Speech Torts

15

description

Defamation and being careful about what you say online

Transcript of Speech Torts

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3. How to Avoid Being Sued for What You Put on the Internet FERGUS O'ROURKE Barrister-at-law www.twitter.com/ubfid www.irish-lawyer.com (Not just law stuff)
  • 4. In Your Dreams ... People should be allowed to say what they like about whoever they like, whether or not they can prove it, and whether or not they're right. ( Bryan Caplan ) Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me ( Anon .)
  • 5. Reality is Different
    • A word once uttered can never be recalled.( Horace )
    • A slip of the foot you may soon recover, but a slip of the tongue you may never get over.( Benjamin Franklin)
  • 6. Speech Torts
    • Defamation (slander+libel)
    • Injurious falsehood
    • Miscellaneous e.g . interference with contractual relationships
  • 7. Defamation
    • defamatory statement means a statement that tends to injure a persons reputation in the eyes of reasonable members of society
    • (Defamation Act 2009)
  • 8. Injurious Falsehood
    • ... involves the making of statements which are untrue...[and]... the falsehood causes harm; harm of a kind which is intended, or, of a kind which is the natural and probable consequence of the making of the false statements.
  • 9. Bad News
    • It is impossible to guarantee to you that you will avoid
    • ever being sued for internet defamation
  • 10. Worse News
    • There is no way to guarantee that you can avoid
    • litigation of any kind
  • 11. Good News 1
    • You can drastically reduce your risks by
    • avoiding malice
    • ... never speaking ill
    • pausing before publishing
    • ... only asserting what you can prove
    • even better, stating opinion not claiming fact
    • This is, to some extent, a counsel of perfection i.e. youd have to be perfect to bring it off
  • 12. Good News 2
    • Even if you err, it need not be a disaster:
    • Withdraw
    • Apologise
  • 13. Third-Party Statements
    • Counsel of Perfection: don't ever publish !
    • Get your own advice if it's a biggie for you
    • Otherwise, take reasonable care
    • Be sure you have no reason to believe it's tortious
  • 14. Summary
    • Whereof o ne cannot speak, thereof one must be silent ( Ludwig Wittgenstein )
    • "Honey, if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all."
    • Awareness is more than half the battle
    • Be good :-)
    • Do you want to get sued? I didn't think so
  • 15. Some Sources
    • Defamation Act, 2009
    • http://www.oireachtas.ie/documents/bills28/acts/2009/a3109.pdf
    • Eoin O'Dell
    • http://www.cearta.ie/
    • Adrianos Facchetti http://www.defamationlawblog.com/
    • Evan Brown
    • http://blog.internetcases.com/