Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of...
Transcript of Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of...
![Page 1: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Six Types of Pushdown Games
Wladimir Fridman
RWTH Aachen University, Germany
Second GASICS Meeting, October 2009
Joint work with Wolfgang Thomas
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 1 / 16
![Page 2: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Outline
1 Motivation and Background
2 Six Types of Pushdown Games
3 Main Result
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 2 / 16
![Page 3: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Church’s Problem of Controller Synthesis
X = X0X1X2... Y = Y0Y1Y2...
input X ∈ Σω1 , output Y ∈ Σω
2 ,(X
Y
)∈ (Σ1 × Σ2)ω = Σω
given: specification L ⊆ Σω
question: is there an automaton (transducer), that transformsevery input X ∈ Σω
1 letter-by-letter into an output Y ∈ Σω2 ,
such that(X
Y
)∈ L?
if yes - construction!
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 3 / 16
![Page 4: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Formulation in Terms of Infinite 2-Player Game
Player 1 and Player 2 pick letters in alternation - Xi ∈ Σ1 resp. Yi ∈ Σ2
Play(X
Y
)=
(X0Y0
)(X1Y1
)(X2Y2
)...
Winning condition given by L ⊆ Σω
Player 2 wins(X
Y
)if(X
Y
)∈ L
Player 1 wins(X
Y
)if(X
Y
)/∈ L
strategy for Player 1 is a function(X0
Y0
)(X1Y1
)...(Xk
Yk
)7→ Σ1
strategy for Player 2 is a function(X0
Y0
)(X1Y1
)...(Xk∗)7→ Σ2
Task: find winner and winning strategy!
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16
![Page 5: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Fundamental Result
Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)
For each MSO-definable game either Player 1 or Player 2 has afinite-state winning strategy,
one can compute the winner and a finite-state machine realizing awinning strategy.
winning condition: winning strategy:regular ω-language L finite automaton (with output)
connection between winning conditions and winning strategies
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 5 / 16
![Page 6: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Pushdown Games
Pushdown Game:
winning condition: ω-context-free language L
game on pushdown graph with parity condition
Pushdown Strategy:
PDA with output
reads opponent’s inputs, outputs player’s next letter to pick
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 6 / 16
![Page 7: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Pushdown Automaton
Definition (PDA)
A pushdown automaton A = (Q,Σ, Γ, δ,qin,⊥)
Q - finite set of states, qin - initial state
Σ - input alphabet
Γ - pushdown alphabet, ⊥ - initial pushdown symbol
δ : (Q × (Σ ∪ {ε})× Γ)→ P(Q × Γ∗)
Definition (Pushdown graph)
For a PDA A a pushdown graph is G(A) = (V ,E)
V = {(q, γ) | q ∈ Q and γ ∈ (Γ \ {⊥})∗⊥}
E ⊆ V × (Σ ∪ {ε})× V , (q,Zγ)a−→ (q′, βγ) if (q, β) ∈ δ(q,a,Z )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 7 / 16
![Page 8: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Pushdown Game: Example
Pushdown game
Q1 = {qin,q2}, Q2 = {q1}
Σ = {a,b, c}, Γ = {Z ,⊥}
qin⊥ qinZ⊥ qinZZ⊥ ...
qinZZZ⊥
q1⊥ q1Z⊥ q1ZZ⊥ ...
q1ZZZ⊥
q2⊥ q2Z⊥ q2ZZ⊥ ...
col(qin) = 0
col(q1) = 1
col(q2) = 1
a a a
b b b
b b b
c
b
b b b
c c c
c
c c
Winning strategy for Player 2
pick "b" if the prefix contains more a’s than b’s
pick "c" if the prefix contains equal number of a’s and b’s,
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 8 / 16
![Page 9: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Pushdown Game: Example
Pushdown game
Q1 = {qin,q2}, Q2 = {q1}
Σ = {a,b, c}, Γ = {Z ,⊥}
qin⊥ qinZ⊥ qinZZ⊥ ...
qinZZZ⊥
q1⊥ q1Z⊥ q1ZZ⊥ ...
q1ZZZ⊥
q2⊥ q2Z⊥ q2ZZ⊥ ...
col(qin) = 0
col(q1) = 1
col(q2) = 1
a a a
b b bb b b
c b
b b b
c c c
c
c c
Winning strategy for Player 2
pick "b" if the prefix contains more a’s than b’s
pick "c" if the prefix contains equal number of a’s and b’s,
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 8 / 16
![Page 10: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Pushdown Games
Remark (Finkel 2001)
For nondeterministic context-free languages L ∈ CFLω it is undecidable todetermine which player has a winning strategy in the Gale-Stewart gamedefined by L.
proof uses undecidability of UNIVERSALITY(CFLω)
conclusion: Church’s Problem for the class of CFLω is undecidable.
Theorem (Walukiewicz 1996)Parity games on deterministic pushdown graphs are determined withdeterministic pushdown winning strategies.
proof idea: reduction to parity game on finite game graph
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 9 / 16
![Page 11: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 12: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 13: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 14: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 15: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 16: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Types of Pushdown Automata
1 deterministic pushdown automaton (DPDA)
2 visibly pushdown automaton (VPA)
stack height controlled by input
3 deterministic stair pushdown automaton (StDPDA)
evaluation of parity condition only at special positions
4 realtime DPDA
no ε-transitions
5 deterministic one-counter automaton (D1CA)
only one pushdown symbol Z (except ⊥)
6 deterministic blind one-counter automaton (DB1CA)
if δ(q,a,⊥) = (q′,Z n⊥) then δ(q,a,Z ) = (q′,Z nZ )
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 10 / 16
![Page 17: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Main Result
Theoremtight connection between winning conditions and winning strategies:
1 DCFLω-games are determined with DCFL w. s.
2 VPLω-games are determined with VPL w. s.
3 StDCFLω-games are determined with DCFL w. s.
4 realtime-DCFLω-games are determined with realtime-DCFL w. s.
5 D1CLω-games are determined with D1CL w. s.
no winning strategies of the corresponding format
6 for DB1CLω-games DB1CL winning strategies do NOT suffice
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 11 / 16
![Page 18: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Cases 1 - 5
Proof idea: refinement of the following approach (M. Y. Vardi)
1 construction of an alternating two-way tree automaton A, whichsimulates the pushdown transitions on the full (Γ \ {⊥})-tree
⊥
A
A B
B
A B
q
q′
δ(q,a,A) = (q′,BB)
2 construction of an equivalent one-way parity tree automaton A′,Player 2 has a winning strategy iff L(A′) 6= ∅,
3 deduction of a strategy in the respective format from the deterministicword automaton generating a regular tree in L(A′)
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 12 / 16
![Page 19: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Case 6 (Blind 1-counter)
Claim: for DB1CLω-games DB1CL winning strategies do NOT suffice.
define a DB1CLω-game G
there is a pushdown winning strategy for Player 2 in G
there is no DB1CL winning strategy for Player 2 in G
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 13 / 16
![Page 20: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Case 6 (Blind 1-counter)
Blind 1-counter game G
⊥ Z⊥ ZZ⊥ ZZZ⊥ ... Color
2
2
0
1
qin
q1
q2
q3
q4
a a a a
b b b b
b b b b
$ $ $ $
1 1 1 1
2 2 2 2
2
1 1 1
Pushdown winning strategy for Player 2:
pick "1" if the prefix constructed by Player 1 is anbm$, m < n
pick "2" if the prefix constructed by Player 1 is anbn$,
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 14 / 16
![Page 21: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Case 6 (Blind 1-counter)
Blind 1-counter game G
⊥ Z⊥ ZZ⊥ ZZZ⊥ ... Color
2
2
0
1
qin
q1
q2
q3
q4
a a a a
b b b b
b b b b
$ $ $ $
1 1 1 1
2 2 2 22
1 1 1
Pushdown winning strategy for Player 2:
pick "1" if the prefix constructed by Player 1 is anbm$, m < n
pick "2" if the prefix constructed by Player 1 is anbn$,
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 14 / 16
![Page 22: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Case 6 (Blind 1-counter)
Lemma{anbn$|n > 0} is not accepted by any DB1CA.
Proof: simple exercise.
There is no DB1CL winning strategy for GEvery strategy has to decide if the prefix chosen by Player 1 is
in {anbn$|n > 0} or
in {anbm$|n,m > 0 and m < n}
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 15 / 16
![Page 23: Six Types of Pushdown Games - automata.rwth-aachen.de · W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 4 / 16. Fundamental Result Theorem (Büchi - Landweber 1969)](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022052811/608a170bfabc0875763d42f0/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Summary
connection between context-free winning conditions and winningstrategies in six special cases
in 5 cases (DPDA, VPA, StDPDA, realtime-DPDA, D1CA) strategiesare implementable by the corresponding type of pushdown machine
for blind 1-counter games blind 1-counter strategies do not suffice
Outlook
open question: general analysisWhat are the abstract reasons for the distinction betweencases 1-5 and case 6?
W. Fridman (RWTH Aachen) Six Types of Pushdown Games GASICS ’09 16 / 16