Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project...

15
© Amec Foster Wheeler 2017 Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Update April 11, 2017

Transcript of Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project...

Page 1: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

© Amec Foster Wheeler 2017

Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Update

April 11, 2017

Page 2: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Project Overview

► Prior Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) issued 2000

► Letter from U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (2010):

► Withdrew Section 404 permit application

► Called for preparation of Supplemental EIS

► Called for additional requirements:

► Wetland delineation study

► Bat survey (Indiana and northern long-eared bat)

► Updated demand analysis

► Programmatic Agreement for archaeology

► Updated Wetland Mitigation Plan

► Supplemental EIS addresses these issues

► Work Order #001 included Phases I and II (June 9, 2016)

Page 3: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Summary of Work Performed to Date

►Phase I: Scoping and Preliminary Coordination

► Compilation/Review of Prior Reports/Analyses

► Agency Coordination/Public Scoping

► Public Informational Meeting

► 14 External Meetings

► Scoping Issues Analysis

► Preparation of Chapter 1: Purpose and Need

Page 4: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Summary of Work Performed to Date

►Phase II: Alternative Analysis

► Verification of City’s Water Demand Analysis

► Assessment of “Yield”

► Alternative development and screening

► Additional Services

► Bat Netting Survey and coordination with U.S. Fish and Wildlife

► Waters of the US Delineation

► Hydrologic Investigation/Modeling-ongoing

Page 5: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Reports Issued to Date

► Technical Memoranda

► Data Gap Analysis

► Gravel Pit Yield Analysis

► Water Demand Review

► Cost Analysis Review

► Summary of Basis For Water Need

► Basis of Hunter Lake Control

Elevation

► Level 1 Alternative Screening

Analysis

5

► Project Reports

► Published “Notice of Intent”

► Public Meeting Scoping Packet

► Scoping Report

► Agency Coordination Plan

► Hunter Lake Bat Survey Report

► Waters of the US Report

► Draft Chapter 1: Purpose and Need

► List of Project Alternatives

Page 6: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Project Challenges

Permitting clarity and direction

► Section 401 Water Quality Certification (IEPA)

► Original Hunter Lake configuration—permittability concerns

► Development of water quality modeling scenarios

Alternative formulation

► Revised Hunter Lake alternative

► Updated engineering: BMP elements, revised spillway, in-lake dams

► Cost estimates

► Integrated wetland and stream mitigation plans

► Sangamon Valley Wells and Hybrid alternatives

6

Page 7: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Basis of Water Need

► Critical Element of SEIS and NEPA Requirement

► Re-evaluation of Yield of Existing Supply System

► Analysis of Existing and Future Demands

► Potable Water

► Existing Industrial and Large Commercial Users

► Future industrial Water Demand

► Contractual Obligations

► Benefits/Contributions of Conservation Measures

► Benefits and Contributions of Drought-Induced Water Restrictions

► Future Wholesale Water Demand

► Planning Year Need: 12 million gallons/day (MGD) in 2065

Page 8: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

0.00

5.00

10.00

15.00

20.00

25.00

30.00

35.00

2012 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 2055 2060 2065

Wate

r V

olu

me (

MG

D)

Year

Springfield Supplemental Water Supply Project SEIS Water Need Analysis--100-year Drought Condition

90 Percent Confidence Level

Water Need Lake Springfield Yield 100-year Drought Demand

2023

Potential Ash Pond Closure

(5.4 MGD)

Planned Hospital Expansion

(0.5 MGD)

2030

Potential Retirement of

Dallman Units 31 and 32

(1.2 MGD) Anticipated

Wholesale Customer (1.5

MGD)

2035-2040

Potential retirement of

Dallman Unit 33 (1 MGD)

Additional Generation

(Closed-cycle) (2 MGD)

2045

Anticipated Wholesale Customer

(0.5 MGD)

Future Industrial Uses (1 MGD)

Design Year

Need: 10.79 MGD

Page 9: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Supplemental Water Supply Sources

9

Page 10: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Alternatives

List of 32 Project Alternatives Developed

► Reservoir

► River Surface Water

► Groundwater

► Hybrids

► Other

Level 1 Screening Analysis

► Factors related to yield, environmental, logistics, cost

► 21 alternatives eliminated

► Inadequate yield/water source unavailable

► Excessive environmental impacts

► Critical permittability issues

► Excessive cost

10

Page 11: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Alternatives Retained for Level 2 Analysis

► Hunter Lake--Revised Configuration

► Havana Lowland Well Fields (Well Field A) (12 MGD)

► Havana Lowland Well Fields (Well Field B) + Sangamon River Valley

(12.3 MGD)

► Illinois River Well #1 (12 MGD)

► Sangamon River Valley Well Fields (12 MGD)

► Havana Lowland Well Fields (Well Fields A+B) (17.8 MGD)

► Illinois River Valley Wells (Wells #1+2) (17.8 MGD)

► Sangamon River Valley Well Fields (10.6 MGD) + Gravel Pit C (1.4

MGD)(12 MGD total)

► Havana Lowlands Well Fields (Well Field A) + Sangamon Valley Wells

(15.3 MGD)

► Illinois River Valley Well #1 + Sangamon Valley Wells (15.3 MGD)

11

Page 12: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Phase III: Draft SEIS

► Description of “Affected Environment” and assessment of

environmental impacts

► Analysis of 24 environmental resources

► Detailed impact assessment of final study alternatives

► Cumulative Impact Assessment

► Biological Assessment (endangered species)

► Section 404(b)(1): “Least Environmentally Damaging and Practicable

Alternative”

► Distribution of Draft SEIS

► Public Meeting

12

Page 13: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Phase IV: Final SEIS

► Analysis of Comments Received on Draft SEIS

► Responses to Comments

► Final Supplemental EIS

► Distribution of Final SEIS

13

Page 14: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

Milestone Schedule

Phase/Task Status/Start Finish

Phase II: Alternatives Analysis

Water Quality Modeling ongoing June 9, 2017

Revised Hunter Lake Designs April 18, 2017 June 29, 2017

Complete Chapter 2: Alternatives June 12, 2017 August 24, 2017

Phase III: Draft SEIS

Chapter 3: Affected Environment April 18, 2017 August 14, 2017

Chapter 4: Environmental Consequences June 30, 2017 September 24, 2017

City/USACE Review September 24, 2017

Notice of Availability November 30, 2017

Public Hearing December 14, 2017

Phase IV: Final SEIS

Final SEIS March 15, 2018

Record of Decision March 22, 2018

14

Page 15: Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Updatesupplementalwater.cwlp.com/ProjectStatusCityCouncilMeeting041117.pdfFinal Supplemental EIS Distribution of Final SEIS 13 . Milestone

© Amec Foster Wheeler 2017

Springfield Water Supply Supplemental EIS Project Update

April 11, 2017