Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that...

40
Slide 1 /39 Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Inde x This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems by Noam Nisan and Shimon Schocken Forthcoming in 2003 by MIT Press, www.idc.ac.il/csd This software was developed by students at the Efi Arazi School of Computer Science at IDC Chief Software Architect: Yaron Ukrainitz Hardware Simulator Tutorial

Transcript of Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that...

Page 1: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

This program is part of the software suitethat accompanies the book

The Elements of Computing Systemsby Noam Nisan and Shimon Schocken

Forthcoming in 2003 by MIT Press, www.idc.ac.il/csd

This software was developed by students at theEfi Arazi School of Computer Science at IDC

Chief Software Architect: Yaron Ukrainitz

Hardware Simulator Tutorial

Page 2: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 2/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

The Elements of Computing Systems (TECS)

The TECS book is based on a constructive approach to learning computer science. The book evolves around the construction of a complete computer platform, done in the framework of a 1- or 2-semesters course.

In the first part of TECS, the students build all the logic gates and chips-set of a simple yet powerful computer, called Hack. This is done using HDL (Hardware Description Language) and a hardware simulator, supplied with the book.

In the second part of TECS, the students build the computer’s software hierarchy, consisting of an assembler, a virtual machine, a Java-like language called Jack, a compiler for it, and a simple operating system, written in Jack.

TECS is completely self-contained, requiringonly programming as a pre-requisite.

Page 3: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 3/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Simulators:

Hardware simulator: used to build and simulate all the gates and chips specified in the book, from elementary logic gates to the CPU;

CPU Emulator: used to give an animated simulation of the Hack computer – the hardware platform built in the book;

VM Emulator: used to give an animated simulation of the Hack VM – a stack-based virtual machine built after the JVM paradigm.

Simulators:

used to build hardware platforms and execute programs;

supplied by us.

Translators:

Used to translate from high-level to low-level

Written by the students

(Executable solutions available).

The book’s software suite:

Page 4: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 4/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

The book’s software suite:

This tutorial describes the Hardware simulator.

Page 5: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 5/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Purpose: learn how to use the simulator with which all the chips specified in the book can be built

Required knowledge: Chapter 1 of the book

Recommended: Appendix A + Appendix B of the book.

Contents:

I. Getting started

II. Test scripts

III. Built-in chips

IV. Clocked chips

V. Debugging tools

Page 6: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 6/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Part I:

Getting Started

Page 7: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 7/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Loading a chip

1. To load a new chip description, click the Load Chip button.

2. Navigate to a directory and select an .hdl file.

Page 8: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 8/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Loading a chip

Names and current values of the chip’s input pins

May be changed by the user.

Read-only view of the loaded .hdl file Defines the chip logic To edit it, use an external text editor.

Names and current values of the chip’s output pins

Calculated by the simulator; read-only.

Names and current values of the chip’s internal pins

(Used in the chip logic to connect the chip’s parts)

Calculated by the simulator; read-only.

Page 9: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 9/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Chip interface

// Exclusive-or gate.CHIP Xor {

IN a,b; OUT out;

// implementation missing}

// Exclusive-or gate.CHIP Xor {

IN a,b; OUT out;

// implementation missing}

Chip interface: Name of the chip Names of all the input and output pins Description of the intended chip operation

Supplied by the chip architect; Similar to an API, or a contract.

Page 10: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 10/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Chip implementation

// Exclusive-or gate.CHIP Xor {

IN a,b; OUT out;

PARTS: Not(in=a,out=Nota); Not(in=b,out=Notb); And(a=a,b=Notb,out=w1); And(a=Nota,b=b,out=w2); Or(a=w1,b=w2,out=out);}

// Exclusive-or gate.CHIP Xor {

IN a,b; OUT out;

PARTS: Not(in=a,out=Nota); Not(in=b,out=Notb); And(a=a,b=Notb,out=w1); And(a=Nota,b=b,out=w2); Or(a=w1,b=w2,out=out);}

Can be implemented by an HDL programmer in several ways

This particular implementation is based on the Boolean expressionXor(a,b) = Or(And(a,Not(b)), And(b,Not(a)))

The internal parts (Not, And, Or) are connected using internal pins, created and named by the HDL programmer (e.g. Nota, Notb, w1, w2).

Page 11: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 11/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Exploring the chip structure

1. Click the PARTS keyword

2. A table pops up, showing all the chip’s internal parts (lower-level chips) and whether they are primitive/compositeand clocked/unlocked.

Page 12: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 12/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

1. Click one of the chip PARTS

2. Another table pops up, showing the input/output pins of the selected part, along with their current values;

A convenient debugging tool.

Exploring the chip structure

Page 13: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 13/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Manual chip testing

1. User: changes the values of some input pins

2. Simulator: responds with 2 cues: The output and internal pins

will be darkened, to indicate that the displayed values are no longer valid

The Eval button will be enabled.

Page 14: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 14/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Manual chip testing

1. User: changes the values of some input pins

2. Simulator: responds with 2 cues: The output and internal pins

are darkened, to indicate that the displayed values are no longer valid

The Eval button is enabled.

Re-calc

3. User: Clicked the Eval button

4. Simulator: re-calculates the values

of the output and internal pins according to the chip logic, applied to the current input values

Page 15: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 15/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Part II:

Test Scripts

Page 16: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 16/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Test scripts

load Xor.hdl,output-file Xor.out,compare-to Xor.cmp,output-list a%B3.1.3 b%B3.1.3 out%B3.1.3;set a 0,set b 0,eval,output;

set a 0,set b 1,eval,output;

load Xor.hdl,output-file Xor.out,compare-to Xor.cmp,output-list a%B3.1.3 b%B3.1.3 out%B3.1.3;set a 0,set b 0,eval,output;

set a 0,set b 1,eval,output;

Good for pro-active, automated and replicable chip testing

Supplied with each chip definition

Using script commands, can effect anything that can be done interactively

Written in a simple language described in Appendix B of the book

A test script can create an output file that records the results of the chip test

If a compare file is supplied, the simulator will compare the generated outputs to the desired outputs,line by line.

| a | b | out || 0 | 0 | 0 || 0 | 1 | 1 || 1 | 0 | 1 || 1 | 1 | 0 |

| a | b | out || 0 | 0 | 0 || 0 | 1 | 1 || 1 | 0 | 1 || 1 | 1 | 0 |

Page 17: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 17/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Loading a script

To load a script file, click the Load Script button

It is not necessarily required to load a chip first, since the script may contain a “load chip” command.

Page 18: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 18/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Script controls

Executes the next simulation step

Executes step after step repeatedly

Pauses the simulation

Resetsthe script

Controls the script execution speed Logical

simulation steps, each ending with a semicolon.

Page 19: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 19/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Running a script

Typical script’s “init” code:

1. Loads Xor.hdl

2. Initializes Xor.out

3. Instructs to compare to Xor.cmp

4. Declares an output line format

Script exec-utionflow

Page 20: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 20/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Script exec-utionends

Running a script

Page 21: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 21/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Output and Compare files

To view the generated output file or the compare file, choose “Output” or “Compare” from the View button.

When the script execution ends, the simulator reports the comparison results between the output file and the compare file.

Page 22: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 22/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Conclusion: the chip logic (Xor.hdl) is apparently well-defined.

Output and Compare files

Observation:This output file looks like the Xor truth table

Page 23: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 23/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Part III:

Built-in Chips

Page 24: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 24/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Built-In chipsGeneral

A built-in chip has an HDL interface and a Java implementation (e.g. Xor.class)

The name of the Java class is specified following the “builtin” keyword

Built-In versions of all the chips discussed inthe book are supplied with the HW simulator.

// Xor gate (builtin)CHIP Xor { IN a,b; OUT out; BUILTIN Xor;}

// Xor gate (builtin)CHIP Xor { IN a,b; OUT out; BUILTIN Xor;}

Objectives

Built-in chips are used to:

Implement primitive chips (Nand, DFF)

Implement chips that have peripheral side effects (like I/O hardware drivers)

Implement chips that feature a GUI (for debugging)

Replace chips that the user didn’t implement for one reason or another

Improve simulation speed and save memory (when used as parts in complex chips)

Test a chip before it is built in HDL

Facilitate behavioral simulation of the entire hardware architecture.

Page 25: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 25/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Loading a built-in chip

2. Built-in chip. Can be tested or used as a part in other chips just like any other chip, without having to write it first.

1. Built-in versions of all the chips mentioned in the book are stored in the “BuiltIn” directory.

Page 26: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 26/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

2. If the loaded chip, or one or more of its parts, have GUI side-effects, the simulator displays the GUI’s here.

Built-in chips with GUI effects

GUI of built-in Screen chip

GUI of built-in RAM16K chip

GUI of built-in Keyboard chip

1. A chip whose parts include built-in chips was loaded into the simulator

Page 27: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 27/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Using built-in chips as internal parts

// demo GUI-empowered chipsCHIP GUIDemo { IN in[16],load,address[15]; OUT out[16]; PARTS: RAM16K(in=in,load=load,address=address[0..13],out=null); Screen(in=in,load=load,address=address[0..12],out=null); Keyboard(out=null);}

// demo GUI-empowered chipsCHIP GUIDemo { IN in[16],load,address[15]; OUT out[16]; PARTS: RAM16K(in=in,load=load,address=address[0..13],out=null); Screen(in=in,load=load,address=address[0..12],out=null); Keyboard(out=null);}

RAM16K, Screen, Keyboard: built-in chips with GUI side-effects

Effect: When the simulator evaluates this chip, it displays the GUI side-effects of the built-in chip parts

This particular chip: The only purpose of this chip is to force the simulator to show the GUI of these built-in chips. Other than that, the chip logic is meaningless: it simultaneously feeds the data input (“in”) into the RAM16K and the Screen chips, and it does nothing with the keyboard.

Page 28: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 28/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

4. The logic of these chips is described in Chapter 5 in the book (“Computer Architecture”).

3. 16 black pixels are drawn in row=156col=320

3. The –1 constantis seen in the RAM16K chip’s GUI

1. User enters:

In = –1(=16 1’s in binary)

address=5012

Load = 1

2. Similar to the”Eval” button. More about this soon

Built-in chips with GUI effects

Page 29: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 29/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Part IV:

Clocked Chips

(Sequential Logic)

Page 30: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 30/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Clocked chips

The implementation of clocked chips is based on sequential logic

The operation of clocked chips depends on the state of the computer’s internal clock:

Clock cycle = “Tick phase” (down), followed by a “Tock-phase” (up)

During a “Tick-Tock”, the internal state of the clocked chip changes, but its output don’t change yet

At the beginning of the next “Tick”, the outputs of the clocked chip commit to the new values

In real computers, the clock is implemented by an oscillator

In simulators, the clock cycles can be simulated either manually by the user, or “automatically” by a test script.

Page 31: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 31/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

The D-Flip-Flop chip (DFF)

// D-Flip Flop.

CHIP DFF {

IN in; OUT out;

BUILTIN DFF;

CLOCKED in,out;}

// D-Flip Flop.

CHIP DFF {

IN in; OUT out;

BUILTIN DFF;

CLOCKED in,out;}

The DFF chip:

A primitive, built-in gate

All the clocked chips are based on low-level DFF’s

DFF Functionality:

• While the clock does a “tick-tock”, the DFF sets its internal state to the value of its input pin

• Exactly when the next “tick-tock” starts, the DFF sets its output pin to the value of its internal state.

Clocked input pin: changes in its value will effect the chip outputs only in next clock cycle

Clocked output pin: can change its value only at the next clock cycle

The simulator knows that the loaded chip is clock-dependent when:

• One or more of its pins is declared “clocked”, or:

• One or more of its parts (or sub-parts) is a clocked chip

Page 32: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 32/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Running the clock manually

First click (“Tick”): the chip’s internal state changes to reflect the new inputs

Second click (“Tock”): the chip’s output will commit to the new state

(this screen shot was taken after a a tick and a tock).

Built-in, clocked chip (RAM8)

GUI of the built-in RAM8 chip

Page 33: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 33/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Running the clock automatically

2. single-action tick-tock

2. Tick-tocks repeatedly and infinitely. Useful when simulating clock-regulated chips, like the program counter (PC) or the CPU.

2. Controls the script speed, and thus the simulated clock speed.

1. Default script: always loaded when the simulator starts running.

Page 34: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 34/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Hardware Simulation Tutorial

Part V:

Debugging tools

Page 35: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 35/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Directory structure (.hdl, .tst, .out, .cmp)

// Xor.tst: typical test script load Xor.hdl,output-file Xor.out,compare-to Xor.cmp,

set a 0,set b 0,eval,output;

// Etc.

// Xor.tst: typical test script load Xor.hdl,output-file Xor.out,compare-to Xor.cmp,

set a 0,set b 0,eval,output;

// Etc.

All the HDL files, test scripts, and comparison files related to the same chip must be placed in the same directory

When a chip or a script file is loaded, the simulator assumes that all the other files relevant to that chip or script are in the same directory as that of the loaded file.

CHIP Xor { IN a, b; OUT out; PARTS: Not(in=a,out=Nota); Not(in=b,out=Notb); And(a=a,b=Notb,out=aNotb); And(a=Nota,b=b,out=bNota); Or(a=aNotb,b=bNota,out=out);}

CHIP Xor { IN a, b; OUT out; PARTS: Not(in=a,out=Nota); Not(in=b,out=Notb); And(a=a,b=Notb,out=aNotb); And(a=Nota,b=b,out=bNota); Or(a=aNotb,b=bNota,out=out);}

When an HDL file is loaded, the simulator looks for the HDL files of its internal parts in the same directory as that of the loaded file

If the .hdl file of an internal part is not found, the simulator invokes its built-In version instead (only if the part is one of the chips specified in the book).

Page 36: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 36/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

System variables

The simulator recognizes and maintains the values of the following variables:

Time: the number of time-units (clock-cycles) that elapsed since the script started running is stored in the variable time

Pins: the values of all the input, output, and internal pins of the simulated chip are accessible as variables, using their HDL names, e.g. a,b,out, Nota, Notb, etc. in the case of the Xor implementation presented earlier in this tutorial

GUI elements: the values stored in the contents of built-in chips with GUI can be accessed via variables with proper names. For example, the value of register 3 of the RAM8 chip can be accessed via RAM8[3].

These variables can be used in scripts and breakpoints, for debugging.

Page 37: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 37/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Breakpoints

The breakpoints logic:

Breakpoint = variable name and value

When the specified variable in some breakpoint reaches its specified value, the script pauses and a message is displayed

A powerful debugging tool.

To update an existing breakpoint, double-click it

to add and remove breakpoints,use the +/- buttons

Page 38: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 38/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Test scripts of complex chips

load Computer.hdlrom-load max.hack,output-file ComputerMax.out,compare-to ComputerMax.cmp,output-list RAM[0]%D2.6.2 RAM[1]%D2.6.2 RAM[2]%D2.6.2,breakpoint PC 10;

set RAM[0] 15,set RAM[1] 32;repeat 14 { tick, tock;}output;

set PC 0,set RAM[0] 47,set RAM[1] 22;while PC<13 { tick, tock;}output;

Clear-breakpoints;

load Computer.hdlrom-load max.hack,output-file ComputerMax.out,compare-to ComputerMax.cmp,output-list RAM[0]%D2.6.2 RAM[1]%D2.6.2 RAM[2]%D2.6.2,breakpoint PC 10;

set RAM[0] 15,set RAM[1] 32;repeat 14 { tick, tock;}output;

set PC 0,set RAM[0] 47,set RAM[1] 22;while PC<13 { tick, tock;}output;

Clear-breakpoints;

Users may write their own test scripts, according to specific debugging needs

Scripts that test the CPU chip or the computer chip usually start by loading a machine-language program into the ROM chip

The rest of the script typically uses various features like:

• Output tables

• Loops

• Breakpoints

• Variables manipulation

• Tick, Tock

• Etc.

• All these features are described in Appendix B of the book.

Page 39: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 39/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Visual options

Script: displays the current script

Output: displays the output file

Compare: displays the comparison file

Screen: displays the GUI effects of built-in chips, if any.

Program flow: animates the flow of the current ROM-resident program

Program & data flow: animates the flow of the current program and the data flow throughout the GUI elements displayed on the screen

No animation (default): program and data flow are not animated.

Tip: When running programs, any animation effects slow down the simulation considerably.

Format of displayed pin values:

Decimal (default) Hexadecimal Binary

Page 40: Slide 1/39Hardware Simulator TutorialTutorial Index This program is part of the software suite that accompanies the book The Elements of Computing Systems.

Slide 40/39Hardware Simulator Tutorial Tutorial Index

Postscript: H.D. Thoreau about chips, bugs, and close observation:

I was surprised to find that the chips were covered with such combatants, that it was not a duellum, but a bellum, a war between two races of ants, the red always pitted against the black, and frequently two red ones to one black. The legions of these Myrmidons covered all the hills and vales in my wood-yard, and the ground was already strewn with the dead and dying, both red and black. It was the only battle which I have ever witnessed, the only battlefield I ever trod while the battle was raging; internecine war; the red republicans on the one hand, and the black imperialists on the other. On every side they were engaged in deadly combat, yet without any noise that I could hear, and human soldiers never fought so resolutely.... The more you think of it, the less the difference. And certainly there is not the fight recorded in Concord history, at least, if in the history of America, that will bear a moment’s comparison with this, whether for the numbers engaged in it, or for the patriotism and heroism displayed.

From “Brute Neighbors,” Walden (1854).