Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
-
Upload
dekonstrukcija -
Category
Documents
-
view
230 -
download
0
Transcript of Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
1/21
Romanticists or Double Insiders? An Essay on the OrDiscourses in Balkan Ethnology
Romanticists or Double Insiders? An Essay on the Origins of
in Balkan Ethnology
by Slobodan Naumovi
Source:
Ethnologia Balkanica (Ethnologia Balkanica), issue: 02 / 1998, pages: 101-
http://www.ceeol.com/ -
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
2/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
3/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
4/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
5/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
6/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
7/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
8/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
9/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
10/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
11/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
12/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
13/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
14/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
15/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
16/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
17/21
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
18/21
117
Cocchiara, Giusepe1952: Storia del folklorein Europa.Torino (transl.The
HistoryofFolkloreinEurope.Philadelphia1981)
Cocchiara,Giusepe[DjusepeKokjara]1984:IstorijafolklorauEvropi.Belgrade.
Cranston,Maurice1974:Ideology.In:EncyclopaediaBritannica9,194198.Cviji,Jovan1918:LaPninsulebalkanique.Gographiehumaine.Paris:Ar-
mandColin.
Damianakos,Stathis1985:Reprsentationsdelapaysanneriedanslethnographie
grecque.In:PaysansetNationsdEuropecentraleetbalkanique.Paris:Mai-
sonneuveetLarose.
Damianakos,Stathis1989:FolkloreandHistoricalProcess.Zagreb:Instituteof
FolkloreResearch.
Geertz,Clifford1964:IdeologyasaCulturalSystem.In:D.Apter(ed.),Ideolo-
gyandDiscontent.London:TheFreePressofGlencoe,Collier-Macmillan.Greenfeld, Liah 1992: Nationalism. Five Roads to Modernity. Cambridge,
Mass.,London:HarvardUniversityPress.
Halpern,JoelM.,EugeneA.Hammel1969:ObservationsontheIntellectual
HistoryofEthnologyandotherSocialSciencesinYugoslavia.In:Comparati-
veStudiesinSocietyandHistory11:1726.
Hastrup,Kirsten1996:AnthropologicalTheoryasPractice.In:SocialAnthro-
pology4,1:7581.
Hobart,Mark 1996:Ethnographyasa Practice, oron the Unimportance of
Penguins.In:Europaea2,1(Nuoro-Brussels)337.
Hobsbawm,Eric1989:NationsandNationalismSince1780.Programme,Myth,
Reality.Cambridge:CambridgeUP.
Karadi, Vuk Stefanovi 1965: Predislovie zamaluprostunarodnuslavenu-
serbskupjesnaricu[ForewordtotheSmallSlaveno-SerbianSongbookofthe
SimpleFolk].In:SabranadelaV.KaradiaI.Belgrade.
Kamenka,Eugene(ed.)1973:Nationalism.TheNatureandEvolutionofanIdea.
London:EdwardArnold.
Karnoouh,Claude1985:Delusagedufolkloreoulesavatarsdufolklorisme.
In:PaysansetNationsdEuropecentraleetbalkanique.Paris:Maisonneuveet
Larose,4962.
Karnoouh,Claude1990:LInventiondupeuple.ChroniquesdeRoumanie.Paris:
Arcantere.
Kligman,Gail1988:Ideology,RitualandIdentity.In:TheWeddingoftheDead.
Ritual,Poetics,andPopularCultureinTransylvania.Berkeley,LosAngeles:
UniversityofCaliforniaPress,249282.
Konstantinov, Milo 1988: Ethnology of the Macedonians. In: Ethnological
Review2324(Belgrade)7588.Kosi,M.1934:Problemisavremenesociologije[Problems ofContemporary
Sociology].Belgrade,103104.
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
19/21
118
Kovaevi,Ivan1977:Uticajromantizmanarazvojnaeetnologije[TheInfluence
ofRomanticismon theDevelopment ofOurEthnology]. In:Marksistika
misao1/77,Belgrade,5467.
Kovaevi,Ivan1981:Etnologijausrpskomprosvetiteljstvu[EthnologyinSerbi-anEnlightenment].PhDthesis,BelgradeUniversity.
Kulii,piro1951:Idejnaiteorijskaosnovaurazvitkunaihetnografskihmuze-
ja[ConceptualandTheoreticalBasisoftheDevelopmentofOurEthnographic
Museums]. In:Zbornik etnografskogmuzejauBeogradu19011951.Bel-
grade,2731.
Kulii,piro1967:Nekashvatanjaineketendencijeunaojsavremenojetnolo-
giji[SomeConceptsandTendenciesinOurContemporaryEthnology].In:
Sociologija1(Belgrade)7583.
Kulii,piro1980:OetnogeneziCrnogoraca[OntheEthnogenesisoftheMon-tenegrin].Titograd:Pobjeda.
Mannheim,Karl31952:IdeologieundUtopie.Frankfurt/M.(transl.KarlMan-
hajm:Ideologijaiutopija.Belgrade:Nolit1978).
Mihilescu,Vintil1991:NationalitetnationalismeenRoumanie.In:Terrain17
(Paris)7990.
Mihilescu,Vintil1993:Nous,lesautres.Histoireduneidentitnon-moderne.
In:idem,Enqutedidentit.(Specialissueof)Civilisations42,2(Brussels)
105117.
Mili,Vojin1956:SociolokakoncepcijaJovanaCvijia[TheSociologicalCon-ceptofJ.Cviji].In:Knjievnost1112(Belgrade).
OSullivan,Timetal.1994:Discourse(byJohnHartley).In:KeyConceptsin
CommunicationandCulturalStudies.London,NewYork:Routledge.
Papi,arana,LydiaSklevicky(eds.)1983:Antropologija ene[TheAnthro-
pologyofWomen].Belgrade.
Pavkovi,Nikola,DuanBandi,IvanKovaevi1988:AspirationsandDirec-
tionsoftheDevelopmentofEthnologyintheSocialistRepublicofSerbia.In:
EthnologicalReview2324(Belgrade)516.
Prevlakis,Georges1992:Laographiegreque ethnographieouidologie?In:
Gographieet cultures2:7584(Bulg. translation in:BalkanisticForum3
(1995)103111).
Plamenatz,John1973:TwoTypesofNationalism.In:Kamenka1973,2236.
Ryan,Alan1970:Science,SocialScienceandIdeology.In:idem,ThePhiloso-
phyoftheSocialSciences.London:MacMillan,220242.
Silverman,Carol1989:TheHistoricalShapeofFolkloreinBulgaria.In:Damia-
nakos1989,149158.
Shils,Edward1968:TheConceptandFunctionofIdeology.In:DavidL.Sills
(ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, vol. 7. London:
MacMillan,6676.
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
20/21
119
Slavec,Ingrid1988:SlovenianEthnologyBetweenthePastandthePresent.In:
EthnologicalReview2324(Belgrade)3759.
Supek,Olga1988:EthnologyinCroatia.In:EthnologicalReview2324(Bel-
grade)1735.Tadi,Ljubomir1972:Tradicija i revolucija [Tradition andRevolution].Bel-
grade:SKZ.
Trgovevi, Ljubinka1986:Naunici Srbije i stvaranje jugoslovenske drave
19141920 [Scholars of Serbia and the Making of the Yugoslav State
19141920].Belgrade:Narodnaknjiga.
Weber,Max1922:GesammelteAufstzezurWissenschaftslehre.Tbingen31968
(transl.Metodologijadrutvenihnauka.Zagreb1989).
Wolff,KurtH.(ed.)1971:FromKarlMannheim.NewYork.
Zador,Tordai1985:LesmetamorphosesdeFolklore:Quelquesreprespourunecomprhension.In:PaysansetnationsdEuropecentraleetbalkaniques.Paris:
Maisonneuve,1933.
Zusammenfassung
RomantikeroderDoppelteInsider?EinEssayberdieUrsprngeideologi-
sierterDiskurseinderBalkanethnologieSlobodanNaumovi,Belgrad
AuchwennsienichtalsderwichtigsteErklrungsansatzfrdieIdeologisierungs-
tendenzenimFachanzusehenist,bedarfdochdieanhaltendeundtiefeZuneigung
dersdosteuropischenEthnologenbzw.VolkskundlerzuromantischenIdeender
Erklrung. Eine der zentralen Thesen diesesBeitrags ist,dadie spezifische
existentielleStellungderBalkanethnologen,dieihrenAusdruckineinemdoppel-
tenInsiderSyndromfindet,andemsiegenerellleiden,ihrefachlicheEinstellung
zutiefstbeeinfluthat.SiesolltealseinerderprimrenFaktorenfrdieIdeologi-sierungderDisziplinbetrachtetwerden.Ethnologenbzw.Volkskundleraufdem
BalkangehrenimPrinzipderGruppean,diesieuntersuchen,undteilenderen
Sprache,Traditionen,dominanteWerteundInteressen,whrendsiegleichzeitig
jener Sozialschicht angehren, deren Aufgabe die Untersuchung, Festigung,
ErfindungundoftauchVerteidigungderSacheebenjenerGruppeist.Weiter-
hinwirdangenommen,dadieWirkungdiesesFaktorsnochverstrktwirddurch
andereFaktoren,diedurchdieBesonderheitenderGeschichtederBalkanstaaten
bedingtsind.InanderenWorten,diebesonderenhistorischbedingtenpolitischen,
wirtschaftlichenundsozialenGegebenheitenderBalkangesellschaftenhabenganzwesentlich dazu beigetragen, das im doppelten Insider Syndrom enthaltene
IdeologisierungspotentialderEthnologennochzuverstrken.Derhiervorgetrage-
-
7/28/2019 Slobodan Naumovic - Romanticists or Double Insiders
21/21
120
neAnsatzhatdenVorzug,daersowohldieFaktoren,dieeinestarkeOrientie-
rungderbalkanischenEthnologenamromantischenErbebedingen,alsauchjene
Faktoren,dieaufnicht-romantischeQuellenzurckgehen,aufzuzeigenundsodie
IdeologisierungderFachdiskursebesserzuerklreninderLageist.