Sources of Flexibility in Human Cognition: Dual Task Studies of Space and Language
description
Transcript of Sources of Flexibility in Human Cognition: Dual Task Studies of Space and Language
Sources of Flexibility in Human Cognition: Dual Task Studies of
Space and Language
Stephanie Lidd and
Jamie Tauber
Linda Hermer-Vasquez, Elizabeth S. Spelke and Alla S. Katsnelson
Human Navigation Abilities
Two unique features Capable of dead reckoning Great flexibility
Disorientation Can reorient themselves after
disorientation How?
Cheng Experiments (1986)
Tested rats’ abilities to find food after disorientation
Rats went to the correct corner and the geometric equivalent at equally high rates Despite differences in non-geometric cues (e.g.
brightness, pattern, and odor) Conclusion: Rats reorient in accordance
with environment shape (geometric module)
Hermer, Spelke: Orientation Abilities in Children (18-24 Months)
Similar to Cheng’s experiment Searched for hidden object in all
white room, then room with one blue wall Searched both corners equally in all
white room Failed to use non-geometric property
(blue wall) as a way of navigation (like adult rats)
Results for Cheng and Hermer &Spelke
Hermer and Spelke: Adult Disorientation
Conducted same experiment using adults
Adults checked geometrically equivalent corners in white room
Were able to use the blue wall as a way of orienting themselves and finding the object (used non-geometric)
Hermer (1994): Disorientation in Children (3-7 years)
Described position of the object as behind colored wall or to the left or right
Children 4+ were successful in describing the objects position behind the wall
Children 6+ were able to describe the position as ‘left’ or ‘right’ of the wall
Hermer (1997) Spatial Language in Children 5-7 years
Tested children’s abilities to use spatial language
Correlation between spatial language and ability to use non-geometric landmarks to locate objects
Causation Between Spatial Language and Development of Spatial Performance Possibilities
Three possibilities Independent, but developmentally
linked Depend on a common factor Development of spatial language
produces change in spatial relations
Experiment 1
Similar to Cheng’s Experiment White room and room with a blue wall
Tested again in each room with ‘verbal shadowing’: repeating a tape-recorded prose
Non-shadowing conditions had ‘white noise’ playing
Disoriented (spun around) before each trial
Diagram of Chamber Used
Results
Experiment 2A
Visual Experimentation with 3 conditions Rhythmic Verbal: repetition of ‘na’ Rhythmic Non-verbal: tapping out pattern Verbal: Repetition of prose
Computer program showing grids varying numbers of ‘T’s and target ‘L’
Subjects had to determine presence or absence of target ‘L’
Results
Experiment 2B
Like Experiment One, with modified disorientation for last 8 subjects
Results: Non-shadowing subjects produced
higher accuracy in recognition Shadowing subjects showed decline in
accuracy Subjects searched with high
frequencies in correct and geometrically equivalent corners
Experiment 2C
Identical with 2B except with Rhythmic shadowing
Results: Shadowing subjects searched the
correct corner with higher frequency than the rotationally equivalent corner
Higher accuracy than verbal shadowing Non-shadowing produced same,
accurate results
What’s the Difference?
Rhythmic and Verbal were equally distracting, yet rhythmic was more accurate Verbal shadowing may interfere with
geometric and non-geometric combination process or
Combination process independent, but verbal shadowing may interfere with their ability to detect or remember the non-geometric landmark
Experiment 3
Verbally shadowing subjects with a simplified version of tests
Instead of being hidden to the left or right, was hidden on top of the walls
Walls were removed from chamber to remove the geometric cues
Results
Subjects located the object with high accuracy
Landmark-appropriate search was higher in Experiment 3 than in the verbal shadowing conditions of Experiments 1 and 2b
Showed adults used non-geometric cues, despite disorientation
Experiment 4
Like Experiment 3, except the object was placed to the left or right of the wall
If verbal shadowing impairs the encoding of non-geometric information only in reorientation tasks, then both subjects should successfully find the object
If verbal shadowing impairs the conjoining of geometric and non-geometric information then non-shadowing subjects should find the object but shadowing subjects should not.
Results
Conclusions
Spatial memory system found in children and adult rats is present in adult humans
Language plays a role in the conjoining of geometric and non-geometric information