Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ...
Transcript of Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ...
![Page 1: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in situ Conditions at the Old Rifle site
Collaborative Research by the SLAC-SFA and Rifle IFRC teams
J.R. Bargar (SSRL)K. Campbell (USGS), H. Veeramani, E. Suvorova, and R. Bernier-Latmani (EPFL), J.E.
Stubbs, and J. Lezama (SSRL), K.-U. Ulrich, L.Y Blue, and D.E. Giammar (WUStL), P.E. Long, and S. Yabusaki (PNNL)
2010 Long-Term Surveillance and Monitoring Conference. November 17, 2010. Grand Junction, Co
![Page 2: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1 in
Naturally reduced sediments from the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery
Dynamics of reduced UState of our understanding
U(VI) “U(IV)”Reduction
U(VI)Oxidation
![Page 3: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
1 in
Naturally reduced sediments from the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery
Dynamics of reduced UState of our understanding
U(VI) “U(IV)”Reduction
U(VI)Oxidation
What are oxidation rates of reduced uranium?What are the mechanisms and their products?
Focus of this talk
![Page 4: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
1 in
Naturally reduced sediments from the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery
Dynamics of reduced U
U(VI) “U(IV)”Reduction
U(VI)Oxidation
Goals: ● Rates/mechanisms for individual U(IV) species● Under aquifer conditions(i.e., the parameters needed for biogeochem models)
Focus of this talk
![Page 5: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
From literature and our group’s work:• uraninite (UO2(s))• U(IV) sorbed to biomass• U(IV) adsorbed to minerals• U(IV) incorporated into Fe sulfides
Forms of reduced uranium
![Page 6: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
From literature and our group’s work:• uraninite (UO2(s))• U(IV) sorbed to biomass• U(IV) adsorbed to minerals• U(IV) incorporated into Fe sulfides
Forms of reduced uranium
Biogenic uraninite• Most well-studied of these materials• Only form of U(IV) for which thermodynamic,
kinetic parameters are known • Can be used as a proxy to understand behavior of
other forms of U(IV) in sediments• Abundant in low-temp. sedimentary ore deposits• Widely used sink term in biogeochemical models
![Page 7: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
How can we isolate individual U(IV) species & assess their reactivity under field conditions?
![Page 8: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Capturing complexity
Increasing complexity
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Stirred reactor: add soluble oxidants
Simplest lab approach
The “real thing”
mineral
Highly complicated:
difficult to isolate individual species
Ideal for studying individual species,
but simplistic
![Page 9: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Capturing complexity
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
mineral
![Page 10: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Capturing complexity
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
0.01 atm O2
√√
k = 5.5•10-13
mol m-2 s-1 (50.1 m2 g-1)Ulrich et al. ES&T (2008)
and GCA (2009)
![Page 11: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Capturing complexity
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
0.01 atm O2
√√
k = 5.5•10-13
mol m-2 s-1 (50.1 m2 g-1)Ulrich et al. (2008)
ES&T 42, 5600
Problem is, this doesn’t give us what we ultimately
need to know……..
![Page 12: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Capturing complexity
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
√√
… namely rates under field conditions that take into account:
• Time-dependent ground water composition
• Role of diffusion
![Page 13: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Approach: in-situ incubations in wells
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Conduct experiment
in-well
In well, biomass present
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
![Page 14: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Increasing complexity
+ Artificial ground water
Conduct experiment
in-well
In well, biomass present
Solid-phase oxidants, in appropriate
matrix
Add soluble oxidants
Highly informative for soluble
oxidants (DO > 0.5 mg/L or NO3
-).
This study
Approach: in-situ incubations in wells
![Page 15: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
• Trace solutes moderate uraninitestability – dramatically so.
• Ground water is compositionally complex in space and time.
• Laboratory investigations: challenged to provide meaningful rates for field (but provide crucial information that links reactivity to structure).
Courtesy of D. Giammar, WUStL
Bio-UO2 dissolution rates
Biogenic uraninite
![Page 16: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
→ need for experiments that capture complex ground water behavior
To assess roles/function of molecular-scale processes at field scalesTo obtain rate laws for biogeochemical models
• Trace solutes moderate uraninitestability – dramatically so.
• Ground water is compositionally complex in space and time.
• Laboratory investigations: challenged to provide meaningful rates for field (but provide crucial information that links reactivity to structure).
Courtesy of D. Giammar, WUStL
Bio-UO2 dissolution rates
Biogenic uraninite
![Page 17: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Rates and mechanisms of biogenic uraniniteoxidation at the Rifle IFRC site
![Page 18: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
B-02: OxicD.O. 0.5-1.2 mg/L
Remove & characterize:• Structure (EXAFS/XANES, TEM)• Composition (XPS, SR-PD)• U loss rate (gel probes)• Reactivity (CFR)
B02 P103
Model for contaminated DOE-LM sites in Co River basinApproach: install bio-uraninitein ground water
• pre-characterize uraninite• Install in wells in
permeable reaction cells
Choose wells w/ contrasting GW comp: P-103: Suboxic
D.O. <0.1 mg/L
months to
years
Approach: Rifle wells as “in-situ chemostats”
Bio-uraninite stability
![Page 19: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Permeable membrane cells:Keep nanoparticles in/bacteria out
Diffusion test on sample cells C and E
y = 9.60xR2 = 0.96
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80Time (h)
Con
d (μ
S/cm
)
Calculated equilibrium
cell E
Cell diffusive half-equilib: ~20 hr.
Two types of samples:• Uraninite-water suspensions• Suspended in polyacrylamide gel pucks:
Diffusion time constant ~ few hr.
U(VI)DO, DIC
UO2
Rifle well
16’
Diaphragm
Diaphragm
Gel pucks
windows
![Page 20: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Predictions: 12 week reaction oxic well
Before reaction
RATE prediction: complete dissolution (B-02)
MECHANISM prediction:Slow oxid. of surface U(IV) → Rapid removal by CO3
-
![Page 21: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Observation ≠ Prediction
After 12 wk. reaction in oxic ground water
Before reaction
![Page 22: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Electron Microscopy: after reaction
• UO2 nanoparticles ~ 1.5 nm diam.• No evidence for any crystalline
secondary phases.• Ca, Si associated with UO2
![Page 23: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Corrosion mechanism
(111) (200)
(220)(311)
(331)
Pre-incubation: 2.07(5) nmP-103: 2.09(4) nmB-02: 2.15(5) nmAll: a=5.466(2) Å
• No accumulation of UO2+X or U(VI) solids.
• EXAFS: Local structural order similar before/after
• Diffraction: no change in material, particle size.
• No UO2+x, calcite, other phases.
• Mechanism = prediction
![Page 24: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Uranium loss rates: gel puck measurements
oxic
Bio-uraninite stability
Cleaned uraninite
Pre
-in
cuba
tion
suboxic
![Page 25: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Uncleaned: cells + uraninite
suboxic
oxic
Biomass retards U loss!
Uranium loss rates: gel puck measurements
Cleaned uraninite
suboxic
oxic
Bio-uraninite stability
Pre
-in
cuba
tion Pre
-in
cuba
tion
![Page 26: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Mass Loss Rates in Rifle Wells
• Observed U loss rate is slow: R ~ 2x10-11
• 50 to100x slower than laboratory dissolution rate• Ca is strongly associated with uraninite after retrieval
0.01 atm O2
B-02 P-103
![Page 27: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
1. O2 diffusion can account for rate (S. Yabusaki, PNNL)
4 month reaction: Predict 52% of uraninite is lostObserve 55% of uraninite is lost
Why is U mass loss so slow?Two possible explanations:
UO2(s)
membranemembrane
UO2 UO2
UO2 distribution: 37d
![Page 28: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
1. O2 diffusion can account for rate (S. Yabusaki, PNNL)
4 month reaction: Predict 52% of uraninite is lostObserve 55% of uraninite is lost
2. Other possible explanation: dissolved trace solutes (e.g., silicate, 0.5 mM, Ca2+, 0.7 mM) retard U corrosion.
UO2(s)
membranemembrane
UO2 UO2
UO2 distribution: 37d
Why is U mass loss so slow?Two possible explanations:
![Page 29: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Conclusions
• Modest diffusion limitation causes large decrease in U loss rate
• Diffusive barriers in natural sediments are likely to be much higher: very slow U release, even in oxicground water
• Presence of biomass further slows oxidation
![Page 30: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
• Modest diffusion limitation causes large decrease in U loss rate
• Diffusive barriers in natural sediments are likely to be much higher: very slow U release, even in oxicground water
• Presence of biomass further slows oxidation
• Suitable for bioremediation? Very good prospects
• Implications for other forms of U(IV): • O2 diffusion limitation important for other forms
of U(IV)• Establishes lower limit for U(IV) release rates.
Conclusions
![Page 31: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
• Continue ongoing experiments for 21 months to establish rates over more realistic time scales
• Investigate stability of other forms of U(IV) (in progress):
• Biomass-sorbed U(IV)
• Mineral-sorbed U(IV)
Future directions
![Page 32: Stability of Biogeochemically Reduced Uranium Under in ... Wednesday...the Rifle IFRC site, LQ Gallery. Dynamics of reduced U. U(VI) “U(IV)” Reduction. U(VI) Oxidation. Goals:](https://reader035.fdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071421/611a303df29a03528f273012/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Acknowledgements
Funding: DOE-BER SBR divisionDOE-BESSwiss National Science Foundation
SLAC-SFA team:
Dan AlessiJuan LezamaMike MasseyApurva MehtaMarc MichelEllie SchofieldJoanne StubbsKai-Uwe UlrichHarish Veeramani
And others….
Dick Dayvault, Dave Traub, Sarah Morris (S.M. Stoller)
Ken Sartain (design/fab)
Joe Rogers (SLAC beam line engineer)
Carol Morris, Aaron Gooch, and Jim Allan (SLAC RCT)