Sr. o. Particulars Page os. Meeting of the GCZMA....

1

I�DEX to the 50 to 55th

Minutes of the Meetings of Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority

(GCZMA)

Sr. �o. Particulars Page �os.

1 50th Meeting of the GCZMA.

2-6

2 51st Meeting of the GCZMA

7

3 52nd Meeting of the GCZMA

8-10

4 53rd Meeting of the GCZMA

11-20

5 54th Meeting of the GCZMA

21

6 55th Meeting of the GCZMA

22-29

2

MI�UTES FOR THE 50th

GCZMA SUB COMMITTEE MEETI�G OF THE GOA COASTAL ZO�E

MA�AGEME�T AUTHORITY HELD O� 07 / 05 / 2009.

The GCZMA sub-committee constituted to decide various CRZ cases/conduct personal hearings and

CRZ matters met under the chairmanship of Secretary (Environment) in his chamber on 07/05/2009.

The list Members who attended is annexed.

Item �o. 1

Minutes of the 49th sub committee meetings held on 04/03/2009 and 20/03/2009 were confirmed.

Item �o. 2 (Development in CRZ-II Areas)

Case �o. 1

Proposed re-construction of residential house G+1 in Chalta �o. 24 of P.T. Sheet �o. 155 of

Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, By Mr. Agnelo Francisco D’Costa (GCZMA/S/09-10/ 09 ).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, subject to the same confirming to the local building byelaws

and with prior permission from Mormugao Planning &Development Authority (MPDA)

Case �o. 2

Proposed re-construction of residential house G+1 in Chalta �o. 112,114,202 & 205 of P.T.

Sheet �o. 172 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, By Mr. Agustinho Fernandes (GCZMA/S/09-

10/ 08 ).



Case �o. 3

Proposed construction of residential building(G+7) in Chalta �o. 38,39 & 40 of P.T. Sheet �o.

135 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, By Mrs. Ivy D’Gama (GCZMA/S/09-10/ 07 ).



Item �o. 3 (Repair & Renovation/Development in CRZ-III Area).

Case �o. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of exiting house in Sy. �o. 135/4 of �agorcem-Palolem village,

Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Ulhas Dessai. (GCZMA/S/09-10/04).

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the plinth and the FAR remains the same.

Case �o. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 257/1 of Cola village, Canacona

Taluka, by Mr Agnelo Moreno Alias Agnelo Mateus Fernandes. (GCZMA/S/09-10/05).


Case �o. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 120/12 of �agorcem-Palolem

village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr Jose Fernandes. (GCZMA/S/09-10/03).


Case �o. 4

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing Chapel in Sy. �o. 37/2 of �agorcem-Palolem

village, Canacona Taluka, by Colomba Holy Cross Chapel Committee (GCZMA/S/09-10/02).


Page 1 of 5Page 1 of 5Page 1 of 5Page 1 of 5

3

Case �o. 5

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing St. Anne’s Presbytery (Parochial House) of Agonda

village, Canacona Taluka, by Fr. Blaise Mascarenhas sfx. (GCZMA/S/08-09/01).


Case �o. 6

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 172/17 of Calangute village,

Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Menino Camilo Fernandes (GCZMA/�/09-10/01).


Case �o. 7

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 133/33 of �agorcem-Palolem

village, Canacona Taluka, by Smt. Durga S. �aik (GCZMA/S/08-09/67).


Case �o. 8

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house bearing no. 143 in Sy. �o134/5-D of

�agorcem-Palolem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Leo Kistodio D’Mello (GCZMA/S/08-

09/69).


Case �o. 9

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house bearing no. 483 in Sy. �o. 132/16 of

�agorcem-Palolem village, Canacona Taluka, by Smt. Hirabai J. Bandekar (GCZMA/S/08-

09/68).


Case �o. 10

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.�o. 160/1 of Anjuna village, Bardez

Taluka, by Mrs. Lorraine Asha Maria Pereira (GCZMA/�/09-10/07).


Case �o. 11

Proposed �oC for repair and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o.244/3(Part) of Calangute

village, Bardez Taluka, by M/s. Aqua Beach Resort (GCZMA/�/08-09/73).


Case �o. 12

Proposed �oC for repair and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 202/2-A of Calangute

village, Bardez Taluka, by Mrs. Sabina Coutinho (GCZMA/�/09-10/02).


Case �o. 13

Proposed �oC for repair and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o.244/3-A of Calangute

village, Bardez Taluka, by Mrs. Saara Mohammod Reza �ajmi (GCZMA/�/09-10/83).


Case �o. 14

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 162/8, 9 of Candolim village,

Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Mario D’Costa (GCZMA / � / 09-10 /10).


Page Page Page Page 2222 of 5of 5of 5of 5

4

Case �o. 15

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 359/15, 23 of Chapora village,

Bardez Taluka, by Mrs. Daswanti V.Dabholkar (GCZMA / � / 09-10 / 05).


Case �o. 16

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 128/11 of Anjuna village, Bardez

Taluka, by Mrs. Philomena Pereira (GCZMA / � / 09-10 /11).

Decision: Deferred, as the documents relating to the structure need more verification.

Item �o. 4 (Other Developments/Regularizations)

Case �o. 1

Proposed repair of bund alongside Zuari River in property under survey no. 99/1 of Village

Bambolim, Tiswadi taluka. (GCZMA/�/1/07/83) (Antonio Fernandes)

Decision: GCZMA members decided to reject the application made by Shri. Antonio Fernandes, to

erect bund wall to prevent sea erosion at the site. However, GCZMA agreed that the recommendation

made by WRD for temporary measures to be taken up the extent of 300mts. at the said site be

permitted to prevent erosion in monsoon and under strict supervision of the WRD.

Case �o. 2

Proposed �OC for repair/modification of existing jetty at Rumod and dredging of certain area

of River Mandovi in Bicholim taluka, by M/s Pandurang Tomblo.

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the dredged material should not be dumped within

NDZ of the river Mandovi.

Case �o. 3

Proposed re-construction of bund wall in Survey no. 564/1 of Curtorim village, Salcete taluka,

by Shri Darryle Da Veiga. (GCZMA/S/08-09/ 28).

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the mangroves should be protected and the re-

construction should be towards landward side from the existing mangrove growth.

Case �o. 4

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy.no. 25/0 of Quelossim village, Mormugao Taluka by M/s. Delta

Engineering Decision: Deferred, It was decided by the GCZMA sub-committee members that the

proposal should be taken for consideration only after the election process is over.

Case �o. 5

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy. �o.30/8 of Cortalim village, Mormugao taluka by M/s. Desa

Engineering

Decision: Deferred, It was decided by the GCZMA sub-committee members that the proposal should

be taken for consideration only after the election process is over.

Case �o. 6

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.16/3 of Cottombi

village, Bicholim taluka by M/s. D.B. Bandodkar & Sons Pvt. Ltd.




5

Case �o. 7

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.18/8 of Tixem

village, Bicholim taluka by M/s. D.B. Bandodkar & Sons Pvt. Ltd.



Case �o. 8

Proposed regularization of barge loading jetty bearing in Sy. �o.58/1 of Sirsaim village, Bardez

taluka by M/s. Anant V. Sarmalkar (GCZMA/S/389).



Case �o. 9

Proposed construction of mechanized twin jetty in survey �o.17/4 of Kottombi village,

BicholimTaluka, by M/s. Bandekar Brothers Pvt.Ltd.(GCZMA/�/09-10/06)



Case �o. 10

Proposed Construction of Shipyard cum dry-dock in Sy. �o. 209/1(Part -A) of Sancoale village,

Mormugao Taluka by M/S. Dylane Shipping Pvt. Ltd.



Case �o. 11

Proposed construction of Barge Repair workshop in Sy. �o. 16/6, Chicalim Village, Mormugao

Taluka by M/s Abishek Engineers.



Case �o. 12

Construction of residential buildings by M/s Hermitage Builders in Sy. �o. 16/4 and Sy. �o.

16/6 at Sernabattim village, Salcete Taluka.

The request of M/s Hermitage Builder vide their letter dated 24/04/2009, for change in site

plans/location and scope of the project from residential to a Health resort, was discussed. Lt. Gen.

R.S.K. Kapur (Retd.), appeared on behalf of the M/s. Hermitage Builders and explained their concept.

Decision: On perusal of the site inspection details, which indicate the structure to be coming up on

sanddunes, it was decided that the same should not be permitted neither should the request for change

in site plans/scope of the project be allowed. The request made by M/s. Hermitage Builders is

therefore rejected.

Item �o. 5 (Any other Items)

Case �o. 1

Urgent Anti Sea erosion and Protection measures for Candolim Beach………Request from

WRD

The matter was discussed with Mr. P.B. Badami, Executive Engg.-I, WRD, who gave a

detailed presentation on the matter and appraised the Members on efforts proposed to be taken up for

preventing further erosion on the beach by installing geotubes, which is a soft measure adopted in

consultation with CWPRS, Pune.

Decision: Approved.


6

Case �o. 2

Proposal from the Department of tourism….(i) Installation of High Mast Light Unit at Miramar

Beach, (ii) Provision of toilets,parking lot and picnic spot at Bogmalo Beach and (iii) Erection of

Iron Gate near Bandodkar Statue at Calalngute.

The Proposals of the Department of Tourism forwarded to the GCZMA were discussed. It

was decided to approve the installation of High Mast Light Unit at Miramar beach, while the other

two proposals to be deferred and site inspection and detailed evaluation of the proposals are carried

out.

Case �o. 3

Illegalities carried out by Shipyards and barge repair workshops at Rassaim, Loutolim and

near Borim Bridge…. Complaints from Public.

The Complaints received form the public about the inaction of various authorities on the

illegal activities being carried out by the shipyards and barge repair facilities at site was deliberated. It

is seen that the Revenue authorities have not yet completed the inquiries and mapping/ site survey

pending before them and that the Village Panchayat has granted approvals without proper verification

of the permissions from other statutory Authorities.

It was decided that the matter be detailed and action required to be taken be put up during the

next meeting i.e. on 27th May 2009, in the meanwhile site inspections be conducted and reports

prepared.

*************

Page Page Page Page 5555 oooof 5f 5f 5f 5

7

The 51st meeting was for only Personal Hearing.

Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of 1111

8

MI�UTES FOR THE 52

nd GCZMA SUB COMMITTEE MEETI�G OF THE GOA COASTAL ZO�E


Item �o. 1 (Construction/Reconstruction/Development in CRZ-II Area).

Case �o. 1

Proposed construction of residential house (G+1) in chalta �o. 55(Part) of P.T. sheet �o. 63 of Vasco city,

Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Rosario Sequeira(GCZMA/S/08-09/33).

Decision: Approved from CRZ Notification 1991 angle, subject to the same conforming to the local building

byelaws and with prior permission from Mormugao Planning & Development Authority (MPDA)

Case �o.2

Proposed construction of first floor to the existing residential house in chalta �o. 3,4 & 5 of P.T. sheet �o.

154 & 155 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Fayaz Mohamed(GCZMA/S/09-10/12 ).



Case �o. 3

Proposed re-construction of residential house (G+1) in chalta �o. 67, 68 & 255 of P.T. sheet �o. 172 of

Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mrs. Maria Anjela A.E. Colasco & Othrs(GCZMA/S/09-10/13).




Case �o. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house bearing �o.1814/A in Sy. �o. 333/2 of Benaulim

village, Salcete Taluka, by Mrs. Maria Rosinha Eusefia Menezes e Fernandes. (GCZMA/S/09-10/ ).

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remains the same.

Case �o. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 81/12 of �agorcem village, Canacona

Taluka, by �agesh Duclo Komarpant (GCZMA/S/08-09/43).

Decision: Deferred, The Chief Officer (CMC) to be called to identify on what basis the order is passed

regarding existence of structure prior to 1991.

Case �o. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. �o. 182/3 of Arambol village, Pernem

Taluka, by Mrs. Telautina Luddin Cardoza (GCZMA / � / 08-09 / 52).

Decision: Approved, one of the documents submitted by the project proponent, contains electricity connection

issued in the year 18/12/ 1990. This proves that the structure was in existence before Feb, 1991. Hence approval

considered subject to existing plinth and FAR.


9

Case �o.4

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.�o. 134/7 of �agorcem village, Canacona

Taluka, by Jagdish Komarpant(GCZMA/S/2/08-09/61).

Decision: Deferred, The Chief Officer (CMC) to be called to identify on what basis the order is passed

regarding existence of structure prior to 1991.

Case �o. 5

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 96/21of Reis-Magos village Bardez

taluka, Mr. Bernardo Bosco D’Souza ( GCZMA/�/09-10/21)

Decision: Deferred, to check whether construction as per the existing plinth and verify the details and approve

the same.

Case �o. 6

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 112/14 of Candolim village Bardez

taluka, M/s. Disco Properties Pvt. Ltd.( GCZMA/�/09-10/20)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remains the same.

Item �o. 3 (Other Developments/Regularizations)

Case �o. 1

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 129/2 of Calangute village, Bardez taluka, by Mr. Jose Joao Pereira

(GCZMA/�/-09-10/04)

Decision: Biofencing/vegetative cover wire fencing is approved subject to the condition that access to the

waterfront, if existing, shall be maintained. Further the project proponent is required to obtain the permission of

the Village panchayat concerned before commencing the work.

Case �o. 2

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.nos. 12/1, 12/2 & 99/2 of Bambolim village, Tiswadi taluka, by M/s Goan

Hotels & Clubs Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/�/-09-10/ 17)

Decision: Approved, subject to the fencing is NDZ of 100 mts. and not 50 mts. as proposed.

Case �o. 3

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 138/1-A,1-A-1,2-A & 5-A of Varca village, Salcete taluka, by M/s. Sohani

Holiday Inn(GCZMA/S/09-10/10)

Decision: Approved, Videography of the site be undertaken indicating contour survey.

Case �o. 4

Proposed Tents in survey nos. 112/1,112/2,113/2,113/3,113/4,113/5,115/1,115/1A and 117/1 of Arrosim

village Mormugao Taluka, by Goa Inn. (GCZMA/S/08-09/6)

Decision: deferred, at present GCZMA is not permit any such structure in NDZ area.

Case �o. 5

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy.no. 25/0 of Quelossim village, Mormugao Taluka by M/s. Delta Engineering

(GCZMA/SAL/RASS/QEL/LOUT/13)

Decision: deferred,

Page Page Page Page 2222 of of of of 3333

10

Case �o. 6

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy. �o.30/8 of Cortalim village, Mormugao taluka by M/s. Desa Engineering

(GCZMA/S/349)

.Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 7

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.16/3 of Cottombi village,

Bicholim taluka by M/s. D.B. Bandodkar & Sons Pvt. Ltd.

Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 8

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.18/8 of Tixem village,


Decision: deferred,

.Case �o. 9

Proposed construction of mechanized twin jetty in survey �o.17/4 of Pale-Kottombi village, Bicholim

Taluka, by M/s. Bandekar Brothers Pvt.Ltd. (GCZMA/�/09-10/06)

Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 10


Mormugao Taluka by M/S. Dylane Shipping Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/S/09-10/15).

Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 11

Proposed construction of Barge Repair workshop in Sy. �o. 16/6, Chicalim Village, Mormugao Taluka by

M/s Abishek Engineers.

Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 12

Proposed for setting up of a Diesel Filing Station and jetty in plot bearing survey �o.4/1(Part) of Village

Bainguinim, Tiswadi Taluka, by M/s Samraat Marine Services. (GCZMA/�/08-09/41)

Decision: deferred,

Case �o. 13

Proposed deployment of temporary removable �ylon slider to transport Ice at Malim near old ferry

ramp in Penha de Franca Village, Bardez Taluka, by Shri Edwiges M. Pires(GCZMA/�/08-09/70).

Decision: deferred,

*************


11

MI�UTES OF THE 53

RD GCZMA MEETI�G OF THE GOA COASTAL ZO�E


53.1


Case �o. 1

Proposed reconstruction of residential building (G+7) in chalta �o. 37,38,39,40,41,42,43 & 44 of P.T.

sheet �o. 63 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Pramod Mehta (GCZMA/S/08-09/30).

Decision: Deferred, The members on perusal of the case papers and the structural details and site location,

desired further clarifications regarding applicability of CRZ Notification, 1991 for this area. Besides the

structure proposed for reconstruction will change the character of the present construction to multidwelling

units. This requires verification from MPDA or TCP Department. GCZMA has been granting approvals for

reconstruction of structures in the CRZ -II areas subject to existing plinth size and expansion upto 9 m in height.

These clarification to be put up in next GCZMA meeting scheduled on 29/01/2010

Case �o.2

Proposed construction of residential house in chalta �o. 217 of P.T. sheet �o. 172 of Vasco city,

Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Shaik Abdul Mutalib(GCZMA/S/09-10/29 ).

Decision: Approved, subject to the construction conforming to the local building byelaws and TCP/MPDA

guidelines

53.2


Case �o. 1


Taluka, by Mrs. �elcy Cardozo (GCZMA/S/08-09/31).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition

that the plinth and the FAR remains the same.

Case �o. 2


Taluka, by Mr. Santosh Pagi (GCZMA/S/08-09/32).



Case �o. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 118/28 of �agorcem-Palolem village,

Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Akalpita P. Ravi Desai (GCZMA/S/08-09/39).



Case �o. 4

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 62/10 of Mashem village, Canacona

Taluka, by Mr. Gopal Prabugaonkar (GCZMA/S/08-09/21).




12

Case �o. 5

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing temple in Sy. �o. 36/2 of �agorcem village, Canacona

Taluka, by Devgi Purush Saustha (GCZMA/S/08-09/19).



Case �o. 6

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing two houses in Sy. �o. 117/6 of �agorcem village,

Canacona Taluka, by Mr. JoaquimD’Silva (GCZMA/S/08-09/33).



Case �o.7

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 343/4 of Cola Village, Canancona Taluka,

by Mrs. Cynthia �. Jacques E Fernandes( GCZMA/S/08-09/36).



Case �o. 8

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 179 of Arambol village, Pernem Taluka, by

Mr. Michael Fernandes (GCZMA / � / 08-09 /41).



Case �o. 9

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. �o. 171/6,7 of Arambol village, Pernem

Taluka, by Mr. Madhukar Fatnaik (GCZMA / � / 08-09 / 61).



Case �o. 10

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. �o. 119/3 of Morjim village, Pernem Taluka,

by Mr. Prabhakar S. �aik (GCZMA / � / 08-09 /54).

Decision: Rejected. The GCZMA members perused the site details and were of the opinion that the present

condition of the structure cannot be termed as existing dwelling unit/house

Case �o. 11

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 109/2 of Cavelossim village, Salcete

Taluka, by Mr. Julio Da Coasta (GCZMA/S/08-09/ 37).



Case �o. 12

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 152/1 of Ambelim-Assolna, Salcete

Taluka, by Mrs. Joanita Pereira (GCZMA/S/08-09/34).



.

Case �o.13

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 12/8 of Pale Village, Mormugao Taluka,

by Mr. Jose Sequeira( GCZMA/S/08-09/ 35).




13

Case �o.14

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 83/5 of Cansaulim Village, Mormugao

Taluka, by Mr. Xavier Gracis ( GCZMA/S/08-09/28).



Case �o.15

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 89/5 of Cansaulim Village, Mormugao

Taluka, by Mr. Xavier Gracis ( GCZMA/S/08-09/27).



Case �o. 16

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 246/4 (Part) of Calangute village

Bardez taluka, Mrs. Lily Fernandes (GCZMA/�/09-10/65)



Case �o. 17

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 208/1 of Calangute village Bardez

taluka, Mrs. Rosa Fernandes.( GCZMA/�/09-10/58)



Case �o. 18

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 59/1 of Reis-Magos village Bardez

taluka, Mrs. Sitabai R. Chodankar.( GCZMA/�/09-10/60)



Case �o. 19

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 239/2 of Calangute village Bardez

taluka, Mr. Felicio Cardoz.( GCZMA/�/09-10/53)



Case �o. 20

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing house in survey no. 58/15 of Assagao village Bardez taluka,

Mrs. Lakshmee Anant Gharse. ( GCZMA/�/09-10/55)



Case �o. 21

Proposed repair/reconstruction to the existing two houses in survey no. 202/4 of Calangute village Bardez

taluka, Aninha F.L. Da Rocha De Souza Ermita & Others.( GCZMA/�/09-10/56)



Case �o. 22

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 139/1 of Calangute village Bardez

taluka, Mrs. Ana Florina Silveira.( GCZMA/�/09-10/52)



Page Page Page Page 3333of of of of 10101010

14

Case �o. 23

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 206/1-D of Anjuna village, Bardez

taluka, Mrs. Angelina D’Souza.( GCZMA/�/09-10/ 46 )

Decision: Rejected. The members were of the opinion that the structure is fairly new and does not appear to

require repairs and renovation. There are also differences between the plinth size and area sought for renovation.

Case �o. 24

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 139/1(Part) of Calangute village,

Bardez taluka, Mrs. Conceicao Silveira.( GCZMA/�/09-10/ 45)



Case �o. 25

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing retaining wall in survey no. 21/1, 22/1 & 22/2 of Ella-Old

Goa village Tiswadi taluka, M/s. Sweta Estates Pvt. Ltd..(GCZMA/�/09-10/3)

Decision: Approved. However no retaining wall shall be constructed in nearby mangrove area.

Case �o. 26

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing temple in survey no. 210/10 of Calangute village Bardez

taluka, by Shantadurga Mandir (GCZMA/�/09-10/49)



Case �o. 27

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 166/1 of Siolim village, Bardez taluka,

by Smt. Savitri G. Govekar (GCZMA/�/09-10/47)



Case �o. 28

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 159/4 of Calangute village, Bardez

taluka, by Mr. Cruz Silveira (GCZMA/�/09-10/48)



Case �o. 29

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing two structures bearing �o. K24/C & K24/E in survey no.

94/13 of Reis-Magos village, Bardez taluka, by Mr. Harbans Singh Siddu (GCZMA/�/09-10/ 64)

Decision: Rejected, the repair/renovation sought is not for a dwelling unit. Besides it is sought to repair and

replace the structure with RCC construction. Such type of activity is not to be permitted.

Case �o. 30

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 203/1 of Calangute village of Bardez

taluka, by Mr. Bibiana Gonsalves (GCZMA/�/09-10/43)



Case �o. 31

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing Resorts in survey no. 2/5 of Panelim village, Tiswadi

taluka, by M/s. Ozone Leisure Resorts Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/�/09-10/39)



Page Page Page Page 4 4 4 4 of of of of 10101010

15

Case �o. 32

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing structures in survey no. 82/0 of Candolim village, Bardez

taluka, by M/s. Sun-n-Sand Hotels Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/�/638)

Decision: Approved. Permission is granted for resumption to carry out repair and renovation of the structures

for which approval was granted by erstwhile Goa State Committee on Coastal Environment (GSCCE).

Case �o. 33

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 142/7 of Calangute village of Bardez

taluka, by Mr. Jehan Irani (GCZMA/�/09-10/51)



Case �o. 34

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 91/10, 11 of Moira village of Bardez

taluka, by Mr. Ramesh Volvoikar (GCZMA/�/09-10/62)



Case �o. 35

Proposed repair and Modification to the existing house in survey no. 365/16 of Salvadoor-do-Mundo of

Bardez taluka, by Smt. Rupmala Halarnkar (GCZMA/�/09-10/34)



Case �o. 36

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 84/33 of Reis-Magos village of Bardez

taluka, by Mr. Gajanan Pednekar (GCZMA/�/09-10/35)



Case �o. 37

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 127/3 of Agonda village of Canacona

taluka, by Mr. Adelsao Coutinho (GCZMA/S/09-10/17)



Case �o. 38

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 130/20-C of Agonda village of

Canacona taluka, by Mr. Joe Fernandes (GCZMA/S/09-10/ 40)



Case �o. 39

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 77/1-A of Colva village of Salcete

taluka, by Mr Roque F. Fernandes (GCZMA/S/09-10/26)



Case �o. 40

Proposed renovation, alterations and additions to the existing house bearing �o. K-57 in survey no. 95/1C

of Reis-Magos, village of Bardez taluka, by Mrs. �andini Sardessai (GCZMA/�/09-10/ 57)




16

Case �o. 41

Proposed renovation to the existing house bearing �o. 783 in survey no. 175/44 of Morjim, village of

Pernem taluka, by Mr. Gerald John Fernandes (GCZMA/�/09-10/63)

Decision: Rejected, there are no supporting documents to prove the structure existed prior to 1991. The matter

requires to be verified with the help of 1993 aerial photograph images. Besides this matter is under scrutiny of

Village Panchayat in term of SMWP No. 2 of 2006.

Case �o. 42

Proposed repairs / renovation of existing Parish House at Tiracol Church in Sy. �o. 16/1 of Tiracol

Village, Pernem.



53.3

Item �o. 3 (Wire fencing/Bio fencing/compound wall)

Case �o. 1

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 147/5 of Calangute village, Bardez taluka, by Mr. Rita D. D’Souza

(GCZMA/�/-09-10/ 50)

Decision: Approved for wire fencing/biofencing only

Case �o. 2

Proposed wire fencing in Sy. nos. 139/1 of Candolim village, Bardez taluka, by Mrs. Marie Christine

Rebillet (GCZMA/�/-09-10/ 25)


Case �o. 3

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 63/1 of Calangute village, Bardez taluka, by Mr. Anthony Joseph

D’Souza(GCZMA/�/09-10/59)


Case �o. 4

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 62/2 and 63/1(Part) of Majorda village, Salcete taluka, by M/s. Majorda

Beach Resorts(GCZMA/S/09-10/25)

Decision: Bio fencing/vegetative cover wire fencing is approved, as the area is within NDZ subject to the

condition that access to the water front, if, existing, shall be maintained. Further, the project proponent is

required to obtain the permission of the Village Panchayat concerned before commencing the work.

Case �o. 5

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 174/9 of Morjim village, Pernem taluka, by Mr. Sameer Lad

(GCZMA/�/09-10/ 42)

Decision: Bio fencing/vegetative cover wire fencing is approved, as the area is within NDZ subject to the

condition that access to the water front, if, existing, shall be maintained. Further, the project proponent is

required to obtain the permission of the Village Panchayat concerned before commencing the work.

Case �o. 6

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 135/5 of �agorcem-Palolem village, Canacona taluka, by Mr. Gajanan S.

�aik & Shri �itin �aik (GCZMA/S/09-10/ 38)

Decision: Rejected. As by putting up the fencing the traditional access would be blocked.


17

53.4

Item �o. 4 (Dredging activity)

Case �o. 1

Proposed dredging of the river Mandovi near existing jetty belonging to M/s. Bandekar Brothers Pvt.

Ltd. at Pale-Cottombi in Bicholim Taluka.

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the dredged material should not be dumped within NDZ of the

river Mandovi

Case �o. 2

Proposed dredging of the river Zuari near existing jetty belonging to M/s. Dempo Pvt. Ltd. at Sanvordem

in Sanguem Taluka.


river Zuari

Case �o. 3

Proposed dredging of the river Sal by Captain of Ports.


river Sal

Case �o. 4

Proposed dredging of the river Zuari by M/s Timblo Pvt. Ltd. at Panchawadi, Capxem Jetty.


river Zuari

53.5

Item �o. 5 (Other development / construction of jetty / Repair of barges / Dry-Docks / Regularisation etc.)

Case �o. 1

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy.no. 25/0 of Quelossim village, Mormugao Taluka by M/s. Delta Engineering

(GCZMA/SAL/RASS/QEL/LOUT/13)

Decision: Approved

Case �o. 2

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy. �o.30/8 of Cortalim village, Mormugao taluka by M/s. Desa

Engineering(GCZMA/S/349)

Decision: Approved

Case �o. 3

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.16/3 of Cottombi village,


Decision: Approved

Case �o. 4

Proposed regularization of barge loading platforms/facilities bearing in Sy. �o.18/8 of Tixem village,


Decision: Approved

Case �o. 5

Proposed construction of mechanized twin jetty in survey �o.17/4 of Pale-Kottombi village, Bicholim

Taluka, by M/s. Bandekar Brothers Pvt.Ltd. (GCZMA/�/09-10/06)

Decision: Recommended for approval and the case to be forwarded by project proponent to MoEF for its

approval in terms of the directions of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa, Panaji Bench, in PIL W.P. No.

21 of 2007( Atmaram Gopal Parab V/s State of Goa)


18

Case �o. 6

Proposed construction of twin jetty for barge loading and unloading facility and dredging the River at

Cottombi in survey �os.18/3, 18/4 & 18/5 at Tishem of Village Cottombi, Bicholim Taluka, by M/s.

Counto Metals and Mining Company Pvt. Ltd.

Decision: Recommended for approval and the case to be forwarded by project proponent to MoEF for its

approval in terms of the directions of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa, Panaji Bench, in PIL W.P. No.

21 of 2007( Atmaram Gopal Parab V/s State of Goa)

Case �o. 7


Mormugao Taluka by M/S. Dylane Shipping Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/S/09-10/15).

Decision: Rejected. It is seen that there is no space/land space for construction of dry-dock facility at the site.

Moreover, the construction would involve land filling in the river at site. The project proponent requires to

submit details about filling in the river area and its effect/ environmental impact on that stretch of the river.

Case �o. 8

Proposed Dry-dock in Sy. �o. 41/2 of Vagurbem village, Ponda taluka by M/s. Sudarshan Dry Docks

(GCZMA/�/09-10/67)

Decision: Deferred. The project proponents are required to present their case in details regarding location of the

site and proposed construction with details of effect/environmental impact on that stretch of the river.

Case �o. 9

Proposed construction of Barge Repair workshop( All temporary G.I. structure/sheds Block “ A” and

Block “ B” in Sy. �o. 16/6, Chicalim Village, Mormugao Taluka by Village Panchayat of Chicalim by

project proponent Shri Uday �aik, Architect Engineer).

Decision: Approved

Case �o. 10

Proposed for setting up of a Diesel Filing Station and jetty in plot bearing survey �o.4/1(Part) of Village

Bainguinim, Tiswadi Taluka, by M/s. Samraat Marine Services. (GCZMA/�/08-09/41)

Decision: Approved

Case �o. 11

Proposed deployment of temporary removable �ylon slider to transport Ice at Malim near old ferry

ramp in Penha de Franca Village, Bardez Taluka, by Shri Edwiges M. Pires(GCZMA/�/08-09/70).

Decision: Rejected. The proposed slider would adversely infriefere and affects the mangrove in that area.

Case �o. 12

Proposed repairs of existing old jetty at Miana Ore Loading plant at Sy. �o. 141/2 of �avelim Village

Bicholim.

Decision: Approved

Case �o. 13

Proposed construction of outfitting jetty, Bundwall, launching pads in Sy. �os. 103, 104 and 112 at Undir

Ponda by M/s Dempo Shipyard Pvt. Ltd.

Decision: Approved. The land filling being done at construction stage should be subsequently removed.

53.6

Item �o. 6 (Cases of Roads / public access / land acquisition and development by Government

Departments)

Case �o. 1

Proposed reconditioning of roads/protection of embankment and improvement of drainage system in V.P.

Velsao-Cansaulim, Mormugao taluka, by Assistant Engineer, SD-II, WD-VI.

Decision: Approved, in public interest


19

Case �o. 2

L.A. for the construction of road near Manuel house to Cansaulim beach in V.P. Cansaulim in

Mormugao taluka, by Assistant Engineer, SD-III, WD-VI.


Case �o.3

L.A. for construction of new bridge including approaches at Arpora and Baga –Calangute by Asst.

Engineer, PWD, Mapusa-Goa.


Case �o. 4

L.A. for construction of road and ramp from Prabhakar Tari’s house upto Albert house at Village �erul

of Bardez taluka by Asst. Engineer, PWD, Mapusa-Goa and construction and widening of road from

John Gomes house to St. Peters Church at Dando Maimer.


Case �o. 5

(i) Proposed development of toilet facilities at Miramar & Calangute, (ii) Erection of Iron Gate at

Calangute and (iii) proposed development of basic facilities, toilet, restaurant and parking facility at

Bogmalo by Department of Tourism.

Decision: The proposals for toilet facility at Miramar and Calangute and erection of Iron gate at Calangute are

approved. The proposals at Bogmalo are deferred. The Department of Tourism should make detailed

presentation on the concept in the next meeting on 29/01/2010

Case �o. 6

Proposed CRZ clearance for the construction of retaining walls at Ribander along �H-4A by Asst.

Engineer, SD-IV, Panaji-Goa.

Decision: Approved, in public interest.

Case �o. 7

(i) Four lanning of �H-4A (69 kms) from Karnataka / Goa Boarder upto Panaji

(ii) Four / six lanning of �H-17 (139 kms) from Maharashtra / Goa Border to Panaji to Goa / Karnataka

border.

Decision: (i) For NH 4A: (Approved in-principle)

For the mangrove areas, the NHAI would have to deposit in advance the cost of afforestation of mangrove areas

over the areas of 61451.13 sq. mts. (thrice the area affected) with Forest Department, Government of Goa for

undertaking the programme. Cost shall be decided by Forest Department. Pre and post construction

environmental mitigation plan would be required to be detailed and submitted. The detailed presentation to be

done in next GCZMA meeting on 29/01/2010.

(ii) For NH-17: (Approved in-Principle)

For the mangrove areas, the NHAI would have to deposit advance the cost of afforestation of mangrove areas

over the areas of 34.62 hectares. (thrice the area affected) with Forest Department, Government of Goa for

undertaking the programme. Cost shall be decided by Forest Department. Pre and post construction

environmental mitigation plan would be required to be detailed and submitted. The detailed presentation to be

done in next GCZMA meeting on 29/01/2010.


20

Case �o. 8

Proposed multi dwelling car parking and Tourism jetty facilities near Panaji City by Department of

Tourism

Decision: Deferred, The Department of Tourism is required to present the case in next GCZMA meeting

highlights of the details of the new proposal so also clarifying on the decision to change the plans approved by

GSIDC. It is also required to obtain details on the plans actually submitted for CFA to GoI and the details of the

agency who would be executing the works.

53.7 Any other matter with permission of the chair.

Item �o. 1 ADDITIO�AL AGE�DA

Case �o. 1

Proposed reconstruction of existing house (G+1) in chalta �o. 10 of P.T. sheet �o. 12 of Panaji city,

Tiswadi Taluka, by Mr. Kishor Krishna �aik (GCZMA/�/09-10/33).

Decision: Approved, subject to the construction conforming to the local building byelaws and TCP/PDA

guidelines

******************** Page Page Page Page 10101010 of of of of 10101010

21

54th Meeting

MI�UTES FOR THE SUB-COMMITTEE MEETI�G OF THE GOA COASTAL

ZO�E MA�AGEME�T AUTHORITY HELD O� 15 / 03 / 2010.


Case �o. 1

Proposed repairs of existing house in Sy. �o. 178/8-A of Arambol village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr.

Mahendra Choughule (GCZMA / � / 08-09 /77).

DECISIO�: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition

that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case �o. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. �o. 127/2 of �erul village, Bardez Taluka, by

Mr. Dasharath K. Kalangutkar (GCZMA / � / 08-09 / 76).



Case �o. 3

Proposed renovation/internal modification of Chapel in Sy. �o. 172/6 of Siolim village, Bardez Taluka, by

St. Peter’S Chapel (GCZMA / � / 08-09 / ).



Case �o. 4

Proposed construction of wire fencing in Sy. �o. 161/7 of Candolim village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr.

Lazarus Pinto (GCZMA/S/08-09/ 37).



******************** Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of 1111

22

MI�UTES OF THE 55TH

GCZMA MEETI�G OF THE GOA COASTAL ZO�E

MA�AGEME�T AUTHORITY TO BE HELD O� 31 / 05 / 2010.

55.1


Case �o. 1

Proposed reconstruction of residential house and compound wall in Chalta �o. 68 to

72 and 330 of P.T. sheet �o. 152 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Devidas

Mardolkar (GCZMA/S/10-11/07).

Decision: Approved, subject to the construction should be in accordance with the local

building byelaws and in accordance with TCP / MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case �o.2

Proposed construction of first floor to the existing residential house in Chalta �o. 288 of

P.T. sheet �o. 172 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. �itin Sadashiv Lotlikar

(GCZMA/S/09-10/56).



Case �o.3

Proposed construction of residential bungalow and compound wall in Chalta �o. 44,

45B, 11(P) of P.T. sheet �o. 176 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Premanand

G. Girap (GCZMA/S/09-10/50).



55.2


Case �o. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 265/14 of Cola village,

Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Antonio Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/08).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject

to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case �o. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 121/13 of Agonda village,

Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Parvati Chiku Pagi (GCZMA/S/09-10/ 58).



Case �o. 3

Proposed Reconstruction/repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 257/3-B

of Cola village, Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Marcelina G. Semedo (GCZMA/S/10-11/06).


to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same. Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of Page 1 of 8888

23

Case �o. 4

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house bearing no. 430/A in Sy. �o.

104/31 of Agonda village, Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Angelina Fernandes

(GCZMA/S/09-10/ 62).



Case �o. 5

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. �o. 108/10 of �aquerim

village, Quepem Taluka, by Smt. Santana Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/09).



Case �o. 6

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 126/5 of Agonda Village,

Canancona Taluka, by Mrs. Malkum Ganesh Pagi( GCZMA/S/09-10/41).



Case �o.7

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 120/20 of Agonda

Village, Canancona Taluka, by Mr. Prakash B. Pagi( GCZMA/S/09-10/54).



Case �o. 8

Proposed repairs and renovation & change of roof to the existing house in Sy. �o. 63/1-

A of Arambol village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Johny S. D’Souza (GCZMA / � / 09-10

/82).



Case �o. 9

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 178/7-F of Arambol

village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Shridhar S. �agvekar (GCZMA / � / 10-11 /08).



Case �o. 10

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 269/10 of Mandrem

village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Mahesh �aik (GCZMA / � / 09-10 /86).


to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same. Page Page Page Page 2222 of of of of 8888

24

Case �o. 11

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 226/1 of Mandrem village,

Pernem Taluka, by Mrs. Anna Maria Baptist D’Souza (GCZMA / � / 10-11 / 07).



Case �o. 12

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. �o. 130/4, 23 of Morjim

village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Menino J. D’Souza (GCZMA / � / 10-11 /06)



Case �o. 13

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 128/22 of Calangute

village Bardez taluka, Mr. Vasant Savardekar (GCZMA/�/10-11/05)



Case �o. 14

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 238/20-A of

Calangute village Bardez Taluka, Mrs. Isebella F. Fernandes (GCZMA/�/10-11/04)



Case �o. 15

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 164/1 of Calangute

village Bardez Taluka, Mr. Antonetto John A D’Souza (GCZMA/�/09-10/90)



Case �o. 16

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey �o. 125/1 of �erul

village Bardez Taluka, Mrs. Sundarbai Dhuri (GCZMA/�/09-10/ 87)



Case �o. 17

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing Part of the house in survey �o. 359/11 of

Anjuna village Bardez taluka, Mr. Mahesh B. Kolvalkar (GCZMA/�/10-11/03)



Case �o. 18

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey �o. 55/3 of Velsao

village of Salcete taluka, by Mrs. Carmelina Fernandes (GCZMA/S/09-10/52).


to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same. Page Page Page Page 3333 of of of of 8888

25

Case �o. 19

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 169/1 of Arambol

village of Pernem taluka, by Mrs. Romanus Fernandes (GCZMA/�/10-11/09)



Case �o. 20


village Pernem taluka, Mr. Vilas A. Mayekar (GCZMA/�/09-10/94)



Case �o. 21


village Pernem taluka, Mr. Ganesh Tandel (GCZMA/�/10-11/89)



Case �o. 22

Proposed repairs and renovation to the existing house in Survey �o. 166/6 of Village

Candolim; Mrs. Philomena Pereira & Silveira.



55.3

Item �o. 3 (Wire fencing/Bio fencing/compound wall)

Case �o. 1

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 149/20 of Calangute village, Bardez taluka, by Mr.

Diago A. Silveira (GCZMA/�/10-11/02)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that the traditional access any should not be

blocked.

Case �o. 2

Proposed wire fencing in Sy. no. 163/9 of Calangute village, Bardez Taluka, by Mrs.

Angelica D’Souza (GCZMA/�/-09-10/ 91)


blocked.

Case �o. 3

Proposed construction of compound wall and cabin for watch in Sy. �o. 288/12-B of

Mandrem village, Pernem taluka, by Mr. Anmol Krishna (GCZMA/�/10-11/01)


blocked. Page Page Page Page 4444 of of of of 8888

26

Case �o. 4

Proposed temporary fencing in Chalta�o.4 of P.T. Sheet �o.56 of Panaji city Tiswadi

Taluka., by M/s. Madkaikar Realtors Pvt. Ltd.(GCZMA/S/09-10/92)

Decision: Approved, construction of the wall as carried out at present may be retained on as

is where basis. However, on the mangrove side only barbed wire fencing without affecting

any mangroves be permitted. No dumping in mangrove areas is permitted.

55.4

Item �o. 5 (Other development / construction of jetty / Repair of barges / Dry-Docks /

Regularisation etc.)

Case �o. 1

Permission to cut the rocks which have surfaced on the Sea Shore at Cacra, by

Directorate of Fisheries,(GCZMA/�/09-10/23) Decision: Approved.

Case �o. 2

Proposed �OC for strengthening of existing bund wall in bearing Sy. �os. 50 & 51 of

Village Tivrem, Ponda Taluka by M/s. Gold Dust (GCZMA/�/09-10/ 93).

Decision: Approved.

Case �o. 3

Proposed construction of Slipway in Survey �o. 41/2 of Village Vagurbem of Ponda

Taluka, by M/s. Sudarshan Dry Docks (GCZMA/�/09-10/67)

Decision: The matter was discussed at length. The GCZMA Members perused the latest site

inspection report carried out by officials of GCZMA. Members took note of the fact, that the

project proponent has undertaken hill cutting in the NDZ portion, apparently without the

mandatory approvals from TCP. GCZMA Members desired to know the view of the CoP

Department in this matter, so also the likely fallout of the activity on the nearby areas.

The GCZMA members took note of the fact that such an activity in the said area is

permissible activity and desired that before permitted any such activity due care should be

taken to ensure that the entire project and future projects; if any; in that areas do not have any

adverse impact on the riverrine and coastal ecosystem.

It was decided to re-inspect the site, with two members of the authority; Dr. A.G.

Untawale & Engineer Pascoal Noronha, alongwith Director (Industries) (Member, GCZMA),

CoP and TCP and the matter placed for final decision in the next GCZMA meeting.

55.6

Item �o. 6 (Cases of Roads / Public Access / Land Acquisition and Development by

Government Departments)

Case �o. 1

Land Acquisition for construction of public road at Kepewada Patnem in ward �o. VII

in Canacona Taluka, (GCZMA/S/09-10/59).

Decision: Approved.


27

Case �o. 2

Proposed development of basic tourist facilities at Bogmalo beach of Village Bogmalo,

Mormugao Taluka.

Decision: Deferred.

Case �o. 3

Proposed Development of Area at Miramar GTDC complex as a lawn and recreational

area.

Decision: Deferred.

Case �o. 4

Proposed construction of single lane Foot Bridge in Village Dongrim, V.P. Azzosim,

Mandem in St. Andre Constituency. (GCZMA / � / 1 / 07 / 85)

Decision: Approved.

Case �o. 5

Proposed development of Government school playground in Vasco City of Mormugao

Taluka.

Decision: Approved.

55.7

Other matter relating to GCZMA

Item �o. 1

Extension of contract services of Shri. Sandeep A. Majik, Office Assistant and Shri.

Suresh P. Priolkar, Office Attendant for a further period of 06 months; in GCZMA

office.

Decision: Approved.

Item no. 2

TA / DA for the supporting staff including those of other Departments / DSLR for

GCZMA outdoor work.

Decision: Approved.

Item no. 3

I. Personal hearing before GCZMA on 31/05/2010.

M/s Models Real Estate Developers and Mr. Peter Vaz v/s GCZMA in W.P. �o. 215 of

2010.

Details of Hearing:

Adv. Mahesh Sonak appeared for the petitioner and Shri. Peter Vaz, Petitioner was

present.

Adv. Mahesh Sonak presented the status of the site, and presented his submissions

before the Authority. He argued that the site concerned has always been in municipal limits

and never has its jurisdiction changed unlike the area at Vaiguinium which is the subject Page Page Page Page 6666 of of of of 8888

28

matter of W.P. No. 519 of 2007. He sought to clarify the differences in both these

areas i.e. the site at Dona Paula and Vaiguinim area. Vaiguinim area was earlier in V.P.

jurisdiction of Taleigao and later in Panaji Municipality and then shifted back to V.P.

Taleigao. However, Dona Paula has remained as a Municipal Area all throughout.

He put forth his argument that the High Court order dated 26/10/2007, in W.P. No.

519 of 2007, is not applicable to his plot. He argued that the High Court has only stayed the

reclassification of CRZ-III to CRZ-II in respect of those areas which were reverted back to

V.P. Status and the order does not comment on Municipal area status.

In the arguments put forth, MS (GCZMA) stated as per CZMP,1996; the area from

Cabo Raj Niwas to Dona-Paula jetty is classified as CRZ- III. In this area lies the plot of the

petitioner on 03/12/2001, Ministry of Environment & Forest (MoEF) has reclassified the area

from Cabo Raj Niwas upto Donapaula Cove as CRZ-II. That would mean that this area

which is CRZ –III was reclassified as CRZ-II. Further, the order of Hon’ble High Court in

W.P. No. 519 of 2007 clearly stays the reclassification done by MoEF the letter dated

03/12/2001 except for the area from Ribandar to Routunda of Gasper Dias in Panaji

Municipal limits.

Adv. Sonak put further the argument that as per CZMP, 1996 item no. 2 (B) (B) (xiii)

(j) “ all areas outside Municipal limits are classified as CRZ-III “. He stated by this fact, his

plot being in municipal limit is classified as CRZ-II and not CRZ-III. It was informed to him,

that the CZMP,1996 clearly specifies the area from Cabo Raj Niwas to Dona Paula jetty as

CRZ-III, irrespective of the fact that the area is in municipality limits or not.

Adv. Sonak; further argued that as per the CZMP, 1996 item no.2 (B) (B) (xiii) (i)

“the plateau top to the extent is classified as CRZ-II which falls in Municipal limits”. He

stated that his plot falls in Municipal limits and is also on a plateau. The GCZMA member

desired to know the height of the plot which is claimed to be the plateau from sea level. Shri

Peter Vaz, petitioner explained that it is approximately 12 mts to 15 mts from sea level.

Hearing was concluded.

Decision: After hearing the petitioner, Advocate for petitioner, after going through the

records of the case and the orders of the Hon’ble High Court; the GCZMA member;

concluded that pursuant to the order of the Hon’ble High Court in W.P. No. 519of 2007; this

area is classified as CRZ-III. There is no dispute the same of being in municipal limits and

GCZMA yet again reiterates its stand taken before the Hon’ble High Court in W.P. No.

519/2007 that the development character of the area cannot change with change in local

authority status. Thus the classification of the area should have been retained as CRZ-II,

being developed and falling in municipal limits. However, with the decision of the Hon’ble

High Court in W.P. No. 519 of 2007, the said area is classified as CRZ-III. In terms of order

in W.P. No. 422/98 and W.P. No. 99/99 dated 13/10/2006; only repairs and renovation of

existing structures to the existing plinth is permissible. Moreover it is in NDZ area and only

repairs and renovations is permissible to the existing plinth. Page Page Page Page 7777 of of of of 8888

29

As far the contention, that the plot is on a plateau is concerned; there is no merit in the

submissions made. The plot is on a cliffy portion with an undulating terrain forming part of

the ledge or outcrop extending into the Zuari river. This is confirmed from detail examination

of Survey of India Toposheet, 1991. The plateau to which is referred in the CZMP, 1996 in

the plateau or highland / mountain (hill) table top land, which is comprising the location of

NIO, La Marvel Colony, portion of Raj Bhavan area etc. Thus it is inferred that the plot is not

on a plateau as made out in the submission of the party.

GCZMA therefore decided that the application of M/s Model Real Estate Developers,

for a development in property bearing Chalta No. 5-I & 5-J in P.T. Sheet No. 165 at Dona

Paula made vide letter dated 13/04/2009; cannot be accepted for granting approval / clearance

from CRZ point of view.

Order be issued accordingly.

******************


Sr. o. Particulars Page os. Meeting of the GCZMA....

Documents

Transcript of Sr. o. Particulars Page os. Meeting of the GCZMA....