State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
Transcript of State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
1/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m`
Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
2/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
3/126
_~d~gml
~fg
G|cng`og
Xg|cgq
m`
Wxhd`
Fgdi~fd`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s
Zxgzdxgnh2
KceXdc`g)ZfN)XN
Bmf`O_zg`og)ZfN
Bmf`Ofwxof)ZfN)ED
@mxed`nHmwi)ZfN
Ic`nd_id~gx)EIc_
BmsfEdxkm)EZF
Kdx`Achhm`s)EZF
GxcoFgezfcii)E_o
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
4/126
^fg|cgqsgvzxgssgnc`~fcsxgzmx~nm`m~`gogssdxcixgzxgsg`~~fg|cgqsml~fg
Od`dncd`Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gmx~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`.
Om`~g`~sml~fcszwhicod~cm`edhgxgzxmnwognc`qfmigmxc`zdx~zxm|cngn~fg
c`~g`ngnwsgcslmx`m`omeegxocdizwxzmsgsd`nlwiidok`mqignageg`~csac|g`
~m~fg
Od`dncd`
C`s~c~w~g
lmx
Fgdi~f
C`lmxed~cm`.
Od`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`
>37Xcofem`nXmdn
_wc~gF&ZNL#
8::6Od`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`
Fmq~moc~g~fcsnmoweg`~2
K.Xdc`g)B.O._zg`og)B.Ofwxof)@.Hmwi)I._id~gx)B.Edxkm)K.Achhm`sd`nG.Fgezfcii)
_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~fd`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s&M~~dqd2OCFC)8::6#.
Og~~gzwhicod~cm`gs~dwsscncszm`chigg`lxd`dcssmwsig~c~xgGvdeg`ngi~d~ngszxgw|gsswxidsd`~g`ecicgwwxhdc`g~igzmcnssd`~.C_H@316477>
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
5/126
^dhig ml Om`~g`~s
Dhmw~~fgOd`dncd`Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gcccDhmw~~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm` |Dok`mqignageg`~s |ccEdc`EgssdagsLxme_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~f
d`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s cvGvgow~c|g_weedxLxme_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqm`Wxhd`Fgdi~f
d`nFgdi~fQgcaf~s vcDhs~xdo~ v|4 Zxmbgo~Hdokaxmw`n4
44 C`~xmnwo~cm`448 _~d~geg`~mlZwxzmsg44? Om`ogz~wdiLxdegqmxk4
8 Eg~fmnmima 784 _s~ged~coIc~gxd~wxgXg|cgq7
844 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxof_~xd~ga 7848 Ic~gxd~wxg^c~ig_od` Ic~gxd~wxgLwiiXg|cgq 1
88 _~dkgfmingx_wx|g&C`lmxegnMzc`cm`#44? Xgswi~s 4?
?4 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxofd`nXg|cgqZxmogss 4??8 Nd~d2Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s 4?
?84 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxMhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4??88 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4>?8? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s47?8> ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s4 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`88??7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)
Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`8??> Nd~d2ZfscodiDo~c|c~8>
?>4 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~8>?>8 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~8>?>? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m ZfscodiDo~c|c~ 87?>> ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~87?>7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~ 87?7 Nd~d2_gng`~dxHgfd|cmwx8
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
7/126
Dhmw~ ~fg Od dncd` Zmzwid~cm` Fgdi~f C`c~cd~c|g
ccc
Dhmw~ ~fg Od`dncd` Zmzwid~cm` Fgdi~f C`c~cd~c|g
^fgOd`dncd Zmzwid~cm Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#)dzdx~ml~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~g
lmxFgdi~fC`lmxed~cm`&OCFC#)qdsoxgd~gnc`4333OZFCsecsscm`cs~qmlmin2
^mlms~gxdhg~~gxw`ngxs~d`nc`amlldo~mxs~fd~dllgo~~fgfgdi~fmlc`nc|cnwdisd`nomeew`c~cgs;d`n ^mom`~xchw~g~m~fgng|gimzeg`~mlzmicocgs~fd~xgnwogc`gtwc~cgsd`ncezxm|g
~fgfgdi~fd`nqgiihgc`amlOd`dncd`s
Dsdkgdo~mxc`zmzwid~cm fgdi~f)OZFC2
Zxm|cngsd`discsmlOd`dncd`d`nc`~gx`d~cm`dizmzwid~cm fgdi~fg|cng`og~mc`lmxezmicocgs~fd~cezxm|g~fgfgdi~fmlOd`dncd`s;
Omeecsscm`sxgsgdxofd`nhwcinsxgsgdxofzdx~`gxsfczs~mg`fd`ogw`ngxs~d`nc`amlxgsgdxoflc`nc`asd`n~mzxmem~gd`discsmls~xd~gacgs~fd~cezxm|gzmzwid~cm fgdi~f;
_`~fgscrgsg|cng`ogdhmw~zmicogvzgxcg`ogs)d`dirgsg|cng`ogm`~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlzmicoc`c~cd~c|gsd`nng|gimzszmicomz~cm`s;
Qmxks~mcezxm|gzwhicok`mqignagd`nw`ngxs~d`nc`aml~fgng~gxec`d`~s~fd~dllgo~c`nc|cnwdid`nomeew`c~fgdi~fd`nqgiihgc`a;d`n
Qmxksqc~fc`OCFC~mom`~xchw~g~mcezxm|geg`~sc`Od`dndsfgdi~fss~ged`n~fgfgdi~fmlOd`dncd`s
Lmxemxgc`lmxed~cm`m`OZFCd`nc~szwhicod~cm`s)zigdsg|csc~2qqqocfcod-ozfc
http://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphihttp://www.cihi.ca/cphi -
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
8/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
9/126
Dhmw~ ~fg Od dncd` C`s~c~w~g lmx Fgdi~f C`lmxed~cm`
|
Dhmw~ ~fg Od`dncd` C`s~c~w~g lmx Fgdi~f C`lmxed~cm`
OCFComiigo~sd`nd`dirgsc`lmxed~cm`m`fgdi~fd`nfgdi~fodxgc`Od`dndd`nedkgsc~
zwhicoid|dcidhigOd`dndslgngxdi)zxm|c`ocdid`n~gxxc~mxcdiam|gx`eg`~soxgd~gnOCFC
dsd`m~lmxzxmlc~)c`ngzg`ng`~mxad`crd~cm`ngncod~gn~mlmxac`adomeem`dzzxmdof
~mOd`dncd`fgdi~fc`lmxed~cm`OCFCsamdi2~mzxm|cng~cegi)doowxd~gd`nomezdxdhig
c`lmxed~cm`OCFCsnd~dd`nxgzmx~sc`lmxefgdi~fzmicocgs)swzzmx~~fggllgo~c|gngic|gx
mlfgdi~fsgx|cogsd`nxdcsgdqdxg`gssdem`aOd`dncd`sml~fgldo~mxs~fd~om`~xchw~g
~mammnfgdi~f
Lmxemxgc`lmxed~cm`m`OCFCd`nc~szwhicod~cm`s)zigdsg|csc~2qqqocfcod
http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/http://www.cihi.ca/ -
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
10/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
11/126
Dok`mqignageg ~s
|cc
Dok`mqignageg`~s
^fcsxgzmx~qdsqxc~~g`hKceXdc`g)Bmf`O_zg`og)Bmf`Ofwxof)@mxed`nHmwi)
Ic`nd_id~gx)BmsfEdxkm)Kdx`Achhm`sd`nGxcoFgezfcii^fgxgzmx~qdsomeecsscm`gn
h~fgOd`dncd`Zmzwid~cm Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#ml~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~glmxFgdi~f
C`lmxed~cm`&OCFC#
C~sfmwinhg`m~gn~fd~~fgom`oiwscm`sc`~fgxgzmx~nm`m~`gogssdxcixgligo~~fmsg
mlOZFCmxOCFC
^fcsxgzmx~qdszggxxg|cgqgn
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
12/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
13/126
Edc` Egssdags Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
cv
Edc` Egssdags Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq
m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
^fcsxg|cgqxg|gdign~fd~g|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~d`nhgfd|cmwxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~
Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~sLmxc`nc|cnwdis)dimqgxsmocmgom`mecos~d~ws&gnwod~cm`ig|gi)
c`omeg)gezimeg`~#qdsml~g`dssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgnmhgsc~dem`ahm~fdnwi~s
d`nofcinxg`Lmxc`s~d`og)imqgxzgxsm`dic`omegdllgo~sdllmxndhcic~mllmmn)qfcof
ngem`s~xd~gs~fgems~om`scs~g`~c`liwg`ogm`lmmnom`swez~cm`_cecidxi)c`nc|cnwdis
ic|c`ac`ecnnigc`omeg~mfcafc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgemxgickgi~mhgzfscodii
do~c|g~fd`~fgcxomw`~gxzdx~sc`imqgxc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsImqgxc`omeg
`gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgdismemxgickgi~mom`~dc`axgd~gxdoogss~msmwxogsmlg`gxang`sg
lmmns&lmxgvdezig)lds~lmmns#d`nimqgxdoogss~mswzgxedxkg~smxm~fgxs~mxgss~mokc`a
fgdi~flmmns
Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~c`~gx|g`~cm`sdcegnd~cezxm|c`a~fgc`omegd`ngnwod~cm`di
s~d~wsmlc`nc|cnwdisd`nldecicgsqc~fc`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sedfgizdnnxgssncszdxc~cgs
c`mhgsc~Dism)cezxm|c`adoogss~mfgdi~flmmnsd`nxgoxgd~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgsc`imqgx
c`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsedfgiz~moxgd~gdfgdi~fqgcaf~lxcg`nig`|cxm`eg`~
_ofmmig`|cxm`eg`~Di~fmwafsofmmisdxg`m~szgoclco~mwxhd`dxgds)s~wncgslxme
c`~gx|g`~cm`szgxlmxegnc sofmmis&lmxgvdezig)d|dcidhcic~mlfgdi~fofmcogsc`|g`nc`a
edofc`gsmxzmc`~mlzwxofdsg`w~xc~cm`c`lmxed~cm`#sfmqgng|cng`oglmxcezxm|c`a
gd~c`ahgfd|cmwxsDiis~wncgsfdnd~igds~smegzmsc~c|ggllgo~sm`lmmnc`~dkg)gc~fgx
c`oxgdsc`afgdi~flmmnofmcogsmxngoxgdsc`aw`fgdi~fdi~gx`d~c|gs)~fmwaf`msofmmi
c`~gx|g`~cm`ssca`clcod`~idllgo~gnhmnqgcaf~sFmqg|gx)c~sfmwinhg`m~gn~fd~smeg
s~wncgs~fd~fd|gdssgssgn~fgcezdo~mlsofmmihdsgnzxmaxdesm`hmnqgcaf~sed
`m~fd|ghgg`c`oiwngnc`~fcsxg|cgqhgodwsg~fgncn`m~szgocld`wxhd`sg~~c`a
Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~omezxgfg`sc|gsofmmilmmnzmicocgsmxgnwod~cm`dic`~gx|g`~cm`s
~fd~zxmem~gfgdi~flmmnofmcogsdxgickgi~mfd|ghg`glcocdigllgo~sm`ofcinxg`s
gd~c`afdhc~s
Hwci~g`|cxm`eg`~^fgems~om`scs~g`~g`|cxm`eg`~didssmocd~cm`smhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi
do~c|c~qgxggigeg`~sml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~Fdiiedxksmlqdikdhcic~&lmxgvdezig)
c`oxgdsgnxgscng`~cding`sc~)ecvgnwsgrm`c`ad`ns~xgg~om``go~c|c~#d`ndoogss
~mxgoxgd~cm`dildocic~cgsdxgdssmocd~gnqc~ffgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sZgmzigszgxogz~cm`s
ml~fgcxhwci~g`|cxm`eg`~dxgdismkg
Qfd~~fcsegd`scs~fd~qdikdhcic~ml`gcafhmwxfmmnsd`ndoogss~mxgoxgd~cm`di
ldocic~cgsc`d`ndxmw`n`gcafhmwxfmmnseddsscs~c`zxmem~c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s
Idokmlc`~gx|g`~cm g|cng`og\gxic~~igg|cng`oggvcs~slmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssml
c`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`om`~gv~Emxgg|diwd~cm`sdxg
`ggngn~m~dkgc`~mdoomw`~`d~wxdigvzgxceg`~sc`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s&lmxgvdezig)
nmgs~fgzxmiclgxd~cm mlhcooigid`gsc`oxgdsgooic`a=#
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
14/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
15/126
Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
vc
Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og
Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
Xd~cm`dig d`n Zwxzmsg
^fgxgid~cm`sfczhg~qgg`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nmhgsc~fdsxgogc|gnic~~igss~ged~co
d~~g`~cm`Mwxzwxzmsgqds~mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrg~fgg|cng`ogm`2
d# s~xwo~wxdid`nomeew`c~ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s~fd~zxmem~g
mxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s;d`n
h# ~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~wxhd`zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a
fgdi~fqgcaf~s
Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n c` ~fg Ic~gxd~wxg
Qglmw`nzxmhdhigg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg gom`mecosg~~c`asd`nmhgsc~
Lmxgvdezig)dimqgxc`nc|cnwdismocmgom`mecos~d~ws&_G_#qdsml~g`dssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgnmhgsc~dem`adnwi~sd`nofcinxg &zdag47#Imqgxzgxsm`dic`omegsdllgo~
dllmxndhcic~mllmmn)d`ndllmxndhcic~fds~fgems~om`scs~g`~c`liwg`ogm lmmnom`swez~cm`
C`dnnc~cm`)imqgx_G_c`nc|cnwdisxgzmx~emxghdxxcgxs~md`nigsszdx~coczd~cm c`
zfscodido~c|c~
Dsqds~fgodsgqc~fc`nc|cnwdifmwsgfmin_G_)`gcafhmwxfmmn_G_qdsdssmocd~gnqc~f
hmnqgcaf~sLmxc`s~d`og)c`nc|cnwdisic|c`ac`ecnnig~mfcafc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmns
dxgemxgickgi~mhgzfscodiido~c|g~fd`~fgcxomw`~gxzdx~sc`imqgxc`omeg
`gcafhmwxfmmnsImqgxc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsdxgdismemxgickgi~mom`~dc`axgd~gx
doogss~msmwxogsmlg`gxang`sglmmns&lmxgvdezig)lds~lmmns#d`nimqgxdoogss
~mswzgxedxkg~smxm~fgxs~mxgss~mokc`afgdi~flmmns
^fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~qdslmw`n~mhgdzm~g`~cdisg~~c`almxc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mzxmem~g
fgdi~fgd~c`adem`aofcinxg`Zxmaxdesqc~fc`~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)
zxmem~cm`mlfgdi~flmmns)zxcogc`og`~c|gs#dxgag`gxdiidssmocd~gnqc~fd`c`oxgdsgn
om`swez~cm`mlfgdi~fcgxlmmns&zdag8:#
^fgwxhd`hwci~g`|cxm`eg`~qdsdssmocd~gnqc~fhm~fzfscodido~c|c~d`nfgdi~f
hmnqgcaf~s_~wncgsom`scs~g`~isfmq~fd~ldo~mxs~fd~zxmem~gmhgsc~&lmxgvdezig)
wxhd`szxdqi)imqc`~gxsgo~cm ng`sc~)imqxgscng`~cding`sc~)imqid`nwsgecv#~g`n
dism~mld|mwxsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwxd`nimqgxzfscodido~c|c~ig|gis&zdag46#Hgodwsg
ems~ml~fgg|cng`ogxg|cgqgnqdsoxmsssgo~cm`di)~fcsswaags~s~fd~dswzzmx~c|gwxhd`
zfscodisg~~c`aedhgdn|d`~dagmws)hw~zgxfdzsc`swllcocg`~hc~sgil~mfd|gdsca`clcod`~
cezdo~m`mhgsc~
Owi~wxgd`ng~f`coc~&smocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~#dismldo~mxgnc`~mmwxlc`nc`as
Dnmz~cm`mldemxgQgs~gx`iclgs~igfdnzxgnmec`d`~i`gad~c|ggllgo~sm`lmmn)
`w~xc~cm`d`nncg~dxfdhc~sLwx~fgxemxg)~fgemxgdoogz~c`aowi~wxgsqgxgmlodxs)
~fgigssickgi~fgqgxg~mhgzfscodiido~c|g
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
16/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
vcc
Nwg~mdidokmlss~ged~cos~wncgsc`~fcsdxgd)|gxic~~igg|cng`ogqdslmw`n~mswzzmx~
~fgxmigmlzmicoc`zxmem~c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s
_cecidx~m~fgidokmllc`nc`asc`~fgzmicodxgd)|gxic~~igg|cng`ogqdsd|dcidhiglmx
~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~
Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n ^dikc`a Qc~f Gvzgx~s
Daxmwzmld~~g`nggsmld`mhgsc~sezmscwefginc`8::7qgxgswx|ggndhmw~
~fggigeg`~sml~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~~fd~om`~xchw~g~mfgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sEms~
xgszm`ng`~slgi~~fd~~fgemxgceegncd~ghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)hckg~xdcis)
qdikc`azd~fs#fdsdaxgd~gxcezdo~m`fgdi~fqgcaf~s~fd`hxmdngxsmocg~di~xg`ns
Qfg`dskgnqfg~fgxofd`agsomwinhgedng~m~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~~mdnnxgss~fg
csswgmlmhgsc~)`gdxidiixgszm`ng`~ssdcngs
Qfd~ Qg Lmw`n c` Zmico Nmoweg`~s
Mhgsc~fdshgg`lxdegnc`oxgdsc`aidsdaimhdi~fxgd~~mfgdi~fd`nd`gzcngeco
^fgaxmqc`a~fxgd~~fd~m|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~zmsgslmxofcinxg`ml~fgqmxinfdshgg
cng`~clcgndsdedbmxzmicocsswgCezicoc~c`~fgg|cng`ogcsd`c`oxgdsc`axgoma`c~cm`
ml~fgomezigvc~ml~fgcsswgd`n~fg`ggnlmx~fgommxnc`d~gnc`|mi|geg`~mldxd`ag
mlzmicodo~mxsdoxmsssgo~mxsd`nsg~~c`as~mic`kc`ngzg`ng`~zmicocgsd`nzxmogssgs
Qc~fxgadxn~m~fgzmicod`discsom`nwo~gn)didxag`wehgxmlzmicoxgszm`sgsqgxg
cng`~clcgnc`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~d`n~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)hw~xgid~c|gilgqfd|ghgg`
ss~ged~codii~gs~gn
Omezdxcsm` Qc~f M~fgx Xg|cgqs
Qfcigc~csncllcowi~~momezdxgxgswi~slxmencllgxg`~s~wncgshgodwsgml~fg|dxcdhcic~
c`eg~fmnswsgn)mwxxg|cgqcsom`scs~g`~qc~fm~fgxzwhicsfgnxg|cgqsml~fgic~gxd~wxg
Lmxc`s~d`og)c`dxg|cgqmlems~ioxmsssgo~cm`dis~wncgs)Hmm~fd`nomiigdawgs?6swxecsg
~fd~~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~)ems~ml~g`dssgssgnd~~fgig|giml~fg`gcafhmwxfmmn)fds
~fgzm~g`~cdi~mc`liwg`oghmnqgcaf~sMwxss~ged~coxg|cgqcsc`ag`gxdidaxggeg`~
qc~fHmm~fg~di;fmqg|gx)c~cscezmx~d`~~m`m~g~fd~mwxxg|cgqqdsicec~gn~mwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~sd`ndidxagzxmzmx~cm`ml~fglc`nc`asqgcng`~clcgnncn`m~xgdof
s~d~cs~codisca`clcod`og
Om`oiwscm`
M|gxdii)qglmw`nsmegg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg s~xwo~wxdiofdxdo~gxcs~cos
mlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nfgdi~fqgcaf~smx~fghgfd|cmwxsdssmocd~gnqc~ffgdi~f
qgcaf~sZgxfdzs~fgems~s~xckc`alc`nc`ac`mwxxg|cgqqds~fgomezig~gidokml
g|cng`oglmx~fgxmigmlzmic~codisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsc`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s
c`~fgwxhd`om`~gv~C`dnnc~cm`~mdadzc`k`mqignagdhmw~~fgomezigvdssmocd~cm`s
dem`aldo~mxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~)~fgxgdismdzzgdxs~mhgdk`mqignagadzdxmw`n
~fgcezdo~mlzmsschigzmicoxgszm`sgs
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
17/126
Gvgow~c|g _weedx Lxme _~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
vccc
Eg~fmn lmx Ic~gxd~wxg Xg|cgq
Gv~g`sc|gsgdxofgsqgxgom`nwo~gn~fxmwaf`wegxmwsnd~dhdsgsd`nnmoweg`~sdoxmss
d|dxcg~mllcgins)c`oiwnc`afgdi~f)smocdisocg`ogs)wxhd`zid``c`ad`n~xd`szmx~d~cm`;
3nmoweg`~shgc`axg~xcg|gn)
qc~f?77c`oiwngnc`~fglc`dixg|cgqWsc`a~qmom`ogz~wdilxdegqmxks)D@AGIM&d`discsaxcnlmxg`|cxm`eg`~sic`kgn~mmhgsc~#d`n_NGFZ&smocding~gxec`d`~smlfgdi~f
d`ng`|cxm`eg`~difgdi~fzxmem~cm`#)diinmoweg`~sqgxgomngnlmxxgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg
~zgsmlg`|cxm`eg`~&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#d`nig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~
&sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwx&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dx#mxhmn
qgcaf~Lc`nc`aslxme~fgsgig|gisd`nmw~omeghgfd|cmwxsqgxgsweedxcrgnd`noxmss
~dhwid~gnqc~fkgdx~coigtwdic~c`ncod~mxs~mng~gxec`g~fgs~xg`a~fml~fgg|cng`og
ad~fgxgnlmxgdofsgo~cm`^mdsscs~qc~fzw~~c`a~fglc`nc`asc`~mom`~gv~)d`d`discs
mlzmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~sqdsom`nwo~gn)dim`aqc~fdswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`n
ngocscm`edkgxsqfmd~~g`ngnd~fc`k~d`km`mhgsc~c`Mo~mhgx8::7
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
18/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
19/126
Dhs~xdo~
v|
Dhs~xdo~
Xd~cm`dig2^mnd~g)g|cng`ogm`s~xwo~wxgsmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sd`ncezicod~cm`s
lmxmhgsc~xd~gsfd|g`m~hgg swhbgo~~mss~ged~coxg|cgq^fgg|cng`oghdsglmxgllgo~c|g
g`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`scsg|g`igssqgiingic`gd~gn
Zwxzmsg2^mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrgg|cng`ogm`d#s~xwo~wxdid`nomeew`c~ig|gi
ofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s~fd~zxmem~gmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~f
qgcaf~sd`nh#~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~wxhd`zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a
fgdi~fqgcaf~s
Eg~fmn2Gv~g`sc|gsgdxofgsqgxgom`nwo~gn~fxmwaf`wegxmwsnd~dhdsgsd`nnmoweg`~s;
3nmoweg`~shgc`axg~xcg|gn)
qc~f?77c`oiwngnc`~fglc`dixg|cgqWsc`a~qmom`ogz~wdilxdegqmxks)diinmoweg`~s
qgxgomngnlmxxgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg ~zgsmlg`|cxm`eg`~&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)
smocmowi~wxdi#d`nig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~&sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwx
&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#mxhmnqgcaf~^mdsscs~qc~fzw~~c`a
~fglc`nc`asc`~mom`~gv~)d`d`discsmlzmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~sqdsom`nwo~gn)dim`a
qc~fdswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxsqfmd~~g`ngnd~fc`k~d`km`mhgsc~
c`Mo~mhgxml8::7
Xgswi~s2^fgd`discsxgswi~gnc`4)?87lc`nc`as)qc~f~fgedbmxc~omec`alxmexgsgdxof
xgid~gn~mzfscodido~c|c~&`5148#d`nncg~&`5?>3#^fgs~xm`ags~ig|gismlg|cng`og
lmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxmxhmnqgcaf~qgxg
mhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi&ncg~#)smocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)mhgsc~-fgdi~f
qgcaf~s#d`ngom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#sg~~c`asd`n
zfscodi&zfscodido~c|c~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#
d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#sgo~mxs\gxic~~ig
g|cng`oggvcs~gnlmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s
&sgg~dhigs8d`n?m`zdag81#
Ml~fgxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxsqgswx|ggn)ems~xgszm`ngn~fd~wxhd`ngsca`
csswgsd`ndoogsschcic~mlzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgs&edc`ic`~fg
zfscodisg~~c`ad`nzfscodisgo~mx#qgxg~fgems~cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~f
hmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~Xgszm`ng`~sdismlgi~~fd~~fgsgldo~mxsomwin
hgdnnxgssgnhzmicoxgszm`sgs)hw~`mszgoclcoxgomeeg`nd~cm`sqgxgzxm|cngn
Qc~fxgadxn~m~fgzmicod`discs)didxag`wehgxmlzmicoxgszm`sgsqgxgcng`~clcgn
c`xgid~cm`~mmhgsc~d`n~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)hw~xgid~c|gilgqfd|ghgg`ss~ged~codii
~gs~gn^fws)c`dnnc~cm`~mdadzc`k`mqignagdhmw~~fgomezigvxgid~cm`sfczsdem`a
ldo~mxsom`~xchw~c`a~mmhgsc~)~fgxgcsdismdk`mqignagadzdhmw~~fgcezdo~mlzmsschig
zmicoxgszm`sgs
Om`oiwscm`s2_megg|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s)cezicod~c`a
c`~gx|g`~cm`sc`zmicod`nzxdo~cogFmqg|gx)idokmlg|cng`ogm`gllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`s
d`nzmicoc`c~cd~c|gsswaags~sd`ggnlmxxgsgdxof~mlciik`mqignagadzs
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
20/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
21/126
Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n
4
4 Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n
4.4 C`~xmnwo~cm`
^fgxdzcnxcsgc`mhgsc~c`Od`dndm|gx~fgzds~~qmngodngs4)8fdsign~mdsg`sg
mlwxag`o
dem`a
zxdo~c~cm`gxs
d`n
zmico
edkgxs
dxmw`n
~fg
`ggn
lmx
emxg
gllgo~c|g
dzzxmdofgs~mmhgsc~zxg|g`~cm`.C`oxgdsc`ai)d`nzgxfdzsc`~wc~c|gi)zwhicofgdi~f
xgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm edkgxsfd|gd~~xchw~gn~fggegxac`amhgsc~gzcngeco~mxdzcn
ofd`agsc`smocdid`nzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~s?d`nfd|godiignlmxdhxmdngxewi~cig|gi
dzzxmdof~mzxg|g`~cm`._wofd`dzzxmdofdnnxgssgszmicod`ng`|cxm`eg`~dildocic~d~mxs
mlmhgsmag`co&mhgsc~zxmem~c`a#hgfd|cmwxs&lmxgvdezig)zmmxncg~d`nsgng`~dx
hgfd|cmwx#._g|gxdizxmec`g`~xgsgdxofgxsedkgomezgiic`adxaweg`~s~fd~~fgg`|cxm`eg`~
ng~gxec`gs~fgzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~c`dzmzwid~cm`d`n~fd~hxmdng`|cxm`eg`~di
c`~gx|g`~cm`ssfmwinhgemxggllgo~c|g~fd`c`nc|cnwdihdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`xgnwoc`a
~fgzmzwid~cm`hwxng`mlmhgsc~.?1Sg~ic~~igxgsgdxofcsd|dcidhigm`g`|cxm`eg`~di
c`liwg`ogsm`mhgsc~>d`n~fd~qfcofcsk`mq`csc`lgxxgnlxmegzcngecmimacodid`n
owi~wxdimhsgx|d~cm`s.^mnd~g)g|cng`ogm ~fgofd`ac`as~xwo~wxgsmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~s
d`ncezicod~cm`slmxmhgsc~xd~gsfds`m~hgg swhbgo~~mdss~ged~coxg|cgq.^fgg|cng`og
hdsglmx~fgzxmogssd`nmw~omegsmlcezigeg`~c`agllgo~c|gg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`s
csg|g`igssqgiingic`gd~gn.C~cs~fgsgadzsc`k`mqignag~fd~qciihgdnnxgssgnh~fcs
_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgq.
4.8 _~d~geg`~ ml Zwxzmsg
Zwxzmsg2^fgzwxzmsgml~fg_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqcs~mxg|cgqd`ns`~fgscrg
g|cng`oglxmexgsgdxofd`naxgic~gxd~wxgm`2
s~xwo~wxdi
d`n
omeew`c~
ig|gi
ofdxdo~gxcs~cos
ml
wxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~s
~fd~
zxmem~g
mxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s;d`n
~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdsscs~zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fqgcaf~s.^fgzwxzmsglmiimqsncxgo~ilxme~fgOd`dncd Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|gs&OZFC#
s~d~gnxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`2
^mqfd~gv~g`~nms~xwo~wxdimxomeew`c~ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sg`omwxdagmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~fqgcaf~s=
4.? Om`ogz~wdi Lxdegqmxk
^fg_~d~g
ml
~fg
G|cng`og
Xg|cgq
qds
awcngn
h
c`~gaxd~c`a
~qm
om`ogz~wdi
lxdegqmxks.
^fglcxs~)swaags~gnhOZFC)cs~fg_ofwird`n@mx~fxcnagemngimlsmocding~gxec`d`~s
mlfgdi~fd`ng`|cxm`eg`~difgdi~fzxmem~cm`&_NGFZ#.6^fg_NGFZemngingsoxchgs
lw`ndeg`~di&edoxm#)c`~gxegncd~g&egsm-omeew`c~#d`nzxmvced~g&ecoxm-c`~gxzgxsm`di#
ig|gismlc`liwg`ogm`~fgfgdi~fmlzmzwid~cm`s.^fgsgom`n)ng|gimzgnszgoclcodii
lmxmhgsc~)csk`mq`dsD@AGIM&d`discsaxcnlmxg`|cxm`eg`~sic`kgn~mmhgsc~#
h_qc`hwx`g~di.1d`ncsfgizlwilmxw`ngxs~d`nc`axgid~cm`sfczshg~qgg g`|cxm`eg`~s
d`nmhgsc~xgig|d`~hgfd|cmwxs&swofdslmmnc`~dkgd`nzfscodido~c|c~#.
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
22/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
8
Hdsgnwzm`~fgGzcngecmimacodi^xcdn)~fghdscozxgecsgml~fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxk
cs~fd~~fgg`|cxm`eg`~c`liwg`ogshmnqgcaf~~fxmwafg`gxac`~dkgd`ng`gxa
gvzg`nc~wxg)qfcof_qc`hwx`d`nomiigdawgs1odii|go~mxsmxegncd~mxs^fgD@AGIM
lxdegqmxkcsd8v>axcnngsoxchc`ag`|cxm`eg`~shscrg&ecoxm-sg~~c`asmxedoxm-sgo~mxs#
d`n~zg&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#Qc~fc`~fgaxcn)gigeg`~sdllgo~c`a
lmmnc`~dkg&LC#d`nzfscodido~c|c~&ZD#dxgofdxdo~gxcrgndsmhgsmag`comxigz~mag`co
&zxmem~c`aigd``gss#Qfcig~fg_NGFZemngifds`m~hgg`|dicnd~gnqc~fxgszgo~
~mmhgsc~)c~nmgszxm|cngdwsglwilxdegqmxklmxmxad`crc`azm~g`~cdig`|cxm`eg`~di
ng~gxec`d`~smlfgdi~fs~d~ws)c`oiwnc`amhgsc~^fg_NGFZemngicsdism`m~icec~gn
~mncg~dxd`nZDhgfd|cmwxsC~qdsgssg`~cdi~fd~~fgxg|cgqgv~g`nhgm`nd`d`discs
mlg`|cxm`eg`~ding~gxec`d`~smlhgfd|cmwxs)ds~fgg`|cxm`eg`~edhgom`~xchw~c`a
~mmhgsc~~fxmwafdi~gx`d~g)g~~mhgngic`gd~gnegofd`cses^fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxk
csomezigeg`~dx)c`~fd~~fgig|gismlc`liwg`og&edoxmd`necoxm#dxgomezdxdhig~m~fg
_NGFZsc`~gxegncd~gd`nzxmvced~gig|gis~fd~OZFCfdscng`~clcgndsems~xgig|d`~~m
~fgxg|cgqhgodwsgml~fgcxemnclcdhcic~^fgD@AGIMlxdegqmxkdnns|dicnc~)c`~fd~
c~fdshgg`zcim~gnd~~fgzmzwid~cm`ig|gi1lmxwsgc`zxcmxc~crc`ac`~gx|g`~cm`shxd~c`a
lmx|dicnc~&g|cng`ogmlcezdo~#)xgig|d`og&~mimodiom`~gv~#d`nzm~g`~cdiofd`agdhcic~
G`|cxm`eg`~di
_crg-^zgZfscodi Gom`meco Zmic~codi _mocm%Owi~wxdi
Doogsschcic~ ~m lmmnsgx|cog mw~ig~s
&lmx gvdezig)xgs~dwxd`~s#
Dllmxndhcic~ ml lmmnsgx|cog mw~ig~s
_ofmmi lmmnmx zfscodi do~c|c~
zmicocgs
Doogz~dhcic~ml do~c|g
~xd`szmx~d~cm`&ooic`a) qdikc`a#
Doogsschcic~ ~m lmmnxg~dci mzzmx~w`c~cgs
&lmx gvdezig)swzgxedxkg~s#
Dllmxndhcic~ ml lmmnxg~dci mzzmx~w`c~cgs
Qmxk%sc~g lmmnmx zfscodi do~c|c~
zmicocgs
Ldeci xmigemngis lmx lmmn
d`n do~c|c~zd~~gx`s
Doogsschcic~ ~m
xgoxgd~cm`di ldocic~cgs
Dllmxndhcic~ ml
xgoxgd~cm`di ldocic~cgs
D|dcidhcic~ ml
fgdi~f%xgid~gnsgx|cogs
G~f`co d`n owi~wxdi
ngemaxdzfcos ml`gcafhmwxfmmns
@wehgx d`n twdic~ml qdikc`a zd~fs
d`n ooigqds
Ncxgo~ edxkg~c`aml lmmn zxmnwo~s c`
sofmmis &lmx gvdezig)|g`nc`a edofc`gs#
Oc|co zdx~coczd~cm` Oxceg d`n sdlg~
_g~~c`as&omeew`c~%
ig|gi#
D|dcidhcic~ ml ~xd`sc~d`n ~xd`sc~ s~mzs
@gcafhmwxfmmnsmocm%gom`meco s~d~ws&c`omeg) gnwod~cm`)
gezimeg`~#
Wxhd` ngsca` Edxkg~ lmxogs
&lmx gvdezig)lmmn zxmnwo~cm`)
ncs~xchw~cm`) zxcog#
_mocm%gom`meco
gtwc~
Aimhdicrd~cm`
^gof`mima
d`n dw~med~cm`
^dvd~cm` d`n
swhscncgs &lmmnzxcog s~xwo~wxg#
Owi~wxdi
doogz~dhcic~ml m|gxqgcaf~
^dhig4
Om`ogz~wdi
Lxdegqmxk
lmx Xg|cgq
_go~mxs
&s~xwo~wxdi#
^xd`szmx~d~cm`
ss~ges
Lw`nc`a lmx
gnwod~cm`)fgdi~f d`n smocdi
sgx|cog ss~ges
Egncd-dn|gx~csc`a
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
23/126
Zxmbgo~ Hdokaxmw`n
?
_c`oggdoflxdegqmxkwsgssicaf~incllgxg`~~gxes~mcng`~clig|gismlg`|cxm`eg`~di
c`liwg`og)qgfd|gofmsg`~mwsgoigdxid`awdagqc~f~gxes~fd~dxgngsoxcz~c|g~mdqcng
|dxcg~mls~dkgfmingxs^fws)D@AGIMsecoxmd`n_NGFZszxmvced~gig|gis
dxg`mq~gxegnsg~~c`asd`nxglgx~mc`nc|cnwdid`nomeew`c~ig|gig`|cxm`eg`~s
_g~~c`asdxgwswdiiagmaxdzfcodiincs~c`o~)dxgxgid~c|gisedii)d`ndxgzm~g`~cdii
c`liwg`ognhc`nc|cnwdis1_cecidxi)D@AGIMsedoxmd`n_NGFZsc`~gxegncd~g
ig|gisdxg`mq~gxegnsgo~mxsd`nxglgx~memxgs~xwo~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~s&^dhig4#
C`ag`gxdi)sgo~mxsdxgomeem`~m~fgqcngxzmzwid~cm`)ml~g`mzgxd~c`ad~xgacm`di)
`d~cm`di)d`nc`~gx`d~cm`diig|gis)d`n~g`n~mhgagmaxdzfcodiincllwsg1
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
24/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
25/126
Eg~fmnmima
7
8 Eg~fmnmima
^fcs_~d~gml~fgG|cng`ogXg|cgqg`omezdssgn~fxggomezm`g`~sLcxs~)dss~ged~co
xg|cgqmlzwhicsfgnd`naxgic~gxd~wxgqdsom`nwo~gn_gom`n)zmicoxgig|d`~nmoweg`~s
qgxgxg|cgqgn~mag~dsg`sgml~fgzmicoom`~gv~c`qfcofwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~dic`liwg`ogs
mlmhgsc~mzgxd~g^fcxn)xgig|d`~ngocscm`edkgxsqgxgom`swi~gn~mad~fgx~fgcxc`zw~
m`~fgxg|cgqd`nfmqc~slc`nc`asedxgid~g~mowxxg`~zmicocgsd`nzxdo~cog
8.4 _s~ged~co Ic~gxd~wxg Xg|cgq
^fgss~ged~coic~gxd~wxgxg|cgq~mmkzidogc`sg|gxdis~dags)zxmaxgssc`alxmec`c~cdi
ic~gxd~wxgsgdxofgs~mdx~coigdssgsseg`~s^fgidxag|miwegmlic~gxd~wxgxg~xcg|gnnwxc`a
~fgsgdxofgs`gogssc~d~gndewi~cs~dagsoxgg`c`azxmogss)axdzfcodiixgzxgsg`~gnh~fg
zxmbgo~limqofdx~c`Dzzg`ncvD
844 Ic~gxd~wxg_gdxof_~xd~ga
^fglcxs~s~dagml~fgss~ged~coxg|cgqqds~mcng`~cldzzxmzxcd~gic~gxd~wxgnd~dhdsgs
~msgdxofW~cicrc`a~fggvzgx~csgmlIc`nd_id~gx)dichxdxcd`skciignc`ic~gxd~wxgsgdxof
~gof`ctwgsd`ns~xd~gacgs)dzzxmzxcd~ghmncgsmlic~gxd~wxgqgxgcng`~clcgnDsgdxof
mled`nd~dhdsgsqdsom`nwo~gn~mcng`~cls~wncgsdnnxgssc`a~fgxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`s
Nd~dhdsgsqgxgsgdxofgnlxme~fgnd~gml~fgcxc`ogz~cm &lmxgvdezig)EGNIC@G
lxme43
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
26/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
::zgxsm`szgxstwdxgkcimeg~xg)hdsgnm`~fgowxxg`~
og`swszmzwid~cm`omw`~D`~gxxc~mxmw~scngmlwxhd`dxgdscsoidssclcgndsxwxdi3
Hgodwsg~fgxgdxged`ncllgxg`~nglc`c~cm`smlwxhd`d`nxwxdidxmw`n~fgqmxin)
~fcsnglc`c~cm qdswsgndsdawcngxd~fgx~fd`d`dhsmiw~gs~d`ndxnIc~gxd~wxgfdn~mxgzmx~
m`nd~domiigo~gnc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~mxzxm|cnghxgdknmq`smlnd~dsm~fd~wxhd`
szgoclcolc`nc`asqgxgdzzdxg`~C`lmxed~cm`m`~fghxmdngxs~wnsg~~c`aqdsxdxgiac|g`)
w`igssc~qdsdedbmxzdx~ml~fgdx~coigc~sgil;~fgxglmxg)c`~fgedbmxc~mlodsgs)xg|cgqgxsnglgxxgnbwnaeg`~ml~fcsoxc~gxcm`~mqfd~qdss~d~gnh~fgdw~fmxsml~fgdx~coig
^fgxgid~c|gimzg`g`ngnsgdxofs~xd~gaw`ngx~dkg`c`~fcsxg|cgqxgswi~gnc`dx~coigs
mled`ncllgxg`~lmxed~shgc`axg~xcg|gnEd`ml~fgdx~coigs)swofds~gof`codixgzmx~s
mxmingxbmwx`di~c~igs)ncn`m~fd|gdhs~xdo~s~mhgsod``gn^fcsxgtwcxgn~fd~~fgdx~coig
hglmw`nc`c~sg`~cxg~d`nswhbgo~gn~m~fgsdegdssgsseg`~zxmognwxgng~dcigndhm|g
84> Ic~gxd~wxgLwiiXg|cgq
^fglwiixg|cgqml~fglc`diic~gxd~wxgsgigo~cm`sc`|mi|gn~qmncs~c`o~zxmogssgs^fglcxs~
zxmogssg`~dcign
zwiic`a
c`nc|cnwdi
lc`nc`as
lxme
gdof
dx~coig
w`ngx
xg|cgq)
qc~f
~fg
omngn
lc`nc`as~fg`hgc`aomezcignd`nd`dirgn^fgsgom`nc`|mi|gndssgssc`a~fgc`nc|cnwdi
dx~coigslmxtwdic~)c`oiwnc`axd~c`asmlsg|gxdioxc~codidx~coiglgd~wxgsd`nomnc`aml~fg
s~wnngsca`^fcsdiimqgn~fgdw~fmxs~medkgdtwdiclcgndssgsseg`~ds~m~fgs~xg`a~f
ml~fglc`nc`asc`d`~mzcodxgdHgodwsgs~wncgsml~g`om`~dc`gnlc`nc`asm`emxg~fd`
m`g~mzcodxgdd`n-mxom`~dc`gnewi~cziglc`nc`asqc~fc`d~mzco)~fglc`nc`axd~fgx~fd`
~fgs~wnqds~fgw`c~mld`discsc`~fcsxg|cgq
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
28/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
6
Omnc`aDx~coigLc`nc`as^mzxm|cngdsweedxmlqfd~csk`mq`d`nw`k`mq`dhmw~~fgdssmocd~cm hg~qgg
~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s)lc`nc`asd`nm~fgxofdxdo~gxcs~cosqgxg
omngnd`nswhbgo~gn~mdlxgtwg`od`discs.Dx~coigsqgxgomngnlmxofdxdo~gxcs~cos
ml~fg
sdezig
zmzwid~cm`)
g`|cxm`eg`~
scrg
d`n
~zg)
ncxgo~cm
ml
lc`nc`a-mw~omeg)
s~wnngsca`d`ns~wntwdic~&sggDzzg`ncvO#.
Ofdxdo~gxcs~cosml~fgsdezigzmzwid~cm`Dagaxmwz)g~f`coofdxdo~gxcs~cosd`nag`ngx
qgxgomngnqc~fgdoflc`nc`a.
G`|cxm`eg`~scrgd`n~zgDoomxnc`a~m~fgD@AGIMaxcn)~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~
gigeg`~sc`~fgic~gxd~wxgqgxgomngnlmx~fgscrg&sg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#)~zg&zfscodi)
gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#d`nszgoclcolgd~wxg&lmxgvdezig)~xd`szmx~d~cm`#.
Ncxgo~cm mllc`nc`a-mw~omeg^fgncxgo~cm ml~fgdssmocd~cm mxgllgo~qdsomngn
dslmiimqs2
:5`mdssmocd~cm
45c`|gxsgdssmocd~cm
85ncxgo~zmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm
?5wsfdzgndssmocd~cm
^fg`wehgxmllc`nc`asxgzmx~c`adzdx~cowidxzd~~gx`qgxg~fg`omw`~gn.^fcscsscecidx
~mdzxmognwxgwsgnh_mhdid`n_~w`kdxn4:c`dxg|cgqmlsmocmgom`mecos~d~ws
d`nmhgsc~.
Ngsca`^fgngsca`ml~fgs~wnqdsxd~gndoomxnc`a~mod~gamxcrd~cm`smlg|cng`og
zxgsg`~gnhZfciz244
D45_s~ged~coxg|cgqsqfcofc`oiwngd~igds~m`gxd`nmecrgnom`~xmiign~xcdi
D85M~fgxss~ged~cod`nfcaftwdic~xg|cgqs
H45C`nc|cnwdixd`nmecrgnom`~xmiign~xcdis)xd`nmecrgngvzgxceg`~dis~wncgsH85@m`xd`nmecrgn)gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs
H?5Qgiingsca`gn)`m`gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs)om`~xmiigns~d~cs~codiicldzzxmzxcd~g;
dismc`oiwngqgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs
O45Ngsoxcz~c|gd`nm~fgxxgsgdxof&lmxgvdezig)om`|g`cg`ogsdezigs#`m~c`H
O85Odsgs~wncgsd`ngvdezigsmlammnzxdo~cog
^fcsdzzxmdofqdsdnmz~gnhgodwsgc~diimqss~wncgsqc~fncllgxg`~ngsca`s)c`oiwnc`a
ss~ged~coxg|cgqsd`ntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs)~mhgc`oiwngnc`~fgsdegd`discs.C~csdism
om`scs~g`~qc~fdlxdegqmxk~fd~fdshgg`zxmzmsgnlmx~xd`sid~c`amhgsc~xgid~gn
g|cng`ogc`~mdo~cm`.48
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
29/126
Eg~fmnmima
3
Dx~coiglgd~wxgtwdic~Hdsgnwzm`~fg`wehgxml~fxgd~s~mc`~gx`di-gv~gx`di|dicnc~)
~fgs~wncgsqgxgxd~gnlmxtwdic~^fcscsscecidx~m~fgdzzxmdofwsgnc`~fgss~ged~co
xg|cgqszxgsg`~gnc ~fgAwcng~mOmeew`c~Zxg|g`~c|g_gx|cogs4?Dsgigo~cm`mllmwxoxc~gxcd
&eg~fmn)sdezic`a)d`discsd`nxgswi~s#qdsgvdec`gn~mdiimqd`dssgsseg`~mltwdic~
doxmss~fcshxmdnxd`agmls~wn~zgsd`nngsca`s4>^fgoxc~gxcdqgxgxd~gnm`dlmwxzmc`~
sodigxd`ac`alxmeAmmn&4#~m\gxZmmx&>#^fgxd~c`asqgxg~fg`sweegndoxmss
~fgedbmxdx~coiglgd~wxgsd`n~fgs~wncgsxd`kgndoomxnc`a~m~fgcxxgid~c|gsomxgDs~wn
qdsnggegn~mhgmlammntwdic~clc~dofcg|gndsomxgml>mx7)mlldcxtwdic~clc~xgogc|gn
dsomxghg~qgg
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
30/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
4:
d~demxgag`gxdiig|gi;lmxgvdezig)qfd~dxgsmegml~fgszgoclcozmzwid~cm`s~fd~dxg
dssgssgnh~fcs~zgmlxgsgdxof=D~~fghgfd|cmwx-mw~omegig|gi)~xg`nsqc~fc`gdof
ml~fglmwxmw~omegaxmwzsod`hggvdec`gn)qfcig`wehgxsd~~fgsg~~c`a-sgo~mxig|gi
hgac ~mzxm|cngd`c`ncod~cm`mlqfgxg~fgg`|cxm`eg`~hgfd|cmwxc`~gxdo~cm`sdxg~dkc`a
zidogNd~dd~~fgszgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~diig|gidiimqdaicezsgc`~m~fgm`~fgaxmw`n
mhsgx|d~cm`sd`nc`~gx|g`~cm`s~fd~xgsgdxofgxsfd|gnmoweg`~gnDsxgswi~sdxg|cgqgn
doxmss~fgsglmwxig|gis)zd~~gx`som`ogx`c`a~fgncs~xchw~cm`mlzmzwid~cm`s)hxmdnd`n
szgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~sd`n~zgsmls~wncgsod`hgng~gxec`gn
Oxmss~dhwid~cm`sqgxgzgxlmxegn~mgicoc~emxgszgoclcoc`lmxed~cm`dhmw~~fg
dssmocd~cm`shg~qgg kg|dxcdhigsd~|dxcmwsig|gismld`discs&sggLcawxg4#_zgoclcodii
mlc`~gxgs~fgxgqgxg~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~slmw`nc`~fgic~gxd~wxg
d`n~fghgfd|cmwxs-mw~omegsmw~ic`gndhm|g)dsqgiids~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg ~fgsg
g`|cxm`eg`~sd`nhmnqgcaf~Mllwx~fgxc`~gxgs~qgxg~fgdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg
hgfd|cmwxs-mw~omegsd`nhmnqgcaf~qc~fc ~fgsgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sOxmss~dhwid~cm`s
qgxgodiowid~gnqc~fc`d`nhg~qgg sg|gxdiidgxsmlnd~d)~mciiwec`d~gd`dssmocd~cm`s~fgxgc`;lmxgvdezig)~fgtwdic~ml~fgs~wncgsgvdec`c`a~fgzfscodisg~~c`aqc~fc`~fg
lmmn-ncg~-`w~xc~cm mw~omegmx~fgncxgo~cm mllc`nc`asxgid~c|g~m~fgszgoclcog`|cxm`eg`~s
lmw`nqc~fc`dsgo~mxml~fgzfscodido~c|c~mw~omeg^fgng~dci~fd~~fgsgs~d~cs~cos
zxm|cngcsgssg`~cdi~mw`ngxs~d`nc`a~fgc`~gxdo~cm`shg~qgg ~fged`ofdxdo~gxcs~cos
d`n~fged`g`|cxm`eg`~diig|gisd~qfcof~fgc`liwg`oghgfd|cmwxsd`nhmnqgcaf~s
Lcawxg4
^fgmxg~codi
Emngi
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
31/126
Eg~fmnmima
44
Ig|gismlG|cng`og
M`ogdiis~wncgsfdnhgg`omngnd`nofgokgnlmxxgicdhcic~)~fmsg~fd~qgxgxd~gnds
gc~fgxd`DmxHw`ngx~fg_~wnNgsca`sgo~cm`ml~fgdssgsseg`~~mmi)d`nxd~gnldcx
mxammndoomxnc`a~m~fgtwdic~xd~c`as)qgxgdaaxgad~gndoomxnc`a~m~fgncxgo~cm`
ml~fglc`nc`as-mw~omegd`nqc~fc`~fg|dxcmwsig|gisml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~&sg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxs#^fg`)dng~gxec`d~cm mlmwxom`lcng`ogc`~fgg|cng`ogqdsedngdslmiimqs2
om`|c`oc`a)zxmhdhig)zmsschig)c`swllcocg`~mx`mg|cng`og^fgsgod~gamxcgslmxig|gisml
g|cng`ogdxgscecidx~m~fmsgng|gimzgnh~fgQmxinOd`ogxXgsgdxofLw`n-Degxcod
C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof47d`nxgog`~idndz~gnh_qc`hwx`)Od~gxsm`)_gcngiid`n
Bdegs4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
32/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
48
_~dkgfmingxsqfmd~~g`ngnDnnxgssc`aMhgsc~c`Od`dnd2D^fc`k^d`km`_gigo~gnZmico
XgsgdxofZxcmxc~cgsc`^mxm`~m)M`~dxcm)c`Mo~mhgx8::7qgxgom`~do~gn~msmicoc~~fgcx
zdx~coczd~cm c`d`m`ic`gswx|g^fcs~fc`k~d`kqdsd~~g`ngnhm|gx3:xgsgdxofgxs
d`nngocscm`edkgxsd`nqdsfms~gnh~fgFgdx~d`n_~xmkgLmw`nd~cm`)~fgOd`dncd`
Zmzwid~cm`Fgdi~fC`c~cd~c|g&OZFC#)~fgOd`dncd`C`s~c~w~gsmlFgdi~fXgsgdxof&OCFX#
d`n~fgOfxm`coNcsgdsgZxg|g`~cm Diicd`ogmlOd`dnd&ONZDO#D`gedciig~~gxqds
sg`~~mdii~fmsgqfmd~~g`ngn~fgsezmscweD`c`~xmnwo~cm`~mmwxs~wnqdsedng
c dig~~gx)d`ndWXIic`kqdszxm|cngndim`aqc~fd`c`|c~d~cm ~mlciimw~d m`ic`gswx|g
^fgtwgs~cm``dcxgomezxcsgnlmwxtwgs~cm`s2
4 Lxmemwxzgxszgo~c|g)ics~wz~m?&~fxgg#ldo~mxs~fd~dxgems~ickgi~mfd|gd`cezdo~m`fgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~
8 Dxg~fgldo~mxsics~gnc`Twgs~cm`4emnclcdhighdzmicoxgszm`sg=Zigdsgofmmsggs)`m)mx`m~swxglmxgdofldo~mx~fd~mwics~gnc`Twgs~cm 4
? Ics~wz~m?&~fxgg#zmicocgs-zxmaxdes-c`c~cd~c|gs~fd~mwk`mqml~fd~gvcs~c`-lmxwxhd`dxgds~mdsscs~zmzwid~cm`sc`dofcg|c`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~s
> Dxgmwdqdxgmlg|cng`ogxgadxnc`a~fgoms~gllgo~c|g`gssml~fgzmicocgs-zxmaxdes-c`c~cd~c|gsmwics~gnc`Twgs~cm`?=Zigdsgofmmsggs)`m)mx`m~swxglmxgdof
c~gemwics~gnc`Twgs~cm`?
^fglwiiswx|gdsc~dzzgdxgnm`ic`gcsc`Dzzg`ncvNG~fcosdzzxm|dilmx~fgswx|g
qdsmh~dc`gnlxme~fgW`c|gxsc~mlDihgx~dFgdi~fXgsgdxofG~fcosHmdxn
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
33/126
Xgswi~s
4?
? Xgswi~s
?.4 Ic~gxd~wxg _gdxof d`n Xg|cgq Zxmogss
^fgxdqic~gxd~wxgsgdxofgsxg|gdign
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
34/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
4>
?88 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s
Dfcafzxmzmx~cm`&>1'#mls~wncgsm`~fgzfscodisg~~c`almw`n`msca`clcod`~dssmocd~cm`
qc~fmhgsc~
mx
fgdi~f
qgcaf~s
^fmsg
s~wncgs
~fd~
ngsoxchgn
dsca`clcod`~
dssmocd~cm`
&7?'#
qgxgszic~g|g`ihg~qgg dzmsc~c|g&81'#d`n`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`&87'#
Hwci~G`|cxm`eg`~d`nId`nWsgEcv
Dzzxmvced~gifdilml~fgzfscodisg~~c`alc`nc`as&71'#qgxgxgid~gn~m~fghwci~
g`|cxm`eg`~)swofdsc`~gxsgo~cm`ng`sc~)xgscng`~cding`sc~d`nid`nwsgecvEms~
ml~fgsglc`nc`asomeglxme~fxggs~wncgs4143^fgc`om`scs~g`ocgsc`~fgxgswi~seg`~cm`gn
zxg|cmwsiod`c`zdx~hggvzidc`gnhg~f`coc~43mxhsgv41C`~fcsxgadxn)c~ed
hg|gxncllcowi~~mag`gxdicrg~fgxgswi~smlc`nc|cnwdis~wncgsLmxgvdezig)c`ds~wn
hLxd`kg~di43hdsgnm`doxmsssgo~cm`dis~wnml~fgoc~mlD~id`~d)daxgd~gxid`nwsg
ecvdem`axgscng`~cdi)omeegxocdi)mllcogd`nc`s~c~w~cm`diqdsdssmocd~gnqc~fdimqgx
zxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~dem`aOdwodscd`s)hw~ncn`m~xgdofs~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogdem`aDlxcod`Degxcod`s^fcss~wndismswaags~gn~fd~fcafgxxgscng`~cding`sc~d`n
c`~gxsgo~cm`ng`sc~qgxgdssmocd~gnqc~fdxgnwognzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~C~qdszxmzmsgn
~fd~~fgsgdssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~dxgegncd~gnhaxgd~gxdemw`~smlqdikc`azgxnd
d`nigss~cegszg`~c`dodx_wxzxcsc`ai)m~fgxs~wncgsfd|gsfmq`~fd~doogss~mdodx
csdssmocd~gnqc~fdimqgxzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~8:Fmqg|gx)dsncsowssgnc`~fglmiimqc`a
sgo~cm`m`~fggom`mecosg~~c`a)~fcsedhgxgid~gn~msmocmgom`mecos~d~ws&_G_#
Qdikdhcic~d`nD|dcidhcic~mlLdocic~cgs
Gig|g`lc`nc`aslxmelc|gs~wncgs8:8>qgxgsmegqfd~gtwc|modic`~fgcxswzzmx~lmx~fg
dssmocd~cm`hg~qgg hmnqgcaf~d`nqdikdhcic~d`ndoogss~mldocic~cgsDoomxnc`a
~mds~wnc`|mi|c`almowsaxmwzs)8?d`m~fgxgigeg`~ml~fgzfscodisg~~c`a~fd~omwin
c`liwg`ogofcinxg`sHECsc`wxhd`sg~~c`asqds~fgzxgsg`ogmldsdlgzidog~mzid
c`imqc`omeg`gcafhmwxfmmnsM`~fgm~fgxfd`n)doxmsssgo~cm`dis~wnc`Oc`oc``d~c84
lmw`n`mdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ofcinm|gxqgcaf~d`nzxmvcec~~mzidaxmw`ns)zxmvcec~
~mlds~lmmnxgs~dwxd`~smxig|giml`gcafhmwxfmmnoxceg
_ofmmiG`|cxm`eg`~
Qc~fc`~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~)4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
35/126
Xgswi~s
47
Lgqlc`nc`asqgxgd|dcidhigngsoxchc`a~fgdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s
d`n~fgzfscodisgo~mx_cvml~fgsg|g lc`nc`asc ~fcssgo~mxodeglxmeds~wnhImzgr83
^fgnd~dc`~fcss~wnqgxghdsgnm`szxdqic`ngv|diwgsodiowid~gn)doomxnc`a~m~fg
8:::og`sws)lmxm|gx?::eg~xmzmic~d dxgdsdoxmss~fgW`c~gn_~d~gsDl~gxom`~xmiic`a
lmxag`ngx)dag)xdog-g~f`coc~)c`omegd`ngnwod~cm`)d`c`oxgdsgc`wxhd`szxdqiqds
dssmocd~gnqc~fd`c`oxgdsgnzxg|dig`ogmlm|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~83
?8? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s
Qc~fc`~fggom`mecosg~~c`a)diems~dii&61'#ml~fglc`nc`asqgxgoidssclcgndssmeg
omehc`d~cm`ml_G_)c`omeg)gnwod~cm`mxgezimeg`~s~d~wsC`ag`gxdi)s~wncgsswaags~gn
~fd~`gcafhmwxfmmns)ew`coczdic~cgsmxdxgdsofdxdo~gxcrgndsngzxc|gn?:?8mximq_G_???3gdxsmldag#?8Mwxxg|cgqcsom`scs~g`~qc~f~fgc`~gxzxg~d~cm ml~fgic~gxd~wxgh~qmxgog`~xg|cgqdx~coigs?1)?6C`ldo~)Hmm~fg~di?6swaags~~fd~imqgx_G_`gcafhmwxfmmns
dxgdzxcedxom`ogx`&z_448Mlzdx~cowidxc`~gxgs~c`~fgOd`dncd`om`~gv~)Emlld~
d`nomiigdawgszxgsg`~gn~fgxgswi~smlds~wnom`nwo~gnc`Fdeci~m`)M`~dxcm)dem`a
ofcinxg`&dags4^fcss~wnxg|gdign~fd~c`~fg~qmimq_G_sofmmisomezdxgn~m~fgfcaf_G_
sofmmi)~fgxgqgxgdzzxmvced~gi~qcogdsed`ofcinxg`c ~fgm|gxqgcaf~-mhgsgod~gamx>4
Fmqg|gx)~fgxgcssmegg|cng`og~fd~~fcsed`m~hgdw`c|gxsdilc`nc`aLmxgvdezig)
dem`adsdezigmlofcinxg`ic|c`ac`~fgEgvcomOc~dxgd)~fmsgic|c`ac`decnnigc`omeg
~mq`fdndfcafgxxcskmlhgc amhgsgqfg`omezdxgn~m~fmsgic|c`ac dimqc`omeg~mq`>?
Dslmx~fg_G_lc`nc`as)gnwod~cm`dismngem`s~xd~gnom`scs~g`~dssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~
qc~fc`~fggom`mecosgo~mxDimqgxgnwod~cm ig|giqdsdssmocd~gnqc~ffcafgxHEC)
c`ngzg`ng`~mlm~fgx_G_ldo~mxsdem`a_qgncsfdnwi~s>>Zdxg`~dignwod~cm`ig|gidism
dzzgdxs~mhgdzxgnco~mxmlmhgsc~c`mw`adnwi~fmmn>7
D c`om`scs~g`~zd~~gx`mllc`nc`ascsmhsgx|gnlmxgom`mecosgo~mx|dxcdhigsc dssmocd~cm`
qc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s^g ml7?lc`nc`as&43'#zxgsg`~gndzmsc~c|g&hg`glcocdi#
dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~)qfcig84&>:'#sfmqgnd`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`^fgcezdo~
ml_G_d`nsmocdizmsc~cm`csg|cng`~d~~fggom`mecosgo~mxig|gi)qc~fdzzxmvced~gi
fdilml~fglc`nc`as&78'#swaags~c`adsca`clcod`~`gad~c|gdssmocd~cm`Dsmzzmsgn~m~fg
sg~~c`aig|gi)_G_c`~fgsgo~mxig|gixgligo~s~fg_G_mldomeew`c~mx`gcafhmwxfmmn
d`n`m~c`nc|cnwdi_G_
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
36/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
4 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZmic~codi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s
Lc|gs~wncgsqc~fd~m~dimlsg|g`lc`nc`asqgxgoidssclcgnc`~fgzmic~codisg~~c`aLc|g
ml~fgsg|g`lc`nc`as&14'#qgxgod~gamxcrgndsfd|c`a`msca`clcod`~dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s^fg~qmm~fgxlc`nc`asqgxglxmedqmxkzidog>1d`nswaags~gnzmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`sqc~fmhgsc~d`nfgdi~fqgcaf~s
Dzxg|cmwsxg|cgqdx~coig>6cng`~clcgnomeew`c~hdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`sdcegnd~om`~xmiic`a
odxncm|dsowidxncsgdsgxcskldo~mxsswofdshmnqgcaf~)c`oiwnc`a~fg@mx~fKdxgicd~xcdi
c`Lc`id`n)~fg_~d`lmxn~fxggomeew`c~d`n~fg_~d`lmxnlc|gomeew`c~s~wncgs)~fg
Ec``gsm~dFgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxded`n~fgZdq~wokg~Fgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxdeDoomxnc`a
~m~fcsxg|cgq)smeg~xcdisxgzmx~gnzmsc~c|gxgswi~slmxofd`agc`himmnzxgsswxgmx
ofmigs~gxmi)hw~`m`gsfmqgndom`|c`oc`agllgo~m`mhgsc~
@ms~wncgsm`~fgzmic~codisgo~mxqgxgcng`~clcgn
?87 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`Mhgsc~-Fgdi~fQgcaf~s
_cecidx~ms~wncgsm`~fgzfscodisg~~c`a)s~wncgsm`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`azxgsg`~d
hxmdnxd`agmllc`nc`asD~m~diml??lc`nc`asqgxggv~xdo~gnlxme4>s~wncgsc`xgid~cm`
~msmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asDem`a~fgsglc`nc`as)dzzxmvced~gi?:'sfmqgn`msca`clcod`~
dssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~mxfgdi~fqgcaf~s
^fgg|cng`oglmx~fgc`liwg`ogmlg~f`coc~mxowi~wxdidsscecid~cm`m`mhgsc~d`nfgdi~f
qgcaf~sqdsgtwc|modiC`smegs~wncgs)hgc`aDlxcod`Degxcod`>3mxEgvcod`Degxcod`41qdsdssmocd~gnqc~fdfcafgxzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~^fgxmigmldsscecid~cm`&dismngsoxchgn
dsdoowi~wxd~cm`#d`nldecid~~c~wng~mqdxnsdsscecid~cm`dsdzxgnco~mxmlmhgsc~fds
dismhgg`gvdec`gnOwi~wxdidsscecid~cm`qdsdssmocd~gnqc~femxgmhgsc~c`Egvcod`
Degxcod`eg`)qfgxgds~fgmzzmsc~gqds~xwgc`Egvcod`Degxcod qmeg`41D`m~fgx
s~wnswaags~gn~fd~~fgdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg doowi~wxd~cm d`nHECcsqgdkd`nswhbgo~
~mowi~wxdincllgxg`ogs7:
^fglc`nc`aslxme~fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`a~fd~sfmqgn~fgems~om`scs~g`~dssmocd~cm`s
qc~fmhgsc~dxgm`gsxgid~c`a~mdn|gx~csc`ad`n~fgegncdMl~fg`c`glc`nc`asc`
dn|gx~csgeg`~d`negncd)sg|g`c`ncod~gndsca`clcod`~zmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`qc~fmhgsc~
qfcig~qmswaags~gn`mdssmocd~cm`^fgsg`c`glc`nc`asfd|ghgg`gv~xdo~gnlxme
~qms~wncgs74)78^gig|cscm`dn|gx~csgeg`~od`ld|mwxd`c`oxgdsgnom`swez~cm`mllmmn)
zdx~cowidxic`m|gxqgcaf~-mhgsgofcinxg`78M`~fgm~fgxfd`n)~gig|cscm d`n~fgegncd
dismfd|g~fgzm~g`~cdi~mfd|gdzmsc~c|gcezdo~m`hmnqgcaf~C`m`gs~wn)dsfmx~
~gxeedssegncdzxmaxdeomehc`gnqc~fsgilfgized`wdisd`nswzzmx~axmwzsign
~msca`clcod`~sfmx~~gxeqgcaf~imss74Fmqg|gx)c~cscezmx~d`~~m`m~g~fd~~fgegncd
c`~gx|g`~cm`dim`gqds`m~swoogsslwi
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
37/126
Xgswi~s
41
M`im`gs~wndnnxgssgn~fg`m~cm`mlsdlg~84C`~fcss~wnmlwxhd`&Oc`oc``d~c#
imqc`omegzxgsofmmigxs)m|gxqgcaf~qds`m~dssmocd~gnqc~f~fgig|giml
`gcafhmwxfmmnoxceg84
Di~fmwaflgqgxs~wncgsqgxgd|dcidhiglmx~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mx)ems~lc`nc`as&3>'#
qgxgs~d~cs~codiisca`clcod`~Gcaf~s~wncgsqgxgcng`~clcgnc`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mx)
qc~fd~m~diml41lc`nc`as^fgsglc`nc`asc`ncod~g~fd~imqgnwod~cm ig|gic`dnwi~s)7?
imqzdxg`~dignwod~cm`ig|gic`ofcinxg`)7>axgd~gx~gig|cscm |cgqc`a)77emxgsgng`~dx
igcswxg8?d`nEgvcod`Degxcod`g~f`coc~7
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
38/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
46
_g|gxdis~wncgsgvdec`gn~fgc`liwg`ogmlwxhd`ngsca`m`hgfd|cmwxd`nmhgsc~
mw~omegs43)8:)87))
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
39/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
40/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
8:
^fghwikml~fgsofmmig`|cxm`eg`~s~wncgsd`nlc`nc`asngdi~qc~f~fgc`liwg`og
mlg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`sm`lmmnc`~dkgDiiml~fgsgs~wncgsed`czwid~gnsmegdszgo~
ml~fgzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~swofdsd|dcidhcic~mlfgdi~fofmcogsc`|g`nc`aedofc`gs
&lmxgvdezig)Fmgxxd`nImwng`
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
41/126
Xgswi~s
84
^qms~wncgsc`|gs~cad~gn~fgxgid~cm`sfczhg~qgg lmmnd|dcidhcic~c`xgs~dwxd`~sd`n
lmmnc`~dkgLmxofcinxg`)~fg`wehgxmlegdisom`swegnc`xgs~dwxd`~s`gad~c|gi
dllgo~gnncg~twdic~
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
42/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
88
M`gml~fgidxags~sfdxgsml~fgg|cng`og&81'mllc`nc`as#ngdisqc~f~fgoms~mllmmnD~
~fg`gcafhmwxfmmnig|gi)lmmnoms~sfd|g`m~hgg`sfmq`~mhgfcafgxc`ncsdn|d`~dagn
`gcafhmwxfmmns)16di~fmwafimqgxc`omegsc`swof`gcafhmwxfmmnsedng~gxfgdi~fcgx
ofmcogsEms~lc`nc`as&7:'mllc`nc`assfmqgn
`mdssmocd~cm`s
^fg|ds~edbmxc~mls~wncgsngdi~qc~fsofmmidsdzmic~codisg~~c`a)qc~fc`~gx|g`~cm`s
c`sofmmilmmnzmicodoomw`~c`almx
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
43/126
Xgswi~s
8?
??7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`Lmmn)
Ncg~d`n@w~xc~cm`
^fgedbmxc~mls~wncgsd`nlc`nc`asxgid~gn~mlmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`gvzimxgn~fg
smocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~&47:-?>3;>?'mllc`nc`as#
_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`as
Lmx~`c`gzdzgxsd`n443lc`nc`asgvdec`gnsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asd`ndssmocd~cm`s
qc~flmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`^fgedbmxc~&14'#lmw`ndssmocd~cm`s&8:'`gad~c|g)7:'
zmsc~c|gd`n4'Wsfdzgn#hg~qgg smocmowi~wxdisg~~c`asd`nlmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`
|dxcdhigs;~fgxgedc`c`a83'lmw`n`mdssmocd~cm`s
^fgedbmxc~&7?'#mllc`nc`asgvdec`gnfmeg-ldecig`|cxm`eg`~sswofdsldeci
omezmsc~cm`&sc`aig|gxswsnwdizdxg`~;lmxgvdezig)Em`cfd`g~di443#)zgxogc|gn`mxes
mlldeciegehgxs&lmxgvdezig)Madxnd`nKigzz44:#mxxmigemngiic`ad`nd|dcidhcic~
mllmmnc`~fgfmeg48:d`n~fgcxc`liwg`ogm`lmmn)ncg~d`n`w~xc~cm`|dxcdhigs@m~dii
lmmn)`w~xc~cm`d`nncg~dx|dxcdhigsqgxgomezdxdhic`liwg`ogn;dssmocd~cm`sqgxglmw`n
lmx14'ml~fg
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
44/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
8>
D~~fgsgo~mxig|gi)~fgxmigmlegncdc`zxmem~c`adsmocmowi~wxdimhgsmag`cog`|cxm`eg`~
csigssoigdx)qc~f7:'mllc`nc`aslxmem`i~qms~wncgssfmqc`adssmocd~cm`hg~qgg
egncdgvzmswxgd`nlmmnom`swez~cm`&lmxgvdezig)Axgg`g~di4??#)di~fmwafm`gxgog`~)
qgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wn Nd~d2 Zfscodi Do~c|c~
?>4 M|gxdiiLc`nc`aslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~
^fgxg|cgqc`oiwngn418 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgZfscodi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm`ZfscodiDo~c|c~
Lcl~`c`gzgxog`~&73'#ml~fglc`nc`asqc~fc ~fgzfscodisg~~c`asfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm mxgllgo~hg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~Lmx~~qmzgxog`~&>8'#ml~fg
lc`nc`asqgxgxgid~gn~mwxhd`ngsca`)qfcigd`m~fgx84#)ed`m`idssgssgnzgxogz~cm`sml~fg
g`|cxm`eg`~c`xgid~cm`~mzfscodido~c|c~Qfcig~fcsedhgom`scngxgndicec~d~cm`)
dxgog`~eg~dd`discs?Lmxc`s~d`og)_c`g~di4>>lmw`n~fd~d`cezmx~d`~
hdxxcgx~mgvgxocsgdem`adaxmwzmlgingxiKmxgd`Degxcod`sic|c`ac`_gd~~igqds~fg
d|dcidhcic~ml~xd`szmx~d~cm`
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
45/126
Xgswi~s
87
?>? ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fgGom`meco_g~~c`ad`n_go~mxm ZfscodiDo~c|c~
Ml~fg77lc`nc`asc`~fggom`mecosg~~c`as)?7&'#sfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg
~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~@m~swxzxcsc`ai)dncs~c`o~dssmocd~cm`
gegxagnhg~qgg _G_d`nzfscodido~c|c~)qc~fimqgxc`omegc`nc|cnwdisxgzmx~c`a
emxghdxxcgxsd`nigsszdx~coczd~cm c`zfscodido~c|c~4>7)4>:)4>1^fgsglc`nc`asomwinhgm`ggvzid`d~cm lmx~fg|gxomeem`_G_axdncg`~
~fd~csmhsgx|gnlmxzfscodido~c|c~4>6
^fmwafemxglc`nc`as&`518#qgxgd|dcidhiglmx~fggom`mecosgo~mx)1'#qgxglxmec`~gx|g`~cm s~wncgsC`~gxgs~c`ai)ofd`ags
c`sofmmig`|cxm`eg`~)owxxcowid)zmicocgsd`nzxdo~cogsqgxgdssmocd~gnqc~fc`oxgdsgs
c`hm~femngxd~gd`n|camxmwszfscodido~c|c~dem`adaxmwzml`c`~faxdngacxis47:
^fgzmic~codisgo~mxfdng|g`lgqgxlc`nc`as&`5>#lxmebws~~fxggs~wncgs4>?)474)478Dii
lc`nc`asc`ncod~gndzmsc~c|gdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ~fgg`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~
Lmxc`s~d`og)Zwofgx4>?d~~xchw~gndxgog`~xgswxag`ogc`hcooic`ac`Agxed`g`~cxgi~m
zwhicozmicocgs~fd~fd|gaxgd~ig`fd`ogn~fgsdlg~)szggn)d`nom`|g`cg`ogmlhcooic`a
?>7 ^fgC`liwg`ogml~fg_mocmOwi~wxdi_g~~c`ad`n_go~mx
m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~
^fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`aqdssgom`n~m~fgzfscodisg~~c`ac`~gxesml~fg`wehgx
mllc`nc`as&`54?7#)dzzxmvced~gi7)47?)47>
Lmxc`s~d`og)c`ds~wnml441Ofc`gsgs~wng`~slxmeaxdngs3~fxmwaf48c`@gqSmxk
Oc~)Swd`nHgxxed`47>lmw`n~fd~doowi~wxd~cm`fdndsca`clcod`~zmsc~c|gomxxgid~cm`
qc~f~m~diig|gimlxgoxgd~cm`zdx~coczd~cm`
^fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxc`oiwngn?7lc`nc`as)qc~f8?'ml~fmsgsfmqc`a`mdssmocd~cm`
hg~qgg ~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~d`nzfscodido~c|c~@m~swxzxcsc`ai)zfscodido~c|c~
qds`gad~c|gidssmocd~gnqc~f~fggv~g`~~mqfcofodxsqgxgowi~wxdiidoogz~gnc`
Dws~xdicd477d`nzmsc~c|gixgid~gn~m~fgzmzwidxc~ml~fgaxgg`em|geg`~c`Agxed`4>?
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
46/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
47/126
Xgswi~s
81
G`|cxm`eg`~
^zg
Lmmn) Ncg~
d`n @w~xc~cm`
Zfscodi
Do~c|c~
_gng`~dx
Hgfd|cmwxHmn Qgcaf~
M|gxdii Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig
_g~~c`as Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig
Zfscodi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zmsschig Zmsschig
Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zxmhdhig
Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
_mocm%owi~wxdi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig
_go~mxs Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig Zmsschig
Zfscodi Zmsschig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zmsschig
Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig Zmsschig
Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
^dhig8
Ig|gis ml
G|cng`ogc lmx
Mhsgx|d~cm`di
Lc`nc`ascc
_mocm%owi~wxdi Zxmhdhig Zxmhdhig @m g|cng`og Zxmhdhig
Dzdx~lxmencg~)~fgxgdzzgdxs~mhgic~~igg|cng`ogmlgvzgxceg`~digllgo~sm`mhgsmag`co
hgfd|cmwxd`nhmnqgcaf~&sgg^dhig?#Qc~fc`ncg~)c~csm`id~~fgsg~~c`asig|gi
qfgxg~fgxgcsd`g|cng`ogmlgvzgxceg`~digllgo~s_zgoclcodii)zfscodid`ngom`meco
sg~~c`asdzzgdx~msfmqsmegzxmecsglmxgllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`s
G`|cxm`eg`~
^zg
Lmmn) Ncg~
d`n @w~xc~cm`
Zfscodi
Do~c|c~
_gng`~dx
Hgfd|cmwxHmn Qgcaf~
M|gxdii Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~
_g~~c`as Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~
Zfscodi Zxmhdhig Zmsschig C`swllcocg`~ C`swllcocg`~
Gom`meco Zxmhdhig Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og C`swllcocg`~ @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
_mocm%owi~wxdi Zmsschig Zmsschig @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
_go~mxs @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
Zfscodi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
Gom`meco @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
Zmic~codi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
^dhig?
Ig|gis ml
G|cng`ogc lmx
Gvzgxceg`~di
Lc`nc`ascc
_mocm%owi~wxdi @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og @m g|cng`og
c Xglgxs~mzxmzmx~cm`mllc`nc`asqc~f`mdssmocd~cm` Zxmhdhig54:'~m83';zmsschig5?:'~m
>3';c`swllcocg`~57:'~m63';`mg|cng`og3:'
cc C`oiwngs~wncgsmlldcxd`nammntwdic~
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
48/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
86
M|gxdii)qgfd|gemxgom`lcng`ogc`mhsgx|d~cm`dilc`nc`as)zdx~cowidxid~~fgsg~~c`as
ig|gilmxncg~d`nsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx_megqfd~swxzxcsc`aqds~fgidokmlg|cng`og
lmxgllgo~c|gg`|cxm`eg`~dic`~gx|g`~cm`s~mdnnxgssmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`nhmn
qgcaf~c`d`wxhd`om`~gv~
?.1 Zmico Om`~gv~
^mag~dsg`sgml~fgzmicoom`~gv~c`qfcofwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~dic`liwg`ogsmlmhgsc~
mzgxd~g)qgxg|cgqgndicec~gn`wehgxmlsweedxzmiconmoweg`~sag`gxd~gnqc~fc`
~fgOd`dncd`om`~gv~^fgsgnmoweg`~sod`hgnc|cngnc`~m~fglmiimqc`aod~gamxcgs2
zggxxg|cgqgnzwhicod~cm`s)ic~gxd~wxgs`~fgsgsd`nxg|cgqs)sweedxxgzmx~sd`ngvzgx~
lmxdD~m~diml4:nmoweg`~sqgxgxg|cgqgn&sggDzzg`ncvL#^fgd`discsml~fgsg
nmoweg`~sfds~fxggzxcedxlmoc2csswglxdec`a)xgswi~sd`nxgomeeg`nd~cm`s^fg
c`~g`~cm`cs~mic`k~fgsgemxghxmdnilmowsgnnmoweg`~s~mmwxs`~fgscslc`nc`aslxme
~fgwxhd`mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~sic~gxd~wxg
?14 CsswgLxdec`a
_c`og4331)qfg`gvzgx~sad~fgxgnd~~fglcxs~QmxinFgdi~fMxad`crd~cm`&QFM#Gvzgx~
Om`swi~d~cm`m Mhgsc~)m|gxqgcaf~d`nmhgsc~fd|ghgg xgoma`crgndsdxdzcniaxmqc`a
~fxgd~~m~fgfgdi~fmlzmzwid~cm`s47
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
49/126
Xgswi~s
83
lmxoxmsssgo~mxd`discsml~fgoms~sd`nhg`glc~smlzwhicozmicocgs.4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
50/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
?:
ZfscodiG`|cxm`eg`~s
Zmicocgs~mxg|cgqew`coczdihidqsd`nldocic~d~gdo~c|g~xd`szmx~hoxgd~c`as~xgg~s~fd~c`omxzmxd~gzgngs~xcd wsgd`nhcooigldocic~cgsd`n~fd~dxgodiegn&ncsomwxdag
fcafszggn|gfcoig~xdllco#;4)4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
51/126
Xgswi~s
?4
Xgnglc`c`a~fgxgszm`ng`~sd`sqgxsc`mwxdndz~gnsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxk1zmsgn
smegofdiig`ags)ds`m~diiml~fgd`sqgxsac|g`lgii`gd~ic`~mm`god~gamx&lmxgvdezig)
smegomwinlc~c`emxg~fd`m`god~gamx#Fmqg|gx)d`d~~gez~qdsedng~mod~gamxcrg
~fgxgszm`sgsc mwxsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxk~medkgdemxgdzzxmzxcd~gomezdxcsm`
hg~qgg s~dkgfmingxxgszm`sgsd`nqfd~qdslmw`nc`~fgss~ged~coxg|cgq
Ems~xgszm`ng`~sd`sqgxsqgxgaxmwzgnqc~fc ~fgsg~~c`asxd~fgx~fd`~fghxmdngxsgo~mxs
od~gamx&sggDzzg`ncvF#^fcsswaags~s~fd~xgszm`ng`~sedlggi~fgemxgceegncd~g
swxxmw`nc`asxd~fgx~fd`hxmdngxsmocg~di~xg`nsd`n-mxzmicocgsfd|gdaxgd~gxcezdo~
m`fgdi~fqgcaf~s^fgzfscodisg~~c`aqds~fgod~gamxlmx~fgems~xgszm`sgs&`5??;
>?'#Ems~ml~fgsgxgszm`sgsc`oiwngnzxgsg`ogmlscngqdiks)zd~fqds)xgoxgd~cm`
ldocic~cgsd`nlmmnmw~ig~sC~sfmwin`m~hgswxzxcsc`a~fd~zfscodisg~~c`asqds~fgems~
omeem`xgszm`sgod~gamxsc`og~fgtwgs~cm`)qfcofom`~dc`gn~fgzfxdsgwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~)edfd|gignzgmzig~m~fc`kceegncd~gidhmw~~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~
Xgid~gn~m~fgzfscodisg~~c`acs~fgzfscodisgo~mx)qfcofqds~fg`gv~ems~omeem`
xgszm`sgod~gamx&`543;87'#^fgxgszm`sgsc`~fcsaxmwzc`oiwngnd`wxhd`ngsca`
mxhwci~g`|cxm`eg`~d`sqgxs)dim`aqc~fzwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`^fgsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`a
qds~fg`gv~ems~omeem`od~gamx&`53;48'#)qfgxgxgszm`sgs|dxcgnom`scngxdhi
Ics~gnc`~fcsod~gamxqgxgsmocdi`g~qmxks)sdlg~&`m~szgoclco~msdlg~mldzfscodi
sg~~c`a#)gnwod~cm`)qmxkiclghdid`og)c`nc|cnwdid~~c~wngsd`nodxwsg&sca`clc`a~fg
ofmcog~mwsgdw~memhcigs#Lc|gxgszm`sgs&
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
52/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
?8
Dii41&4::'#xgszm`sgsc`~fgzfscodisgo~mxqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhighdzmico
xgszm`sg^fgsgxgszm`sgsqgxgog`~xgnems~im`wxhd`ngsca`d`nzwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`
Lmwxmw~mllc|g&6:'#xgszm`sgsc`~fggom`mecosgo~mxqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig
hdzmicoxgszm`sg&M`gxgszm`ng`~qds`m~swxgclsmocmgom`mecoig|gisqgxg
emnclcdhig#Dii&>ml>;4::'#zmic~codisgo~mxxgszm`sgsqgxg~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig
d`nqgxgog`~xgnm`zmicocgsd`nrm`c`amlid`nwsgM`im`gml~qm&7:'#xgszm`sgs
c`~fgsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxqds~fmwaf~~mhgemnclcdhig&M`gxgszm`ng`~qdsw`swxg
qfg~fgxsgng`~dxiclgs~igsqgxgemnclcdhig#
Hdsgnwzm`xgszm`sgs~mtwgs~cm`8)ldo~mxsc`~fgzfscodisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsqgxg
~fmwaf~~mhgdeg`dhig~mdzmicoxgszm`sg^fgm`ildo~mxs~fmwaf~~mhgw`emnclcdhig
qgxgxgid~gn~msdlg~_~dkgfmingxsxgszm`ngns~xm`ai~fd~zmicoofd`agsdllgo~c`a
sg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxsomwinigdn~mfgdi~fcgxhmnqgcaf~s
^fg~fcxntwgs~cm`c`~fgswx|gdskgnxgszm`ng`~s~mics~wz~m~fxggzmicocgs-zxmaxdes-
c`c~cd~c|gs~fd~
gvcs~
c`
wxhd`
dxgds
~m
dsscs~
zmzwid~cm`s
c`
dofcg|c`a
fgdi~f
hmn
qgcaf~s
D~m~diml78xgszm`sgsqgxg~diicgnlmx~fcstwgs~cm`&^qmqgxgoidssclcgnc`~memxg~fd`
m`god~gamxlmxd~m~diml7>d`sqgxs#^fgxgszm`sgs~m~fcstwgs~cm`qgxgemxgofdiig`ac`a
~maxmwzc`~msg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxshgodwsgsmegxgszm`ng`~sad|g|gxszgoclcoc`c~cd~c|gs
c`dagmaxdzfcodxgdd`nm~fgxsad|ghxmdngxldo~mxs~fd~qgxgscecidx~m~fgd`sqgxs
lmw`nc`twgs~cm`4
Oidssclc`a~fgxgszm`sgsc`twgs~cm`?c`~m~fgsg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxslxdegqmxkzxmnwogs
dewofncllgxg`~hxgdknmq`~fd`qdssgg`c`twgs~cm`s4d`n8^fgod~gamxqc~f~fg
ems~xgszm`sgsqdsc`~fgzmic~codisgo~mx&`546;??'#d`n~fgxgszm`sgs|dxcgnlxme
szgoclcoc`c~cd~c|gs&lmxgvdezig)TwghgoOc~ssws~dc`dhigng|gimzeg`~zid`)Fgdi~f
M`~dxcm8:4:#~memxgag`gxcod`sqgxs)swofdszmicocgsld|mwxc`adofd`agc`xg~dciecvmxs`mqoigdxc`azmicocgs_cecidxi~fgzmic~codisg~~c`afdndidxag`wehgxmlxgszm`sgs
&`544;8:'#~fd~c`oiwngnszgoclcozmicocgsc`qmxkzidogs&lmxgvdezig)Hxcs~miEgxs
_twchhstwdic~mliclgzmico)zfscodignwod~cm`c`sofmmis#~m~fgemxgag`gxco&lmx
gvdezig)omeew`c~wsgmlsofmmis#M~fgxod~gamxcgsc`oiwngn`c`gxgszm`sgslmxzfscodi
sg~~c`as&41'#)lc|glmxsmocmowi~wxdisgo~mxs&3'#)lmwxlmxsmocmowi~wxdisg~~c`as&1'#)lmwx
lmxzfscodisgo~mxs&1'#)~qmlmxgom`mecosg~~c`as&>'#d`nm`glmxgom`mecosgo~mxs&8'#
C`om`oiwscm`)ems~s~dkgfmingxsxgszm`ngn~fd~wxhd`ngsca`csswgsd`ndoogsschcic~
mlzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm mzzmx~w`c~cgs&edc`ic ~fgzfscodisg~~c`ad`nzfscodi
sgo~mx#qgxg~fgems~cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~Ems~s~dkgfmingxshgicg|gn~fd~~fgedbmxc~mlldo~mxs)`med~~gx~fgszgoclco
sg~~c`amxsgo~mx)dxgemnclcdhighdzmicoxgszm`sg)~fmwaf~fg~zgmlxgszm`sgqds
`m~szgoclcodiidskgnlmxMl~fgc`c~cd~c|gs~fd~zgmzigk`gqdhmw~)ems~qgxgoidssclcgn
c`~m~fgzmic~codisgo~mxsd`nzmic~codisg~~c`as
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
53/126
Om`oiwscm`s
??
> Om`oiwscm`s
C`xgszm`sg~mmwxxgsgdxoftwgs~cm`&~fd~cs)~mqfd~gv~g`~nms~xwo~wxdimxomeew`c~
ig|giofdxdo~gxcs~cosmlwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~sg`omwxdagmxc`fchc~~fgdofcg|geg`~mlfgdi~f
qgcaf~s=#)~fcsxg|cgqxg|gdignsmegg|cng`oglmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxmhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s^fgs~xm`ags~
ig|gismlg|cng`ogqgxgmhsgx|gnlmxzfscodi&ncg~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)
mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)mhgsc~-fgdi~f
qgcaf~s#sg~~c`as)d`nzfscodi&zfscodido~c|c~#)gom`meco&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)
sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx#d`nsmocmowi~wxdi&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)mhgsc~-fgdi~fqgcaf~s#
sgo~mxs\gxic~~igg|cng`oggvcs~gnlmx~fggllgo~c|g`gssmlc`~gx|g`~cm`sc`dofcg|c`a
fgdi~fqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`om`~gv~&sgg~dhigs8d`n?m`zdag81#
Didxagzxmzmx~cm`ml~fglc`nc`as)zdx~cowidxilmxzfscodido~c|c~d`nsgng`~dx
hgfd|cmwx)qgxgc`~fgzfscodisg~~c`asd`nsgo~mxs^fmwaf~fgig|gimlg|cng`ogqds
zxmhdhiglmxncg~&mhsgx|d~cm`did`ngvzgxceg`~di#d`nsgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx&mhsgx|d~cm`di#c`~fgzfscodisg~~c`as)igssswzzmx~qdslmw`nlmxzfscodido~c|c~d`nhmnqgcaf~
Doomxnc`a~m~fgs~dkgfmingxswx|gmlxgsgdxofgxsd`nngocscm`edkgxs)wxhd`ngsca`
d`ndoogsschcic~~mzfscodido~c|c~d`nfgdi~f`w~xc~cm`mzzmx~w`c~cgsqgxg~fgems~
cezmx~d`~ldo~mxsc`liwg`oc`afgdi~fhmnqgcaf~sc`d`wxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~^fws)
smegncsoxgzd`odzzgdxs~mgvcs~hg~qgg ~fgzgxogz~cm`sml~fgsgngocscm`edkgxsd`n
~fgs~d~gml~fgg|cng`ogqc~fxgadxn~m~fgxmigml~fgzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~c`xgid~cm`
~mfgdi~fqgcaf~sLmxdemxgomezig~gsweedxm`~fgxmigml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~)
zigdsgxglgx~m~fgxg|cgqdx~coigsh_qc`hwx`g~di)4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
54/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
?>
Lwx~fgxemxg)d`ggngvcs~slmxdhg~~gxw`ngxs~d`nc`amlfmq~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~ed
c`liwg`og~fgzxg|dig`ogmlmhgsc~^fcsedhgzdx~cowidxi~xwglmx~fgsofmmisg~~c`a)
qfgxgsg|gxdic`~gx|g`~cm`sfd|gcezxm|gnzfscodido~c|c~d`n`w~xc~cm`k`mqignag-
hgfd|cmwxsqc~fmw~fd|c`adsca`clcod`~cezdo~m`mhgsc~Om`|gxsgi)d~igds~m`gs~wn
dofcg|gnxgnwo~cm`sc`HECqc~fmw~ngem`s~xd~c`ac`oxgdsgnzfscodido~c|c~mxxgnwogn
ncg~dxld~c`~dkg81_g|gxdixg|cgqs)smegmlqfcofdxgss~ged~co)fd|ghgg`xgog`~i
zwhicsfgnc`~fcsdxgd41:41?Di~fmwaf~fgsgxg|cgqsdxg`m~lmowsgnm`~fgwxhd`
g`|cxm`eg`~)~fgod`zxm|cngcezmx~d`~c`scaf~m`sofmmihdsgnc`~gx|g`~cm`s
Icec~d~cm`s
Qfcig~fgxgedhgm~fgxs)~fcsxgzmx~fds~qmicec~d~cm`s~fd~sfmwinhgeg`~cm`gn
Lcxs~)~fgwsgmld|m~gomw`~c`azxmognwxgc`qfcoflc`nc`asqgxgod~gamxcrgnd`n
daaxgad~gnhdsgnwzm`s~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogd`nncxgo~cm`ml~fgxgid~cm`sfcz-ofd`ag
fdshgg oxc~cocrgnc`~fgzds~41>Zm~g`~cdiom`ogx`sqc~f~fcsdzzxmdofdxg~fd~)xgadxnigss
mlsdezigscrg)lc`nc`aslxme|dxcmwss~wncgsdxgd~~xchw~gngtwdiqgcaf~d`n~fd~s~d~cs~codi
sca`clcod`og)qfcofcsfgd|cic`liwg`ognhsdezigscrg)cs~fgm`ic`ncod~mxmlqmx~fc`gss
mldlc`nc`alxmedtwd`~c~d~c|gs~wn^fws)smegidxagd`negd`c`alwilc`nc`asc`
twd`~c~d~c|gs~wncgsedfd|ghgg`zdssgnm|gxhgodwsg~fgdxmsglxmesediisdezig
scrgsd`n~fwsncn`m~dofcg|gs~d~cs~codisca`clcod`ogM`~fgm~fgxfd`n)~fcsdzzxmdof
ncndiimqlmx~fgc`oiwscm`mltwdic~d~c|gnd~d)qfcofqgsggdsds~xg`a~f_gom`n)hgodwsg
mwxxg|cgqc`oiwngnlmwxngzg`ng`~mxmw~omeg|dxcdhigs&ncg~)zfscodido~c|c~)
sgng`~dxhgfd|cmwx)fgdi~fqgcaf~#d`newi~czigig|gisml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~)s~wncgs
ml~g`om`~xchw~gnewi~cziglc`nc`as~m~fgd`discs^fws)~fglc`nc`adsmzzmsgn~m~fg
s~wnqds~fgw`c~mld`discs^fgxglmxg)c~cszmsschig~fd~ds~wnom`~xchw~c`a`wegxmws
lc`nc`as~fd~dxgxgid~gn~mm`gd`m~fgx&~fd~cs)sdegsdezig#qc~fc`d`mw~omeg)d`n
zgxfdzsg|g`qc~fc`~fgsdegig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~&lmxgvdezig)ewi~czigegdswxgsml~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~#)omwinskgq~fgxgswi~s^fd~cs)qfcigqgedfd|gfdn8:mx
?:lc`nc`asqc~fc`dzdx~cowidxig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~lmxd`mw~omeg)c~cszmsschig~fd~
~fmsglc`nc`asqgxgems~ilxme~qmmx~fxggs~wncgsLxmeds~d~cs~codizmc`~ml|cgq)
~fcsqmwinhgzxmhiged~cohgodwsgdedbmxdsswez~cm`mlems~s~d~cs~codi~gs~scs~fd~
lc`nc`asqc~fc`dsdezigdxgc`ngzg`ng`~mlm`gd`m~fgxC~csdismzxmhiged~cohgodwsg
mwxom`lcng`ogc`~fgig|gismlg|cng`ogqdshdsgnwzm`~fg`wehgxd`nzxmzmx~cm`ml
lc`nc`as~fd~sfmqgnsmegdssmocd~cm`hg~qgg ~fgmw~omeg|dxcdhigsd`nig|gisml~fg
g`|cxm`eg`~Fd|c`a`wegxmwslc`nc`aslxme~fgsdegs~wnqmwinicec~mwxom`lcng`og
^mdnnxgss~fcscsswg)qgqgxgodw~cmwsc`mwxxgzmx~c`aclqgsdq~fglc`nc`asmlm`g
s~wnnmec`d~c`a~fgxgswi~slmxdszgoclcoig|giml~fgg`|cxm`eg`~
_weedx
C sweedx)smegg|cng`oggvcs~slmxdssmocd~cm`shg~qgg dszgo~sml~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~
d`nmhgsmag`cohgfd|cmwxd`n-mxhmnqgcaf~)cezicod~c`ac`~gx|g`~cm`sc`zmicod`n
zxdo~cogFmqg|gx)~fgidokmlg|cng`oglmxgllgo~c|gc`~gx|g`~cm`sd`nzmicoc`c~cd~c|gs
swaags~sd`ggnlmxxgsgdxof~mlciik`mqignagadzs
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
55/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
?7
Xglgxg`og Ics~
4 Z^Kd~redxrk)^fgOd`dncd`Mhgsc~Gzcngeco)43674336)Od`dncd`Egncodi
Dssmocd~cm Bmwx`di4 AGaagxd`nH_qc`hwx`)D`GomimacodiDzzxmdof~m~fgMhgsc~Zd`ngeco)
Hxc~csfEgncodiBmwx`di?47)14:11>6:
7 _KKwed`ckd)Ec`csezmscwem`Mhgsc~2M|gx|cgqd`n_meg_~xd~gaco
Om`scngxd~cm`s)D``wdiXg|cgqmlZwhicoFgdi~f88&8::4#2zz83??:6
1 H_qc`hwx`)AGaagxd`nLXdrd)Ncssgo~c`aMhgsmag`coG`|cxm`eg`~s2
^fgNg|gimzeg`~d`nDzzicod~cm mldLxdegqmxklmxCng`~clc`ad`nZxcmxc~crc`a
G`|cxm`eg`~diC`~gx|g`~cm`slmxMhgsc~)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g83)
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
56/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
? _Fdqkgxg~di)Dzzxdcsc`a~fgG|cng`og2Xg|cgqc`aNcszdxd~gNd~d_s~ged~codii)
Twdic~d~c|gFgdi~fXgsgdxof48)3&8::8#2zz486>4833
47 QmxinOd`ogxXgsgdxofLw`nd`nDegxcod`C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof)Lmmn)
@w~xc~cm`d`n~fgZxg|g`~cm`mlOd`ogx2DAimhdiZgxszgo~c|g&Qdsfc`a~m`)NO2Degxcod`
C`s~c~w~glmxOd`ogxXgsgdxof)4331#
4#2zz48?4>&8::8#2zz413?4648
43 INLxd`k)EDD`nxgsg d`n^I_ofecn)Mhgsc~Xgid~cm`sfczsQc~f
Omeew`c~Ngsca`)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)d`n^ceg_zg`~c`Odxs)Degxcod`Bmwx`di
mlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g81&8::>#2zz613#2zz71
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
57/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
?1
8)>
&8::?#2zz?
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
58/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
?6
?6 KEHmm~f)EEZc`ks~m`d`nQ_OZms~m`)Mhgsc~d`n~fgHwci~
G`|cxm`eg`~)Bmwx`diml~fgDegxcod Ncg~g~coDssmocd~cm 4:7&8::7#2zz_44:_441
?3 QBd`sg`d`nDDFdrghxmgkKdezsofxgwx)Ncllgxg`ogsc`Fgcaf~d`nQgcaf~
Hg~qgg`Ofcinxg Ic|c`ac`@gcafhmwxfmmnsmlNcllgxg`~_mocmgom`meco_~d~ws)
Do~dZdgncd~xcod6887
>: _Kc`xd)XZ@gingxd`nABIgqg`nm`)Ngzxc|d~cm d`nOfcinfmmnMhgsc~2
DOxmss_go~cm`di_~wnml8:)31?Ofcinxg`c`Ziemw~f)W`c~gnKc`anme)Bmwx`di
mlGzcngecmimad`nOmeew`c~Fgdi~f7>&8:::#2zz>74 ^Emlld~)^Adiimqdd`nBId~fde)_~d~wxgd`nDnczmsc~Dem`aOfcinxg
c`Om`~xds~c`a@gcafhmxfmmnsc`~fgOc~mlFdeci~m`)M`~dxcm)Od`dnd)Degxcod
Bmwx`dimlFwed`Hcmima41)?&8::7#2zz?77?8 RSc`g~di)ZfscodiDo~c|c~Hwllgxs~fgGllgo~smlOfxm`co_~xgssm`Dnczmsc~
c`Smw~f)D``dismlHgfd|cmxdiEgncoc`g83&8::7#2zz83?? HFgx`d`ngrg~di)Dssmocd~cm`mlMhgsc~Qc~fZfscodiDo~c|c~)^gig|cscm
Zxmaxdesd`nM~fgxLmxesml\cngm\cgqc`aDem`aOfcinxg`c`EgvcomOc~)
C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~8?&4333#2zz6>767>
>> KEFg`xckssm`g~di)Dssmocd~cm`sHg~qgg W`gezimeg`~d`nOdxncm|dsowidx
XcskLdo~mxs\dxcgsqc~f~fgW`gezimeg`~Xd~g2^fgOdxncm|dsowidxXcskLdo~mx
_~wnc`_mw~fgx`_qgng`&OXC__#) _od`nc`d|cd`Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f?4&8::?#2
zz?:7?44
>7 CIcssdwIw`n_mxg`sg`d`n^C_mxg`sg`)Zxmszgo~c|g_~wnml~fgC`liwg`og
ml_mocdiLdo~mxsc`Ofcinfmmnm`XcskmlM|gxqgcaf~c`Smw`aDnwi~fmmn)
C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~4&433:#2
zz?78?6 XQBgllgx)Ec``gsm~d_~wncgsm`Omeew`c~HdsgnDzzxmdofgs~mQgcaf~Imss
d`nOm`~xmi)D``dismlC`~gx`diEgncoc`g443)1Z~8&433?#2zz143184
>3 AELgi~m`g~di)Ncllgxg`ogsc`ZfscodiDo~c|c~Hg~qgg Hidokd`nQfc~gAcxis
Ic|c`ac`Xwxdid`nWxhd`Dxgds)Bmwx`diml_ofmmiFgdi~f18&8::8#2zz87:877
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
59/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
?3
7: IKKfd`)B_mhdid`nXEdx~mxgii)Doowi~wxd~cm`)_mocmgom`meco_~d~ws)d`n
Mhgsc~c`Egvcod`Degxcod`s)Owhd`Degxcod`s)d`nZwgx~mXcod`s)C`~gx`d~cm`di
Bmwx`dimlMhgsc~84)8&4331#2zz343?1
78 BOFdilmxng~di)Gllgo~ml^gig|cscm Dn|gx~csgeg`~slmxLmmnsm`Lmmn
Om`swez~cm`c`Ofcinxg`)Dzzg~c~g>8&8::>#2zz884887
7? OLxgd`nBFgc`xcof)^xg`nsd`nZxgnco~mxsmlM|gxqgcaf~d`nMhgsc~c`Gds~
Agxed`Ofcinxg`) C`~gx`d~cm`diBmwx`dimlMhgsc~81&8::?#2zz3
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
60/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
>:
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
61/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
>4
17 IHIgqcsg~di)Dlxcod`Degxcod`sDoogss~mFgdi~fLmmnMz~cm`sc`_mw~fIms
D`agigsXgs~dwxd`~s)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f37&8::7#2zz
13 HDIdxdcdg~di)Zxmvcec~ml_wzgxedxkg~sCsZmsc~c|giDssmocd~gnQc~fNcg~
Twdic~C`ngvlmxZxga`d`o)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g?3&8::>#2zz6 EKFw`~g~di)Zdq~wokg~Fgdx~Fgdi~fZxmaxdeZmc`~mlZwxofdsg@w~xc~cm`
Gnwod~cm`Zxmaxdec`_wzgxedxkg~s) Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f6:&433:#2
zz1?:1?8
67 XE@dad)Bx)Gllgo~sml_mocmgom`mecod`nNgemaxdzfcoLdo~mxsm`Om`swez~cm
ml_gigo~gnLmmn@w~xcg`~s)Daxcowi~wxdid`nXgsmwxogGom`mecosXg|cgq8?)8&433>#2
zz414468
61)>&4334?>3
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
62/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
>8
61 OF_Xwv~m`g~di)^fgOm`~xchw~cm`mlHxgdklds~~m~fgNcg~smld_dezigml4??4
66 EMsigx)_mocdiOidssd`nFgdi~fHgfd|cmwxc`Nd`csfDnwi~s2DIm`ac~wnc`di
_~wn)ZwhicoFgdi~f4:1)>&433?#2zz8748
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
63/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
>?
4:: OENg|c`gg~di)IclgOmwxsgG|g`~sd`nGvzgxcg`ogs2Dssmocd~cm`Qc~fLxwc~
d`n\gag~dhigOm`swez~cm`c`?G~f`coAxmwzs)Bmwx`diml~fgDegxcod`Ncg~g~co
Dssmocd~cm 33)?&4333#2zz?:3?4>
4:4 OIFwzkg`sg~di)OidssNcllgxg`ogsc`~fgLmmnXwigsEm~fgxsCezmsgm`
^fgcxOfcinxg`2DOxmss@d~cm`di_~wn)_mocdi_ocg`og,Egncoc`g>1)3&4336#2
zz4??44??3
4:8 _EHgncdkm)@MDKqd~gd`nXXwokgx)Ncg~dxHgfd|cmxDem`aDlxcod
Degxcod`s2Dssgssc`aOwi~wxdiCng`~c~d`nFgdi~fOm`socmws`gss)G~f`coc~,
Ncsgdsg4>)>&8::>#2zz7817?8
4:? OOOdezhgiid`n_GFmx~m`)Dzzdxg`~@w~xcg`~C`~dkgsmlOd`dncd`s2
Om`~c`wc`a@w~xc~cm`diOfdiig`agslmxZwhicoFgdi~fZxmlgsscm`dis)Od`dncd
Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f68&4334#2zz?1>?6:
4:> ELxg``g~di)Ng~gxec`d`~smlZfscodiDo~c|c~d`nImqLd~Ncg~Dem`aImq
C`omegDlxcod`Degxcod d`nFcszd`coEcnnig_ofmmi_~wng`~s)ZwhicoFgdi~f
@wxsc`a88)8&8::7#2zz6331
4:7 OOFmxqd~f)_mocmGom`meco_~d~wsd`nNcg~dxFdhc~sc`~fgGingxi2Xgswi~s
LxmedIdxagXd`nme_wx|g)Bmwx`dimlFwed`@w~xc~cm d`nNcg~g~cos8)?&4363#2
zz41?46?
4:
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
64/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
>>
448 DLmxs~f)_Edoc`~xgd`nDD`ngxsm`)Ncg~slmxNcsgdsg=C`~xdwxhd`\dxcd~cm`
c`Xgzmx~gnLmmnOm`swez~cm`c`Aidsamq)Dzzg~c~g88&433>#2zz87381>
44? A^wxxgiig~di)DEwi~cig|giD`discsml_mocmgom`meco&_ediiDxgd#Ncllgxg`ogs
c`FmwsgfminLmmnZwxofdsc`aHgfd|cmwx)Bmwx`dimlGzcngecmima,Omeew`c~
Fgdi~f76)?&8::>#2zz8:6847
44> _Oweec`sd`n_Edoc`~xg)LmmnNgsgx~s2G|cng`ogd`nDsswez~cm`c`Fgdi~f
ZmicoEdkc`a)Hxc~csfEgncodiBmwx`di?87)1???6
447 QFNcg~rg~di)Zmico^mmislmx~fgOfcinfmmnMhgsc~Gzcngeco) Bmwx`di
mlIdq)Egncoc`gd`nG~fcos?:)?_wzzi&8::8#2zz6?61
44#2zz4344
48: @CFd`sm`g~di)Dssmocd~cm`sHg~qgg Zdxg`~diXgzmx~ml~fgFmegLmmn
G`|cxm`eg`~d`nDnmigsog`~C`~dkgsmlLxwc~s)\gag~dhigsd`nNdcxLmmns)Zwhico
Fgdi~f@w~xc~cm 6)4&8::7#2zz1167
484 _BOxmokg~~g~di)Zdxg`~Gnwod~cm`c`Smw~fNcxgo~gn@w~xc~cm`C`~gx|g`~cm`s)
Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g46&4363#2zz>17>34
488 OIZgxxg~di)Ofd`ac`aLxwc~d`n\gag~dhigOm`swez~cm`Dem`aOfcinxg`2
^fg7dNdZmqgxZiwsZxmaxdec`_~Zdwi)Ec``gsm~d)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZwhico
Fgdi~f66&4336#2zz ^Hdxd`mqskcg~di)Ncg~dxOfd`aglmxOdxncm|dsowidxNcsgdsgZxg|g`~cm`Dem`a
HidokDegxcod`Ldecicgs)Fgdi~fGnwod~cm`Xgsgdxof7&433:#2zz>??>>?
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
65/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
>7
487 KOid`oFgzhwx`)Ofcinxg`sHgfd|cmxXgszm`sgs~m^\LmmnDn|gx~csgeg`~s)
Bmwx`diml@w~xc~cm Gnwod~cm`#2zz3?3#2zz>83>?8
481BDLwikgxsm`g~di)Zxmem~cm`s~mC`oxgdsgImqgxLd~LmmnOfmcogsDem`a_~wng`~s
c`_gom`ndx_ofmmis2Ngsoxcz~cm d`nMw~omegsml^DOM_&^xc`aDi~gx`d~c|g
Odlg~gxcdMz~cm`sc`_ofmmis#)ZwhicoFgdi~f@w~xc~cm 1&8::>#2zz>84
483 HXgagx)EAQmm~d`d`n_Hmm~fHw~~gxlcgin)DOmezdxcsm`mlNcllgxg`~
Dzzxmdofgs~mZxmem~gOmeew`c~QcngNcg~dxOfd`ag)Degxcod Bmwx`di
mlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g46)>&8:::#2zz814817
4?: _DLxg`ofg~di)D`G`|cxm`eg`~diC`~gx|g`~cm ~mZxmem~gImqgxLd~Lmmn
Ofmcogsc`_gom`ndx_ofmmis2Mw~omegsml~fg^DOM__~wn)Degxcod`Bmwx`di
mlZwhicoFgdi~f3>&8::>#2zz47:14748
4?4 EEciigxg~di)Ldo~sm`Ld~2DOmeew`c~@w~xc~cm`Gnwod~cm`Odezdca`)
Bmwx`dimlLmmnd`n@w~xc~cm >>)8&4361#2zz6
4?>BKced`nEEOfd`)Doowi~wxd~cm d`nNcg~dxFdhc~smlKmxgd`Degxcod`s)
Hxc~csfBmwx`diml@w~xc~cm 34&8::>#2zz>16
4?7 OIOxdcag~di)Gvzimxc`a~fgGllgo~ml~fgG`|cxm`eg`~m`ZfscodiDo~c|c~2
D_~wnGvdec`c`aQdikc`a~mQmxk)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g8?)8
_wzzi&8::8#2zz??
4?
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
66/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
>: ZDGs~dhxmmks)XGIggd`n@OAwxosck)XgsmwxogslmxZfscodiDo~c|c~
Zdx~coczd~cm`2NmgsD|dcidhcic~d`nDoogsschcic~Ncllgxh@gcafhmxfmmn
_mocmgom`meco_~d~ws=)D``dismlHgfd|cmxdiEgncoc`g87&8::?#2zz4::4:>
4>4 HAcigsOmx~cd`nXBNm`m|d`)Xgid~c|gC`liwg`ogsmlC`nc|cnwdi)_mocdi
G`|cxm`eg`~di)d`nZfscodiG`|cxm`eg`~diOmxxgid~gsmlQdikc`a)Degxcod`
Bmwx`dimlZwhicoFgdi~f3?&8::?#2zz476?4763
4>8 HAcigsOmx~cg~di)C`oxgdsc`aQdikc`a2FmqCezmx~d`~CsNcs~d`og^m)
D~~xdo~c|g`gss)d`n_crgmlZwhicoMzg`_zdog=)Degxcod Bmwx`dimlZxg|g`~c|g
Egncoc`g86)8_wzzi8&8::7#2zz4&4331#2zz?4>> EK_c g~di)Ldo~mxsC`liwg`oc`aGvgxocsgZdx~coczd~cm`d`nTwdic~mlIclgDem`a
GingxiKmxgd`Degxcod`s)Bmwx`dimlOwi~wxdiNc|gxsc~44)>&8::>#2zz4?34>7
4>7 DDGigxg~di)ZfscodiDo~c|c~d`nEc`mxc~Qmeg`2DTwdic~d~c|g_~wn)
Fgdi~fGnwod~cm`d`nHgfd|cmx87&4336#2zz:1 HAcigsOmx~cd`nXBNm`m|d`)_mocmgom`meco_~d~wsNcllgxg`ogsc`Xgoxgd~cm`di
ZfscodiDo~c|c~Ig|gisd`nXgdid`nZgxogc|gnDoogss~md_wzzmx~c|gZfscodi
G`|cxm`eg`~)Zxg|g`~c|gEgncoc`g?7&8::8#2zz>4>74
4>3 AQd`ag~di)DOms~Hg`glc~D`discsmlZfscodiDo~c|c~Wsc`aHckg-Zgngs~xcd
^xdcis)Fgdi~fZxmem~cm Zxdo~cog413
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
67/126
Xglgxg`og Ics~
>1
47: ALgi~m`g~di)Zxmem~c`aZfscodiDo~c|c~c`Acxis2DOdsg_~wnmlM`g_ofmmis
_woogss)Bmwx`diml_ofmmiFgdi~f17)8&8::7#2zz71 ZSwd`nNIHgxxed`)^fgXgid~cm`sfczDem`a_gilGs~gge)Doowi~wxd~cm`)
d`nXgoxgd~cm Zdx~coczd~cm mlXgog`~iDxxc|gnOfc`gsgCeecaxd`~Dnmigsog`~s)
Bmwx`dimlIgcswxgXgsgdxof86&433?#
4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
68/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
>6
4
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
69/126
Dzzg`ncv D2 Zxmbgo~ Limq Ofdx~
>3
Dzzg`ncv D2 Zxmbgo~ Limq Ofdx~
Om`ogz~-Xgls5Om`ogz~wdiOm`~g`~d`n-mxXglgxg`ogs
Ic~gxd~wxg
Nd~dhdsg
_gdxofgs
^c~ig_od`
Doogz~gn
^c~ig_od`
Xgbgo~gn
Xg^c~ig_od``gn
Xgbgo~gn
Xg^c~ig_od``gn
Doogz~gn
Dhs~xdo~_od`
Xgbgo~gn
Dhs~xdo~_od`
Doogz~gn
Dhs~xdo~_od`
W`k`mq`-Lmiimq
WzXgtwcxgn
LwiiDx~coig
LmiimqWz
Doogz~gn
LwiiDx~coig
LmiimqWz
Xgbgo~gn
Lc`di_s~ged~codii
Xg|cgqgnDx~coigs
Dx~coigXgbgo~gnhw~
Kgz~lmxOm`ogz~-Xgls
Dx~coigsQc~fmw~
Dhs~xdo~s_gzdxd~gn
Dx~coigXgbgo~gn
Wzm`LwiiXg|cgq
Dhs~xdo~_od`
Xgbgo~gn)Kgz~
lmxOm`ogz~-Xgls
Dx~coigLwii
Xg|cgq
FdxnOmz-
Gigo~xm`co
Dx~coigs
Xg~xcg|gn
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
70/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
71/126
Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx _gdxof _~xd~ga
74
Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx
_gdxof _~xd~ga
4mhgsc~-mxmhgsc~)emxhcn-mxhmnqgcaf~-
8hmnedssc`ngv-?g`gxac`~dkg-
>em~mxdo~c|c~-mxqdikc`a-mxhcooic`a-
7Gvgxocsg-
mx-44?
47&mhgs.mxhmnqgcaf~mxhmnqgcaf~mxm|gxqgcaf~#~c)dh
4zmx~cm`.~c)dh
87mx-478>
8d`n87
81"mhgsc~-mx"mhgsc~)emxhcn-mx"hmnqgcaf~-
86"hmnedssc`ngv-
83"g`gxac`~dkg-
?:"em~mxdo~c|c~-mx"xw``c`a-mx"sqceec`a-mx"qdikc`a-
?4"Gvgxocsg-
?8"igcswxgdo~c|c~cgs-mx"xgoxgd~cm`-
??"hmnqgcaf~-mx"hmnqgcaf~ofd`ags-mx"qgcaf~adc`-mx"qgcaf~imss-
mx"~fc``gss-
?>"ncg~-mx"lggnc`ahgfd|cmx-mx"lmmnfdhc~s-mx"lmmnzxglgxg`ogs-
?7"lxwc~s-mx"|gag~dhigs-
?:&do~c|.mxc`do~c|.mxlc~mxlc~`gssmxsgng`~dx#~c
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
72/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
78
>4&qdik.mxhcooi.#~c
>8&&lmmnmxncg~.#d`n&ofmcog.mxofmmsgmxzxglgx.mxc`~dkgmxfdhc~.##~c
>?&bw`klmmnmxlds~lmmnmxs`dok.mxfcafld~mxswadx#~c
>>&lxwc~.mx|gag~dhig.mxsml~nxc`k.mxsmndmxzmz#~c
>7zmx~cm`.~c
>7
>186fgdi~fzmico-mx`w~xc~cm`zmico-mxzmicoedkc`a-
>3gvzZwhicoZmico-
7:gvzmxad`crd~cm`dizmico-
74smocdiofd`ag-
78gvzsmocmgom`mecoldo~mxs-mxgnwod~cm`dis~d~ws-mxgezimeg`~-mxw`gezimeg`~-
mxgvzqmxkzidog-mxldeciofdxdo~gxcs~cos-mxc`omeg-mxmoowzd~cm`s-mxgvzzm|gx~-
mxgvzsmocdioidss-mxsmocdiom`nc~cm`s-
7?owi~wxg-mxdoowi~wxd~cm`-
7>smocdiedxkg~c`a-mxedxkg~c`amlfgdi~fsgx|cogs-77edxkg~c`a-mxdn|gx~csc`a-
7
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
73/126
Dzzg`ncv H2 _dezig EGNIC@G-Fgdi~f_~dx _gdxof _~xd~ga
7?
68mx->664
6?wxhd`crd~cm`-
6>wxhd`zmzwid~cm`-mxwxhd`fgdi~f-
67oc~zid``c`a-mxwxhd`xg`gqdi-
61d`n68d`n3:
38>1d`n3:
3?68mx3:
3>>1d`n3?
37icec~3>~mfwed`s
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
74/126
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
75/126
Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d n Xglgxg`og Awcng
77
Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc a Lmxe d`n Xglgxg`og Awcng
Dw~fmx&s#2 Nd~gmlZwhicod~cm`2
^c~ig2
Xg|cgqgx2 Bmwx`di2
_~gz42Edc`Oxc~gxcdlmxDhs~xdo~_od`
4 Nmgs~fcsdx~coiglmowsm`m`gmxemxgml~fglmiimqc`a~fgegs2Ncg~-Lmmn)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)_gng`~dxHgfd|cmwx)Fgdi~fQgcaf~s-Mhgsc~ds~fgzgx~dc`~mgllgo~s
m`zmzwid~cm`s=
Sgs
@m
W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz
8 Dxgg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs&cgsg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#dnnxgssgn=Sgs
@m
W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz
? Nmgs~fcsdx~coigc`oiwngWxhd`zmzwid~cm`s=Sgs
@m
W`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz
Kggzlmxswaags~gnxglgxg`ogs-lmiimqwz
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
76/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
7.
Dx~coigLc`nc`asOmnc`aLmxe
G`|
cxm`eg`
~_g
~~c`a
G`|
cxm`eg`
~_go
~mx
_~wn
CN
Lc`nc`a
/
Hg
fd|
cmwx
_gv
G~f`
coc~
Dag
_G_
_G_
Ng
~dci
Zfs
Gom`
Zm
ic
_%O
Ng
~dci
Zfs
Gom`
Zm
ic
_%O
Ng
~dci
Lc`nc`a
Ncxgo
~.
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
77/126
Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d`n Xglgxg`og Awcng
71
7. _~wnNgsca`2D4_s~ged~coxg|cgqsqfcofom`~dc`d~igds~m`gxd`nmecrgnom`~xmi~xcdi
D8M~fgxss~ged~cod`nfcaftwdic~xg|cgqs
H4C`nc|cnwdi
xd`nmecrgn
om`~xmiign
~xcdis;
xd`nmecrgn
gvzgxceg`~di
s~wncgs
H8@m`xd`nmecrgn)gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs
H?Qgiingsca`gn)`m`gvzgxceg`~dis~wncgs)om`~xmiigns~d~cs~codii
cldzzxmzxcd~g)dismc`oiwngsqgiingsca`gntwdic~d~c|gs~wncgs
O4Ngsoxcz~c|gd`nm~fgxxgsgdxof&g.a.om`|g`cg`ogsdezigs#`m~c`H
O8Odsgs~wncgsd`ngvdezigsmlammnzxdo~cog
.G~fcosd`nHcds
7.Lc`nc`as-Xgswi~s
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
78/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
76
Omnc`aXglgxg`ogd`nNglc`c~cm`s
Edc`Oxc~gxcdlmxDhs~xdo~_od`
4 Nmgs~fcsdx~coiglmowsm`m`gmxemxgml~fglmiimqc`a~fgegs2Ncg~-Lmmn)ZfscodiDo~c|c~)Fgdi~fQgcaf~s-Mhgsc~ds~fgzgx~dc`~mgllgo~sm`zmzwid~cm`s=
^fcstwgs~cm csdssgssc`aqfg~fgx~fgs~wnc`twgs~cm`csgvdec`c`azmzwid~cm ig|gigllgo~smlm`gml~fgics~gn~mzcodxgdsIc~gxd~wxggvoiwngnwsc`a~fcsoxc~gxcd
qmwinc`oiwng~fmsg~fd~dnnxgss~fgsg~mzcosc`ngzg`ng`~mlzmzwid~cm`s&ga
Ofd`agsc`@w~xcg`~Om`~g`~mlIg~~woglxme43178:::#mx`m~gvzicoc~ilmowsgn
m`zmzwid~cm`s&gaD_wx|gmlAxdng_ofmmiZfscodiGnwod~cm`Zxmaxdes#
C`oiwngns~wncgssfmwinhggvzicoc~ilmowsgnm`mhgsc~)hw~od`dismgvzimxgd`xgid~gnfgdi~fom`nc~cm`s&cgod`ogxs)odxncm|dsowidxncsgdsgs)xgszcxd~mx
om`nc~cm`s)ncsdhcic~cgs)g~o#
8 Dxgg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs&cgsg~~c`as)sgo~mxs#dnnxgssgn= ^fcstwgs~cm`gvdec`gsqfg~fgx~fgs~wnlmowsgsm`omeew`c~ig|gisg~~c`as
mxs~xwo~wxdisgo~mxs^fgsgc`oiwngzfscodig`|cxm`eg`~s)gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~s)
zmic~codig`|cxm`eg`~sd`nsmocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~sGvdezigsmlzdzgxs~fd~
qmwinhgdoogz~gnecaf~hg2^fgDoogsschcic~mlAxmogx_~mxgsc d Wxhd`Og`~xg;
Gom`mecoHdxxcgxs~mZfscodiDo~c|c~;NmgsC`oxgdsgn_~dcxqgiiIcaf~c`a
C`oxgdsgWsdagc`~fgQmxkzidog=;mx)^fgCezdo~mld_ofmmiLggnc`aZxmaxde
m`OfcinfmmnMhgsc~
_~wncgs`m~c`oiwngnwsc`a~fcsoxc~gxcdqmwinhg~fmsgc`qfcof~fgimod~cm`mxsg~~c`aml~fgs~wncs`m~dzxcedxlmowsml~fgqmxkLmxgvdezig)di~fmwaf
doic`codi~xcdied~dkgzidogc`dfmszc~di)~fgs~wnqcii`m~hgc`oiwngnw`igss~fgfmszc~di)dsdqmxkzidog)qdsc`oiwngnc`~fgs~wndsdzxcedxlmows_cecidxi)
dzdzgx~fd~gvdec`gsdzmzwid~cm`mlofcinxg`xgoxwc~gnlxmed`gigeg`~dxsofmmi
qmwinhggvoiwngnw`igss~fcsg`|cxm`eg`~csdzxcedxlmowslmx~fgzdzgx&ga^fg
Gllgo~ml_ofmmiLmmnZmicom`Zwxofdsc`aHgfd|cmwxmlBw`cmxFcaf_~wng`~s#
? Nmgs~fcsdx~coigc`oiwngWxhd`Zmzwid~cm`s= Lxme~fgdhs~xdo~)c~sfmwinhgzmsschig~mng~gxec`gqfg~fgx~fgzmzwid~cm`
mlc`~gxgs~c`ds~wncslxmed`wxhd`dxgdMl~g`)xgsgdxofhgc`axgzmx~gnqds
om`nwo~gnd~w`c|gxsc~cgs)qfcofdxgag`gxdiiimod~gnc`wxhd`og`~xgsCl`m~)~fg
zdzgxsfmwinszgoclqfgxgc~fdshgg`om`nwo~gnCl~fgmxcac`ml~fgzmzwid~cm cs`m~szgoclcgn)~fgs~wnqcii`ggn~mhglmiimqgnwz
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
79/126
Dzzg`ncv O2 Dx~coig Omnc`a Lmxe d n Xglgxg`og Awcng
73
@m~d~cm`C`s~xwo~cm`slmxDhs~xdo~_od`
Om`scs~g`oc`~fg`m~d~cm`wsgnnwxc`a~fgdhs~xdo~sod`s~dagcscezmx~d`~cl~fgxg|cgq
cs~mxw`semm~fiGdofxg|cgqgndhs~xdo~ews~hgedxkgnc`swofdqd~fd~c~csoigdx
qfg~fgx~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gn)doogz~gn)mxxgtwcxgslmiimqwz
G`swxgdii`m~d~cm`cszidogn~m~fgigl~ml~fgdhs~xdo~ Ics~4)8d`n?~momxxgszm`nqc~f~fg~fxggtwgs~cm`sw`ngx_~gz4ml~fg
Dssgsseg`~^mmi
Hgscnggdof`wehgx)zidoggc~fgxSmxSgslmxSgs)@mx@mlmx@m)mxW-LWlmxW`k`mq`-@ggnsLmiimqWz)ngzg`nc`am`~fgdzzxmzxcd~gdssgsseg`~lmx~fd~
zdx~cowidxdhs~xdo~Zigdsgnm`m~wsgtwgs~cm`edxks)mxd`m~fgxedxksm~fgx~fd`
~fmsgics~gndhm|gclmwdxgw`swxgml~fgzxmzgxxgszm`sg~mdzdx~cowidxtwgs~cm`)
edxkc~dsw`k`mq`d`nc~qciihglmiimqgnwz
W`ngx`gd~f~fgsg~fxggoxc~gxcd)oigdxiedxkd`Vcl~fgdx~coigcshgc`axgbgo~gn;d3
cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg doogz~gnlmxlwiixg|cgqqc~f`mxgsgx|d~cm`s;mxLmiimqWzcl~fgdx~coig`ggnslwx~fgxxg|cgq~mng~gxec`gc~ss~d~ws
Cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gnmxclc~xgtwcxgslmiimqwz)qxc~gd|gxhxcgl`m~ggvzidc`c`a~fgxgdsm`lmx~fcsdssgsseg`~Lmxgvdezig)@mg`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxs
mx@mgllgo~mlncg~-mhgsc~-zfscodido~c|c~m`zmzwid~cm`sqmwinhgswllcocg`~fgxg
_cecidxi)zxm|cngdhxcgl`m~gngsoxchc`ad`oxc~gxcd~fd~xgtwcxglmiimqwz)wsc`a
dscecidxlmxed~~m~fd~ngsoxchgndhm|g
Cl~fgdx~coigfdshgg`xgbgo~gnhw~cszgxogc|gndshgc`a|diwdhigc`~gxesmlc~som`~g`~)om`ogz~wdiom`~xchw~cm ~m~fglcgin)zm~g`~cdixglgxg`ogsg~o)oigdxi`m~g~fcsw`ngx`gd~f
~fgm~fgxdssgsseg`~sLmiimqwzlmxswaags~gnxglgxg`ogsmxLmiimqwzlmxom`ogz~wdi
om`~g`~qmwinhgswllcocg`~fgxg
Om`ogz~wdiLxdegqmxk_go~mxsd`n_g~~c`as
_g~~c`as
Lmx~fcsxg|cgq)sg~~c`asdxgomeew`c~ig|gildo~mxs~fd~ziddxmigc`c`liwg`oc`ahmn
qgcaf~sc`~fgwxhd`g`|cxm`eg`~_g~~c`asod`hgoidssclcgnc`~mlmwxncs~c`o~~zgs
&zfscodi)gom`meco)zmic~codi)smocmowi~wxdi#nglc`c~cm`sd`ngvdezigszgx~dc`c`a~mgdof
ml~fgsg~zgsdxgac|g`hgimq
4 Zfscodi2Zfscodig`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsxglgx~m~fghwci~g`|cxm`eg`~ml~fgwxhd`dxgd_zgoclcogvdezigsfgxgqmwinc`oiwng~fgncs~xchw~cm`mllmmnd`nzfscodi
do~c|c~deg`c~cgs)c`oiwnc`a~fgzidogeg`~mlaxmogxs~mxgsmxxgs~dwxd`~sd`n
qdikc`a-hckc`a~xdcis)dsqgiidswxhd`zid``c`acsswgsswofdszwhico~xd`szmx~d~cm`
ss~gesC`ed`odsgs)zdzgxsc`~fcsod~gamxqciiom`ogx`~fgzfscodid|dcidhcic~
mxdoogsschcic~mldzdx~cowidxdeg`c~
8 Gom`meco2Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsc`omxzmxd~gdlc`d`ocdidszgo~c`~m~fgom`ogz~smld|dcidhcic~d`ndoogsschcic~^fgems~omeem`~fgeglmx~fcssg~~c`a
cs~fgdllmxndhcic~mldzdx~cowidxc~ge)hgc~lmmnlxmeswzgxedxkg~sd`nxgs~dwxd`~s)
mxsmwxogsmlzfscodido~c|c~ickgaesmxxgoxgd~cm`og`~xgs
-
7/30/2019 State of the Evidence Review on Urban Health and Healthy Weights
80/126
_~d~g ml ~fg G|cng`og Xg|cgq m` Wxhd` Fgdi~f d`n Fgdi~f Qgcaf~s
_mocmOwi~wxdi2_mocmowi~wxdig`|cxm`eg`~dildo~mxsdxgsicaf~iemxgdehcawmws)gvzimxc`a~xg`ns)zgxogz~cm`sd`nlggic`as~mqdxnslmmn)zfscodido~c|c~mxmhgsc~d~dsicaf~ihxmdngxig|giZdzgxsfgxgedgvzimxgowi~wxdihdxxcgxs~mzdx~coczd~cm
c`zfscodido~c|c~mxmlzwxofdsc`afgdi~flmmnslmxdszgoclcog~f`coaxmwz)mx
~fgxmigml~fgldecig`|cxm`eg`~c`zxmem~c`afgdi~fgd~c`amxzfscodido~c|c~
Zdx~cowidxd~~g`~cm`sfmwinhgzdcn~mzdzgxsldiic`ac`~m~fcsod~gamxc`~gxesml~fg
ncs~c`o~cm`hg~qgg ~fcssg~~c`ad`n~fghxmdngxs~xwo~wxdisgo~mxsics~gnhgimq
~fgedc`ncllgxg`ogcs~fd~zdzgxsc`~fcsod~gamxqciizgx~dc`~mdszgoclcog~f`co
axmwzmxldecig`|cxm`eg`~)lmxgvdezig)c`s~gdnmlhgc`aom`ogx`gnqc~fdii
ldecicgsmxdiig~f`coc~cgs
_go~mxs
Lmx~fcsxg|cgq)sgo~mxsxglgx~mhxmdngxs~xwo~wxdildo~mxs~fd~swxxmw`n~fgemxgszgoclco
sg~~c`asngsoxchgndhm|g^fgsgqciihgzxgnmec`d`~iom`ogx`gnqc~fzmzwid~cm`ig|gi
gvzimxd~cm`sd`nd`disgsml~fglmwxg`|cxm`eg`~~zgs
4 Zfscodi2Zfscodig`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxsod`gvzimxg~fc`asswofdsag`gxdi~xg`nsc`wxhd`zid``c`axgid~c|g~mzfscodido~c|c~mxlmmn;~fgxmigml~gof`mimad`n
dw~med~cm`c`zgmzigsndciic|gs;mx~fgcezdo~ml~xd`szmx~d~cm`ss~gesm`d
zmzwid~cm ig|gi
8 Gom`meco2Gom`mecog`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxs)scecidx~m~fgngsoxcz~cm`mlgom`mecosg~~c`asdhm|g)om`ogx`slc`d`ocdidszgo~smlmhgsc~)zfscodido~c|c~d`n-mxgd~c`ad~
dzmzwid~cm`ig|giLmxgvdezig)zdzgxsfgxgedgvzimxg~fgcezdo~mlsmocmgom`mecos~d~wsm`zdx~coczd~cm c`zfscodido~c|c~mxlmmnom`swez~cm`zd~~gx`s)mxecaf~
zxm|cngd`d`discsmlgom`mecoswhscncgsmxedxkg~lmxogsds~fgzgx~dc`~m~fg
d|dcidhcic~mllmmn
? Zmic~codi2Zdzgxsom`ogx`c`azmic~codig`|cxm`eg`~disgo~mxsdxgickgi~mgvzimxg~mzcosswofds~fgcezdo~mlszgoclcozmicocgsm`lmmnoms~smxd|dcidhcic~)lw`nc`a
ngocscm`slmxzmzwid~cm`ig|gignwod~cm zxmaxdesmxsgx|cogs)mx