Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping...

18
Some questions to consider • Do we need regulation? • Does history matter? • Why is one-stop shopping important? • Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Transcript of Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping...

Page 1: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Some questions to consider

• Do we need regulation?

• Does history matter?

• Why is one-stop shopping important?

• Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Page 2: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Boundaries

• Type– Jurisdictional– Regulatory category– Service– Technology

• Set by– Law– Regulator– Courts

Page 3: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Classification of Services

All Services

Common Carrier Broadcast Information Services

Regulated by FCC and State Commissions

Regulated by FCC Not regulated--yet

Page 4: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Common Carrier Services

Common Carrier Services

Wireline Wireless

FCC andState Commissions

FCC States????

Page 5: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Wireline Services

Wireline Services

Interstate--FCC State

localState

LDState

AccessInterstate and International

LD Interstate Access

Page 6: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Boundaries

International long distance

Interstate long distance

State long distance

Local service

Page 7: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

The Players

• Regulators

• Service providers– Wireline providers– Wireless providers– Cable providers

• Customers– Residential, small business, large business,

carriers

Page 8: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

The Incumbent Local Exchange Carriers (ILECs)

• RBOCs– NYNEX– Bell Atlantic Bell Atlantic + GTE = Verizon (+MCI)= Verizon– Pacific Telesis– Southwestern Bell +SNET = SBC +AT&T = AT&T– Ameritech– Bell South– U.S. West = Qwest

• Independents– Alltel– Sprint United– Century– Chillicothe– +1300 more

Page 9: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Regional Bell Companies

Now AT&T

Now AT&T

Now AT&T

Page 10: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Company Access Lines Annual RevAmeritech (SBC) 4,100,000 $2.487 BVerizon 924,000 $517.5 MCBT 838,000 $484 MSprint 650,000 $328 MWestern Res 202,000 $71 MAlltel 147,000 $53 MCenturyTel 83,000 $60 MChillicothe 37,000 $41 MChampaign 12,500 $7.2 MTelephone Service 11,000 $3.5 M

10 largest ILECs in Ohio

Page 11: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?
Page 12: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Who provides what?

• In 1950 (all one monopoly)– International and Interstate Long Distance: AT&T Long Lines– Local: AT&T Local Operating Companies and Independents– State Long Distance: AT&T Local Operating Companies and

Independents

• After 1984 (Local companies and Long distance companies)– International and Interstate Long Distance: The New AT&T, MCI,

Sprint, plus other Long distance companies– Local: RBOCs and Independents– State Long Distance: RBOCs and Independents, and some long

distance companies

Page 13: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

• After 1996 (competition everywhere)– International and Interstate Long Distance:

AT&T, MCI, Sprint, other long distance companies, RBOCs

– Local: RBOCs, Independents, competitive providers (CLECs)

– State Long Distance: RBOCs, Independents, CLECs, AT&T, MCI, Sprint, other long distance companies

Page 14: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

• Wireless providers– Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, Sprint (Nextel)

• Internet access– Cable modem services—cable television

companies– DSL—Local telephone companies and

competitive providers (CLECs)

Page 15: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Lots of mergers

• Mergers:– Wireless

• Cingular and AT&T Wireless• Sprint and Nextel

– Wireline• SBC and AT&T and Bell South• Verizon and MCI

Page 16: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Industry Consolidation

• Biggest local telephone companies (172M):– Verizon and AT&T

• Biggest wireless providers (217M)– Verizon and AT&T

• Biggest long distance providers– AT&T (owned by former SBC)– MCI (owned by Verizon)– Sprint (which is also a local telephone company and

one of the biggest wireless providers)

Page 17: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

And . . . .

• What about cable??????

• What about content/entertainment?????

Page 18: Some questions to consider Do we need regulation? Does history matter? Why is one-stop shopping important? Why didn’t the U.S. Telecom Act of 1996 work?

Bundling of services

• Cable companies– Cable tv– Digital phone– Wireless????

• Telephone companies– Wireline telephone services– Wireless– IPTV????