Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

download Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

of 8

Transcript of Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    1/8

    Issue 20 Fa 2008

    Theses demag a

    Marco PasiUniversity of Amsterdam

    ur ng t e rst con erence o t e Soc etas Mag ca, e ast Juneat t e Un vers ty o Water oo, I presente t e o ow ng t eses as acu m nat on o my paper on t e Ita an ant ropo og st an stor anof religions Ernesto de Martino (1908-1965). The paper exploredsome met o o og ca pro ems re ate to t e stor ca stu y omag c as t ey cou e g g te t roug an exam nat on o e

    art nos wor . T e t eses were meant to e a way o summar z ngmy theoretical and methodological thoughts on the study of magicon the basis of my reading of de Martino. They are therefore heavilyn uence y s eas, part cu ar y as t ey concern t e concept

    o t e ant mag ca po em c as a un amenta eature o westerncu ture.

    T eses e mag a s o course a s y re erence to G or ano Brunoswork on magic bearing the same title. During the discussion thato owe my paper, someone suggeste t at I cou a so ave

    ca e t em Conc us ones, n re erence to P co e a M ran o asown amous 900 art c es on y twenty-s x o w c were n actspecifically devoted to magic). I thought, however, that my aim wasnot really to present conclusions, but rather starting points for a

    Newletter editors welcome responses to Marco Pasis heses de magia. Please send responses eithern the body of an email (if brief) or as an attached file in MS Word format (for longer comments,

    specially if they involve diacritics) to [email protected]. Responses received in time will be

    published in Newsletter issue 21 (Spring 2009).

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    2/8

    age ocietas Magica Newsletter Fall 2008

    scuss on among spec a sts n t estu y o mag c.

    Bruno wrote ty-s x t eses;I ave contente myse w tten. There were nine when Ipresente t em n Water oo, ut

    I ave ec e to a a new oneto ma e my argument c earerand more complete. However, Iave starte t e num er ng rom

    0, so t at t e ast one w st enum er 9. Eac t es s s o owey a certa n num er o su -

    theses that should illustrate andexp a n t e ma n po nt. Some ot e arguments scusse ere aa rea y een presente , ut not

    so systematically, in my doctoralssertat on,La notion de magie

    ans e courant occu tiste en

    Ang eterre (1875-1947, e en ein 2004 at the cole Pratiquedes Hautes tudes, Paris. Ana stract o t e ssertat on asappeare n t e Societas MagicaNews etter 13, W nter 2005),but the dissertation itself is still

    unpu s e .Being painfully aware thata ser ous ograp y onmag c wou reac monstrousproport ons, I ave m te mybibliographical references here tot e essent a .

    F na y, I ma e no part cu ar c a mto or g na ty w t my t eses.Most o t e po nts I am ma ngwill appear to some readersalmost trivial, while a few oft em w per aps e seen as morepro emat c or controvers a . W atI am present ng ere s part y aprecipitation of ideas that have

    een common enoug n recent

    sc o ar y researc on mag c,part y a recap tu at on o my ownt eoret ca re ect ons on t e stu yo mag c, w c ave occup e mymind in the last ten years.

    0. The study of magic is not thesame t ng as t e stu y o t e

    concept o mag c.

    0.1. One s ou a ways e

    wary o wor s t at preten to

    study magic as such. In these

    works, magic is often presented

    as an o ject w ose existence

    is a rea y ta en or grante ,

    ecause it is easi y iscerni e

    in the fabric of history, and its

    i entity can e escri e y

    means o a simp e e nition1

    However, t ere is no meaning u

    istory of magic without a

    istorica pro ematization o t e

    concept o magic. Wit out t is

    pro ematization, t e comp ex

    ways in w ic t e concept or

    rather the concepts of magic

    ave ta en s ape an ave

    een trans orme in istory are

    o scure rat er t an c ari e .

    0.2. The study of magic should

    egin with this historical

    pro ematization o t e

    concept o magic, ut s ou

    ot en t ere. It is essentia to

    nderstand what people meant

    y magic in different historical

    perio s, ut t e stu y o magic

    cannot e carrie out on y rom

    he perspective of intellectualistory. It should obviously also

    inc u e a stu y o t e practices,

    o t e socia e aviors, an

    o t e e ie s t at ave een

    istorically associated with the

    concept o magic2.

    . Mag c s a western concept.Stu y ng t e story o mag cmeans stu y ng t e story owestern cu ture.

    1.1. No one serious y isputes

    the fact that the concept of

    magic, owever one wants to

    un erstan or e ne it, asoriginate an eve ope in

    western culture, just like its

    ideologically cognate concept

    o re igion. T is remains true

    in epen ent y o ow roa y (or

    narrow y we want to e ne t e

    cultural and geographical space

    o t e West. Etymo ogica y, t e

    wor erives rom a particu ar

    c ass o Persian priests (an

    ethnic element was probably

    also involved in the term), whose

    name was trans ate in ancient

    Gree as magoi. It is in ancient

    Greece t at, rom t is noun,

    the term mageia was derived,

    w ic serve increasing y to

    i enti y not w at a person was

    (an t ere ore er et nic origin

    or social function), but what

    a person did. In identifyingmageia as a particu ar set o

    practices an e aviors, t e

    process o conceptua ization o

    magic in western culture began3.

    T e su sequent istory o t e

    concept inc u es o course many

    comp ex eve opments, w ic

    take place in Greek, Roman and

    other Mediterranean cultures,

    an in a t ree Me iterranean

    monot eistic re igions, Ju aism,Christianity, and Islam. All these

    developments belong to the same

    cu tura istory y way o mutua

    in uences, w ic can e exp ore

    an un erstoo istorica y.

    1.2. T e secon sentence may

    Theses contd

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    3/8

    ageoc etas ag ca ews etter a

    Theses contd

    e read just as a corollary of the

    rst one, ut its meaning goes

    eyon a simp e extension o it.

    In act, it is meant to emp asize

    he importance of the study of

    magic for the understanding

    o t e ways in w ic western

    cu ture as s ape its own

    i entity. T is is urt er exp aine

    under point 5.

    2. The scholarly study of magiccan eve op on y t roug au stor ca awareness o t e

    or g ns an t e eve opmentof this concept. This meanscontextualizing the ways in whicht s concept as een use n t epast ot on an em c an an et c

    eve .

    2.1. T e istorica stu y o

    a concept, or of a cluster of

    concepts, can be carried out

    on y wit in a roa er stu y

    o t e cu ture in w ic t is

    concept, or c uster o concepts,

    has originated and developed.

    agic as consistent y eena pro ematic presence in

    western cu ture. It is essentia

    o understandwhy it has beenso. In order to do that, it is

    important to stu y t e socia ,

    po itica , re igious, an more

    genera y i eo ogica , unctions

    hat magic has fulfilled in

    western cu ture. Processes o

    exc usion an o i entity- ui ing

    ave een ma e possi e t roughe use of magic as a specific

    category4.

    2.2. T ese processes ave ta en

    p ace not on y among e ievers

    an opponents o magic, ut a so

    among t e sc o ars stu ying it.

    contd on page 4

    W en we ecome aware o t e

    i eo ogica iases t at can i e

    e in sc o ar y e nitions o

    magic, we understand that these

    efinitions belong to the history

    o t e concept o magic as we ,

    an o not transcen it. As

    sc o ars, we can ecome aware

    of these biases and begin tory avoiding them only when

    we ave a su cient istorica

    now e ge o t e i eo ogica

    functions and of the social

    processes mentioned in 2.15.

    . Magic is not a single object, buta comp ex o stor ca p enomenat at are constant y mo e y t e

    stor ca processes w c t ey go

    through.

    3.1. The biggest problem in

    rying to give a simple definition

    o magic app ica e to any

    istorica materia is t at t e

    concept o magic as een use

    istorically in different ways,

    in or er to per orm i erent

    unctions epen ing on t e

    istorica context. I magic as

    een used in order to carry

    out processes o exc usion ( or

    instance o certain practices,

    e ie s, or socia groups ,

    e o ject o t ese exc usions

    as varied in time and space.

    T ere ave een so many

    epistemo ogica s i ts an

    ruptures in t e istory o western

    culture that it is hard to imagine

    a single definition being ableo capture suc a comp ex

    p enomenon.

    4. Nevert e ess, t s comp exs ows some aspects o cont nu tyand consistency that have to beeterm ne an stu e .

    4.1. I our istorica

    pro ematization o t e concept

    o magic ma es it evi ent t at

    magic is not a single, elementary

    object that can be easily defined,

    o we en up wit an integra

    econstruction t at ma es magic

    isso ve a toget er? S ou

    there not be apars construenso owing t epars estruens o

    t e istorica pro ematization?

    As sai a ove (0.2 , t e stu y o

    magic cannot be just intellectual,

    that is, limited to the study of

    t e i erent istorica concepts

    re ate to magic, an s ou

    a so inc u e aspects suc as

    practices and beliefs. But even

    this would not be sufficient. Thestu y o magic must a so ave

    an am ition to i enti y patterns

    and continuities, which can

    only make a history of magic

    a meaning u project in t e rst

    p ace6

    5. T e story o mag c n westerncu ture, an per aps even westernculture as a whole, cannot be fully

    un erstoo t e p enomenono ant mag ca po em c s notta en nto account an t oroug ynvestigated.

    5.1. Some aut ors ave

    suggested that at least one

    pattern in t e istory o

    magic exists, an t at it is t e

    T e Soc etas Mag caebsite has a new domain:

    ww.societasmagica.org

    Please update your links.

    Announcement

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    4/8

    age ocietas Magica Newsletter Fall 2008

    phenomenon of antimagical

    po emic. Magic was orn in

    ancient Greece as a term wit

    po emica un ertones, an t e

    stigma attac e to t e wor as

    een a permanent feature of its

    su sequent istory7.

    5.2. In its istory, western cu ture

    as consistent y use magic

    as a conceptua space w ere

    ideas, beliefs, behaviors, and/or

    practices that were considered as

    unaccepta e wou e t rown.

    T ese i eas, e ie s, e aviors,

    an or practices wou t ere ore

    ecome identified with a single

    category o exc usion, ca e

    magic.

    5.3. Creating t is category o

    exc usion was an essentia part

    of the process by which western

    culture has defined its identity

    roug out t e centuries. By

    exc u ing w at t ey i not

    want to e or o, westerners

    have defined, implicitly and by

    contrast, w at t ey wante to

    e or o. C oices were ma e,

    in excluding certain things and

    accepting ot ers, w ic ave

    iven western cu ture its speci c,

    individual shape. For this

    reason, understanding the history

    o (t e concept o magic o ers a

    ey to un erstan t e istory o

    western cu ture as a w o e.

    5.4. Antimagica po emic is

    certainly a fundamental pattern

    in t e istory o magic, ut is

    ot necessari y t e on y one.

    Ot er patterns s ou e soug t,

    an possi y i enti e . T ey

    may be more specific, and not

    app ica e to t e w o e o t e

    istorica eve opment o magic,

    ut t ey are e p u nevert e ess

    o understand certain aspects of

    it. One examp e among ot ers

    may e t e communication wit

    on- uman entities in or er to

    o tain now e ge an or power.

    Another may be the manipulation

    o an invisi e, immateria

    su stance in or er to ac ieve

    materia e ects.

    5.5. O ant ropo ogica an

    sociological definitions of magic,

    Theses contd dated and out of fashion as

    t ey may seem to e to ay, may

    sti e use u or an istorica

    understanding of magic, because

    they may help us identify further

    patterns. An examp e may e

    James G. Frazers e nition,

    ase on t e i ea o sympat etic

    magic8. The problem withthese definitions has been that

    t ey o ten ar itrari y ma e one

    o t ese speci c patterns an

    absolute discriminating factor

    for a general definition of magic.

    See a so 8.5.

    . For t s reason, n or erto un erstan t e stor cacomp ex ty o mag c, t s essent a

    to be aware of its dual, perhapseven a ect ca , aspect. T e

    story o mag c nc u es n actot pos t ve an negat ve

    att tu es. T e ormer e ong toauthors who have propoundeda pos t ve concept o mag c aspart o a representat on o t e rwor v ews; t e atter e ong toauthors who have condemned

    mag c as angerous, c t,

    For more information about the Societas Magica see our website at http://www.societasmagica.org

    The Societas Magica invites proposals for essays to run in futureissues of the newsletter.

    e are looking for short essays (1500-2500 words) announcing new developments deriving fromesearch in the study and teaching of magic and its related

    opics. We would be especially interested to see lead articleson modern magic, or periods other than medieval.

    We are also looking for smaller pieces for our notes and queriescolumn. News about dissertations in progress or completed,manuscript discoveries, or other such items are all welcomed.

    Please contact Kathryn Laity: [email protected]

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    5/8

    ageoc etas ag ca ews etter a

    Theses contd

    ne ect ve, or preposterous n awor : unaccepta e).

    6.1. It is o vious t at magic,

    espite its consistent use as

    a category of exclusion by

    aut oritative socia actors,

    as een seen as a positivese -i enti ying category y

    many persons in the history of

    western cu ture. T at w ic

    was perceive as unaccepta e

    y some, as een seen not

    on y as accepta e, ut even

    as desirable, by others. Those

    w o ave supporte a positive

    perception o magic ave o ten

    p ace t emse ves in a situation

    of tension and conflict with their

    cultural and social environment.

    6.2. A sound history of magic

    s ou ocus on ot i ea -

    ypica camps. Popu ar

    istories o magic ave o ten

    focused only on those who have

    i enti e t emse ves positive y

    wit magic9. However, one

    cannot write a istory o magic

    where magicians are the only

    protagonists, and where their

    i eas are not contraste wit t e

    cu tura environment in w ic

    ey ave operate . T ose w o

    have opposed magic (thereby

    a so conceptua izing it are just

    as important or a istorica

    stu y o magic as t ose w o ave

    defended it or have claimed to

    elieve in and practice it. Plinye E er an Augustine are just

    as important or t e istory o

    magic as Marsi io Ficino an

    Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa.

    7. Magic has to be considered asan stor ca pro em t at covers contd on page 7

    t e story o western cu tureas a w o e an spans rom tseg nn ngs to our ay. For t s

    reason mag c as to e stu eand understood ideally in its entire

    stor ca comp ex ty, an not yocus ng on y on s ng e per o s.

    .1. T is is a ca to specia istsin t e istory o magic not to

    remain confined in a given

    istorical period, but to try to be

    ami iar wit t e eve opments o

    magic in ot er perio s as we .

    Know e ge o ot er perio s can

    sometimes throw light on aspects

    o t e perio on w ic ones own

    researc ocuses.

    .2. I it is accepte t ate searc or patterns an

    continuities, and not only

    ruptures and differences, is a

    egitimate aspect o researc on

    magic, t en it ecomes c ear w y

    it is important to now at east

    he general lines of developments

    in perio s t at o not e ong to

    our e o specia ization. No

    pattern can emerge y ocusing

    arrowly on single periods or

    ocal contexts.

    . Studying magic in cultures thatare not western means pro ect nga western concept on cu tures t ator g na y o not possess t.

    8.1. T is is one o t e most

    important acquisitions of a

    econstructionist approach to the

    stu y o magic. Magic as eenconsi ere y generations o

    sc o ars, wor ing especia y rom

    anthropological, ethnological,

    an socio ogica perspectives,

    as a universa e ement o uman

    cu ture. However, i one accepts

    he points above, it becomes

    clear that magic has served to

    circumscri e a speci c area

    wit in western cu ture, in

    order to identify, isolate, and

    often repress, beliefs, ideas,

    e aviors, an or practices t at

    were perceive as i ering rom

    t e norm. T e socia unction

    of this process has its specificistory in western cu ture,

    w ic cannot e automatica y

    transpose to ot er cu tures.

    What was perceived in western

    culture as dangerous, illicit,

    eviant, an t ere y e ne

    as magic, was not necessari y

    perceive in t e same way in

    other cultures. As a consequence,

    t e particu ar conceptua spacet at was create in western

    cu ture t roug t e category

    of magic did not necessarily

    exist elsewhere. Denying this

    pro em or ignoring it ea s

    easi y to t e projection o t is

    conceptua space to cu tures t at

    have not produced this space

    autonomous y t roug t eir

    oca cu tura ynamic. T is

    is t e source o universa isticdiscourses on magic10.

    8.2. It is not a single belief, idea,

    practice and/or behavior that

    ma es magic speci c to western

    cu ture, ut t e way in w ic

    a t ose e ements ave een

    combined together in specific

    patterns, in order to fulfill a

    speci c unction.

    8.3. I magic cannot e i enti e

    on y y certain e ie s, i eas,

    practices, an or e aviors

    (as in old anthropological or

    socio ogica e nitions , ut

    a so y its socia or i eo ogica

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    6/8

    age ocietas Magica Newsletter Fall 2008

    T e rst Soc etas Mag cacon erence prove a great success,

    ot aca em ca y an soc a y. Itssma sca e, ts campus ocat onw c prevente t e part c pantsrom s pp ng out o sess ons an

    into local tourist attractions), andthe healthy mixture of seasonedscholars, recent recipients of theP D, an gra uate stu ents, wereamong t e ma or actors w censure t s success.

    But more than anything else,t was t e t emat c un ty an

    common nterests w c ma ea t e sess ons nterest ng ant oug t-provo ng. For someone

    e myse , w t a ac grounn anc ent story an a eeper

    now e ge o anc ent anme eva Jew s mag c, t s was

    an opportun ty to ear nterest ngpapers on ssues w t w c Ialready was at least partly familiar(including the biblical stories ofE a an E s a, ate-ant queNeop aton sm, an C r st anKa a a ), an on top cs w cwere ent re y new to me nc u ngmo ern pagan sm, t e wor s oErnesto e Mart no, an Descartes

    reams). Moreover, a t esessions were conducted in trulyacademic spirit, with incisivecomments and lively discussionsut no acr mon ous c er ng, an

    t e soc a events at east t ose Inot m ss ecause o my own

    et- ag!) were c aracter ze y a

    Participant Retrospectivere axe an r en y atmosp ere.

    T us, t e on y mprovementcou suggest, or t e next

    con erence o t e Soc etas Mag ca,wou e to try to attract moresc o ars wor ng on non-Westernmag c, nc u ng t e Anc entNear East, India, China, andother regions and periods. Suchan opening up of our intellectual

    or zons w urt er enr c a t epart c pants n t s con erence, ans e even more g t on t e cross-cu tura s m ar t es an erenceso t e mag ca texts an pract ceswe a n so nterest ng.

    G eon Bo aTe -Av v Un vers ty

    Assem ng orty- ve sc o arsfrom seven countries, six provincesan seven states, t e con erence

    Mag c: Front ers an Boun ar es(held 11-15 June 2008 at theUn vers ty o Water oos REVCon erence Centre) c e o w ta broad, conceptual keynote talk ont e Copt c mag c o ate ant qu tyy Pro essor Marv n Meyer

    (Chapman University) whichset t e stage or t e rest o t econ erence. Equa y um nat ng

    were Thursday evenings keynotepresentat on y Pro essor R c arK ec e er Nort westernUniversity), who presented his

    n ngs on t e geograp ca

    concentrat on o w tc tr a s nthe late 15th-century, and TanyaLu rmann Stan or Un vers ty),

    w o treate con erence part c pantsto an overview of her fieldwork onpeop es re at ve recept veness tomyst ca exper ences.

    Brav ng Water oos somet messt ng eat, part c pants earrigorous and enlighteningpapers arrange accor ng to aroug c rono og ca conceptuaorder. Highlights ranged fromPro essor G eon Bo a TeAv v Un vers ty) present ng sexploration of 140,000 fragmentsrom t e Cam r ge Un vers ty

    rarys Gen za co ect onfor magical texts, to Dr Marco

    as s Un vers ty o Amster am)

    presentat on o n ne T eses onagic which both summarized

    t e genera t rust o t e con erencean prov e a unct onadefinition of magic: essentially a

    estern concept w c cant eapp e to ot er cu tures w t outsignificantly altering its semanticspace. We are p ease to present anexpan e vers on o Pas s T eses

    e Magia as the lead article in thisssue o t e news etter.

    avid PorrecaUn vers ty o Water oo

    Magic: Frontiers and BoundariesOrganizer Retrospective

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    7/8

    ageoc etas ag ca ews etter a

    Members of the Societas Magicaare ent t e to a 20% scount onall books in the Magic in Historyser es put out y Pennsy van aState University Press. Mentiont at you are a Soc etas Mag camem er w en or er ng oo s

    by phone (800-326-9180) or fax877-778-2665 . T ese te ep one

    numbers work from the US andCana a.

    20% Discount

    unction in t e speci c context

    o a particu ar cu ture, t en it

    ecomes clear why the cultural

    specificity of magic cannot be

    easi y renounce in avor o

    universa istic app ications.

    8.4. T is oes not mean,owever, t at e ie s, i eas,

    practices and/or behaviors

    associated with magic in western

    cu ture cannot e compare to

    simi ar e ie s, i eas, practices,

    an or e aviors in ot er

    cultures. But one thing is to

    compare t ese i erent e ements,

    anot er to assume t at t ey a

    e ong to a sing e category.

    Combining these elements

    oget er in ways t at e ong to

    e western conceptua ization

    o magic wi te us more a out

    our own cu ture t an a out t e

    culture we want to compare it

    o. T is wi e, in act, an act o

    projection.

    8.5. I t e universa istic c aim o

    genera e nitions o magic is

    abandoned, these definitions can

    o ten o er interesting insig t into

    e patterns o t e eve opment

    o magic in t e istory o western

    cu ture. See a so 5.5.

    9. T e sc o ar y stu y o mag cmay be ideally interdisciplinary,ut ts oun at on must necessar ye stor ca .

    9.1. Ant ropo ogy, socio ogy,psyc o ogy, an cognitive

    science can help us understand

    many aspects of the ways in

    w ic magic as ecome suc a

    signi cant presence in western

    cu ture (see or instance 5.4 .

    But it is history that should study

    e ways in w ic t e concept o

    magic as ta en s ape. Wit out

    is istorica awareness, we

    will always tend to use magic as

    an easily definable, potentially

    niversa category, instea o

    e resu t o cu ture-speci c

    i eo ogica con icts t at are sti

    urking behind our simplisticefinitions11.

    Endnotes

    Even great classics such as LynnThorndikesHistory of Magic andExperimental Science (8 vv., NewYor : Co um a Un vers ty Press,1923-1958), are not exempt fromthis problem.2 An example of a sophisticated

    approach that combines thestor ca pro emat zat on o t e

    concept with such an integralstudy of the phenomena associatedwith it in a given period is RichardKieckhefer, agic in the MiddleAges Cam r ge: Cam r geUniversity Press, 1989).3 On the formation of the conceptof magic in ancient Greece seeFritz Graf, agic in the Ancient

    Wor Cam r ge, MA: HarvarUniversity Press, 1999); WalterBurkert,Da Omero ai Magi. Laradizione orientale nella cultura

    greca (Venezia: Marsilio, 1999) (asar as I am aware t ere s no Eng s

    edition of this book); MatthewDickie, agic and Magicians inhe Greco-Roman World(London

    / New York: Routledge, 2001).On t e percept on o t e Pers anmagoi in Greek culture, see Albert

    de Jong, Traditions of the Magi.Zoroastrianism in Greek and Latin

    Litterature (Leiden / New York /K n: Br , 1997 .

    The general importance ofan historical awareness andcontextualization of the conceptualtools used by scholars, particularly

    heses contd w en ea ng w t pro emat ccategories such as magic, isemphasized by Ernesto de Martinoin all of his works, and is consonantwith the particular historicisttra t on to w c e e onge . Itwill suffice to mention here thework by de Martino that is mostrelevant for our purpose:

    agia ecivilt (Milano: Garzanti, 1962).More recent y, a s m ar ca to ahistorical awareness of the originsof the concept of magic has alsobeen made, among others, byRandall Styers in his fundamental

    a ing Magic. Re igion, Magic,

    and Science in the Modern World

    (Oxford / New York: OxfordUniversity Press, 2004). However,whereas Styers focuses only on

    t e mo ern per o , e Mart nosdiscussion takes the wholehistory of western culture intoconsideration.

    Again, de Martino, agia ecivi t an Styers, a ing Magicare essential here. They both showto what extent the theories and thecontd on page 8

  • 7/30/2019 Societas Magica - SMN Fall 2008 Issue 20

    8/8

    age ocietas Magica Newsletter Fall 2008

    definitions of magic that have beengiven by scholars in the last centuryand a half often express ideologicalpresuppos t ons w ose u t mateorigin can be found in theologicaldiscourses about magic.6 This is perhaps the weak point of

    Styers, aking Magic. He works aea t y econstruct on o t e termmagic, but seems to leave thematter there. Once we know thatmagic has been used as a categoryof exclusion in western culture, andt at sc o ars w t t e r s mp st c,a-historical definitions are noexception to this rule, is all we needto know about magic already there?

    The actual expression antimagicalpo em c po em ca ant mag ca sused by de Martino in his agia ecivilt, p. 6.8 The reference here of course

    s to Frazers amous e n t onof sympathetic magic that canbe found in the third chapter ofhis Golden Bough (in the 1922Macmillan edition). A usefulsurvey o sc o ar y t eor es omagic can be found in GrahamCunningham,Religion and magic.

    Approaches and Theories(New

    York: New York University Press,1999 . Ot er mportant cr t casurveys can be found in Edward E.Evans-Pritchards classic, Theoriesof Primitive Religion (Oxford:Clarendon Press, 1965); and inStan ey Jeyara a am a , agic,Science, Religion, and the Scope of

    Rationality (Cambridge: CambridgeUniversity Press, 1990).9 Just one example from the many

    t at cou e g ven: Kurt Se gman,The History of Magic and the

    Occult(New York: Harmony

    oo s, 1975 .Apart from the aforementioned

    de Martino and Styers, one of themost significant advocates of adeconstructionist approach to

    mag c as een Jonat an Z. Sm t .See for instance his Trading

    laces in Marvin Meyer and Paulirecki (eds.),

    ncient Magic andRitual Power(Leiden / New York / n: E. J. Br , 1995 , 13-27.Recent attempts at reviving a

    scholarly discourse on magic froman anthropological perspectiveshow all the weaknesses that deriverom an nsu c ent stor ca

    problematization of the concept.See for instance the collection ofessays edited by Birgit Meyer and

    eter Pels, agic and Modernity.

    Interfaces of Revelation andConcealment(Stanford: StanfordUniversity Press, 2003).

    Theses contd

    Notes an

    uer es

    Critical Edition In

    rogressKathryn LaFevers EvansIndependent ScholarChickasaw Nation

    Transcription, translation,and commentary of JacquesLefvre dtapless De

    agia naturali, On Naturalag c

    A Rena ssance uman st at t eUn vers ty o Par s, JacquesLefvre dtaples (1455-1536)

    pu s e extens ve y, yet ora most 500 years t e so e comp eteextant manuscript of Lefvres493 unpu s e treat seDeagia natura i rema ne

    unedited. It has been preservedy Bo em ans n w at s now t e

    Researc L rary n O omouc,

    Czech Republic. Its exhumationur ng our mo ern era egan w tau O. Kr ste ers m -20t -

    century microfilm copy of it, nowarc ve at Co um a Un vers ty.

    am wor ng on a cr t ca e t on

    o De Magia natura i Boo s I-VIand intend to publish it in threevo umes. T e rst vo ume wnc u e an ntro uct on cover ng

    the historical background oft e wor an e te vers on omy 2006 Masters t es s w cdemonstrated that despite Lefvrescon emnat on o mag c ater onn s career, t e natura mag c o

    Christian Kabbalah and numbersym o sm rema ne centra toe vres teac ngs t roug out s

    ife), followed by Book II as theey to t s treat se. T e secon

    vo ume w e compr se oooks I & III; the third volume ofoo s IV, V & VI.