sPHENIX Director’s Review...Schedule Health 17-18 Issues and Concerns 19 Summary 20. ... Safety...
Transcript of sPHENIX Director’s Review...Schedule Health 17-18 Issues and Concerns 19 Summary 20. ... Safety...
sPHENIX Director’s Review
RLS Schedule DevelopmentEric Menter
April 9-11, 2019 BNL
Contents
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 2
Topic Slide #
History of sPHENIX Schedule Development 3
P6 Data Management 4-8
Schedule Reports 9-12
Cost Information 13-16
Schedule Health 17-18
Issues and Concerns 19Summary 20
History of sPHENIX Schedule Development
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 3
Create Initial P6 Integrated Master
Schedule
In 2017, 13 Microsoft Project files were converted to and integrated in P6• Validated matching to MS Project plan• Identified completed work vs work to-go• Implemented cost reduction• Implemented expanded FY18 R&D phase
Project Manager’s Schedule Work
Fest
In 2017, all Level 2 managers and Project Estimators worked in the P6 schedule with Project Controls• Improved the work plan• Validated estimate data and project coding
Schedule Development and
Reviews
Over the past five years, multiple reviews have been conducted, on pace with significant schedule development commensurate with project design and estimate maturity.
This includes iterative Scope Reviews, Design Reviews, Safety Reviews, Cost & Schedule and Director Reviews, and the CD1/3A Review in 2018
P6 Data Management: Structures
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 4
MasterData
TransactionalData Data Element
X CalendarsX RolesX ResourcesX Activity Codes and ValuesX Resource Codes and ValuesX User Defined FieldsX Enterprise Project StructureX Projects
X Work Breakdown StructureX ActivitiesX Activity Codes Value AssignmentsX Resource AssignmentsX Resource Assignment UDF Entries
P6 Data Management: Resource Dictionary
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 5
Resource Dictionary
Project is using 83 resources: 70 Labor13 M&S
Each Resource has 5 rates:1) Direct2) Direct Escalated3) Burdened4) Burdened Escalated5) Zero Cost
P6 Data Management: MVTX Resources are Included
MVTX Resources with rates, including burdening and escalation have also been included in the Resource Dictionary. These resources have the same scheme of 5 rate options as those previously mentioned:
1) Direct2) Direct Escalated3) Burdened4) Burdened Escalated5) Zero Cost
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 6
P6 Data Management: Attributes for Activities, Resources
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 7
P6 Data Management: Integration
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 8
Integration with other management tools– P6 data is the source– P6 to Cobra wizard– Cobra is the earned value cost processor– P6 & Cobra used to set the Performance Measurement Baseline (PMB)– Monthly status cycle
• Collect status and ETC information prior to end of month in P6• Import status with wizard from P6 to Cobra• Import of project actuals data from Peoplesoft Financials into Cobra• Post schedule and earned value reports for project team
Schedule Reports – P6 and Excel Used
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 9
We use P6 reports to support project operations throughout the project lifecycle. These are produced either directly from P6 or extracted into Excel.
Schedule Detail (for WBS 1X, 2X and 3X) and Critical Path Reports for both WBS 1X and 2X have been posted to the Site.
Schedule Reports – WBS 1.X ̶ 6-Month Lookahead
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 10
Activities in WBS 1.05 EMCal Electronics, where Remaining Early Start is within a six month range of the Data Date
Schedule Reports – WBS 2.X ̶ 6-Month Lookahead
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 11
Activities in WBS 2.03 Cradle Carriage, where Remaining Early Start is within a six month range of the Data Date
Schedule Reports – Excel Status Request
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 12
Activities ready for update in WBS 1.02 Time Projection Chamber
Cost Information - Source of BNL Resource Rates
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 13
BNL’s Budget Office is the source of rate data; the base year for rates is FY19
Cost Information - Labels in P6 Reports
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 14
Direct FY19$ M&SM&S is the budgeted value of contracts and/or Purchase Orders
Burdened AY$ - LaborIncludes Direct Labor Cost with fringe, burden and escalation
Burdened AY$ - M&SIncludes Direct M&S Cost with burden and escalation
Burdened AY$ - TotalSum of Burdened AY$ - Labor +Burdened AY$ - M&S
Example P6 Activity Report
Cost Information - Tips for Cost Book Data
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 15
ABCDEFG
Fund SourceProject
WBS Level 1WBS Level 2
Resource Type
A B C D E F GA B C D E F G
Activity ID – Activity-level columns are in detail reports
Activity Name – Activity-level columns are in detail reports
Dates roll up
Resource Identifier
Burdened AY$ – Rolls up from detail rows – Sum of Burdened AY$ - Labor + Burdened AY$ - M&S
Cost Category = Fund Source
Time-phased spreadsheet – this report used FY distribution of Burdened AY$
The hierarchy of colored grouping rows roll up the information from the white detail rows
Cost Information - Obligations in P6
Obligations are loaded as discrete Activities in P6 to show commitment dates; they have the same Burdened AY$ as their paired Delivery Acceptance Activities.
Obligations must be filtered out in order to correct rolled-up AY$.(Global Activity Code BNL_Obligation)
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 16
WBS Path Activity ID Activity Name Start Finish Resource ID Direct FY19$ Burdened AY$MP100400 Procure Train Technician to work in CERN Shop on TPC GEMs 3-Feb-20 14-Feb-20 83,550$ 88,940$
1.02.01.06 OBLG119710 Procure Train Technician to work in CERN Shop on TPC GEMs - Obligation
3-Feb-20 3-Feb-20 OBLG 44,470$ 44,470$
1.02.01.06 S120000 Procure Train Technician to work in CERN Shop on TPC GEMs - Delivery Acceptance
10-Feb-20 14-Feb-20 SBU Contracted Purchase 39,080$ 44,470$
MP100410 Procure Production of TPC GEM foils (includes Technician fees) 3-Feb-20 13-Aug-20 284,772$ 303,143$
1.02.01.06 OBLG119701 Procure Production of TPC GEM foils (includes Technician fees) - Obligation
3-Feb-20 3-Feb-20 OBLG 151,572$ 151,572$
1.02.01.06 S120100 Procure Production of TPC GEM foils (includes Technician fees) - Delivery Acceptance
18-Feb-20 13-Aug-20 SBU Contracted Purchase 133,200$ 151,572$
MP100600 Procure TPC GEM HV Power Supplies 18-Feb-20 20-Apr-20 230,729$ 245,615$
1.02.01.07 OBLG121110 Procure TPC GEM HV Power Supplies - Obligation 18-Feb-20 18-Feb-20 OBLG 122,807$ 122,807$
1.02.01.07 S121400 Procure TPC GEM HV Power Supplies - Delivery Acceptance
14-Apr-20 20-Apr-20 SBU Contracted Purchase 107,922$ 122,807$
MP100610 Procure TPC GEM HV Membrane Power Supply 18-Feb-20 20-Apr-20 22,555$ 24,010$
1.02.01.07 OBLG121210 Procure TPC GEM HV Membrane Power Supply - Obligation
18-Feb-20 18-Feb-20 OBLG 12,005$ 12,005$
1.02.01.07 S121500 Procure TPC GEM HV Membrane Power Supply - Delivery Acceptance
14-Apr-20 20-Apr-20 SBU Contracted Purchase 10,550$ 12,005$
MP100810 Procure TPC R1 Module Parts (Frames) 1-Oct-19 6-Dec-19 31,216$ 33,230$
1.02.02.03 OBLG124310 Procure TPC R1 Module Parts (Frames) - Obligation
1-Oct-19 1-Oct-19 OBLG 16,615$ 16,615$
Obligation and Delivery Acceptance Activities in WBS 1.02 Time Projection Chamber
Schedule Health – WBS 1X & 2X Schedule Report
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 17
Schedule Health – Acumen Fuse Analysis
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 18
Analytics from Acumen Fuse tell us that the sPHENIX 1.X and 2.X Schedule is in very good condition.
Issues and Concerns
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 19
• Schedule development status for WBS 3X: INTT & MVTX• Activities with high float• sPHENIX’s context does make higher float values sensible for certain
activities, such as procurements• Hand-offs between Level 2 scope owners in Assembly Hall in ‘21 and
‘22
Summary
April 9-11, 2019 sPHENIX Director's Review 20
sPHENIX’s Resource Loaded Schedule (RLS) is mature and well developed as of this Review. We have been iterating the preliminary baseline while the project has moved through significant design development and long lead procurement.
The embedded project controls team from BNL’s Project Management Center has worked for years with the project’s professionals, designers and management; hence the RLS is the product of deep, collaborative development, while adhering to this laboratory’s standards for project controls.
The RLS is in a state that supports the project’s readiness for PD2/3 approval.