Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP...
Transcript of Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP...
![Page 1: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Status of ITER Neutronicsand CAD/MCNP
Development
Mohamed Sawanfor UW-Madison Team
Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL),Greg Sviatoslavsky, Brian Kiedrowski
FusionTechnologyInstitute
ITER TBM MeetingUCLA
May 10-11 2006
![Page 2: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
2
• ITER first magnetic fusion facilitywhich:
– will produce significant fusion power– requires nuclear licensing
• According to French regulation ITER– will be classified as a nuclear Installation
called “Installation Nucléaire de Base”(INB) due to the expected tritiuminventory and waste generation during thelifetime of ITER
• The aim of ITER Organization is to:– construct and operate such first-of-a-kind
nuclear installation satisfying the demandsand interests of the user community and offunding partners
Neutronic Analysis Service for ITER
![Page 3: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
3
• Extensive neutronics calculations and analyses in ITER are required to– ensure that existing, modified, or proposed structure, system, or component
designs will meet technical and functional requirements– demonstrate capability of safe operation– assess maintaining, repairing, replacing or modifying components– provide required baseline for access, repository and waste management of
components
• Neutronics calculations and analyses shall conform to the ITERManagement and Quality Program (MQP) that establishes the overallframework for the execution of the ITER Project
• This implies the availability of:– Adequate modelling tools which would reduce turnaround time between CAD-
based design and design changes and analysis.– Well documented QA procedures for neutronic work.– Database system
Role of Neutronic Analyses in ITER
![Page 4: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
4
US Neutronics Support Areas:Global model, diagnostics, TBM, FW/shield
![Page 5: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
5
Previous Work on CAD Interfacewith 3D Neutronics
• Translation-based approaches– Tsige-Tamirat et al., FZK– Manson, Raytheon– Van Riper, White Rock Science– Wu et al., Hefei, China+ Speed– Setup effort
• Direct CAD evaluation– Franke et. al, SNL+ Setup effort– Speed
![Page 6: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
6
CAD-Based MCNP(X)• Use Common Geometry Module (CGM) to
interface MCNPX directly to CAD & othergeometry data– Previous efforts found CAD-based ray
tracing to be too slow (20-50x)– Implement ray-tracing approximations in CGM to reduce
calls to exact CAD function
• Benefits:– Dramatically reduce turnaround time
from CAD-based design changes– No translation to MC geometry representation
• Removes limitation on surface types• Improves robustness by using same engine for CAD and MCNP
– Can handle 3D models not supported in MCNP
CGMCAD Voxels
MCNPX
MCNPXNative
Geometry (Other)
![Page 7: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
7
MCNPX/CGM Example ARIES CompactStellerator
• High-degree NURBS geometry from curves/surfacesfit to Fourier series
IB
OB
θT
IB OB
θT
![Page 8: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
8
CPU Time vs. MCNPX
• MCNPX – original code• BB – Axis-oriented bounding box• OBB – Oriented bounding box
• Sorted BB – Grid-sorted BB• Dist limit – transport distance-limited• Facet-only: No ACIS ray intersection
– (less accurate, MUCH faster)
3cyls
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
MCNPX
BB
Sor
t BB
Sor
t BB, d
ist lm
t
Sor
t OBB
Sor
t OBB, d
ist lm
t
OBB, F
acet
-only
Tim
e F
ac
tor
Cobalt
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
MCNPX
BB
Sor
t BB
Sor
t BB, d
ist lm
t
Sor
t OBB
Sor
t OBB, d
ist lm
t
OBB, F
acet
-only
Tim
e F
ac
tor
4.3 3.0!
23.5 12.3!
+
![Page 9: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
9
CAD PROCESSINGCAD PROCESSINGCATIA
file
CATIA STEPfile
CUBIT
ACISfile
MCNPX/CGM
translation
data preparation:
model &analysis
“imprint” surfaces “merge” mating
surfaces
![Page 10: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
10
Imprint & Merge ProcessImprint & Merge Process
Volume A
Volume B
Volume A
Volume B
1. PRIOR to Imprint, top of Volume Bmade up of one surface
2. Following IMPRINT, top of Volume Bmade up of three surfaces
3. Following MERGE, top of Volume B made up of twosurfaces plus one surface shared with Volume A
![Page 11: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
11
CAD Issues Requiring CAD Issues Requiring ““RepairRepair””
• Overlapping Volumes (i.e.: clashes)• Mating surfaces not contacting• Slight “Misalignment”
– Imprint generates ultra thin surfaces– Doesn’t always require repair
Complex Surface Definition
![Page 12: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
12
Examples of Typical CAD IssuesExamples of Typical CAD Issuesand Typical Repairsand Typical Repairs
![Page 13: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
13
Action - Volumes trimmed to contact only
Overlapping VolumesOverlapping VolumesIssue – Overlapping Volumes
![Page 14: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
14
Action – Edit geometry toestablish proper contact
Mating Surfaces Not ContactingMating Surfaces Not Contacting
Issue – No Contact
![Page 15: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
15
Action – Edit geometry to correct misalignment
MisalignmentMisalignmentIssue – misalignment … … causes imprint difficulty
and therefore no merge
![Page 16: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
16
Action – MAY require recreating volume
Edges cross at this point
Action – MAY require recreating volume
Issue – Slight Edge Misalignment
MisalignmentMisalignment
Edges cross at this point
![Page 17: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
17
Complex Surface DefinitionComplex Surface Definition
Action – Recreategeometry and/or“Unify” neighboringvolumes into a singlevolume.
Issue – definition ofneighboring complexsurfaces differ slightly,preventing surfacesfrom merging
![Page 18: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
18
Complex Surfaces & MisalignmentComplex Surfaces & MisalignmentIssue – Misalignment
along curvedsurfaces
![Page 19: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
19
Distribution of Repair EffortsDistribution of Repair Efforts
40%40%MisalignmentMisalignment
50% Complex50% ComplexSurfaceSurfaceDefinitionDefinition
10% Overlapping Volumes10% Overlapping Volumes& Non-contact& Non-contact
![Page 20: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
20
Improving the ProcessImproving the Process
➤Direct Link to CATIA (or appropriate modeler)data – eliminating possible translation issues
➤Work with original ITER data – simplificationprocess may have introduced errors
➤Tighten design process to minimize “designer-introduced” issues
➤Leverage prior work via configuration control -allowing future model revisions to address onlythose area that have changed
![Page 21: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
21
MCNP(X)-CGMDevelopment Plan & Progress
• Upgrade to newest versions of MCNP(X)• Upgrade to MCNPX v2.5.0 complete
– MCNP compatibility enhancement• Forced collision variance reduction• Reflecting boundary conditions• Surface flux tally
– Features added• Elimination of fatal errors from cell and surface definitions• Elimination of surface definitions entirely• Ability to define reflecting boundary conditions in CAD geometry
file
![Page 22: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
22
MCNP(X) Compatibility
• Geometry– Cell volume/Surface areas – functional– Boundary conditions
• Specular reflection – functional• White reflection – functional• Periodic – near term
– Lattice/universe – long term• Source
– Fixed source – functional– Fission source – testing– Surface source write/read – long term
![Page 23: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
23
MCNP(X) Compatibility
• Variance Reduction– Cell importance – functional– Exponential transform – functional– Forced collision – functional– Weight windows (cell-based) – testing– Weight windows (mesh-based) – functional– Detector tallies - functional
![Page 24: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
24
MCNP(X) Compatibility
• Tallies– Surface current (type 1) – functional
• Cosine bins – functional (directional ambiguity)– Surface flux (type 2) – functional– Cell flux (type 4,6,7) – functional– Pulse height (type 8) – testing– Point detector (type 5) – functional– Mesh tallies – functional in MCNPX
• Note: MCNP and MCNPX have different mesh tally implementations– Cell flagging – functional– Surface flagging – functional– Multipliers – functional– Segmenting – long term ??
![Page 25: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
25
CGM-related Enhancements
• CAD/Cubit definition of materials – near term
• CAD/Cubit definition of tallies – long term
• Further geometry-based performanceenhancements
![Page 26: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
26
ITER Model
• “Simplified” ITERbenchmark model
• 40° toroidalsegment
• Source definedon 40x40 R-Z grid
• 774 volumes• 18116 surfaces
![Page 27: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
27
Source Characterization
![Page 28: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
28
Neutron Wall Loading
![Page 29: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
29
Neutron Wall LoadingNormalization = 1.97 x 1019 n/s in 40o segment
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750
Poloidal Distance (cm)
Ne
utr
on
Wa
ll L
oa
din
g (
MW
/m2)
O/BI/B
![Page 30: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
30
F2: Surface flux tally
F4: Cell flux tally
F2: Surface flux tally
F4: Cell flux tally
Divertor Tallies
![Page 31: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
31
Radial flux profile behind dummy port plug
Tally spheres behindport plug
![Page 32: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
32
Nuclear heating in IB Leg of TF Coil
Preliminary19 calculations of 2.6Mparticles (36 hours)2.2 kW total
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Nuclear Heating (kW)
TOP
BOTTOM
![Page 33: Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP …2006/05/11 · Status of ITER Neutronics and CAD/MCNP Development Mohamed Sawan for UW-Madison Team Paul Wilson, Tim Tautges (SNL), Greg](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050608/5faeed58dda28079f84f6d49/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
M. Sawan ITER TBM MeetingMay 10-11, 2006
33
International meeting on ITER neutronics willbe held in Madison July 24-26, 2006
• Review progress of the various CAD/MCNP approachesbeing developed by the various ITER Participant Teams
–The results of the ITER benchmark exercise will be presented anddiscussed
–Determine advantage/shortcomings of various approaches and theprospect for application to ITER analyses
• Check the status of ongoing validation of the code ATTILAagainst results of fusion experiments and its evaluation ingeneral as a tool to complement MCNP calculations
• Discuss QA procedures for neutronics analyses beingdeveloped and implemented in ITER