Managing Geological Uncertainty with Decision Analysis in ...
Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
-
Upload
galuizu001 -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 1/28
Short term mine sequencing
using geological uncertainty
indexes - An application to the
Carajás Iron Ore Complex
Prof. Rodrigo de Lemos Peroni
Mining Engineer José Edson Aragão da Silva
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 2/28
IntroductionGoal
Objectives
Methodology Case Study
Results
Conclusions
Presentation Outline
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 3/28
Motivation
Different quality from planning, mainly in the weekly mineplanning.
Possible causes:
• Some mines are getting close to exhaustion, ore close to the
contact zones and/or, intrinsic variability of the deposits.;
Posing the problem
1 – Predicted quality detachment in the monthly plan when
compared to the executed grades.
2 – High variability in the weekly plans when compared to the
monthly plan.3 – Absence of a good forecast beyond a week.
4 – Lack of knowledge of geological uncertainties impacting the mine
planning.
Introduction
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 4/28
Goal:
Develop a short-term sequencingmethodology to improve the predictability of
quality in the weekly period and to assess the
geological uncertainty of the planned blocks;
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
Introduction
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 5/28
Objectives:
Implement a methodology of weekly sequencing;
Model the Fe grade uncertainties in the N5 mine;
Analyze the geological uncertainty during the mining
periods, aiming to know the risks associated to the
mining areas;
Compare the average quality given by the estimated
block model with the E-Type (Kriged) calculated from
the simulations.
Introduction
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 6/28
Estimated block model:
Very popular in the mining industry;
• Estimate mineral resources;
• In the last decades there were verified discrepancies when
compared to production results;
•
It is “accepted” that the main reasons to a poor reconciliationare related with the uncertainty in the geological interpretation
and with the estimates.
Factors that might affect the estimate uncertainty
1 – Change of support;
2 – Lack of sampling, bad sampling or protocols;
3 – Interpolation errors;
4 – Smooth effect.
Methodology
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 7/28
Geostatistical simulation
• Firstly proposed in the 70’s as a method to provide
a quantitative assessment of the local uncertainty.
sequential Gaussian simulation (sGs)
• Started in the 90´s;
•“Widely” used compared to other simulationalgorithms;
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 8/28
General view
Unknown deposit Geological dataset
Equally probable
models
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 9/28
Simulations generated using the sGsim implemented within SGEMs:
Dataset
EDA
VariogramHematites
sGs 100 Simulations
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 10/28
Case Study
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 11/28
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 12/28
Case Study
N5W, N5E, N5EN e N5Sul
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 13/28
Case Study
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 14/28
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 15/28
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 16/28
N5W
N5E
N5S
Case study – N5 Mine
Main aspects:
• Hematites – HF, HC e HMN;
• Product: Sinter Feed;
• Main variable – Fegl;
• Period considered: 2011 – 2013;• Post processed block model
Localização das amostras da Mina de N5
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Case Study
Final Block Dimensions:
25m x 25m x 15m
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 17/28
Validation
• Histograms
Histograma dos dados
Histograma das realizações
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
Mean
66.86%
Variance
5.99
50 realizations
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 18/28
Validation
• Variogram Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 19/28
Export
Simulations(.CSV)
Calculation ofUncertainty Flag on model
The probability was post processed in
Excel considering the number of times
the criteria Fegl>= 65% was attended.
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 20/28
Export
simulations(.csv)
Calculation of
uncertainty Flag on model
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Methodology
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 21/28
Input parameters for sequencing.
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Sequencing
Results
Conclusions
Technical parameters for sequencing
Model Name
Plant Production (per year)
Plant Recovery
Studied Variable
Reference content (Goal)
Period
65%
Weekly
N5 (Kriging)
50Mt
Global Iron grade (Fegl)
92%
Input data
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 22/28
The blue shades show the areas where the probability of the FEGL content presents
values above 65% are extremely low.
Areas in intense orange and red shades are areas of low uncertainty considering theypresent more than 80% probability to have FEGL grades above the defined cutoff of 65%.
Areas in green and yellow are areas of high uncertainty and or 40 to 60 % probability and
must be better assessed.
Week1 - 46
Week
47
ahead
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Simulation
Results
Conclusions
Results
Probability map for the Fe content present grades above 65%.
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 23/28
To carry out the sequencing in weekly plans, the simulations were fed to the Minesched®
software. The implemented algorithm allows good operational flexibility.
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology -
Sequencing
Results
Conclusions
Results
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 24/28
Results
Areas
shown inthe map.
Graphs presenting the quality and performed geological uncertainty ofeach period.
Note that, although almost all periods have reached the goal of quality
(Kriging model), the associated risks, after week 46, are high, and
confirmed by the low probability of achieving the target grade (65%).
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 25/28
The methodology allowed the predictability of
qualities in periods of mining;
The application of geostatistical simulation
technique has proven to be a valuable tool toapproach the uncertainty of the variable FEGL;
Using the methodology suggested here, it was noted
that the results may assist short-term and mediumterm planning in the preparation of weekly and
monthly plans and in decision making, when periods
of operational difficulties are identified.
Conclusions
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 26/28
Apply the methodology in other iron ore
mines in the Carajás complex and other
mining complexes from VALE;
Spread the methodology in the short-term
and medium term iron ore planning areas and
other commodities in the company;
Next steps
Introduction
Goal
Objectives
Methodology
Results
Conclusions
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 27/28
Aknowledgements
• VALE
• UFRGS/PPGEM
7/23/2019 Short term mine sequencing using geological uncertainty
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-term-mine-sequencing-using-geological-uncertainty 28/28
Thank You!
Gracias!
Obrigado!
Rodrigo Peroni