Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on...

20
Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method method Vidar Tregde Kongsbe g De otek Kongsberg Devotek

Transcript of Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on...

Page 1: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) methodmethod

Vidar TregdeKongsbe g De otekKongsberg Devotek

Page 2: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Kongsberg Devotek

Kongsberg Devotek is the largest independent development house in Norway providing high technology solutions to companies developing owning and selling providing high technology solutions to companies developing, owning and selling products and systems subjected to tough environments. Expertise in Innovation Counseling, System- and Actuator design, FEA- and CFD analysis, Prototyping and testing

Kongsberg Devotek has gained unique technical expertise from a 20 year track of experience indevelopment of advanced technologies for the Maritime, Defense, Oil & Gas, p g , , ,Automotive and Embedded market

Kongsberg Devotek has 90 persons, mainly MSc, BSc and PhD 15 ill € b d t d t 201015 mill € budgeted turnover 2010

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 3: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

VOF Wave Simulation:Introduction

• Ship hydrodynamicsShi i– Ship resistance

– Ship propulsion– Hull-propeller-rudder interactionHull propeller rudder interaction– Coupled simulation of flow and ship motion

• Cavitation• Sloshing in tanks

– Prescribed tank motion– Coupled simulation of ship motion and sloshing in tanks

• Fluid-structure interaction• Slamming loads

– Green water

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

– Wave impact

Page 4: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Resistance and Drag Prediction, I:F S f C l l i Shi R i Free Surface Calculations, Ship Resistance

Comparison between CFD and model test of generated waves

from a vessel

Wet surface of vessel

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 5: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Resistance and Drag Prediction, II: D d Lif f S i i D flDrag and Lift from Seismic Deflector

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 6: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Slamming Loads:Green Water and Wave ImpactGreen Water and Wave Impact

Scope of work: pGeometrical model -> Mesh model -> Set incoming wave -> Perform wave loads calculation with time simulation -> Pressure on struture can be monitored

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 7: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Physics for VOF Wave Simulation

• VOF (Volume of Fluid) methodVOF (Volume of Fluid) method

• Water and air (incompressible)

• HRIC for VOF (high resolution interface capturing)• HRIC for VOF (high resolution interface capturing) Scheme is designed to mimic the convective transport of immiscible fluid components,

resulting in a scheme that is well suited for tracking sharp interfaces.

• Bounded i e VOF between 0 and 1• Bounded, i.e. VOF between 0 and 1

• Turbulence Model: k-ε two equation model

• Trimmed and/or polyhedral mesh

• Stokes 5th order wave

• Coupled simulation of flow and motion of floating

bodies

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 8: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid StructureObjecive and TopicsObjecive and Topics

Objective:Perform CFD simulations of breaking waves, and waves close to breaking hitting rigid offshore structures. Volume of Fluid (VOF) method are used for simulations. The motivation for simulations are finding the worst possible forces at realistic

Topics:

g pwaves with a given probability of occurence.

p• Hydrodynamical analysis of waves on a beach hitting a rigid structure is performed.

•The waves are regular. In this study the region is modelled as slightly 3D, that means the extension in direction parallel to the beach is only very small compared to x- and z-direction. Th fl i d 2DThe flow is assumed 2D.

• The software used is Star CCM+. The software handles 3D cases with free floating bodies and with waves and speed/current, and the numerical method is a Volume of Fluid (VOF) method. This has proven very good for free surface flow cases.

•Simulation of waves propagating into a plane beach, results are compared to experiments.

•Analysis of slamming loads from simulations are sensitive to time step in unsteady analysis.

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 9: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Breaking WavesBeach Slope 1:33Incoming wave:H = 12.2 m

1000 m

T = 11.6 s

Mesh: 93.000 cells, 2D simulation

Depth = 40 m

Depth = 10 m

Depth 40 m

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 10: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Breaking Waves: Comparison with Experiments

Plunging jet

T (s)

Hb (m) Db (m) Hb/Db

Beach Slope 1:10Incoming wave:H = 3.76 m

impact pressure distribution

( )Experiment 2.4 0.26 0.33 0.59 0.79

This study 9.0 3.6 4.5 0.58 0.82

T = 9 s

Mesh: 40.000 cells, 2D simulation

H : wave height at breaking D : still water depth at breaking = slope/sqrt(H / ): surf similarity parameterHb : wave height at breaking, Db : still water depth at breaking, = slope/sqrt(Hb/): surf similarity parameter

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 11: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure: MeshMesh

350 m

Beach Slope 1:10Incoming wave:H = 3.76 mT = 9 s

Mesh: 60.000 cells, 2D simulationTimestep: 2ms

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 12: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure: InitializationInitialization

Regular wavesRegular wavesRegular wavesRegular waves

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 13: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure: First Wave

Fluid force on side plateFluid force on side plate

0.2 s between each picture0.2 s between each pictureFluid force on horizontal Fluid force on horizontal plateplate

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 14: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure: Second Wave

Fluid force on horizontal Fluid force on horizontal plateplate

Fluid force on side plateFluid force on side plate

0.04 s between each picture0.04 s between each picture

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 15: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure:Sealoads on Structure

Fluid force on side plateFluid force on side plate

1. wave1. wave 2. wave2. wave Etc..Etc..

Fluid force on side plateFluid force on side plate

Timestep of 2ms OKTimestep of 2ms OK

Fluid force on horizontal Fluid force on horizontal plateplateplateplate

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 16: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

Waves hitting a Rigid Structure: Timestep Influence on Peak Force Timestep Influence on Peak Force

First slamming hit First slamming hit on structure with on structure with small angle: small angle:

Second slamming Second slamming hit on structure hit on structure with larger angle: with larger angle:

Sensitive to Sensitive to timestep!timestep!

Not sensitive to Not sensitive to timestep.timestep.

17.5 18 18.5

Time [sec]

9m/8s-0.5ms 9m/8s-2.5ms

Example of slamming case very sensitive to Example of slamming case very sensitive to timestep due to small slamming angle between timestep due to small slamming angle between water and structurewater and structure

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

a e a d s uc u ea e a d s uc u e

Page 17: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

VOF Wave Simulation:Animations..

Breaking Waves on a Beach

Waves Hitting a Rigid Structure Waves Hitting a Rigid Structure

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 18: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

VOF Wave Simulation:Animations..

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 19: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

VOF Wave Simulation:Animations..

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010

Page 20: Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with ...€¦ · Simulation of wave loads on offshore structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF)structures with Volume of Fluid (VOF) method

VOF Wave Simulation:Conclusions and Outlook

• Simulation of large scale ocean wave slamming casesSimulation of large scale ocean wave slamming cases are possible with VOF.

• Breaking waves on a beach show good agreement with g g gexperiments

• Simulation of waves over long time is possible without deterioration of accuracy.

• Coupled simulation of flow, motion, and structural deformation is also possible.

NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010NAFEMS NORDIC REGIONAL CONFERENCE 2010