Staples (SPLS) Earnings Report: Q1 2016 Conference Call ... · Ronald Sargent (Chairman & CEO):...
Transcript of Staples (SPLS) Earnings Report: Q1 2016 Conference Call ... · Ronald Sargent (Chairman & CEO):...
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page1of21
Staples(SPLS)EarningsReport:Q12016ConferenceCallTranscriptThefollowingStaplesconferencecalltookplaceonMay18,2016,08:00AMET.Thisisatranscriptofthatearningscall:
CompanyPart icipants
ChrisPowers;StaplesInc.;VPIRRonaldSargent;StaplesInc.;Chairman&CEOChristineKomola;StaplesInc.;CFOShiraGoodman;StaplesInc.;President,NorthAmericanOperations
OtherPart icipants
MichaelLasser;UBS;AnalystMatthewFassler;GoldmanSachs;AnalystMikeBaker;DeutscheBank;AnalystSimeonGutman;MorganStanley;AnalystChrisHorvers;JPMorgan;AnalystKateMcShane;CitiResearch;AnalystGregMelich;EvercoreISI;AnalystDanielBinder;Jefferies;AnalystAnthonyC.Chukumba;BB&T;Analyst
MANAGEMENTDISCUSSIONSECTION
Operator :
Gooddayladiesandgentlemen,welcometotheStaplesInc.,FirstQuarter2016EarningsConferenceCall.Atthistime,allparticipantsareinalisten-onlymode.Later,wewillconductaquestion-and-answersessionandinstructionswillfollowatthattime.
[OperatorInstructions]
Iwouldlikeintroduceyourhostfortoday'sconference,Mr.ChrisPowers,VicePresident,InvestorRelations.Sir,youmaybegin
ChrisPowers (VPIR):
Goodmorningeveryone,andthanksforjoiningusforourFirstQuarter2016EarningsCall.
Duringtoday'scall,wewilldiscusscertainnon-GAAPmetrics.PleaseseetheFinancialMeasuresandOtherDatasectionoftheInvestorInformationportionofstaples.comforareconciliationofthesemeasures.Certaininformationwewilldiscussconstitutesforward-lookingstatementsforthepurposesoftheSafeHarborprovisionsofthePrivateSecuritiesLitigationReformActof1995.Actualresultsmaydiffermateriallyfromthoseindicatedbysuchforward-lookingstatementsasaresultofvariousfactors,includingthosediscussedorreferencedinStaples10-Qfiledthismorning.
HeretodiscussStaplesQ1performance,outlookandstrategicplanareRonSargent,ChairmanandChiefExecutiveOfficer;andChristineKomola,ChiefFinancialOfficer.AlsojoiningusareShiraGoodman,
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page2of21
President,NorthAmericanOperations;andJohnWilson,President,InternationalOperationsandHeadofGlobalTransformation.
Ron?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
ThanksChrisandgoodmorning,everybody.Thanksforjoiningustoday.
Thismorningweannouncedourfirst-quarterresultsthatwererightinlinewithourexpectations.BeforeIdiscussQ1inmoredetail,I'dliketostartoffbycoveringsomerecentheadlinesrelatingtotwotopics;one,isourattemptedacquisitionofOfficeDepot,andtwo,isourstrategicplangoingforward.
IthinkeveryoneonthecallknowsthatlastweektheUSDistrictCourtfortheDistrictofColumbiagrantedtheFTC'srequesttoblockouracquisitionofOfficeDepot.WeweredisappointedthattheFTC'srequestwasgranteddespitethefactthatinourview,itfailedtodefinetherelative--therelevantmarketcorrectlyandfellshortofprovingitscase.
TheFTCexcludedinkandtonerfromthemarketdefinitionofconsumableofficesupplies.TheyonlyfocusedonFortune100customersandacknowledgedthattherewerenoconcernsaboutanyharmtoconsumersorsmallormediumbusinesses.TheFTCignoredthecompetitivethreatfromAmazonBusinessandahostofothercompetitors,andalsoencouragedwitnessestosaythingsthatweren'ttruetobolstertheircase.
We'realsodisappointedthatourproposedremediestosatisfytheFTC'sconcernswereunsuccessfulandthatourcommitmenttoinvestasignificantportionofthesynergiesinlowerpricesforallcustomerswasnotheard.WepursuedtheOfficeDepotacquisitiontoprovideincreasedvaluetocustomerstocompetemoreeffectivelyagainstthelargeanddiversesetofcompetitorsandtogeneratetremendousvalueforshareholders.Overthepast20months,wecommittedalotoftimeandresourcestogettingthedealdone.Giventheadditionaltimeandresourceswe'dhavetocommittopursueanappeal,wehavedeterminedthatinthebestinterestofourshareholderstoforgoappealingthecourtruling.
Earlierthisweek,weterminatedthemergeragreementwithOfficeDepotandwewillpaythe$250millionbreakupfeetomorrow.OurdivestitureagreementwithEssendantwasalsoterminatedinconnectionwiththeterminationoftheOfficeDepotmergeragreement.Andfinally,IwouldjustliketothankbothOfficeDepotandEssendantfortheirhardworkandfortheircollaborationaswepursuedthistransaction.
We'renowfocusedonmovingforward,andwe'refocusedonexecutingastrategicplantodriveshareholdervalueorwhatwerereferringtointernally,asStaples20/20.Thisplanbuildsourreinventionsuccessesoverthepastfewyearsanditissupportedbyourstrongestcompetitiveadvantages.Wehavehadgoodsuccessindrivinggrowthincategoriesbeyondofficesuppliesandingrowingourmidmarketcontractbusiness.We'vealsobeenchallengedbyweakresultsinEuropeandinNorthAmericanstores.
We'reconfidentthatbynarrowingourfocus,moreaggressivelypursuingourbestopportunities,acceleratinggrowthinourassetlightbusinesses,andpullingbackinareaswithlesspotential;wecangetbacktosustainablelong-termsales,andearningsgrowth,andsignificantlyimprovereturnonnetassets.
Ourstrategicplanincludesfourkeypriorities.First,we'refocusingonwinningwithmidmarketcustomersinNorthAmericabyacceleratinggrowthinservicesandproductsbeyondofficesupplies.Second,we'rereshapingStaplesbynarrowingourfocusonNorthAmerica,rightsizingaretailnetwork,andexploringstrategicalternativesforEuropeanoperations.Third,we'retakingaggressiveactiontoreducecostanddriveefficiencyfurtheracrosstheorganization.Fourth,we'recontinuingtoreturncashtoshareholders
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page3of21
throughdividendsandsharerepurchases.
Twomonthsagowestreamlinedorganizationtobuildasimplifiedstructure,speedupdecision-making,andprovideflexibilitytoinvestinourcriticalstrategicobjectives.Thechangeswemadehavesetusupforsuccess,withShiraGoodmanleadingourNorthAmericanoperations,andJohnWilsonoverseeingourinternationaloperationsandourfutureplanningandtransformationefforts,I'mconfidentthatwehavetherightteaminplacetowinwithcustomers.
Overthenextthreeyearswewilldramaticallychangetheprofilestaplesaswepositionourcompanyforthefuture.Morethan95%ofoursaleswillcomefromNorthAmerica,whichisabout85%today.About80%ofoursaleswillbedeliveryversus60%today,andsalesbeyondofficesupplieswillaccountformorethan60%ofourrevenueversuslessthan50%today.
Letmetakeafewminutestogiveyoulittlemorecoloroneachofourfourpriorities.
First,winningwithmidmarketcustomersinNorthAmerica,wedefinethemidmarket,isbusinesscustomerswith10to200employees.Thisisahighlyprofitableandhighlyfragmentedcustomersegment,andtodaywehaveverylowsharewithmidmarketcustomersincategoriesbeyondofficesupplies.Theneedsofthosemidmarketcustomersaligncloselywithourstrengths.Thesecustomersneedawideassortmentofproductsandservices,thesupportivecategoryspecialistwhohaveexpertise,andeasyonlineshoppingexperience,aswellas,quickandreliabledelivery.
Wehaveexpertiseinawiderangeofproductsandservices.Wehaveaworld-classsupplychainandnextdaydeliverycapability.Ourdigitalexpertiseprovidesadifferentiatedcustomerexperience.Wehaveanewmidmarketloyaltyprogramthatisdrivingincreasedspend,hypertensionrates,andincreasedcustomerengagement;andwerecentlyregrettedourB2BdivisionStaplesBusinessAdvantagetoemphasizethemanyadvantagesthatwecanprovidetothosebusinesscustomers.
Toaccelerategrowthinmidmarket,wedevelopedastrongcustomerfocusplanthatbuildsonthestrengths.Ourplanfocusesonincreasingoursharewiththehundredsofthousandsofmidmarketcustomersweservetoday,andonacquiringmanyofthemidmarketcustomersthatwedon'tcurrentlyserve.We'reincreasingofferingofproductsandservicesbeyondofficesupplies,andpursuingmarketsharegainsincorecategorieslikeofficesupplies,ink,toner,andpaper.
We'reinvestinginsharperpricingandenhancedsupply-chaincapabilities.We'redramaticallyexpandingthesizeofourmidmarketsalesforcewiththeadditionofmorethan1000newsalesreps.We'realsopursuingacquisitionsofB2Bserviceprovidersincompaniesspecializingincategoriesbeyondofficesupllies.
Insummary,we'rehelpingsmallermidmarketcustomerscompetelikeaFortune500company
Second,we'rereshapingStaplestoreduceriskandpreserveprofitability.JohnWilsonandtheleadershipteaminEuropehaveworkedtirelesslytostreamlineandstabilizeEuropeoverthepastfewyears.WhilewebelievethereisasignificantopportunitytogeneratevalueinthehighlyfragmentedEuropeanmarket,wealsorecognizethatourbestgrowthopportunitiesareinNorthAmericaandthattheseareourprimaryfocus.Asresult,we'vedecidedtoexplorestrategicalternativesforEuropeanoperations.Overthecomingweeks,weplantomeetwithpotentialbuyersorEuropeanoperationsandwewillprovidemoredetailsontimingandvaluationasweworkthroughthisprocess.
WealsoremaincommittedtoincreasingproductivityandpreservingprofitabilityinourNorthAmericanretailstores.Wehaveclosedmorethan300storesandreducedourleaseobligationsbymorethan$1billioninNorthAmericasince2011.We'vealsoaggressivelymanageourleaserenewalprocess.Today,ouraverageremainingleaselifeinNorthAmericaisabout3.5yearsperstore,whichisareductionof
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page4of21
morethan40%since2011.
Wehavechallengedtheretailstoreteamtodomorewithless,andtheyhavedelivered.Customerservicescoresremainstrongandcustomerconversionisatanall-timehigh.Wewillremainlaserfocusedonthesemetricsgoingforward.WewillalsocontinuetorightsizeourretailstoreportfolioinNorthAmericabyclosingatleast50storesthisyear.
Inadditiontoclosingunproductivestores,wewillcontinuetobuildonthestrengthofouromni-channelcapabilitiesinserviceslikecopyandprint.Webelieveourstoresprovideconvenienceandimmediacythatisvaluedbycustomersofallsizes,includingmidmarketcustomers.
Ourthirdpriorityistoaggressivelyreducecostsacrossthecompanytodriveefficiencyandfundourgrowthinvestments.Overthepastthreeyears,wehavegeneratedapproximately$750millionofannualizedpretaxcostsavingsbyevolvingthebusinessprocesses,increasingproductivity,anddevelopingmoreefficientwaystoservecustomers.
Lastweek,weannouncedanewmulti-yearcostsavingsplanwhichisexpectedtogenerateanadditional$300millionofannualizedpre-taxcostsavingsbytheendof2018.We'refocusedonreducingproductcosts,optimizingpromotions,increasingthemixofStaplesbrandproducts,andreducingoperatingexpenses.Wewillalsocontinuetoreducecostinretailstoresaswerightsizeourstorenetwork.
Ourfourthpriorityistocontinuereturningcashtoshareholders.Weremaincommittedtoourongoingcashdividendprogram.Weplantoresumerepurchasingourcommonstockthroughopenmarketpurchasesduringthesecondquarterof2016.Wearecurrentlyplanningforsharerepurchasesofapproximately$100millionin2016.
Astheindustryleader,wepursuedtheacquisitionofOfficeDepotfromapositionofstrength.We'renowpursuingourstrategicplanfromasimilarposition;wearedramaticallyreshapingourbusinesswhileincreasingourfocusoncategoriesbeyondofficesuppliesandevolvingtomeetthechangingneedsofmidmarketcustomers.Wearereducingourexposuretounderperformingbusinessesandwearereiteratingourcommitmentreturncashtoourshareholders
Now,let'sturntoourfirstquarterresults.TotalcompanysalesforQ1weredownabout1%year-over-year,excludingtheimpactofstoreclosuresandchangesinforeignexchangerates.Non-GAAPoperatingincomerateindollarsimprovedversusQ1oflastyear.Non-GAAPearnings-per-shareof$00.17wasflatversusQ1lastyear.
OnourQ4earningscall,wetalkedaboutourkeyprioritiesfor16',whicharenowacriticalpartofourstrategicplan.Letmetakeafewminutestogiveyousomecoloronourprogressduringthefirstquarter.
Oneofourtopprioritiesistoaccelerategrowthincategoriesbeyondofficesupplies.Today,nearlyhalfofoursalesaregeneratedbeyondofficesupplies;businesscustomersareincreasinglyrelyingonStaplestoprovidethemawiderassortmentofproductsandservices.Themarketforthesecategoriesishighlyfragmentedandwe'rewinningwithbusinesscustomersofallsizesbyprovidingadifferentiatedlevelofserviceandexpertise.
DuringQ1,theNorthAmericancontractcontinuedtoleadthewayherewithgrowthandpromotionalproducts,facilitysupplies,breakroomsupplies,technologyandfurniture.WealsogrewkeycategoriesbeyondofficesuppliesNorthAmericanstoresandonlineduringQ1,withcomparablesalesgrowthinfurniture,facilitysupplies,copyandprint,mailandship,andbreakroomsupplies.
Anotherpriorityistogrowourmidmarketpenetrationandcontract.DuringQ1,wegrewNorthAmerican
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page5of21
contractsalesby2%inlocalcurrency.Ourstrongestmomentumwasinthemidmarketwheresaleswereupinthemid-singledigitsdrivenbysalesbeyondofficesupplies,whichisupabout10%year-over-year.Improvedcustomeracquisitionandretentionoffsetmodestlylowersalestoexistingcustomers,andthiswassupportedbyadditionalmidmarketsalesrepsthatwehiredduringQ1aswellascontinuedstrongperformanceinourmidmarketmembershipprogram.
Wealsonarrowedourfocusonourbestgrowthopportunitiesincontractsduringthefirstquarterwiththeannouncementofourintentiontosellourcontract,print,manufacturing,andoperationsbusinesstoTaylorCorporation.WeacquiredthecontractprintbusinesswhenweboughtCorporateExpressin2008.Asweincreaseourfocusongrowingourassetlightbusinessesandimprovingreturnonnetassets,itmadesenseforustopartwayswithcontractprint.
AtStaples,welackthescaleandmanufacturingexpertisethatthisbusinessrequires.Thebusinessisalsoverycapital-intensive;itgeneratesanoperatingmarginbelowthehouseandgeneratesareturnonnetassetsbelowourcostofcapital.Whilethisbusinessisn'tagreatfitintheStaplesportfolio,it'saperfectfitforTaylor.Weexpectthedealtocloseduringthesecondquarter.Welookforwardtocontinuingtoofferawideassortmentofprintsolutionsforcontractcustomerthroughvendorpartnershipsandourownin-storecapabilities.
We'realsofocusedonimprovingtraffic,bothin-storeandonline.Resultsherebeenmixedduringthefirstquarter.InCanada,trafficinstoresandonlineincreasedyear-over-yearandweimprovedcustomerconversion.IntheUnitedStates,wealsoimprovedcustomerconversioninstoresandonlinebutthiswasnotenoughtooffsetlowercustomertrafficacrossbothchannels.Weremaincommittedtoimprovingcustomertrafficonlineandconversionstores.Afewweeksagowelaunchedthenewunbeatablepricesforinkandtoner.Andwhileit'sstillearly,I'mpleasedreportthatthecustomerfeedbackhasbeenverypositive,andwehaveseenaniceimprovementinonlinetrafficintheUSduringthefirstfewweeksofQ2.Weknowthisistherightdecisiontoimprovepriceperceptionwhiledrivingbusinesscustomeracquisitionandretentionoverthelong-term.
Overthepastfewyearswe'vehadsuccessdrivinggrowthincategorybeyondofficesupplies,growingourmidmarketcontractbusiness,andprovidingbettervaluetoourcustomersbyinvestinginlowerprices.Ourmomentumcontinuedduringthefirstquarter,ourstrategicplanissupportedbyourstrongestcompetitiveadvantagesandbuildsonthesuccesses.We'reconfidentthatbynarrowingourfocusandmoreaggressivelypursuingourbestopportunities,wewillspeedupourtransformationwhilepositioningStaplesforsustainablelong-termsalesandearningsgrowth.
Let'stakeaquicklookatfirst-quarterresultsfromeachofourbusinessunits.I'mgoingtostartwiththeNorthAmericancommercial.Heresaleswereup1%year-over-year,excludingthenegativeimpactofchangesinforeignexchangerates.OnaGAAPbasis,salesinUSdollarswereflatversusQ1lastyearat$2.1billion.Incontract,salesgrew2%inlocalcurrencyduringthequarter.
AsImentionedafewminutesago,wecontinuetodrivestronggrowthincategoriesbeyondofficesuppliesandcontractduringthefirstquarter.Weachieveddouble-digitgrowthinpromotionalproductsandbreakroomsupplies,andsaleswereupinhighsingledigitsinfacilitysupplies.Contractsalesincorecategorieslikeink,andtoner,andpaper,weredowninthelowtomid-singledigits,andsalesofofficesupplieswereflatversusQ12015.
Duringthefirstquarter,NorthAmericanCommercialoperatingmarginsincreased63basispointsto7%,andoperatingincomegrewbyproximally$14millionorabout10%year-over-year.Thisimprovementprimarilyreflectslowerlevellaborcostandreducedmarketingexpense.WeexpectthedivestitureofStaplesprintsolutionstocloseoverthecomingweeks.Asaresultofthesale,weareplanningforabouta4%headwindtoourreportedNorthAmericancommercialsalesandabouta2%headwindtoour
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page6of21
reportedtotalcompanysalesoverthenextyear.
TurningtoNorthAmericanstoresandonline,salesdeclinedapproximately2%excludingthenegativeimpactofchangesinforeignexchangeratesandstoreclosures.OnaGAAPbasis,salesweredown5%to$2.2billionversusQ1oflastyear.Duringthefirstquarter,combinedNorthAmericanstoresandonlinecomparablesalesdeclinedby3%.Thisreflectsa1%localcurrencysalesgrowthonstaples.comanda4%declineinsame-storesales.ResultsinCanadawerestrongerthantheUSinbothstoresandonlineduringthefirstquarter.
Fromacategoryperspective,the3%declineincomparablesalesduringQ1wasentirelydrivenbyongoingweaknessintechnology,aswellasweaknessininkandtoner.Intechnologytabletsandtechnologyaccessorieswereourweakestcategorieswithdouble-digitdeclinesyear-over-year.Inkandtonerweredownthelowsingledigits.Outsideoftechnologyandinkandtoner,comparablesalesinstoresandonlinegrewduringthefirstquarter.Thisgrowthwasdrivenbyfurniture,officesupplies,facilitysupplies,andcopyandprint.
NorthAmericanstoresonlineoperatingmargindecreased40basispointsyear-over-yearto2.8%.Thisprimarilyreflectsthenegativeimpactoflowersalesandfixedexpenses,aswellaslowerproductmargininStaples.comversusQ1oflastyear.Thiswaspartiallyoffsetbyreducedmarketingexpense,improvedretailproductmarginrate,andsavingsrelatedtoreductioninheadcount.WecontinuetorightsizeourretailstorenetworkinNorthAmerica,duringthequarterweclosed14storesintheUnitedStates,endingQ1with1288storesintheUnitedStatesand305storesinCanada.Wehavenowclosedabout256storesorabout14%oftheNorthAmericanchainsince2014,
Finallyturninginternationaloperations,salesheredecreased3%excludingthenegativeimpactofchangesonforeignexchangerates.OnaGAAPbasis,salesinUSdollarsweredown6%year-over-yearto$738millionversusQ1oflastyear.InEuroperetail,same-storesalesdeclined9%duringthefirstquarterdrivenprimarilybyadecreaseincustomertrafficversusQ1.InourcontractbusinessinEurope,localcurrencysalesweredowninthehighsingledigitduringthefirstquarterandourEuropeanonlinebusiness,localcurrencysalesweredowninthelowsingledigit.
DespitetheweaksalestrendsinEuropeduringthefirstquarter,JohnWilsonandhisteaminEuropedidagreatjobaggressivelymanagingexpenses,andinfact,droveimprovedprofitabilityyear-over-year.
OutsideofEurope,wecontinuetodrivesolidgrowthinChinaduringQ1withsalesupinthestrongdouble-digitrangeinlocalcurrencyversusQ1oflastyear.WealsocontinuedtomakeprogressimprovingthebottomlineinAustralia,NewZealand,aswellasChina.Onthebottomlineinternationaloperatingmarginratesimproved13basispointsversusQ1oflastyeartoanoperatinglossof2.4%,andthiswasdrivenbyyear-over-yearimprovementinAustralia,ChinaandinEurope.
Andwiththat,letmeturnitovertoChristinetoreviewourfinancialresults.Christine.
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
ThanksRon.Goodmorningeveryone.
Totalcompanysalesforthefirstquarterwere$5.1billion.Onanon-GAAPbasis,totalcompanysalesdeclined1%versusQ1oflastyear.Thisexcludesa1%headwindfromchangesinforeignexchangeratesanda1%headwindfromstoreswe'veclosedinNorthAmericaduringthepastyear.OnaGAAPbasis,salesdeclined3%versusQ1oflastyear.
Duringthefirstquarter,weachievednon-GAAPdilutedearningspershareof$00.17,whichwasunchangedversusQ1oflastyear.OurQ12016non-GAAPdilutedearningspershareexcludespre-tax
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page7of21
chargesof$66millionprimarilyrelatedtocostsassociatedwiththeproposedacquisitionofOfficeDepotandstoreclosures.Italsoexcludesapretaxchargeof$32millionrelatedtothependingsaleofStaples'printsolutions.
OnaGAAPbasis,wereportednetearningsof$00.06pershare.Thoseprofitmarginsforthefirstquarterdecreased33basispointsto25.3%versusQ1oflastyear.Thisprimarilyreflectslowerproductmarginrateininternationaloperations,anditwaspartiallyoffsetbyimprovedproductmarginsinNorthAmericastores.
Duringthefirstquarter,totalcompanySG&Adecreased$59millionyear-over-year,afterexcludinga$24millionchargeinQ1ofthisyear,primarilyrelatedtheproposedacquisitionofOfficeDepotas$11millionofacquisitionrelatedcostsand$4millionofaccelerateddepreciationduringQ1lastyear.Thisreflectslowerlaborcostsduetoheadcountreductionsandstoreclosures,lowermarketingexpense,andthefavorableimpactofthestrongerUSdollar.AsapercentageofsalesSG&Aexcludingchargesdecreased44basispointsto21.5%.Excludingtheimpactofcharges,non-GAAPtotalcompanyoperatingmarginratesincreased14basispointsyear-over-yearto3.4%
TurningtoourQ1taxrate,excludingtheimpactofcharges,ournon-GAAPeffectivetaxratewas33.5%versusournon-GAAPeffectivetaxrateof33.5%inQ1of2015.Thismodestyearoveryearincreaseinoureffectivetaxratewithprimarilydrivenbychangesinourgeographicmixofearnings,versus2015.Q1capitalexpenditurescameinat$44million,adecreaseof$16millionintheprioryear.Withoperatingcashflowof$276million,wegeneratedfreecashflowof$232millionduringthefirstquarter.
Duringthefirstquarter,wedidmakecashpaymentsof$69millionrelatedOfficeDepotfinancingcommitmentfeesearnedbyourlendersin2015.Ifyouexcludethenegativeimpactofthesepayments,ourfirstquarterfreecashflowcameinat$301million.AttheendofQ1,Stapleshadapproximately$2billioninliquidityincludingcashandcashequivalenceof$946millionandavailablelinesofcreditofabout$1.1billion.
AsRonmentionedatthebeginningofthecall,onofourtopprioritiesistocontinuereturningexcesscashtoshareholders.
Wereturnedmorethan$300milliontoshareholdersannualthroughcashdividendsandweremaincommittedtoourdividendprogram.WealsoplantoresumesharerepurchasesduringQ2.Ourcurrentforecastisforabout$100millionofsharerepurchasesin2016.Asaresult,weplantoreturnapproximately$400milliontoshareholdersthisyearthroughdividendsandrepurchases.
Now,turningtoouroutlook,weremainontracktogetbacktoearningsgrowthin2016.Duringthesecondquarter,weexpecttotalcompanysalestodecreaseversusQ2oflastyear.WeexpecttodrivegrowthincategoriesbeyondofficesuppliesandourcontractbusinessinNorthAmerica.ThiswillbeoffsetbytheheadwindrelatedtothesaleofStaplesPrintSolutions,aswellasongoingweaknessesintechnology,andourretailstoresandforeclosures.
Onthebottomline,weexpectsecondquarternon-GAAPdilutedearningspershareintherageof$00.11to$00.13.OurearningsguidanceexcludesremainingcostsassociatedwiththeproposedacquisitionofOfficeDepot,andtheimpactofongoingstoreclosures,aswellasthenegativeimpactoftheOfficeDepotbreakupfee.Weexpecttogenerateapproximately$600millionofcashflowin2016.Ourfreecashflowguidanceexcludestheimpactofcashpaymentsrelatedacquisitionfinancing,aswellastheimpactofthebreakupfeethatwewillpayOfficeDepotthisweek.
In2016,weplantocloseatleast50retailstoresinNorthAmerica.Overtime,ourstrategicplanwilldriveimprovementinbothtopandbottomline.WewillexperiencesalespressuresasweexplorestrategicalternativesinEuropeandaswecontinuetocloseretailstoresinNorthAmerica.Theseheadwindswillbe
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page8of21
offsetbymidmarketgrowth,fueledbythecategoriesbeyondofficesupplies.
WeexpecttogetbacktosustainableearningsgrowthaswereshapeStaplesandresumeourrepurchaseprograms.WealsoexpectStaplesfreecashflowandthesignificantimprovementinreturnonnetassetsasweincreaseourfocusonassetlightbusinessesandreduceourexposuretoourweakestperformingbusiness.
I'llnowturnitbackovertoourconferencecallmoderatorforQ&A.
QUESTIONS&ANSWERS
Operator :
Thankyou
(OperatorInstructions)
MichaelLasser,UBS.
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
GoodmorningMichael.
MichaelLasser (Analyst-UBS):
HeyRon.Goodmorningandthanksfortakingmyquestion.
SoRon,itseemsliketheweekoftheODPsituation,thestrategyisnowjusttoreturntowhatweretheareasoffocusthatwereinplacepriortothedealandinchipawayafromwhatyou'vebeenworkingon,whetherit'srepairingcosts,growingcategoriesbeyondofficesupplies.Howdoyouknowthat,that'stherightstrategyoratleastthatyou'repursuingthatstrategyattherightpace?Whywouldnotmovingintomoreaggressiveactionsandstepsbetherighttherightpathtopursue?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Well,there'sacoupleofthings,thereasonwe'repursuingthisisbecausewetookagoodhardlookwithalotofinsideandoutsidehelpofallthat'sbeeninvolvedinthisprojectoverthelastseveralmonthswithsomeoutsideresourcesaswell.Welookedatkindof,wheredowecompetebest,whereourstrongestcompetitiveadvantages.
Welookedatnotonlyyouknow,today,butalsokindofdowntheroad.Andyouknow,basicallyitbuildsonsomeofthethingsthatwe'vebeenverysuccessfulatoverthelastseveralyears,andwhetherthat'stheopportunityofmidmarketcustomers.Wherewethinkthere'sagreatopportunitytoone,getmoreofthemaswellassellmoretothem,whetherthat'sgettingfocusedasmoreofadeliveryassetlightcompanyversusanassetheavycompany.
Andwe'vetalkedaboutwhatwe'redoingwithretailsandwhatwe'vedonewithretailstores,whetherthattalksaboutthemakingofareallyatoughdecisionaboutlookingatopportunitiesandoptionsrelatingtoourEuropeanbusiness,andIthinkyouknow,inoursituationandthedecliningindustrycostevaluationissomethingwehavetocontinuetodo.We'vedoneagoodjobwiththataswell.SoIthinkthosearetheelementsofthestrategy.
ImeanI'msureanybodycansay,"you'rebeingtooaggressive"or"notaggressiveenoughaboutyourparticularpartofthestrategy,"butIthink--youknow,inacompetitivesituationwe'realsolookingtoseehowourcompetitorsrespondgoingforward,andwewilladjustandactappropriatelygoingforward.
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page9of21
MichaelLasser (Analyst-UBS):
Andmyfollow-upquestionis,Ithinkwecanhaveaneasierviewonwherewethinkultimately--yoursaleswillleveloffjudgingbytheperformanceofthevarioussegments.
What'sharderforustograspishowsignificantarethepoolsofdiscretionaryexpensesthatyou'redrawingthatyoucouldpotentiallyreducefurtherfromhere,andhowdoyoubalancetoreducetheexpenseswiththeneedforgrowth?Acoupleyearsago,youleftalotandyouslowedtheinvestmenttotryandrealizeareturnoninvestment,what'sthestrategyfromhere?Howbigisthebucketandwheredoyougofromhere?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Well,whenyou'reover$20billionofrevenue,allthebucketsarelarge.
Obviouslyproductbucketisthebiggestbucket--theproductcost.Andwethinkourownbrandrepresentsarealopportunityforustotakecoststhere.
Lookatoursecondbiggestcost--wouldprobablybeinthesupplychainarea,andwe'relookingatalotofthedifferentwaysofapproachingsupplychainandatsomepointifyouwanttoknowmoreaboutthat,Shiracanrespondtothat.
Soyes,thebucketsarelargeanditisalwaysabalancingact.Ithinkwesaidthatthreemonthsagothatweexpecttoimpacttheearningsgrowththisyearafterthree,four,orfiveyearsofreducedearningsyear-over-yearaswe'veinvestedinthebusiness.AndIthinkthisyearistheyearwesaid,we'regoingtogrowthebottomline."
Weexpecttostartgrowingthetoplineagain.Idothinkthat'strue,butasChristinesaid,"wedon'texpecttodothatthisyear."Soyes,it'sabalancingactandthebucketsofopportunityarelarge.
MichaelLasser (Analyst-UBS):
Interesting.
YoumentionedthattheNorthAmericaproductmarginswereoffyear-over-yearthefirstquarter,wasthatjustduetothelowerpenetrationoftechnology,orinthelikeforlikebasisormarginsworkingup?Thankyousomuch.
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Itwasactuallyapartiallyacouplethings.
Oneisyes,itwaspartlymixedbutitwasalsotothepointof--wehaddonealotofhardworkinlookingatourpromotionalstrategy.Sogettingmoretargetedonthetypesofpromotionsthatwehaveoutthereandbeingabletomovemoreofthosedollarstoeverydaylowprices,inparticularlyonline.Soyou'vebeenableto--we'vebeenabletofigureouthowtoreallybalancethattypeofmarketingcampaign.AndIwouldsaythattheU.S.retailhasdonealottogrowtheirservicesbusinessovertimeaswell.
SoIthinkit'sallofthosethingscomingtogetherandthat'sbacktoRon'spointon"largepool",therearealotoflargepoolsthatwedohaveavarietyofwaysthatarestartingtakeholdthatwewillbeabletopursueevenmoreaggressively.
MichaelLasser (Analyst-UBS):
That'sveryhelpfulcommentary.Thankyousomuch
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page10of21
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
ThanksMichael.
Operator :
SimeonGutman,MorganStanley
SimeonGutman (Analyst-MorganStanley):
Hieveryone,it'sSimeonGutman.
Somyfirstquestionitwasmentioned--returningbacktoearningsgrowth,canwespeaktoitintermsofEBITorEBITDAgrowth,isthatgoingtobepositiveeventually?Andinthatsameregard,the$300millionofcostsavingsoverthenextfewyearsisthattooffsetinvestmentorisitsomeofthatcanflowtothebottom--IguesstotheEBITorthebottomline?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Sure,soI'lltakethequestion.
Theearningsgrowthwillcome,wekindofhaven'tdefinitivelydefinedthatyetbecausewedon'twanttogiveforwardlookingguidancebutwedefinitelythinkitwillbetowardsonthebottomline.AndIthinkthe$300million,it'sgoingtobeacombinationofthings,someofitwillgototheshareholdersandthebottomline,someofitwillbeusedtoinvestinthebusiness.Andwewillbeflexibleandwedothinkearningswillgrowjust--inanormalcourseparticularlyonsomeofthesecontractbusinessesthatyousawthisquarter.Sowe'llcontinuetodrivethegrowththroughthesalesofthatbusinessaswellastomangethe$300millionopportunitythatwe'vegot.
SimeonGutman (Analyst-MorganStanley):
Fromthedemandside,someofthecategoriesyousellfacepressure,canyoutalkabouthowthatcurvelookstodayversushowitdidayearago?Isthecurvesteepeningwhenyoulookatink,andtoner,andpaperdemand?Oristherateofdeclineandthatisthatholdingsteady?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Ithinkit'srelativelysteady.
Whenyoulookat,officesupplieswereshrinkingandnowthey'rekindofflattish.Soofficesuppliesthemselvesaregettingalittlebetter.Whenyoulookattheinktonerandpaper,Ithinkthey'vebeendowninthe3to4%overthelastfewyears,andthat'scontinuingon.
Intermsoftechnology,thetechnologyparticularlyinretail,thatrateofdeclineisslowing.We'restillverynegative,butnotnearlyasnegativewasafewyearsago.
SimeonGutman (Analyst-MorganStanley):
Okaymyfinalquestionisonthemarketingexpense.
Ithinkithelpedacrosstheboardbutin--toNorthAmericanindeliveryandinthestores,istherea--firstofall,howdiditcomedown?Whattypeofspendacamedownandistherearesidualhitfromthat?Inotherwords,isthatnotonlyanimpactthatyoucouldseeintheneartermfromleftmarketing,butcouldtherebesomeresidualimpactoverthenextcouplequartersfromit?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page11of21
Aswelookatthemarketingexpense,we'vereallybeenveryscientificandusedalotmoreoftheanalyticcapabilitythatwe'vebeenabletobuildin-house.
Soingeneral,themerchantsandthemarketingpeoplewouldsay,"you'regoingtolosesomesales"andthat'sprobablytrue,butwethinkthatwehaveenoughoffsetinopportunitywithinvestinginpriceontheonlinesideofthehouseforexampleandinvestinginsomeofthesalesforceandthedigitaltoolsinthecontractbusiness.Sowe'vebeenverythoughtfulabouthowwemanagethroughtheusageofthatspendandreallydrivingsalesactivitiesinalaserfocusedwayversuskindofagenericbrandfocusthatwe'vehadinthepast.
SimeonGutman (Analyst-MorganStanley):
Okay,thankyou.
Operator :
MikeBaker,DeutscheBank.
MikeBaker (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Hi,howareyou?
Iwantedtoaskacouplequestionsaboutthatmiddlemarketopportunity.Socanyouhelpusbysizing,whatpercentofyourcommercialbusinessnow--wouldyouconsidermiddlemarkets?Anycommentaryonwhatyouthinkyoursharemightbethere?Thentosortoffollow-up,ishowthisinitiative--ifweretalkingaboutsales,wouldbedifferentthaninthepast.Youknow,I'vecoveredyouforalongtimeandthisisn'tthefirsttimewe'veheardaboutamiddle-marketinitiative.SoIjustwanttoflushthatout.Thanks.
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Onthestatus,it'sabout20%ofourcontractsales.
AndIwillaskShiraGoodmanwho'sbeenheavilyinvolvedinthis.
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
Yes,firstofall,mid-market,whileitisprimarilyaStaplesbusinessadvantage,itactuallyspreadsacrossthecompanyandwehavemidmarketcustomerswhoshopinstores,throughstaples.com,quillandSBA.Andactually,that'salotoftheopportunitywhichis,howwebringthedifferentchanneltogetherandreallyhaveaconvergenceofcoursetogomuchmoreafter?SofromaNorthAmericaperspectiveitiscloserto10or15%ofthetotalNorthAmericanbusiness.
Andwe'realready,youknowtoday,growingandgainingshareinthemarket.Andthatthekeyonit,isthatthesecompaniesarelargeenoughthattheyhavemoresophisticatedneedsinmarketing,facilities,etc,butthey'resmallenoughthattheydon'tactuallyhavethesophisticationorthescaletohavethosein-house.Soweareseeingthatthevaluepropositionofbroadassortment,competitivepricing,veryreliabledelivery,plustheexpertisethatwebringisreallyenablingustogainshareofinthecore,butespeciallyinthebeyondofficebycategory.
MikeBaker (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Andso,anyideawhatthatshareiscurrently?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page12of21
Sotheshareinjustacrosstheboard--ourmid-marketshareislowerthanitisforeithersmallbusinessesorlargerbusinesses,becauseweinvestedmoreintheotherendsofthespectrum.
Thecoreshareisstillverysolidthelastyear,theboughtshareisin1%to2%.It'sahugeopportunity.
MikeBaker (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Okay,interesting.
Thefollowupquestion,justontheStaplesprintbusinessthatyou'redivesting,soyousaiditwouldbea4%hit,whatwillitdototheoperatingprofitinthecommercialbusinessandwillthatbeaccountedforasadiscontinuedoperation?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
Itwillprobablybenegligibletothebottomlinebecauseitdoeshavealotcapital,alotofintensityontheactualoperationssideofit,sowedon'texpectasignificanthit.Itwillgointo--althoughwewillsellitveryquickly,soitwillslowthroughdiscontinuedunlessit'sjustacompletesaleinQ2.
MikeBaker (Analyst-DeutscheBank):
Okaythanksforthecolor.
Operator :
MatthewFassler,GoldmanSachs
MatthewFassler (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):
Goodmorning.Thanks.
Myfirstquestion--apartofitwasaskedprior,butifyouthinkaboutthedeclinebothinmarketingcostsasapercentofsalesandalsothelowerlaborexpensesforNorthAmericandeliveryandthenicemarginexpansionthatyousawthere,withoutissuingguidanceasIknowyou'rereluctanttodo--wouldyousaythatmarginexpansionisfeasiblethereoverthecourseoftheyeargoingforwardwiththekindofsalesperformancethatyouputupinQ1?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
HiMatt,itsChristine.
Actually,asyouknowwefocusedondollargrowth.Sothat'skindofouremphasishere.Havingsaid,thatyouknow,we'vehadkindofnicesteadyreturnsandweexpectthattocontinuethroughouttheyear.
MatthewFassler (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):
Soinotherwords,theinvestmentlevelshavegoneinsuchthatwithlimitedtopline,youshouldbeabletoatleastholdprogressandprofitability?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Yes,Ithinkthat'showwestartedtoseeitandyouseethereturncomingthroughonsomeoftheseinvestmentsthatwehavemade.
MatthewFassler (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):
Secondquestion,kindofstrategically--havingjustbeenthroughthisveryextendedprocessandhaving
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page13of21
gottentoknowthecompetitionIguessIabitbetter,maybeabitdifferently--nowthatyou'veemergedfromthisprocess,anynewperspectivesyouwouldbewillingtoofferaboutwhereyouallthinkyouhaveparticularcompetitivestrengthsandareaswherewereyoufeelcompelledtoimprovethebusinessrelativetocompetition?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Yes,Imeanobviously--Idon'tknowifyou'retalkingaboutAmazonbusinessspecifically,butourviewstherehaven'tchangedatallof.Westillthinkthattheyareaverystrongcompetitorinretailforstaples.comandincontracts.Youknow,webelievethatinordertobesuccessfulinthisindustrywe'vegottobecompetitiveonassortment;we'vegottobecompetitiveonpricesanddeliverycapabilities.
Ithinkourdifferentiationgoingforward,notonlyagainstAmazonbusiness,butanybodyisyouwe'retodifferentiatebestbasedonexpertisethatwecanprovidetomid-marketaswellasservicesthatwecanprovidemid-market.Ithinkwe'vegotlotofinitiativesunderwaythatzeroinonthatmid-marketsegment.AndyouknowatthesametimeIcantellyou,Ithinkstoresstillprovideacompetitiveadvantage.Peoplestillwanttoshopinstores,onlinepurchasingisstillsmall.Ithinkforthecountry,it'sonlyabout20%ofretail,so80%percentisstillgoingonstores.
TheremaybetoomanystoresoutthereandIwouldagreewiththat,andIthinktherewillbefewerstoresgoingforward.ButIthinkthestoredrepresentcompetitoradvantage.Ithinkourspecializedfocusontheofficeproductsandmid-marketisaisgoingtobeacompetitiveadvantageversusothers.
Ithinkyouknow--whenyou'rebuyingasmuchproductaswe'rebuying,weshouldbeabletobuyverywellintheindustry.Sotherearealotofcompetitiveadvantages.Ibelievewehavenotonlyagainsttraditionalofficeproductstoplayers,butalsoIthinkincreasinglygoingforwardgoingagainstAmazon.
MatthewFassler (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):
Finally,Iknowyou--Ithinkyouwalkedthroughsomeoftheresidualcashcostsassociatedwiththemerger.Iknowyourstoreclosingprogramhascashcostsassociatedwithit.
Aswethinkaboutfreecashflowinandmodelitoutfor2016,Christine,what'stheaggregatedollaramountaboveandbeyondyourGAAPearningsandsortoftraditionalCAPEXetc--thatweneedtothinkabouttogettoayearendcashnumber?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Sowe'vegotabout$100millionrelatedtotherestructuringandkindoftheothercoststhatareusual.We'renotincludingthe$250millionbreakupfee.
Soyouknow,wethinkthatthe$600millionisprobablytherightnumberinthekindofordinarycourseofbusiness.
MatthewFassler (Analyst-GoldmanSachs):
Gotit.Thankyousomuch.
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
ThanksMatt.
Operator :
ChrisHorvers,JPMorgan.
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page14of21
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Thanksgoodmorningeverybody.
Iwantedtofollowuponthatquestion.Sothecompetitiveadvantagequestion,thispastyearDepothashadalotofchallengessigningupnewcontractcustomers,canyoutalkaboutyourabilitytomaintainthatedge?Haveyouseenalotofresumesfromtheirsalesforceofthepastyear?HasthedelayedOfficeMaxpledgeandintegrationbenefitedyourbusiness?HowdoyouthinkyoumaintainthisgetscompetitivegapoverDepotgoingforward?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Shira?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
Sowe'veactuallylookedatthatgapoveracoupleofyearsandithasbeenprettysteadythatourcontractfordeliverbusinessgrows600to800basispointsfasterthanOfficeDepot.SoIdon'tthinkit'sachangeintrend.
Whenyoulookatwhat'sdrivingourgrowth,we'vebeensteadyoncustomeracquisition,we'vebeensteadyoncustomerretention.What'sreallydrivingtheStaplesadvantagegrowthismid-marketcustomersandcategoriesbeyondofficesupplies,andneitherofthose,IthinkarereallycoretoOfficeDepot'scontractbusiness.
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Understood,Andthensoagain,andthat'sveryhelpful.
Ron,canyoutalkaboutwhatyourvisionorhowyouthinkaboutthenumberofstores--therightnumberstoresinNorthAmericaortheUnitedStatesfortheofficeproductsindustry?You'vehadsomeviewsinthepastaftergoingthroughthisandseeinghowthebusinesshastransformed,howyouthinkaboutthatgoingforward?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Well,IthinkthecustomerisgoingtodecidehowmanystoresshouldbeoperatingintheUnitedStatesandwho'sgoingtobeowningthestores.
IthinkinthepastI'vequotedanumberofsomethinglike2,400storesinofficeproductsindustryintheUS.I'mnotsurethat'sabadnumberatalltotellyouthetruth.
Whenyoulookattoday,IthinkOfficeDepotoperatesamaybe2,000stores,maybealittleless.WhenyoulookatStaplesthismorning,Ithinkwesaidthatwewereinthe1,280-1,300range.SodoIthinktherearetoomanystorestooclosetogether?Ido,andIthinkouropportunityisgoingtobetofocusonthedeliverybusinessandkindofrightsizeourstorenetwork.Butwewon'tbedoingthatalone,Ithinkwewillalsolookatcompetitiveclosingsaswell.
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Soisthestrategyyoutalked--Ithink50morestoreclosuresthisyear?Soisthestrategytwofoldtowaitfortheleasestocomeup,andatthesametimeseehowaggressiveDepotbecomes?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Ithinkthestrategyistokindofoptimizeourretailnetworkinconjunctionwithotherpeopletryingto
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page15of21
optimizetheirretailnetwork.
IfyoulookathalfofOfficeDepotstoresarewithin5milesoftheStaplesstore.Ifyoulookat70to80%ofOfficeDepotstoresthey'rewithin10milesoftheStaplesstore.SoIthinkintermsofdensity,excludingtheNortheast,there'sprobablyadensityissuethatprobablyhastoberesolvedasanindustry,notjustbyus.
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Makessense.
Andthenjusttofollowuponthegrossmargins--I'mnotsureifyoucoveredthis--thedegradationyearoveryearwasactuallymoresteepthisquarterthaninanpriorquarters,anditseemslikeitrolledoverabitlastquarter.Sowhat'sdrivingthatbecauseitdoesn'tsoundlikethemixhasreallychangedtablets--it'sstillbeendownalot,isthatthepaceofclosuresandintherentsavings--basicallyabating?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
It'sactuallyprettymuchinlinewithwhatwe'veexpected.
Wedidhavesignificantimprovementslastyearandthisyearit'sbeenacombinationoftheplanthatwehavewithinareastoinvestinsomeofourprices.It'sdefinitelythede-leverageoffixedoverheadcostsinourretailbusinessinEuropeandintheUS.It'salmostproductmarginrateimproveinthestoresandintheEuropeanstoresaswellaswe'vebeenabletooptimizesomeofthosepromotionaloffersthatwe'vehad.
Soitisinlinewithourexpectationourplanningstrategyacrossthedifferentbusinessunits.SoIthinkthat'salittlebitofwhatIwouldputthecoloraroundthat.
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Soaswethinkaboutthatgoingforward,doweannualizeoristheideatoinvestinprice,anddrivesales,andtakeoutcoststokeepEBITmarginsflattish?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Itwillvarybybusinessunits.SowearedefinitelyfocusedonmanagingasIsaid,growingearnings.Soyouwillseeitonthebottomlineandinsomebusinessunits,wewillinvestmoreinprice.
Ourstrategyonpriceistobefocusedonthebusinessunitsoroftheunitsandthevelocitythatcangrowthemost.We'realsoveryfocusedonmakingsurethattheotherlineitemswithinthatgrossmargin,includingleveragingoursupply-chainisstillanopportunityforus.
ChrisHorvers (Analyst-JPMorgan):
Thanksverymuch.
Operator :
KateMcShane,CitiResearch.
KateMcShane (Analyst-CitiResearch):
Goodmorning,thanksfortakingmyquestion.
IjusthadonequestionaboutEurope.IknowduringthemergerprocessthatIthinkyouwerelookingfor
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page16of21
interestedbuyersintheOfficeDepotpieceoftheEuropeanbusiness.Ijustwonderedintermsofinteresttotheextentthatyoucantalkaboutit,whatkindofinterestthatyoudidgetandhowwillthedynamicchangenowthatitseemslikebothEuropeanbusinessesareprobablyupforsale?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Christine?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
SoweweredefinitelyworkingwiththeEuropeanCommissiononthesaleoftheOfficeDepotbusiness.Therewasinterest.
SoIthinkthattheofficesupplybusinessoverthereisveryfragmented,it'sverydispersedacrossallareas.Sotherewasinterest.
Ican'tgointodetailsaroundthatpointintime,forourbusinessorfortheirbusiness,it'sstilltooearly.ButIthinkthatthekeypointis,itisafragmentedmarketoverthere.OurbusinessisgettingstrongerandstrongerwiththeleadershipthatismanagedwithJohnandhisteam.Sowe'llseeandkeepyouallupdatedastheprocesscontinues.
KateMcShane (Analyst-CitiResearch):
Andhowlongareyoutogivetheprocess,again,totheextentthatyoucandiscussitbeforeyouknow,maybepursuingkeepingEuropeaspartofthebusinessandcontinuingtoeitherre-strategizeorreformulatethebusiness?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
It'sstillearlyinourthinkingandthere'sdefinitelyavarietyofwaystomanagethealternativesthatwe'vegot.
SoIthinkit'sstilltooearlytoputadefinitivetimelineandspecificsoutthereatthispoint.
KateMcShane (Analyst-CitiResearch):
Okaygreat.
AndthenifIcouldaskanunrelatedquestiontothosetwo--Iknowit'sbeentalkedalittlebitalready,butwithpriceinvestments,canyoutellusabouthowyou'rethinkingabout--howmuchfurtheryouhavetogo?Howmuchmoreworkneedstobedoneandultimatelydoyouthinkyouhavetobetheabsolutelowestpriceinordertosucceedinhowyou'rebalancethat?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Yes,Ithinkitrelatestoknowwhatsegmentofthebusinessweretalkingabout.
IfyoulookatyouknowsomelargestcompaniesinAmerica,they'realreadybuyingveryverywell.Whenyoulookattheouronlinebusiness.orourretailbusiness,Ithinktherearesomeitemsthatare--youknow,weareremaintoohighat.
Onlineacoupleweeksago,weannouncedverysignificantreductionsinthepricesoninkandtoner,whichisthemostprice-sensitiveitemoroneofthemostprice-sensitiveitemsforcustomers.SoIthinkourgoalistogetasclosetoanybodyoutthereintheprice-sensitiveitems.Notsayingyouhavetobetheabsolutelowestbutthinkyouhavegottobewithinshoutingdistance.Particularly,whenyouthinkaboutsomeofthethingsthatretailoffers,therearesomeadvantagesofretailthatthemaybecustomersdon't
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page17of21
quiteexpectyoutobetheabsolutelowest,buttheotherthingsthattheretailoffersthatallowsyoutobeamaybeslightlyhigher.
Ithinkwelookatpricinglikeeverybodyelsedoes.Welookatpricesofitemswouldlookatintheelasticityofthose.Welookatthingsthatarekindofmedium,andwelookatthingsthatarenotelasticatall.ButIthinkingeneraloverthelastthreeyears,partoftheinvestmentsthatwe'vemadeasresultofthecosttakeout,hasbeentolowerprices.Ithinkwestillhaveawaystogo.
Andthenfinally,onceyougetintothecontractarea,you'renegotiatingyourpricesitembyitemintermsofoffcontractoroncontract.I'mnotsurethere'salotmoretobedonebecausewe'reprettyaggressivelypricedinthecontractsideofourbusinessalready.
KateMcShane (Analyst-CitiResearch):
Thankyou.
Operator :
GregMelich,EvercoreISI.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Ihaveacoupleofquestionsreallythinkaboutthelonger-termplanofgettingthe80%from60%ofthecommercialsideofthebusiness.
ThewayyouframeditRon,was"2,400storesfortheofficeproductindustry."Whatdoyouthinkisthereasonablenumberforyouasyoulookoutnow?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Yes,I'mnotgoingtogetintothat.I'mnotsendingoutcompetitivemessagesaboutwhatwethinkournumberisme.Wetalkedabouttheclosing50storesthisyearIthinkwetalkedafewyearsagobyclosing300,andIthinkwiththese50we'llbeaboutatthat300.
Wedon'thavealotofstoresthatlosealotofmoney.Wearetryingtomakesurethatourleaseobligationisgettingaslowaspossible,sowedohaveflexibilitygoingforward.Butintermsofournumberstores,we'renotgetinthere.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Iguessonthatoftheleaseobligation,Ithinktherentexpensenow,isaround$700million.CouldyouletusknowhowmuchthatisinNorthAmericaversustheEurope,giventhatyou'reconsideringleavingtheirstrategicoptions?Also,myguessistheEuropeanleasetermsarelongerthanNorthAmerica,isthattrue,theaveragelease?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Yes,theaverageleaseisalittlelonger,John.It'sjustunderfiveyearsinEuroperightnowistheaverageleaseandtheUSisinthemid-threeyears.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Andoftherentexpense,isEuropehigheronaverageperfoot?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page18of21
Yes,perfoot,definitely.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Last,ontheother$300millionofcostreductionyouguyshaveoutlined,whatactualcostswouldtherebeexecutingonthose?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
I'msorry,whatwasthatquestionagain,Greg?
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Whatcashcostswouldtherebe,ifany,toactexecutingonthenext$300millioncostreductionplanthatyouannounced?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Wehaven'tgonetothatlevelofdetail,butIwouldn'texpecttoasignificantchangeinthatofwhatwe'vedone.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Sotheratiowouldbesimilartowhatwesawonthefirstplan?
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Yes,maybeevenalittlebitless.
GregMelich (Analyst-EvercoreISI):
Okay,fairenough,goodluck.
Christ ineKomola(CFO):
Thankyou.
Operator :
DanielBinder,Jefferies.
DanielBinder (Analyst-Jefferies):
Thankyou.
Ijustwantedtogobacktotheinitiativeintermsofyoumid-market.Obviously,adding1,000newsalespeopleandfocusedonthatpartofthemarketsquarelyfocusesontheindependentchannel,andIwaswonderingifyoucouldjustgiveussortofthestated,theindustryupdateontheindependenceasyouseeit?Andwhetheryouthinkit'sgoingtorequirejustsheerbruteforceintermsofputtingsalespeopleoutthereorincrementalpriceinvestmentversushowyoupricethatsegmenttoday?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
SoIthinkitisbothofferingtothecustomerandhowweapproachthecustomers.
Soitisexpandingourproductsandservices,sowereallycanofferthemfullrangeofwhattheywant.ContinuingourcompetitivepricingasRonsaid,becausewearecompetitiveinthisareaandthedeliver.
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page19of21
Formid-market,actuallyOmnihassomevalue.Theyliketopickitupandstore,timesofsamedayshippingwillbeleveragingourretailnetworkaswellasthingslikeprintingthesamedaysatisfactionthatisvaluabletothem.
Andthenthesecretsauceisreallytheexpertisethatwebringtothemid-marketcustomers,andthat'swherethecombinationofsalesforce,andyes,wewillbeadding1,000people.Butreallycombiningthemandempoweringthemwithdataanddigitalasset,andit'sreallyinthatmixthatwethinkwecangainshareverycosteffectivelyanddifferentiateourselvesfromtheothercompetitorsinthemarket.
DanielBinder (Analyst-Jefferies):
Yes,thoseindependentshavelargelybeensuccessfulwithwhatIwouldprobablydescribeasfanaticalcustomerserviceandstaplesbeingabigorganization,hasgoodcustomerservice--butIsuspectsomeofthemom-and-popbusinessesouttherehavetheselong-termrelationshipswithindependents,sohowdoyoudoyouovercomethat?Howdoyoureallydistinguishyourservicelevelsversusthatmom-and-popplayer?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
Ithinkwedistinguishourserviceslevelswithourexecutionofit.
Youknowoursupplychainisreallygoingstrongonservicelevelandbyaddingthesalespeople.Thatdoesenableamoreoftheonetoonepersonaltouchthatsometimesitdoestaketodifferentiatefromit.
ThefinalpiecethatIwouldaddtoit,isthatincreasinglyourcustomerbaseischangingaswellandtheyarebecomingmoredigitallyastute,they'reusedtobuyingonline,andthereforeourdigitalcapabilitywhichfaroutpacetheindependentfeelers.Weseetimeandtimeagainisreallybeingalevertogrowtheirshare.
DanielBinder (Analyst-Jefferies):
IfIcouldjustfollowupononeotherquestion?
Welltwoactually,one,couldyoujustcommentonthecadenceofthequarter?IknowtherearesomeretailersouttherethathavetalkedaboutaslowdowninApril.Someareattributabletoweatherwhichwouldnotaffectyou,butsomemoremacrotypecommentary?Soifyoucancommentonthat?
Andthenthelastonewasjustregardingthesebosscategoriesyou'veobviouslyoutlinedfromthatyou'repursuingtoday.I'mjustcuriousifthere'sanysetofnewcategoriesthatyouwouldbewillingtosharewithustodaythatarecominguponyourradar?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Sointermsofthecadenceofthequarter,we'reoneoftheluckyretailersthatintheFebruary,March,Aprilquarter--soEasteristypicallyalwaysinourquarter.Sometimesit'slateinthequartersometimesitsearlyquarter.SointermsofthecadencewewereaffectedbytheEastershiftanditcamebacktousthefollowingmonth.
Intermsoftheabosscategories,Shira?
ShiraGoodman (President,NorthAmericanOperations):
Iwouldsaywehaveaverybroadofferingtodaywhenyouthinkabouteverythingfromfacilities,toprint,promo,text,furniture.Butonecategorythatwe'reparticularlyexcitedaboutandisleadingthepackingrowthrateis(snack).Andthatisactuallypartofcopyatthecore,butthenanythingthatsurrounds
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page20of21
copy,includingfoodandsnacksetc,andthat'sarealgrowtharea.Overall,Ithinkascompaniesusebreakroomasawaytoattracttalent,andbuildculture,andit'sarealopportunityforusthat'spayingoff
Operator :
AnthonyC.Chukumba,BB&T.
AnthonyC.Chukumba(Analyst-BB&T):
Goodmorningandthanksfortakingmyquestion.
Iguessmyfirstquestion,canyougiveusaquickupdateintermsofsalestransferratesfromclosedstores?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Sure,letmejustgiveyouabigpicture.
Whenwecloseastore,about70%ofitaffectsanotherstore,andit'sabout30%ofthetimewherewedon'thaveastoreanywhereclose,sothere'snotransferthere,whenyoulookatthe70%,whetherit'satransfer,it'stheroughly20%.AndIunderstandthattheOfficeDepotisgettingahighertransferrate,butmyguessisthestoresthatthey'reclosingtheOfficeMax,OfficeDepotstoresthatareclosertogether.Soitrunsaround20%.
Forthestoreswherewedohavecompetition,ifyouputthose30%inwherewedon'thaveanystorescloseby,itwouldprobablyinthe15%to17%.
AnthonyC.Chukumba(Analyst-BB&T):
Gotit.That'shelpful.
Mylastquestionwasrelatedto--Iguess--thisnewLaborDepartmentregulationwherethey'reincreasingthethresholdforfirstsalaryforemployeesthatareeligibleforovertime.IguessI'mjustwonderingandmaybeit'stooearly--firstoff,doyouseethisishavinganimpactatallinyourNorthAmericanretailstores,andwhatstepsyoutaketofurtheroffsetthat?
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
Obviously,it'sveryearlydays,soyouknow,wehaven'tdoneanymath.ButIcansaythatwewerekindofveryearlyonthisonebecauseweoperatealotofstoresinCalifornia.
Severalyearsago,wereclassifiedsomeofthosequote,"assistantmanagers"tohourlyjustbecauseofthisissue.SoIthinkwe'reprettyfaraheadontheissue.Andthenyouknowmostofourmanager'swork--ourassistantmanagersarekindofworkingsimilartokindofourstoremanagers.Wedon'thavealotof80hourweekmanagertypeslikeyoumighthaveheardaboutinthepress.
AnthonyC.Chukumba(Analyst-BB&T):
Gotit,thankyouforansweringmyquestion,that'shelpful.
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
ThanksAnthony.
Operator :
ThankyouandIwillnowliketoturnthecallovertoMr.RonSargeantforanyclosingremarks.
CompanyName:StaplesIncCompanyTicker:SPLSSector:ServicesIndustry:SpecialtyRetail
EventDescription:Q12016EarningsCallMarketCapasofEventDate:5.39BPriceasofEventDate:8.275
©2014TheStreet,Inc.Al l R ightsReserved Page21of21
RonaldSargent (Chairman&CEO):
I'lljustwrapbysayingthanksforjoiningusonthecallthismorning.Welookforwardtospeakingtoallofyouagainverysoon.
Operator :
Ladiesandgentlemen,thankyouforyourparticipationontoday'sconference.Thisconcludesyourprogram.Youmaynowdisconnec
t.Everyonehaveagreatday.
Allrightsreserved(c)2014TheStreet,Inc.
Pleasefeelfreetoquoteupto200wordspertranscript.Anyquoteshouldbeaccompaniedby"ProvidedbyTheStreet"andalinktothecompletetranscriptandwww.thestreet.com.Anyotheruseormethodofdistributionisstrictlyprohibited.
THEINFORMATIONCONTAINEDINEACHWRITTENORAUDIOTRANSCRIPT(the"TRANSCRIPT")ISAREPRODUCTIONOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SCONFERENCECALL,CONFERENCEPRESENTATIONOROTHERAUDIOPRESENTATION.THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDED"ASIS"AND"ASAVAILABLE"ANDTHESTREETISNOTRESPONSIBLEINANYWAYNORDOESITMAKEANYREPRESENTATIONORWARRANTYREGARDINGTHEACCURACYORCOMPLETENESSOFTHETRANSCRIPTSASPRODUCED,NORTHESUBSTANCEOFAPARTICULARCOMPANY'SINFORMATION.
THETRANSCRIPTSAREPROVIDEDFORINFORMATIONALPURPOSESONLY.THESTREETISNOTPROVIDINGANYINVESTMENTADVICEORENDORSINGANYPARTICULARCOMPANY.