Social Due Diligence Report of Dalkia (Jiamusi) Heating ......In the east of Tong Jiang street 302.9...

26
Social Due Diligence Report 41957-014 24 August 2012 Social Due Diligence Report of Dalkia (Jiamusi) Heating Network Project for the PRC: Municipal District Energy Infrastructure Development Project Prepared by Dalkia (Jiamusi) Urban Heating Co., Ltd. for the Asian Development Bank (ADB) This social due diligence report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

Transcript of Social Due Diligence Report of Dalkia (Jiamusi) Heating ......In the east of Tong Jiang street 302.9...

  • Social Due Diligence Report

    41957-014 24 August 2012

    Social Due Diligence Report of Dalkia (Jiamusi)

    Heating Network Project for the PRC: Municipal

    District Energy Infrastructure Development Project

    Prepared by Dalkia (Jiamusi) Urban Heating Co., Ltd. for the Asian Development Bank (ADB)

    This social due diligence report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

  • Social Due Diligence Report

    Of

    Dalkia (Jiamusi) Heating Network

    Project

    Dalkia (Jiamusi) Urban Heating Co., Ltd.

    24th August 2012

  • 1

    CONTENT

    1、Project Introduction ............................................................................................................... 2

    2、Construction ........................................................................................................................... 3

    3、Employment of Workers From Connected Small Boiler ....................................................... 11

    4、Conclusions ........................................................................................................................... 21

    5、Corrective Plan ..................................................................................................................... 22

    6、Appendix ............................................................................................................................... 23

    TABLES AND FIGURES

    Table 1 - Statistic on Primary and Secondary Pipelines Occupancy (2008-2011)

    Table 2 - Statistic of Substations Occupancy

    Table 3 - Employment of Workers of HOBs Connected (2008-2011)

    Figure 1 - The Main Pipe Network (2007-2011)

    Figure 2 - Office Area for Project and Self-provided Boiler House

    Figure 3 - Small Boiler House Connected and Substations

  • 2

    1、Project Introduction

    1.1 Dalkia (Jiamusi) Urban Heating Co. Ltd. Dalkia Jiamusi was incorporated in April 5, 2007. The Company is a sino-foreign joint venture between Dalkia and Jiamusi New Times Urban

    Infrastructure Investment (Group) Co. Ltd., which belongs to the municipality of Jiamusi and which

    is a substitute for the original Jiamusi Heating Company J(C . Dalkia Jiamusi has a concession for a 25-year-duration to manage the former J(C’s heating network and treble its size.

    1.2 The concession area of Dalkia Jiamusi is located in the downtown of the city of Jiamusi. Its

    service scope is east to Yindamu River, west to Yinggetu road, south to Shengli road and north to

    south bank of Songhua River as shown in Figure 1:

    Figure 1 - The Main Pipe Network (2007-2011)

    1.3 Reconstruction of old pipe network and construction of new heating pipe and connection project

    Within 5 years, Dalkia Jiamusi has invested in the construction and the reconstruction of the heating

    network (including newly-built primary and secondary pipelines for a total 14 kilometers). Dalkia

    Jiamusi has also invested in the reconstruction and new construction of 278 substations with 312

    sets of heat exchangers units.

    1.4 Dalkia Jiamusi is mainly involved in heating distribution. It owns two networks (interconnected).

    The following table summarizes the distribution system to supply heat to the networks:

    The main heat production sources are from two cogenerations which belong to third parties. They

    are located at the West and East sides of Jiamusi. Dalkia Jiamusi also owns a big boiler house,

    Jingjiang, located in the northern part of the town of Jiamusi, and four small peak-boiler houses

    (which heat small areas outside the two networks). The following table summarizes the production

    system to supply heat to the networks:

    West network East network

    Heating Seasons Heating Seasons

    10/11 11/12 10/11 11/12

    Primary Network Length (km) 41 47 93 98

    Number of Substations 67 93 195 185

    Primary Network Temperature 120°C / 70°C 95°C / 60°C

  • 3

    Heating area has increased from 5.7 million sq. meters to 10.6 million sq. meters. End-users have

    also increased from 60. 000 households and more increased to 110,000 households.

    1.5 Plan to build a new boiler as a heat source. Dalkia Jiamusi faced, during last heating season, the

    problem of saturation from the two third-party cogenerations, the main suppliers of heat; this

    saturation is mainly due to a lack of maintenance over the years which led to an important

    deterioration of the heat capacity. This situation not only impacted on Dalkia Jiamusi’s operation, but also impacted on heat supply to end-users. The actual heating quantity of Jiamusi East

    Cogeneration and West Cogeneration could not satisfy quantity demand, and therefore Dalkia

    Jiamusi was not able to ensure heating demand for new buildings.

    The plan is to build 1 x 58 MWth CFB hot-water boiler during year 2012. This boiler will be located

    in the northeast of the west cogeneration site in an area of 1.8 hectares of empty land. This boiler

    will enable Dalkia Jiamusi to heat around 1 million sq. meters. The Investment is estimated to reach

    around RMB 60 million. As of August 2012, only the design has been prepared and the construction

    period may start soon. The operation commencement date is expected to be in the second of half of

    December 2012.

    2、Construction

    2.1 Dalkia’s Jiamusi assets and land used for the Project

    2.1.1 The office area of Dalkia (Jiamusi) is in the form of a lease. The Chinese partner contributed to the JV with the former J(C’s boilers houses, network and substations. These assets belong to Dalkia Jiamusi which uses them without any compensation. There were no land occupation and

    resettlement issues.

    Figure 2 - Office Area and Self-Provided Boiler House

    West Cogeneration East Cogeneration Jinjiang Boiler House Small Boiler Houses

    Supply of

    network West East West

    Not in the network

    covered area

    Capacity

    Boilers 2 x 220 t/h Turbines 1 x 50 MWe

    + 1 x 25 MWe

    Boilers 1 x 1,050t/h Turbines 1 x 300 MWe

    Boilers 3 x 29MWth (+ 1 x 29 MWth back-up)

    Boilers 7.35 MWth

  • 4

    2.1.2 Land occupation for the new boiler. This land belongs to the West Cogeneration and has been

    allocated by Jiamusi government to this company when it was set up (built in 1992, and began to

    operate in 1998) and no relocation happened. It was originally a wasteland for flood discharge of the

    Songhua River, but the local government built a flood control dam at 1 kilometer of the north of west

    cogeneration. Now, it is used by the West Cogeneration to store ash; currently this land is empty – no ashes have been stored. Due to the current problem of lack of heat, the local government has

    decided that this land will to be used to build the new heat source (the project is highly promoted by

    Jiamusi local government) and thus the land will be sold to Dalkia Jiamusi.

    2.2 New Primary and Secondary Pipelines

    From 2008 to 2011, 14 kilometers of new primary and secondary pipelines were built. Main part of

    the network was contributed by the Chinese partner to the JV. Primary network is built on the both

    sides of urban road and bury under the sidewalks. To build the network, the company has to pay

    road digging cost and road recovery expenses to Urban Construction Management Bureau before

    the construction can start. So, pipelines construction did not involve any LA & R problems. By 2011,

    road digging and occupying fees amounted to RMB 123,698.2 in total (actual incurred costs after

    remission from Jiamusi local government). The details are shown in Table 1:

    Table 1 - Statistics on Primary and Secondary Pipelines Occupancy (2008-2011)

    No. Name of Road

    Length of the

    Pipelines

    (Unit: m)

    Wide of the

    Pipelines

    (Unit: m)

    Construction

    Period (Y/M)

    Road Dig Fees

    (RMB)

    1 South of Yong Yi road 60 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 228

    2 Road in residential

    area 193 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    3 No.1 high school

    connection 75 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    4 Road in residential

    area 143 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    5 Xing Lin road 90 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    6 In the north of

    Changan road 40 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    7 Road in residential

    area 137 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    8 Road in residential

    area 126 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    9 in the north of Xing

    Lin road 142 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    10 Jian Guo road 245.8 1.4 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    11 Road in residential

    area 119 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    12 Road in residential

    area 87.5 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    13 Zhong Xin street 168 1.2 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

  • 5

    14 Xin Min alley 186.3 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    15 Road in residential

    area 167 1.4 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    16 Qun Ying alley 94.5 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    17 Road in residential

    area 172 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    18 Road in residential

    area 61.5 1 2008.8-2008.10 Remission

    19 Subtotal of 2008

    length of pipe 2,301.6 subtotal in 2008 228

    20 In the east of Tong

    Jiang street 302.9 1.4 2009.8-2009.10 20,165

    21 In the east of Tong

    Jiang street 36.7 1 2009.8-2009.10 12,000

    22 Road in residential

    area 28.2 1.2 2009.8-2009.10 9,000

    23 Road in factory area 23.5 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    24 Pass Fu Xing alley to

    residential area 133.5 1.2 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    25 In the north of De

    Xiang road 104.4 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    26 Pass Chang Qing road

    to residential area 175.5 1.2 2009.8-2009.10 15,000

    27 Road in residential

    area 141 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    28 Road in residential

    area 77.3 1.2 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    29 The north of Changan

    road 98.8 1.2 2009.8-2009.10 13,000

    30 Road in residential

    area 54.7 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    31 South of Yong Yi road

    to residential area 89 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    32 Road in residential

    area 21 1 2009.8-2009.10 6,888

    33 South of Bao Wei

    road 17.65 1 2009.8-2009.10 Remission

    34 Subtotal of 2009

    length pipe 1,304.15 subtotal in 2009 76,053

    35 Road in residential

    area 51.1 1 2010.8-2010.10 634.99

    36 Road in residential

    area 236 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 3,134.57

    37 Road in residential

    area 105 1 2010.8-2010.10 2,728.18

    38 Road in residential

    area 100 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    39 Road in residential

    area 420.5 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    40 Road in residential

    area 127.7 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    41 Road in residential

    area 366 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

  • 6

    42 Road in residential

    area 192.8 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    43 Crossing of Sheng Li

    road 112.7 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    44 Crossing of Xi Lin

    road 221.4 1 2010.8-2010.10 4,974.61

    45 Chun Guang Hu Tong 94.7 1 2010.8-2010.10 1,677.73

    46 Road in residential

    area 213.2 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 7,766.52

    47 Xin Li Hu Tong 94.2 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    48 East of Song Lin

    street 313.6 1 2010.8-2010.10 4,138.25

    49 Tang Fu alley 245.5 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    50 Xi Lin road 170 1 2010.8-2010.10 634.99

    51 South of Yong He

    alley 79.8 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    52 Road in residential

    area 8.4 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    53 South of Changan

    road, Jian Guo road 238.7 1.4 2010.8-2010.10 10,113.32

    54 Jian Guo road 52.6 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    55 North of Changan

    road 133.6 1 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    56 South Xin Lin road,

    He Ping road 137.4 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 4,087.87

    57 South of Jie Fang road 113 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    58 Xin Yi Hu Tong 202.3 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 7,526.16

    59 South of Guang Fu

    road 32.9 1.2 2010.8-2010.10 Remission

    60 Subtotal of 2010

    length of pipe 4,163.1 Subtotal in 2010 47,417.20

    61 Yong He alley 158.6 1 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    62 Road in residential

    area 152.75 1 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    63 Wei Xin street 64 1.2 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    64 Xing Lin road 61 1 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    65 Road in residential

    area 51 1.2 2011.8-2011.9 Remission

    66 Guang Fu road 20.7 1 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    67 Road in residential

    area 463.41 1 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    68 Xing Cheng Hu Tong 264 1 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

    69 Road in residential

    area 127.4 1.2 2011.5-2011.5 Remission

  • 7

    70 Chang Qing road 120.8 1.2 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    71 Chang Qing road 156 1.2 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    72 Road in residential

    area 160.2 1 2011.6-2011.7 Remission

    73 Road in residential

    area 84 1 2011.8-2011.9 Remission

    74 De Xiang road, Zhong

    Xin street 215 1 2011.6-2011.7 Remission

    75 Road in school 142.1 1 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    76 Road in residential

    area 72 1.2 2011.7-2011.8 Remission

    77 North of Xing Lin

    road 70.5 1 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    78 Yong Tai street 224.3 1.2 2011.6-2011.7 Remission

    79 Road in residential

    area 280.9 1.2 2011.9-2011.10 Remission

    80 Tai Feng alley, Fu

    Feng street, 601.2 1.4 2011.6-2011.7 Remission

    81 Pass through Jian Guo

    road 164.2 1.2 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    82 Zhao Guo Hu Tong 413.8 1.4 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    83 South of Pu Dong

    street 430 1.2 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    84

    Fruit Product

    company boiler's

    connection

    157 1 2011.8-2011.9 Remission

    85 Road in residential

    area 330 1 2011.5-2011.6 Remission

    86 Road in residential

    area 78 1 2011.8-2011.9 Remission

    87 Road in residential

    area 359.9 1 2011.6-2011.7 Remission

    88 Road in residential

    area 766.8 1.2 2011.10-2011.11 Remission

    89 Road in residential

    area 74 1.2 2011.8-2011.9 Remission

    Total of length of pipe in

    2011 6,263.56

    2011 Road

    break/dig fees -

    Accumulative of length of

    pipe 14,032.41 total 123,698.20

    2.3 Substations

    2.3.1 In order to stop small boiler houses which are highly pollutant, construction of substations are

    necessary (it is also according to Jiamusi municipal Party committee and Jiamusi government plans).

    Each year, Dalkia Jiamusi has the obligation to connect new areas/ customers. With the expansion of

    centralized heating networks, the connected small boiler houses are either dismantled or can be

    replaced by substations as well.

  • 8

    Figure 3 - Small Boiler House Connected and Substations

    2.3.2 By the end of 2011, there were a total of 66 new substations, with a total land occupation area

    of around 4,000 sq. meters. Among them, there are 10 substations which used the existed

    basements of buildings, 35 substations which used the location of the dismantled connected small

    boiler houses, 19 substations which used the land freely supplied by related property management

    companies or municipal government, 1 substation for which location is leased and 1 substation

    which used the original location of a substation (agreed with the owner). As the construction of the

    substations is to contribute to and improve public services. Dalkia Jiamusi did not need to pay for

    the occupied state-owned land according to relevant policies of Jiamusi. Detailed information is

    shown in Table 2:

    Table 2 - Statistics on Substations Occupancy

    No. Location

    Floor

    area

    (m2)

    Using

    existed

    basement

    Using

    existed

    HOBs

    Period of

    connection

    Was it newly built?

    (Neither use

    basement nor

    original boiler

    house)

    Source of

    newly-built

    substation’s land (Does it transfer by

    government in

    free? Supply by

    developer in free?

    Or other reasons)

    1 Guo Maitong

    Sub. 80 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    developers

    2 Water

    product Sub. 30 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    developers

    3

    Shu

    Xiangyuan

    Sub.

    40 N N 2008 Y Free provided by

    developers

    4 Bo Fan Sub. 756 N Y 2008 N Free provided by

    owners

    5 Transpotation

    Company Sub. 80 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    developers

    6 Sanshine Sub. 30 Y N 2008 N Free provided by

    developers

    7 Traffic team

    Sub. 20 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    developers

    8 No.9 middle

    school Sub. 40 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    school

  • 9

    9

    Jing Yuan

    Mix-water

    station

    30 N N 2008 Y Free provided by

    developers

    10 Nei Pei Sub. 40 N N 2008 Y Free provided by

    developers

    11 Da Zhan Sub. 40 N Y 2008 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    12 Tian Qi Sub.

    1# 30 N Y 2008 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    13 Tian Qi

    Sub.2# 70 N Y 2008 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    14 Hui Yuan Sub. 120 Y N 2008 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    15 Fu Lian Sub. 30 N N 2008 Y Free provided by

    developers

    16 Heng Ji Sub. 120 Y N 2008 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    17 Pu Ruite

    Boiler House 50 N Y 2008 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    18 Fire Control

    branch Sub. 60 N Y 2008 N

    Free provided by

    Fire control branch

    19 Yuandong

    Yanjiang Sub. N N 2009

    N Took advantage of

    own substation (Used the original

    sub.)

    20 Zhong Fang

    Sub. 88.44 N Y 2009 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    21 Fu Tai Sub. 189.06 N Y 2009 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    22

    Outskirt

    agricultural

    machinery

    Sub.

    32.14 N Y 2009 N

    Free supplied by

    agricultural

    machinery bureau

    23 Ji Xing Sub. 20.48 N Y 2009 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    24

    North

    residential

    Sub.

    66.13 Y N 2009 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    25

    Yong Hong

    Traffic branch

    Sub.

    34.62 N Y 2009 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    26 Xu Fu garden

    Sub. 73.47 N Y 2009 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    27 Hotel Sub. 40.2 N Y 2009 N Free supplied by

    hotel

    28 Fuli Qianjia

    Sub. 80 N N 2009 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    29 Technology

    School Sub. 48 N N 2010 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    30

    No.10

    primary

    school Sub.

    60 N N 2010 Y Free provided by

    developers

    31

    Fu Xing

    residential

    Sub.

    Installation

    24 N N 2010 Y Lease

  • 10

    32

    Education 6#

    residential

    Sub.

    60 N Y 2010 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    33

    Outskirt

    Labor Service

    Sub.

    60 N N 2010 Y Free provided by

    developers

    34 KOKO family

    building Sub. 60 N Y 2010 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    35 Electricity

    Power Sub. 48 N N 2010 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    36 Xin Da Sub. 30 N N 2010 Y Free provided by

    developers

    37 Cheng Jian

    Sub. 60 N N 2010 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    38 Education Jizi

    building Sub. 60 N Y 2010 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    39

    Outskirt

    Council of

    Agriculture

    Sub.

    40 N N 2010 Y Free provided by

    developers

    40 Tang Fu

    garden Sub. 40 N N 2010 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    41 Jia He 1# Sub. 80 N Y 2010 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    42 Sanjiang Gree

    Sub. 80 Y N 2010 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    43

    Deng Feng

    district gvt

    Sub.

    30 N Y 2010 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    44 Hui Xinyuan

    Sub. 30 N N 2010 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    45 Chen Xing

    Sub. 50 N Y 2010 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    46

    Electrical

    Machinery

    Plant Sub.

    24 Y N 2010 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    47 Hai Ge Sub. 30 N Y 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    48 Hong An Sub. 60 Y N 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    49

    Hong Da

    commercial

    center Sub.

    80 N Y 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    50 the north of

    Hongda 15 N N 2011 Y

    Free transferred by

    government

    51

    Second

    campus Sub.

    For No.1 high

    school

    40 N Y 2011 N Free supplied by

    school

    52 Bus company

    Sub. 40 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    53 Xing Hua Jie

    Kun 30 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    54 Hua Qiao

    Hotel Sub. 24 N N 2011 Y

    Free supplied by

    PMC

  • 11

    55 Xin Bao Sub. 24 N Y 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    56 Price Bureau

    Sub. 80 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    57

    Children

    warfare

    institute Sub.

    80 N N 2011 Y Free supplied by

    institute

    58 Xing Hua Sub. 30 Y N 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    59 Shunt family

    building Sub. 32 N N 2011 Y

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    60 Fruit product

    Sub. 24 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    61 Animal

    Market Sub. 20 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    62 Dong Feng

    Sub. 18 N Y 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    63 Tong Fu

    garden Sub. 60 N N 2011 Y

    Free provided by

    developers

    64 Hong Da Sub. 80 N Y 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    65

    Education 5#

    residential

    Sub.

    20 Y N 2011 N Free supplied by

    PMC

    66 Jiongchang

    Shiye Sub. 40 Y N 2011 N

    Free supplied by

    PMC

    3、Employment of Workers From Connected Small Boiler

    From 2008 to 2011, there were 102 small boilers houses connected. 659 affected workers are male,

    and 30 are females including 191 of non-temporary employees, and 468 of seasonal employees.

    Before the connection, their average wage per month was RMB 1,062; and after the connection it is

    RMB 1,385. Rights and interests for these laborers were ensured as these employees were provided

    with strong support for re-employment. The measures taken for the employees are as follows:

    3.1 Measure A: 22 fixed employees worked for PMC before connection. These employees already

    have a position such as security guard and maintainer. Because of seasonal demand, they were

    assigned as stokers for the operation and maintenance of small boilers in winter. According to the

    local policies, after connection, these people no longer need to work in the boilers, but still work for

    PMC. No laid-off workers.

    3.2 Measure B: 78 fixed stokers were assigned to work in other boilers. According to the local

    policies, small boiler houses must to be connected to centralized heating network; but because of

    insufficient heat source due to the urbanization development or because Dalkia Jiamusi’s current network does not reach certain areas yet, therefore the local government allows the construction of

    regional centralized boiler houses. These stokers are usually technicians (with certification) and

    were assigned to work in other boilers by developers. Work is stable, and income is higher compare

    to before. According to the survey and consultation of some workers, they are satisfied with their

    employment arrangement.

  • 12

    3.3 Measure C: 71 fixed employers (incl. 15 female employees) are hired by school, government and

    public enterprises. After connection, according to the Labor Law of PRC, they were assigned to new

    positions such as security guard, cleaner… by their original units, without changing salary, insurance and welfare.

    3.4 Measure D: For the 468 seasonal employees, according to the Employment Contracts Law (2008)

    and Labor Law of PRC (1994), fixed term labor contracts were signed between the employees and

    the employers. These seasonal employees work from October to April (heating season). After the

    heating season, the contracts are automatically terminated. After the heating season, the

    government will inform the units which will be connected to the centralized heating system; the

    units will thus not go to the labor market to employ seasonal employees. The local government set

    up labor market divided into administrative districts to provide better and more information

    regarding re-employment opportunities for seasonal workers.

    3.5 Measure E: 50 full-time workers (incl. 15 female employees), who were near the retirement age,

    were entitled to advanced retirement based on the voluntary application according to rule of Labor

    Law of PRC.

    Table 3 - Employment of Workers of HOBs Connected 2008-2011

    No. Unit

    Related

    Heated

    area by

    HOBs

    m2

    Workers Affected Status of

    workers

    Average

    monthly

    wages

    before

    connecti

    on

    (RMB)

    Arrangement for

    employment after

    connection

    (whereabouts,

    compensation)

    Average

    monthly

    wages

    after

    connecti

    on

    Am

    oun

    t

    Male Fema

    le

    Avera

    ge

    age

    Fixe

    d

    Casua

    l

    1 Tian Qi 1# 12401 5 5 - 45 1 4 1040

    Measure A; JMS

    Yangguang PMC

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    2 Tian Qi 2# 59460 10 8 2 42 1 9 1020

    Measure A; JMS

    Yangguang PMC

    1400 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    3

    Guo

    Maitong

    residential

    34887 5 5 - 40 1 4 1040

    Measure C;

    Guomaitong Company

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    4

    Water-prod

    uct Zong He

    builidng

    15051 4 4 - 49 1 3 1050

    Measure A; JMS

    Yangguang PMC

    1450 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    5

    Shu

    Xiangyuan

    residential

    36939 10 9 1 44 1 9 1020

    Measure A; JMS

    Yangguang PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

  • 13

    6 Xin Da 1# 8455 4 4 - 51 1 3 1050

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    7 Tian Fa

    residential 10099 5 5 - 49 1 4 1040

    Measure A; Xing Ye

    PMC

    1500 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    8

    Transporta

    tion

    Company

    14757 5 5 - 49 1 4 1040

    Measure C;

    Transportation

    company 1350

    Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    9 Yan Jiang

    residential 15476 5 5 - 50 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    10 Sunshine

    residential 11169 5 5 - 52 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    11 Xin Cheng

    residential 19514 5 5 - 52 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1450 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    12 Hui Yuan

    residential 15025 5 5 - 54 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    13

    Dong Feng

    traffic

    branch

    5000 5 5 - 46 1 4 1040

    Measure A; JMS

    Yangguang PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    14

    No.9

    middle

    school Zong

    He building

    11898 5 5 - 45 1 4 1040

    Measure C No.9 middle

    school

    1500 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    15

    Shi Yan

    kindergarte

    n

    10074 5 5 - 49 1 4 1040

    Measure C;

    Kindergarden

    1350 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    16 Cable

    factory 10542 5 5 - 50 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

  • 14

    17

    Qian Jin

    district

    people's

    court

    3339 3 3 - 55 1 2 1067

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    18 Mo Fan

    residential 44162 12 11 1 43 4 8 1067

    Measure A; San Tong

    PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    19

    Training

    center for

    wonmen

    and

    children

    9560 4 4 - 55 1 3 1050

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1450 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    20

    Conmustio

    n engine

    residential

    22300 10 9 1 51 1 9 1020

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    21

    No.7

    middle

    school

    5779 4 4 - 53 1 3 1050

    Measure C No.7 middle

    school

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    22 Jing Yuan 15160 5 5 - 55 2 3 1080

    Measure E

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    23 Trade

    center 6719 5 5 - 56 2 3 1080

    Measure E

    1500 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    24 Heng Ji 39521 10 9 1 47 7 3 1140

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    25 Zhongshan

    Mingyuan 66403 16 15 1 45 7 9 1088

    Measure B 3 persons

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    26 Jixing 1# 18618 5 5 - 48 2 3 1080

    Measure A San Tong

    PMC

    1350 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    27 Fire control

    branch 13432 4 4 - 50 1 3 1050

    Measure C fire control

    branch

    1350 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    28

    Municipal

    governmen

    t 1,2#

    13800 5 5 - 56 2 3 1080

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1450 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

  • 15

    29

    Party

    school Zong

    He building

    6334 4 4 - 54 1 3 1050

    Measure C Party school

    1400 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    30

    No.1 high

    residential

    building

    12021 5 5 - 53 2 3 1080

    Measure C No.1 high

    school

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    31

    Yong Hong

    traffice

    branch Ji Zi

    building

    9831 5 5 - 52 2 3 1080

    Measure C Yong Hong

    traffic branch

    1350 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    32 Ji Yun 8581 5 5 - 55 2 3 1080

    Measure E

    1450 Fixed employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    33 Chang An

    square 40739 20 18 2 43 6 14 1060

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1450 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    34

    Postal

    service

    Zong He

    building

    5224 5 5 - 54 2 3 1080

    Measure C postal office

    1450 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

    35

    Outskirt

    agricultural

    machinery

    bureau

    9790 5 5 - 52 2 3 1080

    Measure C Outskirt

    agricultural machinery

    bureau 1300

    Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    36 Jiamusi

    hotel 22322 5 5 - 47 2 3 1080

    Measure C JMS hotel

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    37 Xue Fu

    garden 24781 5 5 - 46 2 3 1080

    Measure A San Tong

    PMC

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    38 Zhong Fang

    big world 38329 5 4 1 43 2 3 1080

    Measure A San Tong

    PMC

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    39 Ji Xing Zong

    He 18618 10 9 1 49 2 8 1040

    Measure A San Tong

    PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    40 North

    residential 30131 5 5 - 40 2 3 1080

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1350 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

  • 16

    41 Bearing

    plant 38052 10 9 1 45 3 7 1060

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    42 Fu Xing 22089 10 10 - 58 3 7 1060

    Measure E

    1450 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    43 Yuan Dong

    Yan Jiang 41199 10 9 1 48 3 7 1060

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    44 Yuan Dong

    grain depot 50004 18 17 1 47 3 15 1033

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    45 East of beer

    brewery 26710 10 10 - 49 2 8 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    46

    South of

    beer

    brewery

    7440 3 3 - 51 1 2 1067

    Measure C beer

    brewery

    1450 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    47 Xing Cheng 12432 5 5 - 52 3 2 1120

    Measure A PMC

    1500 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    48 stomatologi

    cal hospital 22193 5 5 - 51 3 2 1120

    Measure C

    stomatological hospital

    1500 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

    49 Fuli Qianjia 47626 15 15 - 46 3 12 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    50 Sausage

    company 4243 5 5 - 53 3 2 1120

    Measure C hotel

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    51 Yu Long

    company 5196 3 3 - 54 1 2 1067

    Measure C Yu Long

    Company

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    53 Dong Feng

    court 1657 1 1 - 52 1 - 1067

    Measure C Dong Feng

    court

    1450 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

  • 17

    52 Sen Yu 25869 5 5 - 45 3 2 1120

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    53 Education

    6# 31447 5 5 - 51 3 2 1120

    Measure C Education

    bureau

    1300 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    54 He Ping AB

    building 15601 5 5 - 57 3 2 1120

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    56 Cheng Jian

    Zong He 13329 5 5 - 56 3 2 1120

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    57 Ji Zi

    building 14785 5 5 - 54 3 2 1120

    Measure C Education

    bureau

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    58

    Outskirt

    labor

    service

    12107 5 5 - 52 3 2 1120

    Measure C Outskirt

    labor service

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    59 Dong Fang

    garden 4# 7765 3 3 - 53 1 2 1067

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1350 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    60 Mu

    Gongshang 16948 5 5 - 50 3 2 1120

    Measure A PMC

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    61

    Outskirt

    committee

    of

    agriculture

    19405 5 5 - 51 3 2 1120

    Measure C; Outskirt

    committee of

    agriculture 1450

    Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    62

    Tang Fu

    garden

    (Peng Ji 3#)

    62465 20 18 2 40 2 18 1020

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1350 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    63

    Dong Feng

    district

    governmen

    t

    10732 5 5 - 45 1 4 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

  • 18

    64 HuiXinyuan

    2# 59476 15 14 1 58 2 13 1027

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    65 San Jiang 24199 5 5 - 48 2 3 1080

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1450 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    66 Xing Chen

    residential 34791 5 5 - 47 2 3 1080

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    67 Yongan

    residential 90403 20 18 2 49 2 18 1020

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    68

    Power

    Zong He

    builidng

    3476 3 3 - 51 1 2 1067

    Measure C Electrical

    Power bureau

    1500 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    69

    Electrical

    Power

    bureau

    residential

    9029 4 4 - 52 2 2 1100

    Measure C Electrical

    Power bureau

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    70 Antong

    property 40000 10 9 1 47 2 8 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for three

    months wages

    71

    Justice

    bureau

    residential

    10569 5 5 - 52 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1300 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

    72 Xin Da 2# 14306 5 5 - 53 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1450 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    73 Zhongfang

    Yijing 16288 5 5 - 53 1 4 1040

    Measure A PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    74 Xing

    Xiayuan 12460 5 5 - 51 1 4 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

  • 19

    75 Hong An 32055 10 9 1 57 3 7 1060

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    76 Tong Fu

    family land 36482 5 5 - 51 1 4 1040

    Measure A PMC

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    77

    Planning

    institute

    residential

    16381 5 5 - 51 1 4 1040

    Measure C planning

    design institute

    1400 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    78 Xing Hua

    residential 16451 5 5 - 49 1 4 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    79

    No.2

    primary

    school

    4157 3 3 - 55 1 2 1067

    Measure C No.2

    primary school

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    80

    Shunt

    family

    building

    16411 5 5 - 52 1 4 1040

    Measure C Shunt family

    building

    1450 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    81 Hua Qiao

    Hotel 26009 6 6 - 51 1 5 1033

    Measure C Hua Qiao

    hotel

    1300 Employees

    compensated for seven

    months wages

    82 Tongyuan

    Haige 6908 5 5 - 51 4 1 1160

    Measure A PMC

    1300 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    83

    Bus

    company

    residential

    building

    39884 10 9 1 49 2 8 1040

    Measure C bus

    company

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    84 Ru Yi 8918 5 5 - 52 1 4 1040

    Measure C Ru Yi

    building

    1500 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    85 Xinghua

    Jiekun 12859 5 5 - 47 3 2 1120

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1500 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    86 Ba yi hotel 3862 3 3 - 48 1 2 1100

    Measure C Jiaxi hotel

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

  • 20

    87

    Fruit

    product

    Company

    17067 5 5 - 47 1 4 1040

    Measure C Fruit

    product company

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    88 Education

    5# 28106 5 5 - 46 1 4 1040

    Measure C Education

    bureau

    1350 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    89 Xin Bao 9007 5 5 - 56 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1450 Employees

    compensated for nine

    months wages

    90

    Price and

    traffice

    residential

    51792 20 19 1 43 2 18 1020

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    91 Animal

    market 8259 5 5 - 53 1 4 1040

    Measure E; Advanced

    retirement

    1400 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    92 No. 11 4628 5 5 - 51 1 4 1040

    Measure C No.11

    middle school

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    93

    Dong Feng

    distric

    policemen

    residntial

    building

    31599 8 5 3 49 1 7 1025

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1450 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    94 Changchen

    g Hotel 1971 2 2 - 54 1 1 1100

    Measure C Changcheng

    hotel

    1450 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    95 Hua Gong

    builidng 9# 6975 5 5 - 48 1 4 1040

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1450 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    96

    Hong Da

    golden

    triangle

    95920 20 18 2 45 3 17 1030

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    97

    Hong Da

    commercial

    center

    78328 20 18 2 43 3 17 1030

    Measure B Boiler

    house

    1300 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

  • 21

    98

    the second

    campus of

    No.1 high

    school

    18287 5 5 - 48 1 4 1040

    Measure C No.1 high

    school

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    99

    Ocean

    Wave

    Palace

    19729 5 5 - 44 1 4 1040

    Measure C PMC

    1350 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    100 Harvest

    residential 30546 10 10 - 46 3 7 1060

    Measure B boiler house

    1450 Employees

    compensated for four

    months wages

    101

    Children

    welfare

    association

    11928 5 5 - 50 1 4 1040

    Measure C Department

    of Civil Affairs

    1400 Employees

    compensated for five

    months wages

    102 NSA 1030 2 2 - 44 1 1 1100

    Measure C NSA

    1400 Employees

    compensated for six

    months wages

    Note: Compensations are provided directly by original employing units.

    4、Conclusions

    4.1 The office area of Dalkia (Jiamusi) is rent (5,000 sq. meter of floor area), and is located in 82-1,

    Heping road, Qianjin district; terms of tenancy is 10 years.

    The Chinese partner contributed to the JV with the former J(C’s boilers houses, network and substations. Dalkia Jiamusi is the owner of all these assets and no land occupancy and resettlement

    issues were raised.

    4.2 Land occupancy for the planned new-build heat source. This land was granted by Jiamusi local

    Government to the West Cogeneration. It is an empty land at present, but can be used as ash storage

    by the West Cogeneration. The local government granted Dalkia Jiamusi with the right to use this

    land and Dalkia Jiamusi will have to pay land-transferring fees to government.

    4.3 New primary pipelines are built along the road. Dalkia Jiamusi needs to pay road digging costs

    and road recovery expenses to the municipality. Dalkia Jiamusi is not involved in any land reception

    and resettlement problems in the process of pipelines construction.

    4.4 Among the 66 new-built substations, there are 10 substations which used the existed basements

    of buildings, 35 substations which used the location of the dismantled connected small boiler

    houses, 19 substations which used the land freely supplied by related property management

    companies or municipal government, 1 substation for which location is leased and 1 substation

    which used the original location of a substation (agreed with the owner).

  • 22

    As the construction of the substations is for public services, thus according to the related policies,

    Dalkia Jiamusi did not have to pay any costs for the land use.

    4.5 From 2008 to 2011, Dalkia Jiamusi connected 102 small boiler houses. Affected workers amount

    to 689 people and re-employment arrangements and support plans were provided. Local

    government bureaus and Dalkia Jiamusi worked closely together to address the re-employment

    issues to comply with the China Labor Law.

    5、Corrective Plan

    5.1 Training on ADB’s policy on resettlement and Social Protection Strategy for capacity building are necessary for the staff, especially at the project company level.

    5.2 As of today, because of the lack of heating supply will remain an issue for the heating season

    2012-2013, so there is no plan to connect small boiler houses this year. However, if such plan should

    be implemented in the future, Dalkia will therefore work closely with all the stakeholders and

    prepare a report to address the issue to ADB.

  • 23

    6、Appendix

    Appendix 1shows the notification for the connection of small boilers issued by Jiamusi heating

    office.

  • 24