Solutions for Fitting Room Theft · Web viewA survey of 12 MCAs has identified problem areas that...
Transcript of Solutions for Fitting Room Theft · Web viewA survey of 12 MCAs has identified problem areas that...
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
DATE: 11 October 2011
TO: Angela Fleming, Sears Store Manager 5111 Rogers Ave.
Fort Smith, AR 72903
FROM: Jessica Dutton, MCA (Merchandise and Customer Assistance)
RE: Fitting Room Theft
Project SummaryA survey shows employee-related issues may be a cause of theft in the fitting rooms (Dutton Survey). In my proposal, I am providing a number of solutions that may aid in minimizing the cost related to theft.
Introduction
A survey of 12 MCAs has identified problem areas that cause security issues in the fitting rooms. Shoplifters steal on average $100.00 per visit (NASP). Per day a department store can lose up to $2000 (Division of State Police). Without security precautions, the amount of loss related to shoplifting can severely damage the company’s profit margin. The following three solutions will help to alleviate these issues
First Solution- Managerial Supervision
Better managerial supervision will assist in monitoring if MCAs are doing their job and cleaning out fitting rooms regularly. Without proper supervision fitting rooms can become congested with clothing which creates an atmosphere prime for theft.
Second Solution- Install Security Cameras
Installing visible cameras outside of the fitting rooms will cause some shoplifters to reconsider stealing merchandise. Even imitation cameras would be enough to deter many shoplifters. Most shoplifters do not wish to be caught. Therefore, security cameras will be a deterrent to many shoplifters.
Third Solution- Fitting Room Assistant
Hiring a fitting room attendant would ensure that customers are entering and leaving with the same number of items. To save money the company could reclassify an MCA as a fitting room assistant. A fitting room assistant would also help to keep the fitting rooms neater, which would satisfy many customers.
Conclusion
Any of these solutions, or a combination thereof, would be a good deterrence to theft. Cutting back on theft will increase the company’s net profit by 10% and provide better financial statements to provide to the company’s shareholders (2010 Annual Report). I will be happy to discuss this proposal with you at your convenience. I am also open to any other suggestions you may have.
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Jessica Dutton, MCA
Sears Roebuck and Co.
10/29/2011
2011Solutions for Fitting Room Theft
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Table of ContentsPages
Executive Summary....................................................................................................................1
Introduction.................................................................................................................................2
Recommendations....................................................................................................................2-5
Solution 1: Fitting Room Assistants...............................................................................2
Description............................................................................................................2
Pros........................................................................................................................2
Cons.......................................................................................................................3
Solution 2: Managerial Supervision...............................................................................3 Description.............................................................................................................3
Pros.........................................................................................................................3
Cons........................................................................................................................4
Solution 3: Install Security Cameras.............................................................................4
Description.............................................................................................................4
Pros.........................................................................................................................4
Cons........................................................................................................................5
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................5 List of Annotated References.............................................................................................……8
Appendix....................................................................................................................................10
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Executive SummaryTheft is a problem that every store has to contend with. Each company must determine
the best way for their company to deal with theft and find solutions that work for them.
Companies must perform an analysis of their company to determine what actions they need to
take.
The majority of theft at Sears occurs in the fitting rooms. The following three solutions
can be used to prevent theft. This first solution deals with managerial supervision. It is the job of
MCAs to clean out the fitting rooms at least once an hour. However, due to the lack of
supervision, many of the MCAs check the fitting rooms rarely. Although managers are busy,
they should take the time to see if their employees are performing their jobs proficiently. Since
there is always a manager scheduled, there would be no additional cost.
Another solution is to install security cameras. Regardless of whether or not the cameras
work, they would be a great deterrent to many shoplifters. Working security cameras would be a
better preventative measure, but due to cost considerations, non-working cameras would also be
acceptable. The cost versus the profit of this solution will depend on the type of security cameras
used. It would also be possible to use a mixture of imitation and genuine cameras, with the
genuine cameras being used in the highest risk area.
The most promising solution, due to the increase profit versus the cost, involves using
assets already in possession. Reclassifying current employees as fitting room assistants, or hiring
new employees, will guarantee that someone is always watching the fitting rooms. They could be
responsible for counting the items each customer brings in and leaves with. Not only would this
ensure that customers maintain the same item count, but it would also help to keep the fitting
1
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
rooms neat. The costs associated with this option are fairly minimal. The solutions presented in
this paper will cut down loss due to theft and increase net profit.
IntroductionIn Sears stores combined, shoplifting losses amount to $10 million. Our Sears store has
about $720,000 losses per year (2010 Annual Report). Therefore, it is imperative that actions be
taken to reduce the stores losses. The following recommendations will help to relieve a
significant amount of losses. Many shoplifters steal because they know they can get away with it
(NASP). Currently, it is fairly easy for them to do so considering the lack of preventive measures
in place. The following recommendations will provide options to reduce shoplifting losses.
RecommandationsSolution 1 – Managerial Supervision
Description:
MCAs’ job responsibilities include cleaning out the fitting rooms at regular intervals.
However, many times the fitting rooms are only checked once or twice per shift. When fitting
rooms are full of articles of clothing, it is easier for shoplifters to steal without loss prevention
being able to identify what they have stolen. Therefore, if managerial supervision were
increased, the MCAs could be made to check the fitting rooms every hour.
Pros:If managers can keep MCAs doing their jobs timely and correctly, then it will be easier to
catch shoplifters in the act. Customer satisfaction will also improve due to cleaner fitting rooms.
As a result of there always being a manager scheduled, there would be no cost increase. Fitting
2
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
room schedules could be posted in each fitting room requiring initials for each hour. They could
be collected at the end of the week to check which MCAs did not assist in cleaning out the fitting
rooms.
Cons:Managers often have tasks to complete that keep them from consistently supervising
employees. If the manager is busy elsewhere and cannot come to the floor, then the employees
will slack off unless there is a consequence related to their actions. An MCA can also check the
fitting rooms after multiple hours and just fill in the previous hours as if they had checked it. So,
although there are no cost increases, this solution depends on the manager’s ability to supervise
regularly.
Solution 2 – Install Security
Cameras
Description:
Currently shoplifters feel safe stealing items from the dressing rooms because there is
little chance of them being caught. Depending on the day of the week, Sears can lose on average
$2,000 (Division of State Police) per day from shoplifters. Installing visible security cameras
will make most shoplifters reconsider whether or not they want to steal from Sears. Flyers can
also be posted in the fitting rooms to alert customers that the store is protected by security
cameras.
Pros:Installing visible cameras will inform possible shoplifters that they may be being
watched. Sometimes that is enough to change their mind. Security cameras are a great way to
keep watch on the fitting rooms. As Sears already employs loss prevention staff, there would be
3
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
no need to hire new employees to observe the cameras. However, imitation cameras can be
installed with close to the same results. Many department stores already use imitation security
cameras. Customers believe they are being watched and are less likely to commit a crime. Since
running multiple surveillance cameras can get costly, imitation cameras can be used along with
genuine cameras to keep customers from shoplifting.
Cons:Installing security cameras is the most expensive recommendation. Not only will the store have
to purchase the equipment, but there is also the additional cost of wiring the security camera to
the loss prevention room. Also, seeing as its illegal to use cameras inside of the fitting rooms, the
store will have to rely on the loss prevention staff recognizing signs of thievery.
Solution 3 - Fitting Room Assistants
Description:
Many department stores hire fitting room attendants to assist customers with their fitting
room needs. These employees are responsible for counting the number of items each customer
has and ensuring that they leave with the same number of articles.
Pros:This solution will cut down on theft in the fitting rooms by a large percentage (2010
Annual Report). Requiring customers to account for the items brought into the fitting rooms will
also help leave the fitting rooms clean for the next customer. The fitting room assistant does not
need to be hired on as a new employee; current MCAs can take turns filling in as the fitting room
Imitation Security Camera“Hughes Security”Cost: $14.95
Real Security Camera“Super Circuits”Cost: $249.99
4
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
assistant. Since Sears pays its employees minimum wage, it would not matter if a current
employee or a newly hired employee is used. Paying $7.25 per hour is very efficient considering
the amount the store is currently losing due to theft. A side benefit to fitting room assistants
involves honest customers. Customers have a positive reaction to having an employee close for
any of their needs. Their satisfaction will increase causing sales to also increase. Unlike
installing security cameras, fitting room assistants would be inside the fitting room area.
Therefore, they will be able to listen for suspicious sounds such as: the tearing of tags, the
rustling of bags, and spending an exceptionally long time in the fitting room.
Cons: This Sears has 6 fitting rooms in different areas of the store. Even though employees are
only paid minimum wage, the cost involved with having an employee at each fitting room is
steep. Providing an assistant in the largest and most used fitting room will cause shoplifters to
use the other less used fitting rooms. However, if assistants are used during the busiest time,
shoplifting should be reduced.
ConclusionBased on the cost versus profit of the three solutions, creating fitting room assistants is
the best alternative. The cost is negligible and the profit is very high. With fitting room
attendants, shoplifters will not be able to steal easily within the fitting rooms. Security cameras
are the next best solution. Although shoplifters enjoy the thrill of stealing, they do not wish to be
caught. They will avoid stores that have preventive measures in place. Increased managerial
supervision will be successful by ensuring that shoplifters cannot hide evidence of their theft
under messy fitting rooms. Using one of these solutions will be effective; however, using a
mixture of these solutions would be the best possible choice.
5
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Installing Security Cameras
Pros ConsGood deterrent to most shoplifters High Cost of implementationCan install imitation cameras at drastically lower amount then real ones
It’s illegal to use security cameras inside fitting rooms
No additional staff need to be hired
0
2
4
6
Cost Profit Compairson for So-lutions
CostProfit
By: Jes-sica
Dutton
Managerial Supervision
Pros ConsNo Additional Cost Managers aren’t always available
Customer satisfaction increases due to cleanerfitting rooms
Employees can go put down their initials without cleaning the fitting rooms
Easy to check who is doing their job via Fitting Room Schedules
Fitting Room Attendants
6
7
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Pros ConsLow Cost Cost go up if all fitting rooms have attendants
Internal Supervision
No additional hiring necessary
Higher Customer Satisfaction
List of Annotated References
8
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Dutton, Jessica. “Workplace Issues.” Survey. 7 Oct. 2011.
This survey demonstrates the issues related to theft from the fitting rooms. It highlights
when the employee is working, and how often they run into problems with shoplifters.
This survey was used to demonstrate that there is a problem with the shoplifters.
National Learning & Resource Center (NASP). “Shoplifting Statistics.” n.d. 20 Oct.
2011.
This website list statistics related to shoplifting. The article is beneficial for anybody who
is trying to get statistics about various shoplifting facts. It not only show facts related to
the money lost, but also shows who is most likely to shoplift. I used this article to
determine how much a business may lose daily due to shoplifting.
Division of State Police. “Crime Prevention: Shoplifting.” n.d. 20 Oct. 2011
In this website article, the state police have showed preventive measures for shoplifting.
It gives some statistics on who shoplifts and how much. This is a good article because it
is from a legitimate source that has experience with shoplifters. I used this article to gain
extra facts to reinforce my recommendations.
Sears Holding Corporation. “2010 Annual Report.” n.d. 23 Oct. 2011.
The financial statements list all of their financials for the year. The financials allowed me
to calculate the amount of losses Sears has due to shoplifting. This is a good source
because of the restrictions the Financial Accounting Standard Board puts on financials to
ensure that they are reliable.
Hughes Security Solutions. “Fake Security Cameras.” n.d. 20 Oct. 2011
9
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
I used this source to demonstrate the price difference between a real security camera and
a fake security camera. This source is a good source because they actually sell the
cameras.
Super Circuits. “Security Cameras.” n.d. 20 Oct. 2011
This source was used in comparison to the Hughes Security Solution fake security
camera. This purpose was to show how much more an actual security camera cost versus
a fake one.
Appendix
10
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Survey
Workplace Issues
1) What time of day do you typically work?
a) Morning b) Afternoon c) Night
2) How often do you check the fitting rooms?
a) Less than 1 hr. b) 1 hr. c) 2-4 hours d) Longer than 4 hours
3) How often do you see a manager on the floor?
a) Once per hour b) Once every 4 hoursc) Once per shift d) Other: ______________________________
4) How often do you find evidence of stolen merchandise in the fitting rooms?
a) At least once per shiftb) Twice per weekc) Three times per weekd) Other: ____________________________
5) What do you think is the biggest problem?
a) Fitting Room Theftb) Lack of manager supervisionc) Employees not completing their own workd) None of the above
Proposal 10/10 points Everything is clearly explained.
Jessica DuttonOctober 31, 2011
Cover page 2/2 points For whom? Like the colors.
Table of Contents 2/2 points
Executive Summary 10/10 points Well-written
Report 19/20 points Everything was great! I liked the little photos. Just work on taking out contractions because they lower the professional tone.
Annotated Sources 5/5 points Wow!
Appendix 1/1 point You could also put the tables you made into this section.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Total 49/50 points = 98% = A+ Highest grade! Of course, you get a prize…
This whole report looks amazing, Jessica—very professional and love the shades of green. Can I use this for a future
sample proposal project? You have really raised the bar!