STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ......

11
STATUS OF 6X6X6 m 3 LEM PRODUCTION AND QA/QC PREPARATION FOR ANODE PROCUREMENT BY CEA/IRFU A. Delbart, Ph. Cotte, M. Karolak, E. Mazzucato,Y. Pénichot, Y. Piret, M.Zito (Irfu) LEM n° 30/17 A011 RIM 40 μm 0,50 mm WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19 th 2018

Transcript of STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ......

Page 1: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

STATUS OF 6X6X6 m3

LEM PRODUCTION AND QA/QCPREPARATION FOR ANODE PROCUREMENT

BY CEA/IRFU

A. Delbart, Ph. Cotte, M. Karolak, E. Mazzucato,Y. Pénichot, Y. Piret,

M.Zito (Irfu)

LEM n° 30/17 A011

RIM

40 µm0,50 mm

WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th 2018

Page 2: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

THE 3 LEM DESIGNS

« conservative » design CFR-35

86% active area

96% active area

CFR-34 design(42 LEM produced)

CFR-36 « alternative » design CFR-35 conservative design

85% active area

92% active area

LEMdesign %Activearea FR4 copperguardring FR4ringF copperguardringF FR4ringF copperguardringFCFR-34 96.2 2mm 2mm 4.2mm 6mm 10mm 12mmCFR-35 85.8 10mm 5mm 10mm 20mm 10mm 20mmCFR-36 92.1 2mm 5mm 10mm 20mm 10mm 20mm

LEMborders Screwholes HVconnections

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

2 prototypes will be deliverednext week at Saclay

Same stability as CFR-35 ?

On-going production of 36 LEMs

Increaded margin for stable operation at

3200-3400 V

40+2 LEMs producedQualified w/o anode at

3200 V(10 mn w/o spark)

But unstable operation at > 3200 V with anode

2/10

Page 3: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

CFR-34 VS CFR-35 PROTOTYPESGAIN MEASUREMENTS IN PURE ARGONAT 3.3 BAR

3/10

CFR-34

CFR-35

CFR-34 max HV3200 V CFR-35 max HV

3550 V

@3200 V: CFR-34 barely maintains HV (few minutes) + Anode CFR-35 #1 was operated during 24h with 30 sparks

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

Page 4: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

STATUS OF THE STUDY OF THE SPARKLOCALIZATION IN 3.3 BAR ARGON

Thewideanglewebcamisoperational.Thetwopre-seriesLEMsCFR-34A001&&A002+anode+driftelectricfield wereoperatedatDV>3200Vwithacontinuousvideorecordingofsparks.Analysiswasdonebya“manual”(tedious!)scanofthecamerarecordingswiththehelpofthetimestampstakenfromtheLEMcurrentmonitoringLabview files.

ThefreewareVideoSurveillancesoftwareContaCam iscurrentlytestedtodetectandselectivelyrecordthesparkingeventsandeasethedataanalysis.

4/10Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

NextstepisthestudyofsparklocalizationwithCFR-35andCFR-36.

SparksaremoreoftenobservedclosetothebordersandcornersandnotparticularlyinthevicinityoftheLEM-Anodespacers,norHVconnections.

Sparksoccuring closetocornersandbordersoftentriggersequencesofsparksevery10-30secondsduringupto2-3minutesinthevicinityoftheoriginalspark,sometimesleadingtothetripofthepowersupply (settodosoiftheLEMcurrentisabove2µs for50s).Thisdoesnothappenforsparkslocalizedawayfromborders.

Page 5: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

SPARK LOCALIZATION ON CFR-34 A001@ 3,3 BAR, DVLEM=3500 V, 2 HOURS

5/10

32 sparks : 7 (22%) close to borders, 12 (37%) randomly spread on the LEM active area13 (41%) close to 2 corners with 3 short sequences of 3 & one of 4 consecutive sparks

7 sparks

6 sparks

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

4 (border)+2 sparksat 3450V sparks

Page 6: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

SPARK LOCALIZATION ON CFR-34 A002@ 3,3 BAR, DVLEM=3300-3500 V, 3H20 MN

6/10

67 sparks : 24 (36%) close to borders (with 15 in bottom right), 41 (61%) randomlyspread on the LEM active area (with 20 in bottom right) and 2 (3%) in bottom right corner

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

1 spark

15 sparks

2 sparks

4 sparks

1 spark

1 spark

2 sparks

Page 7: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

LEM PRODUCTION STATUS

42CFR-34designLEMSweredelivered(2pre-seriesLEMsincluded).37+2passedtheQA/QCtestsinsyntheticairand5.7Argon@3.3barabsolutepressure.ELTOShas38rawPanasonicFR4R-1566Wsheetsfortheremaining36LEMproductionof

CEAcontractandorderedanewbatchof68panelsexpectedfordeliveryendofjanuary.Productionwasresumedfor36CFR-35designLEMstobedeliveredbyendoffebruary.

Batch#8(LEMA005-A050)will be delivered next week.ELTOSsenthisquotationtoCERNforaproductionof36moreLEMs.Conditionsarethe

sameastheonesofCEAcontractwithaproductionrateof6LEMsperweek.TheHPvessel could be filled with upto9LEMs with amodificationoftheLEMs assembly.

We will receive next week themechanical partstotestthis newsetup.

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018 7/10

A.Delbart(CEA)/S.Mazzi(ELTOS)lastupdatedate 15December2017 byS.Mazzi

Batch# LEMS/N shipmenttoCEA ELTOSQA/QC QA/ACatsaclay delivered qualified QA/QCcommentscomments0 A001-A002 23June2017 26June2017 passed(08/04/2017) 2 2 A002needed2cleaning-drying-HVQC1 A003-A008 02August2017 04August2017 6LEMsOK 6 6 A003,A006A008neededsecondcleaning-drying-HVQC

2 A009-A014 scheduled28august 28August2017 6LEMsOK 6 6A009repairedbyELTOS.Global"drop"of"visual"qualityA011,A012neededsecondcleaning-drying-HVQC

3 A015-A020 11September2017 5LEMs11/09/2017 5LEMsOK 5 5 "visualquality"isgood.A016needed2HVQA/QC4 A021-A026 11September2017 5LEMs11/09/17&1/11/17 4LEMsOK 5 4 "visualquality"isgood.5 A027-A032 19September2017 6LEMson19/09 6LEMsOK 6 66 A033-A038 19September2017 5LEMson19/09 6LEMsOK 6 6 A037:agolddepositonaborder/A038:asuspiciousmark7 A039-A044 07November2017 6LEMson07/11 6LEMsOK 6 4

8 A045-A050 scheduled15January2018 delaytojanuary22 69 A051-A056 scheduled22January2018 610 A057-A068 scheduled29January2018 1211 A069-A080 scheduled05February2018 12

Total 78 39

ProductionPaused.Resumingoftheproductiondecidedondec14th2017withNEWgerberCFR-35(LEMA018&A025willnotbeproduced)

Page 8: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

PREPARATION FOR ANODE PROCUREMENTBY CEA/IRFU FOR 2 CRP

8/10

Anodegerber files(CERN-1359)werevalidatedinjune 2017fortheorderbyETHZof80anodestoELTOS.Technicalspecifications(gerber files,PCBstack,QA/QC)werefixedtocopewithbothELTOSandELVIArequirements.Q/CbythemanufacturerarestandardonesdrivenbytheIPCA-6002(includingA.O.Iandelectricalcontinuitymeasurements).Q/CofKELsolderingconnectionsisdonebyWA105thankstothetestbenchprovidedbyCEA/Irfu.

WeaddtwoQCrequeststothemanufacturers:measurementoftheanodedimensionswhichshouldbe499.5-0/+0.1mm:to

preventthecuttingofactivestripswhicharelocatedat60µmfromthebordersandtocopewiththemechanicaltolerancesoftheanodeintegrationontheCRP

measurementofthedeflectionoftheanodeinthecentertobelessthan1mm

Wehavethequotations(Anode+KELconnectorsoldering)ofbothELVIAandELTOS.Offersarewithin10%.Delaysare30-41workingdays(for40anodes).

WewillgetthequotationfromtheOUESTRONIC(France)companynextweek.

Weplantoplaceanorderfor40anodesbytheendofthemonthforadeliverybyendofapril.Asecondorderof40LEMswillbeplacedmidmarch.

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

Page 9: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

LEM THICKNESS MEASUREMENT

9/10

TotalLEMthicknessismeasuredonthe4cornersoftheLEMandon2metallographicsectionsbytheLEMmanufacturer.InordertocheckLEMthicknessuniformity,wearetuninganopticaltestbenchforthescanof25x3cm2 locationsovertheLEMsurface.

LEMisflattenedonanopticaltablewithastainlesssteelplate.TheopticalbeamreflectionsthroughtheLEMholes,ontheLEMtopcoppersurfaceandontheLEMtopFR4surfaceareusedtoderivethereferenceopticaltablesurfaceelevation,thetotalLEMthicknessandtheLEMtopcopperlayerthickness.FirsttestsweredonewithaLEMprototype.

Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

Scan through one hole of 3 cm2

LEMTotal thickness

LEM Top copperLayer thickness

Page 10: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

CONCLUSION & PERSPECTIVES

LEMproductionatELTOSwasresumedforanexpecteddeliveryof36CFR-35LEMsbytheendoffebruary.FirstbatchA0045-A050willbedeliverednextweek.

TheHPvesselisequippedwithacamera.Recordingofthesparkinglocationsinpureargon@3,3barfortwoCFR-34LEMsoperatedatDV=3400-3500Vwasdone.Sparksaremoreoftenobservedclosetothebordersandcorners.

LocalizationofsparksonCFR-35andCFR-36prototypeswillbedonethenext2weeksbeforetheresumingoftheQA/QCoftheWA105LEMs.

TheHigh-PressurevesselusedforQA/QCoftheLEMsinArgonat3.3barhasroomtoqualifyatowerof9LEMsinonerun.Thisupgradefrom6LEMswillbetestednextweekandshouldincreasetheQA/QCrateto9LEMsperweek.

WewillselectnextweekaPCBmanufacturertoplaceanorderfor40anodes(+KELconnectorsoldering)whichshouldbedeliveredbytheendofapril.

AnopticaltestbenchisunderdevelopmentforLEMthicknessmeasurementsandcouldbeusedtochecktheLEMthicknessuniformityofthenextproducedLEMs.

10/10Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

Page 11: STATUS OF 6X6X6 m LEMPRODUCTION AND QA/QC … · The two pre-series LEMs CFR-34 A001& & A002 + ... borders often trigger sequences of sparks every 10-30 seconds during up to 2-3 minutes

BACKUP : ON-GOING TEST WITH 55FE SOURCE

11/10Alain Delbart, Status of LEM production & QA/QC, WA105 TCn vidyo meeting, january 19th , 2018

Detection of a spark with ContaCam recording software (A001+anode+cathode+55Fe)

Reference position of the A001 LEM Setup with cathode and 55Fe

Automatic detection and recording of a spark The detected spark