Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and...

36
Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities Mark Chiappone, Steven Miller, Leanne Rutten Nova Southeastern University Oceanographic Center [email protected], 305-898-5390

Transcript of Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and...

Page 1: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities

Mark Chiappone, Steven Miller, Leanne Rutten

Nova Southeastern University Oceanographic Center

[email protected], 305-898-5390

Page 2: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

The Florida Keys Setting

Page 3: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Factors Affecting Florida Coral Reefs • Geography (continental influence, cold fronts)

• Tropical cyclones

• Climate-change drivers and responses:

– Coral bleaching (temperature and UV)

– Coral diseases

– Ocean acidification

• Coastal development (pollution/contamination)

• Urchin die-off (two events)

• Removal of wildlife

• Physical impacts (vessels, anchors, etc.)

• Non-native species (invasive exotics)

Page 4: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

The Future: Minimizing the Damage?

Page 5: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

The Everglades and Miami, 11/21/2008 Earth Snapshot http://www.eosnap.com/image-of-the-day/the-everglades-and-miami-florida-december-24th-2008/

The integrity of hydrologic and biologic components of Florida’s Southeast coast will ultimately depend upon achieving a sustainable

balance between ecosystem and human needs.

Page 6: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

South Florida’s historic and current watershed Sources: USDOI/USGS, USEPA, FDEP, Evergladesplan.org

Page 7: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Cuba, South of Florida and the Bahamas, 07/23/2011 Earth Snapshot http://www.eosnap.com/public/media/2011/07/cuba/20110714-cuba-full.jpg

The Florida Keys Ecosystem: Open and Connected

Page 8: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Diversity: A result of connectivity

Page 9: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Status and Trends: Reef and Hard-bottom The Past

Geologic and environmental contexts

“The past is the key to the present” (Ginsburg and Shinn)

The Present

What has been observed/documented?

What are we to make of present conditions?

Possible Futures

A few years?

A few decades?

End of the 21st century?

Page 10: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Depth to Pleistocene Bedrock Surface USDOI/USGS https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/2007/1751/professional-paper/bedrock-surface.html

Geologic History Influences the Present

Florida Keys Bedrock Surface Map USDOI/USGS https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/2007/1751/professional-paper/bedrock-surface.html

Page 11: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Depth to Pleistocene Bedrock Surface USDOI/USGS https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/2007/1751/professional-paper/bedrock-surface.html

The Past Influences the Present

Summary Illustration Index Map of the Florida Keys USDOI/USGS https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/2007/1751/professional-paper/figures/summary-illustration.html

Page 12: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Benthic Maps: The Early Version

Florida Reef Tract Marine Habitats and Ecosystems Marszalek (1977-82) c/o UF Map and Imagery Library http://ufdc.ufl.edu/UF00016788/00001/citation

Page 13: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Benthic Maps: The Latest Version

Florida Keys Benthic Ecosystems USDOI/USGS https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/2007/1751/professional-paper/benthic-ecosystems.html

Page 14: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Carysfort Light

Molasses Reef

Florida Keys Iconic Bank Reefs

The Elbow

Sombrero Key

Sand Key

Fowey Rocks

American Shoal Alligator Light

Tennessee Light

Page 15: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Reef Tract Marine Habitats and Ecosystems Marszalek (1977-82) c/o UF Map and Imagery Library http://ufdc.ufl.edu/UF00016788/00001/citation

Page 16: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Hard-bottom and Coral Reef Habitats

Page 17: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Status and Trends: Reef and Hard-bottom

The Past (deep and shallow time)

Geologic and environmental contexts

“The past is the key to the present.”

The Present

What has been observed/documented?

What are we to make of present conditions?

Possible Futures

A few years?

A few decades?

End of the 21st century?

Page 18: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

White Band Disease

Bleaching

Bleaching

Diadema Die-off

Gardner et al. 2003 c/o W. Precht

White Band Disease

Regional Caribbean Coral Reef Change

Page 19: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Regional Caribbean Coral Reef Change

Page 20: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Images courtesy of P. Dustan, University of Charleston

Page 21: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Images courtesy of P. Dustan, University of Charleston

Page 22: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,
Page 23: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Images courtesy of P. Dustan, College of Charleston

Page 24: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

CREMP Sampling Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary

Dry Tortugas National Park

Page 25: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Reefs in Recent History

Data from CREMP, USC, UG, UNCW, NSU

Page 26: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Upper Florida Keys Acropora Reefs

Grecian Rocks

N-N Dry Rocks Carysfort Reef

South Carysfort

Elbow Reef

Dry Rocks

French Reef

Sand Island

Molasses Reef

Page 27: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Corals (1999-2015)

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

No

. co

ral ta

xa p

er

tran

sect

(15 m

2)

Coral Species Richness

Patch reefsShallow hard-bottomHigh-relief spur and grooveDeeper fore reef

0.05.0

10.015.020.025.030.035.040.045.050.0

% C

over

Stony Coral Cover

Patch reefsShallow hard-bottomHigh-relief spur and grooveDeeper fore reef

Page 28: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

050,000,000

100,000,000150,000,000200,000,000250,000,000300,000,000350,000,000400,000,000450,000,000500,000,000

SSID PAST SMIC AAGR PPOR MCAV PFUR DSTK MFAV SRAD CNAT PDIV DSTR SBOU ODIF

Scleractinian Abundance: Top 15 speciesFlorida Keys 1999-2009 All Habitats

B B B B B B

050,000,000

100,000,000150,000,000200,000,000250,000,000300,000,000350,000,000400,000,000

SSID SRAD PAST AAGR SMIC PPOR MCAV DSTK PFUR FFRG SCOL DSTR MARE EFAS SBOU

Juvenile Scleractinian Abundance: Top 15 speciesFlorida Keys 1999-2009 All Habitats

85% 96% 98%

72% 88% 94%

Page 29: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Kissling (1964) Looe Key Fore Reef

NURC/UNCW (2012) Looe Key Fore Reef

Page 30: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Florida Keys Reefs of the Future?

The Past (deep and shallow time)

Geologic and environmental contexts

“The past is the key to the present.”

The Present

What has been observed/documented?

What are we to make of present conditions?

Possible Futures

A few years?

A few decades?

End of the 21st century?

Page 31: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Transformation from Corals to…

Re-transformation may not occur anytime soon. Coral larval supply, recruitment, and

post-settlement survivorship Algae, sponge, and octocoral

growth, fecundity, and allelopathic effects Microbiomes may also be altered.

Page 32: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Ajax Reef, Northern Reef Tract Reef framework may be collapsing (2015)

Page 33: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Projected Sea Level Rise 5 ft. by the year 2100 Sources: Climate Central, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, NOAA

Page 34: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Sea Level Rise Scenarios

Page 35: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

What can be done?

Page 36: Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard … · 2017. 7. 27. · Status and Trends in the Florida Keys: Coral Reef and Hard-bottom Communities . Mark Chiappone,

Balancing Human Enterprise and the

Ecosystem