymptotic string tensions, while asymptotic string tensions should in fact depend only on the N-ality of representations. The simple zeroth-order state is clearly missing the center-vortex or domain structure which has to dominate the vacuum at sufficiently large scales.Hope for 3+1 dimensions: Adjoint covariant laplacian has an interval of localized states also in D=4 Euclidean dimensions, so the relevant kernel in the vacuum wave-functional may again be of finite range. We should have some answer in the near future, though the task is numerically much more challenging.

Greensite, Kovalenko, Polikarpov, Syritsyn, Zakharov, ŠO, hep-lat/0606008

No obvious method for systematic improvement.

Page 14: Štefan Olejník Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia Simple (approximate) YM vacuum wave-functional in 2+1 dimensions.

ŠOŠO Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Institute of Physics, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, SlovakiaSciences, Bratislava, Slovakia

14QCD: Facts and Prospects, OberwQCD: Facts and Prospects, Oberwölzölz, Austria, September 12, 2005, Austria, September 12, 2005

DimensionsDimensions