Social Media and Web Marketing in China
description
Transcript of Social Media and Web Marketing in China
-
In the following report, Hanover Research explores best practices in social media anddigitalmarketinginChina.
Social Media and Web Marketing in China
October2013
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS ExecutiveSummaryandKeyFindings................................................................................3KEYFINDINGS.............................................................................................................................3Tailoringmarketingmaterialstotheaudience.................................................................3Popularsocialmediaplatforms.........................................................................................3Launchinganeffectivedigitalmarketingcampaign..........................................................4Trendsamonghighereducationleaders...........................................................................4
SectionI:BestPracticesinStudentRecruitmentMarketinginChina..................................5UNDERSTANDINGTHEAUDIENCE....................................................................................................5MostInfluentialFactors.....................................................................................................7FamilyInfluence.................................................................................................................8OtherConsiderations.........................................................................................................9
TRENDSINSOCIALMEDIAUSEINCHINA........................................................................................10SOCIALMEDIAPLATFORMS.........................................................................................................12Baidu................................................................................................................................12Renren..............................................................................................................................14Weibo...............................................................................................................................15Youku...............................................................................................................................17
EFFECTIVEINTEGRATIONOFTHEDIGITALMARKETINGCAMPAIGN.......................................................18SectionII:ProfilesofMarketLeaders...............................................................................21UNIVERSITYOFALBERTA,CANADA................................................................................................21BROCKUNIVERSITY,CANADA.......................................................................................................21FRESNOPACIFICUNIVERSITY,UNITEDSTATES.................................................................................22UNIVERSITYOFHUDDERSFIELD,UNITEDKINGDOM..........................................................................22UNIVERSITYOFKENTUCKY,UNITEDSTATES....................................................................................23MEMORIALUNIVERSITY,CANADA................................................................................................23
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND KEY FINDINGS AsChinesestudents increasingly lookonline for informationtoaid thecollegeapplicationprocess,itisimperativethatWesternhighereducationinstitutionsprovideinformationthatispertinenttoandthatdirectlytargetsChinesestudents.Whilethescopeofdigitalmediatools is immense, institutionsmust use tools carefully. In this report,Hanover ResearchdiscussesbestpracticesinsocialmediaandwebmarketinginChina.InSectionI,wereviewliteratureonbestpracticesinstudentrecruitmentmarketing,beginningwithanoverviewofthetargetaudienceinChinaandanintroductiontothetopsocialmediaplatformsusedbyhigh school and college students. In Section II, we provide short case studies of sixinstitutions that have embraced social media as a method of recruiting internationalstudentsfromChina.First,wesummarizetheoverallkeyfindings.KEYFINDINGSTAILORINGMARKETINGMATERIALSTOTHEAUDIENCE
Institutions should amplify their reputation asbeinghighquality, and should alsotake care to thoroughly explain application processes to less prepared applicantswhomaynotunderstandthebasicsofadmissionsprotocolsinothercountries.
Particular aspects that should be emphasized in marketing materials and socialmediapostsincluderankingandreputation(particularlyforwellregardedacademicprograms), overall quality, safety, and the opportunity for an internationalexperience.
While social media marketing is intended to reach applicants themselves,institutionsmustunderstand that theirparentsare likely tohavea critical role indecisionmaking. Parents are more interested in qualities such as employmentprospects upon graduation, social and emotional support services, the range ofprogramsoffered,andpossibilitiesformigration.
POPULARSOCIALMEDIAPLATFORMS
The socialmediaplatforms thatappear tobemostpromising for reachingout toChinese applicants include Sina Weibo (similar to Twitter), Renren (similar toFacebook),andYouku(similartoYouTube).
InstitutionsthattakecaretounderstandtheuniquepropertiesofBaidu(similartoGoogle) can ensure that their pages receive traffic from interested students.Strategies for harnessing Baidus capabilities include using common search terms(forexample,topUKuniversity),usinga localizedmicrosite,hostingthewebsitewithinthefirewall,andkeepingimportantinformationatthetopofthewebsite.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 4
LAUNCHINGANEFFECTIVEDIGITALMARKETINGCAMPAIGN
Socialmedia sites shouldbeupdated regularly andposts should linkback to theinstitutionswebsite.Contentmust includekey informationonadmissions criteria(including upcoming deadlines), program options, and other guidelines andrequirements.Storiesaboutrecenteventsoncampusandtestimonialsfromcurrentand former students complement the logistical information and provide a morepersonalsidetoaninstitutionswebpresence.
Direct communication is one of themost critical elements of an effective digitalmarketingcampaign.Socialmediaplatforms shouldnotbeonesided,but insteadshouldinspiredialogtokeepfollowersinterested.
Prospective students should be presented with accessible options for askingquestionsofadmissionsstaffandstudentrepresentatives,andresponsesshouldbebothpromptandpersonal.
TRENDSAMONGHIGHEREDUCATIONLEADERS
Mostinstitutionsusemorethanonesocialmediasite,andSinaWeibo,Renren,andYoukuappear tobe themostcommon. It isalsocommon for institutions touseamessagingortelephoneprogramsuchasQQorSkype.
Mostoftheinstitutionsinthisanalysishiredacurrentorformerstudenttomanagetheir socialmedia sites. English content is typically selected by themarketing oradmissions office at the university and then translated by the social mediacoordinator. Institutions often employMandarin speakers to create ameaningfulpresenceonChinas socialmediaplatformsaswellas to fieldanyquestions frompotentialapplicants.
Thoughmost institutions did not explicitly describe data collection procedures, itappearsthat institutionsgaugethesuccessoftheirsocialmarketingcampaignsbythenumberofapplicants fromChinaaswellas thenumberof followerson theirsocialmediaplatform.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 5
SECTION I: BEST PRACTICES IN STUDENT RECRUITMENT MARKETING IN CHINA In the following pages,we provide an introduction to student recruitmentmarketing inChina. We begin by describing research on motivations of Chinese students seekinginternationalprogramsinordertoassistuniversitiesinhighlightinginformationfoundtobeimportanttothetargetaudience.Fromthere,wediscusscurrenttrendsinsocialmediausein China and provide an overview of the top social medial platforms for recruitinginternationalstudents.Finally,we introducebestpractices in integratingsocialmediauseinto an institutions digitalmarketing campaign,with a focus on strategies for fosteringcommunicationanddialoguewithpotentialapplicants.UNDERSTANDINGTHEAUDIENCEAninstitutionshouldconsidertheculturalcontextinwhichitpresentsitsbrandonlineandmustbeawareofthetypesofinformationinwhichChinesestudentsaremostinterested.Inthefollowingparagraphs,wediscusssomeofthekeycharacteristicsofthetargetaudience.World Education Services (WES), an international education intelligence firm,1dividesinternational students into four main segments based on their preparedness for highereducationandtheirfinancialresources.2Thesegmentsaredefinedasfollows:
Highfliers:highacademicpreparedness,highfinancialresources(32%) Explorers:lowacademicpreparedness,highfinancialresources(28%) Strugglers:lowacademicpreparedness,lowfinancialresources(21%) Strivers:highacademicpreparedness,lowfinancialresources(19%)
Asshown inFigure1,themajorityof internationalstudents fromChina (60percent)havehigh financial resources, while only about half (51 percent) have high academicpreparedness.
1AboutWES.WorldEducationServices.http://www.wes.org/about/2Choudaha,R.,Orosz,K.,andChang,L.2012.NotAllInternationalStudentsaretheSame:UnderstandingSegments,
MappingBehavior.WESResearchandAdvisoryServices.http://www.wes.org/ewenr/12aug/feature.htm
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 6
Figure1:SegmentsofInternationalStudentsfromChina
Source:WorldEducationServices
Theparticularmotivationsofthetwomoreaffluentgroupsareexplained ina2011articlebyAnnWhite, director of theHong KongChina division of the Institute of InternationalEducation.WhiteexplainsthatChinesestudentsturntointernationalinstitutionswithtwomaingoalsinmind,dependingontheircompetitivenessasapplicants.3Among highflier students, those seeking a toptier education tend to prefer U.S.undergraduateinstitutionsastheyoffertheoptimalroutetoU.S.graduateschools,viewedas being of top quality.White notes that British universities are also preferred as theyappeartobeperceivedasaddingsocialpolish. Mosthighfliersknowwhattheywantand how to get it: these applicants have specific fields and goals in mind, and willindependently research options and probably consider the United States first forundergraduate study.Typically thesehighfliersareclearandconfidentaboutwhich fieldandmajorstheywant.4Meanwhile, the affluent yet less academically prepared explorers group conducts itssearch forhighereducationwith thegoalof seekinganalternative to thecompetitionathome.Thesestudentsaremoreopentodifferentcountriesaswellas fieldsofstudy,andmay consider a variety of institutions in a number of destinations. White explains thatexplorersarelesslikelytounderstandtheapplicationprocessthantheirhighflierpeersandmayfeelbombardedwithsometimesmisleadinginformationfromlocalagents.Thesestudents are most responsive to institutions that appear helpful and friendly tointernationalstudents,particularlyiftheyofferspecialESLprograms.5
3White,A.2011.ChineseStudentsInternationalStudy:FactorsFeedingtheDecisionProcess.WorldEducation
Services:WorldEducationNewsandReviews,24:1.http://www.wes.org/ewenr/11feb/feature.htm4Ibid.5Ibid.
Highfliers32%
Explorers28%
Strugglers21%
Strivers19%
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 7
Inmostcases,thedecisiontoattendaninternationaluniversityisacalculatedoneforbothhighfliers and explorers: studentswhobelieve they areunlikely tobe admitted to a topChinese institution choose to study abroad because they think the cachet of aninternationaldegreewillhelpthemmorethanadegreefromasecondorthirdtierChineseuniversity.Thesestudentstendtobeveryawareofdifferentcountriesoptionsandpathsto poststudy employment opportunities and generally prefer (in descending order) theUnitedStates,theUnitedKingdom,Australia,andCanada.6Overall,foreigninstitutionscancater to both groups by highlighting positive outcomes for students, includingemployability, 7 graduate school placement, internships, job prospects, and alumninetworkingopportunities.8MOSTINFLUENTIALFACTORSPaulHoskinswrites in theGuardiansHigher EducationNetwork blog that an institutionmustbeselectiveinitschoiceoffeaturedpeople,places,products,andperformance.Therationalefor includingfactsandaccompanyingmessagesaroundthesecategoriesmustbeevidencebased best,orbetter, than the rest aswell aswrapped andpresented in aculturallynuancedlayerofunderstanding.9Below,wehighlightthetopfactorsfoundtobeinfluentialinmakingdecisionsaboutwheretoenrollininternationalprograms:
An institutions ranking and reputationare consistently citedasamong themostmotivating factors forChinese students and families;Chinese familiesparticularlyfavor institutionsthatothershaveheardof.10Topranked institutions,aswellasinstitutions with a history of accepting Chinese students, are most wellknown,though Tom Melcher, Chairman of Zinch China, argues that an institution canimprove its brand awareness through aggressive marketing in China.11Chinesefamilies are also highly influenced by university rankings, though they may notunderstand the differences between specialty lists (e.g., liberal arts colleges,regional masters colleges, etc.). 12 As such, Zinch International, the collegeadmissions portal, emphasized in its 2011 presentation that institutions shouldhighlightanyrankinglikestatisticsevenifuniquetotheprogram.13
6Ibid.7Spinks,J.andWong,I.2010.UnderstandingStudentRecruitmentinMainlandChina:ACaseStudy.Observatoryon
BorderlessHigherEducation.http://www.ed.ac.uk/polopoly_fs/1.38061!/fileManager/Understanding%20Student%20Recruitment%20in%20Mainland%20China_A%20Case%20Study%20_January%202010_.pdf
8ZinchChina.JumpstartingYourRecruitmentinChina:ABeginnersGuide.PresentedattheNAFSA2011AnnualConference,June2,2011.http://www.slideshare.net/Zipcast11/jumpstartingyourrecruitmentinchinaabeginnersguide
9Hoskins,P.HowtorecruitinternationalstudentsinChina.TheGuardianHigherEducationNetworkblog,March27,2012.http://www.guardian.co.uk/highereducationnetwork/blog/2012/mar/27/recruitingstudentsfromchina
10Melcher,T.2010.HowChineseFamiliesSelectOverseasUniversities.WorldEducationServices:WorldEducationNewsandReviews,23:7.http://www.wes.org/ewenr/10sept/feature.htm
11Ibid.12Ibid.13ZinchChina,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 8
Along the same lines, the perceived quality of an institution in terms of theeducationandalsothequalificationisahighlyinfluentialfactor.14A2009surveyofChinesestudentsfromINTOKnowledgefoundthatthequalityofteachingwasthesecond highestrated factor that influencing mainland students choice ofinstitution.15
An institutions safety is another quality that should be highlighted inmarketingmaterials,particularly inmoreurbanenvironmentswithmore frequent incidencesofviolentcrime.16Chungetal.reportedina2009studythattheperceptionofNewZealandasasafeandharmonioussocietywascriticalforChinesestudentschoosingNew Zealand as an educational destination.17In INTO Knowledges 2009 surveypersonalsafetyandsecuritywasthetopratedinfluencingfactor.18
Althoughthequalityofthe institution is important,severalsourceshave indicatedthatChinesestudentshighlyvaluetheopportunityforaninternationalexperience,and this is most available at an institution where Chinese students are in theminority. 19 In that regard, Zinch International argues that institutions shouldhighlight low international student enrollments as providing a real overseasexperience.20
FAMILYINFLUENCEIt is inthebest interestsof institutionstoexpandthereachoftheirmarketingeffortstoawiderarrayofdecisionmakers,according to several sources.Whitewrites that inmanycases,itistheparentswhohavethefinalsayastowhichcountryandwhichinstitutionthestudentshouldapply.21ZinchChinafurthersupportsthisfinding,assertingthatinstitutionsneed to focusmarketing on parents and use the child as a marketing channel.22Thefigure below was included in Zinch Chinas presentation at the National Association ofInternational Educators (NAFSA) 2011Annual ConferenceDifferent decisionmakers, andcompareshighereducationdecisionmakingprocessesofAmericanandChinesefamilies.14Yang,M.2007.WhatattractsmainlandChinesestudentstoAustralianhighereducation.StudiesinLearning
Evaluation,Innovation,andDevelopment,4:2.AscitedbySpinksandWong.15China:StudentExpectations.2009.INTO.http://www.intocorporate.com/media/37812/china
%20students'%20expectations.pdf16Melcher,Op.cit.17Chung,K.,Holdsworth,D.,Li,Y.,andFam,K.2009.ChineseLittleEmperor,CulturalValuesandPreferred
CommunicationSourcesforUniversityChoice.YoungConsumers,10:2.AscitedbySpinksandWong.18China:StudentExpectations.2009.INTO.Op.cit.19China:StudentExpectations,Op.cit.;Melcher,Op.cit.20ZinchChina,Op.cit.21White,Op.cit.22ZinchChina,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 9
Figure2:DecisionMakingProcesses UNITEDSTATES CHINA
Wholeadstheprocess? Student ParentWhosupportstheprocess? Parent GrandparentsWhofollowstheprocess? Student
Source:ZinchChina
Becauseparentsareso influential inchoosingan institution, it is importanttounderstandthatparentsvaluedifferentcriteriaformakingdecisions.Bodycotts2009studyshedslighton the differences in what is important to parents and students in deciding where tostudy.23 Bodycott interviewed 251 parents and 100 students from mainland Chinawhowereevaluatingstudyabroadoptions.Figure3showsthemaindifferencesbetweenparentandstudentratingsof importance,as identified inthisstudy.Theonly factor foundtobeimportanttobothgroupswastherangeofprogramsavailable.24
Figure3:MostImportantFactorsforStudyAbroadOptionsFACTOR PARENTS STUDENTS
Push InadequatesupplyofuniversitiesinChina Qualityofeducation
Pull
EmploymentprospectsongraduationSocialandemotionalsupportservices
RangeofprogramsavailableMigrationpossibilities
OnsiteaccommodationRangeofprogramsavailableEnglishspeakingenvironmentLanguageandacademicsupport
servicesFacilities,buildingsandgrounds
Source:Bodycott,2009,viaSpinksandWong,2010.OTHERCONSIDERATIONSTimingisalsoafactorinapplyingtoandselectingauniversity,andChineseinstitutionsuseanacceleratedprocesscomparedtoU.S.andBritish institutions.ZinchChinaexplainsthatstudentstakethenationalcollegeentranceexam,calledthegaokao, inJuneaftertheirfinalyearofhighschool.Asaresult,Chinesestudentswhoarenotawareoftheadmissionsprocess used in other countries are at a disadvantage when applying to internationalinstitutions.Ontheotherhand,institutionswithrollingdeadlinesorlateradmissionscyclesmaybemore appealing toChinese studentswho areonly just starting to consider theiroptionsforinternationalstudyneartheendoftheirsenioryearofhighschool.25Regional differenceswithin Chinamust also be considered.According to Chong and Liu,youngpeopleinTaiwanandHongKongaremorelikelytobeknowledgeableaboutoptions
23Bodycott,P.2009.ChoosingaHigherEducationStudyAbroadDestination.JournalofResearchinInternational
Education,8:3.AscitedbySpinksandWong.24SpinksandWong,Op.cit.25ZinchChina,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 10
foreducation in foreigncountries,while theirpeers inmainlandChinamay requiremoreinformationabout internationalstudyopportunities.Assuch, it is importanttothoroughlyexplain concepts that may be unknown to mainland applicants (for example, liberaleducation).26TRENDSINSOCIALMEDIAUSEINCHINASocialmediause inChina isconstantlyrisingat lastcount,therewerenearly600millionactiveusers,afigurethatisup60percentjustfrom2012.27A2012surveybyMcKinseyandCompany that investigated various characteristicsof socialnetworkingbehavior revealedthatanestimated91percentofthetotalpopulationvisitedasocialmediaplatform intheprevious sixmonths, and 95 percent of internet users in Chinawho live in the nationslargest cities have a social media account.28Most of Chinas internet users access theinternet throughapersonalcomputer, thoughmobiledevicesarealsogainingpopularity:accordingtoMcKinsey,about50percentofmobilephoneusers in[the]surveysaidtheywereplanningtobuyasmartphoneinthenextsixmonths,35percentsaidtheyhaveusedatabletcomputer,andonefourthofconsumerswhodonotownatabletcomputersaidtheyplantobuyoneinthenextyear.29Chinesesocialmediausersalsotendtobeveryactive:theMcKinseysurveyreportedthatusers in China generally spend approximately 46minutes per day on socialmedia sites,compared to 37minutes in theUnited States and just sevenminutes in Japan.30Actualusage of these sites, however, can be broken down into six different categories bymotivationandbehavior:31
Social enthusiasts spend a large portion of their time maintaining friendshipnetworks;theyaccountforabout15percentofsocialmediausers.
Resenders,who account for15percentofparticipants, actively repostmessages,suchasjokes,fromothersources.Althoughtheydonotpostoriginalmaterial,theyoftenhavelargenumbersoffollowers.
Readersgenerallydonotparticipatebutreadwhatothershaveposted.Theymakeupabout14percentofusers.
Opinionated users, comprising about 14 percent of participants on socialmediasites,expresstheirown(oftenstrong)opinionsandbuildlargepersonalfollowings.
26ZinchChina,Op.cit.27SocialMediainChinaStatisticsandTrends[Infographic].GoGlobe.comblog,March12,2013.http://www.go
globe.com/blog/socialmediachina/28Chiu,C.,Lin,D.,andSilverman,A.2012.ChinasSocialMediaBoom.McKinsey&Company.
http://www.mckinseychina.com/wpcontent/uploads/2012/04/McKinseyChinasSocialMediaBoom.pdf29Ibid.30Ibid.31Ibid.(Bulletsquotedverbatim)
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 11
QQ spilloversgainaccess to socialmedia sites through theiruseofTencentsQQinstantmessagingservice.Whilethisgroupaccountsfor21percentoftheaudienceforsocialmedia,participationfromtheseusersisminimal.
Inactivesbelongtosocialmediasitesbutdonotparticipateinameaningfulway.Overall, the social media market in China has been described as very fragmented andlocal.32AccordingtoaMcKinseyandCompanybrief,eachsocialmediaandecommerceplatformhasatleasttwomajorlocalplayers:inmicroblogging(orweibo),forexample,SinaWeiboandTencentWeibo;insocialnetworking,anumberofcompanies,includingRenrenandKaixin001.Theseplayershavedifferentstrengths,areasoffocus,and,often,geographicpriorities.33Abriefoverviewofthetopsitesisprovidedinthefigurebelow.34
Figure4:OverviewofTopChineseSocialMediaSitesPLATFORM DESCRIPTIONDouban Openforumformovie,music,andbookreviewsJiayuan ThelargestinternetdatingwebsiteofChina
Kaixin001 ClonedthemostsuccessfulandwellknownFacebookapplicationstotheChinesemarketPengyou Arealnamesocialnetwork
Qzone Socialnetworkingwebsitewhereuserscanwriteblogsandsharephotos,music,etc.Renren FacebookofChina
SinaWeibo Chinesemicrobloggingwebsite(similartoTwitter),withabilitytoincludedimagesandvideoTencentWeibo Chinesemicrobloggingwebsite (similartoTwitter)
Wechat Mobilevoiceandtextappwithsocialnetworkingfeatures,includingphotosharingSource:GoGlobe.comandMashableOver80percentofChinesesocialmediausersareactiveonmorethanonesite,and localplatformsdominatethemarket.35Thoughspecificnumbersvary (inpartbecauseof issueswith virtual, or fake, followers), it is clear that Qzone, a social blogging site, andmicroblogging platforms TencentWeibo and SinaWeibo are favorites among users. Forinstance,theMcKinseysurveyrevealedthat44percentofrespondentsuseQzonethemost,followed by SinaWeibo and Renren (19 percent each), TencentWeibo (8 percent), and
32Chiu,C.,Ip,C.,andSilverman,A.UnderstandingSocialMediainChina.McKinseyQuarterly,April2012.
http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/marketing_sales/understanding_social_media_in_china33Chong,E.andLiu,R.HowSocialMediaUsageAmongChinasDigitalNativesisEvolving.AllThingsD,March8,
2013.http://allthingsd.com/20130308/thepowerofconnectednesshowsocialmediausageamongchinasdigitalnativesisevolving/
34[1]Mei,Y.5ChineseSocialNetworksYouNeedtoWatch.Mashable,July2,2012.http://mashable.com/2012/07/02/chinasocialnetworks/[2]SocialMediainChinaStatisticsandTrends[Infographic],Op.cit.
35Chiu,Ip,andSilverman,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 12
Kaixin(7percent).36RecentestimatesasofMarch2013ofregisteredusersonsomeofChinastopsitesareshowninFigure5,below.37
Figure5:RegisteredUsers,inMillions
Source:AdAgeglobalnewsandGoGlobe.com
SOCIALMEDIAPLATFORMSIn the followingparagraphs,we introduce someof the topplatforms for reachingout toChinesehighschoolstudents.BAIDUBaiduisChinasequivalentofGoogle,andalsooffersotherservicesincludingBaiduTieba(PostBar,adiscussionforum)andBaiduZhidao(BaiduKnows,aquestionandanswersite).38KeystrategiesforusingBaidueffectivelyinclude:
Present content that aligns with key search terms. Paul Hoskins writes in theGuardianblog thatChinese studentsgenerally look fora topUKuniversity inaparticular subject, not a specific place and not your establishment. Thewebsitesthey are most likely referred to are those of agents where there is very littlediscriminationbetweentheofferofoneestablishmentandanother.39Assuch,ClayHensely,oftheCollegeBoard,arguesthatuniversitiesneedtotakeprogramsandmajors into account when trying to reach students. According to Hensley,
36Chiu,Lin,andSilverman,Op.cit.37[1]Madden,N.MarketersHeedChinasSocialMediaExplosion.AdAgeglobalnews,March01,2013.
http://adage.com/article/globalnews/marketersheedchinassocialmediaexplosion/240093/[2]SocialMediainChinaStatisticsandTrends[Infographic],Op.cit.
38Goldkorn,J.YouTube=Youku?WebsitesandtheirChineseEquivalents.FastCompany,January20,2011.http://www.fastcompany.com/1715042/youtubeyoukuwebsitesandtheirchineseequivalents
39Hoskins,Op.cit.
712
507
400
300
259
172
172
113
73
Qzone
TencentWeibo
SinaWeibo
Wechat
Pengyou
Renren
Douban
Kaixin001
Jiayuan
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 13
universities should consider searchengine optimization for their strongestprogramswith internationalappeal,sothattheprograms,not justthe institutions,willpopupinsearchresults.40
Havealocalizedmicrosite.ArnoldMawritesinFourthSourcethatinstitutionsmustunderstandthatappendingMandarinpagestoaUKwebsitedoesnotwork.Pageswillnotbe visibleonChinese search engines. It is thereforenecessary tohave alocalizedmicrositebuiltfromthegroundupwithChinesebrowserhabits,design/UXstandardsandconsumerpersonainmind.41
IncreaseaccessibilitywithinChina.LocalsitesshouldbehostedwithintheChineseGovernmentfirewall,oroveraContentDeliveryNetwork(CDN),otherwise loadingtimesmaybe slowed to thepointatwhich the sitebecomes inaccessible.An ICPlicenseisalsorequiredfromtheGovernmentforallbusinesswebsites,butobtainingoneisamatterofformality.42
Understanddifferences in searchprocesses.Paid searchesonBaiduaredifferentfrom those used in the UK or the U.S. due to the Chinese language structure.According to Ma, this fundamental difference directly affects the bidding ofkeywordsandoptimization/structureofaccounts.Forexample, phrasematchonBaiduactsmorelikemodifiedbroadmatchbroadmatchmodifierdoesnotexistyet on Baidu PPC. Also, broad match captures far more queries due to thecomplexityoftheChineselanguage.43
Simplify text and pages for search engine optimization (SEO). Ma writes thatBaidu spider is stillnotaspowerfulasGooglebot,andgenerallydoesnot crawldeeperthanthreelevelswithinwebsitestructures.44Therefore,institutionsshouldkeepthemostimportantinformationatthetopofeachpage,makethesiteeasytonavigatewithaclearhierarchy,andkeepkeyworddensitytobetween6and10percent.45
40Wheeler,D.NewTwistsinOnlineRecruitingofInternationalStudents.TheChronicleofHigherEducationPlanet
Academeblog,April8,2012.http://chronicle.com/blogs/planet/2012/04/08/newtwistsinonlinerecruitingofinternationalstudents/
41Ma,A.DigitalmarketingtheUKandChina.FourthSource,April22,2013.http://www.fourthsource.com/general/digitalmarketingtheukandchina13965
42Ma,Op.cit.43Ibid.44Ibid.45BaiduSearchEngineOptimisation.CodeThatblog.http://www.codethat.co.uk/blog/search/baiduseoguide
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 14
Figure6:BaiduScreenshot
Source:web2asia46
RENRENRenren andQzone are both considered the Chinese versions of Facebook. According toChong and Liu,Chinese teenagers typicallybeginusing socialmediawithQzone andQQ(Chinas top instantmessagingprogram), twoplatforms thatboasthighconcentrationsofusersbelowtheageof18.Astheygetolder,collegestudentsoutgrowQzoneandmoveontoRenren,whichisdominatedbytheyoungadultpopulation.47Tencents Qzone may boast a larger count of registered users, but the site has beencriticizedasbeingheavilypopulatedby dormant, skeletonprofileswithlowvalueandretention rates.Thesite,which isaccessedprimarilyby teenage, rural,andcasualusers,allowstheuseofnicknamesandaliasesratherthanreal identities.48Meanwhile,Renrenismore popular among college students,49as it serves as an ideal resource for accessingnews about their respective universities, including curriculum updates, supplementarymaterials and classdiscussionboards.50Chong and Liuwrite that college studentsoftenretaintheirQzoneandQQaccountsusually,theywilllogintoQQtostayintouchwiththeirold friends,parents and classmates,butneglect theirQzonepagesanduseRenren
46AsianEquivalentsofWesternWebServicesPart03:China.Web2asia,August5,2009.
http://www.web2asia.com/2009/08/05/asianequivalentsofwesternwebservicespart03china/47ChongandLiu,Op.cit.48Lukoff,K.Chinastopfoursocialnetworks:Renren,Kaixin001,Qzone,and51.com.VentureBeat,April7,2010.
http://venturebeat.com/2010/04/07/china%E2%80%99stop4socialnetworksrenrenkaixin001qzoneand51com/
49Ibid.50ChongandLiu,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 15
instead.RenrenuserstendtobemoretransparentandhonestwhenusingRenren,whiletheyaremorelikelytofiltertheirmessagesonQzone.51
Figure7:UniversityofKentuckysRenrenPage
WEIBOWeibo,whichmeans microblog, is theChinese version of twitter and is offered underseveral platforms. The two biggest players are Sina Weibo and Tencent Weibo.52LikeTwitter,Weiboallowsuserstopost140charactermicroblogs,pictures,andvideos.53Oneofthedifferencesinuseractivity,however,isthatwhileTwitterusersoftenpostaboutnews,SinaWeibouserstendtocommentmoreonentertainmenttopics.54Similarly,someoftheusers with the most followers on Tencent Weibo are celebrities, hosts, famouscompanies, andmedia and entertainment agencies.55SinaWeibo is particularly common
51Ibid.52Lukoff,Op.cit.53Goldkorn,Op.cit.54SocialWebMarketinginChina.GreenBook.http://www.greenbook.org/marketingresearch.cfm/socialweb
marketinginchina1205355Lie,D.,Zhang,J.,Sun,G.,Tang,J.,Ding,Y.,andLuoZ.2012.WhatistheNatureofTencentWeibo:Detectthe
UniqueFeaturesofTencentUsers.http://arxiv.org/vc/arxiv/papers/1211/1211.2197v1.pdf
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 16
amonguniversity students,youngprofessionals,andurbandwellers,whileTencentuserstendtobemorerural.56AccordingtoTinaHu,seniordirectorinChinaforCIC,Weiboisthebestforoutreachforinstitutionsbecauseitallowsuserstoreadinformationthatisnotpublicallyavailable.57Itisestimatedthat70to80percentofChinasuniversitystudentshaveaWeiboaccount,andbetween40and50percentofstudentsuseiteveryday.58
Figure8:UniversityofHuddersfieldsSinaWeiboPage
56Lukoff,Op.cit.57Sharma,Y.UniversitiesincreasinglyuseWeibosocialmediatoreachChinastudents.UniversityWorldNews,
January13,2013.http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=2013011111233585058Ibid.;SocialMediainChina:MorethanJustRecruitment.GeniusRecruiterblog,November4,2012.
http://geniusrecruiter.com/2012/11/04/socialmediainchinamorethanjustrecruitment/
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 17
YOUKUYouku isChinasequivalentofYouTube, though therearesomedistinctdifferences.First,while YouTubes videos are primarily usergenerated, 70 percent of Youkus content issyndicated(i.e.,professionallyproduced).59AccordingtoVictorKoo,YoukusChiefExecutiveOfficer, Youku also primarily features longer videos, rather than short clips or musicvideos.60As a forum for reaching out to prospective students, Youku presents some uniqueopportunities. Clay Hensley, director of international strategy and relationships for theCollege Board, explains that video is particularly popular among Chinese studentsbecause it is hard to censor. Institutions can enlist current students as brandambassadors61totalkabouttheiruniversitylifeandeducationinMandarinorCantoneseand post the video on their own sites or pages. The university should then link to thestudentsvideos.62
Figure9:UniversityofAlbertasYoukupage
59Bradley,R.WhatYouTubecanlearnfromYouku.CNNMoney,July19,2012.
http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2012/07/19/whatyoutubecanlearnfromyouku/60YoukuTranscendsYouTubeasChinaBecomesCenterofInternet.BloombergNews,October17,2010.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/20101017/youkutranscendsyoutubeasinternetscenterofgravityshiftstochina.html
61RecruitingInternationalStudentswithSocialMedia.2012.InigralInsights.Availablefordownloadfromhttp://www.inigral.com/research/socialmediaforinternationalstudents/
62Wheeler,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 18
EFFECTIVEINTEGRATIONOFTHEDIGITALMARKETINGCAMPAIGNInadditiontoawellmanageddigitalmediacampaign,aninstitutionsinternationalstudentwebsite must be designed to clearly and efficiently provide visitors with pertinentinformation, writes Philippe Taza, founder of Higher Education Marketing, a digitalmarketing agency. Taza notes that website content should be limited to essentialinformation that ensures that future international students can easily findwhat theyrelookingforinaquickfivesecondscan.63Theblogspecifiesthatcriticalelementsinclude:
Asearchfeatureforavailableundergraduateandgraduateprograms Admissionscriteria Upcominginternationalrecruitmentvisits Financialandvisarequirements Clearcallstoactionbuttons
Beyond thisstreamlined landingpage for internationalapplicants,additionalpageswithinan institutions international studentportal shouldfocusonpromotingyourmosthighlyratedprograms,emphasizingpositiveworld rankings,andadjusting yourmessages tobeeasilyunderstandabletostudentswhohavegrownupwithdifferenteducationsystemsandare unfamiliar with local geography and culture, according to Taza. Additionally,testimonialsfromcurrentandpastinternationalstudentsintheformofwrittenblogentriesor video posts provide personal connections to potential applicants. To encouragecommunication,institutionscanenlistcurrentstudentstoserveasresourcesinaContactaCurrentStudentwebsitefeature.64Overall, institutions must remember that social media is not intended to be onesided:communication and personal contact are the driving forces behind successful digitalmarketingcampaigns. Inigral,aU.S. consulting firm thathelpsuniversities leverage socialmedia to connect with students, describes several strategies for using social media torecruit internationalstudents.Among them, Inigralrecommends that institutionscreateaprivate (i.e., not open to the public) community where admitted students can meetfaculty, administrators, and other prospective students online. According to Inigral,internationalstudentsarelikelytouseonlinegroupsforthreemainfunctions:meetingothersfromtheirhomecountry,connectingwithothersaroundmajorsorinterests,andgettinganswerstoquestions. Institutionscanalso fosteropen linesofcommunicationbyhostingonlinechats,skypeinterviews,ormeetups.65
63Taza,P.4StepstoDesigningyourWebsiteforInternationalStudentRecruitment.EDUniverse.
http://eduniverse.org/4stepsdesigningyourwebsiteinternationalstudentrecruitment64Ibid.65RecruitingInternationalStudentswithSocialMedia,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 19
Sociology PhD student and blogger Yimei Zhu writes that interaction with prospectivestudentsmaybe the key factor inobtaining followers foraUniversitysWeibopage.66Inexamining growth in thenumberof followers for sixUKuniversities, Zhu found that theUniversityof Sheffield increased thenumberof followersby41percentbetweenAugust2012andFebruary2013throughdeliberate,highqualityinteractionwithotherusers:
AfterexploringthecontentsonSheffieldsWeibopage, it isclearthattheirWeiboaccounthasactivelyinteractedwithstudentsandkeptitdowntoearth.Theyhavemanypostsand reposts showingactivities in campusand students lives, suchasspeeddating event, students eatingdinner together and job fair.When studentsaskedforaquestionregardingtoapost,theofficialaccountrepliedindetail.ItgavethesensetootherstudentreadersthatUniversityofSheffield(accountowner)careabout themandwouldcommunicatewith them if they try.Anotherstrategy is toaskquestionto their followers.Forexample,Sheffieldpostedapictureandaskedwhoknowswherethisis?Manystudentsreplied.ItfosteredinteractionnotonlySheffield official account interactedwith followers, but followers also interactedwitheachotherastheysawtherewasarelaxingenvironmentwhenpeoplecoulddiscussthingsfreely.67
Similarly,JulieCahill,AssistantDirectorof InternationalMarketingandRecruitmentattheUniversityofMontana,explainsthathyperresponsivenessmakesa lasting impressiononprospective international students,andher staffmakeeveryeffort to respond toemailsfrom studentsandapplicantswithin24 to48hours.Tobetter servepotentialapplicantsfrom China, Montanas admissions office created an International Student Associateposition and hired a Mandarinspeaking student to serve as applicants first point ofcontact.68Finally,a2012studyconductedbyswissnexChinarevealsadditionalpracticesfoundtobeeffective in the use of social media to promote international universities to Chinesestudents. The study focused specifically on SinaWeibo as aplatform for communicatingwith students regarding Swiss universities.69To facilitate the flow of information, eachuniversitynamedacommunicatorwhoprovidedcontenttobetranslatedanduploadedto Weibo by a swissnex representative.70Upon evaluating the success of the initiative,participants indicated that having a dedicated person within the swissnex office inShanghaiallowedarapidresponsetothesendingofcontentfromtheuniversities.TheproactivityandreactivityoftheShanghaiteamalsocontributedtomaintainingthesupplyofcontenteitherbylookingforinformationonthepartneruniversitieswebsitesorbyposting
66Zhu,Y.AcasestudyofUKuniversitiesuseof#Weiboaccounts.ScholarlyCommunicationandOpenSpace,July3,
2013.http://yimeizhueresearch.wordpress.com/2013/07/03/acasestudyofukuniversitiesuseofweiboaccounts/
67Ibid.68Leung,S.WooingInternationalStudentswithouttheHelpofUSNews.InigralInsightsblog,March25,2013.
http://blog.inigral.com/wooinginternationalstudentswithoutthehelpofusnews/69FischerSchrieber,I.andLaperrouza,M.2013.SocialMediaandAcademicCommunication:BridgingSinoSwiss
AcademiathroughSocialMedia.swissnexChina.http://www.swissnexchina.org/foryou/1socialmediaandacademiccommunicationbridgingsinoswissacademiathroughsocialmedia.pdf
70Ibid.,p.11.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 20
content from social media pages. 71 Overall, the participants offered the followingrecommendations toother institutions seeking toconnectwithpotentialapplicantsusingChinesesocialmedia:72
Ensurethatapushpullmechanismisinplacewhereasinstitutionspushoutcontentin regularand structuredwaywhileensuring that timelyandappropriate contentfeedstheindividualSinaWeiboaccounts.
Builda libraryofmaterialappealingtothetargetedChineseaudiences(e.g.dreamprojects,rankings,lifestyle).
Haveadedicatedperson/teamwithinmaintaintheSinaWeiboaccounts;appointasubstitute to the account manager to ensure continuity of service in case ofabsence;buildoncommonprocessestoconveymessagesviadedicatedchannels.
Ensure continuous learning regarding the developments of the social medialandscape,inparticularofthechosensocialmediachannel.
Setup abimonthly reportingmechanism to inform the institutionson the latestdevelopments regarding its Sina Weibo account; the report could either beconveyedinverbal(e.g.viaSkype/phone)orwrittenform.
Remainuptodateonthedevelopmentswithinthechosensocialmediaandmoreimportantly outside of the chosen media (e.g. understand the implications ofWeChat for the institutions communication strategy).WhereasTwitter,Facebook,or Google+ is relatively stable social media channels, the situation is very muchdifferent in China. Forecasting the usage levels and popularity of Chinese socialmediainthemediumtermisextremelyhard.
71Ibid.,pp.1718.72Ibid.,pp.1921.(Bulletsquotedverbatimorwithslightvariation)
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 21
SECTION II: PROFILES OF MARKET LEADERS In this section, we look at higher education institutions that are considered to be keyinternationalplayersintheuseofChinesesocialmedia.Weexaminethefollowingtypesofinformationforeachinstitution:
ThespecificChinesesocialmediaplatformsused(withlinkstopagesasavailable) Howtheplatformsareusedandbywhom Howsocialmediaisintegratedwithmarketingactivity Messagingsystemsused Informationondatacollectionandhowsuccessismeasured
UNIVERSITYOFALBERTA,CANADA
Platform(s):Youku,Renren Utilization of platform(s): The University created an International Office with a
director, assistant director and six recruiters. The Office used focus groups ofinternationalstudentsandalumnitoevaluatethewebsite.
Integrationofmarketingactivity:ThesocialmediasiteshelpanswerquestionsanddirecttraffictotheUniversityswebsite,whichprovidestranslatedmaterial.
Typeofmessaging:TheYoukusiteoffersvirtualtours inMandarin,andtranslatedbrochuresareavailablefordownloadontheUniversityswebsite.
Data collection: The University identified internationalization as a key priority in2006and setagoalof increasingenrollment to15percentof theundergraduatestudentbodyby2015.73
BROCKUNIVERSITY,CANADA
Platform(s):Renren,QQ,andSinaWeibo Utilization of platform(s): The International Market Development office hired
student representativeswhospeakMandarin to reachout topotentialapplicants.TheofficeswitchedtheRenrenpagefrompersonaltopublictoallowforvalidationandabroaderreach.
Integration of marketing activity: The representatives spend approximately twohourseachday informally chattingwithprospective studentsandanswering theirquestions. Most questions are related to courses, tuition, accommodations, andotherlogistics(e.g.,transportation).
73Taza,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 22
Typeofmessaging:InformalchatinMandarin. Data collection: Success is measured by the number of QQ and Renren users
interestedintheUniversity.74FRESNOPACIFICUNIVERSITY,UNITEDSTATES
Platform(s):QQ Utilizationofplatform(s):TheadmissionsofficehiredaChinesestudentassistantto
field questions from Mandarinspeaking prospective students and admittedstudents.
Integrationofmarketingactivity:Connectingoneononewithprospectivestudents.Admissionsstaffmembers includecontact information forall threeplatforms (QQplusViberandSkype)intheiremailsignaturesandencourageprospectivestudentstocontactthem.
Typeofmessaging:VoiceandtextcommunicationwithMandarinspeakingstudentsinMandarin.
Datacollection:SuccessismeasuredbynumberofapplicantsfromChina(1in2011to10in2012).75
UNIVERSITYOFHUDDERSFIELD,UNITEDKINGDOM
Platform(s):SinaWeibo Utilizationofplatform(s):TheWeibosite isoperatedbyanalumnuswhoruns the
UniversitysChinaoffice.TheUniversityalsohasaninternationalmarketingteamintheUK.
Integration of marketing activity: The University provides the China office withinformationandpicturestobeturnedintocontentfortheWeibopage.
Type ofmessaging: TheWeibo page serves as a steady and constant stream ofinformationtokeepfollowersinterested.
Datacollection:Withover30,000 followers,UniversityofHuddersfield isregardedasoneofthemostsuccessfulUKuniversitiesatusingWeibo.76
74BrockusesChinasvastsocialmediatorecruitstudents.TheBrockNews,May19,2011.
http://www.brocku.ca/brocknews/?p=986475Leung,Op.cit.76Sharma,Op.cit.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 23
UNIVERSITYOFKENTUCKY,UNITEDSTATES
Platform(s):RenrenandSinaWeibo Utilization ofplatform(s): Thepublic relationsdepartment created a socialmedia
managementpositionandhiredacurrentstudentwhoisfluentinChinese.
Integration of marketing activity: Material from the A&S website that may berelevantorinterestingtoChinesestudentsispostedonsocialmediapages.
Typeofmessaging:News itemsfromtheA&SwebsitearesummarizedandpostedinChinesewithalinktotheEnglishstory.
Data collection: Success ismeasured by the number of Chinese students (350 in2000to600in2010)andcommentsonsocialmediaposts.77
MEMORIALUNIVERSITY,CANADA
Platform(s):Renren,Mixi(socialmedianetworkinJapan),andNaver(searchportalandbloginSouthKorea)
Utilizationofplatform(s):TheSchoolofGraduateStudies(SGS)hiredthreegraduatestudents to targetpotential studentsusing the three socialmediaplatforms. Thestudentsprovideassistancewithnavigatingtheapplicationprocess.
Integration of marketing activity: The social media sites are used to advertiseMemorial University and provide free and accurate information about theapplicationprocesswithoutusinganagent.
Typeofmessaging:Directinteractioninprospectivestudentsnativelanguages. Datacollection:Successappearstobemeasuredbythenumberofapplicants.78
77Lukoff,K.Q&A:UniversityofKentuckyEnrollsinChineseSocialMedia.TechRice,December15,2011.
http://techrice.com/2011/12/15/qauniversityofkentuckyenrollsinchinesesocialmedia/78Cook,M.SGSenlistsforeignsocialmediasitestorecruitworldwide.MemorialUniversitynews,September8,
2011.http://today.mun.ca/news.php?news_id=6617
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 24
PROJECT EVALUATION FORM HanoverResearchiscommittedtoprovidingaworkproductthatmeetsorexceedspartnerexpectations.Inkeepingwiththatgoal,wewould liketohearyouropinionsregardingourreports.Feedbackiscriticallyimportantandservesasthestrongestmechanismbywhichwetailor our research to your organization.When you have had a chance to evaluate thisreport,pleasetakeamomenttofilloutthefollowingquestionnaire.http://www.hanoverresearch.com/evaluation/index.php
CAVEAT Thepublisherandauthorshaveusedtheirbesteffortsinpreparingthisbrief.Thepublisherand authors make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy orcompletenessofthecontentsofthisbriefandspecificallydisclaimanyimpliedwarrantiesoffitness for a particular purpose. There are no warranties which extend beyond thedescriptions contained in this paragraph. No warranty may be created or extended byrepresentatives of Hanover Research or its marketing materials. The accuracy andcompletenessof the informationprovidedhereinand theopinions statedhereinarenotguaranteedorwarranted toproduceanyparticular results,and theadviceand strategiescontained herein may not be suitable for every partner. Neither the publisher nor theauthorsshallbeliableforanylossofprofitoranyothercommercialdamages,includingbutnot limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. Moreover, HanoverResearch is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional services.Partnersrequiringsuchservicesareadvisedtoconsultanappropriateprofessional.
-
Hanover Research | October 2013
2013 Hanover Research | Academy Administration Practice 25
1750HStreetNW,2ndFloorWashington,DC20006
P202.756.2971F 866.808.6585www.hanoverresearch.com