State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

download State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

of 126

Transcript of State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    1/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m`

    Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    2/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    3/126

    _~d~gml

    ~fg

    G|cng`og

    Xg|cgq

    m`

    Wxhd`

    Fgdi~fd`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s

    Zxgzdxgnh2

    KceXdc`g)ZfN)XN

    Bmf`O_zg`og)ZfN

    Bmf`Ofwxof)ZfN)ED

    @mxed`nHmwi)ZfN

    Ic`nd_id~gx)EIc_

    BmsfEdxkm)EZF

    Kdx`Achhm`s)EZF

    GxcoFgezfcii)E_o

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    4/126

    ^fg|cgqsgvzxgssgnc`~fcsxgzmx~nm`m~`gogssdxcixgzxgsg`~~fg|cgqsml~fg

    Od`dncd`Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gmx~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`.

    Om`~g`~sml~fcszwhicod~cm`edhgxgzxmnwognc`qfmigmxc`zdx~zxm|cngn~fg

    c`~g`ngnwsgcslmx`m`omeegxocdizwxzmsgsd`nlwiidok`mqignageg`~csac|g`

    ~m~fg

    Od`dncd`

    C`s~c~w~g

    lmx

    Fgdi~f

    C`lmxed~cm`.

    Od`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`

    >37Xcofem`nXmdn

    _wc~gF&ZNL#

    8::6Od`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`

    Fmq~moc~g~fcsnmoweg`~2

    K.Xdc`g)B.O._zg`og)B.Ofwxof)@.Hmwi)I._id~gx)B.Edxkm)K.Achhm`sd`nG.Fgezfcii)

    _~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~fd`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s&M~~dqd2OCFC)8::6#.

    Og~~gzwhicod~cm`gs~dwsscncszm`chigg`lxd`dcssmwsig~c~xgGvdeg`ngi~d~ngszxgw|gsswxidsd`~g`ecicgwwxhdc`g~igzmcnssd`~.C_H@316477>

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    5/126

    ^dhig ml Om`~g`~s

    Dhmw~~fgOd`dncd`Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gcccDhmw~~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm` |Dok`mqignageg`~s |ccEdc`EgssdagsLxme_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~f

    d`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s cvGvgow~c|g_weedxLxme_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~f

    d`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s vcDhs~xdo~ v|4 Zxmbgo~Hdokaxmw`n4

    44 C`~xmnwo~cm`448 _~d~geg`~mlZwxzmsg44? Om`ogz~wdiLxdegqmxk4

    8 Eg~fmnmima 784 _s~ged~coIc~gxd~wxgXg|cgq7

    844 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxof_~xd~ga 7848 Ic~gxd~wxg^c~ig_od` Ic~gxd~wxgLwiiXg|cgq 1

    88 _~dkgfmingx_wx|g&C`lmxegnMzc`cm`#44? Xgswi~s 4?

    ?4 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxofd`nXg|cgqZxmogss 4??8 Nd~d2Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s 4?

    ?84 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxMhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4??88 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4>?8? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s47?8> ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`88??7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)

    Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`8??> Nd~d2ZfscodiDo~c|c~8>

    ?>4 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~8>?>8 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~8>?>? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m ZfscodiDo~c|c~ 87?>> ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~87?>7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~ 87?7 Nd~d2_gng`~dxHgfd|cmwx8

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    7/126

    Dhmw~ ~fg Od dncd` Zmzwid~cm` Fgdi~f C`c~cd~c|g

    ccc

    Dhmw~ ~fg Od`dncd` Zmzwid~cm` Fgdi~f C`c~cd~c|g

    ^fgOd`dncd Zmzwid~cm Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#)dzdx~ml~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~g

    lmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`&OCFC#)qdsoxgd~gnc`4333OZFCsecsscm`cs~qmlmin2

    ^mlms~gxdhg~~gxw`ngxs~d`nc`amlldo~mxs~fd~dllgo~~fgfgdi~fmlc`nc|cnwdisd`nomeew`c~cgs;d`n ^mom`~xchw~g~m~fgng|gimzeg`~mlzmicocgs~fd~xgnwogc`gtwc~cgsd`ncezxm|g

    ~fgfgdi~fd`nqgiihgc`amlOd`dncd`s

    Dsdkgdo~mxc`zmzwid~cm fgdi~f)OZFC2

    Zxm|cngsd`discsmlOd`dncd`d`nc`~gx`d~cm`dizmzwid~cm fgdi~fg|cng`og~mc`lmxezmicocgs~fd~cezxm|g~fgfgdi~fmlOd`dncd`s;

    Omeecsscm`sxgsgdxofd`nhwcinsxgsgdxofzdx~`gxsfczs~mg`fd`ogw`ngxs~d`nc`amlxgsgdxoflc`nc`asd`n~mzxmem~gd`discsmls~xd~gacgs~fd~cezxm|gzmzwid~cm fgdi~f;

    _`~fgscrgsg|cng`ogdhmw~zmicogvzgxcg`ogs)d`dirgsg|cng`ogm`~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlzmicoc`c~cd~c|gsd`nng|gimzszmicomz~cm`s;

    Qmxks~mcezxm|gzwhicok`mqignagd`nw`ngxs~d`nc`aml~fgng~gxec`d`~s~fd~dllgo~c`nc|cnwdid`nomeew`c~fgdi~fd`nqgiihgc`a;d`n

    Qmxksqc~fc`OCFC~mom`~xchw~g~mcezxm|geg`~sc`Od`dndsfgdi~fss~ged`n~fgfgdi~fmlOd`dncd`s

    Lmxemxgc`lmxed~cm`m`OZFCd`nc~szwhicod~cm`s)zigdsg|csc~2qqqocfcod-ozfc

    http://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphi
  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    8/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    9/126

    Dhmw~ ~fg Od dncd` C`s~c~w~g lmx Fgdi~f C`lmxed~cm`

    |

    Dhmw~ ~fg Od`dncd` C`s~c~w~g lmx Fgdi~f C`lmxed~cm`

    OCFComiigo~sd`nd`dirgsc`lmxed~cm`m`fgdi~fd`nfgdi~fodxgc`Od`dndd`nedkgsc~

    zwhicoid|dcidhigOd`dndslgngxdi)zxm|c`ocdid`n~gxxc~mxcdiam|gx`eg`~soxgd~gnOCFC

    dsd`m~lmxzxmlc~)c`ngzg`ng`~mxad`crd~cm`ngncod~gn~mlmxac`adomeem`dzzxmdof

    ~mOd`dncd`fgdi~fc`lmxed~cm`OCFCsamdi2~mzxm|cng~cegi)doowxd~gd`nomezdxdhig

    c`lmxed~cm`OCFCsnd~dd`nxgzmx~sc`lmxefgdi~fzmicocgs)swzzmx~~fggllgo~c|gngic|gx

    mlfgdi~fsgx|cogsd`nxdcsgdqdxg`gssdem`aOd`dncd`sml~fgldo~mxs~fd~om`~xchw~g

    ~mammnfgdi~f

    Lmxemxgc`lmxed~cm`m`OCFCd`nc~szwhicod~cm`s)zigdsg|csc~2qqqocfcod

    http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/
  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    10/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    11/126

    Dok`mqignageg ~s

    |cc

    Dok`mqignageg`~s

    ^fcsxgzmx~qdsqxc~~g`hKceXdc`g)Bmf`O_zg`og)Bmf`Ofwxof)@mxed`nHmwi)

    Ic`nd_id~gx)BmsfEdxkm)Kdx`Achhm`sd`nGxcoFgezfcii^fgxgzmx~qdsomeecsscm`gn

    h~fgOd`dncd`Zmzwid~cm Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#ml~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~f

    C`lmxed~cm`&OCFC#

    C~sfmwinhg`m~gn~fd~~fgom`oiwscm`sc`~fgxgzmx~nm`m~`gogssdxcixgligo~~fmsg

    mlOZFCmxOCFC

    ^fcsxgzmx~qdszggxxg|cgqgn

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    12/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    13/126

    Edc` Egssdags Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    cv

    Edc` Egssdags Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq

    m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ^fcsxg|cgqxg|gdign~fd~g|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~d`nhgfd|cmwxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~

    Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~sLmxc`nc|cnwdis)dimqgxsmocmgom`mecos~d~ws&gnwod~cm`ig|gi)

    c`omeg)gezimeg`~#qdsml~g`dssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgnmhgsc~dem`ahm~fdnwi~s

    d`nofcinxg`Lmxc`s~d`og)imqgxzgxsm`dic`omegdllgo~sdllmxndhcic~mllmmn)qfcof

    ngem`s~xd~gs~fgems~om`scs~g`~c`liwg`ogm`lmmnom`swez~cm`_cecidxi)c`nc|cnwdis

    ic|c`ac`ecnnigc`omeg~mfcafc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgemxgickgi~mhgzfscodii

    do~c|g~fd`~fgcxomw`~gxzdx~sc`imqgxc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsImqgxc`omeg

    `gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgdismemxgickgi~mom`~dc`axgd~gxdoogss~msmwxogsmlg`gxang`sg

    lmmns&lmxgvdezig)lds~lmmns#d`nimqgxdoogss~mswzgxedxkg~smxm~fgxs~mxgss~mokc`a

    fgdi~flmmns

    Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~c`~gx|g`~cm`sdcegnd~cezxm|c`a~fgc`omegd`ngnwod~cm`di

    s~d~wsmlc`nc|cnwdisd`nldecicgsqc~fc`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sedfgizdnnxgssncszdxc~cgs

    c`mhgsc~Dism)cezxm|c`adoogss~mfgdi~flmmnsd`nxgoxgd~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgsc`imqgx

    c`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsedfgiz~moxgd~gdfgdi~fqgcaf~lxcg`nig`|cxm`eg`~

    _ofmmig`|cxm`eg`~Di~fmwafsofmmisdxg`m~szgoclco~mwxhd`dxgds)s~wncgslxme

    c`~gx|g`~cm`szgxlmxegnc sofmmis&lmxgvdezig)d|dcidhcic~mlfgdi~fofmcogsc`|g`nc`a

    edofc`gsmxzmc`~mlzwxofdsg`w~xc~cm`c`lmxed~cm`#sfmqgng|cng`oglmxcezxm|c`a

    gd~c`ahgfd|cmwxsDiis~wncgsfdnd~igds~smegzmsc~c|ggllgo~sm`lmmnc`~dkg)gc~fgx

    c`oxgdsc`afgdi~flmmnofmcogsmxngoxgdsc`aw`fgdi~fdi~gx`d~c|gs)~fmwaf`msofmmi

    c`~gx|g`~cm`ssca`clcod`~idllgo~gnhmnqgcaf~sFmqg|gx)c~sfmwinhg`m~gn~fd~smeg

    s~wncgs~fd~fd|gdssgssgn~fgcezdo~mlsofmmihdsgnzxmaxdesm`hmnqgcaf~sed

    `m~fd|ghgg`c`oiwngnc`~fcsxg|cgqhgodwsg~fgncn`m~szgocld`wxhd`sg~~c`a

    Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~omezxgfg`sc|gsofmmilmmnzmicocgsmxgnwod~cm`dic`~gx|g`~cm`s

    ~fd~zxmem~gfgdi~flmmnofmcogsdxgickgi~mfd|ghg`glcocdigllgo~sm`ofcinxg`s

    gd~c`afdhc~s

    Hwci~g`|cxm`eg`~^fgems~om`scs~g`~g`|cxm`eg`~didssmocd~cm`smhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi

    do~c|c~qgxggigeg`~sml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~Fdiiedxksmlqdikdhcic~&lmxgvdezig)

    c`oxgdsgnxgscng`~cding`sc~)ecvgnwsgrm`c`ad`ns~xgg~om``go~c|c~#d`ndoogss

    ~mxgoxgd~cm`dildocic~cgsdxgdssmocd~gnqc~ffgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sZgmzigszgxogz~cm`s

    ml~fgcxhwci~g`|cxm`eg`~dxgdismkg

    Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~qdikdhcic~ml`gcafhmwxfmmnsd`ndoogss~mxgoxgd~cm`di

    ldocic~cgsc`d`ndxmw`n`gcafhmwxfmmnseddsscs~c`zxmem~c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s

    Idokmlc`~gx|g`~cm g|cng`og\gxic~~igg|cng`oggvcs~slmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssml

    c`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`om`~gv~Emxgg|diwd~cm`sdxg

    `ggngn~m~dkgc`~mdoomw`~`d~wxdigvzgxceg`~sc`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s&lmxgvdezig)

    nmgs~fgzxmiclgxd~cm mlhcooigid`gsc`oxgdsgooic`a=#

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    14/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    15/126

    Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    vc

    Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og

    Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    Xd~cm`dig d`n Zwxzmsg

    ^fgxgid~cm`sfczhg~qgg`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nmhgsc~fdsxgogc|gnic~~igss~ged~co

    d~~g`~cm`Mwxzwxzmsgqds~mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrg~fgg|cng`ogm`2

    d# s~xwo~wxdid`nomeew`c~ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s~fd~zxmem~g

    mxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s;d`n

    h# ~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~wxhd`zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a

    fgdi~fqgcaf~s

    Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n c` ~fg Ic~gxd~wxg

    Qglmw`nzxmhdhigg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg gom`mecosg~~c`asd`nmhgsc~

    Lmxgvdezig)dimqgxc`nc|cnwdismocmgom`mecos~d~ws&_G_#qdsml~g`dssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgnmhgsc~dem`adnwi~sd`nofcinxg &zdag47#Imqgxzgxsm`dic`omegsdllgo~

    dllmxndhcic~mllmmn)d`ndllmxndhcic~fds~fgems~om`scs~g`~c`liwg`ogm lmmnom`swez~cm`

    C`dnnc~cm`)imqgx_G_c`nc|cnwdisxgzmx~emxghdxxcgxs~md`nigsszdx~coczd~cm c`

    zfscodido~c|c~

    Dsqds~fgodsgqc~fc`nc|cnwdifmwsgfmin_G_)`gcafhmwxfmmn_G_qdsdssmocd~gnqc~f

    hmnqgcaf~sLmxc`s~d`og)c`nc|cnwdisic|c`ac`ecnnig~mfcafc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmns

    dxgemxgickgi~mhgzfscodiido~c|g~fd`~fgcxomw`~gxzdx~sc`imqgxc`omeg

    `gcafhmwxfmmnsImqgxc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgdismemxgickgi~mom`~dc`axgd~gx

    doogss~msmwxogsmlg`gxang`sglmmns&lmxgvdezig)lds~lmmns#d`nimqgxdoogss

    ~mswzgxedxkg~smxm~fgxs~mxgss~mokc`afgdi~flmmns

    ^fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~qdslmw`n~mhgdzm~g`~cdisg~~c`almxc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mzxmem~g

    fgdi~fgd~c`adem`aofcinxg`Zxmaxdesqc~fc`~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)

    zxmem~cm`mlfgdi~flmmns)zxcogc`og`~c|gs#dxgag`gxdiidssmocd~gnqc~fd`c`oxgdsgn

    om`swez~cm`mlfgdi~fcgxlmmns&zdag8:#

    ^fgwxhd`hwci~g`|cxm`eg`~qdsdssmocd~gnqc~fhm~fzfscodido~c|c~d`nfgdi~f

    hmnqgcaf~s_~wncgsom`scs~g`~isfmq~fd~ldo~mxs~fd~zxmem~gmhgsc~&lmxgvdezig)

    wxhd`szxdqi)imqc`~gxsgo~cm ng`sc~)imqxgscng`~cding`sc~)imqid`nwsgecv#~g`n

    dism~mld|mwxsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwxd`nimqgxzfscodido~c|c~ig|gis&zdag46#Hgodwsg

    ems~ml~fgg|cng`ogxg|cgqgnqdsoxmsssgo~cm`di)~fcsswaags~s~fd~dswzzmx~c|gwxhd`

    zfscodisg~~c`aedhgdn|d`~dagmws)hw~zgxfdzsc`swllcocg`~hc~sgil~mfd|gdsca`clcod`~

    cezdo~m`mhgsc~

    Owi~wxgd`ng~f`coc~&smocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~#dismldo~mxgnc`~mmwxlc`nc`as

    Dnmz~cm`mldemxgQgs~gx`iclgs~igfdnzxgnmec`d`~i`gad~c|ggllgo~sm`lmmn)

    `w~xc~cm`d`nncg~dxfdhc~sLwx~fgxemxg)~fgemxgdoogz~c`aowi~wxgsqgxgmlodxs)

    ~fgigssickgi~fgqgxg~mhgzfscodiido~c|g

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    16/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    vcc

    Nwg~mdidokmlss~ged~cos~wncgsc`~fcsdxgd)|gxic~~igg|cng`ogqdslmw`n~mswzzmx~

    ~fgxmigmlzmicoc`zxmem~c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s

    _cecidx~m~fgidokmllc`nc`asc`~fgzmicodxgd)|gxic~~igg|cng`ogqdsd|dcidhiglmx

    ~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~

    Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n ^dikc`a Qc~f Gvzgx~s

    Daxmwzmld~~g`nggsmld`mhgsc~sezmscwefginc`8::7qgxgswx|ggndhmw~

    ~fggigeg`~sml~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~~fd~om`~xchw~g~mfgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sEms~

    xgszm`ng`~slgi~~fd~~fgemxgceegncd~ghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)hckg~xdcis)

    qdikc`azd~fs#fdsdaxgd~gxcezdo~m`fgdi~fqgcaf~s~fd`hxmdngxsmocg~di~xg`ns

    Qfg`dskgnqfg~fgxofd`agsomwinhgedng~m~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~~mdnnxgss~fg

    csswgmlmhgsc~)`gdxidiixgszm`ng`~ssdcngs

    Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n c` Zmico Nmoweg`~s

    Mhgsc~fdshgg`lxdegnc`oxgdsc`aidsdaimhdi~fxgd~~mfgdi~fd`nd`gzcngeco

    ^fgaxmqc`a~fxgd~~fd~m|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~zmsgslmxofcinxg`ml~fgqmxinfdshgg

    cng`~clcgndsdedbmxzmicocsswgCezicoc~c`~fgg|cng`ogcsd`c`oxgdsc`axgoma`c~cm`

    ml~fgomezigvc~ml~fgcsswgd`n~fg`ggnlmx~fgommxnc`d~gnc`|mi|geg`~mldxd`ag

    mlzmicodo~mxsdoxmsssgo~mxsd`nsg~~c`as~mic`kc`ngzg`ng`~zmicocgsd`nzxmogssgs

    Qc~fxgadxn~m~fgzmicod`discsom`nwo~gn)didxag`wehgxmlzmicoxgszm`sgsqgxg

    cng`~clcgnc`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~d`n~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)hw~xgid~c|gilgqfd|ghgg`

    ss~ged~codii~gs~gn

    Omezdxcsm` Qc~f M~fgx Xg|cgqs

    Qfcigc~csncllcowi~~momezdxgxgswi~slxmencllgxg`~s~wncgshgodwsgml~fg|dxcdhcic~

    c`eg~fmnswsgn)mwxxg|cgqcsom`scs~g`~qc~fm~fgxzwhicsfgnxg|cgqsml~fgic~gxd~wxg

    Lmxc`s~d`og)c`dxg|cgqmlems~ioxmsssgo~cm`dis~wncgs)Hmm~fd`nomiigdawgs?6swxecsg

    ~fd~~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~)ems~ml~g`dssgssgnd~~fgig|giml~fg`gcafhmwxfmmn)fds

    ~fgzm~g`~cdi~mc`liwg`oghmnqgcaf~sMwxss~ged~coxg|cgqcsc`ag`gxdidaxggeg`~

    qc~fHmm~fg~di;fmqg|gx)c~cscezmx~d`~~m`m~g~fd~mwxxg|cgqqdsicec~gn~mwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~sd`ndidxagzxmzmx~cm`ml~fglc`nc`asqgcng`~clcgnncn`m~xgdof

    s~d~cs~codisca`clcod`og

    Om`oiwscm`

    M|gxdii)qglmw`nsmegg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg s~xwo~wxdiofdxdo~gxcs~cos

    mlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nfgdi~fqgcaf~smx~fghgfd|cmwxsdssmocd~gnqc~ffgdi~f

    qgcaf~sZgxfdzs~fgems~s~xckc`alc`nc`ac`mwxxg|cgqqds~fgomezig~gidokml

    g|cng`oglmx~fgxmigmlzmic~codisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsc`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s

    c`~fgwxhd`om`~gv~C`dnnc~cm`~mdadzc`k`mqignagdhmw~~fgomezigvdssmocd~cm`s

    dem`aldo~mxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~)~fgxgdismdzzgdxs~mhgdk`mqignagadzdxmw`n

    ~fgcezdo~mlzmsschigzmicoxgszm`sgs

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    17/126

    Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    vccc

    Eg~fmn lmx Ic~gxd~wxg Xg|cgq

    Gv~g`sc|gsgdxofgsqgxgom`nwo~gn~fxmwaf`wegxmwsnd~dhdsgsd`nnmoweg`~sdoxmss

    d|dxcg~mllcgins)c`oiwnc`afgdi~f)smocdisocg`ogs)wxhd`zid``c`ad`n~xd`szmx~d~cm`;

    3nmoweg`~shgc`axg~xcg|gn)

    qc~f?77c`oiwngnc`~fglc`dixg|cgqWsc`a~qmom`ogz~wdilxdegqmxks)D@AGIM&d`discsaxcnlmxg`|cxm`eg`~sic`kgn~mmhgsc~#d`n_NGFZ&smocding~gxec`d`~smlfgdi~f

    d`ng`|cxm`eg`~difgdi~fzxmem~cm`#)diinmoweg`~sqgxgomngnlmxxgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg

    ~zgsmlg`|cxm`eg`~&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#d`nig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~

    &sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwx&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dx#mxhmn

    qgcaf~Lc`nc`aslxme~fgsgig|gisd`nmw~omeghgfd|cmwxsqgxgsweedxcrgnd`noxmss

    ~dhwid~gnqc~fkgdx~coigtwdic~c`ncod~mxs~mng~gxec`g~fgs~xg`a~fml~fgg|cng`og

    ad~fgxgnlmxgdofsgo~cm`^mdsscs~qc~fzw~~c`a~fglc`nc`asc`~mom`~gv~)d`d`discs

    mlzmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~sqdsom`nwo~gn)dim`aqc~fdswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`n

    ngocscm`edkgxsqfmd~~g`ngnd~fc`k~d`km`mhgsc~c`Mo~mhgx8::7

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    18/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    19/126

    Dhs~xdo~

    v|

    Dhs~xdo~

    Xd~cm`dig2^mnd~g)g|cng`ogm`s~xwo~wxgsmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`ncezicod~cm`s

    lmxmhgsc~xd~gsfd|g`m~hgg swhbgo~~mss~ged~coxg|cgq^fgg|cng`oghdsglmxgllgo~c|g

    g`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`scsg|g`igssqgiingic`gd~gn

    Zwxzmsg2^mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrgg|cng`ogm`d#s~xwo~wxdid`nomeew`c~ig|gi

    ofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s~fd~zxmem~gmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~f

    qgcaf~sd`nh#~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~wxhd`zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a

    fgdi~fqgcaf~s

    Eg~fmn2Gv~g`sc|gsgdxofgsqgxgom`nwo~gn~fxmwaf`wegxmwsnd~dhdsgsd`nnmoweg`~s;

    3nmoweg`~shgc`axg~xcg|gn)

    qc~f?77c`oiwngnc`~fglc`dixg|cgqWsc`a~qmom`ogz~wdilxdegqmxks)diinmoweg`~s

    qgxgomngnlmxxgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg ~zgsmlg`|cxm`eg`~&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)

    smocmowi~wxdi#d`nig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~&sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwx

    &ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#mxhmnqgcaf~^mdsscs~qc~fzw~~c`a

    ~fglc`nc`asc`~mom`~gv~)d`d`discsmlzmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~sqdsom`nwo~gn)dim`a

    qc~fdswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxsqfmd~~g`ngnd~fc`k~d`km`mhgsc~

    c`Mo~mhgxml8::7

    Xgswi~s2^fgd`discsxgswi~gnc`4)?87lc`nc`as)qc~f~fgedbmxc~omec`alxmexgsgdxof

    xgid~gn~mzfscodido~c|c~&`5148#d`nncg~&`5?>3#^fgs~xm`ags~ig|gismlg|cng`og

    lmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxmxhmnqgcaf~qgxg

    mhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi&ncg~#)smocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)mhgsc~-fgdi~f

    qgcaf~s#d`ngom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#sg~~c`asd`n

    zfscodi&zfscodido~c|c~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#

    d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#sgo~mxs\gxic~~ig

    g|cng`oggvcs~gnlmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s

    &sgg~dhigs8d`n?m`zdag81#

    Ml~fgxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxsqgswx|ggn)ems~xgszm`ngn~fd~wxhd`ngsca`

    csswgsd`ndoogsschcic~mlzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgs&edc`ic`~fg

    zfscodisg~~c`ad`nzfscodisgo~mx#qgxg~fgems~cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~f

    hmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~Xgszm`ng`~sdismlgi~~fd~~fgsgldo~mxsomwin

    hgdnnxgssgnhzmicoxgszm`sgs)hw~`mszgoclcoxgomeeg`nd~cm`sqgxgzxm|cngn

    Qc~fxgadxn~m~fgzmicod`discs)didxag`wehgxmlzmicoxgszm`sgsqgxgcng`~clcgn

    c`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~d`n~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)hw~xgid~c|gilgqfd|ghgg`ss~ged~codii

    ~gs~gn^fws)c`dnnc~cm`~mdadzc`k`mqignagdhmw~~fgomezigvxgid~cm`sfczsdem`a

    ldo~mxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~)~fgxgcsdismdk`mqignagadzdhmw~~fgcezdo~mlzmsschig

    zmicoxgszm`sgs

    Om`oiwscm`s2_megg|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s)cezicod~c`a

    c`~gx|g`~cm`sc`zmicod`nzxdo~cogFmqg|gx)idokmlg|cng`ogm`gllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`s

    d`nzmicoc`c~cd~c|gsswaags~sd`ggnlmxxgsgdxof~mlciik`mqignagadzs

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    20/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    21/126

    Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n

    4

    4 Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n

    4.4 C`~xmnwo~cm`

    ^fgxdzcnxcsgc`mhgsc~c`Od`dndm|gx~fgzds~~qmngodngs4)8fdsign~mdsg`sg

    mlwxag`o

    dem`a

    zxdo~c~cm`gxs

    d`n

    zmico

    edkgxs

    dxmw`n

    ~fg

    `ggn

    lmx

    emxg

    gllgo~c|g

    dzzxmdofgs~mmhgsc~zxg|g`~cm`.C`oxgdsc`ai)d`nzgxfdzsc`~wc~c|gi)zwhicofgdi~f

    xgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm edkgxsfd|gd~~xchw~gn~fggegxac`amhgsc~gzcngeco~mxdzcn

    ofd`agsc`smocdid`nzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~s?d`nfd|godiignlmxdhxmdngxewi~cig|gi

    dzzxmdof~mzxg|g`~cm`._wofd`dzzxmdofdnnxgssgszmicod`ng`|cxm`eg`~dildocic~d~mxs

    mlmhgsmag`co&mhgsc~zxmem~c`a#hgfd|cmwxs&lmxgvdezig)zmmxncg~d`nsgng`~dx

    hgfd|cmwx#._g|gxdizxmec`g`~xgsgdxofgxsedkgomezgiic`adxaweg`~s~fd~~fgg`|cxm`eg`~

    ng~gxec`gs~fgzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~c`dzmzwid~cm`d`n~fd~hxmdng`|cxm`eg`~di

    c`~gx|g`~cm`ssfmwinhgemxggllgo~c|g~fd`c`nc|cnwdihdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`xgnwoc`a

    ~fgzmzwid~cm`hwxng`mlmhgsc~.?1Sg~ic~~igxgsgdxofcsd|dcidhigm`g`|cxm`eg`~di

    c`liwg`ogsm`mhgsc~>d`n~fd~qfcofcsk`mq`csc`lgxxgnlxmegzcngecmimacodid`n

    owi~wxdimhsgx|d~cm`s.^mnd~g)g|cng`ogm ~fgofd`ac`as~xwo~wxgsmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s

    d`ncezicod~cm`slmxmhgsc~xd~gsfds`m~hgg swhbgo~~mdss~ged~coxg|cgq.^fgg|cng`og

    hdsglmx~fgzxmogssd`nmw~omegsmlcezigeg`~c`agllgo~c|gg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`s

    csg|g`igssqgiingic`gd~gn.C~cs~fgsgadzsc`k`mqignag~fd~qciihgdnnxgssgnh~fcs

    _~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgq.

    4.8 _~d~geg`~ ml Zwxzmsg

    Zwxzmsg2^fgzwxzmsgml~fg_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqcs~mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrg

    g|cng`oglxmexgsgdxofd`naxgic~gxd~wxgm`2

    s~xwo~wxdi

    d`n

    omeew`c~

    ig|gi

    ofdxdo~gxcs~cos

    ml

    wxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~s

    ~fd~

    zxmem~g

    mxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s;d`n

    ~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s.^fgzwxzmsglmiimqsncxgo~ilxme~fgOd`dncd Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gs&OZFC#

    s~d~gnxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`2

    ^mqfd~gv~g`~nms~xwo~wxdimxomeew`c~ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sg`omwxdagmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s=

    4.? Om`ogz~wdi Lxdegqmxk

    ^fg_~d~g

    ml

    ~fg

    G|cng`og

    Xg|cgq

    qds

    awcngn

    h

    c`~gaxd~c`a

    ~qm

    om`ogz~wdi

    lxdegqmxks.

    ^fglcxs~)swaags~gnhOZFC)cs~fg_ofwird`n@mx~fxcnagemngimlsmocding~gxec`d`~s

    mlfgdi~fd`ng`|cxm`eg`~difgdi~fzxmem~cm`&_NGFZ#.6^fg_NGFZemngingsoxchgs

    lw`ndeg`~di&edoxm#)c`~gxegncd~g&egsm-omeew`c~#d`nzxmvced~g&ecoxm-c`~gxzgxsm`di#

    ig|gismlc`liwg`ogm`~fgfgdi~fmlzmzwid~cm`s.^fgsgom`n)ng|gimzgnszgoclcodii

    lmxmhgsc~)csk`mq`dsD@AGIM&d`discsaxcnlmxg`|cxm`eg`~sic`kgn~mmhgsc~#

    h_qc`hwx`g~di.1d`ncsfgizlwilmxw`ngxs~d`nc`axgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg g`|cxm`eg`~s

    d`nmhgsc~xgig|d`~hgfd|cmwxs&swofdslmmnc`~dkgd`nzfscodido~c|c~#.

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    22/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    8

    Hdsgnwzm`~fgGzcngecmimacodi^xcdn)~fghdscozxgecsgml~fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxk

    cs~fd~~fgg`|cxm`eg`~c`liwg`ogshmnqgcaf~~fxmwafg`gxac`~dkgd`ng`gxa

    gvzg`nc~wxg)qfcof_qc`hwx`d`nomiigdawgs1odii|go~mxsmxegncd~mxs^fgD@AGIM

    lxdegqmxkcsd8v>axcnngsoxchc`ag`|cxm`eg`~shscrg&ecoxm-sg~~c`asmxedoxm-sgo~mxs#

    d`n~zg&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#Qc~fc`~fgaxcn)gigeg`~sdllgo~c`a

    lmmnc`~dkg&LC#d`nzfscodido~c|c~&ZD#dxgofdxdo~gxcrgndsmhgsmag`comxigz~mag`co

    &zxmem~c`aigd``gss#Qfcig~fg_NGFZemngifds`m~hgg`|dicnd~gnqc~fxgszgo~

    ~mmhgsc~)c~nmgszxm|cngdwsglwilxdegqmxklmxmxad`crc`azm~g`~cdig`|cxm`eg`~di

    ng~gxec`d`~smlfgdi~fs~d~ws)c`oiwnc`amhgsc~^fg_NGFZemngicsdism`m~icec~gn

    ~mncg~dxd`nZDhgfd|cmwxsC~qdsgssg`~cdi~fd~~fgxg|cgqgv~g`nhgm`nd`d`discs

    mlg`|cxm`eg`~ding~gxec`d`~smlhgfd|cmwxs)ds~fgg`|cxm`eg`~edhgom`~xchw~c`a

    ~mmhgsc~~fxmwafdi~gx`d~g)g~~mhgngic`gd~gnegofd`cses^fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxk

    csomezigeg`~dx)c`~fd~~fgig|gismlc`liwg`og&edoxmd`necoxm#dxgomezdxdhig~m~fg

    _NGFZsc`~gxegncd~gd`nzxmvced~gig|gis~fd~OZFCfdscng`~clcgndsems~xgig|d`~~m

    ~fgxg|cgqhgodwsgml~fgcxemnclcdhcic~^fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxkdnns|dicnc~)c`~fd~

    c~fdshgg`zcim~gnd~~fgzmzwid~cm`ig|gi1lmxwsgc`zxcmxc~crc`ac`~gx|g`~cm`shxd~c`a

    lmx|dicnc~&g|cng`ogmlcezdo~#)xgig|d`og&~mimodiom`~gv~#d`nzm~g`~cdiofd`agdhcic~

    G`|cxm`eg`~di

    _crg-^zgZfscodi Gom`meco Zmic~codi _mocm%Owi~wxdi

    Doogsschcic~ ~m lmmnsgx|cog mw~ig~s

    &lmx gvdezig)xgs~dwxd`~s#

    Dllmxndhcic~ ml lmmnsgx|cog mw~ig~s

    _ofmmi lmmnmx zfscodi do~c|c~

    zmicocgs

    Doogz~dhcic~ml do~c|g

    ~xd`szmx~d~cm`&ooic`a) qdikc`a#

    Doogsschcic~ ~m lmmnxg~dci mzzmx~w`c~cgs

    &lmx gvdezig)swzgxedxkg~s#

    Dllmxndhcic~ ml lmmnxg~dci mzzmx~w`c~cgs

    Qmxk%sc~g lmmnmx zfscodi do~c|c~

    zmicocgs

    Ldeci xmigemngis lmx lmmn

    d`n do~c|c~zd~~gx`s

    Doogsschcic~ ~m

    xgoxgd~cm`di ldocic~cgs

    Dllmxndhcic~ ml

    xgoxgd~cm`di ldocic~cgs

    D|dcidhcic~ ml

    fgdi~f%xgid~gnsgx|cogs

    G~f`co d`n owi~wxdi

    ngemaxdzfcos ml`gcafhmwxfmmns

    @wehgx d`n twdic~ml qdikc`a zd~fs

    d`n ooigqds

    Ncxgo~ edxkg~c`aml lmmn zxmnwo~s c`

    sofmmis &lmx gvdezig)|g`nc`a edofc`gs#

    Oc|co zdx~coczd~cm` Oxceg d`n sdlg~

    _g~~c`as&omeew`c~%

    ig|gi#

    D|dcidhcic~ ml ~xd`sc~d`n ~xd`sc~ s~mzs

    @gcafhmwxfmmnsmocm%gom`meco s~d~ws&c`omeg) gnwod~cm`)

    gezimeg`~#

    Wxhd` ngsca` Edxkg~ lmxogs

    &lmx gvdezig)lmmn zxmnwo~cm`)

    ncs~xchw~cm`) zxcog#

    _mocm%gom`meco

    gtwc~

    Aimhdicrd~cm`

    ^gof`mima

    d`n dw~med~cm`

    ^dvd~cm` d`n

    swhscncgs &lmmnzxcog s~xwo~wxg#

    Owi~wxdi

    doogz~dhcic~ml m|gxqgcaf~

    ^dhig4

    Om`ogz~wdi

    Lxdegqmxk

    lmx Xg|cgq

    _go~mxs

    &s~xwo~wxdi#

    ^xd`szmx~d~cm`

    ss~ges

    Lw`nc`a lmx

    gnwod~cm`)fgdi~f d`n smocdi

    sgx|cog ss~ges

    Egncd-dn|gx~csc`a

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    23/126

    Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n

    ?

    _c`oggdoflxdegqmxkwsgssicaf~incllgxg`~~gxes~mcng`~clig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~di

    c`liwg`og)qgfd|gofmsg`~mwsgoigdxid`awdagqc~f~gxes~fd~dxgngsoxcz~c|g~mdqcng

    |dxcg~mls~dkgfmingxs^fws)D@AGIMsecoxmd`n_NGFZszxmvced~gig|gis

    dxg`mq~gxegnsg~~c`asd`nxglgx~mc`nc|cnwdid`nomeew`c~ig|gig`|cxm`eg`~s

    _g~~c`asdxgwswdiiagmaxdzfcodiincs~c`o~)dxgxgid~c|gisedii)d`ndxgzm~g`~cdii

    c`liwg`ognhc`nc|cnwdis1_cecidxi)D@AGIMsedoxmd`n_NGFZsc`~gxegncd~g

    ig|gisdxg`mq~gxegnsgo~mxsd`nxglgx~memxgs~xwo~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~s&^dhig4#

    C`ag`gxdi)sgo~mxsdxgomeem`~m~fgqcngxzmzwid~cm`)ml~g`mzgxd~c`ad~xgacm`di)

    `d~cm`di)d`nc`~gx`d~cm`diig|gis)d`n~g`n~mhgagmaxdzfcodiincllwsg1

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    24/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    25/126

    Eg~fmnmima

    7

    8 Eg~fmnmima

    ^fcs_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqg`omezdssgn~fxggomezm`g`~sLcxs~)dss~ged~co

    xg|cgqmlzwhicsfgnd`naxgic~gxd~wxgqdsom`nwo~gn_gom`n)zmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~s

    qgxgxg|cgqgn~mag~dsg`sgml~fgzmicoom`~gv~c`qfcofwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~dic`liwg`ogs

    mlmhgsc~mzgxd~g^fcxn)xgig|d`~ngocscm`edkgxsqgxgom`swi~gn~mad~fgx~fgcxc`zw~

    m`~fgxg|cgqd`nfmqc~slc`nc`asedxgid~g~mowxxg`~zmicocgsd`nzxdo~cog

    8.4 _s~ged~co Ic~gxd~wxg Xg|cgq

    ^fgss~ged~coic~gxd~wxgxg|cgq~mmkzidogc`sg|gxdis~dags)zxmaxgssc`alxmec`c~cdi

    ic~gxd~wxgsgdxofgs~mdx~coigdssgsseg`~s^fgidxag|miwegmlic~gxd~wxgxg~xcg|gnnwxc`a

    ~fgsgdxofgs`gogssc~d~gndewi~cs~dagsoxgg`c`azxmogss)axdzfcodiixgzxgsg`~gnh~fg

    zxmbgo~limqofdx~c`Dzzg`ncvD

    844 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxof_~xd~ga

    ^fglcxs~s~dagml~fgss~ged~coxg|cgqqds~mcng`~cldzzxmzxcd~gic~gxd~wxgnd~dhdsgs

    ~msgdxofW~cicrc`a~fggvzgx~csgmlIc`nd_id~gx)dichxdxcd`skciignc`ic~gxd~wxgsgdxof

    ~gof`ctwgsd`ns~xd~gacgs)dzzxmzxcd~ghmncgsmlic~gxd~wxgqgxgcng`~clcgnDsgdxof

    mled`nd~dhdsgsqdsom`nwo~gn~mcng`~cls~wncgsdnnxgssc`a~fgxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`s

    Nd~dhdsgsqgxgsgdxofgnlxme~fgnd~gml~fgcxc`ogz~cm &lmxgvdezig)EGNIC@G

    lxme43

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    26/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ::zgxsm`szgxstwdxgkcimeg~xg)hdsgnm`~fgowxxg`~

    og`swszmzwid~cm`omw`~D`~gxxc~mxmw~scngmlwxhd`dxgdscsoidssclcgndsxwxdi3

    Hgodwsg~fgxgdxged`ncllgxg`~nglc`c~cm`smlwxhd`d`nxwxdidxmw`n~fgqmxin)

    ~fcsnglc`c~cm qdswsgndsdawcngxd~fgx~fd`d`dhsmiw~gs~d`ndxnIc~gxd~wxgfdn~mxgzmx~

    m`nd~domiigo~gnc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~mxzxm|cnghxgdknmq`smlnd~dsm~fd~wxhd`

    szgoclcolc`nc`asqgxgdzzdxg`~C`lmxed~cm`m`~fghxmdngxs~wnsg~~c`aqdsxdxgiac|g`)

    w`igssc~qdsdedbmxzdx~ml~fgdx~coigc~sgil;~fgxglmxg)c`~fgedbmxc~mlodsgs)xg|cgqgxsnglgxxgnbwnaeg`~ml~fcsoxc~gxcm`~mqfd~qdss~d~gnh~fgdw~fmxsml~fgdx~coig

    ^fgxgid~c|gimzg`g`ngnsgdxofs~xd~gaw`ngx~dkg`c`~fcsxg|cgqxgswi~gnc`dx~coigs

    mled`ncllgxg`~lmxed~shgc`axg~xcg|gnEd`ml~fgdx~coigs)swofds~gof`codixgzmx~s

    mxmingxbmwx`di~c~igs)ncn`m~fd|gdhs~xdo~s~mhgsod``gn^fcsxgtwcxgn~fd~~fgdx~coig

    hglmw`nc`c~sg`~cxg~d`nswhbgo~gn~m~fgsdegdssgsseg`~zxmognwxgng~dcigndhm|g

    84> Ic~gxd~wxgLwiiXg|cgq

    ^fglwiixg|cgqml~fglc`diic~gxd~wxgsgigo~cm`sc`|mi|gn~qmncs~c`o~zxmogssgs^fglcxs~

    zxmogssg`~dcign

    zwiic`a

    c`nc|cnwdi

    lc`nc`as

    lxme

    gdof

    dx~coig

    w`ngx

    xg|cgq)

    qc~f

    ~fg

    omngn

    lc`nc`as~fg`hgc`aomezcignd`nd`dirgn^fgsgom`nc`|mi|gndssgssc`a~fgc`nc|cnwdi

    dx~coigslmxtwdic~)c`oiwnc`axd~c`asmlsg|gxdioxc~codidx~coiglgd~wxgsd`nomnc`aml~fg

    s~wnngsca`^fcsdiimqgn~fgdw~fmxs~medkgdtwdiclcgndssgsseg`~ds~m~fgs~xg`a~f

    ml~fglc`nc`asc`d`~mzcodxgdHgodwsgs~wncgsml~g`om`~dc`gnlc`nc`asm`emxg~fd`

    m`g~mzcodxgdd`n-mxom`~dc`gnewi~cziglc`nc`asqc~fc`d~mzco)~fglc`nc`axd~fgx~fd`

    ~fgs~wnqds~fgw`c~mld`discsc`~fcsxg|cgq

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    28/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    6

    Omnc`aDx~coigLc`nc`as^mzxm|cngdsweedxmlqfd~csk`mq`d`nw`k`mq`dhmw~~fgdssmocd~cm hg~qgg

    ~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s)lc`nc`asd`nm~fgxofdxdo~gxcs~cosqgxg

    omngnd`nswhbgo~gn~mdlxgtwg`od`discs.Dx~coigsqgxgomngnlmxofdxdo~gxcs~cos

    ml~fg

    sdezig

    zmzwid~cm`)

    g`|cxm`eg`~

    scrg

    d`n

    ~zg)

    ncxgo~cm

    ml

    lc`nc`a-mw~omeg)

    s~wnngsca`d`ns~wntwdic~&sggDzzg`ncvO#.

    Ofdxdo~gxcs~cosml~fgsdezigzmzwid~cm`Dagaxmwz)g~f`coofdxdo~gxcs~cosd`nag`ngx

    qgxgomngnqc~fgdoflc`nc`a.

    G`|cxm`eg`~scrgd`n~zgDoomxnc`a~m~fgD@AGIMaxcn)~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~

    gigeg`~sc`~fgic~gxd~wxgqgxgomngnlmx~fgscrg&sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#)~zg&zfscodi)

    gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#d`nszgoclcolgd~wxg&lmxgvdezig)~xd`szmx~d~cm`#.

    Ncxgo~cm mllc`nc`a-mw~omeg^fgncxgo~cm ml~fgdssmocd~cm mxgllgo~qdsomngn

    dslmiimqs2

    :5`mdssmocd~cm

    45c`|gxsgdssmocd~cm

    85ncxgo~zmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm

    ?5wsfdzgndssmocd~cm

    ^fg`wehgxmllc`nc`asxgzmx~c`adzdx~cowidxzd~~gx`qgxg~fg`omw`~gn.^fcscsscecidx

    ~mdzxmognwxgwsgnh_mhdid`n_~w`kdxn4:c`dxg|cgqmlsmocmgom`mecos~d~ws

    d`nmhgsc~.

    Ngsca`^fgngsca`ml~fgs~wnqdsxd~gndoomxnc`a~mod~gamxcrd~cm`smlg|cng`og

    zxgsg`~gnhZfciz244

    D45_s~ged~coxg|cgqsqfcofc`oiwngd~igds~m`gxd`nmecrgnom`~xmiign~xcdi

    D85M~fgxss~ged~cod`nfcaftwdic~xg|cgqs

    H45C`nc|cnwdixd`nmecrgnom`~xmiign~xcdis)xd`nmecrgngvzgxceg`~dis~wncgsH85@m`xd`nmecrgn)gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs

    H?5Qgiingsca`gn)`m`gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs)om`~xmiigns~d~cs~codiicldzzxmzxcd~g;

    dismc`oiwngqgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs

    O45Ngsoxcz~c|gd`nm~fgxxgsgdxof&lmxgvdezig)om`|g`cg`ogsdezigs#`m~c`H

    O85Odsgs~wncgsd`ngvdezigsmlammnzxdo~cog

    ^fcsdzzxmdofqdsdnmz~gnhgodwsgc~diimqss~wncgsqc~fncllgxg`~ngsca`s)c`oiwnc`a

    ss~ged~coxg|cgqsd`ntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs)~mhgc`oiwngnc`~fgsdegd`discs.C~csdism

    om`scs~g`~qc~fdlxdegqmxk~fd~fdshgg`zxmzmsgnlmx~xd`sid~c`amhgsc~xgid~gn

    g|cng`ogc`~mdo~cm`.48

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    29/126

    Eg~fmnmima

    3

    Dx~coiglgd~wxgtwdic~Hdsgnwzm`~fg`wehgxml~fxgd~s~mc`~gx`di-gv~gx`di|dicnc~)

    ~fgs~wncgsqgxgxd~gnlmxtwdic~^fcscsscecidx~m~fgdzzxmdofwsgnc`~fgss~ged~co

    xg|cgqszxgsg`~gnc ~fgAwcng~mOmeew`c~Zxg|g`~c|g_gx|cogs4?Dsgigo~cm`mllmwxoxc~gxcd

    &eg~fmn)sdezic`a)d`discsd`nxgswi~s#qdsgvdec`gn~mdiimqd`dssgsseg`~mltwdic~

    doxmss~fcshxmdnxd`agmls~wn~zgsd`nngsca`s4>^fgoxc~gxcdqgxgxd~gnm`dlmwxzmc`~

    sodigxd`ac`alxmeAmmn&4#~m\gxZmmx&>#^fgxd~c`asqgxg~fg`sweegndoxmss

    ~fgedbmxdx~coiglgd~wxgsd`n~fgs~wncgsxd`kgndoomxnc`a~m~fgcxxgid~c|gsomxgDs~wn

    qdsnggegn~mhgmlammntwdic~clc~dofcg|gndsomxgml>mx7)mlldcxtwdic~clc~xgogc|gn

    dsomxghg~qgg

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    30/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    4:

    d~demxgag`gxdiig|gi;lmxgvdezig)qfd~dxgsmegml~fgszgoclcozmzwid~cm`s~fd~dxg

    dssgssgnh~fcs~zgmlxgsgdxof=D~~fghgfd|cmwx-mw~omegig|gi)~xg`nsqc~fc`gdof

    ml~fglmwxmw~omegaxmwzsod`hggvdec`gn)qfcig`wehgxsd~~fgsg~~c`a-sgo~mxig|gi

    hgac ~mzxm|cngd`c`ncod~cm`mlqfgxg~fgg`|cxm`eg`~hgfd|cmwxc`~gxdo~cm`sdxg~dkc`a

    zidogNd~dd~~fgszgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~diig|gidiimqdaicezsgc`~m~fgm`~fgaxmw`n

    mhsgx|d~cm`sd`nc`~gx|g`~cm`s~fd~xgsgdxofgxsfd|gnmoweg`~gnDsxgswi~sdxg|cgqgn

    doxmss~fgsglmwxig|gis)zd~~gx`som`ogx`c`a~fgncs~xchw~cm`mlzmzwid~cm`s)hxmdnd`n

    szgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~sd`n~zgsmls~wncgsod`hgng~gxec`gn

    Oxmss~dhwid~cm`sqgxgzgxlmxegn~mgicoc~emxgszgoclcoc`lmxed~cm`dhmw~~fg

    dssmocd~cm`shg~qgg kg|dxcdhigsd~|dxcmwsig|gismld`discs&sggLcawxg4#_zgoclcodii

    mlc`~gxgs~fgxgqgxg~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~slmw`nc`~fgic~gxd~wxg

    d`n~fghgfd|cmwxs-mw~omegsmw~ic`gndhm|g)dsqgiids~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg ~fgsg

    g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nhmnqgcaf~Mllwx~fgxc`~gxgs~qgxg~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg

    hgfd|cmwxs-mw~omegsd`nhmnqgcaf~qc~fc ~fgsgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sOxmss~dhwid~cm`s

    qgxgodiowid~gnqc~fc`d`nhg~qgg sg|gxdiidgxsmlnd~d)~mciiwec`d~gd`dssmocd~cm`s~fgxgc`;lmxgvdezig)~fgtwdic~ml~fgs~wncgsgvdec`c`a~fgzfscodisg~~c`aqc~fc`~fg

    lmmn-ncg~-`w~xc~cm mw~omegmx~fgncxgo~cm mllc`nc`asxgid~c|g~m~fgszgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~s

    lmw`nqc~fc`dsgo~mxml~fgzfscodido~c|c~mw~omeg^fgng~dci~fd~~fgsgs~d~cs~cos

    zxm|cngcsgssg`~cdi~mw`ngxs~d`nc`a~fgc`~gxdo~cm`shg~qgg ~fged`ofdxdo~gxcs~cos

    d`n~fged`g`|cxm`eg`~diig|gisd~qfcof~fgc`liwg`oghgfd|cmwxsd`nhmnqgcaf~s

    Lcawxg4

    ^fgmxg~codi

    Emngi

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    31/126

    Eg~fmnmima

    44

    Ig|gismlG|cng`og

    M`ogdiis~wncgsfdnhgg`omngnd`nofgokgnlmxxgicdhcic~)~fmsg~fd~qgxgxd~gnds

    gc~fgxd`DmxHw`ngx~fg_~wnNgsca`sgo~cm`ml~fgdssgsseg`~~mmi)d`nxd~gnldcx

    mxammndoomxnc`a~m~fgtwdic~xd~c`as)qgxgdaaxgad~gndoomxnc`a~m~fgncxgo~cm`

    ml~fglc`nc`as-mw~omegd`nqc~fc`~fg|dxcmwsig|gisml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~&sg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxs#^fg`)dng~gxec`d~cm mlmwxom`lcng`ogc`~fgg|cng`ogqdsedngdslmiimqs2

    om`|c`oc`a)zxmhdhig)zmsschig)c`swllcocg`~mx`mg|cng`og^fgsgod~gamxcgslmxig|gisml

    g|cng`ogdxgscecidx~m~fmsgng|gimzgnh~fgQmxinOd`ogxXgsgdxofLw`n-Degxcod

    C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof47d`nxgog`~idndz~gnh_qc`hwx`)Od~gxsm`)_gcngiid`n

    Bdegs4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    32/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    48

    _~dkgfmingxsqfmd~~g`ngnDnnxgssc`aMhgsc~c`Od`dnd2D^fc`k^d`km`_gigo~gnZmico

    XgsgdxofZxcmxc~cgsc`^mxm`~m)M`~dxcm)c`Mo~mhgx8::7qgxgom`~do~gn~msmicoc~~fgcx

    zdx~coczd~cm c`d`m`ic`gswx|g^fcs~fc`k~d`kqdsd~~g`ngnhm|gx3:xgsgdxofgxs

    d`nngocscm`edkgxsd`nqdsfms~gnh~fgFgdx~d`n_~xmkgLmw`nd~cm`)~fgOd`dncd`

    Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#)~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~gsmlFgdi~fXgsgdxof&OCFX#

    d`n~fgOfxm`coNcsgdsgZxg|g`~cm Diicd`ogmlOd`dnd&ONZDO#D`gedciig~~gxqds

    sg`~~mdii~fmsgqfmd~~g`ngn~fgsezmscweD`c`~xmnwo~cm`~mmwxs~wnqdsedng

    c dig~~gx)d`ndWXIic`kqdszxm|cngndim`aqc~fd`c`|c~d~cm ~mlciimw~d m`ic`gswx|g

    ^fgtwgs~cm``dcxgomezxcsgnlmwxtwgs~cm`s2

    4 Lxmemwxzgxszgo~c|g)ics~wz~m?&~fxgg#ldo~mxs~fd~dxgems~ickgi~mfd|gd`cezdo~m`fgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~

    8 Dxg~fgldo~mxsics~gnc`Twgs~cm`4emnclcdhighdzmicoxgszm`sg=Zigdsgofmmsggs)`m)mx`m~swxglmxgdofldo~mx~fd~mwics~gnc`Twgs~cm 4

    ? Ics~wz~m?&~fxgg#zmicocgs-zxmaxdes-c`c~cd~c|gs~fd~mwk`mqml~fd~gvcs~c`-lmxwxhd`dxgds~mdsscs~zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~s

    > Dxgmwdqdxgmlg|cng`ogxgadxnc`a~fgoms~gllgo~c|g`gssml~fgzmicocgs-zxmaxdes-c`c~cd~c|gsmwics~gnc`Twgs~cm`?=Zigdsgofmmsggs)`m)mx`m~swxglmxgdof

    c~gemwics~gnc`Twgs~cm`?

    ^fglwiiswx|gdsc~dzzgdxgnm`ic`gcsc`Dzzg`ncvNG~fcosdzzxm|dilmx~fgswx|g

    qdsmh~dc`gnlxme~fgW`c|gxsc~mlDihgx~dFgdi~fXgsgdxofG~fcosHmdxn

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    33/126

    Xgswi~s

    4?

    ? Xgswi~s

    ?.4 Ic~gxd~wxg _gdxof d`n Xg|cgq Zxmogss

    ^fgxdqic~gxd~wxgsgdxofgsxg|gdign

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    34/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    4>

    ?88 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s

    Dfcafzxmzmx~cm`&>1'#mls~wncgsm`~fgzfscodisg~~c`almw`n`msca`clcod`~dssmocd~cm`

    qc~fmhgsc~

    mx

    fgdi~f

    qgcaf~s

    ^fmsg

    s~wncgs

    ~fd~

    ngsoxchgn

    dsca`clcod`~

    dssmocd~cm`

    &7?'#

    qgxgszic~g|g`ihg~qgg dzmsc~c|g&81'#d`n`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`&87'#

    Hwci~G`|cxm`eg`~d`nId`nWsgEcv

    Dzzxmvced~gifdilml~fgzfscodisg~~c`alc`nc`as&71'#qgxgxgid~gn~m~fghwci~

    g`|cxm`eg`~)swofdsc`~gxsgo~cm`ng`sc~)xgscng`~cding`sc~d`nid`nwsgecvEms~

    ml~fgsglc`nc`asomeglxme~fxggs~wncgs4143^fgc`om`scs~g`ocgsc`~fgxgswi~seg`~cm`gn

    zxg|cmwsiod`c`zdx~hggvzidc`gnhg~f`coc~43mxhsgv41C`~fcsxgadxn)c~ed

    hg|gxncllcowi~~mag`gxdicrg~fgxgswi~smlc`nc|cnwdis~wncgsLmxgvdezig)c`ds~wn

    hLxd`kg~di43hdsgnm`doxmsssgo~cm`dis~wnml~fgoc~mlD~id`~d)daxgd~gxid`nwsg

    ecvdem`axgscng`~cdi)omeegxocdi)mllcogd`nc`s~c~w~cm`diqdsdssmocd~gnqc~fdimqgx

    zxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~dem`aOdwodscd`s)hw~ncn`m~xgdofs~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogdem`aDlxcod`Degxcod`s^fcss~wndismswaags~gn~fd~fcafgxxgscng`~cding`sc~d`n

    c`~gxsgo~cm`ng`sc~qgxgdssmocd~gnqc~fdxgnwognzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~C~qdszxmzmsgn

    ~fd~~fgsgdssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~dxgegncd~gnhaxgd~gxdemw`~smlqdikc`azgxnd

    d`nigss~cegszg`~c`dodx_wxzxcsc`ai)m~fgxs~wncgsfd|gsfmq`~fd~doogss~mdodx

    csdssmocd~gnqc~fdimqgxzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~8:Fmqg|gx)dsncsowssgnc`~fglmiimqc`a

    sgo~cm`m`~fggom`mecosg~~c`a)~fcsedhgxgid~gn~msmocmgom`mecos~d~ws&_G_#

    Qdikdhcic~d`nD|dcidhcic~mlLdocic~cgs

    Gig|g`lc`nc`aslxmelc|gs~wncgs8:8>qgxgsmegqfd~gtwc|modic`~fgcxswzzmx~lmx~fg

    dssmocd~cm`hg~qgg hmnqgcaf~d`nqdikdhcic~d`ndoogss~mldocic~cgsDoomxnc`a

    ~mds~wnc`|mi|c`almowsaxmwzs)8?d`m~fgxgigeg`~ml~fgzfscodisg~~c`a~fd~omwin

    c`liwg`ogofcinxg`sHECsc`wxhd`sg~~c`asqds~fgzxgsg`ogmldsdlgzidog~mzid

    c`imqc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsM`~fgm~fgxfd`n)doxmsssgo~cm`dis~wnc`Oc`oc``d~c84

    lmw`n`mdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ofcinm|gxqgcaf~d`nzxmvcec~~mzidaxmw`ns)zxmvcec~

    ~mlds~lmmnxgs~dwxd`~smxig|giml`gcafhmwxfmmnoxceg

    _ofmmiG`|cxm`eg`~

    Qc~fc`~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~)4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    35/126

    Xgswi~s

    47

    Lgqlc`nc`asqgxgd|dcidhigngsoxchc`a~fgdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s

    d`n~fgzfscodisgo~mx_cvml~fgsg|g lc`nc`asc ~fcssgo~mxodeglxmeds~wnhImzgr83

    ^fgnd~dc`~fcss~wnqgxghdsgnm`szxdqic`ngv|diwgsodiowid~gn)doomxnc`a~m~fg

    8:::og`sws)lmxm|gx?::eg~xmzmic~d dxgdsdoxmss~fgW`c~gn_~d~gsDl~gxom`~xmiic`a

    lmxag`ngx)dag)xdog-g~f`coc~)c`omegd`ngnwod~cm`)d`c`oxgdsgc`wxhd`szxdqiqds

    dssmocd~gnqc~fd`c`oxgdsgnzxg|dig`ogmlm|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~83

    ?8? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s

    Qc~fc`~fggom`mecosg~~c`a)diems~dii&61'#ml~fglc`nc`asqgxgoidssclcgndssmeg

    omehc`d~cm`ml_G_)c`omeg)gnwod~cm`mxgezimeg`~s~d~wsC`ag`gxdi)s~wncgsswaags~gn

    ~fd~`gcafhmwxfmmns)ew`coczdic~cgsmxdxgdsofdxdo~gxcrgndsngzxc|gn?:?8mximq_G_???3gdxsmldag#?8Mwxxg|cgqcsom`scs~g`~qc~f~fgc`~gxzxg~d~cm ml~fgic~gxd~wxgh~qmxgog`~xg|cgqdx~coigs?1)?6C`ldo~)Hmm~fg~di?6swaags~~fd~imqgx_G_`gcafhmwxfmmns

    dxgdzxcedxom`ogx`&z_448Mlzdx~cowidxc`~gxgs~c`~fgOd`dncd`om`~gv~)Emlld~

    d`nomiigdawgszxgsg`~gn~fgxgswi~smlds~wnom`nwo~gnc`Fdeci~m`)M`~dxcm)dem`a

    ofcinxg`&dags4^fcss~wnxg|gdign~fd~c`~fg~qmimq_G_sofmmisomezdxgn~m~fgfcaf_G_

    sofmmi)~fgxgqgxgdzzxmvced~gi~qcogdsed`ofcinxg`c ~fgm|gxqgcaf~-mhgsgod~gamx>4

    Fmqg|gx)~fgxgcssmegg|cng`og~fd~~fcsed`m~hgdw`c|gxsdilc`nc`aLmxgvdezig)

    dem`adsdezigmlofcinxg`ic|c`ac`~fgEgvcomOc~dxgd)~fmsgic|c`ac`decnnigc`omeg

    ~mq`fdndfcafgxxcskmlhgc amhgsgqfg`omezdxgn~m~fmsgic|c`ac dimqc`omeg~mq`>?

    Dslmx~fg_G_lc`nc`as)gnwod~cm`dismngem`s~xd~gnom`scs~g`~dssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~

    qc~fc`~fggom`mecosgo~mxDimqgxgnwod~cm ig|giqdsdssmocd~gnqc~ffcafgxHEC)

    c`ngzg`ng`~mlm~fgx_G_ldo~mxsdem`a_qgncsfdnwi~s>>Zdxg`~dignwod~cm`ig|gidism

    dzzgdxs~mhgdzxgnco~mxmlmhgsc~c`mw`adnwi~fmmn>7

    D c`om`scs~g`~zd~~gx`mllc`nc`ascsmhsgx|gnlmxgom`mecosgo~mx|dxcdhigsc dssmocd~cm`

    qc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s^g ml7?lc`nc`as&43'#zxgsg`~gndzmsc~c|g&hg`glcocdi#

    dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~)qfcig84&>:'#sfmqgnd`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`^fgcezdo~

    ml_G_d`nsmocdizmsc~cm`csg|cng`~d~~fggom`mecosgo~mxig|gi)qc~fdzzxmvced~gi

    fdilml~fglc`nc`as&78'#swaags~c`adsca`clcod`~`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`Dsmzzmsgn~m~fg

    sg~~c`aig|gi)_G_c`~fgsgo~mxig|gixgligo~s~fg_G_mldomeew`c~mx`gcafhmwxfmmn

    d`n`m~c`nc|cnwdi_G_

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    36/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    4 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s

    Lc|gs~wncgsqc~fd~m~dimlsg|g`lc`nc`asqgxgoidssclcgnc`~fgzmic~codisg~~c`aLc|g

    ml~fgsg|g`lc`nc`as&14'#qgxgod~gamxcrgndsfd|c`a`msca`clcod`~dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s^fg~qmm~fgxlc`nc`asqgxglxmedqmxkzidog>1d`nswaags~gnzmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s

    Dzxg|cmwsxg|cgqdx~coig>6cng`~clcgnomeew`c~hdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`sdcegnd~om`~xmiic`a

    odxncm|dsowidxncsgdsgxcskldo~mxsswofdshmnqgcaf~)c`oiwnc`a~fg@mx~fKdxgicd~xcdi

    c`Lc`id`n)~fg_~d`lmxn~fxggomeew`c~d`n~fg_~d`lmxnlc|gomeew`c~s~wncgs)~fg

    Ec``gsm~dFgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxded`n~fgZdq~wokg~Fgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxdeDoomxnc`a

    ~m~fcsxg|cgq)smeg~xcdisxgzmx~gnzmsc~c|gxgswi~slmxofd`agc`himmnzxgsswxgmx

    ofmigs~gxmi)hw~`m`gsfmqgndom`|c`oc`agllgo~m`mhgsc~

    @ms~wncgsm`~fgzmic~codisgo~mxqgxgcng`~clcgn

    ?87 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s

    _cecidx~ms~wncgsm`~fgzfscodisg~~c`a)s~wncgsm`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`azxgsg`~d

    hxmdnxd`agmllc`nc`asD~m~diml??lc`nc`asqgxggv~xdo~gnlxme4>s~wncgsc`xgid~cm`

    ~msmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asDem`a~fgsglc`nc`as)dzzxmvced~gi?:'sfmqgn`msca`clcod`~

    dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~mxfgdi~fqgcaf~s

    ^fgg|cng`oglmx~fgc`liwg`ogmlg~f`coc~mxowi~wxdidsscecid~cm`m`mhgsc~d`nfgdi~f

    qgcaf~sqdsgtwc|modiC`smegs~wncgs)hgc`aDlxcod`Degxcod`>3mxEgvcod`Degxcod`41qdsdssmocd~gnqc~fdfcafgxzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~^fgxmigmldsscecid~cm`&dismngsoxchgn

    dsdoowi~wxd~cm`#d`nldecid~~c~wng~mqdxnsdsscecid~cm`dsdzxgnco~mxmlmhgsc~fds

    dismhgg`gvdec`gnOwi~wxdidsscecid~cm`qdsdssmocd~gnqc~femxgmhgsc~c`Egvcod`

    Degxcod`eg`)qfgxgds~fgmzzmsc~gqds~xwgc`Egvcod`Degxcod qmeg`41D`m~fgx

    s~wnswaags~gn~fd~~fgdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg doowi~wxd~cm d`nHECcsqgdkd`nswhbgo~

    ~mowi~wxdincllgxg`ogs7:

    ^fglc`nc`aslxme~fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`a~fd~sfmqgn~fgems~om`scs~g`~dssmocd~cm`s

    qc~fmhgsc~dxgm`gsxgid~c`a~mdn|gx~csc`ad`n~fgegncdMl~fg`c`glc`nc`asc`

    dn|gx~csgeg`~d`negncd)sg|g`c`ncod~gndsca`clcod`~zmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~

    qfcig~qmswaags~gn`mdssmocd~cm`^fgsg`c`glc`nc`asfd|ghgg`gv~xdo~gnlxme

    ~qms~wncgs74)78^gig|cscm`dn|gx~csgeg`~od`ld|mwxd`c`oxgdsgnom`swez~cm`mllmmn)

    zdx~cowidxic`m|gxqgcaf~-mhgsgofcinxg`78M`~fgm~fgxfd`n)~gig|cscm d`n~fgegncd

    dismfd|g~fgzm~g`~cdi~mfd|gdzmsc~c|gcezdo~m`hmnqgcaf~C`m`gs~wn)dsfmx~

    ~gxeedssegncdzxmaxdeomehc`gnqc~fsgilfgized`wdisd`nswzzmx~axmwzsign

    ~msca`clcod`~sfmx~~gxeqgcaf~imss74Fmqg|gx)c~cscezmx~d`~~m`m~g~fd~~fgegncd

    c`~gx|g`~cm`dim`gqds`m~swoogsslwi

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    37/126

    Xgswi~s

    41

    M`im`gs~wndnnxgssgn~fg`m~cm`mlsdlg~84C`~fcss~wnmlwxhd`&Oc`oc``d~c#

    imqc`omegzxgsofmmigxs)m|gxqgcaf~qds`m~dssmocd~gnqc~f~fgig|giml

    `gcafhmwxfmmnoxceg84

    Di~fmwaflgqgxs~wncgsqgxgd|dcidhiglmx~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mx)ems~lc`nc`as&3>'#

    qgxgs~d~cs~codiisca`clcod`~Gcaf~s~wncgsqgxgcng`~clcgnc`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mx)

    qc~fd~m~diml41lc`nc`as^fgsglc`nc`asc`ncod~g~fd~imqgnwod~cm ig|gic`dnwi~s)7?

    imqzdxg`~dignwod~cm`ig|gic`ofcinxg`)7>axgd~gx~gig|cscm |cgqc`a)77emxgsgng`~dx

    igcswxg8?d`nEgvcod`Degxcod`g~f`coc~7

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    38/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    46

    _g|gxdis~wncgsgvdec`gn~fgc`liwg`ogmlwxhd`ngsca`m`hgfd|cmwxd`nmhgsc~

    mw~omegs43)8:)87))

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    39/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    40/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    8:

    ^fghwikml~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~s~wncgsd`nlc`nc`asngdi~qc~f~fgc`liwg`og

    mlg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`sm`lmmnc`~dkgDiiml~fgsgs~wncgsed`czwid~gnsmegdszgo~

    ml~fgzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~swofdsd|dcidhcic~mlfgdi~fofmcogsc`|g`nc`aedofc`gs

    &lmxgvdezig)Fmgxxd`nImwng`

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    41/126

    Xgswi~s

    84

    ^qms~wncgsc`|gs~cad~gn~fgxgid~cm`sfczhg~qgg lmmnd|dcidhcic~c`xgs~dwxd`~sd`n

    lmmnc`~dkgLmxofcinxg`)~fg`wehgxmlegdisom`swegnc`xgs~dwxd`~s`gad~c|gi

    dllgo~gnncg~twdic~

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    42/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    88

    M`gml~fgidxags~sfdxgsml~fgg|cng`og&81'mllc`nc`as#ngdisqc~f~fgoms~mllmmnD~

    ~fg`gcafhmwxfmmnig|gi)lmmnoms~sfd|g`m~hgg`sfmq`~mhgfcafgxc`ncsdn|d`~dagn

    `gcafhmwxfmmns)16di~fmwafimqgxc`omegsc`swof`gcafhmwxfmmnsedng~gxfgdi~fcgx

    ofmcogsEms~lc`nc`as&7:'mllc`nc`assfmqgn

    `mdssmocd~cm`s

    ^fg|ds~edbmxc~mls~wncgsngdi~qc~fsofmmidsdzmic~codisg~~c`a)qc~fc`~gx|g`~cm`s

    c`sofmmilmmnzmicodoomw`~c`almx

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    43/126

    Xgswi~s

    8?

    ??7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)

    Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`

    ^fgedbmxc~mls~wncgsd`nlc`nc`asxgid~gn~mlmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`gvzimxgn~fg

    smocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~&47:-?>3;>?'mllc`nc`as#

    _mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`as

    Lmx~`c`gzdzgxsd`n443lc`nc`asgvdec`gnsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asd`ndssmocd~cm`s

    qc~flmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`^fgedbmxc~&14'#lmw`ndssmocd~cm`s&8:'`gad~c|g)7:'

    zmsc~c|gd`n4'Wsfdzgn#hg~qgg smocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asd`nlmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`

    |dxcdhigs;~fgxgedc`c`a83'lmw`n`mdssmocd~cm`s

    ^fgedbmxc~&7?'#mllc`nc`asgvdec`gnfmeg-ldecig`|cxm`eg`~sswofdsldeci

    omezmsc~cm`&sc`aig|gxswsnwdizdxg`~;lmxgvdezig)Em`cfd`g~di443#)zgxogc|gn`mxes

    mlldeciegehgxs&lmxgvdezig)Madxnd`nKigzz44:#mxxmigemngiic`ad`nd|dcidhcic~

    mllmmnc`~fgfmeg48:d`n~fgcxc`liwg`ogm`lmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`|dxcdhigs@m~dii

    lmmn)`w~xc~cm`d`nncg~dx|dxcdhigsqgxgomezdxdhic`liwg`ogn;dssmocd~cm`sqgxglmw`n

    lmx14'ml~fg

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    44/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    8>

    D~~fgsgo~mxig|gi)~fgxmigmlegncdc`zxmem~c`adsmocmowi~wxdimhgsmag`cog`|cxm`eg`~

    csigssoigdx)qc~f7:'mllc`nc`aslxmem`i~qms~wncgssfmqc`adssmocd~cm`hg~qgg

    egncdgvzmswxgd`nlmmnom`swez~cm`&lmxgvdezig)Axgg`g~di4??#)di~fmwafm`gxgog`~)

    qgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wn Nd~d2 Zfscodi Do~c|c~

    ?>4 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~

    ^fgxg|cgqc`oiwngn418 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`ZfscodiDo~c|c~

    Lcl~`c`gzgxog`~&73'#ml~fglc`nc`asqc~fc ~fgzfscodisg~~c`asfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm mxgllgo~hg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~Lmx~~qmzgxog`~&>8'#ml~fg

    lc`nc`asqgxgxgid~gn~mwxhd`ngsca`)qfcigd`m~fgx84#)ed`m`idssgssgnzgxogz~cm`sml~fg

    g`|cxm`eg`~c`xgid~cm`~mzfscodido~c|c~Qfcig~fcsedhgom`scngxgndicec~d~cm`)

    dxgog`~eg~dd`discs?Lmxc`s~d`og)_c`g~di4>>lmw`n~fd~d`cezmx~d`~

    hdxxcgx~mgvgxocsgdem`adaxmwzmlgingxiKmxgd`Degxcod`sic|c`ac`_gd~~igqds~fg

    d|dcidhcic~ml~xd`szmx~d~cm`

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    45/126

    Xgswi~s

    87

    ?>? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm ZfscodiDo~c|c~

    Ml~fg77lc`nc`asc`~fggom`mecosg~~c`as)?7&'#sfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg

    ~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~@m~swxzxcsc`ai)dncs~c`o~dssmocd~cm`

    gegxagnhg~qgg _G_d`nzfscodido~c|c~)qc~fimqgxc`omegc`nc|cnwdisxgzmx~c`a

    emxghdxxcgxsd`nigsszdx~coczd~cm c`zfscodido~c|c~4>7)4>:)4>1^fgsglc`nc`asomwinhgm`ggvzid`d~cm lmx~fg|gxomeem`_G_axdncg`~

    ~fd~csmhsgx|gnlmxzfscodido~c|c~4>6

    ^fmwafemxglc`nc`as&`518#qgxgd|dcidhiglmx~fggom`mecosgo~mx)1'#qgxglxmec`~gx|g`~cm s~wncgsC`~gxgs~c`ai)ofd`ags

    c`sofmmig`|cxm`eg`~)owxxcowid)zmicocgsd`nzxdo~cogsqgxgdssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgs

    c`hm~femngxd~gd`n|camxmwszfscodido~c|c~dem`adaxmwzml`c`~faxdngacxis47:

    ^fgzmic~codisgo~mxfdng|g`lgqgxlc`nc`as&`5>#lxmebws~~fxggs~wncgs4>?)474)478Dii

    lc`nc`asc`ncod~gndzmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~

    Lmxc`s~d`og)Zwofgx4>?d~~xchw~gndxgog`~xgswxag`ogc`hcooic`ac`Agxed`g`~cxgi~m

    zwhicozmicocgs~fd~fd|gaxgd~ig`fd`ogn~fgsdlg~)szggn)d`nom`|g`cg`ogmlhcooic`a

    ?>7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx

    m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~

    ^fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`aqdssgom`n~m~fgzfscodisg~~c`ac`~gxesml~fg`wehgx

    mllc`nc`as&`54?7#)dzzxmvced~gi7)47?)47>

    Lmxc`s~d`og)c`ds~wnml441Ofc`gsgs~wng`~slxmeaxdngs3~fxmwaf48c`@gqSmxk

    Oc~)Swd`nHgxxed`47>lmw`n~fd~doowi~wxd~cm`fdndsca`clcod`~zmsc~c|gomxxgid~cm`

    qc~f~m~diig|gimlxgoxgd~cm`zdx~coczd~cm`

    ^fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxc`oiwngn?7lc`nc`as)qc~f8?'ml~fmsgsfmqc`a`mdssmocd~cm`

    hg~qgg ~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~@m~swxzxcsc`ai)zfscodido~c|c~

    qds`gad~c|gidssmocd~gnqc~f~fggv~g`~~mqfcofodxsqgxgowi~wxdiidoogz~gnc`

    Dws~xdicd477d`nzmsc~c|gixgid~gn~m~fgzmzwidxc~ml~fgaxgg`em|geg`~c`Agxed`4>?

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    46/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    47/126

    Xgswi~s

    81

    G`|cxm`eg`~

    ^zg

    Lmmn) Ncg~

    d`n @w~xc~cm`

    Zfscodi

    Do~c|c~

    _gng`~dx

    Hgfd|cmwxHmn Qgcaf~

    M|gxdii Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig

    _g~~c`as Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig

    Zfscodi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zmsschig Zmsschig

    Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zxmhdhig

    Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    _mocm%owi~wxdi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig

    _go~mxs Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zmsschig

    Zfscodi Zmsschig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zmsschig

    Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig

    Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    ^dhig8

    Ig|gis ml

    G|cng`ogc lmx

    Mhsgx|d~cm`di

    Lc`nc`ascc

    _mocm%owi~wxdi Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zxmhdhig

    Dzdx~lxmencg~)~fgxgdzzgdxs~mhgic~~igg|cng`ogmlgvzgxceg`~digllgo~sm`mhgsmag`co

    hgfd|cmwxd`nhmnqgcaf~&sgg^dhig?#Qc~fc`ncg~)c~csm`id~~fgsg~~c`asig|gi

    qfgxg~fgxgcsd`g|cng`ogmlgvzgxceg`~digllgo~s_zgoclcodii)zfscodid`ngom`meco

    sg~~c`asdzzgdx~msfmqsmegzxmecsglmxgllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`s

    G`|cxm`eg`~

    ^zg

    Lmmn) Ncg~

    d`n @w~xc~cm`

    Zfscodi

    Do~c|c~

    _gng`~dx

    Hgfd|cmwxHmn Qgcaf~

    M|gxdii Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~

    _g~~c`as Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~

    Zfscodi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~

    Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og C`swllcocg`~ @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    _mocm%owi~wxdi Zmsschig Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    _go~mxs @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    Zfscodi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    Gom`meco @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    ^dhig?

    Ig|gis ml

    G|cng`ogc lmx

    Gvzgxceg`~di

    Lc`nc`ascc

    _mocm%owi~wxdi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og

    c Xglgxs~mzxmzmx~cm`mllc`nc`asqc~f`mdssmocd~cm` Zxmhdhig54:'~m83';zmsschig5?:'~m

    >3';c`swllcocg`~57:'~m63';`mg|cng`og3:'

    cc C`oiwngs~wncgsmlldcxd`nammntwdic~

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    48/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    86

    M|gxdii)qgfd|gemxgom`lcng`ogc`mhsgx|d~cm`dilc`nc`as)zdx~cowidxid~~fgsg~~c`as

    ig|gilmxncg~d`nsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx_megqfd~swxzxcsc`aqds~fgidokmlg|cng`og

    lmxgllgo~c|gg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdnnxgssmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`nhmn

    qgcaf~c`d`wxhd`om`~gv~

    ?.1 Zmico Om`~gv~

    ^mag~dsg`sgml~fgzmicoom`~gv~c`qfcofwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~dic`liwg`ogsmlmhgsc~

    mzgxd~g)qgxg|cgqgndicec~gn`wehgxmlsweedxzmiconmoweg`~sag`gxd~gnqc~fc`

    ~fgOd`dncd`om`~gv~^fgsgnmoweg`~sod`hgnc|cngnc`~m~fglmiimqc`aod~gamxcgs2

    zggxxg|cgqgnzwhicod~cm`s)ic~gxd~wxgs`~fgsgsd`nxg|cgqs)sweedxxgzmx~sd`ngvzgx~

    lmxdD~m~diml4:nmoweg`~sqgxgxg|cgqgn&sggDzzg`ncvL#^fgd`discsml~fgsg

    nmoweg`~sfds~fxggzxcedxlmoc2csswglxdec`a)xgswi~sd`nxgomeeg`nd~cm`s^fg

    c`~g`~cm`cs~mic`k~fgsgemxghxmdnilmowsgnnmoweg`~s~mmwxs`~fgscslc`nc`aslxme

    ~fgwxhd`mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~sic~gxd~wxg

    ?14 CsswgLxdec`a

    _c`og4331)qfg`gvzgx~sad~fgxgnd~~fglcxs~QmxinFgdi~fMxad`crd~cm`&QFM#Gvzgx~

    Om`swi~d~cm`m Mhgsc~)m|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~fd|ghgg xgoma`crgndsdxdzcniaxmqc`a

    ~fxgd~~m~fgfgdi~fmlzmzwid~cm`s47

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    49/126

    Xgswi~s

    83

    lmxoxmsssgo~mxd`discsml~fgoms~sd`nhg`glc~smlzwhicozmicocgs.4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    50/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ?:

    ZfscodiG`|cxm`eg`~s

    Zmicocgs~mxg|cgqew`coczdihidqsd`nldocic~d~gdo~c|g~xd`szmx~hoxgd~c`as~xgg~s~fd~c`omxzmxd~gzgngs~xcd wsgd`nhcooigldocic~cgsd`n~fd~dxgodiegn&ncsomwxdag

    fcafszggn|gfcoig~xdllco#;4)4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    51/126

    Xgswi~s

    ?4

    Xgnglc`c`a~fgxgszm`ng`~sd`sqgxsc`mwxdndz~gnsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxk1zmsgn

    smegofdiig`ags)ds`m~diiml~fgd`sqgxsac|g`lgii`gd~ic`~mm`god~gamx&lmxgvdezig)

    smegomwinlc~c`emxg~fd`m`god~gamx#Fmqg|gx)d`d~~gez~qdsedng~mod~gamxcrg

    ~fgxgszm`sgsc mwxsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxk~medkgdemxgdzzxmzxcd~gomezdxcsm`

    hg~qgg s~dkgfmingxxgszm`sgsd`nqfd~qdslmw`nc`~fgss~ged~coxg|cgq

    Ems~xgszm`ng`~sd`sqgxsqgxgaxmwzgnqc~fc ~fgsg~~c`asxd~fgx~fd`~fghxmdngxsgo~mxs

    od~gamx&sggDzzg`ncvF#^fcsswaags~s~fd~xgszm`ng`~sedlggi~fgemxgceegncd~g

    swxxmw`nc`asxd~fgx~fd`hxmdngxsmocg~di~xg`nsd`n-mxzmicocgsfd|gdaxgd~gxcezdo~

    m`fgdi~fqgcaf~s^fgzfscodisg~~c`aqds~fgod~gamxlmx~fgems~xgszm`sgs&`5??;

    >?'#Ems~ml~fgsgxgszm`sgsc`oiwngnzxgsg`ogmlscngqdiks)zd~fqds)xgoxgd~cm`

    ldocic~cgsd`nlmmnmw~ig~sC~sfmwin`m~hgswxzxcsc`a~fd~zfscodisg~~c`asqds~fgems~

    omeem`xgszm`sgod~gamxsc`og~fgtwgs~cm`)qfcofom`~dc`gn~fgzfxdsgwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~)edfd|gignzgmzig~m~fc`kceegncd~gidhmw~~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~

    Xgid~gn~m~fgzfscodisg~~c`acs~fgzfscodisgo~mx)qfcofqds~fg`gv~ems~omeem`

    xgszm`sgod~gamx&`543;87'#^fgxgszm`sgsc`~fcsaxmwzc`oiwngnd`wxhd`ngsca`

    mxhwci~g`|cxm`eg`~d`sqgxs)dim`aqc~fzwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`^fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`a

    qds~fg`gv~ems~omeem`od~gamx&`53;48'#)qfgxgxgszm`sgs|dxcgnom`scngxdhi

    Ics~gnc`~fcsod~gamxqgxgsmocdi`g~qmxks)sdlg~&`m~szgoclco~msdlg~mldzfscodi

    sg~~c`a#)gnwod~cm`)qmxkiclghdid`og)c`nc|cnwdid~~c~wngsd`nodxwsg&sca`clc`a~fg

    ofmcog~mwsgdw~memhcigs#Lc|gxgszm`sgs&

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    52/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ?8

    Dii41&4::'#xgszm`sgsc`~fgzfscodisgo~mxqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhighdzmico

    xgszm`sg^fgsgxgszm`sgsqgxgog`~xgnems~im`wxhd`ngsca`d`nzwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`

    Lmwxmw~mllc|g&6:'#xgszm`sgsc`~fggom`mecosgo~mxqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig

    hdzmicoxgszm`sg&M`gxgszm`ng`~qds`m~swxgclsmocmgom`mecoig|gisqgxg

    emnclcdhig#Dii&>ml>;4::'#zmic~codisgo~mxxgszm`sgsqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig

    d`nqgxgog`~xgnm`zmicocgsd`nrm`c`amlid`nwsgM`im`gml~qm&7:'#xgszm`sgs

    c`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxqds~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig&M`gxgszm`ng`~qdsw`swxg

    qfg~fgxsgng`~dxiclgs~igsqgxgemnclcdhig#

    Hdsgnwzm`xgszm`sgs~mtwgs~cm`8)ldo~mxsc`~fgzfscodisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsqgxg

    ~fmwaf~~mhgdeg`dhig~mdzmicoxgszm`sg^fgm`ildo~mxs~fmwaf~~mhgw`emnclcdhig

    qgxgxgid~gn~msdlg~_~dkgfmingxsxgszm`ngns~xm`ai~fd~zmicoofd`agsdllgo~c`a

    sg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsomwinigdn~mfgdi~fcgxhmnqgcaf~s

    ^fg~fcxntwgs~cm`c`~fgswx|gdskgnxgszm`ng`~s~mics~wz~m~fxggzmicocgs-zxmaxdes-

    c`c~cd~c|gs~fd~

    gvcs~

    c`

    wxhd`

    dxgds

    ~m

    dsscs~

    zmzwid~cm`s

    c`

    dofcg|c`a

    fgdi~f

    hmn

    qgcaf~s

    D~m~diml78xgszm`sgsqgxg~diicgnlmx~fcstwgs~cm`&^qmqgxgoidssclcgnc`~memxg~fd`

    m`god~gamxlmxd~m~diml7>d`sqgxs#^fgxgszm`sgs~m~fcstwgs~cm`qgxgemxgofdiig`ac`a

    ~maxmwzc`~msg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxshgodwsgsmegxgszm`ng`~sad|g|gxszgoclcoc`c~cd~c|gs

    c`dagmaxdzfcodxgdd`nm~fgxsad|ghxmdngxldo~mxs~fd~qgxgscecidx~m~fgd`sqgxs

    lmw`nc`twgs~cm`4

    Oidssclc`a~fgxgszm`sgsc`twgs~cm`?c`~m~fgsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxkzxmnwogs

    dewofncllgxg`~hxgdknmq`~fd`qdssgg`c`twgs~cm`s4d`n8^fgod~gamxqc~f~fg

    ems~xgszm`sgsqdsc`~fgzmic~codisgo~mx&`546;??'#d`n~fgxgszm`sgs|dxcgnlxme

    szgoclcoc`c~cd~c|gs&lmxgvdezig)TwghgoOc~ssws~dc`dhigng|gimzeg`~zid`)Fgdi~f

    M`~dxcm8:4:#~memxgag`gxcod`sqgxs)swofdszmicocgsld|mwxc`adofd`agc`xg~dciecvmxs`mqoigdxc`azmicocgs_cecidxi~fgzmic~codisg~~c`afdndidxag`wehgxmlxgszm`sgs

    &`544;8:'#~fd~c`oiwngnszgoclcozmicocgsc`qmxkzidogs&lmxgvdezig)Hxcs~miEgxs

    _twchhstwdic~mliclgzmico)zfscodignwod~cm`c`sofmmis#~m~fgemxgag`gxco&lmx

    gvdezig)omeew`c~wsgmlsofmmis#M~fgxod~gamxcgsc`oiwngn`c`gxgszm`sgslmxzfscodi

    sg~~c`as&41'#)lc|glmxsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxs&3'#)lmwxlmxsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`as&1'#)lmwx

    lmxzfscodisgo~mxs&1'#)~qmlmxgom`mecosg~~c`as&>'#d`nm`glmxgom`mecosgo~mxs&8'#

    C`om`oiwscm`)ems~s~dkgfmingxsxgszm`ngn~fd~wxhd`ngsca`csswgsd`ndoogsschcic~

    mlzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm mzzmx~w`c~cgs&edc`ic ~fgzfscodisg~~c`ad`nzfscodi

    sgo~mx#qgxg~fgems~cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~Ems~s~dkgfmingxshgicg|gn~fd~~fgedbmxc~mlldo~mxs)`med~~gx~fgszgoclco

    sg~~c`amxsgo~mx)dxgemnclcdhighdzmicoxgszm`sg)~fmwaf~fg~zgmlxgszm`sgqds

    `m~szgoclcodiidskgnlmxMl~fgc`c~cd~c|gs~fd~zgmzigk`gqdhmw~)ems~qgxgoidssclcgn

    c`~m~fgzmic~codisgo~mxsd`nzmic~codisg~~c`as

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    53/126

    Om`oiwscm`s

    ??

    > Om`oiwscm`s

    C`xgszm`sg~mmwxxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`&~fd~cs)~mqfd~gv~g`~nms~xwo~wxdimxomeew`c~

    ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sg`omwxdagmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~f

    qgcaf~s=#)~fcsxg|cgqxg|gdignsmegg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s^fgs~xm`ags~

    ig|gismlg|cng`ogqgxgmhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi&ncg~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)

    mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)mhgsc~-fgdi~f

    qgcaf~s#sg~~c`as)d`nzfscodi&zfscodido~c|c~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)

    sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#

    sgo~mxs\gxic~~igg|cng`oggvcs~gnlmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a

    fgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`om`~gv~&sgg~dhigs8d`n?m`zdag81#

    Didxagzxmzmx~cm`ml~fglc`nc`as)zdx~cowidxilmxzfscodido~c|c~d`nsgng`~dx

    hgfd|cmwx)qgxgc`~fgzfscodisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxs^fmwaf~fgig|gimlg|cng`ogqds

    zxmhdhiglmxncg~&mhsgx|d~cm`did`ngvzgxceg`~di#d`nsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx&mhsgx|d~cm`di#c`~fgzfscodisg~~c`as)igssswzzmx~qdslmw`nlmxzfscodido~c|c~d`nhmnqgcaf~

    Doomxnc`a~m~fgs~dkgfmingxswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxs)wxhd`ngsca`

    d`ndoogsschcic~~mzfscodido~c|c~d`nfgdi~f`w~xc~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgsqgxg~fgems~

    cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~^fws)

    smegncsoxgzd`odzzgdxs~mgvcs~hg~qgg ~fgzgxogz~cm`sml~fgsgngocscm`edkgxsd`n

    ~fgs~d~gml~fgg|cng`ogqc~fxgadxn~m~fgxmigml~fgzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~c`xgid~cm`

    ~mfgdi~fqgcaf~sLmxdemxgomezig~gsweedxm`~fgxmigml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~)

    zigdsgxglgx~m~fgxg|cgqdx~coigsh_qc`hwx`g~di)4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    54/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ?>

    Lwx~fgxemxg)d`ggngvcs~slmxdhg~~gxw`ngxs~d`nc`amlfmq~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~ed

    c`liwg`og~fgzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~^fcsedhgzdx~cowidxi~xwglmx~fgsofmmisg~~c`a)

    qfgxgsg|gxdic`~gx|g`~cm`sfd|gcezxm|gnzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm`k`mqignag-

    hgfd|cmwxsqc~fmw~fd|c`adsca`clcod`~cezdo~m`mhgsc~Om`|gxsgi)d~igds~m`gs~wn

    dofcg|gnxgnwo~cm`sc`HECqc~fmw~ngem`s~xd~c`ac`oxgdsgnzfscodido~c|c~mxxgnwogn

    ncg~dxld~c`~dkg81_g|gxdixg|cgqs)smegmlqfcofdxgss~ged~co)fd|ghgg`xgog`~i

    zwhicsfgnc`~fcsdxgd41:41?Di~fmwaf~fgsgxg|cgqsdxg`m~lmowsgnm`~fgwxhd`

    g`|cxm`eg`~)~fgod`zxm|cngcezmx~d`~c`scaf~m`sofmmihdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`s

    Icec~d~cm`s

    Qfcig~fgxgedhgm~fgxs)~fcsxgzmx~fds~qmicec~d~cm`s~fd~sfmwinhgeg`~cm`gn

    Lcxs~)~fgwsgmld|m~gomw`~c`azxmognwxgc`qfcoflc`nc`asqgxgod~gamxcrgnd`n

    daaxgad~gnhdsgnwzm`s~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogd`nncxgo~cm`ml~fgxgid~cm`sfcz-ofd`ag

    fdshgg oxc~cocrgnc`~fgzds~41>Zm~g`~cdiom`ogx`sqc~f~fcsdzzxmdofdxg~fd~)xgadxnigss

    mlsdezigscrg)lc`nc`aslxme|dxcmwss~wncgsdxgd~~xchw~gngtwdiqgcaf~d`n~fd~s~d~cs~codi

    sca`clcod`og)qfcofcsfgd|cic`liwg`ognhsdezigscrg)cs~fgm`ic`ncod~mxmlqmx~fc`gss

    mldlc`nc`alxmedtwd`~c~d~c|gs~wn^fws)smegidxagd`negd`c`alwilc`nc`asc`

    twd`~c~d~c|gs~wncgsedfd|ghgg`zdssgnm|gxhgodwsg~fgdxmsglxmesediisdezig

    scrgsd`n~fwsncn`m~dofcg|gs~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogM`~fgm~fgxfd`n)~fcsdzzxmdof

    ncndiimqlmx~fgc`oiwscm`mltwdic~d~c|gnd~d)qfcofqgsggdsds~xg`a~f_gom`n)hgodwsg

    mwxxg|cgqc`oiwngnlmwxngzg`ng`~mxmw~omeg|dxcdhigs&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)

    sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)fgdi~fqgcaf~#d`newi~czigig|gisml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)s~wncgs

    ml~g`om`~xchw~gnewi~cziglc`nc`as~m~fgd`discs^fws)~fglc`nc`adsmzzmsgn~m~fg

    s~wnqds~fgw`c~mld`discs^fgxglmxg)c~cszmsschig~fd~ds~wnom`~xchw~c`a`wegxmws

    lc`nc`as~fd~dxgxgid~gn~mm`gd`m~fgx&~fd~cs)sdegsdezig#qc~fc`d`mw~omeg)d`n

    zgxfdzsg|g`qc~fc`~fgsdegig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)ewi~czigegdswxgsml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~#)omwinskgq~fgxgswi~s^fd~cs)qfcigqgedfd|gfdn8:mx

    ?:lc`nc`asqc~fc`dzdx~cowidxig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~lmxd`mw~omeg)c~cszmsschig~fd~

    ~fmsglc`nc`asqgxgems~ilxme~qmmx~fxggs~wncgsLxmeds~d~cs~codizmc`~ml|cgq)

    ~fcsqmwinhgzxmhiged~cohgodwsgdedbmxdsswez~cm`mlems~s~d~cs~codi~gs~scs~fd~

    lc`nc`asqc~fc`dsdezigdxgc`ngzg`ng`~mlm`gd`m~fgxC~csdismzxmhiged~cohgodwsg

    mwxom`lcng`ogc`~fgig|gismlg|cng`ogqdshdsgnwzm`~fg`wehgxd`nzxmzmx~cm`ml

    lc`nc`as~fd~sfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ~fgmw~omeg|dxcdhigsd`nig|gisml~fg

    g`|cxm`eg`~Fd|c`a`wegxmwslc`nc`aslxme~fgsdegs~wnqmwinicec~mwxom`lcng`og

    ^mdnnxgss~fcscsswg)qgqgxgodw~cmwsc`mwxxgzmx~c`aclqgsdq~fglc`nc`asmlm`g

    s~wnnmec`d~c`a~fgxgswi~slmxdszgoclcoig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~

    _weedx

    C sweedx)smegg|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~

    d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxhmnqgcaf~)cezicod~c`ac`~gx|g`~cm`sc`zmicod`n

    zxdo~cogFmqg|gx)~fgidokmlg|cng`oglmxgllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`sd`nzmicoc`c~cd~c|gs

    swaags~sd`ggnlmxxgsgdxof~mlciik`mqignagadzs

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    55/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    ?7

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    4 Z^Kd~redxrk)^fgOd`dncd`Mhgsc~Gzcngeco)43674336)Od`dncd`Egncodi

    Dssmocd~cm Bmwx`di4 AGaagxd`nH_qc`hwx`)D`GomimacodiDzzxmdof~m~fgMhgsc~Zd`ngeco)

    Hxc~csfEgncodiBmwx`di?47)14:11>6:

    7 _KKwed`ckd)Ec`csezmscwem`Mhgsc~2M|gx|cgqd`n_meg_~xd~gaco

    Om`scngxd~cm`s)D``wdiXg|cgqmlZwhicoFgdi~f88&8::4#2zz83??:6

    1 H_qc`hwx`)AGaagxd`nLXdrd)Ncssgo~c`aMhgsmag`coG`|cxm`eg`~s2

    ^fgNg|gimzeg`~d`nDzzicod~cm mldLxdegqmxklmxCng`~clc`ad`nZxcmxc~crc`a

    G`|cxm`eg`~diC`~gx|g`~cm`slmxMhgsc~)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g83)

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    56/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ? _Fdqkgxg~di)Dzzxdcsc`a~fgG|cng`og2Xg|cgqc`aNcszdxd~gNd~d_s~ged~codii)

    Twdic~d~c|gFgdi~fXgsgdxof48)3&8::8#2zz486>4833

    47 QmxinOd`ogxXgsgdxofLw`nd`nDegxcod`C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof)Lmmn)

    @w~xc~cm`d`n~fgZxg|g`~cm`mlOd`ogx2DAimhdiZgxszgo~c|g&Qdsfc`a~m`)NO2Degxcod`

    C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof)4331#

    4#2zz48?4>&8::8#2zz413?4648

    43 INLxd`k)EDD`nxgsg d`n^I_ofecn)Mhgsc~Xgid~cm`sfczsQc~f

    Omeew`c~Ngsca`)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)d`n^ceg_zg`~c`Odxs)Degxcod`Bmwx`di

    mlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g81&8::>#2zz613#2zz71

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    57/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    ?1

    8)>

    &8::?#2zz?

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    58/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    ?6

    ?6 KEHmm~f)EEZc`ks~m`d`nQ_OZms~m`)Mhgsc~d`n~fgHwci~

    G`|cxm`eg`~)Bmwx`diml~fgDegxcod Ncg~g~coDssmocd~cm 4:7&8::7#2zz_44:_441

    ?3 QBd`sg`d`nDDFdrghxmgkKdezsofxgwx)Ncllgxg`ogsc`Fgcaf~d`nQgcaf~

    Hg~qgg`Ofcinxg Ic|c`ac`@gcafhmwxfmmnsmlNcllgxg`~_mocmgom`meco_~d~ws)

    Do~dZdgncd~xcod6887

    >: _Kc`xd)XZ@gingxd`nABIgqg`nm`)Ngzxc|d~cm d`nOfcinfmmnMhgsc~2

    DOxmss_go~cm`di_~wnml8:)31?Ofcinxg`c`Ziemw~f)W`c~gnKc`anme)Bmwx`di

    mlGzcngecmimad`nOmeew`c~Fgdi~f7>&8:::#2zz>74 ^Emlld~)^Adiimqdd`nBId~fde)_~d~wxgd`nDnczmsc~Dem`aOfcinxg

    c`Om`~xds~c`a@gcafhmxfmmnsc`~fgOc~mlFdeci~m`)M`~dxcm)Od`dnd)Degxcod

    Bmwx`dimlFwed`Hcmima41)?&8::7#2zz?77?8 RSc`g~di)ZfscodiDo~c|c~Hwllgxs~fgGllgo~smlOfxm`co_~xgssm`Dnczmsc~

    c`Smw~f)D``dismlHgfd|cmxdiEgncoc`g83&8::7#2zz83?? HFgx`d`ngrg~di)Dssmocd~cm`mlMhgsc~Qc~fZfscodiDo~c|c~)^gig|cscm

    Zxmaxdesd`nM~fgxLmxesml\cngm\cgqc`aDem`aOfcinxg`c`EgvcomOc~)

    C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~8?&4333#2zz6>767>

    >> KEFg`xckssm`g~di)Dssmocd~cm`sHg~qgg W`gezimeg`~d`nOdxncm|dsowidx

    XcskLdo~mxs\dxcgsqc~f~fgW`gezimeg`~Xd~g2^fgOdxncm|dsowidxXcskLdo~mx

    _~wnc`_mw~fgx`_qgng`&OXC__#) _od`nc`d|cd`Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f?4&8::?#2

    zz?:7?44

    >7 CIcssdwIw`n_mxg`sg`d`n^C_mxg`sg`)Zxmszgo~c|g_~wnml~fgC`liwg`og

    ml_mocdiLdo~mxsc`Ofcinfmmnm`XcskmlM|gxqgcaf~c`Smw`aDnwi~fmmn)

    C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~4&433:#2

    zz?78?6 XQBgllgx)Ec``gsm~d_~wncgsm`Omeew`c~HdsgnDzzxmdofgs~mQgcaf~Imss

    d`nOm`~xmi)D``dismlC`~gx`diEgncoc`g443)1Z~8&433?#2zz143184

    >3 AELgi~m`g~di)Ncllgxg`ogsc`ZfscodiDo~c|c~Hg~qgg Hidokd`nQfc~gAcxis

    Ic|c`ac`Xwxdid`nWxhd`Dxgds)Bmwx`diml_ofmmiFgdi~f18&8::8#2zz87:877

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    59/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    ?3

    7: IKKfd`)B_mhdid`nXEdx~mxgii)Doowi~wxd~cm`)_mocmgom`meco_~d~ws)d`n

    Mhgsc~c`Egvcod`Degxcod`s)Owhd`Degxcod`s)d`nZwgx~mXcod`s)C`~gx`d~cm`di

    Bmwx`dimlMhgsc~84)8&4331#2zz343?1

    78 BOFdilmxng~di)Gllgo~ml^gig|cscm Dn|gx~csgeg`~slmxLmmnsm`Lmmn

    Om`swez~cm`c`Ofcinxg`)Dzzg~c~g>8&8::>#2zz884887

    7? OLxgd`nBFgc`xcof)^xg`nsd`nZxgnco~mxsmlM|gxqgcaf~d`nMhgsc~c`Gds~

    Agxed`Ofcinxg`) C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~81&8::?#2zz3

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    60/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    >:

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    61/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    >4

    17 IHIgqcsg~di)Dlxcod`Degxcod`sDoogss~mFgdi~fLmmnMz~cm`sc`_mw~fIms

    D`agigsXgs~dwxd`~s)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f37&8::7#2zz

    13 HDIdxdcdg~di)Zxmvcec~ml_wzgxedxkg~sCsZmsc~c|giDssmocd~gnQc~fNcg~

    Twdic~C`ngvlmxZxga`d`o)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g?3&8::>#2zz6 EKFw`~g~di)Zdq~wokg~Fgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxdeZmc`~mlZwxofdsg@w~xc~cm`

    Gnwod~cm`Zxmaxdec`_wzgxedxkg~s) Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f6:&433:#2

    zz1?:1?8

    67 XE@dad)Bx)Gllgo~sml_mocmgom`mecod`nNgemaxdzfcoLdo~mxsm`Om`swez~cm

    ml_gigo~gnLmmn@w~xcg`~s)Daxcowi~wxdid`nXgsmwxogGom`mecosXg|cgq8?)8&433>#2

    zz414468

    61)>&4334?>3

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    62/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    >8

    61 OF_Xwv~m`g~di)^fgOm`~xchw~cm`mlHxgdklds~~m~fgNcg~smld_dezigml4??4

    66 EMsigx)_mocdiOidssd`nFgdi~fHgfd|cmwxc`Nd`csfDnwi~s2DIm`ac~wnc`di

    _~wn)ZwhicoFgdi~f4:1)>&433?#2zz8748

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    63/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    >?

    4:: OENg|c`gg~di)IclgOmwxsgG|g`~sd`nGvzgxcg`ogs2Dssmocd~cm`Qc~fLxwc~

    d`n\gag~dhigOm`swez~cm`c`?G~f`coAxmwzs)Bmwx`diml~fgDegxcod`Ncg~g~co

    Dssmocd~cm 33)?&4333#2zz?:3?4>

    4:4 OIFwzkg`sg~di)OidssNcllgxg`ogsc`~fgLmmnXwigsEm~fgxsCezmsgm`

    ^fgcxOfcinxg`2DOxmss@d~cm`di_~wn)_mocdi_ocg`og,Egncoc`g>1)3&4336#2

    zz4??44??3

    4:8 _EHgncdkm)@MDKqd~gd`nXXwokgx)Ncg~dxHgfd|cmxDem`aDlxcod

    Degxcod`s2Dssgssc`aOwi~wxdiCng`~c~d`nFgdi~fOm`socmws`gss)G~f`coc~,

    Ncsgdsg4>)>&8::>#2zz7817?8

    4:? OOOdezhgiid`n_GFmx~m`)Dzzdxg`~@w~xcg`~C`~dkgsmlOd`dncd`s2

    Om`~c`wc`a@w~xc~cm`diOfdiig`agslmxZwhicoFgdi~fZxmlgsscm`dis)Od`dncd

    Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f68&4334#2zz?1>?6:

    4:> ELxg``g~di)Ng~gxec`d`~smlZfscodiDo~c|c~d`nImqLd~Ncg~Dem`aImq

    C`omegDlxcod`Degxcod d`nFcszd`coEcnnig_ofmmi_~wng`~s)ZwhicoFgdi~f

    @wxsc`a88)8&8::7#2zz6331

    4:7 OOFmxqd~f)_mocmGom`meco_~d~wsd`nNcg~dxFdhc~sc`~fgGingxi2Xgswi~s

    LxmedIdxagXd`nme_wx|g)Bmwx`dimlFwed`@w~xc~cm d`nNcg~g~cos8)?&4363#2

    zz41?46?

    4:

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    64/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    >>

    448 DLmxs~f)_Edoc`~xgd`nDD`ngxsm`)Ncg~slmxNcsgdsg=C`~xdwxhd`\dxcd~cm`

    c`Xgzmx~gnLmmnOm`swez~cm`c`Aidsamq)Dzzg~c~g88&433>#2zz87381>

    44? A^wxxgiig~di)DEwi~cig|giD`discsml_mocmgom`meco&_ediiDxgd#Ncllgxg`ogs

    c`FmwsgfminLmmnZwxofdsc`aHgfd|cmwx)Bmwx`dimlGzcngecmima,Omeew`c~

    Fgdi~f76)?&8::>#2zz8:6847

    44> _Oweec`sd`n_Edoc`~xg)LmmnNgsgx~s2G|cng`ogd`nDsswez~cm`c`Fgdi~f

    ZmicoEdkc`a)Hxc~csfEgncodiBmwx`di?87)1???6

    447 QFNcg~rg~di)Zmico^mmislmx~fgOfcinfmmnMhgsc~Gzcngeco) Bmwx`di

    mlIdq)Egncoc`gd`nG~fcos?:)?_wzzi&8::8#2zz6?61

    44#2zz4344

    48: @CFd`sm`g~di)Dssmocd~cm`sHg~qgg Zdxg`~diXgzmx~ml~fgFmegLmmn

    G`|cxm`eg`~d`nDnmigsog`~C`~dkgsmlLxwc~s)\gag~dhigsd`nNdcxLmmns)Zwhico

    Fgdi~f@w~xc~cm 6)4&8::7#2zz1167

    484 _BOxmokg~~g~di)Zdxg`~Gnwod~cm`c`Smw~fNcxgo~gn@w~xc~cm`C`~gx|g`~cm`s)

    Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g46&4363#2zz>17>34

    488 OIZgxxg~di)Ofd`ac`aLxwc~d`n\gag~dhigOm`swez~cm`Dem`aOfcinxg`2

    ^fg7dNdZmqgxZiwsZxmaxdec`_~Zdwi)Ec``gsm~d)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhico

    Fgdi~f66&4336#2zz ^Hdxd`mqskcg~di)Ncg~dxOfd`aglmxOdxncm|dsowidxNcsgdsgZxg|g`~cm`Dem`a

    HidokDegxcod`Ldecicgs)Fgdi~fGnwod~cm`Xgsgdxof7&433:#2zz>??>>?

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    65/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    >7

    487 KOid`oFgzhwx`)Ofcinxg`sHgfd|cmxXgszm`sgs~m^\LmmnDn|gx~csgeg`~s)

    Bmwx`diml@w~xc~cm Gnwod~cm`#2zz3?3#2zz>83>?8

    481BDLwikgxsm`g~di)Zxmem~cm`s~mC`oxgdsgImqgxLd~LmmnOfmcogsDem`a_~wng`~s

    c`_gom`ndx_ofmmis2Ngsoxcz~cm d`nMw~omegsml^DOM_&^xc`aDi~gx`d~c|g

    Odlg~gxcdMz~cm`sc`_ofmmis#)ZwhicoFgdi~f@w~xc~cm 1&8::>#2zz>84

    483 HXgagx)EAQmm~d`d`n_Hmm~fHw~~gxlcgin)DOmezdxcsm`mlNcllgxg`~

    Dzzxmdofgs~mZxmem~gOmeew`c~QcngNcg~dxOfd`ag)Degxcod Bmwx`di

    mlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g46)>&8:::#2zz814817

    4?: _DLxg`ofg~di)D`G`|cxm`eg`~diC`~gx|g`~cm ~mZxmem~gImqgxLd~Lmmn

    Ofmcogsc`_gom`ndx_ofmmis2Mw~omegsml~fg^DOM__~wn)Degxcod`Bmwx`di

    mlZwhicoFgdi~f3>&8::>#2zz47:14748

    4?4 EEciigxg~di)Ldo~sm`Ld~2DOmeew`c~@w~xc~cm`Gnwod~cm`Odezdca`)

    Bmwx`dimlLmmnd`n@w~xc~cm >>)8&4361#2zz6

    4?>BKced`nEEOfd`)Doowi~wxd~cm d`nNcg~dxFdhc~smlKmxgd`Degxcod`s)

    Hxc~csfBmwx`diml@w~xc~cm 34&8::>#2zz>16

    4?7 OIOxdcag~di)Gvzimxc`a~fgGllgo~ml~fgG`|cxm`eg`~m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~2

    D_~wnGvdec`c`aQdikc`a~mQmxk)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g8?)8

    _wzzi&8::8#2zz??

    4?

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    66/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    >: ZDGs~dhxmmks)XGIggd`n@OAwxosck)XgsmwxogslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~

    Zdx~coczd~cm`2NmgsD|dcidhcic~d`nDoogsschcic~Ncllgxh@gcafhmxfmmn

    _mocmgom`meco_~d~ws=)D``dismlHgfd|cmxdiEgncoc`g87&8::?#2zz4::4:>

    4>4 HAcigsOmx~cd`nXBNm`m|d`)Xgid~c|gC`liwg`ogsmlC`nc|cnwdi)_mocdi

    G`|cxm`eg`~di)d`nZfscodiG`|cxm`eg`~diOmxxgid~gsmlQdikc`a)Degxcod`

    Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f3?&8::?#2zz476?4763

    4>8 HAcigsOmx~cg~di)C`oxgdsc`aQdikc`a2FmqCezmx~d`~CsNcs~d`og^m)

    D~~xdo~c|g`gss)d`n_crgmlZwhicoMzg`_zdog=)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZxg|g`~c|g

    Egncoc`g86)8_wzzi8&8::7#2zz4&4331#2zz?4>> EK_c g~di)Ldo~mxsC`liwg`oc`aGvgxocsgZdx~coczd~cm`d`nTwdic~mlIclgDem`a

    GingxiKmxgd`Degxcod`s)Bmwx`dimlOwi~wxdiNc|gxsc~44)>&8::>#2zz4?34>7

    4>7 DDGigxg~di)ZfscodiDo~c|c~d`nEc`mxc~Qmeg`2DTwdic~d~c|g_~wn)

    Fgdi~fGnwod~cm`d`nHgfd|cmx87&4336#2zz:1 HAcigsOmx~cd`nXBNm`m|d`)_mocmgom`meco_~d~wsNcllgxg`ogsc`Xgoxgd~cm`di

    ZfscodiDo~c|c~Ig|gisd`nXgdid`nZgxogc|gnDoogss~md_wzzmx~c|gZfscodi

    G`|cxm`eg`~)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g?7&8::8#2zz>4>74

    4>3 AQd`ag~di)DOms~Hg`glc~D`discsmlZfscodiDo~c|c~Wsc`aHckg-Zgngs~xcd

    ^xdcis)Fgdi~fZxmem~cm Zxdo~cog413

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    67/126

    Xglgxg`og Ics~

    >1

    47: ALgi~m`g~di)Zxmem~c`aZfscodiDo~c|c~c`Acxis2DOdsg_~wnmlM`g_ofmmis

    _woogss)Bmwx`diml_ofmmiFgdi~f17)8&8::7#2zz71 ZSwd`nNIHgxxed`)^fgXgid~cm`sfczDem`a_gilGs~gge)Doowi~wxd~cm`)

    d`nXgoxgd~cm Zdx~coczd~cm mlXgog`~iDxxc|gnOfc`gsgCeecaxd`~Dnmigsog`~s)

    Bmwx`dimlIgcswxgXgsgdxof86&433?#

    4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    68/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    >6

    4

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    69/126

    Dzzg`ncv D2 Zxmbgo~ Limq Ofdx~

    >3

    Dzzg`ncv D2 Zxmbgo~ Limq Ofdx~

    Om`ogz~-Xgls5Om`ogz~wdiOm`~g`~d`n-mxXglgxg`ogs

    Ic~gxd~wxg

    Nd~dhdsg

    _gdxofgs

    ^c~ig_od`

    Doogz~gn

    ^c~ig_od`

    Xgbgo~gn

    Xg^c~ig_od``gn

    Xgbgo~gn

    Xg^c~ig_od``gn

    Doogz~gn

    Dhs~xdo~_od`

    Xgbgo~gn

    Dhs~xdo~_od`

    Doogz~gn

    Dhs~xdo~_od`

    W`k`mq`-Lmiimq

    WzXgtwcxgn

    LwiiDx~coig

    LmiimqWz

    Doogz~gn

    LwiiDx~coig

    LmiimqWz

    Xgbgo~gn

    Lc`di_s~ged~codii

    Xg|cgqgnDx~coigs

    Dx~coigXgbgo~gnhw~

    Kgz~lmxOm`ogz~-Xgls

    Dx~coigsQc~fmw~

    Dhs~xdo~s_gzdxd~gn

    Dx~coigXgbgo~gn

    Wzm`LwiiXg|cgq

    Dhs~xdo~_od`

    Xgbgo~gn)Kgz~

    lmxOm`ogz~-Xgls

    Dx~coigLwii

    Xg|cgq

    FdxnOmz-

    Gigo~xm`co

    Dx~coigs

    Xg~xcg|gn

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    70/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    71/126

    Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx _gdxof _~xd~ga

    74

    Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx

    _gdxof _~xd~ga

    4mhgsc~-mxmhgsc~)emxhcn-mxhmnqgcaf~-

    8hmnedssc`ngv-?g`gxac`~dkg-

    >em~mxdo~c|c~-mxqdikc`a-mxhcooic`a-

    7Gvgxocsg-

    mx-44?

    47&mhgs.mxhmnqgcaf~mxhmnqgcaf~mxm|gxqgcaf~#~c)dh

    4zmx~cm`.~c)dh

    87mx-478>

    8d`n87

    81"mhgsc~-mx"mhgsc~)emxhcn-mx"hmnqgcaf~-

    86"hmnedssc`ngv-

    83"g`gxac`~dkg-

    ?:"em~mxdo~c|c~-mx"xw``c`a-mx"sqceec`a-mx"qdikc`a-

    ?4"Gvgxocsg-

    ?8"igcswxgdo~c|c~cgs-mx"xgoxgd~cm`-

    ??"hmnqgcaf~-mx"hmnqgcaf~ofd`ags-mx"qgcaf~adc`-mx"qgcaf~imss-

    mx"~fc``gss-

    ?>"ncg~-mx"lggnc`ahgfd|cmx-mx"lmmnfdhc~s-mx"lmmnzxglgxg`ogs-

    ?7"lxwc~s-mx"|gag~dhigs-

    ?:&do~c|.mxc`do~c|.mxlc~mxlc~`gssmxsgng`~dx#~c

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    72/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    78

    >4&qdik.mxhcooi.#~c

    >8&&lmmnmxncg~.#d`n&ofmcog.mxofmmsgmxzxglgx.mxc`~dkgmxfdhc~.##~c

    >?&bw`klmmnmxlds~lmmnmxs`dok.mxfcafld~mxswadx#~c

    >>&lxwc~.mx|gag~dhig.mxsml~nxc`k.mxsmndmxzmz#~c

    >7zmx~cm`.~c

    >7

    >186fgdi~fzmico-mx`w~xc~cm`zmico-mxzmicoedkc`a-

    >3gvzZwhicoZmico-

    7:gvzmxad`crd~cm`dizmico-

    74smocdiofd`ag-

    78gvzsmocmgom`mecoldo~mxs-mxgnwod~cm`dis~d~ws-mxgezimeg`~-mxw`gezimeg`~-

    mxgvzqmxkzidog-mxldeciofdxdo~gxcs~cos-mxc`omeg-mxmoowzd~cm`s-mxgvzzm|gx~-

    mxgvzsmocdioidss-mxsmocdiom`nc~cm`s-

    7?owi~wxg-mxdoowi~wxd~cm`-

    7>smocdiedxkg~c`a-mxedxkg~c`amlfgdi~fsgx|cogs-77edxkg~c`a-mxdn|gx~csc`a-

    7

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    73/126

    Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx _gdxof _~xd~ga

    7?

    68mx->664

    6?wxhd`crd~cm`-

    6>wxhd`zmzwid~cm`-mxwxhd`fgdi~f-

    67oc~zid``c`a-mxwxhd`xg`gqdi-

    61d`n68d`n3:

    38>1d`n3:

    3?68mx3:

    3>>1d`n3?

    37icec~3>~mfwed`s

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    74/126

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    75/126

    Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d n Xglgxg`og Awcng

    77

    Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc a Lmxe d`n Xglgxg`og Awcng

    Dw~fmx&s#2 Nd~gmlZwhicod~cm`2

    ^c~ig2

    Xg|cgqgx2 Bmwx`di2

    _~gz42Edc`Oxc~gxcdlmxDhs~xdo~_od`

    4 Nmgs~fcsdx~coiglmowsm`m`gmxemxgml~fglmiimqc`a~fgegs2Ncg~-Lmmn)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)_gng`~dxHgfd|cmwx)Fgdi~fQgcaf~s-Mhgsc~ds~fgzgx~dc`~mgllgo~s

    m`zmzwid~cm`s=

    Sgs

    @m

    W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz

    8 Dxgg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs&cgsg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#dnnxgssgn=Sgs

    @m

    W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz

    ? Nmgs~fcsdx~coigc`oiwngWxhd`zmzwid~cm`s=Sgs

    @m

    W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz

    Kggzlmxswaags~gnxglgxg`ogs-lmiimqwz

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    76/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    7.

    Dx~coigLc`nc`asOmnc`aLmxe

    G`|

    cxm`eg`

    ~_g

    ~~c`a

    G`|

    cxm`eg`

    ~_go

    ~mx

    _~wn

    CN

    Lc`nc`a

    /

    Hg

    fd|

    cmwx

    _gv

    G~f`

    coc~

    Dag

    _G_

    _G_

    Ng

    ~dci

    Zfs

    Gom`

    Zm

    ic

    _%O

    Ng

    ~dci

    Zfs

    Gom`

    Zm

    ic

    _%O

    Ng

    ~dci

    Lc`nc`a

    Ncxgo

    ~.

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    77/126

    Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d`n Xglgxg`og Awcng

    71

    7. _~wnNgsca`2D4_s~ged~coxg|cgqsqfcofom`~dc`d~igds~m`gxd`nmecrgnom`~xmi~xcdi

    D8M~fgxss~ged~cod`nfcaftwdic~xg|cgqs

    H4C`nc|cnwdi

    xd`nmecrgn

    om`~xmiign

    ~xcdis;

    xd`nmecrgn

    gvzgxceg`~di

    s~wncgs

    H8@m`xd`nmecrgn)gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs

    H?Qgiingsca`gn)`m`gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs)om`~xmiigns~d~cs~codii

    cldzzxmzxcd~g)dismc`oiwngsqgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs

    O4Ngsoxcz~c|gd`nm~fgxxgsgdxof&g.a.om`|g`cg`ogsdezigs#`m~c`H

    O8Odsgs~wncgsd`ngvdezigsmlammnzxdo~cog

    .G~fcosd`nHcds

    7.Lc`nc`as-Xgswi~s

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    78/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    76

    Omnc`aXglgxg`ogd`nNglc`c~cm`s

    Edc`Oxc~gxcdlmxDhs~xdo~_od`

    4 Nmgs~fcsdx~coiglmowsm`m`gmxemxgml~fglmiimqc`a~fgegs2Ncg~-Lmmn)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)Fgdi~fQgcaf~s-Mhgsc~ds~fgzgx~dc`~mgllgo~sm`zmzwid~cm`s=

    ^fcstwgs~cm csdssgssc`aqfg~fgx~fgs~wnc`twgs~cm`csgvdec`c`azmzwid~cm ig|gigllgo~smlm`gml~fgics~gn~mzcodxgdsIc~gxd~wxggvoiwngnwsc`a~fcsoxc~gxcd

    qmwinc`oiwng~fmsg~fd~dnnxgss~fgsg~mzcosc`ngzg`ng`~mlzmzwid~cm`s&ga

    Ofd`agsc`@w~xcg`~Om`~g`~mlIg~~woglxme43178:::#mx`m~gvzicoc~ilmowsgn

    m`zmzwid~cm`s&gaD_wx|gmlAxdng_ofmmiZfscodiGnwod~cm`Zxmaxdes#

    C`oiwngns~wncgssfmwinhggvzicoc~ilmowsgnm`mhgsc~)hw~od`dismgvzimxgd`xgid~gnfgdi~fom`nc~cm`s&cgod`ogxs)odxncm|dsowidxncsgdsgs)xgszcxd~mx

    om`nc~cm`s)ncsdhcic~cgs)g~o#

    8 Dxgg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs&cgsg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#dnnxgssgn= ^fcstwgs~cm`gvdec`gsqfg~fgx~fgs~wnlmowsgsm`omeew`c~ig|gisg~~c`as

    mxs~xwo~wxdisgo~mxs^fgsgc`oiwngzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~s)gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~s)

    zmic~codig`|cxm`eg`~sd`nsmocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~sGvdezigsmlzdzgxs~fd~

    qmwinhgdoogz~gnecaf~hg2^fgDoogsschcic~mlAxmogx_~mxgsc d Wxhd`Og`~xg;

    Gom`mecoHdxxcgxs~mZfscodiDo~c|c~;NmgsC`oxgdsgn_~dcxqgiiIcaf~c`a

    C`oxgdsgWsdagc`~fgQmxkzidog=;mx)^fgCezdo~mld_ofmmiLggnc`aZxmaxde

    m`OfcinfmmnMhgsc~

    _~wncgs`m~c`oiwngnwsc`a~fcsoxc~gxcdqmwinhg~fmsgc`qfcof~fgimod~cm`mxsg~~c`aml~fgs~wncs`m~dzxcedxlmowsml~fgqmxkLmxgvdezig)di~fmwaf

    doic`codi~xcdied~dkgzidogc`dfmszc~di)~fgs~wnqcii`m~hgc`oiwngnw`igss~fgfmszc~di)dsdqmxkzidog)qdsc`oiwngnc`~fgs~wndsdzxcedxlmows_cecidxi)

    dzdzgx~fd~gvdec`gsdzmzwid~cm`mlofcinxg`xgoxwc~gnlxmed`gigeg`~dxsofmmi

    qmwinhggvoiwngnw`igss~fcsg`|cxm`eg`~csdzxcedxlmowslmx~fgzdzgx&ga^fg

    Gllgo~ml_ofmmiLmmnZmicom`Zwxofdsc`aHgfd|cmwxmlBw`cmxFcaf_~wng`~s#

    ? Nmgs~fcsdx~coigc`oiwngWxhd`Zmzwid~cm`s= Lxme~fgdhs~xdo~)c~sfmwinhgzmsschig~mng~gxec`gqfg~fgx~fgzmzwid~cm`

    mlc`~gxgs~c`ds~wncslxmed`wxhd`dxgdMl~g`)xgsgdxofhgc`axgzmx~gnqds

    om`nwo~gnd~w`c|gxsc~cgs)qfcofdxgag`gxdiiimod~gnc`wxhd`og`~xgsCl`m~)~fg

    zdzgxsfmwinszgoclqfgxgc~fdshgg`om`nwo~gnCl~fgmxcac`ml~fgzmzwid~cm cs`m~szgoclcgn)~fgs~wnqcii`ggn~mhglmiimqgnwz

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    79/126

    Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d n Xglgxg`og Awcng

    73

    @m~d~cm`C`s~xwo~cm`slmxDhs~xdo~_od`

    Om`scs~g`oc`~fg`m~d~cm`wsgnnwxc`a~fgdhs~xdo~sod`s~dagcscezmx~d`~cl~fgxg|cgq

    cs~mxw`semm~fiGdofxg|cgqgndhs~xdo~ews~hgedxkgnc`swofdqd~fd~c~csoigdx

    qfg~fgx~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gn)doogz~gn)mxxgtwcxgslmiimqwz

    G`swxgdii`m~d~cm`cszidogn~m~fgigl~ml~fgdhs~xdo~ Ics~4)8d`n?~momxxgszm`nqc~f~fg~fxggtwgs~cm`sw`ngx_~gz4ml~fg

    Dssgsseg`~^mmi

    Hgscnggdof`wehgx)zidoggc~fgxSmxSgslmxSgs)@mx@mlmx@m)mxW-LWlmxW`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz)ngzg`nc`am`~fgdzzxmzxcd~gdssgsseg`~lmx~fd~

    zdx~cowidxdhs~xdo~Zigdsgnm`m~wsgtwgs~cm`edxks)mxd`m~fgxedxksm~fgx~fd`

    ~fmsgics~gndhm|gclmwdxgw`swxgml~fgzxmzgxxgszm`sg~mdzdx~cowidxtwgs~cm`)

    edxkc~dsw`k`mq`d`nc~qciihglmiimqgnwz

    W`ngx`gd~f~fgsg~fxggoxc~gxcd)oigdxiedxkd`Vcl~fgdx~coigcshgc`axgbgo~gn;d3

    cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg doogz~gnlmxlwiixg|cgqqc~f`mxgsgx|d~cm`s;mxLmiimqWzcl~fgdx~coig`ggnslwx~fgxxg|cgq~mng~gxec`gc~ss~d~ws

    Cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gnmxclc~xgtwcxgslmiimqwz)qxc~gd|gxhxcgl`m~ggvzidc`c`a~fgxgdsm`lmx~fcsdssgsseg`~Lmxgvdezig)@mg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs

    mx@mgllgo~mlncg~-mhgsc~-zfscodido~c|c~m`zmzwid~cm`sqmwinhgswllcocg`~fgxg

    _cecidxi)zxm|cngdhxcgl`m~gngsoxchc`ad`oxc~gxcd~fd~xgtwcxglmiimqwz)wsc`a

    dscecidxlmxed~~m~fd~ngsoxchgndhm|g

    Cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gnhw~cszgxogc|gndshgc`a|diwdhigc`~gxesmlc~som`~g`~)om`ogz~wdiom`~xchw~cm ~m~fglcgin)zm~g`~cdixglgxg`ogsg~o)oigdxi`m~g~fcsw`ngx`gd~f

    ~fgm~fgxdssgsseg`~sLmiimqwzlmxswaags~gnxglgxg`ogsmxLmiimqwzlmxom`ogz~wdi

    om`~g`~qmwinhgswllcocg`~fgxg

    Om`ogz~wdiLxdegqmxk_go~mxsd`n_g~~c`as

    _g~~c`as

    Lmx~fcsxg|cgq)sg~~c`asdxgomeew`c~ig|gildo~mxs~fd~ziddxmigc`c`liwg`oc`ahmn

    qgcaf~sc`~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~_g~~c`asod`hgoidssclcgnc`~mlmwxncs~c`o~~zgs

    &zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#nglc`c~cm`sd`ngvdezigszgx~dc`c`a~mgdof

    ml~fgsg~zgsdxgac|g`hgimq

    4 Zfscodi2Zfscodig`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsxglgx~m~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~ml~fgwxhd`dxgd_zgoclcogvdezigsfgxgqmwinc`oiwng~fgncs~xchw~cm`mllmmnd`nzfscodi

    do~c|c~deg`c~cgs)c`oiwnc`a~fgzidogeg`~mlaxmogxs~mxgsmxxgs~dwxd`~sd`n

    qdikc`a-hckc`a~xdcis)dsqgiidswxhd`zid``c`acsswgsswofdszwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`

    ss~gesC`ed`odsgs)zdzgxsc`~fcsod~gamxqciiom`ogx`~fgzfscodid|dcidhcic~

    mxdoogsschcic~mldzdx~cowidxdeg`c~

    8 Gom`meco2Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsc`omxzmxd~gdlc`d`ocdidszgo~c`~m~fgom`ogz~smld|dcidhcic~d`ndoogsschcic~^fgems~omeem`~fgeglmx~fcssg~~c`a

    cs~fgdllmxndhcic~mldzdx~cowidxc~ge)hgc~lmmnlxmeswzgxedxkg~sd`nxgs~dwxd`~s)

    mxsmwxogsmlzfscodido~c|c~ickgaesmxxgoxgd~cm`og`~xgs

  • 7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights

    80/126

    _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s

    _mocmOwi~wxdi2_mocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsdxgsicaf~iemxgdehcawmws)gvzimxc`a~xg`ns)zgxogz~cm`sd`nlggic`as~mqdxnslmmn)zfscodido~c|c~mxmhgsc~d~dsicaf~ihxmdngxig|giZdzgxsfgxgedgvzimxgowi~wxdihdxxcgxs~mzdx~coczd~cm

    c`zfscodido~c|c~mxmlzwxofdsc`afgdi~flmmnslmxdszgoclcog~f`coaxmwz)mx

    ~fgxmigml~fgldecig`|cxm`eg`~c`zxmem~c`afgdi~fgd~c`amxzfscodido~c|c~

    Zdx~cowidxd~~g`~cm`sfmwinhgzdcn~mzdzgxsldiic`ac`~m~fcsod~gamxc`~gxesml~fg

    ncs~c`o~cm`hg~qgg ~fcssg~~c`ad`n~fghxmdngxs~xwo~wxdisgo~mxsics~gnhgimq

    ~fgedc`ncllgxg`ogcs~fd~zdzgxsc`~fcsod~gamxqciizgx~dc`~mdszgoclcog~f`co

    axmwzmxldecig`|cxm`eg`~)lmxgvdezig)c`s~gdnmlhgc`aom`ogx`gnqc~fdii

    ldecicgsmxdiig~f`coc~cgs

    _go~mxs

    Lmx~fcsxg|cgq)sgo~mxsxglgx~mhxmdngxs~xwo~wxdildo~mxs~fd~swxxmw`n~fgemxgszgoclco

    sg~~c`asngsoxchgndhm|g^fgsgqciihgzxgnmec`d`~iom`ogx`gnqc~fzmzwid~cm`ig|gi

    gvzimxd~cm`sd`nd`disgsml~fglmwxg`|cxm`eg`~~zgs

    4 Zfscodi2Zfscodig`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxsod`gvzimxg~fc`asswofdsag`gxdi~xg`nsc`wxhd`zid``c`axgid~c|g~mzfscodido~c|c~mxlmmn;~fgxmigml~gof`mimad`n

    dw~med~cm`c`zgmzigsndciic|gs;mx~fgcezdo~ml~xd`szmx~d~cm`ss~gesm`d

    zmzwid~cm ig|gi

    8 Gom`meco2Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxs)scecidx~m~fgngsoxcz~cm`mlgom`mecosg~~c`asdhm|g)om`ogx`slc`d`ocdidszgo~smlmhgsc~)zfscodido~c|c~d`n-mxgd~c`ad~

    dzmzwid~cm`ig|giLmxgvdezig)zdzgxsfgxgedgvzimxg~fgcezdo~mlsmocmgom`mecos~d~wsm`zdx~coczd~cm c`zfscodido~c|c~mxlmmnom`swez~cm`zd~~gx`s)mxecaf~

    zxm|cngd`d`discsmlgom`mecoswhscncgsmxedxkg~lmxogsds~fgzgx~dc`~m~fg

    d|dcidhcic~mllmmn

    ? Zmic~codi2Zdzgxsom`ogx`c`azmic~codig`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxsdxgickgi~mgvzimxg~mzcosswofds~fgcezdo~mlszgoclcozmicocgsm`lmmnoms~smxd|dcidhcic~)lw`nc`a

    ngocscm`slmxzmzwid~cm`ig|gignwod~cm zxmaxdesmxsgx|cogs)mx